WADcher: State of the art of accessibility standards, evaluation tools, and technologies
Description
Disclaimer: This deliverable was finalised at the end of 2019. It reflects the state-of-the-art at that time. This field evolves continuously and may not reflect the state-of-the-art at the time the reader browses the document.
The WADcher project aims to provide an infrastructure to support monitoring of Web accessibility in Europe. This type of activity can be obtained only through the support of automatic validation tools. However, such tools must evolve in order to address the continuous technological evolution, and the corresponding change in accessibility guidelines.
This deliverable aims to provide an updated description of the state of art of the tools for automatic validation of accessibility guidelines. For this purpose, we have selected several web accessibility assessment tools according to several criteria (such as supporting at least the version 2.0 of WCAG and available in the English language). We also analyse some commercial accessibility services (including e.g. the Deque plugins for Chrome and Firefox, the Siteimprove Accessibility checker for Chrome, and the software developed by The Paciello Group). We compared them based on some critical features at the end of the section.
The deliverable also introduces metrics for accessibility evaluation, analyse relevant metrics for web accessibility, and report some research work that has been carried out on this topic, up to the most recent studies.
The analysis of the various accessibility validation tools has been carried out according to several dimensions: guidelines, languages supported, validation source, feedback provided, validation scope, whether DOM and/or CSS are checked, and plugin supported, and how the service is made available. For each tool we also provide relevant screenshots.
In the deliverable we also compare and discuss the most relevant tool features, such as validation scope, how they support customization of accessibility audits, overview of their validation results along with reports with details on the errors detected. The discussion includes remarks that can be useful for the further development of the WADcher set of tools based on the reviewed and collected information.
Disclaimer: Some of the descriptions contained in section 1 are based on the tool developers or manufacturers documentation and may not reflect the actual capabilities of the tools because not all of them have been fully reviewed by the consortium. The information in this document shall not be taken as any kind of endorsement from the consortium or from the European Commission.