The Rotation Gap Is Not An Error: Ternary Structure in IBM Quantum Hardware
Authors/Creators
Contributors
Other:
Description
Standard quantum error correction assumes that all syndrome activations represent errors requiring correction. This paper presents evidence from 756 QEC runs across three IBM Eagle r3 processors (ibm_brisbane, ibm_kyoto, ibm_osaka) that this assumption is incomplete.
The hardware exhibits sub-Poissonian syndrome statistics — Fano factor F = 0.856 (t = −131 against Poisson) with zero dependence on code distance (ANOVA p = 0.79) and linear burst scaling (R² = 0.9999). These statistics indicate that a fraction of syndrome events are not random noise but structured cooperative transitions arising from the Z₃ chirality classes of IBM's heavy-hex (Eisenstein-compatible) lattice connectivity.
A regime classifier decoder is introduced that distinguishes binary errors from ternary transitions using five structural features (isolation, boundary status, density contrast, chirality, temporal consistency). On a mixed error model calibrated to the IBM hardware statistics, the classifier reduces logical error rates by 7–19% at static detection depth (τ = 1) across all cell sizes, with p < 0.0001 in all four τ = 1 conditions. The improvement mechanism is selective abstention: the classifier correctly identifies 75–80% of ternary transitions at τ = 1 (88–98% at τ = 5) and leaves them uncorrected, whereas a standard decoder miscorrects them.
A cross-platform control on Google's 105-qubit Willow processor (420 experiments, d = 3, 5, 7) shows the opposite statistics: super-Poissonian (F = 2.42), super-linear burst scaling, and positive spatial correlation. The Willow result is a prospective prediction of the Merkabit framework (Paper 15), which identifies hexagonal connectivity as the structural requirement for Z₃ chirality-driven anti-bunching. IBM's heavy-hex architecture satisfies this requirement; Google's grid architecture does not. The classifier applied to Willow produces zero improvement, confirming the effect is architecture-specific.
The IBM sub-Poissonian statistics were consistent with Paper 15's framework when the DAQEC benchmark became available. The Willow analysis was conducted after Paper 15 was complete, on data not previously examined, and constitutes the prospective test.
Direct hardware validation (§2.7): A hexagonal syndrome circuit (7-node cell, 12 CNOTs per round, T = 20 rounds, 4,000 shots) was run on real IBM Quantum hardware by Thor Henning Hetland. On ibm_strasbourg (Eagle r3) with native-direction CX gates, F = 0.9611 < 1 — sub-Poissonian, confirming the prediction on a processor and circuit independent of the original analysis. The routed circuit on the same processor gives F = 1.207, and ibm_fez (Heron r2) gives F = 18.75 — both super-Poissonian. The signal is gate-direction-sensitive: wrong-direction CX gates inflate circuit depth from 1163 to 2045, destroying the anti-bunching structure. This sensitivity confirms the effect is geometric: it depends on preserving native hexagonal connectivity at the gate level.
Key results: F = 0.856 ± 0.03 (IBM) vs F = 2.42 ± 0.36 (Willow) · linear burst scaling R² = 0.9999 (IBM) · 7–19% LER improvement · zero classifier effect on Willow · f = 14.4% ternary fraction
Data sources: IBM DAQEC benchmark, Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.17881116 · Google Willow surface code data, Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.13273331
Files
Paper_3_The_Rotation_Gap_Is_Not_An_Error_correct_v.2.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- Is part of
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.19417293 (DOI)
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.18925475 (DOI)
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.18980026 (DOI)
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.18981288 (DOI)
- Preprint: 10.5281/zenodo.19437878 (DOI)