AI Discovery Systems and the Geometry of Verification A Topological Diagnostic of Autonomous Scientific Systems
Description
This paper introduces the TRIDENT diagnostic stack, a five-stage methodology for evaluating the reliability of AI-driven scientific discovery systems. The framework analyses the structural relationship between inference operators and verification operators within discovery pipelines — the measurement geometry of AI science.
The stack is applied to five representative systems: the AI Scientist (Sakana AI), AlphaFold (DeepMind), robotic laboratory automation platforms, self-driving research loops, and AlphaTensor (DeepMind). Each system is evaluated through five sequential diagnostics: Detection/Observation Protocol (DOP), Underlying Structure Detection (USDOP), Structured Diagnostic Output (SDOP), TRIDENT gates (G1–G4), and the Geometry Constitutive Test (LBS).
The analysis yields a general reliability theorem:
AI Discovery Reliability ∝ N_verified / (N_verified + N_proxy + N_narrative + N_interpret)
where N_verified denotes modes directly constrained by a verification operator — either physical measurement (E_physical) or formal logical verification (E_formal). Reliability is determined by the position of the verification operator relative to the branch survival gate, not by model capability or scale.
The five cases define a phase diagram of AI discovery systems across two axes: verification type and gate position. A new failure mode — the temporal topology violation — is identified in iterative self-driving pipelines. Four engineering design rules follow directly from the analysis.
Diagnostic stack: TOOLBOX_MASTER v1.9 — Cases 001–005 — Status: VERIFIED
Files
trident_zenodo.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- References
- Publication: 10.5281/zenodo.19995433 (DOI)