Abiotic Co-Production of RNA and DNA in Model Protocells: Challenging the RNA World Hypothesis with Meisner et al.'s Methodology
Authors/Creators
Description
The RNA World Hypothesis (RWH) posits that RNA, with its genetic and catalytic capabilities, was the primordial self-replicating molecule, with DNA emerging as an RNA-derived product. Meisner et al. (2019) [1] supported RWH by demonstrating nonenzymatic RNA synthesis in model protocells, achieving ribonucleotide yields of ~2–5% under prebiotic conditions (60–80°C, pH 6–7). However, their focus on RNA overlooks the potential for simultaneous DNA synthesis, a gap this study addresses. Adapting Meisner et al.’s methodology, we simulated protocell dynamics to model the co-production of RNA and DNA, incorporating UV-driven RNA synthesis and 2’-OH deoxygenation for DNA synthesis. Using conditions of 80°C (pH 6.2) and 60°C (pH 7.0), the simulation included free ribonucleotides (100 nt equivalent; 25% A, 25% G, 25% C, 25% U), deoxyribonucleotides (20 nt equivalent), RNA and DNA oligomers (5–15 nt), peptides, lipid vesicles (80% oleate), phosphate, and montmorillonite catalysis. Results showed rapid RNA degradation (ribonucleotides to 0.7–1.1%, oligomers to 0.08–0.12%) and robust DNA yields (deoxyribonucleotides to 5.8–6.2%, oligomers to 0.45–0.50%). Validated by statistical analyses, these findings challenge RWH’s RNA-first narrative and support the Matter World Hypothesis (MWH) by demonstrating the simultaneous abiotic formation of RNA and DNA