Plant size, latitude, and phylogeny explain within-population variability in herbivory
Creators
- Wetzel, William1
- Hahn, Philip2
- Inouye, Brian3
- Underwood, Nora3
- Whitehead, Susan4
- Abbott, Karen5
- Bruna, Emilio2
- Cacho, N. Ivalu6
- Dyer, Lee7
- Tooker, John8
- Crowder, David9
- Elderd, Bret10
- Groenteman, Ronny11
- Eubanks, Micky12
- Paynter, Quentin11
- McCall, Andrew13
- Moreira, Xoaquín14
- Lecomte, Nicolas15
- Frago, Enric16
- Vandvik, Vigdis17
- Sobral, Mar18
- Pearse, Ian19
- Bronstein, Judith20
- Bagchi, Robert21
- Bagchi, Sumanta22
- Poveda, Katja23
- Sakata, Yuzu24
- Penczykowski, Rachel25
- Laihonen, Miika26
- Parthasarathy, Narayanaswamy27
- Waller, Lauren28
- Sasal, Yamila29
- Zarnetske, Phoebe30
- EGBON, Ikponmwosa31
- Kharouba, Heather32
- Puy, Javier33
- Sapir, Yuval34
- Lindroth, Richard35
- Piper, Frida I.36
- Karban, Richard37
- Kim, Tania N.38
- Kalske, Aino26
- Kimuyu, Duncan39
- Zhong, Zhiwei40
- Pepi, Adam37
- Massad, Tara41
- Tack, Ayco42
- Utsumi, Shunsuke43
- Burghardt, Karin44
- Buckley, Yvonne45
- Ohsaki, Haruna46
- Weber, Marjorie47
- Yamawo, Akira46
- Andrade, Janete48
- Angulo, Diego49
- Barrett, Sarah50
- Ben-Simchon, Eyal51
- Bloodworth, Kathryn52
- Rosenheim, Jay37
- Bustos-Segura, Carlos53
- Barbosa, Milton54
- Castagneyrol, Bastien55
- Calixto, Eduardo2
- Santos, Bráulio48
- Allen, Warwick56
- Carvalho, Raquel57
- Anstett, Daniel30
- Abdala-Roberts, Luis58
- Dáttilo, Wesley59
- Forister, Matthew7
- Valtonen, Anu60
- Rasmann, Sergio53
- Gripenberg, Sofia61
- Tougeron, Kévin62
- Cornelissen, Tatiana54
- Anjos, Diego63
- Koerner, Sally52
- Dallstream, Caroline64
- Pringle, Elizabeth7
- Holm, Sille60
- Baskett, Carina65
- Chiuffo, Mariana29
- Fernandes, Geraldo54
- Helms, Anjel12
- Moore, Christopher66
- Endara, María-José67
- Gossner, Martin68
- França, Filipe69
- Moles, Angela70
- Robinson, Moria30
- Pereira, Cássio54
- Cinto Mejía, Elizeth30
- Cogni, Rodrigo57
- Cortez, Dezirea71
- Ejomah, Afure31
- Farah, Keiko25
- Farias, Rafael de Paiva72
- Finn, Alain45
- Florjancic, Grace4
- Fox, Quinn25
- Grof-Tisza, Patrick53
- Haack, Nora73
- Haq, Shiekh Marifatul74
- Hennecke, Justus75
- Holeski, Liza76
- Kagiya, Shinnosuke43
- Kersch-Becker, Monica8
- Komatsu, Kimberly52
- Krishnan, Sushmita77
- Lamelas-López, Lucas78
- LaScaleia, Michael21
- Li, Xiaofei79
- LoPresti, Eric80
- Louthan, Allison38
- Maia, Laís56
- Mills, Charlotte70
- Ogbebor, Charlee81
- Pardikes, Nicholas82
- Rosenheim, Leah37
- Runyon, Justin83
- Salgado-Luarte, Cristian84
- Sawant, Manasi85
- Schroeder, Hayley23
- Segre, Hila51
- Smith, David71
- Torrico-Bazoberry, Daniel86
- Uyi, Osariyekemwen31
- Vaca-Uribe, Jessica87
- Lehn, Carlos88
- Moshobane, Moleseng89
- Ferrante, Marco78
- Merwin, Andrew90
- Pan, Vincent30
- Morrison, Colin91
- Nakajima, Kazuhide92
- Shelef, Oren51
- Eisenring, Michael68
- Rosche, Christoph93
- Segoli, Michal94
- Muola, Anne95
- Villellas, Jesus96
- Losada, María18
- Everingham, Susan97
- Mijango-Ramos, Zarluis91
- Phartyal, Shyam98
- Kalwajtys, Michael30
- Martin, Bruce30
- Davis, Julien23
- Trowbridge, Amy35
- Cock, Marina99
- Hermann, Sara8
- Getman-Pickering, Abigail100
- Quintero, Carolina29
- Luizzi, Victoria20
- Hutchinson, Matthew101
- Cope, Olivia102
- Greig, Keri91
- Lyon, Nicholas30
- Tayal, Mandeep103
- Kluse, Jennifer10
- Shinohara, Naoto104
- Zehr, Luke30
- Fernandes, Akshatra105
- Keasar, Tamar106
- Pawar, Rohit85
- Schumann, Isabell75
- Sadeh, Asaf51
- van Dijk, Laura42
- Novais, Samuel59
- Singh, Rachit Pratap2
- Gooden, Ben107
- Pareja, Martín108
- Salcido, Danielle7
- Nakadai, Ryosuke109
- Yim, Samantha7
- Stotz, Gisela110
- Lynn, Joshua17
- Quijano, Teresa58
- Hahn, Lisa75
- Mannall, Tosca97
- Maia, Renata54
- Cinoğlu, Damla91
- Kariyat, Rupesh111
- Getman-Pickering, Zoe112
- Dimarco, Romina113
- Gianoli, Ernesto84
- Sato, Yasuhiro114
- Dole, Haley30
- McGurrin, Kelsey44
- Jackson, Eleanor61
- Lynch, Shannon38
- 1. Montana State University
- 2. University of Florida
- 3. Florida State University
- 4. Virginia Tech
- 5. Case Western Reserve University
- 6. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México
- 7. University of Nevada Reno
- 8. Pennsylvania State University
- 9. Washington State University
- 10. Louisiana State University
- 11. Landcare Research New Zealand*
- 12. Texas A&M University
- 13. Denison University
- 14. Misión Biológica de Galicia
- 15. Université de Moncton
- 16. Centre de Coopération Internationale en Recherche Agronomique pour le Développement
- 17. University of Bergen
- 18. University of Santiago de Compostela
- 19. United States Geological Survey
- 20. University of Arizona
- 21. University of Connecticut
- 22. Indian Institute of Science Bangalore
- 23. Cornell University
- 24. Akita Prefectural University
- 25. Washington University in St. Louis
- 26. University of Turku
- 27. Pondicherry University
- 28. Lincoln University
- 29. Instituto de Investigaciones en Biodiversidad y Medioambiente*
- 30. Michigan State University
- 31. University of Benin
- 32. University of Ottawa
- 33. Estación Biológica de Doñana
- 34. Tel Aviv University
- 35. University of Wisconsin-Madison
- 36. University of Talca
- 37. University of California Davis
- 38. Kansas State University
- 39. Karatina University
- 40. Northeast Normal University
- 41. Gorongosa National Park
- 42. Stockholm University
- 43. Hokkaido University
- 44. University of Maryland, College Park
- 45. Trinity College Dublin
- 46. Hirosaki University
- 47. University of Michigan–Ann Arbor
- 48. Federal University of Paraíba
- 49. Centro de Investigación Científica de Yucatán*
- 50. Department of Parks and Wildlife
- 51. Agricultural Research Organization
- 52. University of North Carolina at Greensboro
- 53. University of Neuchâtel
- 54. Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais
- 55. Institut National de Recherche pour l'Agriculture l'Alimentation et l'Environnement Nouvelle-Aquitaine Bordeaux Centre*
- 56. University of Canterbury
- 57. Universidade de Sao Paulo
- 58. Autonomous University of Yucatán
- 59. Instituto de Ecología
- 60. University of Eastern Finland
- 61. University of Reading
- 62. University of Picardie Jules Verne
- 63. Federal University of Uberlândia
- 64. McGill University
- 65. Institute of Science and Technology Austria
- 66. Colby College
- 67. Universidad de las Américas
- 68. Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research
- 69. University of Bristol
- 70. University of New South Wales
- 71. California State University, San Bernardino
- 72. Federal University of Bahia
- 73. Independent Institute for Environmental Issues*
- 74. Wildlife Trust of India, Wildlife Crime Control Division*
- 75. Leipzig University
- 76. Northern Arizona University
- 77. Amrita Vishwa Vidyapeetham University
- 78. University of the Azores
- 79. Jilin Agricultural University
- 80. University of South Carolina
- 81. Nigerian Institute For Oil Palm Reasearch
- 82. Utah State University
- 83. Rocky Mountain Research Station
- 84. University of La Serena
- 85. University of Pune
- 86. Universidad del Desarrollo
- 87. Corporación Universitaria Minuto de Dios
- 88. Instituto Federal de Educacao Ciencia e Tecnologia Farroupilha - Campus Panambi*
- 89. South African National Biodiversity Institute
- 90. Baldwin–Wallace College
- 91. The University of Texas at Austin
- 92. Chuo University
- 93. Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg
- 94. Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
- 95. Norwegian Institute of Bioeconomy Research
- 96. University of Alcalá
- 97. University of Bern
- 98. Nalanda University
- 99. INCITAP (CONICET-UNLPam)*
- 100. ,
- 101. University of California, Merced
- 102. Whitworth University
- 103. Clemson University
- 104. Tohoku University
- 105. Ganpat Parsekar College of Education Harmal*
- 106. University of Haifa
- 107. Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation
- 108. State University of Campinas
- 109. National Institute for Environmental Studies
- 110. Andrés Bello University
- 111. University of Arkansas at Fayetteville
- 112. University of Massachusetts Amherst
- 113. University of Houston
- 114. University of Zurich
Description
Interactions between plants and herbivores are central in most ecosystems, but their strength is highly variable. The amount of variability within a system is thought to influence most aspects of plant-herbivore biology, from ecological stability to plant defense evolution. Our understanding of what influences variability, however, is limited by sparse data. We collected standardized surveys of herbivory for 503 plant species at 790 sites across 116° of latitude. With these data, we show that within-population variability in herbivory increases with latitude, decreases with plant size, and is phylogenetically structured. Differences in the magnitude of variability are thus central to how plant-herbivore biology varies across macroscale gradients. We argue that increased focus on interaction variability will advance understanding of patterns of life on Earth.