Published April 21, 2026 | Version v1

Boundary Theory

Description

We present boundary theory, a structural framework built from five primitives: the oriented boundary (with two slot positions that may be identified or distinct), nesting (containment between boundaries), modal commitment, NAND-contrastive alethic colour, and an attention attribute (amber) that formalises the minimum attentional capacity required for any agent to use any framework. The framework originates in a simple observation: the act of ostensive naming — pointing at something and saying what it is, as in “this is a circle” — requires exactly these five primitives and no others, with each primitive instantiated by an identifiable component of the act. Boundary theory makes explicit the mechanism of an act so ordinary it has escaped formalisation, specifying each primitive operationally rather than categorially so that the mechanism is executable by a parser and not merely describable by a philosopher. We show that these primitives suffice to decompose eighteen of the sixty-five Natural Semantic Metalanguage (NSM) primes of the v20 chart, corresponding to the logical-ontological-quantificational-modal fragment of semantics plus bare attentional selection. We classify the remaining primes as importing one of ten recognisable content-axes outside the framework’s scope: perspective, phenomenology, valuation, magnitude, temporality, oriented space, embodiment, process, agency, or possession. The fact that the forty-seven N-primes fall into a small number of clustered content-categories rather than dispersing across unrelated items is itself evidence that the Y/N distinction tracks a genuine structural joint rather than being gerrymandered. Applying the framework to three mathematical foundations (ZFC, category theory, type theory), we identify the shared semantic floor as an eleven-prime core common to all three. Each foundation reduces to boundary theory plus at most one characterisable extension: category theory equals boundary theory under the relabelling of self-loop boundaries as objects and non-degenerate boundaries as morphisms, with no extension required; ZFC equals boundary theory plus one interpretation-layer addition (infinity); type theory equals boundary theory plus one primitive-layer addition (typing), with an optional further addition for unbounded universe hierarchies in practical implementations. Three foundations that appear incomparably different share a five-primitive common core and differ only by small, specific, characterisable extensions. The framework is presented in two parallel formulations, Minimal English and formal symbolic, which are jointly human-readable and machinecheckable. The reduction chain mathematics → English → NSM primes → boundary theory primitives is explicit at every layer, with each NSM prime’s reduction either provided as a structural capture or identified as an irreducible leaf labelled by the specific content it imports.

Files

boundary_theory.pdf

Files (525.5 kB)

Name Size
md5:8c00253f21520fa23bf8f90dd05a342c
323.9 kB Preview Download
md5:f6c488915dbd2a480b31bf0e1a2f23a6
190.7 kB Download
md5:4b5db9101c8f4f5852c4e6c1b97049c0
10.8 kB Download