Published October 3, 2025 | Version v1
Journal article Open

Microanalysis of Peasant Households in the Era of Modernization: Evidence from the Russian Empire

Authors/Creators

  • 1. Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow, Russia

Description

The article presents the results of the econometric analysis of microdata obtained from drawing up the budgets of peasant households in five regions – two European (Novgorod province, Simbirsk province) and three Asian (Ural region, Central Asian and Far Eastern) – in the period from the beginning of the Stolypin reform (1906) to the outbreak of the First World War (1914).

The purpose of the study is to shed light on the question of whether there was an agrarian revolution in pre-revolutionary Russia. The regression analysis of the production function showed that the main factor significantly influencing the output is the amount of land, followed by the number of horses, with number of workers being insignificant. At the same time, it follows from the stochastic boundary model applied to the production function that there are no technologically special differences between the regions, whereas technologies did not differ much from previous centuries. Study of peasant farms' embeddedness in market relations demonstrated that marketability in all the regions was approximately 31-37%.

It is concluded that during the period under study in Russia, the modernization of the agricultural sector was at an initial stage, that is, the processes that could later lead to an agrarian revolution were just beginning.

Files

POPECON_article_127923.pdf

Files (457.9 kB)

Name Size Download all
md5:1f4dd34a71b6642e99c39c033cf07662
331.3 kB Preview Download
md5:3630f837cd014122a808ac81b04253ff
126.6 kB Preview Download

Additional details

Related works

Cites
Publication: 10.2139/ssrn.2555273 (DOI)

References

  • Allen R (1992) Enclosure and the yeoman: the agricultural development of the South Midlands 1450-1850. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 376 рр.
  • Allen R (1999) Tracking the agricultural revolution in England. Economic History Review New Series 52(2): 209–235.
  • Byres T (2009) The landlord class, peasant differentiation, class struggle and the transition to capitalism: England, France and Prussia compared. The Journal of Peasant Studies 36(1): 33–54.
  • Chayanov V (1929) Byudzhetnye issledovaniya. Istoriya i metody [Budget research. History and methods] Novyj agronom, Moskva.
  • Chayanov AV (1989) Krest'yanskoe khozyaistvo. Izbrannye trudy [Peasant economy: Selected works] Ekonomika, Moskva.
  • Chernomorskiy MN (1955) Krest'yanskie byudzhety i vyborochnye perepisi kak istochnik po sotsial'no-ehkonomicheskomu razvitiyu derevni [Peasant budgets and sample censuses as a source for the socio-economic development of the village] Trudy MGIAI, Moskva.
  • Clark G (1987) Productivity growth without technical change in European agriculture before 1850. The Journal of Economic History 47(2): 419–432.
  • Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossiiskoi imperii. Chast' 1 (1889) S-Petersburg. 26 (20).
  • Davydov M (2016) Dvadtsat' let do Velikoi voiny: rossiiskaya modernizatsiya Vitte-Stolypina. [Twenty Years Before the Great War: Witte-Stolypin's Russian Modernization] Aletejya, SPb.
  • Dennison T, Nafziger S (2011) Micro-Perspectives on Living Standards in Nineteenth Century Russia. Research Papers in Economics No. 2011-07.
  • De Vries J (1994) The industrial revolution and the industrious revolution. The Journal of Economic History 54(2): 249–270.
  • De Vries J (2016) Revolyutsiya trudolyubiya: potrebitel'skoe povedenie i ehkonomika domokhozyaistv s 1650 goda do nashikh dnei [Revolution of industriousness; consumer behavior and household economics from 1650 to the present day] Izdatel'skij dom «Delo» RANHiGS. Moscow.
  • Field D (1989) The polarization of peasant households in prerevolutionary Russia: Zemstvo censuses and problem of measurement. Research in Economic History 5: 477–505.
  • Glavnoe upravlenie zemleustroistva i sel'skogo khozyaistva, otdel pereseleniya. Dannye byudzhetno-hozyajstvennogo obsledovaniya 75-ti Pereselencheskih hozyajstv Kustanajskogo, Aktyubinskogo i Ural'skogo uezdov [Main Department of Land Management and Agriculture, Relocation department. Data from budgetary and economic monitoring of 75 resettlement farms of the Kustanai,Aktobe and Uralsk districts] (1911) Izdanie Turgajsko-Ural'skoj pereselencheskoj organizacii.
  • Glavnoe upravlenie zemleustroistva i sel'skogo khozyaistva,otdel pereezda. Hozyajstvennyj byt kirgizskogo,sartovskogo i russkogo naseleniya yugo-vostochnoj chasti Chimkentskogo uezda Syr-Dar'inskoj oblasti: dannye byudzhetnogo issledovaniya [Main Department of Land Management and Agriculture. Relocation department. Household life of the Kyrgyz, Sart and Russian population of the south-eastern part of the Chimkent district of the Syr-Darya region: data from a budgetary study] (1910) Tashkent.
  • Gregory P (1972) Economic growth and structural change in Tsarist Russia: a case of modern economic growth? Soviet Studies 23 (3): 418-434.
  • Istoriya razvitiya gosudarstvennoj statistiki v Amurskoj oblasti 1895-2015 [History of the development of state statistics in the Amur region 1895-2015] (2015) Pod red. Davydovoj GA [Davydova GA (Ed)] Blagoveshchensk.
  • Izvestiya Amurskoi ehkspeditsii, poslannye po vysochaishemu komandovaniyu; vypusk 2. Materialy statistiko-ekonomicheskogo obsledovaniya kazach'ego i krest'yanskogo hozyajstva Amurskoj oblasti [Proceedings of the Amur Expedition sent by the highest command; issue 2. Materials of statistical and economic research of Cossack and peasant economy of the Amur region] (1913) St. Petersburg.
  • Johnson R (1997) Family life cycles and economic stratification: A case-study in rural Russia. Journal of social history. Spring: 705–731.
  • Kessler G, Markevich A (2019) Electronic Repository of Russian Historical Statistics, 18th – 21st centuries. Version 2. http://ristat.org/
  • Kovalchenko ID, Selunskaya NB, Litvakov BM (1982) Sotsial'no-ehkonomicheskii stroi pomeshchich'ego khozyaistva Evropeiskoi Rossii v ehpokhu kapitalizma [Socio-economic structure of the landlord economy of European Russia in the era of capitalism] Nauka. Moskva.
  • Kovalchenko ID, Moiseenko TL, Selunskaya NB (1988) Sotsial'no-ehkonomicheskii stroi krest'yanskogo khozyaistva Evropeiskoi Rossii v ehpokhu kapitalizma. [Socio-economic structure of the peasant economy of European Russia in the era of capitalism: (sources and research methods)] Moskovskij gosudarstvennyj universitet imeni M.V. Lomonosova Izdatel'skij Dom. Moskva.
  • Kratkie byudzhetnye svedeniya po hutorskomu i obshchinnomu krest'yanskomu hozyajstvu Simbirskoj gubernii [Brief budgetary information on the farm and communal peasant economy of the Simbirsk province] (1914) Simbirsk.
  • Kuznets S, Murphy J (1966) Modern economic growth: Rate, structure, and spread. Vol. 2. Yale University Press. New Haven.
  • Lenin V (1947) Razvitie kapitalizma v Rossii: Protsess obrazovaniya vnutrennego rynka dlya krupnoi promyshlennosti [The development of capitalism in Russia: The process of formation of an internal market for large-scale industry] Gos. izd-vo polit. lit. Leningrad.
  • Leonard C (2011) Agrarian Reform in Russia. The Road from Serfdom. Cambridge University Press, 402 pp.
  • Markevich A (2019) A Regional Perspective on the Economic Development of the late Russian Empire, May, 14. https://ssrn.com/abstract=2555273 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2555273
  • Ministerstvo Zemledeliya (Komitet po Zemleustroitel'nym Delam). Kratkij ocherk za desyatiletie 1906-1916 (1916) Petrograd.
  • Mironov BN (2012) Blagosostoyanie naseleniya i revolyutsii v imperskoi Rossii. [Welfare of the population and revolution in imperial Russia: XVIII-early XX centuries] Izdatel'stvo Ves' Mir. Moskva.
  • Obzor Amurskoj oblasti za 1910 god. Prilozhenie k vsepoddanneishemu otchetu Voennogo gubernatora Amurskoi oblasti. [Review of the Amur Region for 1910. Addendum to the Most Submissive Report of the Military Governor of the Amur Region] (1911) Izdanie Amurskij oblastnoj statisticheskij komitet.
  • Obzor Amurskoj oblasti za 1912 god. Prilozhenie k vsepoddanneishemu otchetu Voennogo gubernatora Amurskoi oblasti [Review of the Amur Region for 1912. Addendum to the Most Submissive Report of the Military Governor of the Amur Region] (1913) Izdanie Amurskij oblastnoj statisticheskij komitet.
  • Obzor Novgorodskoj gubernii za 1911 god. [Review of the Novgorod province for 1911] (1912) Novgorod.
  • Obzor Syr-Dar'inskoj oblasti za 1909 god. [Review of the Syr-Darya region for 1909] (1911) Tipografiya pri kancelyarii Turkest. Tashkent.
  • Obzor Turgajskoj obl. za 1910 god. Prilozhenie k vsepoddanneishemu otchetu Voennogo gubernatora [Review of the Turgay region for 1910. Addendum to the Most Submissive Report of the Military Governor] (1911) Orenburg.
  • Obzor Ural'skoj obl. za 1910 god. Prilozhenie k vsepoddanneishemu otchetu Voennogo gubernatora [Review of the Ural region for 1910. Addendum to the Most Submissive Report of the Military Governor] (1911) Ural'sk.
  • Ostrovsky AV (2013) Zernovoe proizvodstvo Evropeiskoi Roscii v kontse XIX – nachale XX v [Grain production in European Russia in the late 19th – early 20th centuries] Poltorak LLC. St. Petersburg.
  • Overton M (1996) Re-establishing the English agricultural revolution. The Agricultural History Review: 1-20.
  • Raschetno-statisticheskii otdel Novgorodskoi gubernskoi zemskoi upravy. Byudzhety krest'yanskih hozyajstv Novgorodskoj gubernii [Estimation and statistical department of the Novgorod province Zemstvo council. Budgets of peasant farms of Novgorod province] (1918) Gubernskaya tipografiya. Novgorod.
  • Rashin AG (1956) Naselenie Rossii za 100 let (1813–1913). Statisticheskie ocherki. [Population of Russia for 100 years (1811–1913): Statistical essays] Pod red. akad. SG Strumilina [Strumilina SG (Ed)] Gosstatizdat. Moskva.
  • Rostow WW (1960) The stages of economic growth: A non-communist manifesto. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge.
  • Rozinskaya N, Sorokin A, Artamonov D (2021) Peasants' inequality and stratification: evidence from pre-revolutionary Russia. Scandinavian Economic History Review 69(3): 253–277.
  • Rubakin NA (1912) Rossiya v cifrah. Strana. Narod. Sosloviya. Klassy: Opyt statisticheskoj harakteristiki soslovno-klassovogo sostava naseleniya russkogo gosudarstva [Russia in numbers. A country. People. Estates. Classes: An experience of statistical characteristics of the estate-class composition of the population of the Russian state] Izd-vo "Vestnik znaniya. St Peterburg.
  • Shcherbina FA (1900) Krest'yanskie byudzhety [Peasant budgets] Vol'noe ekonomicheskoe obshchestvo. Voronezh.
  • Statisticheskij obzor Simbirskoj gubernii za 1911 god. [Statistical review of the Simbirsk province for 1911] (1912) Simbirsk.
  • Statisticheskij spravochnik po agrarnomu voprosu [Statistical Handbook on the Agrarian Question] (1917) Pod. red. Oganovskogo NP, Chayanova AV, vypusk 1 [Oganovsky NP, Chayanov AV (Eds), issue 1] Moskva, «Universal'naya biblioteka».
  • The Agrarian History of Sweden. 4000 BC to AD 2000. Myrdal J, Morell M (Eds) (2011) Nordic Academic Press. Lund.
  • Trojnickij AG (1861) Krepostnoe naselenie v Rossii po 10-i narodnoi perepisi: statisticheskoe issledovanie [Serf population in Russia according to the 10th national census: a statistical study] tip. Karla Vul'fa. St-Peterburg.
  • Trudy podsektsii statistiki XI s"ezda russkikh estestvoispytatelei i vrachei 1901 g [Proceedings of the Statistics Subsection of the XI Congress of Russian Naturalists and Doctors in 1901] (1902) SPb.
  • Van Zanden JL (1991) The first green revolution: the growth of production and productivity in European agriculture, 1870-1914. Economic History Review. XLIV (2): 215–239.