Published October 1, 2025 | Version 1

La verdad como obligación: Rehenes y desaparecidos en la guerra moderna

  • 1. Centro Universitario de la Defensa - Academia General Militar

Description

Legal Review of “La verdad como obligación: Rehenes y desaparecidos en la guerra moderna,” by Dr. Andrés Miguel Cosialls (CODESEL Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 5, October 2025)

Dr. Andrés Miguel Cosialls’ article “La verdad como obligación: Rehenes y desaparecidos en la guerra moderna” represents one of the most technically rigorous and normatively coherent analyses in recent Spanish-language scholarship on International Humanitarian Law (IHL). The study offers an exhaustive juridical and hermeneutical interpretation of Articles 32 to 34 of Additional Protocol I to the 1949 Geneva Conventions, establishing a clear and logical bridge between humanitarian obligations and the autonomous right to the truth.

From a doctrinal standpoint, Cosialls frames Article 32 not as a mere preambular clause but as a structural norm of contemporary humanitarian law. His reading is both systematic and teleological: Article 32 operates as the conceptual foundation for all subsequent obligations concerning missing persons, shifting the analytical focus from the abstract duties of States to the concrete subjective right of families to know the fate of their relatives. This perspective aligns with the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (Velásquez Rodríguez v. Honduras, 1988) and the United Nations Committee on Enforced Disappearances (Principle No. 7, 2019), confirming the article’s continuous applicability beyond the cessation of hostilities.

The author’s argumentation distinguishes itself by integrating primary sources (ICRC Commentaries, Customary International Humanitarian Law, Sassòli 2024, and relevant ICTY/ICC jurisprudence) into a unified interpretive framework. His thesis—that the right to know transcends the temporal limits of war and persists until each disappearance is resolved—extends the humanitarian rationale of IHL into the post-conflict phase, merging it with transitional justice mechanisms based on truth, memory, and reparation.

Cosialls also advances a nuanced distinction between missing persons and hostages, grounding his differentiation on the element of intentionality. While disappearance may result from chaos or negligence, hostage-taking presupposes deliberate coercion. Yet, the article goes further, recognizing that in modern conflicts—such as Syria, Colombia, or Ukraine—these categories frequently overlap, producing cumulative violations of IHL. His analysis of jurisprudence from Karadžić, Mladić, and Kvočka demonstrates how both practices have evolved from moral wrongs into fully prosecutable international crimes.

Another remarkable contribution is the comparative treatment of IHL across international, non-international, and hybrid armed conflicts. Cosialls identifies the asymmetry of obligations between the Geneva Conventions and Additional Protocol II, critically exposing how legal lacunae in non-international conflicts allow States and non-State actors to evade humanitarian accountability. His call for the universalization of protection mechanisms under customary IHL—particularly Rule 117 on the obligation to search for the missing—reflects a forward-looking interpretation in line with ICRC’s 2024 report International Humanitarian Law and the Challenges of Contemporary Armed Conflicts.

In the penultimate section, the author links the duty of search and truth disclosure with the sphere of international criminal responsibility. Hostage-taking is framed as a war crime under Article 8 of the Rome Statute, while enforced disappearance is treated as a crime against humanity under Article 7. This synthesis of humanitarian and criminal frameworks not only reinforces the normative density of Articles 32–34 but also emphasizes command responsibility under Article 28, highlighting the personal accountability of commanders and political leaders.

From an academic and practical perspective, the article succeeds in reasserting the humanitarian essence of IHL while articulating an operational framework for its enforcement. Its argumentation is both meticulous and evocative, balancing legal precision with moral clarity. The conclusion—that Article 32 is a “permanent mandate of elucidation, documentation, and reparation” binding all parties until every disappearance is resolved—captures the enduring human dimension of humanitarian law in an era marked by hybrid wars, opaque detentions, and digital disinformation.

Files

COSIALLS_La_verdad_como_obligacion_Rehenes_y_desaparecidos_guerra_moderna_CODESEL_Boletin_2025_5.pdf