Published December 10, 2012 | Version v1
Other Open

Email correspondence with Cochrane (2012-2018)

  • 1. Re-Check
  • 2. Université de Lausanne
  • 3. McGill University
  • 4. Concordia University
  • 5. University of Waterloo, McMaster University
  • 6. Université de Montréal
  • 7. Université Laval


Emails sent between 2012 and 2018 to the Cochrane Gynaecological, Neuro-oncology & Orphan Cancer Group (CGNOCG), senior editor of the HPV vaccines Cochrane review, to Cochrane Editor in Chief David Tovey and to CGNOCG coordinating Editor Jo Morrison to point at methodological and ethical flaws in the Cochrane HPV vaccines review protocol, in the revised protocol, in the original and reconstituted authors panel, on the published review, and to ask when our June 4th 2018 analysis would be finally published, to insist tables should be made public, and to reiterate our request to receive a feedback from the review authors.
This email collection includes the exchange of February 2015 about the Cochrane HPV vaccines review’ leading author having presented intermediary review results at a congress, although we were informed in December 2014 that the review work hadn’t even started. Cochrane replied: “(..) The protocol was originally published a number of years ago now so it is inevitable that the authors would have commenced work on some, but not all, aspects of the review. We were unaware that the authors had presented preliminary findings of their review. Whilst it is not uncommon for researchers on Cochrane Reviews to present interim findings from their work prior to publication, this is not something which we are in a position to stop or approve. As such so we cannot comment on the presentation of preliminary results of the systematic review by the authors”.
When the emails were sent with attachment, the attachment’s content is presented.
Where needed, explanatory notes were added.



Files (2.3 MB)

Name Size Download all
391.8 kB Preview Download
560.7 kB Preview Download
549.3 kB Preview Download
788.4 kB Preview Download