The Great Narrative–Affect Gap: A Large-Scale Baseline of Story–Emotion Discrepancy in Online Relationship Narratives
Description
This preprint presents the first population-scale empirical baseline of the narrative–affect gap—the structural discrepancy between how elaborately people narrate their relational experiences and how intensely they express emotion. Using 351,734 de-identified posts from Reddit’s r/relationships, the study computes a transparent psycholinguistic index of narrative complexity (Level of Complexity; LoC), document-level affective polarity, and three derived indices: the Narrative–Affect Discrepancy Index (NADI), the Emotional Flatness Score (EFS), and the Over-Narration Index (ONI).
Analyses reveal that LoC and affective magnitude are nearly orthogonal (r = 0.07), contradicting long-standing assumptions of expressive congruence. The NADI distribution exhibits a strongly right-skewed tail, and unsupervised clustering identifies five expressive archetypes—Intellectualized Detachment, Ruminative Over-elaboration, Pragmatic Distancing, Unstructured Venting, and Affective Paradox—each reflecting distinct emotion-regulation strategies enacted through language.
This work provides a structural human baseline for narrative psychology, clinical screening research, and emotion-aware AI. It also connects the narrative–affect gap to broader ethical questions of affective sovereignty, emphasizing how digital systems may distort or constrain natural expressive regimes if they implicitly enforce congruence between story and emotion.
The preprint is conceptually aligned with the ANEST/ANAD dataset (Zenodo DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17632586), which provides derived features and reproducible analysis code.
Files
Kim_2025_NHB_NarrativeAffectGap_Main.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- Is supplemented by
- Dataset: 10.5281/zenodo.17632586 (DOI)