Published May 14, 2026 | Version v1

THREE CLOSURE REGIMES OF NEGATION Pre-Closure Quantifier Negation (Det_lex NO), Post-Closure Exclusion (Det_syn NOT), and Propositional Negation (NEG_ext)

Authors/Creators

Description

This article argues that English negation decomposes into three closure-stratified installation regimes,
each defined by the type-level object available at its closure gate. Det_lex NO installs ¬ pre-closure inside
generalized-quantifier formation (CG1), generating downward entailment and robust NPI licensing.
Det_syn NOT is post-closure exclusion over nominal candidates of type e* (CG2), contrast-set-dependent
and REIFY-mediated, incapable of creating DP-internal DE geometry. NEG_ext is propositional denial of
type
⟨t,t⟩ (CG3), scoping over the outputs of the nominal pipeline and producing classical double negation
when applied to CG1-negative propositions.
The architecture is governed by two formal principles: the Closure-Compatibility Condition (CCC),
which blocks higher-closure operators from accessing lower-closure internal structure, and the RepairCost Lower Bound (RCLB), which prefers lower-cost installations. The framework derives the polarity
asymmetries between NO and NOT, the contrast dependence of NP-internal NOT, the typed noncancellation of not no N sequences, and the availability of classical double negation under clausal denial.
Cross-linguistic evidence from German and French supports the triple-regime typology. Seven explicit
falsifiers and audit-ready corpus coding criteria make the proposal empirically testable.
 

Files

Three Closure Regimes of Negation.pdf

Files (997.5 kB)

Name Size
md5:92757c3fd01754c6084c8d34410c62fa
997.5 kB Preview Download