species,abb,start_breeding_season_month,mass,eggs,incubation,specialization,migration,distance,latitude,longitude,study_site,food_shift,food_significant,food_shift_p,bird_shift,bird_significant,bird_shift_p,dif,reported_dif,dif_significant,dif_p,fitness,fitness_parameters_measured,period,years,absolute_shift,yardstick,method,event,measure,reference,temp_site,order American golden-plover,AGP,6,158,4,26,C,M,13000,71.3,-156.6,Utqiagvik,-0.84,<0.001,S,-0.31,0.201,NS,0.53,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,2006-2016,11,5.83,peak abundance,20% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,"Saalfeld and Lanctot, 2017",1.400053115,Charadriiformes Baird's sandpiper,BS,6,47.5,4,20,C,M,11500,69.6,-138.9,Herschel_Island,-0.21,0.26,NS,-0.52,<0.01,S,-0.31,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,"1984-1986, 2007-2009",24,0.96,arthropod emergance,50% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,Grabowski et al. 2013,0.333681702,Charadriiformes Bar-tailed godwit,BtG,5,370.5,4,20.5,C,M,9000,72.8,106,South-Eastern_Taimyr,-0.4,0.08,NS,-0.7,0.03,S,-0.3,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,1992-2016,25,-7.5,crane fly appearance,observation,egg-laying,all nests were included with year and date,Rakhimberdiev et al. 2018,1.691962667,Charadriiformes Blue tit,BT,4,11.1,10,14,C,R,0,65,25.5,Oulu,-0.86,0.032,S,0.153,0.41,NS,1.013,NA,NA,NA,NO,mean nestling mass per brood and number of fledged young,1998-2011,14,14.182,peak biomass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,median,Vatka et al. 2014,2.018580143,Passeriformes Blue tit,BT,4,11.1,10,14,C,R,0,52,5.75,Hoge_Veluwe,-0.75,0.0007,S,-0.48,0.002,S,0.27,0.26,0.093,NS,NA,NA,1985-2005,21,5.67,peak biomass,frass-fall method,hatching,mean,Both et al. 2009,0.674589313,Passeriformes Blue tit,BT,4,11.1,10,14,C,R,0,51.3,4.5,Antwerp,-0.55,significant,S,-0.52,<0.001,S,0.03,0.03,>0.5,NS,NO,"2nd brood, clutch size",1979-2007,29,0.87,peak biomass,"mean daily temperature, 8.03-17.05",fledging,mean,Matthysen et al. 2011,0.617476838,Passeriformes Canada goose,CG,5,4291,5.5,27,H,M,3000,53,-81.3,Akimiski_Island,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,0,0.08,0.85,NS,NA,NA,1993-2010,18,0,peak quality,NDVI,hatching,mean,Brook et a. 2015,1.396102038,Anseriformes Capercaillie,CA,4,2975,7.5,26,O,R,0,60.2,12.5,Varald_State_Forest,-0.129,NA,NA,-0.12,<0.001,S,0.009,NA,NA,NA,NA,Brood frequency (***) and brood size (NS),1979-2016,38,0.342,new bilberry shoots and leaves,"200GDD, 5 deg threshold",hatching,NA,Wegge and Rolstad 2017,0.362912211,Galliformes Coal tit,CT,3,9.6,9,15,O,R,0,52,5.75,Hoge_Veluwe,-0.75,0.0007,S,-0.36,0.06,NS,0.39,0.39,0.018,S,NA,NA,1985-2005,21,8.19,peak biomass,frass-fall method,hatching,mean,Both et al. 2009,0.808174612,Passeriformes Collared flycatcher,CF,5,12,6,13,C,M,7000,48.7,16.9,Lanzhot,-0.19,<0.001,S,-0.2,<0.001,S,0.01,NA,NA,NA,NO,mortality of chicks,1961-2007,47,0.47,end of frass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,mean,Bauer et al. 2010,0.356278222,Passeriformes Collared flycatcher,CF,5,12,6,13,C,M,7000,48.8,16.8,Lednice,-0.19,<0.001,S,-0.19,<0.001,S,0,NA,NA,NA,NO,mortality of chicks,1961-2007,47,0,end of frass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,mean,Bauer et al. 2010,0.361789753,Passeriformes Collared flycatcher,CF,5,12,6,13,C,M,7000,48.9,16.6,Vranovice,-0.21,<0.001,S,-0.19,<0.001,S,0.02,NA,NA,NA,NO,mortality of chicks,1961-2007,47,-0.47,end of frass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,mean,Bauer et al. 2010,0.364676172,Passeriformes Dunlin,DU,6,59,4,22,C,M,5000,71.3,-156.6,Utqiagvik,-0.84,<0.001,S,-0.13,0.05,S,0.71,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,2003-2016,14,9.94,peak abundance,20% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,"Saalfeld and Lanctot, 2017",0.830401715,Charadriiformes Eurasian black grouse,BlG,5,1050,8,26,O,R,0,60.2,12.5,Varald_State_Forest,-0.129,NA,NA,-0.12,<0.001,S,0.009,NA,NA,NA,NA,Brood frequency (NS) and brood size (NS),1979-2016,38,0.342,new bilberry shoots and leaves,"200GDD, 5 deg threshold",hatching,NA,Wegge and Rolstad 2017,0.375138435,Galliformes Great tit,GT,3,17,8.5,13.5,C,R,0,65,25.5,Oulu,-0.86,0.032,S,-0.335,0.005,S,0.525,NA,NA,NA,NO,mean nestling mass per brood and number of fledged young,1996-2011,16,8.4,peak biomass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,median,Vatka et al. 2014,1.65039681,Passeriformes Great tit,GT,3,17,8.5,13.5,C,R,0,52,5.75,Hoge_Veluwe,-0.75,0.0007,S,-0.36,0.014,S,0.39,0.38,0.038,S,NA,NA,1985-2005,21,8.19,peak biomass,frass-fall method,hatching,mean,Both et al. 2009,0.808174612,Passeriformes Great tit,GT,3,17,8.5,13.5,C,R,0,51.3,4.5,Antwerp,-0.55,significant,S,-0.5,<0.001,S,0.05,0.03,>0.5,NS,NO,"2nd brood, clutch size",1979-2007,29,1.45,peak biomass,"mean daily temperature, 8.03-17.05",fledging,mean,Matthysen et al. 2011,0.714922088,Passeriformes Great tit,GT,3,17,8.5,13.5,C,R,0,51.8,-1.3,Wytham,-0.326,<0.0001,S,-0.298,<0.0001,S,0.028,not shown,not significant,NS,NO,"population size, mean recrutment success of birds",1961-2007,47,1.316,peak biomass,half-fall date,egg-laying,mean,"Charmantier et al. 2008, Visser et al. 2012",0.309231486,Passeriformes Great tit,GT,3,17,8.5,13.5,C,R,0,48.8,16.8,Lednice,-0.19,<0.001,S,-0.17,<0.01,S,0.02,NA,NA,NA,NO,mortality of chicks,1961-2007,47,-0.94,end of frass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,mean,Bauer et al. 2010,0.264607039,Passeriformes Great tit,GT,3,17,8.5,13.5,C,R,0,48.7,16.9,Lanzhot,-0.19,<0.001,S,-0.15,<0.01,S,0.04,NA,NA,NA,NO,mortality of chicks,1961-2007,47,-1.88,end of frass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,mean,Bauer et al. 2010,0.259295543,Passeriformes Great tit,GT,3,17,8.5,13.5,C,R,0,48.9,16.6,Vranovice,-0.21,<0.001,S,-0.15,<0.01,S,0.06,NA,NA,NA,NO,mortality of chicks,1961-2007,47,-2.35,end of frass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,mean,Bauer et al. 2010,0.267184018,Passeriformes Greater snow goose,SG,6,2900,4.5,24,H,M,5000,73.2,-80,Bylot_Island,-0.089,0.764,NS,0.046,0.651,NS,0.135,NA,NA,NA,NA,"clutch size, nesting success and ratio of young to adults",1989-2012,24,3.24,peak quality,NDVI,egg-laying,mean,Gauthier et al. 2013,1.626115901,Anseriformes Lapland longspur,LL,5,28.75,5,11.75,C,M,4500,69.6,-138.9,Herschel_Island,-0.21,0.26,NS,-0.304,0.1,NS,-0.094,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,"1984-1986, 2007-2009",24,6,arthropod emergance,50% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,Grabowski et al. 2013,0.83584299,Passeriformes Lesser snow goose,SG,6,2900,4.5,24,H,M,4000,67.2,-100.25,Karrak_Lake,-0.337,significant,S,0.035,not significant,NS,0.372,0.326 (for both species in the study),significant,S,YES-,"gosling/adult proportions, goosling size, goosling survival probability",1992-2014,23,8.556,peak quality,NDVI,hatching,mean,"Ross et al. 2017, 2018",0.190112131,Anseriformes Long-billed dowitcher,DO,5,112.5,4,20.5,C,M,6000,71.3,-156.6,Utqiagvik,-0.84,<0.001,S,-0.27,0.03,S,0.57,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,2006-2016,11,6.27,peak abundance,20% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,"Saalfeld and Lanctot, 2017",2.198929336,Charadriiformes Pectoral sandpiper,PS,6,74.75,4,22,C,M,13500,71.3,-156.6,Utqiagvik,-0.84,<0.001,S,-0.5,<0.001,S,0.34,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,2003-2016,14,4.76,peak abundance,20% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,"Saalfeld and Lanctot, 2017",0.830401715,Charadriiformes Pied flycatcher,PF,4,12,6,14,C,M,5500,52,5.75,Hoge_Veluwe,-0.87,NA,NA,-0.3,<0.001,S,0.57,NA,NA,NA,YES-,NA,1973-2010,28,15.96,peak biomass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,mean,Visser et al 2012 (review),0.905506339,Passeriformes Red phalarope,ReP,6,55,4,19,C,M,13000,71.3,-156.6,Utqiagvik,-0.84,NA,NA,-0.34,NA,NA,0.5,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,2003-2016,14,7,peak abundance,20% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,"Saalfeld and Lanctot, 2017",0.830401715,Charadriiformes Red-necked phalarope,RnP,6,34,4,19,C,M,11000,71.3,-156.6,Utqiagvik,-0.84,<0.001,S,-0.01,0.964,NS,0.83,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,2006-2016,11,9.13,peak abundance,20% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,"Saalfeld and Lanctot, 2017",1.400053115,Charadriiformes Rhinoceros auklet,RA,5,533,1,35,C,R,0,44.4,141.3,Teuri_Island,-1.1,significant,S,0.36,significant,S,1.46,NA,NA,NA,YES-,"growth, survival and fledging mass","1984, 1985, 1987, 1992-2006",23,33.58,prey switch,observation of food load,hatching,NA,Watanuki et al. 2009,-0.055501782,Charadriiformes Ross's goose,RG,6,1428.5,4.5,21.5,H,M,4000,67.2,-100.25,Karrak_Lake,-0.337,significant,S,0.024,not significant,NS,0.361,0.326 (for both species in the study),significant,S,YES-,"gosling/adult proportions, goosling size, goosling survival probability",1992-2014,23,8.303,peak quality,NDVI,hatching,mean,"Ross et al. 2017, 2018",0.190112131,Anseriformes Sanderling,SA,6,71.5,4,28,C,M,8500,74.5,-20.6,Zackenberg,-1.27,0.0004,S,-0.23,0.24,NS,1.07,NA,NA,NA,NO,chicks growth,1996-2013,18,22.86,peak abundance,pitfall traps,hatching,mean,Reneerkens et al. 2016,0.974417189,Charadriiformes Semipalmated sandpiper,SS,6,30.5,4,21,C,M,10000,71.3,-156.6,Utqiagvik,-0.84,<0.001,S,-0.24,0.036,S,0.6,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,2003-2016,14,8.4,peak abundance,20% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,"Saalfeld and Lanctot, 2017",0.830401715,Charadriiformes Semipalmated sandpiper,SS,6,30.5,4,21,C,M,9500,69.6,-138.9,Herschel_Island,-0.21,0.26,NS,-0.261,0.49,NS,-0.051,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,"1984-1986, 2007-2009",24,6.96,arthropod emergance,50% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,Grabowski et al. 2013,0.333681702,Charadriiformes Snow bunting,SB,6,37,5,12.5,O,M,3000,69.6,-138.9,Herschel_Island,-0.21,0.26,NS,-0.478,0.27,NS,-0.268,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,"1984-1986, 2007-2009",24,1.92,arthropod emergance,50% snow cover,egg-laying,mean,Grabowski et al. 2013,0.333681702,Passeriformes Sparrowhawk,SP,4,153,4.5,33,C,R,0,52,5.75,Hoge_Veluwe,-0.42,<0.001,S,0.09,0.46,NS,0.51,0.49,0.007,S,NA,NA,1985-2004,20,10.2,peak biomass,fleging biomass based on hatching date,hatching,mean,Both et al. 2009,0.760966465,Accipitriformes Sparrowhawk,SP,4,153,4.5,33,C,R,0,57.5,10.2,Sindal_and_Hjorring,-0.4,<0.05,S,-0.05,0.34,NS,0.33,NA,NA,NA,NA,NA,1977-1997,21,6.93,availablity of food,mean fledging date,mean fleding date,mean,Nielsen and Moller 2006,0.390776363,Accipitriformes Thick-billed murre,TM,6,945,1,32.5,C,M,2000,62.5,-83.4,Coats_Island,-0.895,NA,NA,-0.265,NA,NA,0.63,NA,NA,NA,YES-,nestlings growth rate,1988-2007,20,12.06,"seasonality change, food peak","50% ice cover, date of peak attendance",hatching,mean,Gaston et al. 2009,1.395570496,Charadriiformes Willow tit,WT,4,11.5,7,14,O,R,0,65,25.5,Oulu,-1.02,0.05,S,-0.24,0.217,NS,0.78,NA,NA,NA,YES+,"nestling survival rate, mean nestling weight per brood",1996-2009,14,10.92,peak biomass,frass-fall method,egg-laying,median,Vatka et al. 2011,1.939170442,Passeriformes Wood warbler,WW,5,10.7,6,13,C,M,6000,52.2,-3.5,Carmarthenshire_and_Powys,-0.41,0.055 (comparison of two periods),NS,-0.33,0.008 (comparison of two periods),S,0.08,0.26,0.046,S,YES-,"clutch size, brood size, nestling weights, fledging success","1982-1984, 2009-2011",30,8.7,peak biomass,water traps,egg-laying,NA,Mallord et al. 2016,0.110203612,Passeriformes