[{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa4f" }, "href": "/comments/1000253", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "The object isn't a supernova. In the Transient Name Server no results are found.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-12T22:03:16.916Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000253", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-12T22:03:16.916Z", "upvotes": { "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1523614677" }, "user_id": "1251879", "user_login": "m3cok", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "m3cok" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caf6c0ef4255c3eb3094" }, "href": "/comments/1000711", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "This comment has been deleted", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T06:22:38.008Z", "discussion_id": "566962", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000711", "is_deleted": true, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-30T08:33:03.447Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1498433", "user_login": "t5b9w", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 64, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Gravity Spy Glitch Library", "discussion_updated_at": "2019-03-16T17:59:00.988Z", "discussion_users_count": 9, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "t5b9w", "userRoles": [ "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa50" }, "href": "/comments/1000773", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "I would say blue thing is a cosmic ray hit on the ccd \"film\"", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T08:04:59.779Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000773", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T08:04:59.779Z", "upvotes": { "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1523614675" }, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c749c0ef4255c3ea8248" }, "href": "/comments/1000820", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "@rl6lg Good morning, a nice surprise for you😀 clock s", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T08:57:34.141Z", "discussion_id": "107267", "focus_id": "3832472", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000820", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@BLGoodwin": { "id": 1430195, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T08:57:34.141Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1536599", "user_login": "h2zto", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3832472", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-11-14T04:48:22.765Z", "discussion_users_count": 10, "discussion_focus_id": "3832472", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "h2zto" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c749c0ef4255c3ea8249" }, "href": "/comments/1000822", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "and extremely loud😀", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T08:59:13.438Z", "discussion_id": "107267", "focus_id": "3832472", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000822", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T08:59:13.438Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1536599", "user_login": "h2zto", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3832472", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-11-14T04:48:22.765Z", "discussion_users_count": 10, "discussion_focus_id": "3832472", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "h2zto" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa51" }, "href": "/comments/1000855", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Thanks. These cosmic ray hits seem to pop up everywhere!", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T09:42:14.499Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000855", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T09:42:14.499Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1251879", "user_login": "m3cok", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "m3cok" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c749c0ef4255c3ea824a" }, "href": "/comments/1000865", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "The 1 sec delay seems to be ubiquitous with Wall extremely loud, with or without blip and ram", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T09:53:50.193Z", "discussion_id": "107267", "focus_id": "3832472", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000865", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T09:53:50.193Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1430195", "user_login": "rl6lg", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3832472", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-11-14T04:48:22.765Z", "discussion_users_count": 10, "discussion_focus_id": "3832472", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "rl6lg" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa52" }, "href": "/comments/1000869", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "or rain down :umbrella:\n:)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T10:04:54.392Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000869", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T10:04:54.392Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa53" }, "href": "/comments/1000874", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Nice work checking JPL and TNS, eliminating possibilities :D\n\nIf you click on the object in DECalS and choose ‘single image cutouts’ it can be seen as an odd-shaped sharp thing in only 1 image. Pretty much every checkbox for artifact checked here.\n\nhttp://www.legacysurvey.org/viewer/cutouts/?ra=191.2394&dec=0.9339&layer=decals-dr5\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T10:21:57.955Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000874", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1000253", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T10:21:57.955Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1251879, "reply_user_login": "m3cok", "reply_user_display_name": "m3cok", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c749c0ef4255c3ea824b" }, "href": "/comments/1000922", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "#clock Hi Ecce, @zchzf please can you contact @zchzf to discuss clocks\nthanks 😀", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T11:28:54.891Z", "discussion_id": "107267", "focus_id": "3832472", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000922", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@EcceruElme": { "id": 322252, "type": "User" }, "@BLGoodwin": { "id": 1430195, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": { "#clock": "clock" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T11:28:54.891Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1536599", "user_login": "h2zto", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3832472", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-11-14T04:48:22.765Z", "discussion_users_count": 10, "discussion_focus_id": "3832472", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "h2zto" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d4c0ef4255c3ea3312" }, "href": "/comments/1000929", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Out of the 2000 new subjects, 790 have already been completed. I hope you guys have more new subjects, as they may be needed soon!", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T11:35:11.499Z", "discussion_id": "597443", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000929", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T11:35:11.499Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "172", "user_login": "06390", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Out of data? Nope!", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T07:44:06.278Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "06390" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c749c0ef4255c3ea824c" }, "href": "/comments/1000978", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "I agree, that the 1 sec period problem is usually present on both type of extremely loud, from both observing run in Livingston. And 1 sec period problem is present in many other type of glitches in both detector, from both observing run but in O2 more often. Maybe the 60Hz mains power frequency should be considered too if it can be related to this seemingly very general problem.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T12:20:55.600Z", "discussion_id": "107267", "focus_id": "3832472", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000978", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T12:20:55.600Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "322252", "user_login": "zchzf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3832472", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-11-14T04:48:22.765Z", "discussion_users_count": 10, "discussion_focus_id": "3832472", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "zchzf", "userRoles": [ "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c749c0ef4255c3ea824d" }, "href": "/comments/1000998", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "In any project like this timers are ubiquitous pieces of equipment. If only the significant ones could be traced...........", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T12:44:15.178Z", "discussion_id": "107267", "focus_id": "3832472", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1000998", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T12:44:15.178Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1430195", "user_login": "rl6lg", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3832472", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-11-14T04:48:22.765Z", "discussion_users_count": 10, "discussion_focus_id": "3832472", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "rl6lg" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa54" }, "href": "/comments/1001162", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Thanks. :) You're right, one must look at the shape of the object seen in the CCD image as well. Cosmic ray hits often have sharp edges.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T14:58:27.712Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1001162", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T15:32:11.726Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1251879", "user_login": "m3cok", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "m3cok" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca3ac0ef4255c3eb0035" }, "href": "/comments/1001285", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Spiral. #phys560", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T16:14:56.145Z", "discussion_id": "576784", "focus_id": "20283878", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1001285", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#phys560": "phys560" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T16:14:56.145Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1761326", "user_login": "txz7s", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 35, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20283878", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-16T02:24:27.796Z", "discussion_users_count": 20, "discussion_focus_id": "20283878", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "txz7s" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca3ac0ef4255c3eb0036" }, "href": "/comments/1001313", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Possibly spiral #phys560 ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T16:24:26.614Z", "discussion_id": "576784", "focus_id": "20283878", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1001313", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#phys560": "phys560" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T16:24:26.614Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1761326", "user_login": "txz7s", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 35, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20283878", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-16T02:24:27.796Z", "discussion_users_count": 20, "discussion_focus_id": "20283878", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "txz7s" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca3ac0ef4255c3eb0037" }, "href": "/comments/1001325", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Disturbed spiral for me as well ! :D", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T16:34:28.155Z", "discussion_id": "576784", "focus_id": "20283878", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1001325", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1001313", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T16:34:28.155Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "123", "user_login": "eax9k", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1761326, "reply_user_login": "txz7s", "reply_user_display_name": "txz7s", "discussion_comments_count": 35, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20283878", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-16T02:24:27.796Z", "discussion_users_count": 20, "discussion_focus_id": "20283878", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "eax9k", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa55" }, "href": "/comments/1001482", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "#12 hrs object-merger?? #6hrs blue clump of stars", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T18:25:24.470Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1001482", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#6hrs": "6hrs" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T18:25:24.470Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "231323", "user_login": "whb7j", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "whb7j" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa56" }, "href": "/comments/1001527", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "................", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-13T18:56:51.089Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1001527", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-13T18:56:51.089Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa57" }, "href": "/comments/1002183", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Hi @whb7j, please read the comments already posted, because the blue thing was already discussed.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.443Z", "discussion_id": "600017", "focus_id": "20685260", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002183", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@angelikabellinghausen": { "id": 231323, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.443Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685260", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T04:46:54.510Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "20685260", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d4c0ef4255c3ea3313" }, "href": "/comments/1002290", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "I think the retired subjects counter is a bit broken. The previous (unusual) set had exactly 790 subjects - somehow it's still counting those towards retirement in the new set of 2000. I generally trust the 'classifications required' more - 60k new classifications should take about 6 days. I'll make a note to add some more batches Monday morning.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T07:44:06.241Z", "discussion_id": "597443", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002290", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T07:44:06.241Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "290475", "user_login": "y15xu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Out of data? Nope!", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T07:44:06.278Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "y15xu", "userRoles": [ "admin" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c63bc0ef4255c3ea5ec3" }, "href": "/comments/1002324", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "@rl6lg 😀 good morning, this subject is BR before #ram😀", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T08:31:12.564Z", "discussion_id": "95911", "focus_id": "3536761", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002324", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@BLGoodwin": { "id": 1430195, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "177059", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": { "#ram": "ram" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T08:31:12.564Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1536599", "user_login": "h2zto", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1430195, "reply_user_login": "rl6lg", "reply_user_display_name": "rl6lg", "discussion_comments_count": 16, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3536761", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-14T08:31:12.779Z", "discussion_users_count": 7, "discussion_focus_id": "3536761", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "h2zto" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caadc0ef4255c3eb1c20" }, "href": "/comments/1002411", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "To complete the list of useful links add VizieR?\n\nSearch radius perhaps to ~10 asec to minimize hits?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T11:07:43.389Z", "discussion_id": "589500", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002411", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T11:07:43.389Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 47, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Metadata Requests", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-09-07T17:47:16.205Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98281" }, "href": "/comments/1002618", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Are there still 'Exercises' for the students of the Astronomy MOOC by Chris Impey at the University of Arizona?\nThese are the instructions in the course:Activity no. 1, \"Galaxy Zoo\"\n\nThe purpose of this activity is for you to (1) learn the major classifications of galaxies, (2) understand the unique features galaxies, and (3) take part in citizen science!\n\nUnder \"exercises,\" click \"lecture and activity quizzes.\" Here you should see \"Activity no. 1, \"Galaxy Zoo\". Click on this and begin the activity. Further instructions will be found within the activity module.\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T13:59:04.550Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002618", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T13:59:04.550Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1330689", "user_login": "37g41", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "37g41" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98282" }, "href": "/comments/1002664", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Could you give us the link for this ? ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T14:31:57.218Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002664", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T14:31:57.218Z", "upvotes": { "christy": { "readgmail": { "com": "1523724484" } } }, "user_id": "123", "user_login": "eax9k", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "eax9k", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98283" }, "href": "/comments/1002714", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "https://www.coursera.org/learn/astro/supplement/p4VXV/lesson-eight-overview\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T15:06:24.222Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002714", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T15:06:24.222Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1330689", "user_login": "37g41", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "37g41" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98284" }, "href": "/comments/1002736", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Sorry, but I can't access that lesson eight overview. The link gets me to the landing page for the course.\nIf you are having problems, you should try and contact someone from the course.\nGood luck ! ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T15:25:48.700Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002736", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T15:25:48.700Z", "upvotes": { "christy": { "readgmail": { "com": "1523724494" } } }, "user_id": "123", "user_login": "eax9k", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "eax9k", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98285" }, "href": "/comments/1002849", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "We got this email on March 15\nChris \n15 Mar\nto galaxy-zoo \nDear Galaxy Zoo volunteers,\n\nGalaxy Zoo is back! We have a brand new site at www.galaxyzoo.org and new images of galaxies, which have never been seen before. These galaxies come from a large telescope in Chile, and so the images reveal finer structure and fainter details than in the original project. We already know that your classifications help us explore and understand the Universe, but with these new images we’re expecting to see more - and understand more about the cosmos than ever before.\n\nThe team are ready to make use of your classifications, so we hope that you can whip through these images in record time - if you have a few minutes to spare, please go to www.galaxyzoo.org and help us out.\n\nThanks,\n\nChris and the Galaxy Zoo Team\n\nPS The site has also been updated - you can read more about these changes at blog.galaxyzoo.org/2018/03/15/new-galaxies-new-galaxy-zoo.\n\nI have contacted Prof Impey.\nThank you!\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T16:50:23.792Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002849", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@zooniverse": { "org": { "id": 247055, "type": "User" } } }, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T16:50:23.792Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1330689", "user_login": "37g41", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "37g41" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98286" }, "href": "/comments/1002862", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Oh, okay. \nThis email is just to anounce the relaunch of Galaxy Zoo on the new platform (Panoptes).\nNot sure what it has to do with the course, sorry! \n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T16:58:16.147Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002862", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T16:58:16.147Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "123", "user_login": "eax9k", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "eax9k", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bfd4c0ef4255c3e9af92" }, "href": "/comments/1002890", "links": {}, "board_id": "391", "body": "#supersnap Spruce Grouse (Male). Good to see!", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-14T17:32:58.407Z", "discussion_id": "598834", "focus_id": "20427422", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1002890", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2439", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2439", "tagging": { "#supersnap": "supersnap" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-14T17:32:58.407Z", "upvotes": { "momsabina": "1537377937" }, "user_id": "1462020", "user_login": "9updk", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20427422", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-09-22T11:45:41.243Z", "discussion_users_count": 7, "discussion_focus_id": "20427422", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 128175, "board_description": "Comments about specific photos", "board_discussions_count": 75919, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2203, "project_slug": "zooniverse/snapshot-wisconsin", "project_title": "Snapshot Wisconsin", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "9updk" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bfb6c0ef4255c3e9acf5" }, "href": "/comments/1003463", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "#lacey #cluster #shower", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T00:26:30.827Z", "discussion_id": "115571", "focus_id": "3833119", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1003463", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": { "#lacey": "lacey", "#cluster": "cluster", "#shower": "shower" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T00:26:30.827Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "821090", "user_login": "keslh", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3833119", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-07-21T00:35:57.610Z", "discussion_users_count": 11, "discussion_focus_id": "3833119", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "keslh" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98287" }, "href": "/comments/1004182", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "There used to be Exercises for our students to do....", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T12:58:44.706Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004182", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T12:58:44.706Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1330689", "user_login": "37g41", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "37g41" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81bf" }, "href": "/comments/1004266", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "#tidal-tail. A jet-like extension seen going down from this galaxy. The closest neighbour seems to be an edge-on situated above this one, as seen in the SDSS image below. So why is the jet-like extension pointing in the opposite direction?\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr14/SkyServerWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=197.79752&dec=1.2007&width=512&height=512&scale=0.4)\n\nz is 0.06451 for the central galaxy and 0.06494 for the edge-on.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T14:19:24.777Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004266", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#tidal-tail": "tidal-tail" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T14:20:31.862Z", "upvotes": { "Budgieye": "1523854834" }, "user_id": "172", "user_login": "06390", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "06390" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c0" }, "href": "/comments/1004270", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Perhaps the tail is the remnant of a smaller galaxy being consumed?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T14:21:33.529Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004270", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T14:21:33.529Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "172", "user_login": "06390", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "06390" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c1" }, "href": "/comments/1004277", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Or just an artifact created by the diffraction spikes of a star seen near this galaxy in the sky?\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr14/SkyServerWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=197.78742&dec=1.17282&width=512&height=512&scale=0.4)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T14:29:16.315Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004277", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T14:29:16.315Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "172", "user_login": "06390", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "06390" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca53c0ef4255c3eb0650" }, "href": "/comments/1004458", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Not the same name of the two asteroids (green blobs) in this image of the field ^S20532288\n\n![Subject 20532288](http://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=173.8351&dec=-1.0168&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5&width=640&height=640)\n\nData from JPL \n\nleft #asteroid R.A.=11:35:21.408, Dec.=-01 01 11.640 J2000) [72896 2001 KA54](https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/sbdb.cgi?sstr=72896) Observation Date = 2017-Mar-04 05:22:00\n\nright #asteroid R.A.=11:35:19.392, Dec.=-01 00 50.760 J2000) [2006 SA352](https://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/sbdb.cgi?sstr=2006%20SA352) Observation Date = 2017-Mar-04 05:22:00", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T16:20:07.276Z", "discussion_id": "583145", "focus_id": "20532288", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004458", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "^S20532288": { "id": 20532288, "type": "Subject" } }, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "993381", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#asteroid": "asteroid" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T16:21:06.927Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "2274", "user_login": "ztjl3", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1251879, "reply_user_login": "m3cok", "reply_user_display_name": "m3cok", "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20532288", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:12:20.287Z", "discussion_users_count": 7, "discussion_focus_id": "20532288", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "ztjl3" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb0584" }, "href": "/comments/100460", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "Just to make it clear: as a beta tester I was putting together an annotated (hashtags) structured sub database (collections) for the project built on my ideas based on visual data analysis. ( when I was finding and categorizing several maybe new glitch types which were not included on the beta classification table, I found it was best way from my part to help as a beta tester ). Database (any, collections too) needs to be checked and updated regularly to keep it representative and I am doing that too on the collections. Duplications and misinterpretations bring a big mess in this. To back up collections would be useful but Zooniverse platform has got limitations, have to accept it however it's still really feasible if you understand how it works (@qm482 I understand that it takes time for \"kinda coder\" , it's why you put \"reserved, just in case\" etc. It is ridiculous from you but not my business. But your aggressive commenting style without relevant knowledge background can be misleading for people with less experiences, it's the reason I mention it, coz it would be really a shame otherwise I hate to get personal) ", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-20T12:34:52.770Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "100460", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@MvGulik": { "id": 3462, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-04-21T15:28:04.038Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "322252", "user_login": "zchzf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "zchzf" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca53c0ef4255c3eb0651" }, "href": "/comments/1004609", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "![Example Alt Text](http://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=173.8395&dec=-1.0196&zoom=15&layer=decals-dr5) ![Example Alt Text](http://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=173.8309&dec=-1.0143&zoom=15&layer=decals-dr5)\nAsteroid 72896 2001 KA54 mag 14 Asteroid 2006 SA352 mag 17\nI don't understand, I have the same names.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T17:31:14.685Z", "discussion_id": "583145", "focus_id": "20532288", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004609", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T17:37:49.906Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20532288", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:12:20.287Z", "discussion_users_count": 7, "discussion_focus_id": "20532288", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca53c0ef4255c3eb0652" }, "href": "/comments/1004686", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "I think the problem is CeciliaB’s post is the last one on comments page 1 and c_cld reacted to that comment.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T18:50:16.071Z", "discussion_id": "583145", "focus_id": "20532288", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004686", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1004609", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T18:50:16.071Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20532288", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:12:20.287Z", "discussion_users_count": 7, "discussion_focus_id": "20532288", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa42" }, "href": "/comments/1004760", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "I have assumed that this unusual galaxy is an edge-on disc with a huge central bulge. It could be a disc, though, with massive tidal debris on opposite ends. The former interpretation fits with the symmetry of the disc, and the latter by the asymmetry of the 'tidal debris'. @ChristineM", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T19:50:11.627Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004760", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@ChristineM": { "id": 834636, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T19:50:11.627Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1430195", "user_login": "rl6lg", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "rl6lg" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa43" }, "href": "/comments/1004774", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Or mayby a polar ring ?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T20:12:30.941Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004774", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T20:12:30.941Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "123", "user_login": "eax9k", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "eax9k", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa44" }, "href": "/comments/1004784", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "IIRC, there's a rare morphological class in one of Ron Buta's papers which may fit this galaxy well: it's something like an elliptical which also has a disk. From memory, the disks are usually embedded in the elliptical, but maybe this is an exception?\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T20:23:02.609Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004784", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T20:23:02.609Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "184", "user_login": "z62ev", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "z62ev" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa45" }, "href": "/comments/1004813", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "DECaLS Residuals also shows more clearly two arcs above and below center. Perhaps also a double / merging nucleus, so might all be caused by a merger in its final stage.\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=191.1202&dec=-0.4529&zoom=14&layer=decals-dr5-resid =300x)\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=191.1202&dec=-0.4529&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5-resid =300x)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T20:45:44.725Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004813", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T20:47:00.493Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa46" }, "href": "/comments/1004815", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Does anyone see an #x-shape?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T20:47:19.325Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004815", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#x-shape": "x-shape" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T20:47:19.325Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa47" }, "href": "/comments/1004834", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Maybe with a great deal of imagination. :)\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T21:08:42.579Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004834", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:12:05.855Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1251879", "user_login": "m3cok", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "m3cok" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa48" }, "href": "/comments/1004838", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "The galaxy is in a NED catalog of nearby galaxies considered to be hosts of binary compact objects.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T21:10:47.899Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004838", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1004813", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:10:47.899Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1251879", "user_login": "m3cok", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1373986, "reply_user_login": "b1wlq", "reply_user_display_name": "b1wlq", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "m3cok" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca53c0ef4255c3eb0653" }, "href": "/comments/1004840", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Thank you Ghost_Sheep", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T21:12:20.238Z", "discussion_id": "583145", "focus_id": "20532288", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004840", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:12:20.238Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20532288", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:12:20.287Z", "discussion_users_count": 7, "discussion_focus_id": "20532288", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa49" }, "href": "/comments/1004847", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Haha ofcourse the one source I rarely check.\n\nDo you refer to the LIGO source paper? Because I don’t think that says anything about the nature of the object, just that it might be a possible host for compact object mergers detected with LIGO.\n\nWhich does lead me to the bottom of the NED reference page, from 1991; \n\n*CCD multi-object spectroscopy of galaxies at the UKST* \n\nThat should / could contain some very revealing information about this galaxy.\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T21:20:24.582Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004847", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1004838", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:20:24.582Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1251879, "reply_user_login": "m3cok", "reply_user_display_name": "m3cok", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c958c0ef4255c3ead41c" }, "href": "/comments/1004875", "links": {}, "board_id": "952", "body": "I recently joined your project and was anxious to be able to help identify some of the wildlife using the tools you've provided...but in the last few days I am finding that probably 90% of the photos I'm shown are \"nothing here\" identifications. Am I really helping your project by looking at these?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T21:44:00.086Z", "discussion_id": "603034", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1004875", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T21:44:00.086Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1768982", "user_login": "w2ouf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 26, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Large % of \"nothing here\" photos...", "discussion_updated_at": "2019-02-25T16:21:27.154Z", "discussion_users_count": 17, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 1141, "board_description": "This is a place to post questions, report bugs, or get general information about Wildwatch Kenya.", "board_discussions_count": 269, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 272, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "w2ouf" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c2" }, "href": "/comments/1005011", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "But the diffraction spikes of the star are short. Can they create such an effect? #objects_that_need_more_research.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-15T23:59:52.679Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1005011", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#objects_that_need_more_research": "objects_that_need_more_research" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-15T23:59:52.679Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "172", "user_login": "06390", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "06390" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c3" }, "href": "/comments/1005296", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "It would be a good idea, before using the tag #objects_that_need_more_research , could you search for all information that you can find,\neg an image from another sky survey, NED, spectrum\nJust in case it doesn't need more research :)\n\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=197.7962&dec=1.1835&zoom=13&layer=decals-dr5) \nhttp://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=197.7962&dec=1.1835&zoom=13&layer=decals-dr5", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T05:02:21.741Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1005296", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#objects_that_need_more_research": "objects_that_need_more_research" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T05:37:48.979Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c4" }, "href": "/comments/1005346", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "I checked DECaLS, SDSS and PanSTARRS and found the feature in all of them but couldn't deduce its nature.\n\nIs there some clue in the spectrum?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T06:17:35.610Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1005346", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1005296", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T06:17:35.610Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "172", "user_login": "06390", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "06390" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c5" }, "href": "/comments/1005519", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "If no one has published anything exciting about it, just say \"nothing in NED\". There is a spectrum in NED\n\n It is getting too difficult to check old Talk, Forum under several ID numbers, so I wouldn't suggest this anymore unless it was something amazing. Also, DECaLS images were used after the old Forum was closed, so nothing will be found in the forum.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T10:54:25.274Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1005519", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:36:16.842Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98288" }, "href": "/comments/1005520", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Hi Christy,\n\nThere are no exercises to complete on Galaxy Zoo beyond performing classifications. I am guessing that the Coursera website is asking you to check out Galaxy Zoo and perform some classifications as a learning activity - the 'further instructions' being our own instructions on classifying. Please let us know how Prof. Impey responds!\n\nIf you're a teacher, you might be interested in this purpose built classroom site - https://classroom.zooniverse.org/#/astro-101-with-galaxy-zoo/educators/\n\nHope this helps!\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T10:57:39.164Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1005520", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T10:57:39.164Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "290475", "user_login": "y15xu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "y15xu", "userRoles": [ "admin" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e98289" }, "href": "/comments/1005691", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Hi Christy,\n\nThe head of the Coursera course is named Chris (Impey), and the PI of Galaxy Zoo is also named Chris (Lintott), so I think that's all that happened here -- the first post looks like an assignment from Chris Impey's Coursera course and the later post is from the newsletter we sent out announcing the new GZ (signed by Chris Lintott). So unless I've misunderstood something I think they're unrelated! :)\n\nBest,\n-Brooke", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T13:46:48.702Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1005691", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T13:46:48.702Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "2760", "user_login": "obsxz", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "obsxz", "userRoles": [ "admin", "team" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c958c0ef4255c3ead41d" }, "href": "/comments/1005778", "links": {}, "board_id": "952", "body": "Yes!! They photos can tell us just as much as the photos with something in them. We can start to see the areas that have high volumes of nothing here photos and the areas that have high volumes of animals and try to figure out why. Why are some areas lacking in wildlife? Is it vegetation, access to water, presence of livestock? In addition, by identifying the areas that support higher volumes of wildlife, we can identify the areas that may be in need of better protection and conservation measures. ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T15:04:56.504Z", "discussion_id": "603034", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1005778", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "1004875", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T15:04:56.504Z", "upvotes": { "BeckiL": "1551919687", "Oliviaagnew": "1548134779", "IloveAnimals90": "1548113444" }, "user_id": "1671510", "user_login": "jgyi7", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1768982, "reply_user_login": "w2ouf", "reply_user_display_name": "w2ouf", "discussion_comments_count": 26, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Large % of \"nothing here\" photos...", "discussion_updated_at": "2019-02-25T16:21:27.154Z", "discussion_users_count": 17, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 1141, "board_description": "This is a place to post questions, report bugs, or get general information about Wildwatch Kenya.", "board_discussions_count": 269, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 272, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "jgyi7", "userRoles": [ "moderator", "team", "scientist", "admin" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb0585" }, "href": "/comments/100585", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "This comment has been deleted", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-20T21:00:19.000Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "100585", "is_deleted": true, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-05-13T04:28:27.116Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "3462", "user_login": "qm482", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "qm482" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb0586" }, "href": "/comments/100591", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "Deleted \"the good point...\" before seeing your reply, oops.\n\nNow you mix up facts with critics on your list about me (wow). it's exactly just one of that kind of reasons why I hate to get personal.\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-20T21:15:20.122Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "100591", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-04-21T18:08:03.476Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "322252", "user_login": "zchzf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "zchzf" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c6" }, "href": "/comments/1005938", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Can’t find anything referencing the feature in NED or SIMBAD (for me that’s a good sign but opinions differ :) )\n\nSDSS spectrum says ‘Galaxy red / AGN’. \n\n![Example Alt Text](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/get/SpecById.ashx?id=332240286501595136 =600x) http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/tools/explore/summary.aspx?ra=197.796711&dec=1.187144\n\nI guess the un-annotated spike is misaligned skyglow substraction at 5577Å? https://dr12.sdss.org/spectrumDetail?plateid=295&mjd=51985&fiber=363\n\nIt is seen / assumed before that interactions between galaxies can leave long straight tidal streams. If this was caused by the other galaxy at 12:00 I guess it was a close call and happenend a very very long time ago.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T17:13:49.914Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1005938", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T17:13:49.914Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57ed" }, "href": "/comments/1006025", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "[SDSS J164919.04+131350.6](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr14/en/tools/explore/Summary.aspx?id=1237668706224833233):\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr14/SkyServerWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Explore.Image&ra=252.329348948513&dec=13.2307433987513&scale=0.2&width=400&height=400)\n\nGalaxy-galaxy overlap or interaction? Or star-galaxy overlap?\n\n([Source](https://radiotalk.galaxyzoo.org/#/boards/BRG0000006/discussions/DRG0000ohd))", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T18:32:01.228Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006025", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T18:32:01.228Z", "upvotes": { "Andro": { "meda31": "1619354740" } }, "user_id": "184", "user_login": "z62ev", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "z62ev" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57ee" }, "href": "/comments/1006130", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Orange object is clearly moving between SDSS / DECaLS while other objects stay stationary so that's probably a MW star.\n\n![Example Alt Text](https://media.giphy.com/media/1X7AriU8c8vL7q56Du/giphy.gif =500x) https://gph.is/2H3S7rB\n\nYou can see for yourself in DECaLS viewer, after following the link to DECaLS select the SDSS layer, then use your spacebar to flip between both layers.\n\nhttp://legacysurvey.org/viewer?ra=252.3293&dec=13.2307&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T19:57:31.343Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006130", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1006025", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T19:58:10.302Z", "upvotes": { "Budgieye": "1523941643", "JeanTate": "1523911801" }, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 184, "reply_user_login": "z62ev", "reply_user_display_name": "z62ev", "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c7" }, "href": "/comments/1006183", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "The tidal tail gets broader and fuzzier towards its end. Could that area be the remains of an earlier galaxy?\n\nSDSS DR14: http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr14/SkyServerWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=197.795&dec=1.178&scale=0.19806&width=512&height=512&opt=&query=\n\nEDIT: I see now that karthikeyan.d has a similar suggestion higher up in this thread.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T20:26:12.570Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006183", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T21:52:04.234Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1251879", "user_login": "m3cok", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "m3cok" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57ef" }, "href": "/comments/1006245", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Cool! :)\n\nHow did you make the image (is it a GIF)?\n\nIf it's moved that much in, what, less than a decade?, the star must be either very high speed or local, right? Do you think it's possible to estimate the movement, in arcsecs (with an estimate of error)?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T20:53:05.639Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006245", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1006130", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T20:53:05.639Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "184", "user_login": "z62ev", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1373986, "reply_user_login": "b1wlq", "reply_user_display_name": "b1wlq", "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "z62ev" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57f0" }, "href": "/comments/1006258", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Yeah took two images from Aladin Desktop and made a gif with giphy, link is next to the GIF if you want to paste it somewhere else. But I must say the movement is visually more clear to me in DECaLS viewer flipping the images.\n\nI guess I can check the movement but takes some time; gotta find the mjd's to be meaningful.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T20:57:38.485Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006258", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1006245", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T20:57:38.485Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 184, "reply_user_login": "z62ev", "reply_user_display_name": "z62ev", "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57f1" }, "href": "/comments/1006282", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Some uncertanties here, I had to use SDSS i band becaue coloured is a bit too fuzzy. Rough estimates if you agree to the numbers;\n\n - Measured movement between SDSS i - DECaLS ~510mas\n- SDSS mjd_i 53530 = 06-09-2005\n- DECaLS coadded images uses two z band images, one from 2015-04-12 and one from 2016-02-27. To be more certain I'd have to download the FITS files but no time now sorry.\n- Between SDSS i - DECaLS z either 3505 days or 3827 days\n- PM between 53mas/yr - 49mas/yr = around 50mas/yr. Not spectecularly high I think. \n\nHope this helps :)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-16T21:20:22.602Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006282", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-16T21:20:22.602Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57f2" }, "href": "/comments/1006706", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Amazing graphics.\nDo you think it is moving up and to the left? So both the ra and dec would be positive?\nNot in SIMBAD, it is too dim for that.\n\nNot in motion verified stars. Probably in WISE, though the data is probably confused since there are two stars so close together.\n\nhttp://vizier.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=&-out.add=_r&-out.add=_RAJ%2C_DEJ&-sort=_r&-to=&-out.max=20&-meta.ucd=2&-meta.foot=1&-c.rs=50&-c=252.32934+13.2307\n\nMaybe put in a comment in Backyard Worlds \nhttps://www.zooniverse.org/projects/marckuchner/backyard-worlds-planet-9/talk", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T05:01:05.808Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006706", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T05:07:50.798Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57f3" }, "href": "/comments/1006787", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Yeah I do agree it seems to be moving positive RA and Dec.\n\nThe white one is probably a galaxy since it’s an RGZ target, no movement visible.\n\nUnlikely that it would be interesting for BYW, clearly visible in SDSS is bad news. They’ve got hundreds of good BD candidates to pick from so leave all the ordinary movers / M dwarfs to GAIA DR2 release (almost upon us).", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T07:37:58.371Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006787", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1006706", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T07:38:43.684Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57f4" }, "href": "/comments/1006793", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Is it in GAIA? I couldn't find it. \nBackyard Worlds want to find all close objects, not just the coldest. If it isn't in SIMBAD, then it is suitable.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T08:06:25.685Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006793", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T08:06:25.685Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57f5" }, "href": "/comments/1006862", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "I meant the upcoming Data Release 2 of GAIA many astronomers are so excited about.\n\nThere will be a huge rush when its released, probably an avalanche of papers following that.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T10:17:32.570Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006862", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1006793", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T10:17:32.570Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57f6" }, "href": "/comments/1006866", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "The first table down gives a comparison between GAIA DR1 and DR2;\n\nhttps://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/gaia/dr2", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T10:20:57.918Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1006866", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T10:20:57.918Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb6cc0ef4255c3eb57f7" }, "href": "/comments/1007095", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "> is probably a galaxy since it’s an RGZ target\n\nActually no. The FIRST host is a different galaxy in the ARG field; this white-red pair struck me as unusual, so I wrote it up.\n\nIf it's red and has indeed a quite significant proper motion, I agree with @pbhh2 that it's likely of interest to more than one team of astronomers, if not the BYW one.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T14:21:14.248Z", "discussion_id": "564750", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1007095", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@Budgieye": { "id": 247, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1006787", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T14:21:14.248Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "184", "user_login": "z62ev", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1373986, "reply_user_login": "b1wlq", "reply_user_display_name": "b1wlq", "discussion_comments_count": 219, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Objects that need more research", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T16:53:14.705Z", "discussion_users_count": 26, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "z62ev" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e9828a" }, "href": "/comments/1007470", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Will let you know, Mike", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T18:31:34.493Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1007470", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1005520", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:31:34.493Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1330689", "user_login": "37g41", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 290475, "reply_user_login": "y15xu", "reply_user_display_name": "y15xu", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "37g41" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddbc0ef4255c3e9828b" }, "href": "/comments/1007471", "links": {}, "board_id": "1268", "body": "Yes, bit of a coincidence, Brooke.\nNot the cause of the students' confusion...", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.764Z", "discussion_id": "601788", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1007471", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1005691", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.764Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1330689", "user_login": "37g41", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 2760, "reply_user_login": "obsxz", "reply_user_display_name": "obsxz", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Exercises", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-17T18:32:37.874Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2912, "board_description": "A place to get general help for using the site. ", "board_discussions_count": 587, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 355, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "37g41" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c862c0ef4255c3eaab85" }, "href": "/comments/1007672", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "#rare unique blip whistle", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T20:35:34.029Z", "discussion_id": "604600", "focus_id": "10962551", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1007672", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": { "#rare": "rare" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T20:35:34.029Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1536599", "user_login": "h2zto", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 10962551", "discussion_updated_at": "2019-11-10T21:21:27.545Z", "discussion_users_count": 2, "discussion_focus_id": "10962551", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "h2zto" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca3ac0ef4255c3eb0038" }, "href": "/comments/1007937", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "#phys560 SBc ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-17T23:55:07.718Z", "discussion_id": "576784", "focus_id": "20283878", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1007937", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#phys560": "phys560" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-17T23:55:07.718Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1764525", "user_login": "zfipl", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 35, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20283878", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-16T02:24:27.796Z", "discussion_users_count": 20, "discussion_focus_id": "20283878", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "zfipl" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c958c0ef4255c3ead41e" }, "href": "/comments/1008025", "links": {}, "board_id": "952", "body": "Thank you for your reply. I do have to admit that after a string of \"nothing heres\" a photo with animals is particularly thrilling. Especially the giraffes - they are such magnificent creatures - and I hope you have complete success with your Project.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-18T01:28:52.065Z", "discussion_id": "603034", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1008025", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-18T01:28:52.065Z", "upvotes": { "IloveAnimals90": "1548113499" }, "user_id": "1768982", "user_login": "w2ouf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 26, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Large % of \"nothing here\" photos...", "discussion_updated_at": "2019-02-25T16:21:27.154Z", "discussion_users_count": 17, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 1141, "board_description": "This is a place to post questions, report bugs, or get general information about Wildwatch Kenya.", "board_discussions_count": 269, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 272, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "w2ouf" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c8" }, "href": "/comments/1008204", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "There is a spectrum in NED and also in the SDSS page (with different units for the y axis). However, these are for the central galaxy, right? Can they be used to derive details about this extra feature?\n\nI noticed that this tail is not visible in the single image cutouts of DECaLS. Probably too faint to be seen in these images.\n\nhttp://www.legacysurvey.org/viewer/cutouts/?ra=197.7965&dec=1.1866&layer=decals-dr5\n\nAs mentioned earlier, it is seen in the PanSTARRS images\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=197.7967+1.1871&filter=color&filter=g&filter=r&filter=i&filter=z&filter=y&filetypes=stack&auxiliary=data&size=240&output_size=0&verbose=0&autoscale=99.500000&catlist=\n\nIt is also seen in the image found in NED\n\nhttps://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/cgi-bin/imgdata?objname=2MASX+J13111122%2B0111136&hconst=73.0&omegam=0.27&omegav=0.73&corr_z=1\n![Example Alt Text](https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/dss/2MASX_J13111122+0111136_5.gif)\n\nI hope it is not a faint comet whose coma is in front of the galaxy :-)\n\n@pbhh2, you said\n\n> It is getting too difficult to check old Talk, Forum under several ID\n> numbers, so I wouldn't suggest this anymore unless it was something\n> amazing. \n>\nBy \"this\", do you mean adding objects_that_need_more_research tag or referring to the old talk/forum?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-18T04:47:31.626Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1008204", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@Budgieye": { "id": 247, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-18T04:47:31.626Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "172", "user_login": "06390", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "06390" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81c9" }, "href": "/comments/1008227", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "No, I meant checking to see if any Zooite had noticed this before, to give proper credit. But it is getting too difficult to check every ID number in 3 places.\n1237648722849169576\nhttp://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/tools/explore/summary.aspx?ra=197.796711&dec=1.187144\nSDSS J131111.21+011113.7\nand additional IDs for dimmer objects in the tail\n![Example Alt Text](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/SkyserverWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=197.795651270585&dec=1.17870208370247&scale=0.09903175&width=512&height=512&opt=P&query=&PhotoObjs=on)\n\nand redo the search , in the old SDSS dr7 number, which we Zooites used http://cas.sdss.org/dr7/en/tools/chart/navi.asp\n588848901531107443\n\nin old Talk \nhttps://talk.galaxyzoo.org/\n\nand the Forum, which is read only\nhttp://www.galaxyzooforum.org/index.php?PHPSESSID=4ppqbbi39cvqo0m7clsm6l56n1;wwwRedirect (use the orange Search, rather than the white box Search)\n\nAnd that is hoping that the Zooite used a SDSS ID rather than just the 57.............. number.\n\nI didn't see it in Mergers or flybys with incredibly long tails http://www.galaxyzooforum.org/index.php?topic=279481.0\n\nSo, too much work to do at first, but gets done later if the discovery is very important.\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-18T05:21:31.366Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1008227", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1008204", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-18T05:52:53.985Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 172, "reply_user_login": "06390", "reply_user_display_name": "06390", "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81ca" }, "href": "/comments/1008325", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Thanks for the details. However, if this object is found to have been discussed earlier, that means it has already been classified in an earlier GZ project. Why include it in the new one?\n\nIf it has been classified earlier, can the ra/dec values be used to search the GZ database? If the IDs of the classifiers are stored for each galaxy, we could try searching for their names in the old forums. You may have done this already.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-18T07:46:41.691Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1008325", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1008227", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-18T07:46:41.691Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "172", "user_login": "06390", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "06390" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caadc0ef4255c3eb1c21" }, "href": "/comments/1008421", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Good idea! I've had a look at this - here's a first effort for a link to include:\n\nhttp://vizier.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?&-c=195.55572995603276,0.5196312737422266&-c.rs=10\n(searches Vizier for the RA and DEC of [this image](https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/zookeeper/galaxy-zoo/talk/1269/602031) with a 10 arcsec radius)\n\nVizier has quite a sophisticated url-query system - you can read about the other options [here](http://vizier.u-strasbg.fr/doc/asu-summary.htx).\n\nLet me know what you think please.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-18T10:04:36.710Z", "discussion_id": "589500", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1008421", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-18T10:04:36.710Z", "upvotes": { "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1524046338" }, "user_id": "290475", "user_login": "y15xu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 47, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Metadata Requests", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-09-07T17:47:16.205Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "y15xu", "userRoles": [ "admin" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caadc0ef4255c3eb1c22" }, "href": "/comments/1008429", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Works perfect! Already incorporating max 10 arcsecs limits results so makes it useful for quick further study (while not too confusing for those that are new to VizieR) IMHO.\n\nOfcourse the example galaxy gets ‘a lot’ of hits because it is included in a lot of catalogs.\n\nAlso in VIKING I see like a lot of other subjects from current set.\n\nMight I also suggest the ICRAR / GAMA [Panchromatic Swarp Imager](http://cutout.icrar.org/psi.php)? :D :D Also checks for HST images btw.\n\nTBH it sometimes functions badly eg not finding images where it should etc. But when target is in multiple surveys works perfect, also different bands RGB images possible.\n\nThanks!", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-18T10:21:58.722Z", "discussion_id": "589500", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1008429", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1008421", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-18T10:21:58.722Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 290475, "reply_user_login": "y15xu", "reply_user_display_name": "y15xu", "discussion_comments_count": 47, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Metadata Requests", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-09-07T17:47:16.205Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81cb" }, "href": "/comments/1008487", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Yes, they have been looked at before, but in SDSS where the images are much fuzzier. These DECaLS images have more resolution.\nI wish there was some way to access objects in talks and forum by ra, dec. I have asked for a sky map with markers, hopefully eventually we will get one.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-18T11:31:51.145Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1008487", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-18T11:31:51.145Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c745c0ef4255c3ea81cc" }, "href": "/comments/1008490", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "There is a lot of information in the old Forum. If 1,000 people spent 1,000 hours posting information, it gives you an idea of how much effort was put into it. \nThere were many more than 1,000 people, though some may not have posted much. I posted much more than 1,000 hours.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-18T11:34:16.113Z", "discussion_id": "602706", "focus_id": "20685218", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1008490", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-18T11:34:16.113Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 18, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685218", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-05-17T06:42:08.539Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "20685218", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb0587" }, "href": "/comments/100908", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "This comment has been deleted", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-21T21:55:45.314Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "100908", "is_deleted": true, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-05-13T04:28:49.277Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "3462", "user_login": "qm482", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "qm482" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb0588" }, "href": "/comments/100912", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "I was sure you come up with this :) :) :) \nI am not a native speaker, not easy to find the way how to stop the discussion with u what I absolutely want. Continue to go deeper and deeper if you want. I am fed with this. Bye", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-21T22:05:18.273Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "100912", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-04-21T22:05:18.273Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "322252", "user_login": "zchzf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "zchzf" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb0589" }, "href": "/comments/100914", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "fed up, I mean.", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-21T22:07:51.800Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "100914", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-04-21T22:07:51.800Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "322252", "user_login": "zchzf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "zchzf" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb9dc0ef4255c3eb6a3c" }, "href": "/comments/1009371", "links": {}, "board_id": "1270", "body": "SuperstringMuno that's an awesome pic!", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T01:39:59.904Z", "discussion_id": "576372", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1009371", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "984829", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T01:39:59.904Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1764915", "user_login": "ewjjm", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1758900, "reply_user_login": "fuuh3", "reply_user_display_name": "fuuh3", "discussion_comments_count": 406, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Just Chat", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-08-31T09:02:37.940Z", "discussion_users_count": 54, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2488, "board_description": "A place for general chat", "board_discussions_count": 500, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 246, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "ewjjm" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c958c0ef4255c3ead41f" }, "href": "/comments/1009484", "links": {}, "board_id": "952", "body": "I saw a posted photo that had 3 camels. They are not listed in the selection menu. How would we mark a photo if there is clearly an animal that is not a species listed? Thank you", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T04:03:16.874Z", "discussion_id": "603034", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1009484", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T04:03:16.874Z", "upvotes": { "IloveAnimals90": "1548113505" }, "user_id": "1763418", "user_login": "lmi13", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 26, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Large % of \"nothing here\" photos...", "discussion_updated_at": "2019-02-25T16:21:27.154Z", "discussion_users_count": 17, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 1141, "board_description": "This is a place to post questions, report bugs, or get general information about Wildwatch Kenya.", "board_discussions_count": 269, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 272, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "lmi13" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c958c0ef4255c3ead420" }, "href": "/comments/1009939", "links": {}, "board_id": "952", "body": "Great question! Camels are actually keep as livestock in northern Kenya. :) We lump goats, donkeys, goats, sheep, dogs, cattle, and camels into the general tag of livestock. \n\nFor animals that are not on the list, like steenbok, you can just tag as nothing here. That is better than tagging it as a different animal. \n\nThanks so much for helping out!! Hope you are enjoying it! ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T15:37:44.911Z", "discussion_id": "603034", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1009939", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "1009484", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T15:37:44.911Z", "upvotes": { "IloveAnimals90": "1548113520" }, "user_id": "1671510", "user_login": "jgyi7", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1763418, "reply_user_login": "lmi13", "reply_user_display_name": "lmi13", "discussion_comments_count": 26, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Large % of \"nothing here\" photos...", "discussion_updated_at": "2019-02-25T16:21:27.154Z", "discussion_users_count": 17, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 1141, "board_description": "This is a place to post questions, report bugs, or get general information about Wildwatch Kenya.", "board_discussions_count": 269, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Help", "board_users_count": 272, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "jgyi7", "userRoles": [ "moderator", "team", "scientist", "admin" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caadc0ef4255c3eb1c23" }, "href": "/comments/1009975", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "From the next batch of subjects, coming up in about a day and half:\n- SDSS Explore link will use http:// for correct zooming/etc.\n- VizieR search link will be included in metadata\n\nLet's see what science you can do with these!\n\nI'll make a note of the GAMA and HST suggestions but to be honest I might not add these any time soon - there's some other backend changes I need to work on first.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T15:59:39.008Z", "discussion_id": "589500", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1009975", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T15:59:39.008Z", "upvotes": { "Budgieye": "1524154307", "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1524165477" }, "user_id": "290475", "user_login": "y15xu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 47, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Metadata Requests", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-09-07T17:47:16.205Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "y15xu", "userRoles": [ "admin" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caadc0ef4255c3eb1c24" }, "href": "/comments/1009990", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Thank you MikeWalmsley for the automated links. No more errors in copying in pasting, esp forgetting the negative sign.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T16:13:00.762Z", "discussion_id": "589500", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1009990", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T16:13:00.762Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 47, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Metadata Requests", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-09-07T17:47:16.205Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa61b" }, "href": "/comments/1010172", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "This guide has many examples from the SDSS database, used by Galaxy Zoo 2. \nThe images are in three colours: blue, green and red.\n\nThe new Hubble Zoo is using data from the Hubble Space Telescope, and those images have better resolution. \nThe images are in two colours: light blue and orange.\n \npublished strong lenses with an arc visible in SDSS.\n\nThis post was first published in Galaxy Zoo Forum http://www.galaxyzooforum.org/index.php?topic=275811.0\n\n\n2 [What is a gravitational lens?](https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/zookeeper/galaxy-zoo/talk/1269/606015?comment=1010190)\n\n3 [Why are gravitational lenses important?](https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/zookeeper/galaxy-zoo/talk/1269/606015?comment=1010193)\n\n4 ![Recognizing \n confirmed strong lenses in SDSS](https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/zookeeper/galaxy-zoo/talk/1269/606015?comment=1010195)\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:15:26.307Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010172", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.213Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa61c" }, "href": "/comments/1010190", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "2\n## What is a gravitational lens?\n\n\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/02/Gravitational_lens-full.jpg)\ncredit: NASA \nhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gravitational_lens-full.jpg\n\nHere is model of a gravitational lens. We are looking at it from the side.\n\nA gravitational lens consists of a massive lensing galaxy, and lensed galaxies that are behind it.\nHere is a diagram of a gravitational lens system, looking at it from the side.\n\nEarth... a massive lensing galaxy with strong gravity.... a distant spiral galaxy behind it\n\nLight starts to travel from distant spiral galaxy towards Earth (straight white lines).\n\nWe can't see the distant spiral galaxy directly because the massive lensing galaxy is in the way. The spiral galaxy would have been too dim to see anyway.\n\nThe light that passes near a massive galaxy, is pulled towards that galaxy by gravity (the bending path of the light is shown by the curving white lines). A great deal of light that should have been heading in other directions is now heading towards Earth.\n\nThe light reaches telescopes on Earth, and a picture is taken. (The photograph of the galaxies as seen from Earth is superimposed in middle of the diagram. ) We see the massive lensing galaxy in the middle of the photograph, with the light from the distant spiral lensed galaxy as arcs around it. (The apparent path of the light is shown by yellow lines.)\n\n\n-------------------------------------------------\n\n ![Example Alt Text](http://casjobs.sdss.org/ImgCutoutDR7/getjpeg.aspx?ra=177.1380745&dec=19.50087261&scale=0.2&width=200&height=200&opt=G)\n\tHere is what a lens looks like in a photograph taken by the SDSS telescope. \nWe are looking at it, of course, from the Earth.\n\n\n\nIf the distant source is directly behind the lensing galaxy, the lensed galaxy is a ring.\n587742572151374147[587742572151374147](http://cas.sdss.org/dr7/en/tools/explore/obj.asp?id=587742572151374147) The \"Cosmic Horseshoe\"\nreference: http://arxiv.org/abs/0706.2326v3\nThe orange galaxy is the massive lensing galaxy.\nThe distant galaxy is directly behind the massive lensing galaxy, so we can't see it directly. \nMuch light from the distant galaxy has been bent towards us by the massive lensing galaxy. \nIt is concentrated into a ring around the massive lensing galaxy. \n\n-----------------------------------------------------\n\n![http://casjobs.sdss.org/ImgCutoutDR6/getjpeg.aspx?ra=181.50872096&dec=51.70820096&scale=0.2&width=200&height=200&opt=G](http://casjobs.sdss.org/ImgCutoutDR6/getjpeg.aspx?ra=181.50872096&dec=51.70820096&scale=0.2&width=200&height=200&opt=G)\nIf the distant galaxy is not directly behind the massive lensing galaxy, arcs are formed instead.\n588013382206357664 \nreference: http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.4475\nThe orange galaxy is the massive lensing galaxy.\nThe lensed galaxy is the white arc. It is much further away than the massive lensing galaxy.\n\n\n \n\n![Example Alt Text](http://imgsrc.hubblesite.org/hu/db/images/hs-2003-01-h-full_jpg.jpg)\nphoto: HubbleSite\tWhy look for lenses on SDSS when Hubble Space Telescope pictures can see more detail?\n\nThe (Sloan Digital Sky Survey) telescope covers a lot of sky quickly, while other telescopes can look at only a small piece of sky. Computers help set up the SDSS data base. Computers can sort galaxies by size, location and proximity to other galaxies, colours and redshift, if that is available. You can learn to use the SDSS search. But computers cannot recognize shapes.\n\nGalaxy Zoo 2 gets its pictures from SDSS, and help sort galaxies by shape.\n\nPeople can classify galaxies according to shape, recognize unusual shapes and interactions, and find new objects.\nAfter classifying their galaxy, Zooites can post unusual discoveries on the Forum, and discuss the galaxy with other Zooites. For gravitational lenses, the thread is Possible strong gravitational lenses in Weird and Wonderful.\nA scientist may look at the post and think that it is a possible lens, and then the galaxy can be put on the waiting list for analysis by other telescopes. The galaxy could be confirmed as a lens, and Galaxy Zoo could be credited with a find. \n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:20:31.035Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010190", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T20:14:17.539Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caadc0ef4255c3eb1c25" }, "href": "/comments/1010191", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Thanks so much, most of the most useful and most used links are now directly linked. Very quick and indeed prevents cut&paste errors :)\n\n(Most most most most, I seem to be most fond of this word, most peculiar)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:21:18.432Z", "discussion_id": "589500", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010191", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1009975", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T19:21:18.432Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 290475, "reply_user_login": "y15xu", "reply_user_display_name": "y15xu", "discussion_comments_count": 47, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Metadata Requests", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-09-07T17:47:16.205Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa61d" }, "href": "/comments/1010193", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "3\n## Why are gravitational lenses important?\n\n\n\n### 1 To refine the parameters that define our Universe\n\n...how and when it started, how it is growing, what will happen in the future. See wikipedia Gravitational lens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_lens\n\n![http://chandra.harvard.edu/photo/2006/1e0657/1e0657.jpg](http://chandra.harvard.edu/photo/2006/1e0657/1e0657.jpg)\nphoto: Chandra\t\n\n### 2 To weigh the amount of dark matter around a galaxy. \nhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter\n\nThe amount of bending of lensed light around a galaxy shows how much the galaxy weighs. If it seems the galaxy weighs more than the mass of stars and gas in it, the rest of the mass must be due to dark matter, and we can learn more about what our universe is made of.\nThis composite image shows the hot gas around the galaxy cluster 1E 0657-56, also known as the \"bullet cluster.\" Normal matter between the galaxies is shown in pink: dark matter is shown in blue.\n![http://imgsrc.hubblesite.org/hu/db/images/hs-2003-01-f-full_jpg.jpg](http://imgsrc.hubblesite.org/hu/db/images/hs-2003-01-f-full_jpg.jpg)\nphoto: Hubble Space Telescope\nhttp://hubblesite.org/image/1280/news_release/2003-01\t\n\n### 3 To find galaxies that are normally too far away to be seen.\n\nThe concentration of light of distant objects means that we can see galaxies that are very far away that are ordinarily too dim to see. With the help of gravitational lenses we will be able to see galaxies 13 billion light years away. The edge of our visible universe is about about 13.7 billion years away. So it adds to our understanding of the early universe.\n\nThe long bright blue streaky things are the lensed galaxies.\nSDSS can only see the biggest and brightest of these.\n\n \nThere are three types of gravitational lens\nSee Wikipedia Gravitational Lens \n\nStrong lensing forms rings, arcs and multiple images. This is what we are looking for in the Forum.\nWeak lensing shows only stretching of images.\nMicro-lensing shows no change in the lensed object's shape, just in brightness.\n\n\nI would like to thank Gumbosea for his inspiration and knowledge on the Possible Strong Gravitational Lens thread, and for looking over this guide. Thanks also to and Pluk, blt and Aprajita for the use of their illustrations. Thanks also the the major contributors to the thread who are getting expert in analyzing pictures for lenses and sharing their knowledge with newbies like me.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:21:43.976Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010193", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-14T05:45:18.119Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa61e" }, "href": "/comments/1010195", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "4 \n## Recognizing confirmed strong lenses in SDSS\n\nThe lensing galaxy has to be a massive galaxy to have enough gravity to bend light.\n\n----------------------------------------------------\n![Example Alt Text](http://casjobs.sdss.org/ImgCutoutDR7/getjpeg.aspx?ra=210.80219907&dec=54.34895402&scale=1.584508&width=400&height=512&opt=&query=)\n\n### This is **not** a massive galaxy\n\n\nSpiral galaxies are too little to bend light!\n [587735695913320507](http://cas.sdss.org/dr7/en/tools/explore/obj.asp?id=587735695913320507) The Pinwheel Galaxy, posted by Wosret\n\n-------------------------------------------------------------\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://casjobs.sdss.org/ImgCutoutDR7/getjpeg.aspx?ra=168.96625653&dec=1.49862791&scale=0.2&width=200&height=200&opt=G)\n\n[587728307491897590](http://cas.sdss.org/dr7/en/tools/explore/obj.asp?id=587728307491897590) **This is a massive galaxy**\nPosted by ElisabethB\nThis elliptical galaxy is probably a thousand times more massive than a spiral galaxy.\n\nOnly elliptical galaxies (and preferably many in a cluster) can bend light!\n\n\n--------------------------------------------------\n\n\n**The massive galaxies don't actually bend light : they bend space. \nThe light still thinks that it is going in a straight line.**\n\n **Lensed galaxies are a different colour from the massive lensing galaxy**\n\n**The lensing massive galaxy and the lensed galaxy are at different distances and the lensing galaxy is closer**\n\n## Let us look at the colour of the lensing galaxy\n\nThe galaxy that acts as a lens is an massive elliptical galaxy.\nThey are at least a billion years years away, with a redshift (z) over 0.15 \nThis is far enough away so that the white colour of the galaxy is redshifted to yellow, orange or red.\n \nThe colours described below are the colours as shown on the SDSS pictures.\n\n--------------------------------------------------------\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://casjobs.sdss.org/ImgCutoutDR7/getjpeg.aspx?ra=247.47734696&dec=35.47763614&scale=0.2&width=75&height=75&opt=) yellow lensing galaxy\n587733441053065699\nyellow colour z=0.2\n2 billion light years away\nhttp://skyserver.sdss.org/dr7/en/tools/explore/obj.asp?id=587733441053065699\n\n----------------------------------------------------------\n\n\n ![588297863111180358](http://casjobs.sdss.org/ImgCutoutDR7/getjpeg.aspx?ra=177.1380745&dec=19.50087261&scale=0.2&width=75&height=75&opt=) orange lensing galaxy\n\norange colour z=0.4\n4 billion light years away\n\nhttp://cas.sdss.org/dr7/en/tools/explore/obj.asp?id=587742572151374147\n\n---------------------------------------------------\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://casjobs.sdss.org/ImgCutoutDR7/getjpeg.aspx?ra=151.14243927&dec=41.21209441&scale=0.2&width=75&height=75&opt=) red lensing galaxy\n\nred colour z=0.6\n6 billion light years away\n\n\nSDSS cannot see normal galaxies further away than z~1.2. These galaxies have their light redshifted into the infrared and the infrared light does not penetrate Earth's atmosphere.\n\n\nThe colour of the lensed galaxy\n\nThe lensed galaxies are further away than the lensing galaxy.\n\nLensing does not change the redshift or quality of the light from the distant galaxy.\nLensing just concentrates the light.\nFor information on the colour and redshift of galaxies, see Zooite Guide to Spectra\n\nSDSS cannot see ordinary galaxies when they are far away at z>1.2, because all their light gets reshifted into IR (infrared light), and SDSS cannot see IR. So most of the lensed galaxies that SDSS can see will be active galaxies.\n\n\nActive galaxies produce UV light (ultraviolet light),which is redshifted into visible light that SDSS can see.\nThese galaxies either have \nactive star-forming regions that produce UV light or have an \nactive black hole with hot gas that produce UV light. \nIf an active galaxy is far away, and so the UV light is redshifted, that light becomes visible as bright blue, bright white (ie blue+green+red), bright green, or red light, depending on how far away it is.\n\n\n\n587724650875453828\nThe \"purple\" blob is a star forming galaxy which has been lensed.\nIt is far away (z=0.779), and should be red.\nBut it is a star-forming galaxy with UV light, which has been redshifted into blue light.\nMost of the ordinary light is still present, though redshifted into red light.\nRed + blue = magenta (though people call it purple).\nhttp://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0112249\nHubble photo in: http://hubblesite.org/gallery/album/entire/pr2003001f/\n\nThe shape of the lenses galaxy\nGumosea provides information on shapes found in arcs \n see http://www.galaxyzooforum.org/index.php?topic=6927.msg66286#msg66286\n\nTexture: the lensed galaxies will have a different texture to the lensing galaxy.\nLensing galaxies will have a rough fluffy texture.\nLensed galaxies will have a smoother texture.\n\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:21:55.738Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010195", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-14T05:47:30.682Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa61f" }, "href": "/comments/1010197", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "5 placeholder\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:22:06.523Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010197", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:57:26.640Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa620" }, "href": "/comments/1010198", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "6 placeholder\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:22:21.869Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010198", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:56:27.190Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa621" }, "href": "/comments/1010199", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "7 placeholder\n\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:22:38.776Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010199", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:55:12.182Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa622" }, "href": "/comments/1010200", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "8 placeholder\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:22:46.854Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010200", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:53:39.712Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa623" }, "href": "/comments/1010201", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "9 placeholder\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:22:55.031Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010201", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:50:08.897Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa624" }, "href": "/comments/1010202", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "10 placeholder", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:23:02.876Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010202", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T19:29:44.358Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa625" }, "href": "/comments/1010204", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "11 placeholder", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:23:11.069Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010204", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T19:29:53.719Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa626" }, "href": "/comments/1010205", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "12 placeholder", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:23:17.610Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010205", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T19:30:33.614Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa627" }, "href": "/comments/1010206", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "13 placeholder", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:23:25.267Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010206", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T19:30:18.472Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa628" }, "href": "/comments/1010207", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "14 placeholder\nHere are some more published strong lenses with an arc visible in SDSS.\n\nThe redshift (z) of the lensed galaxies has been proven by spectroscopy \n \n\tz=0.389 \n\nlarge galaxy z=0.23\nsmall blue arc z=0.389, strong OIII lines\n\"The Sloan Bright Arcs Survey : Six Strongly Lensed Galaxies at z=0.4-1.4\"\n2008 http://arxiv.org/abs/0812.3934\n588297863115047025 \nSDSS J104943.14+442035.6 \nposted by gumbosea\n\n \n\n\t~0.6\n\nmassive galaxy has z=0.44, \nestimate of z for arc is ~0.6\n\"Hall’s Arc\" , a serendipitous discovery of a giant arc in the SDSS data while doing a computer search for lenses.\n\"A Systematic Search for High Surface Brightness Giant Arcs in a Sloan Digital Sky Survey Cluster Sample\"\n2004 http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0701383\n587727230523080836 \nSDSS J014656.00-092952.4 \n\n\n\n\tz=0.766\n\nThe lensing galaxy is the orange galaxy, with a redshift of z=0.388\nThe distant galaxy is the pink arc at z= 3.6. \nSpectropscopy shows that it is a quasar.\n\"The SDSS Discovery of a Strongly Lensed Post-Starburst Galaxy at z=0.766\"\n2003 http://arxiv.org/abs/0804.1487\n587739115775197598 \nSDSS J082728.83+223253.9 \nposted by gumbosea\n\n\n\n\tz=0.725\n\nThe massive lensing galaxy appears red, with a redshift of 0.274.\nThe lensed galaxy(s) forms a bluish pink arc with a radius of 4\", and a z=0.725\n\"Two new large-separation gravitational lenses from SDSS\"\n2008 http://uk.arxiv.org/abs/0806.4188 CSWA 3 \nSDSS J124032.28+450902.8 \n588017605222793376\nposted by Fluffyporcupine\n\n\n\tz=0.776\n\none LRB and 2 smaller ones z=0.336\nbright arc 12.6\" long to the southeast z=0.776, faint extension to southwest\n\"The Sloan Bright Arcs Survey : Six Strongly Lensed Galaxies at z=0.4-1.4\"\n2008 http://arxiv.org/abs/0812.3934\n587741829121638526\nSDSS J111310.64+235639.5 \n\n\n\tz=0.850\n\nred galaxy at z=0.170, blue arc to west z=0.850\n\"The Sloan Bright Arcs Survey : Six Strongly Lensed Galaxies at z=0.4-1.4\"\n2008 http://arxiv.org/abs/0812.3934\n587733441053065699\n SDSS J162954.56+352839.4 \n\n\n\n\tz=0.985\n\nluminous red galaxy redshift z=0.4517\nextended blue arc to south with 3 knots, length 10.1\" z=0.985\nThe Sloan Bright Arcs Survey : Six Strongly Lensed Galaxies at z=0.4-1.4\n2008 http://arxiv.org/abs/0812.3934\n587733412060987606\nSDSS J151118.73+471340.3\nposted by Gumbosea\n\n\n\n\tz=0.97\n\nThe two massive lensing galaxies at z=0.43\nThere are two lensed galaxies which form 2 white arcs with a radius of 11\" \nand have a redshift of z=0.97 and 0.14 \n\"The Cheshire Cat\" \"Two New Large Separation Gravitational Lenses from SDSS\"\n2008 http://arxiv.org/abs/0806.4188 Cassowary catalog CSWA 2.1 and 2.2\n\"lensing two background sources, the first a star-forming galaxy at z = 0.97 and the second a high redshift\ngalaxy (z > 1.4)\n\"The Sloan Bright Arcs Survey : Six Strongly Lensed Galaxies at z=0.4-1.4\"\nhttp://arxiv.org/abs/0812.3934\n588013382200131773 and \n588013382200131774\nSDSS J103843.59+484917.7 and SDSS J103842.69+484920.2 \nposted by reddevil013 as Galactic Smiley Face\n\n\n\nz=1.018\n\n\"SDSS J120923.7+264047: a new massive galaxy cluster with a bright giant arc\"\nlensing galaxy z=0.55\nlong purple arc at radius of 10\" has redshift of z=1.018 (I think this is the one they analyzed)\n2008 http://arxiv.org/abs/0808.0721 CSWA 8 \n587741600957333763 \nposted by ElisabethB \n\n\n\n\n588295841784725744\nSDSS J113740.05+493635.5 \nz=1.4\ntwo lensed galaxies at 1.38 and 1.411\nlens is two merging galaxies z=0.4483\nThe Sloan Bright Arcs Survey : Six Strongly Lensed Galaxies at z=0.4-1.4\nhttp://arxiv.org/abs/0812.3934\n\n\n\n\tz=2.0\n\nThe lensing galaxy is red at z=0.422.\nThe lensed galaxy is a white arc with a radius of 5\" (?) and z=2.0\n\"Discovery of A Very Bright, Strongly-Lensed z=2 Galaxy in the SDSS DR5\"\n2008 \"The Clone\" CSWA 6 http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.4475 \n588013382206357664 \nSDSS J120602.09+514229.5 \nposted by Chipper Q and gumbosea\n\n\n\n\t2.379\n\nThe red galaxy, the lens, is at a redshift of 0.444 (4.6 billion light years)\nThe distant source is a star-forming galaxy with a redshift of 2.379 (10.9 billion light years)\nand forms an almost complete Einstein ring of diameter 10\" \n\"The Cosmic Horseshoe: Discovery of an Einstein Ring around a Giant Luminous Red Galaxy\"\n2007 http://arxiv.org/abs/0706.2326\n587742572151374147 \nSDSS J114833.13+193003.1 \n\n\n\tz=2.73\n\nmassive galaxy z=0.38 \nlensed galaxy is z=2.73\nThere are three images of the distant galaxy in the arc.\nSpectroscopy showed that it was determined to be a star forming galaxy.\n\"The 8 o'clock Arc: A Serendipitous Discovery of a Strongly Lensed Lyman Break Galaxy in the SDSS DR4 Imaging Data\"\n(named for the time of day when it was found, not the position of the arc)\n2006 The 8 O'Clock Arc http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/astro-ph/0611138\n588290880028999911 \nSDSS J002240.91+143110.4 \n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:23:32.731Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010207", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:57:14.836Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa629" }, "href": "/comments/1010208", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "15 placeholder\n\n\nDouble quasars in SDSS,... and triple, and quadruple.\n\nA quasar is a galaxy with an extremely bright centre, or nucleus, where black hole in the nucleus is feeding on stars. We don't see the rest of the galaxy, just the small bright centre. After its light has been through a lens, the arcs produced are still very small, and look like a tiny points of light. \n\nGalaxy Zooites can't see any shape in these arcs, since the arcs look like stars. We need spectra to distinguish quasars from stars, and we often don't have spectra. Therefore, looking for lensed quasars is not something that we Zooites can easily do. \n\nAlso, computer searches of SDSS can easily look for 2 quasars within a certain distance, so obvious examples have already been found. What to look for is two or more stars of exactly the same colour though not necessarily the same size, in close proximity, possibly with a dim red galaxy in between them.\n\nThe colours of quasars are not affected by lensing.\nThere is an excellent display of quasar colour and spectra arranged in redshift order, \nby SDSS at Redshift Gallery : Quasars\nObject of the Day Saturday 29thAugust 2009 Gravitationally lensed QSO's \n\n \nThere are many published examples of double, triple and quadruple quasars. Many have been found using radio telescopes. \nSQLS: Lens list\nThis is a selection of quasars that can be seen in visible light.\n\n \n\t\tz=1.41\nThose two “stars” are lensed light from one quasar. \nThis object is the first example of a gravitational lens\nthe massive lensing elliptical galaxy, seen between them, \nlies at redshift z = 0.355 (3.7 billion ly)\nThe distant quasar lies at redshift z = 1.41 (8.7 billion ly)\n1979 The Twin Quasar http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/bib_query?1979Nat...279..381W\n\"Q0957+561 A, B: Twin Quasistellar Objects or Gravitational Lens?\"\n587729388218679312\n587732583125352514\n\n\n\n\t\tz=1.73\n\n2003 http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0312427\n\"A gravitationally lensed quasar with quadruple images separated by 14.62arcseconds\" \n \nThere have been many lensed quasars found, but this has a wide separation between lensed galaxies\nThe orange massive galaxy has z= 0.67 \nIt has two nearby companions at z=0.67 \nThe lensed quasar is in 4 arcs, at z=1.73\n588297863111180358 SDSS J100434.18+411243.5\n588297863111180354\n588297863111180355\n588297863111180356\n588297863111180357\n\n\n\n\t\tz=2.024\n\nThe triple quasar Q1115+080A, B, C - A quintuple gravitational lens image\nhttp://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/bib_query?1979Nat...279..381W\nPG 1115+080 A gravitational cloverleaf Hazard, et al 1984, ApJ, 282\nAstronomy Picture of the Day March 31, 1999\nand Chandra\n588017726004396138\n588017726004396139\n\n\n\n\t\tz=2.024\n\n2009 SDSS J082016.11+081215.9 http://arxiv.org/abs/0906.2647\n \"A new gravitational lens from the MUSCLES survey: ULAS J082016.1+081216\"\nThe lens galaxy as a faint red object of redshift 0.803 \nThe lensed quasar has a double image (not really visible in SDSS) and z= 2.024\n587735349086257357\n\n\n\n\t\tz=2.237\n\n2009 SDSS J0819+5356 \nred lensing galaxy z=0.294\nlensed quasar, blue 4\" to north west, z=2.237, \nlisted as a star on NED\nspectrum evidently a mix of the red galaxy and the quasar \n“Five New High-Redshift Quasar Lenses from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey”\n2009 http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.0912\n587737826214674652\n587737826214674651 \n587737826214674653\n \n\n\n\n\t\tz=2.241\n\n2009 SDSS J1339+1310 \ndouble quasar \n“Five New High-Redshift Quasar Lenses from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey”\n2009 http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.0912\n587738568175058991\n587738568175058992\n\n\n\n\t\tz=2.701\n\n2009 SDSS J1258+1657\ndouble quasar\n“Five New High-Redshift Quasar Lenses from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey”\n2009 http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.0912\n587742774027878477\n\n\n\n\t\tz=3.317\n\n2009 SDSS J1400+3134 \ndouble quasar\n“Five New High-Redshift Quasar Lenses from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey”\n2009 http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.0912\n587739406254538958\n587739406254538957\nposted by 1000GGG, AlexandredOr suggested that it might be a lens\n\n\n\t\tz=3.626\n\n2009 SDSS J1254+2235 \ndouble quasar\n“Five New High-Redshift Quasar Lenses from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey”\n2009 http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.0912\n587742014361174098\n587742014361174099\n\nThese quasars have been listed as examples. Since Galaxy Zooites cannot identify double lensed quasars by shape, it is better that we concentrate on arcs and rings.\n« Last Edit: July 29, 2011, 06:45:05 am by Budgieye »\nReport to moderator 86.164.128.162\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:23:39.868Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010208", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:56:21.420Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa62a" }, "href": "/comments/1010209", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "16 placeholder\n\nRe: These are not lenses\n« Reply #3 on: July 28, 2009, 07:34:08 am »\nPart 4 These are not lenses\n\nThese examples are NOT gravitational lenses\n\nSince SDSS does not have the resolution of Hubble and other telescopes, we have to use our best judgement, using colour, shape and texture to recognize less obvious lenses.\n\n\tWe can see the thicker star forming regions of spiral arms, but we can't see the thinner regions due to low surface brightness of the outer part. So it looks like objects arranged around a galaxy See low surface brightness galaxies and Phil Marshall's Blog\nThis is not a gravitational lens. Perhaps there is not enough colour difference.\nBut the next one might be. When in doubt- post.\n587741490889753129 SDSS J081303.24+155216.9 \n\n\tthe thick outer arms in galaxies by Phil Marshall's Blog\nThis is not a gravitational lens.\nBut the next one might be. When in doubt- post.\n588010359598089071 SDSS J081303.24+155216.9\n\n\n\tblue star forming areas on the edges of galaxies \nThis is not a gravitational lens.\nBut the next one might be.\n587731679585566825\n\n\n\n\n\tsatellite galaxies, though it was hoped to be an Einstein Cross\nPhil Marshall's Blog\nThis is not a gravitational lens.These satellite galaxies are the same colour and texture as the centre galaxy\nBut the next one might be.\n587725073919377715SDSS J092622.10-003757.8\n\n\n\n\nhot areas in colliding galaxies we got observing time\nThis is not a gravitational lens.\n \nQuote from: Half65 on November 20, 2008, 07:37:30 pm\nStephenT posted this in Where does it go?\n\n \n 587743958884286603 \n\n\n\t\tOoops. A red star and a galaxy fragment. This is not a gravitational lens.\nThe beautiful spiral is 587742062136131600\nThe red star is 587742062136132080\n\n\n\nHere are links to articles in Wikipedia. \nEinstein ring\n\nGravitational lens", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:23:47.629Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010209", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:55:02.001Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa62b" }, "href": "/comments/1010210", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "17 placeholder", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:23:54.760Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010210", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T19:31:10.935Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa62c" }, "href": "/comments/1010214", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "18 Galaxy Zoo SpaceWarps and Lens Zoo\n\n Lenses from Hubble Zoo\n\nsee 69 Lenses from Hubble by c_cld\n\nhttp://aegis.ucolick.org/images/strong_lenses.jpg\n\n\n\n \t12016031 spectrum\nhttp://zoo-hst.s3.amazonaws.com/12016031.jpg\n587735694840758754\nTHE DEWDROP \nposted by ElisabethB\t12004138 spectrum\nhttp://zoo-hst.s3.amazonaws.com/12004138.jpg\nan Einstein's cross\nposted by c_cld\n \n\nQuote from: drphilmarshall on May 24, 2010, 10:37:27 pm\nQuote from: drphilmarshall on May 24, 2010, 05:07:42 pm\nQuote from: ElisabethB on May 21, 2010, 10:06:30 pm\nQuote from: Bruno on May 21, 2010, 02:01:38 pm\n\nEGSD2 J141753.4+523540\nSDSS J141753.34+523539.3 DEEP2 12016405\n:o, very nice possibility ! :D\n\nYeah, I like this one too! Do you think that's a faint counter-image at 10 o clock? I think it might be. I'll check my robot's reject list to see if this is there... :-)\n\nPhil\n\n\nOK everyone, I have made you a webpage: \n\nhttp://www.slac.stanford.edu/~pjm/HAGGLeS/hlsp/EGS\n\nFrom there you can download or view the catalog of outputs from our robotic search - you can read the paper at http://arxiv.org/abs/0805.1469\n\nI found Bruno's object - it was picked up by the robot, but downweighted by our conservative human experts! Hmm - we said we wthought it was only \"possibly a lens\" - but on second thoughts I'm not so sure! Anyway, keep them coming - if you see something cool, and its not in the robot's catalog, game on!\n\n\n\nhttp://www.slac.stanford.edu/~pjm/HAGGLeS/hlsp/EGS/lenstable_optimistic+humanclassification.html\n\nNotice that we only pre-selected about 1000 objects, for being bright red galaxies - massive ellipticals are what we expect most lenses to be. You'll also notice that a simple brightness and colour selection leads to a few interloping stars and so on, but the robot seems able to cope with that. It would have been better to do a morphological selection - but we did not have you guys to help at the time! \n\nIf you find objects you think are lenses, please do post them before checking the robot results: as your recent candidate shows, robots and experts can easily miss things... And keep an eye out for lensing by galaxies that are neither bright nor red! :-)\n\nGood luck!\n\nPhil\n\nQuote from: Bruno on May 07, 2010, 03:45:16 pm\nQuote from: h.kohler on May 06, 2010, 09:50:48 pm\nFirst I thought it was a SDSS image but no, it is a Hubble one\n\n\nhttp://zoo-hst.s3.amazonaws.com/13025503.jpg\nHi H.kohler\naccording to NED/ Simbad you hit the jackpot \nSL2S J142031+525822 -- Gravitational Lens\nSDSS J142031.80+525822.0 http://cas.sdss.org/dr6/en/tools/explore/obj.asp?id=587735665306763476\nDEEP2 13025503\n 8)\n\n \nQuote from: Bruno on May 02, 2010, 01:50:49 pm\n AEGIS / Hubble \nDEEP2 12024284 HST J141833+524352 G Lens\n\n*SDSS J141833.10+524352.3 14h18m33.1s +52d43m52s G_Lens >30000 0.462536\n\n Strong Gravitational lenses in Hubble Space Telescope photos\n\nSome great posts taken from taken from the Possible Strong Gravitational Lenses thread\n\nThere are many pictures of strong gravitational lenses taken by Hubble Space Telescope.\nSee their website: \nhttp://hubblesite.org/gallery/album/exotic/gravitational_lens/\n\nThis is \"our\" Phil Marshall's list of possible lenses from Hubble pictures.\nQuote from: drphilmarshall on May 24, 2010, 10:37:27 pm\n\nOK everyone, I have made you a webpage: \n\nhttp://www.slac.stanford.edu/~pjm/HAGGLeS/hlsp/EGS\n\nFrom there you can download or view the catalog of outputs from our robotic search - you can read the paper at http://arxiv.org/abs/0805.1469\n\n\n\nPhil\n\nHere are illustrations from a slide show by Ray Lucas, Space Telescope Science Institute (recommended by c_cld)\nslide presentation\n\n\nA picture by the upgraded Hubble telescope.\nThe lensed galaxies are the stretched red and blue streaks.\nThere is detail of the lensed galaxy detail visible on the large red\nA good explanation in Astronomy Picture of the Day 2009 September 21\nThis galaxy cluster is not in the SDSS footprint, so we can't see it in SkyServer.\n\n\n\nMany of these lenses require a fine resolution and cannot be in the SDSS SkyServer pictures.\nHere are some comparisions.\n\n\nHere is a lovely comparison by Pluk,\n\nQuote from: pluk on September 22, 2007, 07:04:23 pm\nTaken from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Einstein_Rings.jpg (thanks to gumbosea for the pointer)\n\n\n\nI tried looking these up in SDSS, which I think I did correctly by taking (for instance) J073728.45+321618.5 from the image and turning that into ra and dec parameters as ra=07:37:28.45 and dec=32:16:18.5. I tried feeding each thusly acquired pair to the SDSS DR6 Navigate Tool and each resulted in an SDSS object neatly centered in view. Alas, none showed any sign of the rings we're seeing above.\n\nI think I'm doing it correctly, still I don't see even a hint of a ring anywhere. ???\n\n587728669337584268\n\nJ073728.44+321618.6\n587731499183833286\n\nJ095629.77+510006.3\n588295840712949880\n\nJ120540.40+491029.2\n588010879838322829\n\nJ125028.26+052349.0\n588007005792567441\n\nJ140228.20+632133.2\n587722951697957575\n\nJ162746.44-005357.5\n587729409150681281\n\nJ163028.15+452036.2\n587727179519033515\n\nJ232120.93-093910.3\n\nedit:\n\nguess this explains it:\n\nQuote from: gumbosea on September 22, 2007, 05:26:26 pm\nThe article on rings contains a montage of rings image by the HST, the 'sharp and clear' rings mention earlier. When you look them up in SDSS DR6 using the 'navi' page, you can't see any arc; they are washed out by the central galaxy (not a big enough ring radius).\n\n\n\n\nanother from Aprajita\n\nQuote from: Aprajita on February 17, 2009, 05:52:41 pm\nQuote from: ElisabethB on February 15, 2009, 12:08:09 pm\n587728307491897590\n \n\nWell spotted! This is a region that contains a known Massive Cluster (MACS J1115.8+0129) that has been selected in the X-ray (z~0.35). These massive clusters are known to be sites where strong gravitational lensing is likely. Indeed the reddish arc is very likely to be a lensed galaxy. I have attached a HST preview image (png file) of this region with much higher resolution than the SDSS images in which elongated arcs can be clearly seen in this region (but please note the orientation is different to that of the SDSS image - that has north up and east to the left - so don't forget to take that into consideration when you visually compare the two images). The red arc is SDSS 111551.89+012946.7 - marked with a \"2\" and the lensing galaxy SDSS J111551.90+012955.0 marked with a \"1\".\n\nAprajita.\n\n\n\n\n\nfrom blt\n\nQuote from: blt on January 14, 2008, 02:54:37 am\nHubble has found a double Einstein ring in the SDSS data. I believe that this is the Galaxy: http://cas.sdss.org/astro/en/tools/explore/obj.asp?id=587735344263856391\n\n\n\nRead about it at http://hubblesite.org/newscenter/archive/releases/2008/04/fastfacts/\n\nHere are the Hubble pics:\n\n\n \n\nQuote\nhe massive foreground galaxy is almost perfectly aligned in the sky with two background galaxies at different distances. The foreground galaxy is 3 billion light-years away. The inner ring and outer ring are comprised of multiple images of two galaxies at a distance of 6 billion and approximately 11 billion light-years.\n\nSLACS team member Adam Bolton of the University of Hawaii's Institute for Astronomy in Honolulu first identified the lens in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). “The original signature that led us to this discovery was a mere 500 photons (particles of light) hidden among 500,000 other photons in the SDSS spectrum of the foreground galaxy,” commented Bolton.\n\n“The twin rings were clearly visible in the Hubble image”, added Tommaso. “When I first saw it I said ‘wow, this is insane!’ I could not believe it!”\n\nThe distribution of dark matter in the foreground galaxies that is warping space to create the gravitational lens can be precisely mapped. In addition, the geometry of the two Einstein rings allowed the team to measure the mass of the middle galaxy precisely to be a value of 1 billion solar masses. The team reports that this is the first measurement of the mass of a dwarf galaxy at cosmological distance (redshift of z=0.6).\n\nFrom http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/01/080110102319.htm\n\nAlso posted to Google Sky with overlays http://bbs.keyhole.com/ubb/showflat.php/Cat/0/Number/1093420/an/0/page/0#1093420\n\n\n\n\nVisible lenses in the Hubble picture of Abell 1689 seen in SDSS\n \n \n587724650875453478\n\nHere is Abell 1689 in SDSS. Here is part of Abell 1689 with the lensed galaxies pointed out.\n\nThe magenta galaxies are:\n587724650875454355 and 587724650875453828\nhttp://skyserver.sdss3.org/dr8/en/tools/explore/obj.asp?id=1237655500272500870 in dr9\n\n \nhttp://hubblesite.org/gallery/album/entire_collection/pr2003001f/\nHere is a link to the picture of Abell 1689 that Hubble took. It is nearly the same scale, but you have to put your head sideways to your right to put north at the top and make it look the same as SDSS.The arc is white, and there is see the some structure of a galaxy in the arc. \nhttp://hubblesite.org/gallery/album/exotic_collection/pr2008008b/large_web\n\n \nIn the SDSS image, the magenta galaxies are near the bottom.\nIn Hubble, the corresponding arcs are are the larger stretched galaxies in the top left corner.\n \nmagenta galaxy at 5:30 in SDSS Skyserver, and the same galaxy in Hubble\nRemember in Hubble, north is on the right, so the picture has a quarter turn.\nhttp://hubblesite.org/gallery/album/entire/pr2003001f/\n587724650875453828\n \n\nmagenta galaxy at 6:30. \nIn the Hubble image of the whole cluster, the arc is white and looks like a galaxy.\nNED says it has a red shift of z=0.69\n587724650875454355\n\n\nLovely astronomy picture of the day 2009 Aug 23 \n\n\nUnfortunately, it is outside of the SDSS sky\n\n\nQuote from: jules on December 19, 2011, 09:27:47 am\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:24:25.874Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010214", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:53:32.360Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa62d" }, "href": "/comments/1010216", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "19 Strong Gravitational Lens Surveys.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:24:33.860Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010216", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-05-12T07:48:44.879Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa62e" }, "href": "/comments/1010218", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "20 placeholder", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:24:41.682Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010218", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T19:31:44.273Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c83ec0ef4255c3eaa62f" }, "href": "/comments/1010219", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "placeholder", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-19T19:24:55.049Z", "discussion_id": "606015", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010219", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-19T19:32:01.597Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 21, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Zooites Guide to Strong Gravitational Lenses", "discussion_updated_at": "2020-07-24T04:59:03.247Z", "discussion_users_count": 1, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb058a" }, "href": "/comments/101031", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "Sooo, how it's going, the reporting? :) :) I am really interested to know zooniverse opinion!!! it would be very useful for you too, maybe learn something about ethics, how to deal with other people ideas, about appropriate style too (o.k. mine is not appropriate sometimes but it's exclusively dedicated to you :) ) you think you can fool around everybody?\n\nCage, cage, funny that you can't see at which side of the cage you are :))) \n\nupdating comments before having answer is o.k. Attempting to edit other users post in any way: not good. you are not a moderator, call for one. holding several accounts in the same time in one community for whatever reason: never look good especially when the task can be done on one account, you see: https://www.zooniverse.org/collections/EcceruElme\n\nso I hope u really did that report\n\n\n\n \n", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-22T12:41:47.036Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "101031", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-04-22T12:43:51.428Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "322252", "user_login": "zchzf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "zchzf" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c8b2c0ef4255c3eab813" }, "href": "/comments/1010622", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "in the news?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-20T00:55:34.682Z", "discussion_id": "106249", "focus_id": "3496776", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010622", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-20T00:55:34.682Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1771971", "user_login": "5jlin", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 22, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3496776", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-06-20T00:24:46.985Z", "discussion_users_count": 21, "discussion_focus_id": "3496776", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "5jlin" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa4a" }, "href": "/comments/1010790", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "Edge view or unusual Form? ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-20T06:00:28.893Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010790", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-20T06:00:28.893Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1719965", "user_login": "trec0", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "trec0" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb058b" }, "href": "/comments/101087", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "This comment has been deleted", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-22T19:14:19.852Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "101087", "is_deleted": true, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "99379", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-05-13T04:29:09.632Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "3462", "user_login": "qm482", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 3462, "reply_user_login": "qm482", "reply_user_display_name": "qm482", "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "qm482" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa4b" }, "href": "/comments/1010900", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "#polar-ring #edge-on #dustlane", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-20T08:56:25.959Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1010900", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#polar-ring": "polar-ring", "#edge-on": "edge-on", "#dustlane": "dustlane" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-20T08:56:25.959Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1392258", "user_login": "24l3s", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "24l3s" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb058c" }, "href": "/comments/101094", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "Fair play will help u to proceed.", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-22T20:32:56.232Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "101094", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-04-22T20:32:56.232Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "322252", "user_login": "zchzf", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "zchzf" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca3ac0ef4255c3eb0039" }, "href": "/comments/1011387", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "I agree possible spiral", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-20T17:22:00.010Z", "discussion_id": "576784", "focus_id": "20283878", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1011387", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-20T17:22:00.010Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1772261", "user_login": "6upna", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 35, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20283878", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-16T02:24:27.796Z", "discussion_users_count": 20, "discussion_focus_id": "20283878", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 124002, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75572, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "6upna" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bf9ac0ef4255c3e9aa4c" }, "href": "/comments/1011748", "links": {}, "board_id": "1267", "body": "![Example Alt Text](http://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=191.1199&dec=-0.4531&zoom=14&layer=decals-dr5)\nhttp://www.legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=191.1199&dec=-0.4531&zoom=14&layer=decals-dr5", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:32.920Z", "discussion_id": "602988", "focus_id": "20685061", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1011748", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:32.920Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 20685061", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-20T19:37:33.067Z", "discussion_users_count": 8, "discussion_focus_id": "20685061", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 123998, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 75569, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 5061, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995e3" }, "href": "/comments/1012024", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "Any guesses?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-20T22:19:11.014Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012024", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-20T22:19:11.014Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1667417", "user_login": "97k50", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "97k50", "userRoles": [ "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995e4" }, "href": "/comments/1012148", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "Duikers?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-20T23:46:55.392Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012148", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-20T23:46:55.392Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1752202", "user_login": "fnhpv", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "fnhpv" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995e5" }, "href": "/comments/1012159", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "Here’s another earlier photo - based on their small size, color, rounded tail-less rumps and pointed noses, they are Dik Dik. We’ve seen them in this spot. That’s my guess. ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-20T23:53:45.241Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809855", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012159", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "1012024", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-20T23:53:45.241Z", "upvotes": { "luli29": "1524288689" }, "user_id": "1672000", "user_login": "p3oke", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1667417, "reply_user_login": "97k50", "reply_user_display_name": "97k50", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "p3oke" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995e6" }, "href": "/comments/1012405", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "I agree, although they somehow look a little different to the dikdik we are used to seeing. Perhaps a different subspecies ? More intriguing yet is the creature (in the top photo only) between the dikdiks and the bottom of the photo. At first glance it appears like the head and neck of a bustard, but I can find no bustard (or any other bird) with these yellow, gray & white facial markings. On enlarging the photo, I thought it could even be a snake (cobra ?) in the act of swallowing something. I'm still none the wiser.\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T02:16:13.861Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012405", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T02:16:13.861Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1631551", "user_login": "drhca", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "drhca" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995e7" }, "href": "/comments/1012549", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "They do look like dik diks here. Did the bird fly down right next to them in this picture? The dik dik's body on the right is being blocked by something , perhaps that strange bird?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T05:31:10.765Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012549", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T05:31:10.765Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1752202", "user_login": "fnhpv", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "fnhpv" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995e8" }, "href": "/comments/1012555", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "Wow, good eye. I totally missed the bird. Zooming in, I can see its face, eye and beak. It does look similar to a Bustard and has a black mark on the face, running underneath the eye. But it’s very snakelike, too! Hmmm...", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T05:40:25.963Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012555", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "1012405", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T05:40:25.963Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1672000", "user_login": "p3oke", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1631551, "reply_user_login": "drhca", "reply_user_display_name": "drhca", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "p3oke" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995e9" }, "href": "/comments/1012564", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "On second glance it may just be the plants and the camera angle making the dik dik's coat look very strange. The bird head in top picture looks like it's attached to a plant, the eye looks fake when you blow it up, and there is a second \"eye\" on a smaller scale, below it on the right side of it,but that doesn't explain the plant not being in the bottom picture. Very puzzling.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T05:49:06.317Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012564", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T05:53:58.544Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1752202", "user_login": "fnhpv", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "fnhpv" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995ea" }, "href": "/comments/1012731", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "@Peregrin20 , you were correct with bustard. In the photo before posted here, it shows a full body shot of a bird, definitely a Bustard. With the black streak under the eye and a black throat patch (mostly obscured by grass) in the first photo, it looks like a #white-bellied_bustard or two are hanging around. ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T08:59:19.778Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809858", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012731", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@Peregrin20": { "id": 1631551, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": { "#white-bellied_bustard": "white-bellied_bustard" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T08:59:19.778Z", "upvotes": { "luli29": "1524303750" }, "user_id": "1672000", "user_login": "p3oke", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "p3oke" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995eb" }, "href": "/comments/1012781", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "It's nice to see this photo since it solves the mystery of the first photo.\n\n\n\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T09:44:59.062Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012781", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T09:44:59.062Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1752202", "user_login": "fnhpv", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "fnhpv" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995ec" }, "href": "/comments/1012933", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "Good detective work. I'm still puzzled by the amount of yellow in the face in the original picture. I can't find any others on the net that are quite like it. If the markings were white, it would make so much more sense. I wonder if the yellow is a local variation.\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T12:07:37.808Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1012933", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T12:07:37.808Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1631551", "user_login": "drhca", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "drhca" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c8b5c0ef4255c3eab884" }, "href": "/comments/1013067", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "Could possibly be a double blip, but they are both so small? Any ideas as to what celestial phenomenon could create a double blip like this with such small measurements??", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T14:00:05.618Z", "discussion_id": "104717", "focus_id": "3816626", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1013067", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T14:00:05.618Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 22, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3816626", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T14:00:05.811Z", "discussion_users_count": 22, "discussion_focus_id": "3816626", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198beb4c0ef4255c3e995ed" }, "href": "/comments/1013272", "links": {}, "board_id": "671", "body": "I agree. It could be a local variation or do you think it’s the lighting?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.402Z", "discussion_id": "606994", "focus_id": "19809859", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1013272", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "2789", "reply_id": "1012933", "section": "project-2789", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.402Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1672000", "user_login": "p3oke", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1631551, "reply_user_login": "drhca", "reply_user_display_name": "drhca", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 19809859", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-21T16:07:31.497Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "19809859", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 87970, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 53129, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2827, "project_slug": "sandiegozooglobal/wildwatch-kenya", "project_title": "Wildwatch Kenya", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "p3oke" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bfb5c0ef4255c3e9acd3" }, "href": "/comments/1013600", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "#possiblenewglitch ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T19:53:52.435Z", "discussion_id": "404217", "focus_id": "10967004", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1013600", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": { "#possiblenewglitch": "possiblenewglitch" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T19:53:52.435Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1765694", "user_login": "kbznd", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 10967004", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-08-15T14:39:40.954Z", "discussion_users_count": 10, "discussion_focus_id": "10967004", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "kbznd" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c1aac0ef4255c3e9dc95" }, "href": "/comments/1013715", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "Koi on Steroids", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T21:23:43.642Z", "discussion_id": "104256", "focus_id": "3772775", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1013715", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T21:23:43.642Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 12, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3772775", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-02-12T23:36:28.019Z", "discussion_users_count": 12, "discussion_focus_id": "3772775", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caabc0ef4255c3eb1b85" }, "href": "/comments/1013722", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "2000hz weird thing", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-21T21:29:51.824Z", "discussion_id": "89154", "focus_id": "3498540", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1013722", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-21T21:29:51.824Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 46, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3498540", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-10-10T12:51:49.101Z", "discussion_users_count": 44, "discussion_focus_id": "3498540", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118138, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73376, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198caf6c0ef4255c3eb3095" }, "href": "/comments/1016023", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "This comment has been deleted", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T03:25:58.800Z", "discussion_id": "566962", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016023", "is_deleted": true, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-30T08:32:49.429Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1498433", "user_login": "t5b9w", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 64, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Gravity Spy Glitch Library", "discussion_updated_at": "2019-03-16T17:59:00.988Z", "discussion_users_count": 9, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "t5b9w", "userRoles": [ "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cad4c0ef4255c3eb2630" }, "href": "/comments/1016071", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "I knew it was a chirp!", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T04:22:31.562Z", "discussion_id": "352977", "focus_id": "10354645", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016071", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T04:22:31.562Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 55, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 10354645", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-07-07T03:50:46.009Z", "discussion_users_count": 46, "discussion_focus_id": "10354645", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118138, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73376, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198cb14c0ef4255c3eb3b32" }, "href": "/comments/1016080", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "I focused on T=0 and classified that as the chirp! Gravity Spy is very immersive and exciting. ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T04:30:18.191Z", "discussion_id": "445577", "focus_id": "13267396", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016080", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T04:30:18.191Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 79, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 13267396", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-15T15:41:07.411Z", "discussion_users_count": 60, "discussion_focus_id": "13267396", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118138, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73376, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c9e0c0ef4255c3eaedd8" }, "href": "/comments/1016086", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "Stand alone violin harmonic?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T04:33:51.198Z", "discussion_id": "89171", "focus_id": "3498536", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016086", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T04:33:51.198Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 30, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3498536", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-06-01T16:03:32.124Z", "discussion_users_count": 27, "discussion_focus_id": "3498536", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118138, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73376, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c994c0ef4255c3eadf1b" }, "href": "/comments/1016099", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "#1400ripple", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T04:45:34.910Z", "discussion_id": "89177", "focus_id": "3498532", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016099", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": { "#1400ripple": "1400ripple" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T04:45:34.910Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 27, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3498532", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-23T04:45:35.039Z", "discussion_users_count": 27, "discussion_focus_id": "3498532", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c47ec0ef4255c3ea28a3" }, "href": "/comments/1016106", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "#gemini", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T04:52:06.459Z", "discussion_id": "91110", "focus_id": "3496900", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016106", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": { "#gemini": "gemini" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T04:52:06.459Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 14, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 3496900", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-07-07T03:54:52.848Z", "discussion_users_count": 13, "discussion_focus_id": "3496900", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c92cc0ef4255c3eacc4f" }, "href": "/comments/1016222", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "#green_pea spectroscopically found in GAMA (G09) survey\n\nSDSS-ID\t587727943489356059 [1237653664714260777](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr14/en/tools/explore/Summary.aspx?id=1237653664714260777) GAMAJ084915.23+012918.4 CATAID = 376183 RA = 132.31347245 1.4884577 z 0.20949\n\n![1237653664714260777](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr14/SkyServerWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=132.31347&dec=1.48846&scale=0.049515875&width=448&height=448&opt=GL&query=&Grid=on&Label=on)\n\nHSC-SSP\n\n![GAMAJ084915.23+012918.4](https://i.imgur.com/8aECKRj.png) gri composite\n\nGAMA spectrum SPECID = G09_Y1_CN2_290\n\n![SPECID = G09_Y1_CN2_290](http://www.gama-survey.org/dr2/data/spectra/gama/reduced_08/1d/png/G09_Y1_CN2_290.png)\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T08:21:44.845Z", "discussion_id": "554022", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016222", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#green_pea": "green_pea" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T08:23:36.095Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "2274", "user_login": "ztjl3", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 25, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Pea galaxies.", "discussion_updated_at": "2021-11-05T15:28:44.929Z", "discussion_users_count": 7, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "ztjl3" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3323" }, "href": "/comments/1016546", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Volunteers of the Milky Way Project and @Shingeru from Disk Detective found some galaxies in their projects and I want to point out some galaxies.\n\nMaybe someone can help us here? I am going to post them one after another.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T14:43:11.899Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016546", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T14:43:11.899Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1502635", "user_login": "re2nu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "re2nu" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3324" }, "href": "/comments/1016552", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "RA:157.1956719 DEC:-14.7873234 [AWI00000iq](https://talk.diskdetective.org/#/subjects/AWI00000iq) SED suggests galaxy | PanSTARRS the galaxy looks reddish [AllWISE_J102846.96-144714.3](http://vizier.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/VizieR-5?-ref=VIZ5addf1d57b61&-out.add=.&-source=II/328/allwise&AllWISE===J102846.96-144714.3&-out.orig=o)\n[PanSTARRS](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=157.1956719-14.7873234)\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1004/030/rings.v3.skycell.1004.030.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1004/030/rings.v3.skycell.1004.030.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1004/030/rings.v3.skycell.1004.030.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=157.195672&y=-14.787323&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T14:47:27.129Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016552", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T15:31:48.615Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1502635", "user_login": "re2nu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "re2nu" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3325" }, "href": "/comments/1016580", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Two of them have some spots off-centre\nRA:52.4323368 DEC:-3.5241805 [AWI0000oiw](https://talk.diskdetective.org/#/subjects/AWI0000oiw) SED suggests galaxy | spots at r i z\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=52.4323368-3.5241805\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=52.432337&y=-3.524180&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512)\n\n---\n\nRA: 204.815792 DEC:-10.0465141 [AWI0000tvl](https://talk.diskdetective.org/#/subjects/AWI0000tvl) SED suggests galaxy | spot at i z y\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=204.815792-10.0465141\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=204.815792&y=-10.046514&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T15:03:07.421Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016580", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T15:27:47.419Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1502635", "user_login": "re2nu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "re2nu" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3326" }, "href": "/comments/1016591", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Galaxies don't look very exciting in PanSTARRS. This one is not in DECaLS , nor in SDSS. Not in Hubble.\n\nfirst on the list\nhttps://www.zooniverse.org/projects/zookeeper/galaxy-zoo/talk/1269/609647?comment=1016552\n\nBest in the i frame, even so, not much to say about it. Maybe a spiral galaxy, since the nucleus looks large in relation to the disk size.\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1004/030/rings.v3.skycell.1004.030.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1004/030/rings.v3.skycell.1004.030.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1004/030/rings.v3.skycell.1004.030.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=157.195672&y=-14.787323&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1004/030/rings.v3.skycell.1004.030.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=157.195672&y=-14.787323&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.500000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS i filter\n\n\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T15:08:03.529Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016591", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T16:06:32.544Z", "upvotes": { "Melina_t": "1524503838" }, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3327" }, "href": "/comments/1016592", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "RA:42.5966016 DEC:-9.7242124 [AWI0000iek](https://talk.diskdetective.org/#/subjects/AWI0000iek) SED suggests galaxy | it has a long tail\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=42.5966016-9.7242124\nSee also DECaLS DR5: http://legacysurvey.org/viewer?ra=42.5966&dec=-9.7246&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5\n![Example Alt Text](http://legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=42.5965&dec=-9.7254&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T15:08:04.338Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016592", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T15:29:20.285Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1502635", "user_login": "re2nu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "re2nu" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3328" }, "href": "/comments/1016611", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "There are also a two spiral galaxies:\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=297.48072011+48.71435563\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=244.0463242-6.7813102\nAnd one with a bar:\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=250.8938947+4.72249\nAnd some overlap or merger:\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=264.4698702+39.8778173\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=211.1123824-8.2591867", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T15:19:23.636Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016611", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T15:19:23.636Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1502635", "user_login": "re2nu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "re2nu" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3329" }, "href": "/comments/1016633", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Thank you! I am not a galaxy expert and I thought I might point out some galaxies that looked unusual from the sample. Glad that I am learning more about such things.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T15:35:04.451Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016633", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1016591", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T15:35:04.451Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1502635", "user_login": "re2nu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "re2nu" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea332a" }, "href": "/comments/1016747", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Spots off-center. It is quite small, but I think that it is a galaxy, but it may be a star. The little red disks look for red foreground stars in our own galaxy. \n\nNED just says UV source, that is, if I have the right object.\nhttps://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/cgi-bin/objsearch?search_type=Near+Position+Search&in_csys=Equatorial&in_equinox=J2000.0&lon=52.4323368d&lat=-3.5241805d&radius=0.16666666666666666&hconst=73&omegam=0.27&omegav=0.73&corr_z=1&z_constraint=Unconstrained&z_value1=&z_value2=&z_unit=z&ot_include=ANY&nmp_op=ANY&out_csys=Equatorial&out_equinox=J2000.0&obj_sort=Distance+to+search+center&of=pre_text&zv_breaker=30000.0&list_limit=5&img_stamp=YES\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=52.432337&y=-3.524180&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=52.4323&dec=-3.5243&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5) DECaLS\nhttp://legacysurvey.org/viewer?ra=52.4323&dec=-3.5245&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5\n\nNothing in SDSS or Hubble \n52.4323368-3.5241805\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1245/013/rings.v3.skycell.1245.013.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=52.432337&y=-3.524180&size=100&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS\n\n----------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n------------------------------------------------------------------------------------\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=204.815792&y=-10.046514&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512)\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1105/048/rings.v3.skycell.1105.048.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=204.815792&y=-10.046514&size=100&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=204.8155&dec=-10.0468&zoom=15&layer=decals-dr5) DECaLS\nA very nice galaxy, with spiral arms or tidal trails.\nThe red disk is a foreground star in our own galaxy.\n\n204.815792,-10.0465141\n\nNothing in SDSS\n\nThis is quite likely in Hubble, in an image of a comet. Maybe someone who knows how to do FITS images can call up an image.\nhttp://hla.stsci.edu/hlaview.html#Inventory|filterText%3D%24filterTypes%3D|query_string=%20204.815792%2C-10.0465141&posfilename=&poslocalname=&posfilecount=&listdelimiter=whitespace&listformat=degrees&RA=204.815792&Dec=-10.046514&Radius=0.200000&inst-control=all&inst=ACS&inst=ACSGrism&inst=WFC3&inst=WFPC2&inst=NICMOS&inst=NICGRISM&inst=COS&inst=WFPC2-PC&inst=STIS&inst=FOS&inst=GHRS&imagetype=best&prop_id=&spectral_elt=&proprietary=both&preview=1&output_size=256&cutout_size=12.8|ra=&dec=&sr=&level=&image=&inst=ACS%2CACSGrism%2CWFC3%2CWFPC2%2CNICMOS%2CNICGRISM%2CCOS%2CWFPC2-PC%2CSTIS%2CFOS%2CGHRS&ds=\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T17:05:42.830Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016747", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1016580", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T17:56:48.136Z", "upvotes": { "Melina_t": "1524503845", "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1524505671" }, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1502635, "reply_user_login": "re2nu", "reply_user_display_name": "re2nu", "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea332b" }, "href": "/comments/1016827", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "GAMA PSI also checks all HST images / filters and gives nought result, so probly not imaged by the HST.\n\nhttp://cutout.icrar.org/psi.php", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T17:52:21.165Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016827", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1016747", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T17:52:21.165Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea332c" }, "href": "/comments/1016833", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "The colum for \"Target\" in the link for Hubble says COMET-TEMPEL-1, so I guess we are not going to see much of the stars and galaxies. I think it is this one (same year): https://www.spacetelescope.org/news/heic0508/", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T17:58:45.416Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016833", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1016747", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T17:58:45.416Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1502635", "user_login": "re2nu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "re2nu" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea332d" }, "href": "/comments/1016855", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "![Example Alt Text](http://legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=42.5965&dec=-9.7254&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5)\n\nSome galaxies have long tidal trails.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T18:13:34.843Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016855", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1016592", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T18:13:34.843Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1502635, "reply_user_login": "re2nu", "reply_user_display_name": "re2nu", "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea332e" }, "href": "/comments/1016867", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "two spiral galaxies\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/2339/019/rings.v3.skycell.2339.019.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/2339/019/rings.v3.skycell.2339.019.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/2339/019/rings.v3.skycell.2339.019.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=297.480720&y=48.714356&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000) PanSTARRS\n spiral galaxy\nNothing in DECaLS\n\n=======================================\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1203/031/rings.v3.skycell.1203.031.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1203/031/rings.v3.skycell.1203.031.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1203/031/rings.v3.skycell.1203.031.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=244.046324&y=-6.781310&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000) PanSTARRS\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1203/031/rings.v3.skycell.1203.031.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1203/031/rings.v3.skycell.1203.031.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1203/031/rings.v3.skycell.1203.031.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=244.046324&y=-6.781310&size=100&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS\ndisturbed edge-on galaxy?\nnothing in DECaLS\n\n=============================\n\none with a bar\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1474/014/rings.v3.skycell.1474.014.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1474/014/rings.v3.skycell.1474.014.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1474/014/rings.v3.skycell.1474.014.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=250.893895&y=4.722490&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000) PanSTARRS\n\n\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1474/014/rings.v3.skycell.1474.014.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1474/014/rings.v3.skycell.1474.014.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1474/014/rings.v3.skycell.1474.014.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=250.893895&y=4.722490&size=100&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=250.8939&dec=4.7223&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5) DECaLS\nhttp://legacysurvey.org/viewer?ra=250.8940&dec=4.7223&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5\n\nAgree, one huge bar", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T18:18:54.921Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016867", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1016611", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T18:33:17.818Z", "upvotes": { "Melina_t": "1524508845" }, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1502635, "reply_user_login": "re2nu", "reply_user_display_name": "re2nu", "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea332f" }, "href": "/comments/1016900", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "And some overlap or merger:\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=264.4698702+39.8778173\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/2138/096/rings.v3.skycell.2138.096.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/2138/096/rings.v3.skycell.2138.096.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/2138/096/rings.v3.skycell.2138.096.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=264.469870&y=39.877817&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000) PanSTARRS\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/2138/096/rings.v3.skycell.2138.096.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/2138/096/rings.v3.skycell.2138.096.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/2138/096/rings.v3.skycell.2138.096.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=264.469870&y=39.877817&size=100&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS\n\nI don't know, it could be a merger. It is very blue indicative of star formation which follows a merger.\n\nNothing in DECaLS or SDSS 264.4698702 39.8778173\n\n===========================================================\n\nhttp://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/ps1cutouts?pos=211.1123824-8.2591867\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1106/093/rings.v3.skycell.1106.093.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1106/093/rings.v3.skycell.1106.093.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1106/093/rings.v3.skycell.1106.093.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=211.112382&y=-8.259187&size=240&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000) PanSTARRS\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://ps1images.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/fitscut.cgi?red=/rings.v3.skycell/1106/093/rings.v3.skycell.1106.093.stk.y.unconv.fits&blue=/rings.v3.skycell/1106/093/rings.v3.skycell.1106.093.stk.g.unconv.fits&green=/rings.v3.skycell/1106/093/rings.v3.skycell.1106.093.stk.i.unconv.fits&x=211.112382&y=-8.259187&size=100&wcs=1&asinh=True&autoscale=99.750000&output_size=512) PanSTARRS\n\n211.1123824-8.2591867\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://legacysurvey.org//viewer/jpeg-cutout?ra=211.1123&dec=-8.2593&zoom=16&layer=decals-dr5) DECaLS\n\nnot in SDSS dr14\n\nlovely round bright nucleus makes me thing of a blazar, that is, looking right into a quasar,but\nNED has nothing, unless I had made a mistake with the coordinates\n[EDIT: no, a blazar would be white in all sky images]\nhttps://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/cgi-bin/objsearch?search_type=Near+Position+Search&in_csys=Equatorial&in_equinox=J2000.0&lon=211.1123824d&lat=-8.2591867d&radius=0.16666666666666666&hconst=73&omegam=0.27&omegav=0.73&corr_z=1&z_constraint=Unconstrained&z_value1=&z_value2=&z_unit=z&ot_include=ANY&nmp_op=ANY&out_csys=Equatorial&out_equinox=J2000.0&obj_sort=Distance+to+search+center&of=pre_text&zv_breaker=30000.0&list_limit=5&img_stamp=YES", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T18:35:20.978Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016900", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1016611", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.663Z", "upvotes": { "Melina_t": "1524509002" }, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 1502635, "reply_user_login": "re2nu", "reply_user_display_name": "re2nu", "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982b8" }, "href": "/comments/1016903", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "In a project I'm running I've already hit quite a few greyish objects, and one has a spectrum and is classified as quasar at z=0.78.\n\n[SDSS J235936.09+054515.9 1237678778478100658](https://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/tools/explore/Summary.aspx?id=1237678778478100658)\n\n![enter image description here](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/SkyserverWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=359.900411538586&dec=5.75442808926545&scale=0.049515875&width=512&height=512&opt=&query= =300x)\n\n![enter image description here](https://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/get/SpecById.ashx?id=4970993322073714688 =500x)\n\nSIMBAD: http://simbad.u-strasbg.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=%4010522397&Name=SDSS%20J235936.09%2b054515.9&submit=submit\n\nLooking at the other objects I got hits on is it likely I'm getting a huge load of unclassified QSO's? \n\nThree of many examples:\n\n\n![enter image description here](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/SkyserverWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=0.0830586673391593&dec=-8.18238509933417&scale=0.05&width=512&height=512&opt=GL&query=&Grid=on&Label=on =300x)\n\n[SDSS J000019.93-081056.5](https://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/tools/explore/Summary.aspx?id=1237680241450484014)\n\n![enter image description here](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/SkyserverWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=359.90142199686&dec=-8.43378613027986&scale=0.05&width=512&height=512&opt=GL&query=&Grid=on&Label=on =300x)\n\n[SDSS J235936.34-082601.6](https://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/tools/explore/Summary.aspx?id=1237680262389629128)\n\n![enter image description here](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/SkyserverWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Chart.Image&ra=0.1068907720867&dec=-8.48926748237974&scale=0.049515875&width=512&height=512&opt=GL&query=&Grid=on&Label=on =300x)\n\n[SDSS J000025.65-082921.3](https://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/tools/explore/Summary.aspx?id=1237680262389694585)\n\nhttps://talk.galaxyzoo.org/?_ga=1.191070186.1751955194.1484309494#/boards/BGZ0000007/discussions/DGZ0002ve4?page=4&comment_id=5ade24fc210f78162800127f\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T18:36:11.707Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1016903", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T18:36:11.707Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bfb9c0ef4255c3e9ad2c" }, "href": "/comments/1017037", "links": {}, "board_id": "328", "body": "800hz ripple thingy", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T19:39:00.593Z", "discussion_id": "352063", "focus_id": "5739139", "focus_type": "Subject", "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017037", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T19:39:00.593Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1769040", "user_login": "2sltj", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": true, "discussion_title": "Subject 5739139", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-06-22T13:19:28.442Z", "discussion_users_count": 10, "discussion_focus_id": "5739139", "discussion_focus_type": "Subject", "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 118137, "board_description": "General comment threads about individual subjects", "board_discussions_count": 73375, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": true, "board_title": "Notes", "board_users_count": 2762, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "2sltj" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb058d" }, "href": "/comments/101705", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "---\n---\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-25T04:22:44.688Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "101705", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-09-29T19:50:49.949Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "3462", "user_login": "qm482", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "qm482" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3330" }, "href": "/comments/1017051", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Thank you for this insight, @pbhh2!", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T19:48:21.013Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017051", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": { "@Budgieye": { "id": 247, "type": "User" } }, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T19:48:21.013Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1502635", "user_login": "re2nu", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "re2nu" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c248c0ef4255c3e9ec4a" }, "href": "/comments/1017152", "links": {}, "board_id": "1270", "body": "https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/04/180423125115.htm\n\nFace recognition for galaxies", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T21:01:41.301Z", "discussion_id": "609934", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017152", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T21:03:03.158Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1392258", "user_login": "24l3s", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 13, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "AI in Astronomy", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-06-26T22:56:47.534Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2488, "board_description": "A place for general chat", "board_discussions_count": 500, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 246, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "24l3s" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c4d5c0ef4255c3ea3331" }, "href": "/comments/1017209", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "You're welcome. I should like to visit your Milky Way :)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-23T21:53:32.143Z", "discussion_id": "609647", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017209", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-23T21:53:32.143Z", "upvotes": { "Melina_t": "1524560847" }, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 15, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Galaxies in other Zooniverse projects", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T04:53:58.692Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5509, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c248c0ef4255c3e9ec4b" }, "href": "/comments/1017746", "links": {}, "board_id": "1270", "body": "I don't think we will be out of a job soon :)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T05:14:43.986Z", "discussion_id": "609934", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017746", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T05:14:43.986Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 13, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "AI in Astronomy", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-06-26T22:56:47.534Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2488, "board_description": "A place for general chat", "board_discussions_count": 500, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 246, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198c248c0ef4255c3e9ec4c" }, "href": "/comments/1017797", "links": {}, "board_id": "1270", "body": "I hope not!", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T06:22:46.122Z", "discussion_id": "609934", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017797", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T06:22:46.122Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1392258", "user_login": "24l3s", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 13, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "AI in Astronomy", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-06-26T22:56:47.534Z", "discussion_users_count": 5, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 2488, "board_description": "A place for general chat", "board_discussions_count": 500, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 246, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "24l3s" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982b9" }, "href": "/comments/1017850", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "I spent some time on this, and got nowhere. Quasars are usually bright though.\n\n ", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T07:45:43.145Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017850", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T07:46:29.841Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982ba" }, "href": "/comments/1017872", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "The spectrum is quite faint. I would say blue star, except for that peak at 4800 Å\nNot a quasar, which should be low and bumpy at less than 4800 Å. I think I wouldn't spend time with such a weak spectrum. \n\nI think they are all blue stars.\n\n![Example Alt Text](http://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/SkyserverWS/ImgCutout/getjpeg?TaskName=Skyserver.Explore.Image&ra=359.900411538586&dec=5.75442808926545&scale=0.2&width=200&height=200&opt=G)\n\n![Example Alt Text](https://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/get/SpecById.ashx?id=4970993322073714688)\n\nThe interactive spectrum shows hardly any peaks.\nhttps://dr12.sdss.org/spectrumDetail?plateid=4415&mjd=55831&fiber=528\n\nhttps://skyserver.sdss.org/dr12/en/tools/explore/Summary.aspx?id=1237678778478100658", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T08:19:02.177Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017872", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T08:32:37.675Z", "upvotes": { "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1524564606" }, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982bb" }, "href": "/comments/1017949", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Thank you for taking a look at it. \n\nThe redshift of z=0.78 might explain the faintness.\n\nThe reason I know the first one is a quasar is because the only reason it is in SIMBAD is it is included in **The Sloan Digital Sky Survey quasar catalog: tenth data release.** which only contains certified quasars according to one of the first lines in the abstract; \n\n*We present the Data Release 10 Quasar (DR10Q) catalog from the Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS) of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey III. The catalog includes all BOSS objects that were targeted as quasar candidates during the first 2.5 years of the survey and that are confirmed as quasars via visual inspection of the spectra, have luminosities Mi[z=2]< -20.5 (in a ΛCDM cosmology with H0=70km/s/Mpc, ΩM=0.3, and ΩΛ=0.7), and either display at least one emission line with a full width at half maximum (FWHM) larger than 500km/s or, if not, have interesting/complex absorption features.*\n\nhttp://simbad.u-strasbg.fr/simbad/sim-id?Ident=%4010522397&Name=SDSS%20J235936.09%2b054515.9&submit=submit\n\nThe rest of the objects I got hits on and are look-a-likes.\n\n\n", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T10:15:56.853Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017949", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1017872", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T10:18:29.003Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982bc" }, "href": "/comments/1017967", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Over in Radio Galaxy Zoo, one fairly often finds that an SDSS STAR (photometric classification) is the (obvious) host of an (obvious) radio source, whether #compact, #triple, #hourglass, or ...\n\nSometimes, there's an SDSS spectrum, and if there is, it's nearly always/frequently a QSO. If there's no SDSS spectrum, sometimes NED gives a redshift, one that is too high for the SDSS object to be a galaxy.\n\nAnd sometimes, neither SDSS nor NED has a redshift. So I collect them: \"STAR but likely a QSO but don't know it\". It's a not small Collection.\n\nHope this helps, and happy hunting! :)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T11:00:06.865Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1017967", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": { "#compact": "compact", "#triple": "triple", "#hourglass": "hourglass" }, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T11:00:06.865Z", "upvotes": { "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1524573509" }, "user_id": "184", "user_login": "z62ev", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "z62ev" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198ca50c0ef4255c3eb058e" }, "href": "/comments/101803", "links": {}, "board_id": "329", "body": "This comment has been deleted", "category": null, "created_at": "2016-04-25T16:59:49.601Z", "discussion_id": "48615", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "101803", "is_deleted": true, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "1104", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-1104", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2016-05-13T04:30:36.398Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "3462", "user_login": "qm482", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 37, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "Abandoned thread", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-01-02T11:44:05.106Z", "discussion_users_count": 4, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": true, "board_comments_count": 2094, "board_description": "A place for general discussion about Gravity Spy or anything else you want to talk about", "board_discussions_count": 374, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Chat", "board_users_count": 185, "project_slug": "zooniverse/gravity-spy", "project_title": "Gravity Spy", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "qm482" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982bd" }, "href": "/comments/1018031", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "I’ve learned to ignore SDSS STAR/GALAXY classification alltogether.\n\nOne more hint these are all QSO’s is that they all jumped out because of the same SDSS RGB value + all look the same as the certified quasar.\n\nBut agreed there must be a lot anyway, the SDSS spectrum QSO catalogue alone contains many thousands.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T12:44:00.712Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1018031", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1017967", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T12:44:00.712Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 184, "reply_user_login": "z62ev", "reply_user_display_name": "z62ev", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982be" }, "href": "/comments/1018050", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "I have changed my mind, it is probably a quasar at z=2.0\nI looked at \nRedshift Gallery: Quasars http://classic.sdss.org/gallery/gal_zqso.html\n\nBut it does seem quite dim. Are quasars allowed to be dim?", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T13:13:57.122Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1018050", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T13:18:39.988Z", "upvotes": { "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1524582998" }, "user_id": "247", "user_login": "pbhh2", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "pbhh2", "userRoles": [ "team", "moderator" ] },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982bf" }, "href": "/comments/1018069", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "If you see \"SMALL_DELTA_CHI2\" in an SDSS spectrum, take a very close look at it. If it's ratty, chances are any redshift estimate will be, at best, uncertain. In the case of SDSS J235936.09+054515.9, zsp=3.1115 is clearly wrong ... the continuum is still going up at the blue end! Much more likely that the broad emission feature marked Ly-alpha is in fact MgII, which is consistent with a z of ~0.78.\n\n> I’ve learned to ignore SDSS STAR/GALAXY classification alltogether.\n\nWell, if the SDSS classification is GALAXY, it's very unlikely it is, in fact, a STAR (i.e. a point source); however, many STARs are, in fact, galaxies. You can be certain you've got a QSO only if you have a (good) spectrum.\n\n> One more hint these are all QSO’s is that they all jumped out because of the same SDSS RGB value + all look the same as the certified quasar.\n\nQuite a few searches for QSOs have been done with similar criteria, and there are several published catalogs of such (if I'm not mistaken).\n\nOne way to winnow out at least some imposters is to look at the WISE colors ... in a WISE color-color diagram (W1-W2 vs W2-W3?), QSOs live in a well-defined region, with very few imposters (of course, you'll also find QSOs outside that region, and not all objects you choose to look at will have good WISE magnitudes).\n\nHope this helps, and happy hunting! :)", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T13:28:30.260Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1018069", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T13:28:30.260Z", "upvotes": { "Ghost_Sheep_SWR": "1524583124" }, "user_id": "184", "user_login": "z62ev", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": null, "reply_user_login": null, "reply_user_display_name": null, "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "z62ev" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982c0" }, "href": "/comments/1018211", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "I thought the certified spectrum in SIMBAD /NED z=0.78 was reliable, but either way a QSO at z=0.78 or higher. I guess high redshift makes them look dim to us.", "category": null, "created_at": "2018-04-24T15:20:21.012Z", "discussion_id": "609817", "focus_id": "", "focus_type": null, "group_mentioning": {}, "id": "1018211", "is_deleted": false, "mentioning": {}, "project_id": "5733", "reply_id": "1018050", "section": "project-5733", "tagging": {}, "updated_at": "2018-04-24T15:20:21.012Z", "upvotes": {}, "user_id": "1373986", "user_login": "b1wlq", "versions": [], "reply_user_id": 247, "reply_user_login": "pbhh2", "reply_user_display_name": "pbhh2", "discussion_comments_count": 11, "discussion_subject_default": false, "discussion_title": "All QSO's?", "discussion_updated_at": "2018-04-24T17:56:46.656Z", "discussion_users_count": 3, "discussion_focus_id": "", "discussion_focus_type": null, "discussion_locked": false, "board_comments_count": 5508, "board_description": "A place to discuss the science behind the site, and inspired by the results", "board_discussions_count": 493, "board_parent_id": "", "board_subject_default": false, "board_title": "Science", "board_users_count": 195, "project_slug": "zookeeper/galaxy-zoo", "project_title": "Galaxy Zoo", "moderatable_actions": [], "user_display_name": "b1wlq" },{ "_id": { "$oid": "6198bddec0ef4255c3e982c1" }, "href": "/comments/1018215", "links": {}, "board_id": "1269", "body": "Ah yes I remember again, I’ve got a nice graph for that from BYW. Post it later.\n\nAnd also; whoops EDIT W1