Mill's methods, induction, and case sensitivity in qualitative comparative analysis: A comment on Hug (2013)
Authors/Creators
Description
After years of silence on the method of Qualitative Compara-tive Analysis (QCA), the journal Political Analysis—generally considered the organ of cutting-edge political methodol-ogy—lately featured an intriguing piece by one of its editorial board members.1 In this article, Hug (2013) criticizes (1) QCA for its reliance on Mill’s methods of agreement and difference, which are inappropriate in the social sciences; (2) applied re-searchers for having perverted the method’s original objective of deductive theory testing to generate theory; and (3) the method itself for being highly sensitive to missing data and measurement error, a fact he accuses QCA’s proponents of having swept under the rug. He further claims to be offering remedies to the last problem in particular and concludes that, since the discipline now seems to agree on the central mes-sage of King, Keohane and Verba (1994) that a single standard for conducting social-scientific enquiry applies, the use of QCA may soon simply fade away.
Files
Thiem_2014_Mill's_QMMR_12_2.pdf
Additional details
Related works
- Is part of
- 2153-6767 (ISSN)