Published March 19, 2026 | Version v3
Preprint Restricted

Kochen--Specker Contextuality and the Tetralemmatic Calculus of Quantum Mechanics

Description

The contextual character of quantum observables—formalized by the Kochen--Specker theorem
and Bohr's complementarity—represents a fundamental rupture in classical binary logic.
In interference regimes, such as the double-slit experiment, polar questions
(e.g., ``Which path did the particle take?'') are operationally unaskable, yet standard
logical frameworks fail to formalize this unaskability without collapsing into truth-value
gaps or triviality. We resolve this by introducing a context-indexed formal logic that
adjoins an explicit \emph{applicability predicate} to the valuation space.

Drawing structural inspiration from the ancient \emph{catuṣkoṭi} (tetralemma), we map
quantum operational states onto four distinct logical sectors: \emph{Thesis/Antithesis}
(strong measurement and decoherence), \emph{Synthesis} (paraconsistent gluts realized
via weak measurement), and \emph{Holothesis} (paracomplete gaps representing typed
inapplicability). From this logical foundation, we generate a $*$-algebra equipped with
a positive warrant functional. Through the Gelfand--Naimark--Segal (GNS) construction,
we demonstrate that Hilbert-space structure—and the \emph{physical complex phase structure}—emerges
canonically from an order-$4$ logical symmetry rather than being presupposed.
Contextuality is quantified via incompatibility graphs, with chromatic number bounding
minimal classical embeddings.

We establish a \emph{locus symmetry-breaking} correspondence wherein physical symmetry
breaking dictates logical polarity, while symmetry preservation dictates logical
transcendence (self-duality). This \emph{logic-first reconstruction} unifies Relational
Quantum Mechanics (Rovelli) and Consistent Histories (Griffiths, Omnès, Gell-Mann, Hartle)
as regime-relative logical stances within a pre-geometric ontology of \emph{interdependent
origination} (contextual co-arising of observer and observable), where the observer's
contextual frame and the system's observable reality are co-arising and non-separable.
The framework yields testable deviations in many-body or higher-dimensional interference
regimes ($I_3 \neq 0$), providing an empirical pathway for detection.

Files

Restricted

The record is publicly accessible, but files are restricted. Log in to check if you have access.

Additional details

Additional titles

Subtitle
The Formal Roots of the Unaskable in Quantum Measurement

Dates

Submitted
2026-03-17