Presentation Open Access

The solution to Arrow's difficulty in social choice (sheets)

Colignatus, Thomas

These are the sheets of a presentation on June 8 2018, at the conference of Dutch and Flemish political science. These sheets give an overview, and see "Voting Theory for Democracy" (VTFD) for precision. Arrow's theorem is that four axioms would be reasonable and morally required each by themselves, but together they result into a contradiction. The deduction stands but the interpretation can be rejected. Arrow confuses voting and deciding. The axiom of "pairwise decision making" can be rejected - and Arrow's label "independence of irrelevant alternatives" is distractive. A method that many would find interesting is Borda Fixed Point.

This is an update of the sheets of my presentation on March 16 2001 for the Social Choice group in Tilburg, The Politicologenetmaal 2018 has this link: https://politicologenetmaal.eu See Voting Theory for Democracy at https://zenodo.org/record/291985
Files (311.3 kB)
Name Size
2018-06-04-Sheets-Arrow.pdf
md5:0408382dca5d43e556c9ecaef9032c78
311.3 kB Download
29
10
views
downloads
All versions This version
Views 2929
Downloads 1010
Data volume 3.1 MB3.1 MB
Unique views 2929
Unique downloads 99

Share

Cite as