Published December 30, 2025 | Version v1
Other Open

Epistemological Analysis of Academic Claims: Digital Forensics Misuse and Researcher Integrity in Document Authentication

Authors/Creators

Description

This article explores the application of epistemology and professional ethics in verifying scientific claims within popular literature. Using the case study of Roy Suryo’s analysis of Joko Widodo’s diploma, this paper examines the demarcation between science and pseudoscience. The analysis focuses on the misapplication of Error Level Analysis (ELA) on secondary data, the failure to adhere to the hierarchy of evidence, and the ethical breach of publishing unverified hypotheses as final conclusions. The study highlights the pathology of intellectual behavior that mirrors historical scientific failures such as the Andrew Wakefield case, while contrasting it with the gold standard of scientific integrity established by Richard Feynman. 

Files

Artikel Ilmiah Uji Epistemologi terhadap suatu klaim Akademik (final).pdf

Files (238.4 kB)

Additional details

Additional titles

Alternative title (Indonesian)
Verifikasi Epistemologis Klaim Akademik: Analisis Kritis terhadap Penyalahgunaan Forensik Digital dan Integritas Karakter Ilmuwan dalam Kasus Autentikasi Dokumen