There is a newer version of this record available.

Preprint Open Access

Manuscripts with Few Significant Introduced Variants

Barbara Bordalejo; Peter M. W. Robinson

The literature of stemmatics is rich in discussions of two phenomena which, it is commonly held, render the orderly assignation of manuscripts into families problematic, even impossible. These two phenomena are coincident agreement (where unrelated manuscripts share the same reading, apparently by simple coincidence) and contamination (where a manuscript combines readings from two or more manuscripts). In this article, we suggest that there is a third area of difficulty which causes considerable problems to the stemmatic project. This third area is the phenomenon of multiple manuscripts within a tradition which cannot be assigned to any family because there is no consistent pattern of agreement in introduced variants between them and other manuscripts.

 

 

Files (3.8 MB)
Name Size
Saggi_Bordalejo_Robinson evidenziato-2.pdf
md5:eea4ffaa8270406051f194737b693188
2.0 MB Download
Saggi_Bordalejo_Robinson evidenziato.docx
md5:7846970db41286f35c0193614a6ac0af
1.8 MB Download
220
141
views
downloads
All versions This version
Views 22086
Downloads 14154
Data volume 251.2 MB106.5 MB
Unique views 20183
Unique downloads 11951

Share

Cite as