Published February 2, 2026 | Version v1

The Comparative Asymmetry Principle: Relational Disequilibrium in Multi-Agent Environments

Authors/Creators

Description

This paper formalizes how self-evaluating agents generate internal disequilibrium through observation of other agents. We define the conditions under which perceived asymmetry between an agent's current state and the observed states of others produces a measurable behavioral perturbation—comparative perturbation (Π)—distinct from deficit-driven motivation.

The framework makes four principal contributions: (1) A domain-independent formalization defining five structural properties (P1–P5) jointly sufficient to produce comparative perturbation, applicable to biological, artificial, and organizational agents; (2) A three-level decomposition distinguishing behavioral perturbation (Π), internal mobilization (M), and subjective tension (Σ); (3) A resolution taxonomy identifying five structurally distinct resolution strategies with determinants of strategy selection; (4) Formal integration with the Viability Mismatch Law and the theory of self-organizing systems.

The principle unifies social comparison theory, relative deprivation research, and reference-dependent utility models under a general systems framework while maintaining a clear separation between its domain-independent core and domain-specific phenomenological extensions.

Keywords: social comparison, comparative perturbation, multi-agent systems, relational evaluation, goal drift, behavioral perturbation, viability mismatch, self-organizing systems, relative deprivation, reference-dependent utility

Files

The_Comparative_Asymmetry_Principle.pdf

Files (393.6 kB)

Name Size
md5:0064e7383432d1c2909c8dd5a4cf12d8
393.6 kB Preview Download