Published March 2, 2026 | Version v1

ARBITRABILITY OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY DISPUTES IN INDIA: DRAWING THE LINE BETWEEN RIGHTS IN REM AND RIGHTS IN PERSONAM

Authors/Creators

  • 1. Symbiosis Law School, Pune

Description

This paper examines the evolving arbitrability of intellectual property disputes in India through the traditional distinction between rights in rem and rights in personam. While intellectual property rights are statutorily granted and enforceable against the world at large, their commercial exploitation increasingly takes place through private contractual arrangements, giving them a hybrid legal character. Indian courts initially adopted a rigid approach that treated IP disputes as largely non arbitrable. Recent jurisprudence, particularly following Vidya Drolia, reflects a gradual shift towards a more contextual and functional analysis. This paper argues that arbitrability should depend not merely on classification, but on the practical impact of arbitral determinations on third party rights and public registers. Through an examination of key Supreme Court and High Court decisions, the study highlights India's movement towards recognising contractual IP disputes as arbitrable, while preserving judicial control over issues of validity and infringement. It proposes a functional impact test to balance party autonomy with public interest, and calls for legislative clarity to strengthen India's arbitration framework in IP driven commercial disputes.

Files

69a48a1db337c.pdf

Files (209.9 kB)

Name Size
md5:79297c34328e6673971728c47448446b
209.9 kB Preview Download

Additional details