WARRANTED DIVERGENCE: RETHINKING CREATIVE DECISION-MAKING UNDER PEDAGOGICAL UNCERTAINTY IN PRE-SERVICE PRIMARY TEACHER EDUCATION
Authors/Creators
Description
Primary teachers routinely act before they know what a pupil understands. This conceptual-analytic study examines a scenario-based micro-methodology, situation – alternatives – justification – adaptation, derived from a dissertation model of future primary teachers' professional-creative activity. It aligns the method's four stages with the model's components and codes the nine instructional alternatives in its three practice situations on six dimensions drawn from creativity, noticing, and formative assessment research. Seriating the coded matrix separates seven defensible alternatives from two contrast cases: the strongest responses are not the most novel but those that change how the pupil can show her thinking, thereby producing new evidence. The situations also serve two functions, selection among defensible options and discrimination of indefensible ones. I propose warranted divergence as a standard for creative decision-making under uncertainty and recommend adding epistemic-yield and trade-off lines to the decision card. The codes are single-analyst judgements, not outcome data, and require empirical testing.