Journal article Open Access

A Systematic Survey of the Effects of Wind Mass Loss Algorithms on the Evolution of Single Massive Stars

Mathieu, Renzo; Christian, D. Ott; Steven, N. Shore; Selma, E. de Mink

Mass loss processes are a key uncertainty in the evolution of massive stars. They determine the amount of mass and angular momentum retained by the star, thus influencing its evolution and presupernova structure. Because of the high complexity of the physical processes driving mass loss, stellar evolution calculations must employ parametric algorithms, and usually only include wind mass loss. We carried out an extensive parameter study of wind mass loss and its effects on massive star evolution using the open-source stellar evolution code MESA. We provide a systematic comparison of wind mass loss algorithms for solar-metallicity, nonrotating, single stars in the initial mass range of $15\,M_\odot$ to $35 M_\odot$. We consider combinations drawn from two hot phase (i.e.,\ roughly the main sequence) algorithms, three cool phase (i.e., post-main-sequence) algorithms, and two Wolf-Rayet mass loss algorithms. We discuss separately the effects of mass loss in each of these phases. In addition, we consider linear wind efficiency scale factors of $1$, $0.33$, and $0.1$ to account for suggested reductions in mass loss rates due to wind inhomogeneities.  We find that the initial to final mass mapping for each zero-age main-sequence (ZAMS) mass has a $\sim 50\%$ uncertainty if all algorithm combinations and wind efficiencies are considered. The ad-hoc efficiency scale factor dominates this uncertainty. While the final total mass and internal structure of our models vary tremendously with mass loss treatment, final luminosity and effective temperature are much less sensitive for stars with ZAMS mass $\lesssim 30\,M_\odot$.  This indicates that uncertainty in wind mass loss does not negatively affect estimates of the ZAMS mass of most single-star supernova progenitors from pre-explosion observations.  Our results furthermore show that the internal structure of presupernova stars is sensitive to variations in both main sequence and post main-sequence mass loss. The compactness parameter $\xi \propto \mathcal{M}/R(\mathcal{M})$ has been identified as a proxy for the "explodability" of a given presupernova model. We find that $\xi$ varies by as much as $30\%$ for models of the same ZAMS mass evolved with different wind efficiencies and mass loss algorithm combinations. This suggests that the details of the mass loss treatment might bias the outcome of detailed core-collapse supernova calculations and the predictions for neutron star and black hole formation.

Each tarball contains the stellar structure for the corresponding check point (.data file) and a model that can be used as a starting point for computations with MESA (.mod). Input parameter files are available at https://stellarcollapse.org/renzo2017

Acknowledgements. We wish to thank B. Paxton, F. Timmes, and R. Farmer for invaluable help with MESA. We acknowledge helpful exchanges with W. D. Arnett, M. Cantiello, D. Clausen, A. de Koter, L. Dessart, Y. Götberg, A. L. Piro, J. Fuller, N. Smith, and E. Zapartas. MR thanks the University of Pisa, where part of this work was carried out as his Master Thesis in Physics, and acknowledges the precious support of the "Lorentz group". This work is supported in part by NSF under grant numbers AST-1205732, AST-1212170, and PHY-1151197, and by the Sherman Fairchild Foundation. Some of the computations used resources of NSF's XSEDE network under allocation TG-PHY100033. Most of the simulation were carried out using the Caltech compute cluster Zwicky funded through NSF grant no. PHY-0960291 and the Sherman Fairchild Foundation. The runs to the onset of core collapse were carried out on the Dutch national e-infrastructure Cartesius, project number 15162) with the support of the SURF Cooperative.
Files (19.0 GB)
Name Size
15K-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:491279a526c6414c66f8d6104e692da1 48.7 MB Download
15K-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:806edf5b90858928a0b12808fb32a978 67.1 MB Download
15K-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:2562056c8d8f8b7c22a9deb651e895ff 43.1 MB Download
15K-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:5257fde240f4e90e4f04396fa1af3a98 48.1 MB Download
15K-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:23f563be995666b2d0604ad69c02e738 65.9 MB Download
15K-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:3f3a15f43e347fec12f5c8b17d80ed8f 43.2 MB Download
15K-dJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:63c434a17e35f8ab35ac56fee4c9d4fe 47.5 MB Download
15K-dJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:773848f051e71c7a4d481abf04331d43 66.2 MB Download
15K-dJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:1d0e73fba207dba597ba78f8853a618f 43.9 MB Download
15K-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:878d021a81f3ccefb68c5b3e1be20171 48.7 MB Download
15K-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:ca62e2226b97bce25fb0b599f646e8a5 66.2 MB Download
15K-NJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:83eb2d603cc7abf5ea621aac86050e64 81.5 MB Download
15K-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:1a72d2e4d139f76afdf872b52ec88d5c 43.1 MB Download
15K-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:cfc27234130a1d38c10e114cda3f64db 48.1 MB Download
15K-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:de322cdf06c6d868b9b34b1c08c26fde 66.2 MB Download
15K-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:5d7dfa334834a967ff1391fa342a8cbf 43.2 MB Download
15K-NJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:438683f1a1d8c5537192686eda9012b1 47.5 MB Download
15K-NJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:a9970d3c1bdc3851eec3c251ed1ceb29 68.1 MB Download
15K-NJ1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:faab19c39a29981e055ccc630db0c16e 84.4 MB Download
15K-NJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:a031da04906e3e834e90d940a9f59bda 43.9 MB Download
15K-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:c53a9382cf2942ef0b3bc50af75011f6 48.7 MB Download
15K-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:7676440a5e7b3719b5026a6af6c32478 66.0 MB Download
15K-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:7816bf4a20d615c67df6ccac7918132c 43.1 MB Download
15K-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:8d37244df1b820fd418b7c62f40a5bb0 48.1 MB Download
15K-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:ca14926d5c096d90cd7ba2d6d9a033c3 66.8 MB Download
15K-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:1a9c7e9c0c0d8c15d600b0d7d0e03a42 43.2 MB Download
15K-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:23b107f0d57f47343f3bd481df4f511c 47.5 MB Download
15K-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:20d21f41c1979fb999c8ccb6e9655690 67.8 MB Download
15K-vL1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:16d42387a37d88c8434891f8d9d55614 87.3 MB Download
15K-vL1.0_onset_cc.tar.gz md5:ca9c696e85174b5c5947941337994860 6.8 MB Download
15K-vL1.0_remeshed_O_depl.tar.gz md5:3b210838ac9cb809cba3af8a404b8113 7.4 MB Download
15K-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:1fe3b2dc7e7d82166be76c0ae29ef813 43.9 MB Download
15V-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:d25b3b865da3fb904ab9624ccdc8a781 48.6 MB Download
15V-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:e5db381b5b3978b032ef8e759c3ee576 66.7 MB Download
15V-dJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:6e1fc9cf47438f75f03838e59477421f 85.5 MB Download
15V-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:b377582c290b4636a04e5fec062ca3cf 43.1 MB Download
15V-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:3078b0df7d86f2d71133c9622392ca27 48.4 MB Download
15V-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:762606ee589a11950d5dbfd3642bc7c0 65.7 MB Download
15V-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:70a324401fa3a6e53e7033f6cfe06fb2 43.5 MB Download
15V-dJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:303401bb721818a5eab80371bf91de47 47.2 MB Download
15V-dJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:60fa37b53d79afb71bca6cca0cf5a53b 65.8 MB Download
15V-dJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:97c80549368c41c9a25397cfe757863d 44.5 MB Download
15V-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:0a280ea7f6727b6e1f1772fff3008662 48.6 MB Download
15V-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:f4e3b0beb196160527d29bafb7ee0ccd 66.4 MB Download
15V-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:992eafaa3d33d5c8edabd3580a336d10 43.1 MB Download
15V-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:9c49b8e2f3f7efcadfbdfb20a1d9303b 48.4 MB Download
15V-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:a076a155e4a7672c6d829668c65cd58a 66.2 MB Download
15V-NJ0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:72281fa5176df5be34e9289bbb98fb74 83.2 MB Download
15V-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:7f682bfd00247ea8acddec067cd3e79a 43.5 MB Download
15V-NJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:da92842cb543d5ddc93a9a58d84d77e6 47.2 MB Download
15V-NJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:ebcef633687af1b8ffffb5a9ff64aafb 66.4 MB Download
15V-NJ1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:540535e85abde67831f798700807aad3 82.7 MB Download
15V-NJ1.0_onset_cc.tar.gz md5:135d9dc24757ac28cfd8282988f62e06 5.1 MB Download
15V-NJ1.0_remeshed_O_depl.tar.gz md5:e918728a12296997cb5ced929e9f5a39 7.0 MB Download
15V-NJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:f3383290f2edcbec72ccff24037b2e5d 44.5 MB Download
15V-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:597a6619709bca1acee61a872e329e50 48.6 MB Download
15V-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:ce968481cf97ff7d009ce0d661388687 65.9 MB Download
15V-vL0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:218b391d67802d84ea1a321674fef1d2 83.9 MB Download
15V-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:c61b0ca747131cfd98c970d31b63c6fd 43.1 MB Download
15V-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:aef3f46fc06cde727cc49c7f20bb2b86 48.4 MB Download
15V-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:aa5758693f342086d8e44fa6e87abf73 66.9 MB Download
15V-vL0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:2d1a88e6bbf319b40e7e10fba9f9e07b 85.0 MB Download
15V-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:58cb5f530b4b76434247ba9ff7656b81 43.5 MB Download
15V-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:a8e0b9a1a3dffd825455f2b0eaba8302 47.2 MB Download
15V-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:5130b73a6c72c7e0a50700a51cc1cb88 68.6 MB Download
15V-vL1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:f49f40ac3ba7441450dbc13363e5e475 86.5 MB Download
15V-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:69405d9a0eb43272804ca73775db8fb6 44.5 MB Download
20K-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:2ae6b4a4b749c4dc3e462cd3aa8bd7ec 52.3 MB Download
20K-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:7a4374cf288fb76d9536292caab565d6 69.1 MB Download
20K-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:9454b4ae16e3b0aa131914f14d835fd0 45.4 MB Download
20K-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:c88ff3af1caa36294eeb59af6721aea9 52.3 MB Download
20K-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:7c5327e457fa5af1866101f06eef8aa8 69.5 MB Download
20K-dJ0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:ef4a7ec08c4df1d47c91e6b2494104cf 90.9 MB Download
20K-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:e966730aa63d441826b8cbe50f301d33 45.6 MB Download
20K-dJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:4f822f1c6b54128d62b6bcd8b2bf56c3 52.1 MB Download
20K-dJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:dd234150a0e497a989e17e6c6a184991 66.3 MB Download
20K-dJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:18b9bc1fa366213da86e44609dcbeb6d 45.9 MB Download
20K-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:09199dcedee64abe98e631c030aff5d0 52.3 MB Download
20K-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:d3ee1fbdd2062383f28b8b48344e0a94 69.9 MB Download
20K-NJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:776160eb0916c98800b61b14ae43d6de 82.0 MB Download
20K-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:0bc5d591399d5588ad431ebcb18f47fe 45.4 MB Download
20K-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:12cd7cf44734af5c0c592db985c13a22 52.3 MB Download
20K-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:6a4ed915b3b02fd79209dac2f7157559 69.5 MB Download
20K-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:65cc9754b3031f0487befc1082e3095c 45.6 MB Download
20K-NJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:e0babb826f19ab6bf551728d7079f221 52.1 MB Download
20K-NJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:0b5034f36ab023875126652a9dccf8bb 65.8 MB Download
20K-NJ1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:6d6104e8134a9cb86fbd6a898fa1fd39 80.3 MB Download
20K-NJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:91b344bd7efd9ce728fe9a75c68ccb9e 45.9 MB Download
20K-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:448902dcdc34d84ee3438b298a582731 52.3 MB Download
20K-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:1c141111bab5668e37361fb24e50829c 69.5 MB Download
20K-vL0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:466927db853a0fff3bb0c312bd646723 86.4 MB Download
20K-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:19c8a73bbbaa81f1a9eca0891bb4fa79 45.4 MB Download
20K-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:0a4e87d577a3dd4e252d88f23035096e 52.3 MB Download
20K-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:dcf8fda9818aefe99cb093a3af44ae49 66.0 MB Download
20K-vL0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:073e237ec1037d59471deae393f5f9c5 77.0 MB Download
20K-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:1bc26ac55c5023fb4e8da14495d5c8e9 45.6 MB Download
20K-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:5ae60cd8a559ef3d6ab977f36a43e0ae 52.1 MB Download
20K-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:1e0e5a499805d60029296c71a85d7e2b 73.8 MB Download
20K-vL1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:1b6deeacee23ae226df42cc628201770 88.7 MB Download
20K-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:27b6eb05a7ab2178cb846fb3fcf86c27 45.9 MB Download
20V-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:65beb73d8a9346ad067506d3e0b903a5 52.5 MB Download
20V-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:f78f3ade0a6633e664240978a1f8389a 69.2 MB Download
20V-dJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:410a397da4322f92b07771e78f8b7f03 84.2 MB Download
20V-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:8c0d263c1b0ae4b303c910d51bd7ca14 45.6 MB Download
20V-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:619a616c4ab6ca725dfb97123df8e272 52.0 MB Download
20V-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:16f95fadb4cac203623980fed95c38b0 69.6 MB Download
20V-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:224c26ca11b2a16e57b3f11389418e59 46.0 MB Download
20V-dJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:604fc9937c84e5ae629885b2188565db 51.4 MB Download
20V-dJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:9158ab66db7a5659acb6cc3cd8091678 66.9 MB Download
20V-dJ1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:66fdb9892b4af574e68ecff26519d59f 86.1 MB Download
20V-dJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:5c7b8624266ddbbbe2d97d3a357b20f9 46.1 MB Download
20V-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:df5df10c9b1f9453be5b43274f7bacb6 52.5 MB Download
20V-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:f6459be659c74be47800a168cf19e333 69.3 MB Download
20V-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:0eda339cc86a4a7a23c78d02f54d5858 45.6 MB Download
20V-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:45367a459a2f08e63565145861ffffe0 52.0 MB Download
20V-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:8612002c02c680675e0697abbb9ef76c 69.4 MB Download
20V-NJ0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:2a1c02e876807553316aa7cd0d7a8af8 86.7 MB Download
20V-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:f1c42bcaef69c01e4744cf428d3f5e3e 46.0 MB Download
20V-NJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:f5a5a09f6e0299101543576e71cfbec0 51.4 MB Download
20V-NJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:22bae877e071bd4966fa201f7ac7c3ca 67.1 MB Download
20V-NJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:850fc254b8e3570091722d56374c8a0f 46.1 MB Download
20V-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:83f694ea3266e5a46125073629817b53 52.5 MB Download
20V-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:1ed78c6acbca36cba02e50d65230c79b 70.3 MB Download
20V-vL0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:568118a7788081ba4031d37ca53b12e5 82.4 MB Download
20V-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:1e8c8951dbd47639357aaaa10315e2f3 45.6 MB Download
20V-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:d63d3c2cbbda79cc1ce70cca5118ad95 52.0 MB Download
20V-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:4dbc3d581a9137619809ce09dc9b69e5 66.4 MB Download
20V-vL0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:134c72cd983307a58888a5df66cefea3 80.4 MB Download
20V-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:fdea57498f725cd5af541827efddfaee 46.0 MB Download
20V-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:1a509d376fe450c95bace69af92c6507 51.4 MB Download
20V-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:b070672f1836315dee3cd68f821ed7fb 74.6 MB Download
20V-vL1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:84a4a5e8a2c9a12b6b4c401af1c3ea25 83.7 MB Download
20V-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:9459bb7084628896fe1420cbaeae4a61 46.1 MB Download
25K-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:97405a24a9863f8952d1b57b49bc44b6 53.3 MB Download
25K-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:bfbfadbbe2fc2e943f655ddb02e18e6c 67.2 MB Download
25K-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:9e12a1b7475ab0a278e67fdd18d42691 47.9 MB Download
25K-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:8ea4c6158d40ca93589f95f72f2df697 53.6 MB Download
25K-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:8b275b7c20741b891d0cf74e5e78220b 69.7 MB Download
25K-dJ0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:07b09b1ca9275e7d52dcc6b4ddeb27f0 93.5 MB Download
25K-dJ0.33_onset_cc.tar.gz md5:4bc5edabbd0c23103e9606ca38fa96a9 4.6 MB Download
25K-dJ0.33_remeshed_O_depl.tar.gz md5:60feae5fbc5924406c153471899b4d36 8.4 MB Download
25K-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:70e788f2f8e8aa43425f5b8647dd9daf 47.9 MB Download
25K-dJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:43fd3b74e476242b1aa5376a1f758b6b 53.1 MB Download
25K-dJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:34eee3f2a2905328522ce984edb47cc0 65.5 MB Download
25K-dJ1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:dbdb6c65becdec1b2f80e3bd8e56be56 88.8 MB Download
25K-dJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:78d711b9046b096ebc4e9c5e84bb1176 48.6 MB Download
25K-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:f57e112192501fba63970891063ccf39 53.3 MB Download
25K-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:9b40bd09e5b12659906762885f8c1cec 70.2 MB Download
25K-NJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:7d803b3834807cbdaa5fdf7193e282fd 87.6 MB Download
25K-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:ebe4ecbb73fb8d18c431698d985b4d48 47.9 MB Download
25K-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:b63e5b1557406db86a36020262971c57 53.6 MB Download
25K-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:95e707309967029d84263acc187d7003 70.8 MB Download
25K-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:f5844d3697fcbff04e95646cf6080bba 47.9 MB Download
25K-NJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:0900fcf046f0a8121c84d1eb8fb84e2f 53.1 MB Download
25K-NJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:ad0298825da4a1eb7b5d236f06016c4b 65.8 MB Download
25K-NJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:f8925ec128d61f0a2526450bf53ba1f3 48.6 MB Download
25K-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:98a04900babb677a36909da3af8669e3 53.3 MB Download
25K-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:5e18eea2f1e8fdebad0f08e0bb168335 69.8 MB Download
25K-vL0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:8fa58d119deb9a0417687d3e977cb3ae 86.9 MB Download
25K-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:62423a9ced5d6a5594d04533f0d47c30 47.9 MB Download
25K-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:269f473d702202fd4dc8afb4f265165e 53.6 MB Download
25K-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:fea587ce7fa43f362d4672870cf6589f 70.2 MB Download
25K-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:c685903f5c0e67c30087ad1de9c63103 47.9 MB Download
25K-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:6fca8627489280da6bf504e9ed3bbec5 53.1 MB Download
25K-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:539170ee8b9e7c47fc0c540e48916574 63.0 MB Download
25K-vL1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:6d90fd10c63364b1b99e1a8859961d64 84.2 MB Download
25K-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:cf85828ad7ef6d98b581534f0d06be11 48.6 MB Download
25V-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:3292cbe597f72596f886caa36dd1ea99 53.3 MB Download
25V-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:3b61da7f8588c4553bcb8672f3480b45 68.0 MB Download
25V-dJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:2392565148bbd8efcb1aaa6f02b5cc42 92.3 MB Download
25V-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:31ef9a1eca862ef0f4831193ac3e4556 48.3 MB Download
25V-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:44a36782284f03267e86016411c0bfbc 53.5 MB Download
25V-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:1bbd277636180b3158e291d2209aa6d9 71.0 MB Download
25V-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:5727301d47328ceb188a5832a36d04c4 48.5 MB Download
25V-dJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:f44ec89b62d370be40fd9bb03f3689c9 52.9 MB Download
25V-dJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:5803697f41075d2916871d044d764946 63.5 MB Download
25V-dJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:e785abb824c5ed6f92df59c38b2d35e9 48.3 MB Download
25V-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:6f0d5e4e96c13b1af3ab73241d132d8e 53.3 MB Download
25V-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:d299643cfe7c67b5390846a609e35da7 69.6 MB Download
25V-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:a0f64a9d65ddb0b115771951ddb24e8d 48.3 MB Download
25V-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:7b3a42d97bf5bdd61c2a728c4cf1cf97 53.5 MB Download
25V-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:d9838833429f65640561eb6946ab7c3d 70.7 MB Download
25V-NJ0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:7011d73fc568f7a57f619be34434e984 93.1 MB Download
25V-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:fe33ae016d89797b2d63c1016b7f912d 48.5 MB Download
25V-NJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:99b5a7df9d567a42cad7e0c313a4ac8c 52.9 MB Download
25V-NJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:4a22d5fb1aba5622504d08332058c049 65.1 MB Download
25V-NJ1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:1fd17b1ac8088f0abe4305edb6873d8d 87.0 MB Download
25V-NJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:0aa4dad5be16bb346f3831cad79f2090 48.3 MB Download
25V-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:697d20db6051d8cb7c714c8951ee33f6 53.3 MB Download
25V-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:ad6a16985b3eddc5be735f95d76f2bcf 70.0 MB Download
25V-vL0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:6fdfb91e7ea20e82569194c7f840ea17 91.8 MB Download
25V-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:eae14d1907bfe6650f027e0f3d1338b2 48.3 MB Download
25V-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:2adddd56430bd8c3eae15119c9bf31e5 53.5 MB Download
25V-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:1b20dd34f76f6702c974b0fc1684507d 69.9 MB Download
25V-vL0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:78bbd6516a10e5fb852f78866b6ffdc7 93.7 MB Download
25V-vL0.33_onset_cc.tar.gz md5:f8f9217ba143f82ee09047690616439f 5.0 MB Download
25V-vL0.33_remeshed_O_depl.tar.gz md5:74228e433c665a743f213341c84282b2 7.3 MB Download
25V-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:cdf92acf9a5406b0ede3a651d6bc532b 48.5 MB Download
25V-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:6d10c225a45557dc7a746677a0ea7695 52.9 MB Download
25V-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:b169fa8bfae019406d6649df06a98f58 62.9 MB Download
25V-vL1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:766b0d658570f13ce53976a54a216205 83.8 MB Download
25V-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:163fa851c7d765d920a088d073190b39 48.3 MB Download
30K-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:8baa29da08a6ec01ed4e63f4e507ba8a 55.1 MB Download
30K-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:b0dd648d0e12fb8bc0341ced3f559c52 72.4 MB Download
30K-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:c980dd53a06ed6f9954696f9083ec46d 49.6 MB Download
30K-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:36fee838282b374282aa87963566328d 54.6 MB Download
30K-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:02bd3d5c30f14e33a2226fff2c14d676 73.9 MB Download
30K-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:9473001230f501f1cfb30a384bc092cf 48.7 MB Download
30K-dJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:b84fdb44a8f66dabce37a7f1ef30136a 54.0 MB Download
30K-dJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:577d7fa553b21c68ebc4175677c52f13 67.0 MB Download
30K-dJ1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:ffbe635ddf5f90bdeec146b181c0602c 87.4 MB Download
30K-dJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:4987a3c18638694bfe3fe696c2f66465 49.2 MB Download
30K-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:d6a918d6b5de343925eabbbff208c8de 55.1 MB Download
30K-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:c08a4bb38eddb60a880eb0a2e3398cf8 72.4 MB Download
30K-NJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:f8ff78078fe99c7cc845db90998068f4 91.5 MB Download
30K-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:86be7975211f2510fdf5fc62964b1e27 49.6 MB Download
30K-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:fa768b715c9d138c535dbae2ff22313e 54.6 MB Download
30K-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:f17c86307d2ce160106ccf51dcc9b890 74.8 MB Download
30K-NJ0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:157280fc3fad0595bda45a6444c4072f 89.0 MB Download
30K-NJ0.33_onset_cc.tar.gz md5:9294d68ebd06fa90f4632c8da10afb5a 5.3 MB Download
30K-NJ0.33_remeshed_O_depl.tar.gz md5:8440fd434e5fc30d04b3fd1d5dea9b66 7.5 MB Download
30K-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:718e1afdcd7c054c53bd6de380582845 48.7 MB Download
30K-NJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:41932623962649b2baf19419302bdbc8 54.0 MB Download
30K-NJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:1247775f929e2d8fc0a55d33c3875721 65.9 MB Download
30K-NJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:c5c4721a645995a30d6c427a58aba21d 49.2 MB Download
30K-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:e00d1933a0e8a072fcfe47adfe99e779 55.1 MB Download
30K-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:cf46f95be92994b316f2fb5ace852a67 68.3 MB Download
30K-vL0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:d74a017c8161cd9cab27304cc8d69eec 89.9 MB Download
30K-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:404b00e5fd6558e7ddb5d2e7c5736c10 49.6 MB Download
30K-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:2be64a1ecdc0e52edab9bf575f635209 54.6 MB Download
30K-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:c8e78bd7371680b249f887ace1bfbf52 72.5 MB Download
30K-vL0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:24e5224a54014a15e75b2fcf6acfc61a 90.3 MB Download
30K-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:640cc9a290f9f9396e0317f29dac535c 48.7 MB Download
30K-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:e0ce10548defb2d83b5665564bd5234d 54.0 MB Download
30K-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:13dcb3670b5af880055b2daf5e2de422 70.0 MB Download
30K-vL1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:a3b73621e86e8224ed3fd38daf24a5a6 91.3 MB Download
30K-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:6f948f0447727e815adf2432995e9f1a 49.2 MB Download
30V-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:130cd88a4f95d3efc45a601b5b9b86b2 54.5 MB Download
30V-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:a2a6cd6f202db60a032f635253067cdd 70.3 MB Download
30V-dJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:de0b77f2f2b0906565fda7db95edd764 89.6 MB Download
30V-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:cb196e76c8b04af05e5af56c4287bb42 48.7 MB Download
30V-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:d20f47fb64fe7685478ae2b9e79452e9 54.8 MB Download
30V-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:aca8cbfbf2d7f14830c98e0ae24ab936 70.8 MB Download
30V-dJ0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:0075c078f18d9aba84837d7e2d8eab5f 90.4 MB Download
30V-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:a9556c1b3687f5a55c37a2b36c877c27 49.7 MB Download
30V-dJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:f584c6c54346d6bc5242495da5bd1725 53.3 MB Download
30V-dJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:1aa641f0bffb5f368d475f1337d10a6c 62.8 MB Download
30V-dJ1.0_O_depl.tar.gz md5:6b085b8cbcf5f28313d6f1a2fc499f2d 85.8 MB Download
30V-dJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:20d8c2fa1d20ba965134389a085017e0 49.3 MB Download
30V-dJ_0.33_onset_cc.tar.gz md5:36823305cbd93948d85cda79e815064b 5.5 MB Download
30V-dJ_remeshed_O_depl.tar.gz md5:d8a4b941dc55c80c1649eb360c2d6d76 7.7 MB Download
30V-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:3c1d8c2b4b420fd9b280e1d1c02988cd 54.5 MB Download
30V-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:f1f2bb247d66a647f103a9282cce7f3f 72.7 MB Download
30V-NJ0.1_O_depl.tar.gz md5:162e736bec717c2f8ba04dd418955062 90.6 MB Download
30V-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:5fd86be4f553528d1e594b9e265f0804 48.7 MB Download
30V-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:c24b7ad534e20ad3f3d9581db763d3d5 54.8 MB Download
30V-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:792d95538094aba8a44345c61058be5e 71.3 MB Download
30V-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:b3dc014cf7e55565cae0ad5c8bc65f20 49.7 MB Download
30V-NJ1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:37d54fca105c722704e89e72d6b47633 53.3 MB Download
30V-NJ1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:f101187da8e856fd0c75b3cba2aa72d4 56.7 MB Download
30V-NJ1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:09718d7cd41fafb292ca13e37537bbc1 49.3 MB Download
30V-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:15d7f34dad9419518f79b212c7d09e69 54.5 MB Download
30V-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:4f1f7a3a02a8f6d7ff2c1675cbf1c39c 74.6 MB Download
30V-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:2945da6050a39df472a5cb27e68ad188 48.7 MB Download
30V-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:af5c922b30ecbd69e05ccf5ce6a6d9ba 54.8 MB Download
30V-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:df73c1fb2f4dfebf8e7ac33b6b76704e 73.8 MB Download
30V-vL0.33_O_depl.tar.gz md5:ce0f2f29cf95945d0fab3dd40254d11d 89.3 MB Download
30V-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:fd16227de87d7e65bbe920edca71e468 49.7 MB Download
30V-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:0c053431e7ad8951cc4e6b46ac4595cc 53.3 MB Download
30V-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:72fa3004a7938a1eac829dc7835d04e1 67.7 MB Download
30V-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:4b200035068ec51f22f6457b802030ad 49.3 MB Download
35K-dJ-NL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:190abf20e6b6ec78834d7c25acaf44c4 53.3 MB Download
35K-dJ-NL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:6897259e6e2b321ddbb08340ad1a0818 66.5 MB Download
35K-dJ-NL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:f22a0c816ef3d716daf2e6957f071cab 49.9 MB Download
35K-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:31cec75b18ace502dd9db926dcc89c3f 55.6 MB Download
35K-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:806784e8cf5f737bb01597f2e21897a0 75.0 MB Download
35K-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:9bda0fd79fa02cc5ad6663c1a230317b 49.2 MB Download
35K-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:08a8629abfa3c836e084b2a28393002c 55.5 MB Download
35K-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:e8cf59bdfea94e883f6b7d81a5d54e9b 72.2 MB Download
35K-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:51eeda7712e82cc3bdfd80b7e687e719 49.3 MB Download
35K-NJ-NL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:73dbc9f5c5152e0a88b107ff173524df 53.3 MB Download
35K-NJ-NL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:30b7d9240f4efc482ebb8a9868803ba1 64.6 MB Download
35K-NJ-NL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:becc6abd364a6b0dbfb1ff45a522febf 49.9 MB Download
35K-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:2d2abd0fff71f936eafa3950050e00f2 55.6 MB Download
35K-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:612e8cdb096a7e0de79ee58508e33b6e 75.3 MB Download
35K-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:3255010e09e905dec2f5d2386654dc73 49.2 MB Download
35K-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:499a4d36d375259a5847eddb94dab070 55.5 MB Download
35K-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:b35d25d6392de9829412ec2f9ea10df6 73.0 MB Download
35K-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:2a1ac86fc244de3643f5fb0713361093 49.3 MB Download
35K-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:c82e865f103cbdd9e1f4f16d93e5ad2b 55.6 MB Download
35K-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:c1d8ffbe274ead33c3cfcded563e416e 73.7 MB Download
35K-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:bde9590f8a3339cbc3000a992dc10f92 49.2 MB Download
35K-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:d4c1025c3aad94ca5709a8781686b26f 55.5 MB Download
35K-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:64c40a496974319f69161132b680505d 75.6 MB Download
35K-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:8930f5615cd0a4f8b421ac3711c8966e 49.3 MB Download
35K-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:8d6e85dd791c5b0237f18d52be13469d 53.3 MB Download
35K-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:1210b677a28fc145c1f0f72aadcd8f28 71.1 MB Download
35K-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:b0364c195ee52638c39f3efc62e6974d 49.9 MB Download
35V-dJ-NL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:4b3f62f6f0ca95c87e57109c9fe0bba2 52.1 MB Download
35V-dJ-NL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:4e2441961ed3a08b4394d473cda1a99b 85.1 MB Download
35V-dJ-NL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:5231e01a28288198612b2c4feed71923 48.9 MB Download
35V-dJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:c2e195e0dfc7b63936737658ccdd8575 55.9 MB Download
35V-dJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:7b6396e8cb80b324c791250146129a2f 78.9 MB Download
35V-dJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:14a95228e65d5d767ca1c1ef46736240 49.4 MB Download
35V-dJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:3f2d39f70be8fd8ba76f80aea1927884 55.1 MB Download
35V-dJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:36166754303a818ce440350910e97c05 73.8 MB Download
35V-dJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:99ce46a738fc651b85e54a657d407a52 50.3 MB Download
35V-NJ-NL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:3a33e2ad6603459861b50e6122e767fa 52.1 MB Download
35V-NJ-NL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:82a1e4d0f01c0a8baa9c83623f8cbc3f 67.1 MB Download
35V-NJ-NL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:70efdc2194db9729ed0688456527aa59 48.9 MB Download
35V-NJ0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:264625a6459af5b10bf2eeff98b7a3bb 55.9 MB Download
35V-NJ0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:7547e395867fc3fc398b0386e522018e 75.5 MB Download
35V-NJ0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:1446d227ca9f3f31af790ee8bd8fd74d 49.4 MB Download
35V-NJ0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:55d296f76a2644129b4c56e8c06dd78c 55.1 MB Download
35V-NJ0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:97583ebedf80f30fc47e48bd3acfd1cc 72.6 MB Download
35V-NJ0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:a52374a5ba80b5e3d679cc039eb0edb9 50.3 MB Download
35V-vL0.1_end_hot.tar.gz md5:f9ad0676559161ecdfe9b7b8151a58cb 55.9 MB Download
35V-vL0.1_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:0a1aa2b9efc35ac22ff11c7ed206326c 77.9 MB Download
35V-vL0.1_TAMS.tar.gz md5:f0bffcb8536c7a40fba8130b50116afd 49.4 MB Download
35V-vL0.33_end_hot.tar.gz md5:f0cf66fe198086fdeb3127447adf5d73 55.1 MB Download
35V-vL0.33_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:f86d2c512f3d86a829e5109a7369b373 75.6 MB Download
35V-vL0.33_TAMS.tar.gz md5:11b24fa3d1847ff250c2c42a049bb0ba 50.3 MB Download
35V-vL1.0_end_hot.tar.gz md5:61cc9cfee547b1505d8dc453650434a7 52.1 MB Download
35V-vL1.0_end_mass_loss.tar.gz md5:20d7c13f2181122fc91899e58385e536 70.7 MB Download
35V-vL1.0_TAMS.tar.gz md5:d4030af97dadf939706b54ec44d74f80 48.9 MB Download

Share

Cite as