Classical Free Particle Lagrangian Consistent with Relativity and Quantum Mechanics
Authors/Creators
Description
Classical mechanics introduces a function, L(x,v,t), called a Lagranian. such that the classical action: Integral (t1,t1) L(x,v,t)dt is stationary on variations of path, i.e. delta Action =0. This in turn leads to the differential equation: d/dt dL/dv partial - dL/dx partial =0 (if there are no constraints). The Lagrangian, however, is not a unique function in that different forms may satisfy the same differential equation.
In particular, the Lagrangian (relativistic) for a free particle is usually written as: -mo sqrt(1-vv/cc) ((1)). Given that v=constant, one has the almost trivial result: dv/dt=0. In other word, delta Action=0 yields no extra information for this Lagrangian because v=dx/dt by definition and v=constant a priori, so the differential equation is d/dt v=0.
In principle, however, the action is varied with respect to paths. Dt appears automatically, but a path should depend on x which is absent in ((1)). We thus suggest that there may be an issue using this Lagrangian form even though it gives the correct dv/dt=0. In particular, we argue that physical information about x is lost. We suggest that one may write the free particle action in a Lorentz invariant manner (something we have argued in previous notes), namely A = -Et+px (which is also a Lorentz invariant). This holds under the constraint that v=x/t. This can be shown to satisfy dv/dt, but at the same time there is a variation which satisfies delta Action=0, namely: v is held constant, ct→ct+b and x->x+b, where b is any arbitrary value. This implies uncertainty in both x and t beyond the usual solution x=vt. In other words, x=vt is not the whole picture even in classical action theory.
Given that b may be any arbitrary value, this uncertainty in x and t, does not directly lead to free particle quantum mechanics. In fact, an arbitrary b is a problem. To obtain quantum mechanics , one needs to consider the notion of conservation of momentum which is inherent in both Newtonian mechanics and classical Lagrangian theory. In particular, if one has two particles with momentum p1,p2 (one dimension and nonrelativistically) and the same rest mass, mo, we show that Lagrangian theory predicts conservation of momentum for internal forces (no external forces present).. Thus, for a free particle, momentum conservation must be respected from classical considerations. Given an arbitrary b, a probability linked with this uncertainty in x would not conserve probability unless one fixes b=hbar/p, i.e. makes it dependent on p in order to create orthogonality. This leads to exp(ipx) and exp(-iEt), i.e. free particle quantum mechanics.