Calibration of Thermal Measurement Systems: Methods, Performance Evaluation, and Measurement Uncertainty Assessment
Authors/Creators
Description
Thermal measurement systems are critical to
industrial manufacturing, environment
monitoring, medical care and research. But
their trustworthiness requires proper
calibration and traceability. This review
explores the latest calibration techniques for
widely used thermal measurement instruments,
such as thermocouples, resistance temperature
detectors (RTDs), thermistors, radiation
thermometers and thermal cameras [1-4]. The
research offers a practical approach to assess
instrument performance using statistical
quality control methods such as repeatability,
stability and measurement deviation [5,6].
Moreover, it discusses the measurement
uncertainty evaluation process using the
internationally recognized Guide to the
Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement
(GUM) approach, enabling laboratories to
enhance their measurement confidence [7].
The study also compares the main calibration
techniques, including fixed-point calibration,
comparison calibration and electrical
simulation [8-10]. Fixed-point calibration is
the most accurate method and can achieve
uncertainties of 0.5 mK for standard platinum
resistance thermometers (SPRTs) at the triple
point of water [11,12]. In contrast, comparison
calibration is more adaptable, and is the
method commonly used in industrial practice
for its convenience and ease of operation
[13,14]. As an example, a Type K
thermocouple was calibrated using an SPRT as
the reference standard [15]. The measurements
found expanded uncertainties (coverage factor
k = 2) of 0.08 °C at 0°C and 1.2°C at 1100°C,
demonstrating the uncertainty growth at higher
temperature [16]. Evaluation of uncertainty via
Monte Carlo simulation (10⁶ iterations) also
verified the uncertainty model and the
accuracy of the results [17,18]. Finally, the
review offers recommendations for setting
calibration intervals, establishing uncertainty
budgets and participating in proficiency testing
schemes [19-21]. These benchmarks are
particularly helpful for laboratories accredited
to ISO/IEC 17025, where technical
proficiency and traceability of measurement
are required [22,23].