Nuevos paradigmas de legitimación en el uso de la fuerza: De la invasión de Irak (2003) a la guerra en Irán (2026)
Authors/Creators
- 1. Centro Universitario de la Defensa - Academia General Militar
Description
LEGAL REVIEW
Blasco Lisa, Sandra. “Nuevos paradigmas de legitimación en el uso de la fuerza: De la invasión de Irak (2003) a la guerra en Irán (2026).” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 8, April 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.
The article develops a sophisticated and doctrinally grounded comparative analysis of the evolution of legal and political paradigms governing the use of force in the contemporary international system. By juxtaposing the 2003 invasion of Iraq with the 2026 operations against Iran, the study identifies a dual transformation: the progressive reconfiguration of the legal arguments used to justify military action and the parallel mutation of strategic modalities in the conduct of hostilities. This duality situates the article firmly at the intersection of ius ad bellum, strategic studies, and the broader dynamics of international order.
At the core of the analysis lies the transformation of legitimizing narratives in the use of force. The article convincingly demonstrates that the 2003 intervention in Iraq was framed within a formal—albeit highly contested—legal architecture, grounded in an expansive interpretation of Article 51 of the United Nations Charter. The doctrinal construct of anticipatory or preventive self-defence, which sought to extend the temporal threshold of lawful defensive action to encompass foreseeable threats, is identified as a central pillar of this justification . This interpretative shift is critically examined through the lens of classical doctrine, particularly the distinction articulated by Dinstein between preemptive and interceptive self-defence, which serves to delimit the boundaries of legality by excluding actions based on merely hypothetical threats.
The article further situates this doctrinal evolution within a broader strategic and political context. The legitimization of the Iraq intervention relied not only on legal argumentation but also on a comprehensive narrative strategy combining allegations of weapons of mass destruction, links to terrorist organizations, and systemic threat characterization. This multidimensional approach reflects the integration of legal discourse with strategic communication, highlighting how the construction of legitimacy in international law is often intertwined with broader processes of narrative framing and political persuasion.
A particularly significant contribution of the article lies in its analysis of the erosion of multilateral legitimacy mechanisms. While the 2003 intervention was accompanied by attempts—ultimately unsuccessful—to secure explicit authorization from the United Nations Security Council, the 2026 operations against Iran are characterized by a marked departure from this model. The article identifies a clear tendency toward unilateralism and the marginalization of multilateral institutions, reflecting a broader shift from a paradigm of “legalized strategy” to one more closely aligned with Realpolitik . This evolution raises fundamental questions regarding the continued capacity of international law to function as an effective constraint on the use of force.
From an operational perspective, the article highlights a parallel transformation in the conduct of warfare. The invasion of Iraq is characterized as a classical interstate conflict involving large-scale ground operations and prolonged territorial occupation, with all the attendant legal challenges under International Humanitarian Law, particularly in relation to occupation regimes and the protection of civilian populations. In contrast, the operations against Iran exemplify a shift toward limited, remote, and highly targeted uses of force, primarily through precision strikes aimed at neutralizing political and military leadership . This transition reflects a broader trend in contemporary warfare toward minimizing direct military exposure while maximizing strategic effect.
The legal implications of this operational shift are profound. The increasing reliance on targeted killings raises complex questions regarding the identification of lawful targets, particularly when state officials are involved. The article situates this issue within the broader doctrinal debate on direct participation in hostilities, as well as within the evolving jurisprudence of post-9/11 counterterrorism operations. The reference to what has been termed the “law of 9/11” underscores the emergence of a more permissive legal framework that expands the scope of lawful lethal force while simultaneously challenging established human rights norms .
Another critical dimension of the analysis concerns the role of international law in shaping—or failing to shape—state behavior in an era of great power competition. The article argues that the progressive marginalization of legal constraints reflects not only strategic considerations but also deeper structural changes in the international system, including shifts in the distribution of power and the declining influence of multilateral institutions. This perspective aligns with realist critiques of international law, which emphasize its dependence on underlying power structures for effective enforcement.
The article represents a significant and intellectually rigorous contribution to the study of the use of force in international law. By combining doctrinal analysis, strategic insight, and empirical comparison, it offers a compelling account of the evolving relationship between law, power, and legitimacy in the contemporary international system. Its identification of a shift from legal justification toward strategic pragmatism provides a valuable framework for understanding the challenges facing the international legal order in an era of increasing geopolitical competition.
Files
BLASCO_LISA_Nuevos_paradigmas_de_legitimacion_en_el_uso_de_la_fuerza_Iran_CODESEL_Boletin_2026_8.pdf
Files
(409.3 kB)
| Name | Size | |
|---|---|---|
|
BLASCO_LISA_Nuevos_paradigmas_de_legitimacion_en_el_uso_de_la_fuerza_Iran_CODESEL_Boletin_2026_8.pdf
md5:2f2dcf5054f742b43443e002f6f8e0ad
|
409.3 kB | Preview Download |