Published March 8, 2013 | Version v1
Journal article Open

Ethical Dilemmas in Egyptian Archaeology and Repatriation Practices: An African Perspective Comparative Study

  • 1. Minia University
  • 2. Environmental Research Institute (ERI)

Description

Egyptian archaeology has faced significant ethical dilemmas regarding repatriation of artifacts to their countries of origin and indigenous communities. The research employs a comparative analysis approach, drawing from archival data, interviews with archaeologists and representatives of indigenous communities, and scholarly literature to explore divergent perspectives on ethical conduct in Egyptian archaeological contexts. A notable finding is the disparity in how artifacts are classified (as national heritage versus local property) between Egypt's Ministry of Antiquities and indigenous groups, leading to conflicts over repatriation rights. The study highlights the need for a more nuanced approach that respects both international legal frameworks and cultural sensitivities of affected communities. Archaeological practices should incorporate community consultation processes early in project planning stages, ensuring equitable decision-making on artifact management and repatriation. Egyptian archaeology, ethical dilemmas, repatriation, indigenous communities, comparative study

Files

zenodo.19002007.pdf

Files (92.9 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:8a98b384945724a6f98a5b7f0383080e
16.2 kB Download
md5:6d2a5b1f6f9f2fe8471167dd837cad97
76.7 kB Preview Download