P41 v1.6: The GWTC-4/5 Mass Gap as Evidence for CCEGA Ultracompact Objects — GWTC-5.0 Added, 52 Events, Spin Limit a* ≤ 0.343, All Pass
Authors/Creators
Description
V1.6
Updates P41 v1.5 with GWTC-5.0 (released May 26 2026, 390 total events). 23 new intermediate-regime events added. 52 total events with both components in 4.56–14.75 M☉. All consistent with CCEGA spin limit a_max/M = 0.343–0.503. Maximum observed chi_eff = 0.220 vs most restrictive limit 0.345. Test passed across 10 years of LVK observations O1–O4c.
V1.5
Corrects M_crit from 12.0 to 14.75 M☉. Intermediate regime now 4.56–14.75 M☉. 29 events identified with both components in regime (vs 18 in v1.4). Spin limit updated: a_max/M = 0.343–0.503. All 29 events consistent with CCEGA spin limit. Maximum observed chi_eff = 0.210 vs most restrictive limit 0.343. Test passed.
V1.4
Adds Section 5: spin test from P51 v2 against 18 GWTC-4.0 events. All consistent with a_max/M = 0.356–0.503. Rotational stability open problem.
v1.3
Updated phase boundaries Mmax = 4.56 M☉ (P34 v2.0), Mcrit = 12.0 M☉ (P36 v2.0). Note Added addresses catalog variance limitations following Corelli et al. arXiv:2603.00239.
Analysis of all 369 gravitational wave events in GWTC-4.0 O4a. 21 events (5.7%) populate the CCEGA intermediate regime (2.33–9.20 M☉). Statistically significant differences from true black holes in spin (p<0.0001), total mass (p<0.0001), and mass ratio (p<0.0001). GW190814 and GW230529 consistent with CCEGA ultracompact objects. Circumstantial evidence — not confirmation. Definitive tests: NICER tidal deformability (2029), Einstein Telescope echoes (2035+). M_max boundary carries uncertainty (P29 v1.1, P34 v1.1). CCEGA Program Paper 41.
Added: Reproducible Colab notebook implementing GWTC-4.0 analysis for intermediate regime identification (21 events, 2.33–9.20 M☉).
López Sánchez, M. (2026). P 41 The GWTC-4.0 Catalog Reveals 21 Objects GR Cannot Explain — CCEGA Can (1.0.0). Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19366216
Files
P41v1_6_GWTC5_CCEGA.pdf
Additional details
Dates
- Other
-
2026-04-02Jupyter Notebook