Enriched list of litterature reviews on procedural justice and democracy in sustainability transitions
Authors/Creators
-
1.
Dispositifs d'information et de communication à l'ère du numérique - Paris Ile-de-france
-
2.
Centre d'Etudes et de Recherches Appliquées à la Gestion
- 3. Technical University of Denmark
Description
The files are an extract of a sample that was built on Wikidata using the following process :
Importing selected articles into Wikidata
We imported the articles available here https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20749973 into Wikidata. To import the selected articles meta-data into Wikidata, we first ran a script to check if any article was already present in the database. Next we used another script that checks the ISSN of the publication in Wikidata and add P-Q-pairs in the extra field of Zotero. Then we exported the articles data using the "export to Wikidata QuickStatements" function of Zotero and use the QuickStatements tool to add them to Wikidata.
Next we used the Cita (V1.0.0-beta.17) Zotero add-on to add articles QID in Zotero. At this point we identified that duplicates had been created in Wikidata (possibly because the initial script did not work that well because of the recent Graph Split on Wikidata). We merged duplicates on wikidata using the "Merge" gadget on Wikidata. We checked manually for duplicated statments in those items.
Article classification through meta-data enrichement
The project aimed to enrich the medata of academic items by using wikidata. We selected the most relevant properties in Wikidata to reflect these classifications : main subject (P921) to describe what the article is about, study type (P8363) to describe its main methodology/research design and research site (P6153) to describe its geographical focus.
Main subjects
We first read the articles abstracts and listed relevant topics and their Wikidata ID in a shared spreadsheet. These topics were :
| Qid | Main topic | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Q42377797 | acceptability | characteristic of a thing being subject to acceptance for some purpose |
| Q2798912 | accountability | concept of responsibility in ethics, governance and decision-making |
| Q421953 | actor–network theory | theory within social science |
| Q84459973 | affordability | |
| Q185836 | age of a person | time elapsed since a person was born |
| Q4764988 | animal studies | field in which animals are studied in a variety of cross-disciplinary ways |
| Q4338318 | awareness | state or ability to perceive, to feel, or to be conscious of events, objects, or sensory patterns |
| Q4930066 | blue carbon | carbon captured by the world's coastal ocean ecosystems |
| Q430460 | capability approach | economic theory |
| Q7569 | child | human between birth and puberty |
| Q4116870 | civic engagement | individual or group activity addressing issues of public concern |
| Q125928 | climate change | human-caused changes to climate on Earth |
| Q260607 | climate change
adaptation |
process of adjustment to actual or expected climate change and its effects, seeking to moderate or avoid harm or exploit beneficial opportunities |
| Q1291678 | climate justice | term linking the climate crisis with environmental and social justice |
| Q2270945 | co-creation | product or service design process in which input from consumers plays a central role |
| Q16972712 | co-design | approach to design attempting to actively involve all stakeholders |
| Q16324410 | coproduction | product or service design process in which input from consumers plays a central role |
| Q11024 | communication | act of conveying intended meaning |
| Q177634 | community | social unit of human organisms who share common values |
| Q5154673 | community choice aggregation | alternative energy supply system |
| Q113514984 | community energy | delivery of community-led renewable energy, energy demand reduction and energy supply projects |
| Q65807646 | community participation | The taking part by members of a community in decisionmaking processes related to the development of their community |
| Q188843 | cosmopolitanism | ideology that all human beings belong to a single community, based on a shared morality |
| Q11693783 | decarbonization | change of economy, especially of energy industries, towards lower carbon dioxide emissions |
| Q284289 | deliberative democracy | form of democracy focusing on consensus |
| Q7174 | democracy | form of government |
| Q552284 | distributive justice | concept of the socially just allocation of goods |
| Q1230584 | diversity | concept in sociology and political studies |
| Q1049066 | ecological economics | research field on the interdependence of human economies and natural ecosystems |
| Q8134 | economics | social science that studies the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services |
| Q868575 | empowerment | providing increased autonomy |
| Q295865 | ecosystem service | benefits created by nature, forests and environmental systems |
| Q138359220 | energy citizenship | involvement of citizens in energy-related decisions |
| Q131444737 | community energy | [redirection] |
| Q16869822 | energy consumption | amount of energy or power used |
| Q1358789 | senior | elderly person |
| Q14944319 | energy democracy | concept in environmental justice movement |
| Q192704 | energy efficiency | ratio between the useful energy output and the input of a machine |
| Q24965464 | energy modeling | process of building computer models of energy systems in order to analyze them |
| Q1805337 | energy policy | policy addressing energy issues |
| Q1341244 | energy poverty | lack of access to modern energy services |
| Q3406659 | energy production | conversion of energy from a primary source into a form useful to humans |
| Q117091181 | energy justice | subconcept of economic equality |
| Q3456219 | energy renovation | building works aimed at reducing energy consumption and decarbonising the energy sources used |
| Q2700433 | energy security | national security considerations of energy availability |
| Q837718 | energy storage | capture of energy produced at one time for use at a later time |
| Q795757 | energy transition | long-term structural change towards sustainable energy systems |
| Q1479527 | environmental justice | system of fairness |
| Q771773 | fairness | concept in sociology and generally the interaction of society |
| Q56395513 | farming system | method of agricultural production defined by its physical practices and economic characteristics |
| Q5465532 | food system | all processes and infrastructure involved in feeding a population |
| Q4421 | forest | dense collection of trees covering a relatively large area |
| Q48277 | gender | social concept which distinguish the different gender categories |
| Q1553864 | governance | all of the processes of governing, whether undertaken by a government, market or network, whether over a family, tribe, formal or informal organization or territory and whether through the laws, norms, power or language of an organized society |
| Q8458 | human rights | inalienable fundamental rights to which a person is inherently entitled |
| Q11376059 | human rights violation | act or omission which contravene the principles of human rights |
| Q103817 | indigenous people | first inhabitants of an area and their descendants |
| Q113561794 | indigenous science | indigenous knowledge applied to the scientific method |
| Q770480 | injustice | quality relating to unfairness or undeserved outcomes |
| Q17142211 | interactional justice | the perceived appropriateness of interpersonal treatment |
| Q1516555 | intersectionnality | theoretical framework of multidimensional oppression |
| Q6316391 | just transition | Framework developed by the trade union movement to encompass wide range of social interventions needed to secure decent work opportunities and a greener economy. |
| Q366139 | legitimation | the process of making something acceptable and normative to a group |
| Q3027857 | living lab | user-centered, open innovation ecosystem integrating research and innovation in real life communities |
| Q59679511 | low income | home with little money |
| Q43619 | natural environment | all living and non-living things occurring naturally on Earth or some region thereof |
| Q127514833 | nature-positive | global goal to halt and reverse nature loss by 2030 |
| Q13023682 | non-human | organism not in the genus Homo |
| Q728646 | partnership | arrangement in which parties agree to cooperate to advance their mutual interests |
| Q3907287 | policy making | the act of developing policy |
| Q9357091 | political theory | class of theory |
| Q265425 | postcolonialism | academic discipline |
| Q25107 | power | ability to influence the behavior of others |
| Q442100 | procedural justice | fairness in the processes that resolve disputes and allocate resources |
| Q7249406 | project governance | management framework |
| Q7257735 | public engagement | Policy-making practice |
| Q541936 | public participation | participation of citizens in various policy decisions and planning processes |
| Q6142016 | recognition justice | social philosophy theory |
| Q10509953 | renewable electricity | electricity from renweable sources |
| Q12705 | renewable energy | energy collected from renewable resources |
| Q56510941 | renewable energy policy | |
| Q1165392 | restorative justice | approach to justice where victims and perpetrators mediate a restitution agreement |
| Q4414036 | rural population | inhabitants of rural areas or of small towns classified as rural |
| Q17152351 | smart system | adaptive intelligent systems |
| Q187588 | social class | group of people categorized in a hierarchy based on socioeconomic factors |
| Q264892 | social justice | concept that discrimination recognized in society should be remedied |
| Q34749 | social science | academic disciplines concerned with society and the relationships between individuals in society |
| Q2930198 | stakeholder participation | involvement of groups or individuals affected by the actions of an entity |
| Q125359881 | sustainability transition | |
| Q219416 | sustainability | ability of human civilization to coexist with the biosphere in a steady state |
| Q131201 | sustainable development | mode of human development that meets current demands without compromising the needs of future generations |
| Q7649586 | Sustainable Development Goals | set of United Nations-defined global development goals and climate change |
| Q69883 | urban planning | technical and political process concerned with the use of land and design of the urban environment |
| Q920600 | urban renewal | program of land redevelopment in cities, often where there is urban decay |
| Q3376054 | vulnerable population | group of persons whose range of options is severely limited, are subjected to coercion, or who may be compromised in their ability to give informed consent |
| Q107389921 | water-management | |
| Q7981051 | well-being | measure of how well life is to someone or a group with factors such as health, happiness and satisfaction |
| Q467 | woman | female adult human |
| Q188867 | future studies | study of possible, probable, and preferable social, technological and political futures |
| Q1038171 | participatory design | active involvement of all stakeholders in the design process |
Then, for each article, we inferred what the main subject (P921) was from the abstracts and author provided keywords.
Study types
Our review included only litterature reviews. We first read abstracts to identify all the different types of litterature reviews present in the corpus and created wikidata items which did not exist, for example integrative literature review (Q137209848) and conceptual review (Q137174203). We improved these method items using the methodological references cited in the reviewed papers. The types of reviews were :
| Qid | Study type | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Q603441 | bibliometrics | statistical analysis of written publications, such as books or articles |
| Q472342 | scientometrics | study of measuring and analysing science, technology and innovation |
| Q815382 | meta-analysis | statistical method that summarizes data from multiple sources |
| Q1504425 | systematic review | publication type, study that gathers, analyzes, and communicates the results of research and information on a topic |
| Q2412849 | literature review | process of information search and text of a review article (Q7318358), which includes the current knowledge including substantive findings, as well as theoretical and methodological contributions to a particular topic |
| Q6822263 | meta-regression | statistical tool used in meta-analyses |
| Q7301211 | realist evaluation | [...] |
| Q17007303 | combinatorial meta-analysis | [...] |
| Q70470634 | network meta-analysis | meta-analysis of randomized trials in which estimates of comparative treatment effects are visualized and interpreted from a network of interventions |
| Q101116078 | scoping review | search for concepts by mapping the language and data which surrounds those concepts and adjusting the search method iteratively to synthesize evidence and assess the scope of an area of inquiry |
| Q110665014 | narrative review | type of literature review, without structured method of retrieval and analysis |
| Q137174203 | conceptual review | academic research aiming to review existing concepts and definitions in the litterature |
| Q137174450 | critical review | type of literature review analysing strenghts, major contributions, mistakes and neglected issues in an academic field of research |
| Q137209848 | integrative literature review | type of literature review |
| Q137211242 | narrative review | type of literature review, without structured method of retrieval and analysis |
Then, we added the study type (P8363) of each articles based on the abstract and method sections. In case of doubt, we compared our interpretation.
Research site
When an article had a specific geographical focus, we used the property research site (P6153) to describe it. For example, the article "A Review of Energy Communities in Sub-Saharan Africa as a Transition Pathway to Energy Democracy (Q137901202)" focused on sub-Saharan Africa (Q132959).
Authors
We used the Author Disambiguator tool to create Wikidata items for researchers who did not yet have one. This tool helps to minimise errors caused by homonyms among researchers: following a query, it categorises scientific publications into thematic groups. It also automatically searches for ORCID, ResearchGate and VIAF pages.
Note on contributions :
Amelie E. Pereira annotated all the items. Adélie Ranville imported the items in Wikidata, provided the initial list of "main topics" and checked the annotations for topics, study type and research site. Finn Nielsen helped remove duplicate items, provided technical advice and helped visualise the list of imported articles.
Files
2026-04-21-Enriched Sample.csv
Files
(277.7 kB)
| Name | Size | Download all |
|---|---|---|
|
md5:862c05c9666974a1c822d958ccb61f32
|
40.2 kB | Preview Download |
|
md5:061b9700fa63712d444989aa7f4e6b26
|
237.6 kB | Download |
Additional details
Related works
- Continues
- Proposal: 10.5281/zenodo.20760602 (DOI)
Funding
Dates
- Created
-
2026-05