Two Forces, Two Energies and Special Relativity for a Radiating Charge?
Authors/Creators
Description
Newtonian mechanics introduces a potential V(r vector) which represents energy, but at the same time is associated with a force through F= -grad V(r vector). In other words, this force is due to changes in energy V(r vector) in space. A point charge, which has rest mass, can be accelerated due to a force. According to special relativity rest mass is equivalent to energy and so accelerated energy is now a second kind of force. In fact, if V(r vector) is energy, then one would expect that this energy may be accelerated giving rise to this second kind of force (which is not gradient dependent). At this point, there is one energy (V(r vector) created by a source with rest mass) and two kinds of forces, one gradient dependent and the second existing only if the source (with rest mass) is accelerated.
An issue arises if one considers the two kinds of forces, -grad V(r vector) (or its Lorentz corrected form) and V(r) dv/dt (symbolic form), where dv/dt is acceleration. {Here, we are being somewhat simplistic in writing V(r) dv/dt. This is not the exact expression, but symbolically shows that there is no extra gradient acting on V(r).} The point we wish to make is that -grad V(r) and V(r) dv/dt have very different spatial drop-offs if V(r) goes as 1/ r (positive power). As a result, a person measuring force would notice V(r) dv/dt if the source of V(r) is accelerating. Given the slow drop-off, the measurer would not associate this force with -grad V(r) and so would think that it possibly comes from a different source independent of the object creating V(r). In other words, it is possible to take a source which creates V(r) and accelerate it. This leads to the usual -grad V(r) (Lorentz corrected) which is linked to the source object and second piece of energy and momentum which also represents force and has broken off from the source, and is linked with V(r) dv/dt.
The question arises: Why should there be this second source of energy? We argue that it is anticipated from special relativity. If one creates a Lorentz transformation for a particle with rest mass, (presumably a source of V(r)), then the formulation involves a parameter b (units of speed) which is the same as seen in all frames. It is described by E=pc which is linked to the wave equation velocity= b = frequency*wavelength and x=bt. It seems that this speed b is an upper bound speed and frame independent and so seems to be similar to that of a wave. The b object is a special one which does not have rest mass, but has energy and momentum. If there is no medium associated with b, then by Newton’s action-reaction one would expect some kind of force to be present as well. The question then becomes: What kind of forces are these which create a kind of wave which has a maximum speed? From the previous paragraph, we considered a general V(r vector) associated with a particle with rest mass. Then V(r) is created by the source particle, but we noted that if acceleration occurs, then V(r) dv/dt (symbolic form) might be seen as a separate entity with energy , momentum and force, but no source now. It seems that this is a candidate for the maximum speed b. Interestingly, even though V(r) is written as any potential, it is the electromagnetic one which supplies a photon which has no rest mass. Experimentally, it is known that photons are radiated by accelerating charges. Thus, special relativity, which seems to be completely general in terms of viewing a particle with rest mass from different constant -v frames, seems to be tied to one kind of physical force- electromagnetism through the photon.
As a result, the electric and magnetic fields which “break” off when there is acceleration should be able to create a second kind of energy and momentum (namely .5 eo Electric dot Electric + .5/uo Magnetic dot Magnetic) and 1/uo Electric x Magnetic field.
We consider these ideas here.