Section,Criterion,Count,Papers
A. Characteristics,Which author/s conducted the interview or focus group?,13,"sas2019quality, kendall2020third, lyon2020women, tassabehji2020female, ghosh2019current, fannoun2019towards, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, bano2017user, sablis2020team, bass2016artefacts, taylor2016adopting"
A. Characteristics,"What were the researcher’s credentials? E.g. PhD, MD",48,"besker2020influence, oliveira2020code, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, medeiros2020requirements, martinez2020agile, oriol2020data, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, chaabane2019modeling, kashfi2019integrating, dennehy2019breaking, hamzah2019exploratory, prana2019categorizing, zayan2019example, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, eckert2019alone, fannoun2019towards, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, pinto2018work, bick2017coordination, kurtanovic2018user, medeiros2018quality, ebad2018influencing, jovanovic2017transition, bano2017user, senapathi2017refining, sas2019quality, sablis2020team, siddoo2017factors, wang2016cheap, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, murphy2014design, anantharaman2018"
A. Characteristics,What was their occupation at the time of the study?,10,"lyon2020women, siddoo2017factors, wang2016cheap, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, murphy2014design"
A. Characteristics,Was the researcher male or female?,11,"lyon2020women, tassabehji2020female, siddoo2017factors, wang2016cheap, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, murphy2014design"
A. Characteristics,What experience or training did the researcher have?,6,"kendall2020third, lyon2020women, tassabehji2020female, lenberg2019misaligned, siddoo2017factors, taylor2016adopting"
B. Relationship,"Was a relationship established prior to study commencement?
",8,"sas2019quality, lyon2020women, lenberg2019misaligned, rejab2019agile, mishra2016professional, gandomani2015empirically, murphy2014design, anantharaman2018"
B. Relationship,"What did the participants know about the researcher? e.g. personal goals, reasons for doing the research",13,"sas2019quality, lyon2020women, tassabehji2020female, lenberg2019misaligned, rejab2019agile, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, murphy2014design, anantharaman2018"
B. Relationship,"What characteristics were reported about the interviewer/facilitator? e.g. Bias, assumptions, reasons and interests in the research topic",4,"lyon2020women, ayala2018system, ulziit2015conceptual, murphy2014design"
C. Framework,What methodological orientation was stated to underpin the study?,43,"besker2020influence, oliveira2020code, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, medeiros2020requirements, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, chaabane2019modeling, kashfi2019integrating, hamzah2019exploratory, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, eckert2019alone, fannoun2019towards, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, bick2017coordination, kurtanovic2018user, medeiros2018quality, siddoo2017factors, makinen2016improving, bass2016artefacts, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, alsahli2016toward, zayour2016qualitative, martini2016multiple, taylor2016adopting, gandomani2016agile, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, giuffrida2015conceptual, anantharaman2018, tamburri2015social"
D. Selection,"How were participants selected? e.g. purposive, convenience, consecutive, snowball",38,"besker2020influence, oliveira2020code, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, martinez2020agile, tassabehji2020female, chaabane2019modeling, hamzah2019exploratory, prana2019categorizing, melegati2019model, lenberg2019misaligned, eckert2019alone, fannoun2019towards, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, pinto2018work, bick2017coordination, kurtanovic2018user, ebad2018influencing, jovanovic2017transition, bano2017user, senapathi2017refining, sas2019quality, sablis2020team, siddoo2017factors, bass2016artefacts, hoda2016multi, mishra2016professional, taylor2016adopting, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, murphy2014design, anantharaman2018"
D. Selection,"How were participants approached? e.g. face-to-face, telephone, mail, email",24,"oliveira2020code, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, tassabehji2020female, luz2019adopting, melegati2019model, lenberg2019misaligned, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, pinto2018work, bick2017coordination, ebad2018influencing, bano2017user, senapathi2017refining, sas2019quality, sablis2020team, siddoo2017factors, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, anantharaman2018"
D. Selection,How many participants were in the study?,57,"besker2020influence, oliveira2020code, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, medeiros2020requirements, martinez2020agile, oriol2020data, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, chaabane2019modeling, kashfi2019integrating, dennehy2019breaking, hamzah2019exploratory, prana2019categorizing, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, eckert2019alone, fannoun2019towards, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, pinto2018work, bick2017coordination, kurtanovic2018user, medeiros2018quality, ebad2018influencing, jovanovic2017transition, bano2017user, senapathi2017refining, sas2019quality, sablis2020team, siddoo2017factors, wang2016cheap, makinen2016improving, aliempirical, bass2016artefacts, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, alsahli2016toward, zayour2016qualitative, martini2016multiple, iyawa2016customer, taylor2016adopting, gandomani2016agile, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, murphy2014design, anantharaman2018, tamburri2015social"
D. Selection,How many people refused to participate or dropped out? Reasons?,1,gandomani2015empirically
E. Setting,"Where was the data collected? e.g. home, clinic, workplace",35,"sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, martinez2020agile, oriol2020data, tassabehji2020female, luz2019adopting, prana2019categorizing, zayan2019example, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, fannoun2019towards, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, pinto2018work, bick2017coordination, kurtanovic2018user, medeiros2018quality, ebad2018influencing, jovanovic2017transition, bano2017user, senapathi2017refining, sablis2020team, siddoo2017factors, bass2016artefacts, hoda2016multi, zayour2016qualitative, taylor2016adopting, gandomani2016agile, anantharaman2018"
E. Setting,Was anyone else present besides the participants and researchers?,3,"minhas2020regression, tassabehji2020female, jovanovic2017transition"
E. Setting,"What are the important characteristics of the sample? e.g. demographic data, date",41,"besker2020influence, oliveira2020code, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, medeiros2020requirements, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, chaabane2019modeling, kashfi2019integrating, dennehy2019breaking, hamzah2019exploratory, zayan2019example, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, fannoun2019towards, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, bick2017coordination, jovanovic2017transition, siddoo2017factors, bass2016artefacts, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, iyawa2016customer, taylor2016adopting, gandomani2016agile, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, giuffrida2015conceptual, murphy2014design, anantharaman2018, tamburri2015social"
F. Collection,"Were questions, prompts, guides provided by the authors? Was it pilot tested?",35,"besker2020influence, oliveira2020code, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, medeiros2020requirements, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, dennehy2019breaking, hamzah2019exploratory, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, pinto2018work, bick2017coordination, medeiros2018quality, bano2017user, sablis2020team, siddoo2017factors, makinen2016improving, bass2016artefacts, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, martini2016multiple, iyawa2016customer, giuffrida2015conceptual, tamburri2015social"
F. Collection,"Were repeat interviews carried out? If yes, how many?",5,"lyon2020women, farias2019designing, fannoun2019towards, bano2017user, mishra2016professional"
F. Collection,Did the research use audio or visual recording to collect the data?,38,"besker2020influence, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, medeiros2020requirements, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, hamzah2019exploratory, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, eckert2019alone, fannoun2019towards, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, bick2017coordination, bano2017user, siddoo2017factors, makinen2016improving, bass2016artefacts, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, iyawa2016customer, gandomani2016agile, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, giuffrida2015conceptual, murphy2014design, anantharaman2018, tamburri2015social"
F. Collection,Were field notes made during and/or after the interview or focus group?,7,"minhas2020regression, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, tassabehji2020female, fannoun2019towards, mishra2016professional, iyawa2016customer"
F. Collection,What was the duration of the interviews or focus group?,36,"besker2020influence, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, kendall2020third, ghobadi2020generational, lyon2020women, medeiros2020requirements, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, chaabane2019modeling, kashfi2019integrating, dennehy2019breaking, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, bick2017coordination, jovanovic2017transition, bano2017user, senapathi2017refining, sas2019quality, sablis2020team, siddoo2017factors, hoda2016multi, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, iyawa2016customer, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, tamburri2015social"
F. Collection,Was data saturation discussed?,20,"besker2020influence, medeiros2020requirements, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, kashfi2019integrating, hamzah2019exploratory, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, eckert2019alone, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, bass2016artefacts, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, mishra2016professional, gandomani2016agile, gandomani2015empirically"
F. Collection,Were transcripts returned to participants for comment and/or correction?,4,"minhas2020regression, siddoo2017factors, fontana2015progressive, tamburri2015social"
G. Analysis,How many data coders coded the data?,12,"oliveira2020code, minhas2020regression, tassabehji2020female, lenberg2019misaligned, strandberg2019information, ayala2018system, siddoo2017factors, makinen2016improving, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, anantharaman2018, tamburri2015social"
G. Analysis,Did authors provide a description of the coding tree?,11,"minhas2020regression, tassabehji2020female, melegati2019model, strandberg2019information, bick2017coordination, teixeira2015lessons, ulziit2015conceptual, gandomani2015empirically, giuffrida2015conceptual, anantharaman2018, tamburri2015social"
G. Analysis,Were themes identified in advance or derived from the data?,39,"besker2020influence, oliveira2020code, sas2019quality, minhas2020regression, tassabehji2020female, farias2019designing, luz2019adopting, chaabane2019modeling, kashfi2019integrating, dennehy2019breaking, hamzah2019exploratory, prana2019categorizing, melegati2019model, ghosh2019current, lenberg2019misaligned, eckert2019alone, fannoun2019towards, rejab2019agile, strandberg2019information, pano2018factors, ayala2018system, pinto2018work, bick2017coordination, kurtanovic2018user, medeiros2018quality, ebad2018influencing, jovanovic2017transition, bano2017user, senapathi2017refining, sas2019quality, sablis2020team, wang2016cheap, makinen2016improving, stray2016daily, alsahli2016toward, martini2016multiple, gandomani2016agile, gandomani2015empirically, anantharaman2018"
G. Analysis,"What software, if applicable, was used to manage the data?",16,"pano2018factors, ayala2018system, bick2017coordination, bano2017user, senapathi2017refining, sablis2020team, bass2016artefacts, giardino2015software, stray2016daily, zayour2016qualitative, martini2016multiple, teixeira2015lessons, gandomani2015empirically, fontana2015progressive, murphy2014design, anantharaman2018"
G. Analysis,Did participants provide feedback on the findings?,2,"minhas2020regression, gandomani2015empirically"