1) Name of the tool	2) Provider	3) Access / Link	4) Form	5) Publication year	6) Development status	Automation level of the evaluation	8) Editing time	9) Number of upper categories	10) Number of questions	11) Comprehensibility of the evaluation	12) Generic	13) Subject reference	14) Explanation of the question	15) Feedback of the results	16) Final Report	17) Language	18) Registration required	19) Costs in Euro	20) Complies with FAIR principles	21) Required knowledge and skills 	22) Comment
FAIR Evaluation Services	FAIRsharing.org	https://fairsharing.github.io/FAIR-Evaluator-FrontEnd/#!/	Fully Configurable Tool, Automatic Tools	2018	complete and will be updated	completely automatic evaluation	5 min	4	22	all answers equally without weighting	yes	no	short explanation	short feedback	overview of passed tests with evaluation protocol	English	no	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	RDM knowledge and computational skills 	"evaluates only machine-readable data (e.g. no quality of documentation), based on ""FAIRsFAIR Data Object Assessment Metrics"": https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3775793"
FAIRshake	CFDE-CC	https://fairshake.cloud/	Fully Configurable Tool, Automatic Tools	2018	complete and will be updated	manual and automatic evaluation	20 min	4	16	weighting with indication of weights	yes	no	short explanation	no feedback	intermediate and final result in a color-coded matrix	English	yes	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	RDM knowledge and computational skills 	definition of binary questions, no lists or follow-up questions possible
F-UJI Automated FAIR Data Assessment Tool	FAIRsFAIR	https://www.f-uji.net/	Automatic Tools	2020	complete and will be updated	completely automatic evaluation	1 min	4	16	weighting with indication of weights and explanation for weighting	yes	no	no explanation	short feedback	final result as percentage and evaluation protocol with JSON export function for protocol and metadata	English	no	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	computational skills 	"evaluates only machine-readable data (e.g. no quality of documentation), based on ""FAIRsFAIR Data Object Assessment Metrics"": https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3775793"
FAIR Enough	Institute of Data Science at Maastricht University	https://fair-enough.semanticscience.org/collections/fair-evaluator-maturity-indicators	Automatic Tool, Fully Configurable Tool	2022	complete and will be updated	completely automatic evaluation	1min	4	22	all answers equally without weighting	yes	no	"simple explanation
"	short feedback	final result as percentage and evaluation protocol with JSON export function 	English	no	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	computational skills 	"evaluates only machine-readable data (e.g. no quality of documentation), based on ""FAIRsFAIR Data Object Assessment Metrics"": https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3775793"
SATIFYD: Self-Assessment Tool to Improve the FAIRness of Your Dataset	DANS, FAIRsFAIR	https://satifyd.dans.knaw.nl/	Improved Survey Tool	2019	complete	manual and automatic evaluation	15~20 min	4	12	weighting with indication of weights	yes	no	detailed explanation	detailed feedback	intermediate and final result as percentage with PDF export function	English	no	no 	Use of other criteria	beginners without knowledge	no comment
FAIR self assessment tool	ARDC (Australian Research Data Commons)	https://ardc.edu.au/resources/aboutdata/fair-data/fair-self-assessment-tool/	Improved Survey Tool	2018	complete	manual and automatic evaluation	15 min	4	12	weighting with indication of weights	yes	no	detailed explanation	detailed feedback	intermediate and final result as bar chart	English	no	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	beginners without knowledge	internal explanation links do not work
FairDataBR	FairDataBR	https://wrco.ufpb.br/fair/index-en.html	Improved Survey Tool	2021	complete	manual and automatic evaluation	10~15min	4	20	weighting but without indication of weights and without explanation	yes	no	no explanation	no feedback	intermediate and final result as decimal number with PDF export function	English, Portuguese	no	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	RDM knowledge	partly missing English translation in explanations
CSIRO 5-star Data Rating tool	OzNome (CSIRO-led initiative)	https://csiro-enviro-informatics.github.io/5stardata/	Improved Survey Tool	2017	complete	manual and automatic evaluation	15min	5	17	weighting but without indication of weights and without explanation	yes	no	no explanation	no feedback	intermediate and final result as star chart	English	no	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	RDM knowledge and computational skills	bug in question 15 to 16, share link does not work, 5-star principle difficult to understand
How FAIR are your data?	EUDAT	https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1065990	Regular List Tool	2017	complete	completely manual evaluation	10~20 min	4	16	all answers equally without weighting	yes	no	no explanation	no feedback	no result	English, Spanish	no	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	RDM knowledge	no comment
Data Object Assessment Metrics	FAIRsFAIR	https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3775793	Regular List Tool	2020	complete and will be updated	completely manual evaluation	60~120 min	4	17	weighting with indication of weights and explanation for weighting	yes	no	detailed explanation with examples	detailed feedback with examples	no reuslt	English	no	no 	Aspects comply with FAIR principles	computational skills 	accompanying document for FAIR Evaluation Services, F-UJI and FAIR Enough
Simple Grid FAIR Poster	SHARC	https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1995645	Regular List Tool	2018	complete	completely manual evaluation	20 min	4	18	weighting with indication of weights	yes	no	short explanation	no feedback	no result	English	no	no 	Principles incorrectly assigned F-A-I-R	RDM knowledge	poster description on zenodo available in French only