Algebraic structure of the CHSH failure mode: a Bell-state-selective diagnostic for coherent Ry errors
Description
The textbook CHSH measurement configuration {a, a', b, b'} = {0, pi/2, pi/4, -pi/4} with Form I evaluates to S = 0 on all four Bell states in the spin-1/2 convention used by gate-based quantum processors. This "failure mode", documented as a state-formula-angle mismatch in a companion pedagogical note (doi:10.5281/zenodo.20146219), is shown here to have a clean algebraic origin: the corresponding Bell operator reduces to sqrt(2) * (sigma_z (x) sigma_x + sigma_x (x) sigma_z), whose spectrum is {-2*sqrt(2), 0, 0, +2*sqrt(2)}, with the kernel spanned by {|Phi+>, |Psi->} and the non-kernel pair {|Phi->, |Psi+>} mapped to each other.
Main results. The note establishes three properties of the failure-mode configuration:
(1) The CHSH value S is preserved at exactly zero under arbitrary symmetric local Pauli channels (depolarizing, dephasing, bit-flip) and under local Rx and Rz rotations on either qubit, for every Bell state. Verified numerically with 1000 random Pauli channels per state and across the full range of standard noise channels.
(2) Local Ry(theta) rotations break S = 0 only for the pair {|Phi->, |Psi+>}, with closed form S = 2*sqrt(2)*|sin(theta)|, reaching the Tsirelson bound at theta = pi/2.
(3) The asymmetry has a direct algebraic origin in the correlation tensor: the kernel pair has equal XX and ZZ moments (t_1 = t_3), while the broken pair has opposite signs (t_1 = -t_3). This connects to and gives algebraic meaning to the Bell-state taxonomy of the companion paper.
Diagnostic interpretation. The same CHSH measurement that fails in textbook form becomes a no-extra-resource diagnostic for coherent Ry-type errors restricted to a specific Bell-state family. If S > 0 in this configuration, then (i) the state is in the {|Phi->, |Psi+>} family, and (ii) a coherent Ry error of magnitude theta_err = arcsin(S/(2*sqrt(2))) is present. Incoherent Pauli noise alone cannot produce this signal.
Calibration of novelty. The note explicitly searches the self-testing literature (Supic-Bowles 2020 review) and the CHSH-under-noise literature (Kofman 2012, Kofman-Korotkov 2008) and reports that this specific asymmetric breaking pattern was not located in those communities. Priority is explicitly disclaimed with respect to gate-set-tomography and randomized-benchmarking literatures, which were not exhaustively surveyed. The result is presented as either a novel observation or, if previously catalogued elsewhere, an independent algebraic rederivation with closed-form expression in terms of the correlation tensor.
Reproducibility. The repository contains the LaTeX source, the bibliography, both figures, and seven Python scripts that reproduce every numerical claim from scratch using only NumPy and Matplotlib. Each script is self-contained and runs in seconds.
Companion paper. This work extends the pedagogical note "State-dependent CHSH inequality on gate-based quantum processors" (Perez-Eugenio 2026, doi:10.5281/zenodo.20146219), which documents the original state-formula-angle compatibility issue and the corrected configurations. The present note can be read independently.
Files
CHSH_Failure_Mode_Algebraic_Structure_v1.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- Is supplemented by
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.20146219 (DOI)