line.no,author,year.conduct,study,exp.no,substudy,resp.no,time.no,GRIIDC,rep.id,"Oil Exposure trmt (O,D, or Both)",Oil/dispersant  concentration (if applicable),div.cat,#poly.treat,Poly levels,div.design,Broad classification,More specific classification,Species,Target response species,#oil.levels,oil levels,Oil Amount,dispersant,dispersant.trmt,disp.levels,oil.type,disp.type,oil.weathered,oil.meth,other.treatments,#treatment.levels,Other.treatment.levels,exp.type,season,other.treat.level,Response type,response.cat,Response.Level(2020),Response units,Duration,If.oil.pulse.timesince,# times Sampled ,Time.Response,mean.poly,sd.poly,n.poly,mean.mono,sd.mono,n.mono,LRR,Var LRR,mean difference,Hedge's d,Var Hd,Notes
25,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,A,1A,1,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1A_1_End,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,substitutive,Plant,Emergent aquatic vegetation,Spartina & Avicennia,Spartina & Avicennia,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude,NA,Yes,pulse,Genetic Diversity,2,"Mono (1 SA genotype), Poly (3 SA genotypes)",mesocosm,year-long,NA - not fully crossed,Total Belowground Biomass,Biomass,Population,g,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),1.356,1.018,16,1.066,0.783,28,0.240625864,0.054494062,0.29,0.325768625,0.099420254,
26,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,A,1A,1,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1A_1_End,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,substitutive,Plant,Emergent aquatic vegetation,Spartina & Avicennia,Spartina & Avicennia,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude,NA,Yes,pulse,Genetic Diversity,2,"Mono (1 SA genotype), Poly (3 SA genotypes)",mesocosm,year-long,NA - not fully crossed,Total Belowground Biomass,Biomass,Population,g,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),2.984,2.4133,16,2.331,1.041,28,0.246967322,0.04800238,0.653,0.384839245,0.099897254,
29,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,A,1A,2,End,"R4.x262.000:0034 (added own cal to response variables: Hughes 2012, Osland et al. 2017)",1A_2_End,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,substitutive,Plant,Emergent aquatic vegetation,Spartina & Avicennia,Spartina & Avicennia,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude,NA,Yes,pulse,Genetic Diversity,2,"Mono (1 SA genotype), Poly (3 SA genotypes)",mesocosm,year-long,NA - not fully crossed,Total Aboveground Bioamss,Biomass,Population,g,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),38.04,20.52,16,11.28,13.41,28,1.215606992,0.068662273,26.76,1.611328335,0.127718593,
30,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,A,1A,2,End,"R4.x262.000:0034 (added own cal to response variables: Hughes 2012, Osland et al. 2017)",1A_2_End,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,substitutive,Plant,Emergent aquatic vegetation,Spartina & Avicennia,Spartina & Avicennia,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude,NA,Yes,pulse,Genetic Diversity,2,"Mono (1 SA genotype), Poly (3 SA genotypes)",mesocosm,year-long,NA - not fully crossed,Total Aboveground Bioamss,Biomass,Population,g,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),14.84,6.85,16,13.98,16.72,28,0.059698501,0.064402397,0.86,0.060252229,0.098255539,
41,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,B,1B,2,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1B_2_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,SA Belowground Biomass,Biomass,Population,g,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),1.007,0.52,8,1.25125,1.02,12,-0.217167438,0.088708913,-0.24425,-0.271762205,0.210179701,
42,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,B,1B,2,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1B_2_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,SA Belowground Biomass,Biomass,Population,g,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),1.979,0.813,8,2.1945,0.886,12,-0.103362564,0.034679575,-0.2155,-0.240455022,0.209778799,
43,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,C,1C,2,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1C_2_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,SA Belowground Biomass,Biomass,Population,g,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),0.676125,0.573,8,0.69975,0.498,8,-0.034345158,0.153088578,-0.023625,-0.04160933,0.250054104,
44,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,C,1C,2,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1C_2_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,SA Belowground Biomass,Biomass,Population,g,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),1.512375,0.638,8,2.80875,3.04,8,-0.619058282,0.168675318,-1.296375,-0.55802436,0.259730975,
45,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,B,1B,3,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1B_3_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,SA leaf growth,Growth,Population,cm/day,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),1.008,0.608,8,0.971,0.997,12,0.03739698,0.133333285,0.037,0.040885766,0.208375124,
46,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,B,1B,3,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1B_3_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,SA leaf growth,Growth,Population,cm/day,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),1.2743,0.239,8,1.174,0.449,12,0.081980287,0.016586262,0.1003,0.251911439,0.209919818,
47,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,C,1C,3,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1C_3_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,SA leaf growth,Growth,Population,cm/day,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),1.718,1.124,8,1.358,0.954,8,0.235147794,0.115194168,0.36,0.326496951,0.253331258,
48,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,C,1C,3,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1C_3_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,SA leaf growth,Growth,Population,cm/day,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),1.515,0.865,8,1.281,0.806,8,0.167774416,0.090234942,0.234,0.264630267,0.252188412,
53,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,B,1B,5,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1B_5_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,Flower production,Reproduction,Population,# of flowers,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),10,4.84,8,9.917,4.926,12,0.008334637,0.049843128,0.083,0.016247141,0.208339933,
54,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,B,1B,5,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1B_5_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,Flower production,Reproduction,Population,# of flowers,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),14,5.757,8,13.33,6.665,12,0.049040195,0.041970482,0.67,0.101414647,0.208590457,
55,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,C,1C,5,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1C_5_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Flower production,Reproduction,Population,# of flowers,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),8.5,2.928,8,11.25,7.344,8,-0.280301965,0.068100978,-2.75,-0.465074161,0.256759187,
56,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,C,1C,5,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1C_5_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Flower production,Reproduction,Population,# of flowers,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),12.125,3.98,8,15.25,4.773,8,-0.229310066,0.025713139,-3.125,-0.672339603,0.264126267,
57,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,B,1B,6,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1B_6_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,Seed production,Reproduction,Population,total # of seeds,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),737.5,402.317,8,627.584,350.292,12,0.161388562,0.063160109,109.916,0.283452425,0.210341965,
58,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,B,1B,6,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1B_6_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,Seed production,Reproduction,Population,total # of seeds,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),652.875,302.398,8,636.75,425.49,12,0.025008573,0.064026841,16.125,0.040390478,0.208374118,
59,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,C,1C,6,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1C_6_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Seed production,Reproduction,Population,total # of seeds,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),679.25,440.41,8,715.875,311.44,8,-0.052516322,0.076207421,-36.625,-0.09078618,0.250257567,
60,Hughes et al. 2018,2015-2016,1,C,1C,6,End,R4.x262.000:0034,1C_6_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Spartina alterniflora,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Seed production,Reproduction,Population,total # of seeds,year,11 months,5,Final (Sept 2016),577.375,235.48,8,913.25,420.06,8,-0.458517697,0.047237873,-335.875,-0.932570776,0.277177758,
82,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,A,1A,4,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1A_4_End,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,"Spartina alterniflora, Avicennia",Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Genetic Diversity,2,"SA mono, SA poly",mesocosm,year-long,NA- not fully crossed within taxa,Denitrification Potential Rate,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),61.588125,87.70621766,16,22.70714286,29.32222212,28,0.997789538,0.186303637,38.88098214,0.664672113,0.103234615,
83,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,A,1A,4,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1A_4_End,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,"Spartina alterniflora, Avicennia",Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Genetic Diversity,2,"SA mono, SA poly",mesocosm,year-long,NA- not fully crossed within taxa,Denitrification Potential Rate,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),65.695,49.34689021,16,57.04464286,45.96751812,28,0.14118865,0.058455001,8.65035714,0.179969538,0.098582343,
84,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,A,1A,13,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1A_13_End,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,"Spartina alterniflora, Avicennia",Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Genetic Diversity,2,"SA mono, SA poly",mesocosm,year-long,NA- not fully crossed within taxa,N2 fixation potential,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),9.77875,12.56958014,16,9.963571429,14.00353903,28,-0.018723921,0.173813864,-0.184821429,-0.013435686,0.098216337,
85,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,A,1A,13,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1A_13_End,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,"Spartina alterniflora, Avicennia",Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Genetic Diversity,2,"SA mono, SA poly",mesocosm,year-long,NA- not fully crossed within taxa,N2 fixation potential,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),11.290625,13.24657866,16,7.6275,11.01667276,28,0.392212598,0.160534113,3.663125,0.303282378,0.099259515,
89,Sobecky et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,16,End,R4.x262.000:0051.,1C_2_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Nitrite reductase (denitrifer) microbial Abundance,Denitrifer Abundance,Community,qPCR copies of nirS,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),119170.8333,136796.4239,6,204637.5,232514.8338,6,-0.540682084,0.43478209,-85466.6667,-0.413575063,0.340460181,
90,Sobecky et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,16,End,R4.x262.000:0051.,1C_2_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Nitrite reductase (denitrifer) microbial Abundance,Denitrifer Abundance,Community,qPCR copies of nirS,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),108562.5,193464.1664,6,41902.08333,15074.68577,6,0.951990497,0.550856876,66660.41667,0.448441666,0.341712497,
91,Sobecky et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,15,End,R4.x262.000:0051.,1C_3_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Nitrous oxide reductase (denitrifer) microbial Abundance,Denitrifer Abundance,Community,qPCR copies of nosZ,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),117404.1667,76266.55462,6,165070.8333,175029.0615,6,-0.340752276,0.257713741,-47666.6666,-0.325918058,0.337759274,
92,Sobecky et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,15,End,R4.x262.000:0051.,1C_3_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Nitrous oxide reductase (denitrifer) microbial Abundance,Denitrifer Abundance,Community,qPCR copies of nosZ,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),230187.5,439093.8897,6,92104.16667,58717.77503,6,0.915974011,0.674194605,138083.3333,0.406900263,0.340231993,
101,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,4,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1C_4_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Denitrification Potential Rate,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),44.64125,75.46954777,8,78.535,100.6557043,8,-0.564886066,0.562590788,-33.89375,-0.360224218,0.254055046,
102,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,4,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1C_4_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Denitrification Potential Rate,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),71.79125,55.89805298,8,59.59875,44.81702337,8,0.186128002,0.146465101,12.1925,0.227539136,0.251617939,
103,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,B,1B,4,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1B_4_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,Denitrification Potential Rate,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),16.355,17.94156069,8,20.42666667,25.98156246,12,-0.222307576,0.285248219,-4.07166667,-0.168170298,0.209040365,
104,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,B,1B,4,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1B_4_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,Denitrification Potential Rate,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),54.71875,55.80442057,8,56.71333333,45.03726302,12,-0.035802909,0.182561818,-1.99458333,-0.03858925,0.208370562,
105,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,13,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1C_13_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,N2 fixation potential,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),12.19,17.48622233,8,7.3675,4.416096369,8,0.503537508,0.302124382,4.8225,0.357524629,0.253994496,
106,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,13,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1C_13_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,N2 fixation potential,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),9.63875,8.657339475,8,12.9425,17.17045615,8,-0.294725038,0.320848499,-3.30375,-0.229717769,0.25164907,
107,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,B,1B,13,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1B_13_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,N2 fixation potential,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),7.7125,5.569913439,8,10.08333333,16.38676092,12,-0.268041506,0.28528353,-2.37083333,-0.171077522,0.209065021,
108,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,B,1B,13,End,R4.x262.000:0026,1B_13_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Mono,N2 fixation potential,Ecosystem Process,Ecosystem,umol N m-2hr-1,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),13.24125,13.15911356,8,8.460833333,11.38135993,12,0.447889285,0.274246905,4.780416667,0.378264394,0.211910432,
110,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,14,Intermediate,R4.x262.000:0026,1C_6_Intermediate,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Sediment oxygen demand,Benthic fluxes,Ecosystem,umol O2 m-2hr-1,year,6 months,2,Intermediate (April 2016),724.8166667,263.2703357,6,796.9333333,310.6910727,6,-0.094852279,0.047320115,-72.1166666,-0.231176462,0.335560107,
111,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,14,Intermediate,R4.x262.000:0026,1C_6_Intermediate,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Sediment oxygen demand,Benthic fluxes,Ecosystem,umol O2 m-2hr-1,year,6 months,2,Intermediate (April 2016),536.1333333,220.2329555,6,615.1,139.6256853,6,-0.13740197,0.036711314,-78.9666667,-0.395320185,0.339844919,
118,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,11,Intermediate,R4.x262.000:0026,1C_11_Intermediate,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Chlorophyll a concentration,Benthic Alagae Abundance,Community,mg m-2,year,6 months,2,Intermediate (April 2016),284.6333333,254.3729991,6,191.9333333,136.6070228,6,0.394053713,0.217542083,92.7,0.419116998,0.340652461,
119,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,11,Intermediate,R4.x262.000:0026,1C_11_Intermediate,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Chlorophyll a concentration,Benthic Alagae Abundance,Community,mg m-2,year,6 months,2,Intermediate (April 2016),180.35,104.3830781,6,215.8,123.2972019,6,-0.179452645,0.110237851,-35.45,-0.286460861,0.336752493,
132,Sobecky et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,12,End,R4.x262.000:0025,1C_12_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Bacterial Shannon Diversity,Secondary Production,Community,,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),6.28016,0.36657,6,6.56166,0.39956,6,-0.043848162,0.001185829,-0.2815,-0.677706351,0.352470246,
133,Sobecky et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,12,End,R4.x262.000:0025,1C_12_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Bacterial Shannon Diversity,Secondary Production,Community,,year,11 months,2,Final (Sept 2016),6.73381,0.22932,6,6.82589,0.17913,6,-0.01358163,0.000308071,-0.09208,-0.413085582,0.340443321,
134,Valentine et al. ,2017,3,A,3A,1,End,  R4.x262.000:0047 ,3A_1_End,Oil,NA,Taxon,2,"2 predator species, 4 predator species",substitutive,Animal,Vert & Invert predators,"Ariopsis felis, Fundulus grandis, Opsanus beta, Callinectes sapidus",Prey species: C.sapidus (blue crab,2,"None, Oiled",1 mL oil/L (127mL),None,None,None,TBD,NA,No,press (2 inoculations per 48 hours to simulate press conditions),NA,NA,NA,mescosm,Fall,NA,Blue crab (prey) consumption,Consumption,Community,% consumed,48 hours,24 hours,1,End,0.29,0.18,8,0.25,0.35,24,0.148420005,0.129823623,0.04,0.122401833,0.166900764,
136,Valentine et al. ,2017,3,A,3A,1,End,  R4.x262.000:0047 ,3A_1_End,No Oil,NA,Taxon,2,"2 predator species, 4 predator species",substitutive,Animal,Vert & Invert predators,"Ariopsis felis, Fundulus grandis, Opsanus beta, Callinectes sapidus",Prey species: C.sapidus (blue crab,2,"None, Oiled",1 mL oil/L (127mL),None,None,None,TBD,NA,No,press (2 inoculations per 48 hours to simulate press conditions),NA,NA,NA,mescosm,Fall,NA,Blue crab (prey) consumption,Consumption,Community,% consumed,48 hours,24 hours,1,End,0.45,0.29,8,0.24,0.27,24,0.628608659,0.104647955,0.21,0.74493521,0.175337424,
137,Valentine et al. ,2017,3,A,3A,2,End,  R4.x262.000:0047 ,3A_2_End,Oil,NA,Taxon,2,"2 predator species, 4 predator species",substitutive,Animal,Vert & Invert predators,"Ariopsis felis, Fundulus grandis, Opsanus beta, Callinectes sapidus",Prey species: C.sapidus (blue crab,2,"None, Oiled",1 mL oil/L (127mL),None,None,None,TBD,NA,No,press (2 inoculations per 48 hours to simulate press conditions),NA,NA,NA,mescosm,Fall,NA,"Shrimp (Palaemonetes, prey) consumed",Consumption,Community,% consumed,48 hours,24 hours,1,End,0.81,0.34,8,0.61,0.38,24,0.28357529,0.03819357,0.2,0.525418784,0.170980181,
139,Valentine et al. ,2017,3,A,3A,2,End,  R4.x262.000:0047 ,3A_2_End,No Oil,NA,Taxon,2,"2 predator species, 4 predator species",substitutive,Animal,Vert & Invert predators,"Ariopsis felis, Fundulus grandis, Opsanus beta, Callinectes sapidus",Prey species: C.sapidus (blue crab,2,"None, Oiled",1 mL oil/L (127mL),None,None,None,TBD,NA,No,press (2 inoculations per 48 hours to simulate press conditions),NA,NA,NA,mescosm,Fall,NA,"Shrimp (Palaemonetes, prey) consumed",Consumption,Community,% consumed,48 hours,24 hours,1,End,0.9,0.13,8,0.36,0.4,24,0.916290732,0.054048354,0.54,1.47934948,0.200861587,
140,Valentine et al. ,2017,3,A,3A,3,End,  R4.x262.000:0047 ,3A_3_End,Oil,NA,Taxon,2,"2 predator species, 4 predator species",substitutive,Animal,Vert & Invert predators,"Ariopsis felis, Fundulus grandis, Opsanus beta, Callinectes sapidus",Prey species: C.sapidus (blue crab,2,"None, Oiled",1 mL oil/L (127mL),None,None,None,TBD,NA,No,press (2 inoculations per 48 hours to simulate press conditions),NA,NA,NA,mescosm,Fall,NA,"Fish (Fundulus xenicus, prey) consumed",Consumption,Community,% consumed,48 hours,24 hours,1,End,0.31,0.27,8,0.25,0.26,24,0.21511138,0.139889768,0.06,0.222921708,0.167443137,
142,Valentine et al. ,2017,3,A,3A,3,End,  R4.x262.000:0047 ,3A_3_End,No Oil,NA,Taxon,2,"2 predator species, 4 predator species",substitutive,Animal,Vert & Invert predators,"Ariopsis felis, Fundulus grandis, Opsanus beta, Callinectes sapidus",Prey species: C.sapidus (blue crab,2,"None, Oiled",1 mL oil/L (127mL),None,None,None,TBD,NA,No,press (2 inoculations per 48 hours to simulate press conditions),NA,NA,NA,mescosm,Fall,NA,"Fish (Fundulus xenicus, prey) consumed",Consumption,Community,% consumed,48 hours,24 hours,1,End,0.42,0.25,8,0.21,0.28,24,0.693147181,0.118362623,0.21,0.749029794,0.175433005,
146,Krause,2017,4,A,4A,1,Dur,R4.x262.000:0048,4A_1_Dur,Oil,1 ppm,Taxon,1,3 species,additive,Plants,Phytoplankton,"diatom (Skeletonema sp.), dinoflagellat (Prorocentrum sp.) and chlorophyte (Tetraselmis sp.)",Plantkon,9,"None, WAF, WAF + dispersant, dispersant only crossed with 1,10, 40 ppm of petrochemicals",Variable,Yes,"Dispersant only, Dispersant + Oil","presence at 1,10, 40 ppm",?,SlickGone,YES,pulse,Initial density,3,"High, med, low",microscoms (beakers),winter-summer (multiple trials) ,1 ppm, Max Growth Rate,Production,Population,cells/day,6-21 days,6-21 days,daily,Integrated across experimental time,0.497576689,0.103804173,3,0.834320943,0.693795113,22,-0.516868459,0.045939465,-0.336744254,-0.490684176,0.383603298,
147,Krause,2017,4,A,4A,1,Dur,R4.x262.000:0048,4A_1_Dur,No Oil,1 ppm,Taxon,1,3 species,additive,Plants,Phytoplankton,"diatom (Skeletonema sp.), dinoflagellat (Prorocentrum sp.) and chlorophyte (Tetraselmis sp.)",Plantkon,9,"None, WAF, WAF + dispersant, dispersant only crossed with 1,10, 40 ppm of petrochemicals",Variable,Yes,"Dispersant only, Dispersant + Oil","presence at 1,10, 40 ppm",?,SlickGone,YES,pulse,Initial density,3,"High, med, low",microscoms (beakers),winter-summer (multiple trials) ,1 ppm, Max Growth Rate,Production,Population,cells/day,6-21 days,6-21 days,daily,Integrated across experimental time,0.472197306,0.073824056,3,0.982460624,0.895084887,27,-0.732663346,0.038889719,-0.510263318,-0.575452719,0.375889468,
149,Krause,2017,4,B,4B,1,Dur,R4.x262.000:0048,4B_1_Dur,Oil,10 ppm,Taxon,1,3 species,additive,Plants,Phytoplankton,"diatom (Skeletonema sp.), dinoflagellat (Prorocentrum sp.) and chlorophyte (Tetraselmis sp.)",Plantkon,9,"None, WAF, WAF + dispersant, dispersant only crossed with 1,10, 40 ppm of petrochemicals",Variable,Yes,"Dispersant only, Dispersant + Oil","presence at 1,10, 40 ppm",?,SlickGone,YES,pulse,Initial density,3,"High, med, low",microscoms (beakers),winter-summer (multiple trials) ,10 ppm, Max Growth Rate,Production,Population,cells/day,6-21 days,6-21 days,daily,Integrated across experimental time,0.643193261,0.241413481,3,0.877016548,0.947711502,16,-0.310080621,0.119941162,-0.233823287,-0.249818712,0.397475686,
151,Krause,2017,4,C,4C,1,Dur,R4.x262.000:0048,4C_1_Dur,Oil,40 ppm,Taxon,1,3 species,additive,Plants,Phytoplankton,"diatom (Skeletonema sp.), dinoflagellat (Prorocentrum sp.) and chlorophyte (Tetraselmis sp.)",Plantkon,9,"None, WAF, WAF + dispersant, dispersant only crossed with 1,10, 40 ppm of petrochemicals",Variable,Yes,"Dispersant only, Dispersant + Oil","presence at 1,10, 40 ppm",?,SlickGone,YES,pulse,Initial density,3,"High, med, low",microscoms (beakers),winter-summer (multiple trials) ,40 ppm, Max Growth Rate,Production,Population,cells/day,6-21 days,6-21 days,daily,Integrated across experimental time,0.647275521,0.047165534,3,1.266890032,2.415579461,16,-0.671548335,0.228989005,-0.619614511,-0.260839414,0.397623786,
159,Krause,2017,4,D,4D,1,Dur,R4.x262.000:0048,4D_1_Dur,Oil + Dispersant,1 ppm,Taxon,1,3 species,additive,Plants,Phytoplankton,"diatom (Skeletonema sp.), dinoflagellat (Prorocentrum sp.) and chlorophyte (Tetraselmis sp.)",Plantkon,9,"None, WAF, WAF + dispersant, dispersant only crossed with 1,10, 40 ppm of petrochemicals",Variable,Yes,"Dispersant only, Dispersant + Oil","presence at 1,10, 40 ppm",?,SlickGone,YES,pulse,Initial density,3,"High, med, low",microscoms (beakers),winter-summer (multiple trials) ,1 ppm, Max Growth Rate,Production,Population,cells/day,6-21 days,6-21 days,daily,Integrated across experimental time,0.505492074,0.042985672,3,0.566341689,0.307490773,12,-0.113665228,0.026975961,-0.060849615,-0.202116579,0.41802837,
161,Krause,2017,4,E,4E,1,Dur,R4.x262.000:0048,4E_1_Dur,Oil + Dispersant,10 ppm,Taxon,1,3 species,additive,Plants,Phytoplankton,"diatom (Skeletonema sp.), dinoflagellat (Prorocentrum sp.) and chlorophyte (Tetraselmis sp.)",Plantkon,9,"None, WAF, WAF + dispersant, dispersant only crossed with 1,10, 40 ppm of petrochemicals",Variable,Yes,"Dispersant only, Dispersant + Oil","presence at 1,10, 40 ppm",?,SlickGone,YES,pulse,Initial density,3,"High, med, low",microscoms (beakers),winter-summer (multiple trials) ,10 ppm, Max Growth Rate,Production,Population,cells/day,6-21 days,6-21 days,daily,Integrated across experimental time,0.327647141,0.096532423,3,0.078184832,0.287380454,12,1.432861575,1.154804119,0.249462309,0.879193427,0.442432703,
163,Krause,2017,4,F,4F,1,Dur,R4.x262.000:0048,4F_1_Dur,Oil + Dispersant,40 ppm,Taxon,1,3 species,additive,Plants,Phytoplankton,"diatom (Skeletonema sp.), dinoflagellat (Prorocentrum sp.) and chlorophyte (Tetraselmis sp.)",Plantkon,9,"None, WAF, WAF + dispersant, dispersant only crossed with 1,10, 40 ppm of petrochemicals",Variable,Yes,"Dispersant only, Dispersant + Oil","presence at 1,10, 40 ppm",?,SlickGone,YES,pulse,Initial density,3,"High, med, low",microscoms (beakers),winter-summer (multiple trials) ,40 ppm, Max Growth Rate,Production,Population,cells/day,6-21 days,6-21 days,daily,Integrated across experimental time,0.277782294,0.07420609,3,-0.737322705,0.945309906,12,,0.160765854,1.015104999,1.098095217,0.456860437,
182,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,1,END,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_1_END,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,NA,survival,Survival,Population,proportion of individuals that survived,25 days,25 days,1,End,0.833333333,0.204124145,5,0.967,0.104355163,10,-0.148764774,0.013164595,-0.133666667,-0.881673988,0.325911634,
184,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,1,END,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_1_END,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,Substitutive - High density Mono,survival,Survival,Population,proportion of individuals that survived,25 days,25 days,1,End,0.8,0.139443338,5,0.933,0.141268067,10,-0.153793473,0.00836897,-0.133,-0.889611559,0.326380291,
185,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,2,END,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_2_END,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,NA,Max. luminophore depth,Bioturbation ,Ecosystem,cm,25 days,25 days,1,End,7.4,0.894427191,5,6.2,2.859681412,10,0.176930708,0.024195976,1.2,0.464668651,0.307197232,
187,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,2,END,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_2_END,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,Substitutive - High density Mono,Max. luminophore depth,Bioturbation ,Ecosystem,cm,25 days,25 days,1,End,8,0.707106781,5,6.8,3.552776692,10,0.162518929,0.028859693,1.2,0.378743394,0.304781552,
188,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,3,Dur,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_3_Dur,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,NA,Sediment Oxygen Deman,Benthic Fluxes,Ecosystem,mmol O2 m-2 d-1,25 days,25 days,1,"Averaged across time (early, mid and later time periods)",-40.71941445,2.722226567,3,-36.25545232,5.302147887,10,0.116115213,0.003628522,-4.46396213,-0.841538359,0.460571288,
190,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,3,Dur,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_3_Dur,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,Substitutive - High density Mono,Sediment Oxygen Deman,Benthic Fluxes,Ecosystem,mmol O2 m-2 d-1,25 days,25 days,1,"Averaged across time (early, mid and later time periods)",-28.63291704,1.500323653,4,-29.35711068,5.542772053,10,-0.024977787,0.004251139,0.72419364,0.139544353,0.350695451,
233,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,4,END,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_4_END,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,NA,Horizontal luminphore dispersion,Bioturbation ,Ecosystem,Ripley's K,25 days,25 days,1,End,50.156,19.553,5,38.811,13.614,10,0.256434437,0.042700059,-11.345,-0.680851299,0.31545195,Horizonatl dispersion evaluated at 2cm depth with 1cm radius - this was response highlighted in MEPs paper
234,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,4,END,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_4_END,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,Substitutive - High density Mono,Horizontal luminphore dispersion,Bioturbation ,Ecosystem,Ripley's K,25 days,25 days,1,End,58.26,23.564,5,60.909,48.674,5,-0.044465196,0.160438677,2.649,0.062571043,0.400195757,lower K values indicate higher dispersion 
236,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,5,END,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_5_END,Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,NA,Luminophore subduction,Bioturbation ,Ecosystem,Depth integrated (4-10cm) Luminophore pixel abundance,25 days,25 days,1,End,9469.3,3221.8,4,19379.3,23027.7,10,-0.716150499,0.170137025,-9910,-0.463697777,0.35767913,
237,Dorgan et al. ,20176,5,A,5A,5,END,R4.x262.000:0050,5A_5_END,No Oil,NA,Taxon,1,2 Species,Substitue,Invertebrates,Benthic Infauna,Owenia fusiforms & Hemipholia elognatat,,2,"None, Oiled",0.1mL per 1mL of water (1:10 ratio),No,No,0,MC252 Reference Material, WAF,Yes,Pulse?,Polyculture Density ,2,(Additive vs Substitutive Design),outdoor mescosom,Spring,Substitutive - High density Mono,Luminophore subduction,Bioturbation ,Ecosystem,Depth integrated (4-10cm) Luminophore pixel abundance,25 days,25 days,1,End,21380.6,26898.8,5,22221.9,28505,10,-0.03859432,0.481103109,-841.3,-0.028258209,0.300026618,
13,Schrandt et al. 2018,2016,2,A,2A,2,End,R4.x262.213:0004,2A_2_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,2,"2 parental pairs, 3 parental pairs",substitutive,Animal,Bivalve,eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),3,"none, oil, oil + dispersant",1 ppt (1mL oil to 1L water),Yes,Yes,"mixed with oil, ratio 1:20 (dispersant to oil)",surrogate MC252 requested from BP,SlickGone (substitute for Corexit),No?,pulse,Salinity,2,mesohaline (15-20 ppt), low salinity (5-10 ppt),DISL,Fall,mesohaline (15-20 ppt),Shell height (difference in height of surviving oysters),Population,change in mm,21 days,21 days,1,Final,-0.2,2.485618635,9,-0.88,1.618181813,15,-1.481604541,17.38736734,0.68,0.331905996,0.180072811,
15,Schrandt et al. 2018,2016,2,A,2A,2,End,R4.x262.213:0004,2A_2_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,2,"2 parental pairs, 3 parental pairs",substitutive,Animal,Bivalve,eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),3,"none, oil, oil + dispersant",1 ppt (1mL oil to 1L water),Yes,Yes,"mixed with oil, ratio 1:20 (dispersant to oil)",surrogate MC252 requested from BP,SlickGone (substitute for Corexit),No?,pulse,Salinity,2,mesohaline (15-20 ppt), low salinity (5-10 ppt),DISL,Fall,mesohaline (15-20 ppt),Shell height (difference in height of surviving oysters),Population,change in mm,21 days,21 days,1,Final,-0.91,1.641305942,9,-0.25,1.908299048,15,1.291983682,4.245833569,-0.66,-0.350950469,0.180343741,
18,Schrandt et al. 2018,2016,2,B,2B,2,End,R4.x262.213:0004,2B_2_End,Oil + Dispersant,NA,Genetic,2,"2 parental pairs, 3 parental pairs",substitutive,Animal,Bivalve,eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),3,"none, oil, oil + dispersant",1 ppt (1mL oil to 1L water),Yes,Yes,"mixed with oil, ratio 1:20 (dispersant to oil)",surrogate MC252 requested from BP,SlickGone (substitute for Corexit),No?,pulse,Salinity,2,mesohaline (15-20 ppt), low salinity (5-10 ppt),DISL,Fall,mesohaline (15-20 ppt),Shell height (difference in height of surviving oysters),Population,change in mm,21 days,21 days,1,Final,-0.78,1.623159462,9,-0.5,2.153343865,15,0.444685821,1.717665215,-0.28,-0.136740217,0.178167317,
19,Schrandt et al. 2018,2016,2,C,2C,2,End,R4.x262.213:0004,2C_2_End,Oil,NA,Genetic,2,"2 parental pairs, 3 parental pairs",substitutive,Animal,Bivalve,eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),3,"none, oil, oil + dispersant",1 ppt (1mL oil to 1L water),Yes,Yes,"mixed with oil, ratio 1:20 (dispersant to oil)",surrogate MC252 requested from BP,SlickGone (substitute for Corexit),No?,pulse,Salinity,2,mesohaline (15-20 ppt), low salinity (5-10 ppt),DISL,Fall,low salinity (5-10 ppt),Shell height (difference in height of surviving oysters),Population,change in mm,21 days,21 days,1,Final,-1.12,2.550884378,9,-0.57,1.611303229,15,0.675447603,1.109110045,-0.55,-0.264909456,0.179239799,
21,Schrandt et al. 2018,2016,2,C,2C,2,End,R4.x262.213:0004,2C_2_End,No Oil,NA,Genetic,2,"2 parental pairs, 3 parental pairs",substitutive,Animal,Bivalve,eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),3,"none, oil, oil + dispersant",1 ppt (1mL oil to 1L water),Yes,Yes,"mixed with oil, ratio 1:20 (dispersant to oil)",surrogate MC252 requested from BP,SlickGone (substitute for Corexit),No?,pulse,Salinity,2,mesohaline (15-20 ppt), low salinity (5-10 ppt),DISL,Fall,low salinity (5-10 ppt),Shell height (difference in height of surviving oysters),Population,change in mm,21 days,21 days,1,Final,-0.7875,1.905531422,8,0.83,2.040245083,15,,1.134707847,-1.6175,-0.780942966,0.204924752,
22,Schrandt et al. 2018,2016,2,D,2D,2,End,R4.x262.213:0004,2D_2_End,Oil + Dispersant,NA,Genetic,2,"2 parental pairs, 3 parental pairs",substitutive,Animal,Bivalve,eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),eastern oyster (Crassostrea viriginica),3,"none, oil, oil + dispersant",1 ppt (1mL oil to 1L water),Yes,Yes,"mixed with oil, ratio 1:20 (dispersant to oil)",surrogate MC252 requested from BP,SlickGone (substitute for Corexit),No?,pulse,Salinity,2,mesohaline (15-20 ppt), low salinity (5-10 ppt),DISL,Fall,low salinity (5-10 ppt),Shell height (difference in height of surviving oysters),Population,change in mm,21 days,21 days,1,Final,-1.61,1.518359588,8,-1.17,1.565280659,15,0.31923043,0.230497357,-0.44,-0.273646207,0.193294542,
243,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,10,Intermediate,R4.x262.000:0026,,Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Phosphate flux,Benthic fluxes,Ecosystem,umol P m-2hr-1,year,6 months,2,Intermediate (April 2016),-0.3,0.836660027,6,-0.3,0.83666003,6,0,2.592592605,0,0,0.333333333,More negative is better EF
244,Behzad et al.,2015-2016,1,C,1C,10,Intermediate,R4.x262.000:0026,,No Oil,NA,Genetic,1,3 Genotypes = Max,substitutive,Plant,Emergent Aquatic Vegetation,Spartina alterniflora,Microbes,2,"None, oiled",8L/m2,No,No,0,surrogate Louisiana sweet crude oil,NA,Yes,pulse,Taxon Diversity,2,"Mono (SA only), Poly (SA + AG)",mesocosm,year-long,Taxon - Poly,Phosphate flux,Benthic fluxes,Ecosystem,umol P m-2hr-1,year,6 months,2,Intermediate (April 2016),-0.366666667,0.557374799,6,-0.133333333,0.27325202,6,1.011600915,1.085123967,0.233333334,0.490694724,0.343365888,More negative is better EF