INTERNATIONAL LABOUR OFFICE ... ; I ^ Ä * i A ••.-'• LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN Report of a Mission of the International Labour Office (January-February 1950) Prepared for the Information of the Petroleum Committee of the International Labour Organisation GENEVA 1950 S T U D I E S A N D REPORTS New Series, No. 24 P U B L I S H E D BY T H E I N T E R N A T I O N A L L A B O U R O F F I C E GENEVA, SWITZERLAND Published in the United Kingdom for the INTERNATIONAL by Staples Press Limited, London LABOUR OFFICE PRINTED BY "IMPRIMERIE CENTRALE". LAUSANNE. SWITZERLAND CONTENTS Page INTRODUCTION CHAPTER I : The Oil Areas The Abadan Area The Oilfields Rapidity of the Industry's Growth CHAPTER I I : The Labour Force Composition Characteristics CHAPTER III : Recruitment and Training Recruitment Training Abadan Fields Training Iranians in the United Kingdom CHAPTER IV : Conditions of Work Engagement and Contract of Employment Wage System Wage Increments and Promotion Wages and Prices Allowances Hours of Work Holidays with Pay Termination of Employment Disciplinary Code Turnover Social Insurance Safety Contract Labour CHAPTER V : Housing 1 5 5 7 8 10 11 12 14 14 16 16 19 19 20 20 21 21 23 23 23 24 24 24 24 25 26 28 31 Housing in Abadan Housing in the Oilfields 31 35 CHAPTER VI : Social Services 36 Distribution of Food, Clothing and Other Supplies Organisation of the Scheme Works Canteens Stores, Restaurants and Laundry for Staff Employees Company Agricultural Development Schemes Health Services Curative Services in Abadan 36 37 38 38 39 39 40 IV CONTENTS Page Curative Services in the Oilfields Problems concerning Medical Services School Medical Service Preventive Medical Services Primary and Secondary Education Education for Adult Workers Transport Recreation 40 41 42 42 42 44 44 45 CHAPTER VII : The Trade Union Situation The Trade Union Movement Legal Position of Trade Unions Oil Workers' Unions Trade Union Activity Handicaps to Trade Union Development 46 46 48 49 50 52 CHAPTER VIII : Labour-Management Relations Joint Departmental Committees Provisions of the Labour Law Factory Councils Settlement of Disputes High Labour Council Summary 54 54 55 56 57 59 60 CHAPTER IX : The Wider Scene The Country and its People Living Conditions Iranian Industry Labour Protection The Country's Needs 62 62 63 65 67 68 CHAPTER X : Conclusions Recruitment Training Wages and Prices Hours of Work Working Conditions Social Insurance Safety Contract Labour Housing Distribution of Commodities Health Services Education Trade Unions Labour-Management Relations General Observations 70 71 72 72 73 73 74 74 75 76 77 78 79 79 81 83 INTRODUCTION In November 1948 the Iranian Government, through its delegation at the second session of the I.L.O. Petroleum Committee, invited the International Labour Office to send a Mission to south Iran with a view to preparing a report giving an objective picture of social conditions in the oil industry and, if necessary, to framing recommendations which the Iranian Government might take into account in giving effect to the resolutions adopted by the Petroleum Committee. The invitation was noted by the Governing Body of the I.L.O. at its 107th Session (Geneva, December 1948) and the DirectorGeneral appointed as members of the Mission the following officials of the International Labour Office : Mr. John Price (Chief of the Industrial Committees Section)—Head of the Mission ; Mr. P. P. Fano (member of the Industrial Committees Section) ; and Mr. A. Djamalzadeh (member of the Conditions of Work Section), who also acted as interpreter. The Mission left Geneva for Abadan on 9 January 1950. From 11 to 31 January the Mission studied conditions at the refinery in Abadan and at the oilfields of Masjid-i-Sulaiman and Agha Jari and also paid a visit to Ahwaz, the capital of the province of Khuzistan. Subsequently it spent a few days in Isfahan visiting textile factories and other plants, and went on to Teheran, where it discussed the problems of the oil industry with representatives of the Government departments concerned and in the meantime visited other industrial undertakings. In Teheran the Mission was received by H.I.M. the Shah, by Prince Abdul Reza, who is in charge of the seven-year plan for the economic development of Iran, by the Prime Minister, Mr. Saed, and by the Minister of Finance, Mr. Golshayan. During the last week of its journey, the Mission spent three days in Iraq at the invitation of the Government of Iraq, discussed conditions in the oil industry with Government representatives and representatives of the oil companies in Baghdad, paid visits to two of the local factories and visited the installations of the Iraq Petroleum Company at Kirkuk. The Mission was received in Baghdad by the Minister of Economics, Mr. Ihsan Rifat, and the Minister of Social Affairs, Mr. Tewfik Wahbi. The Mission returned to Geneva on 18 February 1950. 2 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN While in Iran the Mission examined the various problems of the petroleum industry under the headings (a) conditions of work, (b) social, community and welfare services, and (c) industrial relations. Under the first heading it enquired into recruitment, training, wages, hours of work, rest periods and holidays with pay, procedure for severance of employment, social insurance schemes, safety and the position of contract labour. Under the second heading it examined the problems of housing, food supplies, health services, education, transport services and recreation facilities. Finally, under the third heading, the Mission enquired into the legal and de facto conditions of trade union organisation in the country and the development of trade unionism and labourmanagement relations in the oil industry. The Mission was able to visit all the parts of the installations of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company which had any significance for its study and to examine the various services provided by the Company and the public authorities for the benefit of the oil workers and their families. The Mission is glad to say that it was given every facility for making its enquiries. Wherever it went the Mission made an effort to consult all the parties concerned, and to give them an opportunity to explain all the problems in which they were interested and to express their points of view separately. Thus the Mission paid several visits to the Abadan refinery accompanied by officials of the Company and a separate visit with the representatives of the trade unions of workers in Khuzistan. Similarly, the residential quarters in Abadan were visited both with officials of the Company and separately with representatives of the oil workers. The Mission was conducted through the municipal districts of the town by the municipal authorities, headed by the Mayor. The Mission paid visits to the Government labour offices at Abadan, Masjid-i-Sulaiman, Agha Jari, Ahwaz and Isfahan, and had numerous discussions with representatives of Government departments in Teheran, Abadan and the oilfields. In Teheran the Mission visited the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Labour and the offices of the organisation for the seven-year plan. The Mission met the general manager of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company at Abadan, the general refinery manager, the general manager of " Fields ", the chief industrial adviser to the Company and numerous officials of the Company who are in charge of different services. Careful consideration was given to the views of the unions of oil workers in Abadan and the oilfields. In all instances the representatives of the unions were given an opportunity to express themselves freely to INTRODUCTION 3 the Mission and were invited to submit a memorandum concerning the questions which they wished the Mission to bear particularly in mind. The opinions of individual unorganised workers on the problems under consideration were always elicited wherever an opportunity arose. The Mission felt that in order to form a fair opinion of the conditions obtaining in the oil industry it was essential to consider these conditions in the light of the general standard of living of the country as a whole and, more especially, from the point of view of the level attained in other modern industrial undertakings in Iran. It was with this end in view that the Mission visited textile mills and other plants at Ahwaz and Isfahan and a number of Government-owned and private industrial concerns at Teheran, including cement works, a tobacco factory, glass works and chemical works. Questions concerning conditions of employment and the state of trade union organisation in the country as a whole were discussed with representatives of the Federation of Trade Unions of Iranian Workers (E.S.K.I.) and of the Central Council of Unions of Workers and Peasants (E.M.K.A.) during the visits which the Mission paid to their offices at Isfahan and Teheran. Conversations on similar subjects were also held with individual private employers and with the general secretary of the Employers' Industrial Council of Iran. The Mission was invited to attend a meeting of the High Labour Council at Teheran, at which it met representatives of the various Government departments and the representatives of the employers and workers. The Mission wishes to express its gratitude to H.I.M. the Shah and to the members of his Government for the personal interest which they took in its work. The Mission is also greatly obliged to the representatives of the Government departments, to the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company and to the trade unions for the trouble they took to provide both information and comment. It wishes to mention in particular the great assistance it received during its stay in Iran from Dr. Naficy, UnderSecretary of State of the Ministry of Labour, Dr. Jalali, Director-General of the Ministry of Labour, and Mr. Naghavi, the representative of the Ministry of Finance in Abadan. It may be useful to mention here that, as is well known, there have been differences of opinion between the Iranian Government and the Company for some time past concerning certain questions arising out of the Concession. During its stay in Iran the Mission observed that these questions were mainly of an economic and financial nature. The Mission was concerned primarily, however, with working and living 4 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN conditions in the petroleum industry and it did not find it possible to go into the questions mentioned above. The Mission nevertheless recognises the importance of these questions for the petroleum workers and the Iranian people in general, and it hopes that they will be solved as soon as possible to the satisfaction of all concerned. f t t r ¡3 s ^ y ^ » ( d -¿ % ? < s A . y/.V......•&« CHAPTER I THE OIL AREAS The operations of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company in south-west Iran are carried on partly in Abadan, at the head of the Persian Gulf, and partly in the foot-hills of the Zagros Mountains, over a hundred miles away. Between the refinery at Abadan and the oilfields in the foot-hills lies the desert. THE ABADAN AREA Abadan and its refinery stand on Abadan Island, which is flanked on one side by the Bahmanshir river and on the other by the Shatt-el-Arab —a combination of the Tigris, Euphrates and Karun rivers. The oil from the wells is brought to the refinery through pipelines which cross the desert from the various producing fields and converge upon the refinery area. Oil was found in commercial quantities in 1908, though the original Concession dated from 1901. It was in 1911 that the first pipeline to the selected site for the refinery at Abadan was completed. The annual capacity of this pipeline was 400,000 tons, whereas the amount now being piped to Abadan per annum is 24,000,000 tons. When prospecting started in the early days of the century the whole area was mostly uninhabited. There was a scattered nomadic population in the hills and around the Gulf, but there was hardly any cultivation, and the land was largely waste. Abadan Island itself, like the adjacent districts, was a desert, broken only by a fringe of date palms near the river. The early refinery was completed in 1912. Since then, during a period of less than 40 years, Abadan has grown from a tiny village to a town with a population which is estimated at 173,000 and which may be as high as 200,000. Such a rapid growth would have raised serious problems in any country; in Iran the problems were particularly acute. The absence of agriculture meant that practically all food had to be brought from long distances. Machinery, equipment, and construction materials had likewise to be imported. There were no other industries in the area, no 6 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN centres of population and therefore no public services, such as water supply, lighting and drainage. There was no railway, the roads were tracks, and transport was a matter for camels, donkeys and river craft. In spite of these natural handicaps the refinery at Abadan has become the largest in the world, and the inhabited area around the plant has extended over a great part of the island. In addition to the usual features the refinery possesses its own power station, which also provides current for lighting and heating the residential areas, an ice plant which supplies ice for the canteens, restaurants, offices and houses, and a pumping station through which more water is pumped daily than is used by the population of London. The residential areas comprise not only houses and quarters of various types, but also shops and stores, schools and cinemas, clinics and a hospital. Sports grounds, swimming pools and clubs have been provided, and a bus service has been organised. Outside the Company's area is a growing municipality, with houses, shops and a bazaar. The housing in this town is mainly of the oldfashioned and primitive type, and the area is seriously overcrowded. The town is, however, being extended and new houses are being built. The Company is assisting in the building of some of the houses as well as of schools and clinics. It also supplies the town's water and electricity. In the Abadan area the inhabitants are mainly Arabs from the surrounding districts and from the region of the Persian Gulf, together with tribesmen—mostly Bakhtiari—from the hill country of Khuzistan. Few of these had had any previous experience of industry or had lived a settled life in towns. Most of them had lived in mountain or desert villages, and many had been accustomed to migrate from place to place according to the season. The number of inhabitants who moved in from other industries or from towns and cities was very small. A few came down from Isfahan and even from Teheran, but these were exceptions. The foreign population of Abadan is a small percentage of the whole, since it consists in the main of about 3,000 European and Indian employees of the Company, with their families. Life is extremely difficult in this part of Iran because of the great heat in summer, the low rainfall and the absence of vegetation. The Abadan area is surrounded by a desert, not of sand but of salty earth. The only trees to be seen in this region, apart from those planted in Abadan itself, are the date palms which grow in a narrow belt along the banks of the rivers. The oppressive summer heat necessitates the provision of fans, air coolers and supplies of ice and raises serious problems of house construction. Nothing grows in the desert, except THE OIL AREAS 7 in small and widely separated patches where the water and soil happen to be sweet. In such places grain and vegetables are grown. It is, however, possible to produce crops by irrigation, though the process of sweetening the soil is slow and costly. Near Abadan and at Khosrowabad the Company has flooded, drained and sweetened certain areas and has succeeded in producing substantial quantities of vegetables. These areas are crossed by irrigation ditches, which are supplied with fresh water pumped from the nearby rivers. In Abadan itself the Company has laid out gardens and planted imported trees along the roads. THE OILFIELDS In the oilfield areas—known as " Fields "—the situation is similar in some respects but more favourable in others. The oilfields are in various stages of development and therefore present different problems in regard to employment, housing, and the organisation of community services. In some parts of the area wells are being drilled and the size and shape of the field are still unknown, whereas in other parts the field has been fully explored and has settled down to steady production. The oilfields are over 100 miles from Abadan. The oil is found in the hills on the side nearest the plain which extends from the Zagros range to the coast. Like the plain itself, the hills are arid and bare. There are no trees to be seen and no vegetation, except in spring, when the slopes are thick with grass and flowers. Wheat is, however, grown in sufficient quantity by the local population, who also rear their own cattle. The oldest field is at Masjid-i-Sulaiman, where the first oil was struck in large quantities in 1908. This proved to be a large and important field and it subsequently became the headquarters for the whole of the Fields area. Other important oilfields are to the north of Masjidi-Sulaiman at Lali, and to the south at Naft Safid (White Oil Springs), Haft Kel and Agha Jari. The industrial and residential development of Masjid-i-Sulaiman extends over a period of some 40 years, during which the community has had time to settle down, but in the newer fields the problems of labour supply, housing and the provision of community services have to be taken in hand from the beginning. Agha Jari, which came into production during the war, is still being explored and developed, but it already produces more than Masjid-i-Sulaiman. The field at Lali is even newer and may turn out to be more important than Agha Jari. These areas obviously have many of their community problems still before them. One of the most pressing of these problems is the provision of living accommodation, but it is not possible to solve 8 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN this problem completely until the extent and importance of the field are known. In Agha Jari, for example, a residential and administrative centre was chosen in what was thought to be the most advantageous position, but subsequent drilling showed that the field ran in quite a different direction and that the projected " centre " was, in fact, near the end of the field, which extends for 28 miles. Throughout the Fields area there was an absence of communications and public services until the Company started its operations. Roads have been made by the Company to hnk together the various producing centres and to connect Fields with Abadan and with Ahwaz, the capital of the province. Ahwaz is on the Iranian State Railway and is the only place from which there is a rail connection. The railway runs north to Teheran but does not extend south to Abadan. All transport between Abadan and Fields is carried on by road or by the Company's aeroplanes. As in the case of Abadan, there were no industrial or urban centres in what is now the Fields area. Accordingly, in addition to making roads, the Company has had to pump drinking water from the rivers and to generate electricity for lighting and heating. It has also built houses and schools, clinics and a hospital. Throughout the area there are villages in the hills which are inhabited by men of the Bakhtiari tribe, large numbers of whom now work for the Company. The houses in the villages are usually made of baked mud, and they frequently provide shelter not only for the family but also for animals. It is still customary for the Bakhtiari to follow their flocks to the grass as the seasons change, and many of the tribesmen who come to the oilfields from a distance return after a period to their villages and to their traditional life. It is commonly remarked in the petroleum industry that many of the industry's labour and social problems arise from the conditions under which the oil is found. This is well exemplified by the experience of the oil industry of south Iran, where some of the industry's greatest difficulties are due to the conditions prevailing in the area; but, as will be seen in other parts of this report, these difficulties have been seriously aggravated by the rapidity with which the industry has grown. RAPIDITY OF THE INDUSTRY'S GROWTH An indication of the rapidity of growth is given in the following figures which have been published by the Company. There were two periods of expansion during and after the first world war, and by 1937 the annual production reached 10,000,000 tons for the first time. When 9 THE OIL AREAS the second world war began, production fell from 9,583,000 tons in 1939 to 8,626,000 in 1940 and to 6,605,000 in 1941. But from then onwards very heavy demands were made upon Abadan for the war effort. In 1942 a large construction programme was undertaken, and the production figure rose to 13,274,000 tons in 1944, 17,000,000 in 1945 and 19,100,000 in 1946. x The total employment figures (salaried employees and wage earners) in Abadan rose from 12,076 at the beginning of 1935 to 22,813 at the beginning of 1939, while in Fields they rose from 4,907 to 8,689 in the same period. During the three following years the figures fell as follows (number at the beginning of each year) : 1940 1941 1942 Abadan Fields 18,304 16,421 17,175 7,819 4,954 4,638 Subsequently, as will be seen below, the figures rose again. 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 1948 1949 1 Abadan Fields 26,157 26,448 32,775 33,241 33,660 36,412 38,812 5,088 5,516 9,499 12,809 12,728 13,981 17,158x Figures supplied by the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company. Clearly a rate of expansion involving the addition of so many workers and their families to the population of such an area was bound to leave a legacy of difficult social problems. 2 1 A Short History of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company, published by the AngloIranian Oil Company, London, 1948. 2 The Company also has a small field at Naft-i-Shah in north-western Iran. This field is connected by a pipeline with a refinery at Kermanshah, where petroleum products for the north and north-west of Iran are refined. The Mission was not asked to visit these installations, but it made enquiries about conditions in these areas while in Iran and was informed that the labour and social problems which arise at Naft-iShah and Kermanshah are on a smaller scale and much less acute than those to be faced in Abadan and Fields. CHAPTER II THE LABOUR FORCE While some of the problems of the industry arise from the nature of the area in which the oil is found, others are due to the composition and characteristics of the industry's labour force. It will have been seen from the last chapter that the main sources of labour supply for the petroleum industry in south Iran are the Persian Gulf, with the surrounding deserts, and the hill country of Khuzistan. The workers drawn from these areas were mainly desert Arabs and Bakhtiari tribesmen, who had no industrial background and who for the most part had no experience even of small-scale handicrafts. Their economy was pastoral, their organisation tribal, and their life for generations had been lived in small villages and tents with the simplest food and only the barest necessities. Such men were quite unused to the ways of industry and were at first completely unskilled. A petroleum industry, however, while requiring unskilled workers, is also in need of large numbers of men with a great variety of skill, both in the producing fields and in the refineries. Since skilled labour was not available on the spot, the Company had to make use of a certain number of artisans from other countries, such as India, in addition to the European specialists who were brought in as engineers, chemists and administrators. It was evident that this could not be a long-term solution, but only a response to an immediate need. Accordingly, because of the composition and characteristics of the available labour force, the Company has had to give close attention to the question of training, coupled with the problems of upgrading and promotion. It has also been faced with a connected problem—that of increasing the proportion of Iranians in its employ during a period when increases were taking place in the labour force as a whole. These problems have been the more difficult because the situation of the area and the prevailing conditions discourage many of the better qualified workers, technicians and supervisory personnel from taking up jobs in the petroleum industry. Iran is a country of great distances and inadequate communications, and Abadan and Fields are far removed from other cities and centres of industry. Moreover, the climate of THE LABOUR FORCE 11 south Iran is extremely trying in summer, much more so than on the central plateau or in the north. Accordingly, artisans with jobs and homes in other parts of the country are not attracted in any numbers to Abadan. Similarly, people with qualifications for clerical, administrative, technical and supervisory duties usually find that life in, say, Teheran or Isfahan has more attractions than life in the south. These circumstances increase the difficulty of obtaining qualified workers and of keeping them once they have had experience of the conditions of the area. COMPOSITION By far the greater proportion of the workers in Abadan and Fields are classed as "labour", a term which includes large numbers of unskilled workers and also apprentices, trainees, skilled workers and artisans. Such " labour " is employed in oil production, refinery operations, maintenance work, pipeline operations, construction work, transport services, oil loading at the jetties, cargo handling and a host of other jobs in the industrial and residential areas. In addition, there are salaried employees—technical, commercial and senior—including supervisory personnel, foremen and office staffs. The " labour ", i.e., the wage-earning employees, accounted for 33,000 out of a total employment figure of 38,000 in Abadan at the beginning of 1949, and for 15,000 out of 17,000 in Fields on the same date. In Abadan all the trainees and apprentices, all the unskilled workers and all the skilled workers (except nine out of a total of 9,500) were Iranians. Of the 9,700 artisans, nine out of 10 were Iranians, while out of 5,800 salaried employees the number of Iranians was 3,300. In Fields the only foreigners in the wageearning categories were among the artisans (184 out of 3,465), while the number of Iranian salaried employees was 975 out of a total of 1,830. Fortunately, the employment of women and children in the industry does not constitute a serious problem. Very little juvenile labour is employed. The Labour Law forbids the employment of children under 12, but the Company does not accept children under 14. The majority of the Company's employees under 18 are apprentices and trainees. Women are employed in small numbers but not on the industrial side. Out of 783 women employed in Abadan and Fields in 1949 there were 63 non-Iranian salaried employees in the medical services and 449 Iranian salaried employees in the medical services and on commercial work. There were also 271 Iranian women wage earners, of whom about half were learner clerks and the remainder chiefly sanitary and laundry workers. In addition to the Company's own labour there are some thousands of workers employed by contractors who carry out jobs for the Company. 12 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN These workers are engaged on plant construction, pipeline laying, road making, drainage and sewerage work, and building operations in the residential areas. The number of these workers varies with the work to be done, and their employment is for the most part casual. The Company keeps a certain number of construction men on its own books, but the contractors' men are not regarded as employees of the Company. Their work is, nevertheless, necessary for the maintenance and development of the Company's operations and their problems have to be taken into account in any study of conditions in the area. CHARACTERISTICS As already indicated, few of those who seek employment at Abadan and Fields have any industrial background or skill in the use of tools. The dress of a typical worker at Abadan or Fields is a compromise between European clothes and Arab or Bakhtiari dress, just as bis Ufe is a compromise between that of large-scale modern industry and that of the mountain or the desert, between the new ideas of the West and the old traditions of the East. He may wear the coloured headcloth of the Arab with a blue boiler suit, or the wide black trousers of the Bakhtiari with a European jacket. He may have leather shoes or rubber boots, but he is more likely to walk about in " ghivers "—white canvas-topped shoes which slip on without straps or laces. It is evident that his habits of thought and beha viour are those of the pastoral tribe rather than of the industrial proletariat. The man whose forbears were nomads, whose needs were easily satisfied and who paid little regard to the passage of time, does not take easily to factory hours, methods or discipline. If he was an artisan in the town bazaar he did his work sitting or kneeling on the ground and not standing at a bench. He did not work to exact measurements but made his copper pots, his brass trays or his wrought iron articles in traditional shapes and sizes by rule of thumb. He could not read a blueprint because he could not read at all. As a consequence of this, practically all the skilled workers and artisans have to be trained by the Company, and training has also to be given even for some of the simpler jobs. The Company's training methods and programmes have had to begin with the most elementary stages. Both in apprentice training and in the training of adult workers attention has had to be given to primary education as well as to the theory and practice of metal working. Before a man can become a mechanic he must be able to use a ruler and to read thefigureson gauges, but at the beginning nine workers out of 10 were completely illiterate. It was therefore necessary to teach them reading and writing in their ./- •• î^^*"-; <t.-t¿Yur™t Views of Abadan A . Drilling crew at work, S.W. Iran Part of refinery, Abadan THE LABOUR FORCE 13 own language and to give them the rudiments of English, at the very least. Even now trainees can be seen in the plant studying their own language and at the same time learning to measure in fractions of an inch, to read the Fahrenheit scale and to recognise such words as " hammer ", " file ", " distillation ", " superfractionator ", " power station" and "pipeline". The prevailing illiteracy has also had its effects on the recruitment of clerks and typists, with the result that arrangements have been made for the employment of " learner clerks " and "commercial trainees". In view of the circumstances outlined above, it is not surprising to find that there is a relatively high turnover of labour in the industry. It is true that large numbers of men have settled down in Abadan and Fields, and that many have been with the Company for periods of 10, 15 and 20 years; but the majority do not yet regard themselves as oil workers or consider the area as their permanent home. The influence of tradition and the call of the tribe are strong; it is therefore quite usual for men to migrate to the hills or to the Gulf from time to time and to return to the industry after an interval. Many of the men, indeed, regard their work in the industry as temporary, since they eventually expect to go back to their native villages and to resume their pastoral way of fife. Another aspect of this problem is that, because of the shortage of skilled labour throughout Iran and of the unpleasant climatic conditions in the south, men who have been trained, or even only partially trained, by the Company as mechanics and motor drivers are easily attracted to other jobs in the area or to other parts of the country. Enough has already been said in these pages to illustrate the kinds of problem which arise from the composition and characteristics of the industry's labour force. Attention may, however, be drawn to one other group of problems of particular importance—those relating to trade unionism, collective bargaining and industrial relations. Because of the nature of the labour force, these are matters of unusual difficulty. Trade unionism and collective bargaining are conceptions which came from the West and which until recently found no place in the thoughts and activities of the workers of Iran. Relations between employers and workers likewise constitute a new problem. When the employer is no longer a master craftsman or merchant who works alongside his men, and when the men find themselves for the first time in large industrial plants, the relations between them cannot be regulated in the old traditional ways. Accordingly new approaches have had to be made to this problem, taking account of the circumstances of the industry and the attitudes of the men concerned. More will be said about these questions in other parts of this report. 2 CHAPTER III RECRUITMENT AND TRAINING RECRUITMENT As has been pointed out, the operations of the Company are not confined to the production and refining of oil, but include a multitude of other activities which add greatly to the variety of experience and skills needed in the performance of the work and to the difficulty of obtaining suitable personnel. The building up of a staff which includes such a wide range of occupations as oil drillers, engineers, administrators, chemists, mechanics, draughtsmen, railwaymen, motor drivers, store keepers, dockers, doctors, nurses, and many others would in any country present formidable problems, but in the case of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company these problems are magnified by the fact that in Iran basic industries have not yet developed sufficiently to provide training grounds for an adequate number of skilled workers and specialists. Moreover, the problem of recruitment is complicated by the physical conditions and tropical climate of the area. It will be remembered that the unskilled workers employed by the Company, though they are recruited locally, come, in fact, to a large extent from the pastoral nomadic tribes of Bakhtiari who live on the hills which emerge many miles north of Abadan, and from the Arab tribes of the Persian Gulf. Highly qualified and skilled Iranian employees, on the other hand, come from distant centres of handicraft and industry and are recruited by the Company's main recruiting office in Teheran, or in Abadan, Masjid-i-Sulaiman and Ahwaz. Moreover, all the Company sales offices are in contact with the main office in Teheran and constitute a veritable recruiting network throughout the country. In accordance with the terms of the Concession, the total strength of the Company's unskilled labour is at present composed entirely of Iranians. The Concession, on the other hand, also makes it an obligation for the Company to recruit its skilled workers, as well as its technical and commercial staff, from among Iranian nationals to the extent 15 RECRUITMENT A N D TRAINING that it finds in Iran persons who possess the requisite competence and experience. Since the supply of salaried employees and skilled labour in Iran is constantly short of the increasing requirements of the oil industry, the Company has undertaken to train a large number of young Iranians within the industry and has employed a number of foreigners, particularly British and Indians. The statistical information below shows that over the last 15 years the number of Iranian salaried employees, as well as artisans and skilled workers, has increased at a greater rate than that of foreigners. However, the number of foreigners has also increased, no doubt as a result of the increase in the scope of the Company's operations and the difficulty of finding in Iran all the personnel necessary to fill the new vacancies. TABLE I. IRANIAN A N D FOREIGN WORKERS EMPLOYED BY THE A . I . O . C . AT ABADAN Salaried employees 1935 1936 1937 1938 1939 1940 1941 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 1948 1949 x Artisans s Skilled workers Iranians Foreigners Iranians Foreigners Iranians Foreigners 495 505 632 791 1,007 1,008 908 924 908 968 1,061 1,451 1,781 2,386 4 3,368 919 948 869 928 1,260 1,103 1,010 925 1,378 1,714 2,010 2,236 2,186 2,307 s 2,440 2,175 2,435 2,387 3,055 4,924 3,356 2,757 2,954 4,778 4,192 4,832 5,137 5,189 5,234 6 8,738 405 510 460 442 839 701 804 681 1,251 1,399 1,459 1,522 1,275 1,184 989° 2,838 3,017 3,034 3,380 4,452 4,318 4,189 4,661 7,060 7,319 10,214 10,842 12,614 14,077 7 9,568 42 19 2 — — — t — — —• — — — — — 97 1 The figures given are supplied by the Company and are the only ones available. * 1 Jan. of each year. a Artisans include foremen (Ostad Kar) and other control grades. Heads of technical departments (Sar Ostad Kar) are included among salaried employees. * Including 540 trainees. ö Specialist contractors included for the first time. • Grade 1 skilled workers included for the first time. ' Grades 2 and 3 only. The largest proportion of foreigners is still to be found in posts requiring a very high degree of experience in technical, administrative and commercial matters ; it should be noted in this connection that some foreigners with high qualifications are also employed by the Iranian Government for its own industrial enterprises. 16 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN TABLE II. IRANIAN AND FOREIGN WORKERS EMPLOYED BY THE A.I.O.C. AT FIELDS 1 Salaried <¡mployees Artisans 3 Skilled workers Year* Iranians Foreigners 262 282 386 475 496 515 346 297 266 277 418 513 595 754 434 378 360 410 484 362 202 151 182 212 468 575 569 654 855 B 1935 1936 1937 1938 1939 1940 1941 1942 1943 1944 1945 1946 1947 1948 1949 975 4 Iranians Foreigners Iranians 129 99 95 111 140 107 63 46 53 55 93 187 198 161 184 6 1,386 1,544 1,724 2,022 2,589 2,645 1,819 1,878 2,275 2,559 3,834 4,880 5,884 4,983 5,897' 619 755 936 1,111 1,592 1,538 967 940 1,102 1,170 1,422 2,066 2,158 2,483 3,465 « Foreigners — — — — — — — — — — — — — — 1 Thefiguresgiven are supplied by the Company and are the only ones available. * 1 Jan. of each year. 8 Includes foremen (Ostad Kar) and other control grades. Heads of technical departments (Sar Ostad Kar) are included among salaried employees. * Including 32 trainees. fi Specialist contractors included for thefirsttime. 6 Grade 1 skilled workers included for thefirsttime. ' Grades 2 and 3 only. TABLE III. IRANIAN AND FOREIGN SALARIED EMPLOYEES EMPLOYED BY THE A.I.O.C. AT ABADAN AND FIELDS ON 3 0 NOVEMBER 1 9 4 9 X Class Graded . . Non-graded 1 Foreigners Iranians 2,756 696 765 3,544 Thefiguresgiven are supplied by the Company and are the only ones available. TRAINING Abadan Over a period of 20 years the Company has evolved a system of training which aims at producing the largest possible number of trained men from among the youths of the country. The Company scheme provides facilities for acquiring practically all the specialised skills which the Company requires, including courses for the training of graded and non-graded staff, foremen, artisans and skilled workers in a multitude of trades. All possible opportunities for employment in the Company's service and elsewhere are therefore open to the young trainees, according to their education, intelligence and vocation. RECRUITMENT AND TRAINING 17 A training course for foremen is helping both to open up avenues of promotion for Iranian personnel and to improve relations between the workers and their immediate superiors. The scheme is run on " training within industry " 1 lines and has been in operation in Fields since the end of 1947 and in Abadan since the beginning of 1948. At the end of November 1949 there were in Abadan 516 staff trainees and 2,961 labour trainees, all of whom were Iranians. Though no trainee is tied to remain in the Company's employ, the Company undertakes on its part to accept all suitable trainees. Training is largely carried out on the job, and it is part of the function of each department in the refinery to provide practical teaching for trainees ; but training on the job is in all cases supplemented by theoretical instruction and basic training, which are imparted in three different establishments set up by the Company for this purpose : the Abadan Technical Institute, the apprentice training shops, and the works training centre. All trainees receive pay, leave with pay and medical and sports facilities. An apprentices' hostel has been established by the Company in order to provide adequate accommodation for the apprentices who come to Abadan for commercial or technical training from other areas, including the northern provinces. The Company supplies the hostel with all its requirements and for a modest fee the boys can obtain their meals there. In 1949 the hostel accommodated 300 boys. The Abadan Technical Institute, which was opened in 1939, is a large modern building surrounded by gardens and sports grounds. It includes a main hall used for examinations, public lectures and other functions, a reading room, a library and the class rooms and laboratories of the three technical departments (engineering, science and commerce). The Institute is entirely financed and administered by the Company but is academically governed by the Ministry of Education. Its degrees and certificates are officially recognised, and its teaching forms an integral part of the Iranian national system of education. The Institute is designed primarily to train pupils in specialised branches of industry and commerce by means of part-time education. The length and the curriculum of the courses vary with the degree of education obtained by the pupils before their enrolment and with the objectives to be attained. Graduates of Teheran University and Teheran Higher Technical College are given practical training at the Institute to enable them to take up senior technical and administrative posts in the Company's 1 Cf. " Training Within Industry in the United States ", in International Labour Review, Vol. LIV, Nos. 3-4, Sept.-Oct. 1946, pp. 160-178. 18 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN organisations. The length of the course is two years, including six months' pre-training and six months on the job. Boys with a secondary school certificate follow a five years' course, including from four and a half to nine months' full-time academic training at the Technical Institute. After graduation they may take up senior posts in engineering and chemistry. Alternatively, they may choose to be trained to become foremen, junior shift engineers or clerical assistants, in which case the length of the course is two years, of which part is spent in theoretical training at the Institute. Schoolboys who have gone only half way through secondary education are given part-time courses of four years in technical or commercial subjects, at the end of which they may obtain the ordinary certificate of the Technical Institute and take up posts as foremen, junior shift engineers, junior draughtsmen, health inspectors or clerical assistants. Alternatively they may follow a part-time course of two years and qualify for a low-grade clerk post. The total number of students attending the Technical Institute in the school year 1948-1949 was 790. The apprentice training shops are designed for training boys of about 14 years of age who have spent at least six years at school, i.e., boys who can read and write in Persian and who know the first rules of arithmetic. The apprentice training shops cater for two kinds of apprentices : (1) the artisan apprentice, who spends two years in the shop and another three years in different departments of the refinery and then becomes a high-grade fitter, electrical fitter, wireman, turner or machinist; and (2) the technical apprentice, who spends one year in the shop, at the same time attending classes in the Technical Institute, and then goes to different departments in the refinery for three or four years (attending the Technical Institute as before), ultimately becoming a junior foreman, draughtsman or chemical assistant. In the apprentice training shops all trainees acquire a working knowledge of English, and they are given safety lectures and, once a week, physical training. In 1949 there were 567 artisan apprentices and 164 technical apprentices, but the demand for apprentices in the refinery was still greater than the supply. Admission to the Technical Institute and the apprentice training shops is always subject to the pupils having previously attained a certain standard of education, and also in certain instances to a competitive examination. Youths and young men with little or no instruction, on the other hand, are given an opportunity to improve their capacity through the works training centre, which has been set up to select trainees from among appHcants for work; to determine by process of RECRUITMENT AND TRATNING 19 observation and tests, in workshops and class rooms, the type of work for which they have the greatest aptitude; and to arrange for their training in a selected trade within an appropriate department. The centre is specially interested in the training of (1) boys between 14 and 17 years of age, who are trained to become skilled artisans after a period of five years; (2) adults of 20 to 35 years of age, who after three months in the works training centre and two years in the departments may become low-grade artisans or unskilled tradesmen; and (3) men between 18 and 35 years of age, who are trained as skilled workers, tank dippers, locomotive attendants, cooks, drivers and welders. The most recent development in the Company's training policy has been the establishment in April 1949 of the Abadan Nursing School, where practical and theoretical training is imparted to Iranian nurse trainees in courses which last three years. Fields Training schemes are also operated in the Company's oilfields similar to those in Abadan and under the same conditions, though owing to the fact that the oilfields are scattered over a vast area and consist of small units, these schemes are less comprehensive than those in Abadan, and the number of trainees is smaller. At the end of November 1949 there were in the oilfields 35 staff trainees and 400 labour trainees, all Iranians. Training Iranians in the United Kingdom Under the terms of the Concession the Company has undertaken to sponsor and finance schemes for educating and training Iranians in the United Kingdom. Under these schemes a number of the best students from the Abadan Technical Institute are selected each year for university education or for practical engineering courses in Great Britain. In 1949 77 Iranian students were sent to Great Britain for education and training under the Company's auspices. CHAPTER IV CONDITIONS OF WORK ENGAGEMENT AND CONTRACT OF EMPLOYMENT Every worker, before being engaged, is medically examined and identified by means of photographs and fingerprints. This is done with a view to discovering whether he has been in the service of the Company before and also in order to prevent men unfit for employment from introducing themselves in the place of persons who have passed the medical test and have been regularly engaged. After these formalities a personal card is drawn up for the new recruit, on which a complete record of his employment history is kept. Collective agreements have not yet become a common practice in Iran. In the oil industry salaried employees receive a letter of appointment which specifies the terms under which they serve, whereas the conditions of employment of wage earners are governed by Company regulations and by the provisions of the Labour Law. The first Labour Law in Iran was enacted in 1946. Its provisions referred to hours of work, leave and holidays, conditions of work for women and children, contracts of employment, industrial hygiene, loss of employment, wages, trade unions, the settlement of disputes, the High Labour Council and the Aid Fund. From time to time consideration was given by the High Labour Council to possible revisions of the Law, and eventually a new Bill was submitted to Parliament in 1948. On the basis of this Bill a new Labour Law was approved by Parliament in June 1949 for an experimental period of one year and was brought into force by a Decree published by the Minister of Labour in January 1950. Regulations made under the terms of the old Law, however, remain in force until new regulations are made, as prescribed by the new Law. Matters dealt with in the new Law include hours of work, holidays and annual leave, the contract of employment, termination of employment, health and protection of workers, wages, trade unions, the settlement of disputes, the High Labour Council, the Aid Fund, employment offices and co-operative societies. 21 CONDITIONS OF WORK WAGE SYSTEM The Company's wage policy and the wage categories into which the Company's labour force is divided are based on the minimum wage regulations adopted by the Iranian Government in 1946 in connection with the first Labour Law. The grades and the corresponding statutory minimum wage scale are shown in table IV. TABLE IV. COMPANY WAGE SCALE Pay Grade Unskilled Grade 3 Grade 2 Grade 1 Head of technical department Minimum wage Minimum wage plus 20 per cent. Minimum wage plus 40 per cent. Minimum wage plus 70 per cent. Twice minimum wage Two and a half times minimum wage The statutory minimum wage for unskilled workmen is fixed annually by the local board for the settlement of disputes and is subject to approval by the High Labour Council. In the province of Khuzistan, which includes Abadan and the oilfields, it was 40 rials x a day in 1949. The statutory minimum wage is based on the cost of a number of items which are deemed to be necessary to meet the living requirements of a workman, his wife and two children. Table V shows these items (or " basket ") for Abadan and the oilfield areas in 1949. Wage Increments and Promotion Unskilled workers who have completed one year of meritorious service on the minimum basic rate are eligible for an increase of 2 rials a day and after a further two years of continuous service they may be granted a further increase of 2 rials. A similar system of increments—but on a higher scale—for meritorious service is provided for artisans and skilled workers (grades 3, 2 and 1) and for foremen. Promotion from one grade to another is subject to a trade test. The Company encourages its wage earners to pass such tests, and to those who fail the first time a refresher course is given in order that they may make a second attempt. Wage earners may also be promoted to the salaried grades by appearing before a central committee which examines all such nominations for promotions. A similar committee exists to examine promotions from non-graded staff to graded staff. The result of the Company's policy of 1 At present official rates of exchange, 1 rial=£0.011 or $0,031. 22 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN wage increments and promotion has been that only a relatively small number of workers are not paid more than the statutory minimum wage (see table VI). TABLE V. ITEMS USED TO CALCULATE MINIMUM WAGE, ABADAN AND FIELDS, 1949 Food for one month : Bread Sugar Meat Ghee Rice Tea Cheese Peas and beans Curd Dates Fish Vegetables and fruit . . . . Fuel, light, etc., for one month : Charcoal Matches Electricity Ice Accommodation : Quarters . . Clothing for one year : Winter suit Summer suit Socks Shoes Ghivers Hat Underpants Shirts Family clothing Miscellaneous TABLE VI. 67 kg. (or 50 kg. flour) 2 kg. 3 kg. 2 kg. 7 kg. Va kg. i y 2 kg. 3 kg. 4 kg. 5 kg. 2 kg. 5 per cent, of total cost of above items 30 10 6 150 kg. (or 24 litres kerosene) boxes kilowatt hours kg. 1 room, approximately 12 eu. m. 1 1 4 pairs 1 pair 1 pair 1 2 pairs 2 75 per cent, of total cost of above 10 per cent, of the total cost of all the above items WAGE EARNERS ON MINIMUM WAGE RATES AND ABOVE ON 3 1 DECEMBER 1949 IN ABADAN AND FIELDS 1 Grade Grade 3 Grade 2 Grade 1 Foreman Total . . . 1 Number of workers on minimum wage rates Number of workers above minimum wage rates 1,167 2,353 2,570 1,210 47 7,347 11,996 2,109 7,893 11,050 2,219 35,267 The figures are supplied by the Company and are the only ones available. CONDITIONS OF WORK 23 Wages and Prices In the areas of the Company's operation, speculation on the part of local traders and inflationary pressure due to the concentration of a large and comparatively well-paid labour force have caused open market prices to rise well above the level of the prices upon which the minimum wage for Khuzistan has been calculated. The minimum wage regulations provide that in places where such a situation arises the employer is required to place at the disposal of his workers the commodities included in the minimum wage basket at the prices on which the minimum wage is based. However, even before the adoption of this provision the Company was operating its own food and clothing distribution scheme for the benefit of its employees. Details of this scheme are given in Chapter VII. It is sufficient to mention here that thanks to this scheme many of the food and other items consumed by the workers are supplied by the Company at subsidised prices or at prices below those charged in the local market. According to a computation made by the Company, the availability of Company supplies at controlled prices has made it possible to maintain the cost of the agreed standard of living, upon which the minimum statutory wage is based, at 39.13 rials a day (about the amount of the statutory minimum wage). The same standard of living would have cost the workers 76.87 rials if they had had to make all their purchases on the free market. It should be noted that all Company labour, and not only workers on the lower wage rates, can benefit from the scheme. Allowances Allowances exist for workmen working in areas where living accommodation, amenities, etc., are below the normal standard. The amounts are 30 per cent, of the basic pay (maximum of 20 rials) for the outstation allowance, 100 per cent, for night allowance for vehicle drivers, 75 per cent, for pipe construction allowance, and so on. Other allowances are given for driving, work of an exceptionally dirty nature, work necessitating the wearing of heavy protective equipment, working at heights above the ground, etc. HOURS OF WORK Under the Labour Law the normal hours of work must not exceed eight per day or 48 per week. Company employees work 4 3 % hours per week in summer and 44% in winter. The working week consists of five and a half days, for which workers receive—in accordance with the law—seven days' pay. 24 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN The rates for overtime and shift work paid by the Company conform to the statutory regulations, which fix them at 35 and 10 per cent, of the basic pay respectively. HOLIDAYS WITH PAY In addition to the weekly rest day, which falls on Friday, the workers are given seven statutory public holidays, seven non-statutory public holidays and, after one year's continuous service, 10 days' leave per annum—in all cases without loss of pay. TERMINATION OF EMPLOYMENT The Labour Law prescribes that a worker who wishes to leave his employment must give the employer seven days' written notice and, in case of dismissal, that the employer must pay the worker one week's pay for every year of service. The Company pays the amount of the statutory severance allowance also in case of resignation. In case of dismissal on medical grounds after less than one year's service, the Company allows three months' pay, and workers who have been with the Company for a number of years receive one month's pay for every year of service. DISCIPLINARY CODE If there is direct evidence of misbehaviour, upon report from the foreman a man may be suspended from work by the job officer for a maximum of seven days. Suspension for longer periods and in cases which call for investigation may only be decided by the Company labour officer. There are three grounds for dismissal : unsatisfactory conduct or work, unsuitability for training and redundancy. In all cases of suspension or dismissal the person concerned has a right of appeal. The relative procedure is described in Chapter IX. TURNOVER The turnover of Iranian employees as shown in table VII is comparatively large, especially in the lower categories of wage earners. Labour wastage occurs mostly among the newly recruited unskilled workers. Thus, of 8,227 Abadan wage earners leaving employment in 1948, 58.96 per cent, had less than one year's service and 28.20 per cent. less than two years' service. There are various reasons for these high percentages. One is that tribesmen seeking employment in the oil industry as unskilled workers 25 CONDITIONS OF WORK TABLE VII. TURNOVER OF IRANIAN EMPLOYEES IN 1948 Per cent. of monthly strength Categories Graded salaried employees Non-graded technical employees . . . . Non-graded commercial employees . . . Wage earners (all grades) Over-all categories 1 1 3.93 6.99 10.49 21.09 20.06 The figures are supplied by the Company and are the only ones available. often do not intend to stay in employment for more than a few months. They make their way to the oil areas when there is little work to be done up country, and after they have saved sufficient money they return to their homes. Conscription is another factor which has an important effect on wastage; it has been noted that employees, particularly in the unskilled group, sometimes disappear from employment in order to evade it. On the other hand, the number of workers who seek re-engagement is also very high. In 1948, out of 3,977 skilled workers entering the industry in Abadan, 2,067 were re-engagements, and out of 5,154 unskilled workers entering the industry, the number of re-engagements was 5,136. SOCIAL INSURANCE Two forms of compulsory social insurance are in operation under the Labour Law. The first covers wage earners against industrial accidents and illness caused by employment and is financed by contributions totalling 3 per cent, of the workers' earnings, of which 1 per cent, is paid by the workers and 2 per cent, by the employers. This scheme is administered by the Iran Insurance Company but is largely carried out through the hospitals and clinics established by the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company. The medical officer of the Iran Insurance Company in Abadan has been given accommodation in the A.I.O.C. hospital, where he has full access to hospital records and co-operates with the A.I.O.C. medical officers on medical boards and welfare clinics so as to be able to follow up his patients from the insurance point of view. The other form of social insurance operated under the Labour Law of 1949 covers marriage, pregnancy, support to large families, childbirth, burial and legal aid.1 According to law, this scheme should be financed 1 The Law also makes provision for assistance to workers and members of their families in case of accident or illness not caused by employment and for old-age and disablement benefits. However, the detailed measures for the application of these provisions have not yet been issued, and at present this section of the scheme is not in operation anywhere in Iran. 26 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN by a levy of 3 per cent, on the total earnings of the wage earners, of which 1 per cent, should be paid by the workers and 2 per cent, by the employers. These contributions should be paid into an aid fund controlled by the board of settlement of the undertaking concerned. In the case of the A.I.O.C, however, the aid funds, both in Abadan and Fields, are financed exclusively by the dues of the workers, since the Company, with the agreement of the Government, retains its contributions in view of the special benefits which the Company itself has undertaken to provide for its workers. These benefits include medical assistance and free hospitalisation in case of non-industrial accident or illness, the payment of full wages to men who are absent from work through sickness and until they are certified fit for work again, and the payment of more generous retirement allowances than those provided by the law to men who have a long record of service. SAFETY The normal planning and supervision of safety measures in the Company's installations is the responsibility of a special Safety Department, the head of which is the chief safety engineer. There is a safety engineer at the refinery and another at Fields. These officers are supported by a supervisory staff of safety specialists at the job level. When an accident occurs, an investigation is held by a court of enquiry, an important function of which is the improvement of safety measures. The court of enquiry meets each month and consists of the manager of the refinery personnel (chairman), the works manager, the manager of the general department, the labour superintendent and the chief safety engineer. The Company has not yet found it practicable to develop joint safety committees, although it has recognised that the tendency must be towards the encouragement of the joint consultation method. On the other hand, suggestions for the improvement of safety are discussed by the joint departmental committees concerned and adopted if approved. A very great effort has been made by the Company to develop safety consciousness among its workers. The Company's safety regulations are read and explained to all new recruits before they are actually set to work, and special safety classes are regularly held at Abadan and in the oilfields for all types of apprentices and trainees and for all types of workmen engaged in work of a particularly dangerous nature. One of the methods employed for training machine shop operators and apprentices is the showing of instructional films. The films illustrate right and wrong methods of working, and the results of failure to take the necessary care. CONDITIONS OF WORK 27 Posters are made and printed by the Company itself and distributed throughout the works as constant reminders to personnel to become safety conscious and avoid accidents. These posters relate chiefly to hand accidents, which are the most frequent. Mechanical safeguards are provided for the many different types of machines in use in order to protect the workers against coming into contact with the moving parts or cutters. Many of these safeguards are fully automatic and come immediately into operation should a machinist get his hands, fingers or other parts of his body near to the dangerous moving parts. Approach platforms, stairways, sumps, buildings, roofs and other places where there is a possibility of falling are provided with fixed guards in the form of hand rails. Many different types of equipment for the personal protection of workers engaged in the multifarious processes of production and refining have been adopted or devised. Different types of eye protection are available for men working in the refining units, workshops, engineering and transport sections. In the acid and production units the employees are provided with rubber aprons, gauntlet gloves, gum boots and anti-splash goggles, and respirators are always available for use against the possibility of a concentration of acid fumes. For those men who are working on sulphur milling and loading, dust respirators and goggles are provided. Very special precautions are taken for the protection of the workmen in the final process of blending products with tetra-ethyl-lead. Their protective equipment is coloured white to enable any splash to be observed immediately; each man must wear a special respirator during the time he is working, and on leaving the job he has a bath and a complete change of clothing to avoid contamination through contact with lead. These men are also subject to periodic medical inspection to ensure that they have not become infected by the chemical lead. Special equipment is also used where it is found necessary to enter a vessel that has contained acid or acid products, and if the vessel has not been freed of all gas vapours the Bloman breathing apparatus is operated in order to ensure a constant supply of fresh air to the man inside the vessel. In the provision of all this equipment, consideration has been given to the abnormal climatic conditions that prevail and, for tropical heat in summer time, fabrics have been produced that are both light and durable and, at the same time, afford the fullest possible protection with a minimum of discomfort to the wearer. First-aid posts are provided in the refinery and in the oilfields, and at all strategic points the working areas are dotted with first-aid booths which, upon being entered, automatically release a shower of water and 28 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN wash away any poisonous materials which might have splashed the clothing or the body of a worker. CONTRACT LABOUR In addition to the workers directly employed by the Company, other workers are employed within the Company's areas by contractors to whom the Company assigns certain work which generally falls outside its normal activities or does not justify the employment of a regular labour force. Thus, inside the refinery contract labour is employed in navvy work, building, riveting and tank cleaning, painting and handling sulphur. Outside the refinery and in the oilfields it is engaged in pipe track and road construction, building and maintenance work. The casual or seasonal nature of these occupations causes the number of workers employed by contractors to fluctuate continuously. Most of them are engaged for a specific job, and once this is finished they are laid off and must wait for another opportunity of employment. This in itself contrasts with the relative security which is enjoyed by the workers employed by the Company. But there are other reasons which make the conditions of contract labour far less favourable. In the first place the almost complete lack of controls favours a disregard of the provisions of the Labour Law by contractors, and especially by contractors who operate on a small scale—and these are in the majority. It is generally admitted in Abadan and the oilfields that many contractors pay their workers less than the legal minimum wage and bypass the statutory regulations concerning the payment of weekly rest days, the rates for overtime, holidays with pay, and so on.1 The second reason why the position of contract labour is incomparably worse is that it is excluded from all the schemes which the Company operates for the benefit of its own workers. This exclusion is particularly serious in the field of health and food services. For instance, a worker employed by a contractor has no claim to be admitted to the only hospital in Abadan (which is a Company hospital) and even if he is received there he does not have the privilege— which is granted to company workers in case of non-industrial accident or sickness—of being treated free.2 The contract labourer, moreover, is not entitled to make purchases in the Company shops, which means 1 This statement does not apply to all contractors. For instance, the Tola Company, which operates bus services in Abadan and the vicinity under a contract from the Á.I.O.C. and employs in these services about 1,000 people, pays the following minimum wage rates : drivers, 125 rials for nine hours' service and 150 rials for 10 hours' service; helpers, from 72 to 91 rials. 2 See Chapter VI. Welding a crude-oil bucket A break for tea in the oilfields ñ ¿ !-#^Èp; . Artisans' houses, Abadan Power station, Abadan 29 CONDITIONS OF WORK that for him the statutory minimum wage has hardly more than half the purchasing power that it has for a Company worker.1 The Company has endeavoured to safeguard the interests of contract labour by inserting in the contracts a clause binding the contractor to observe all Iranian legislation affecting conditions of employment and in particular the provisions relating to the minimum wage. In this respect the main burden of enforcing the Labour Law must, however, rest upon the Iranian Government and in particular upon the Government labour offices in Company areas. At present the staff employed in the Government's labour offices is clearly insufficient in numbers and experience to carry out the duties of labour inspection over such vast areas and for so many contractors. Again, the Labour Law itself is inadequate in so far as it provides no sanctions in cases of infringement of its provisions. In these circumstances, and until legal regulations have been issued to redress this situation, the only road open to the officials of the Ministry of Labour when they are confronted with violations of the law is to appeal to the employer or try to conciliate the issue. Neither method appears to have been particularly successful. Workers and certain Government officials showed great concern with regard to the position of contract labour and were under the impression that it was the Company's policy to increase the number of operations farmed out to contractors. In this connection table VIII, based TABLE VIII. STRENGTH OF CONTRACT LABOUR AND COMPANY LABOUR Fields Abadan Year" 1945 1946 1947 1948 1949 No. of No. of wage workers earners employed by employed contractors by Company (estimate) 6,953 4,869 4,850 5,303 7,694 29,704 29,554 29,693 31,719 33,004 Contract labour as percentage of Company labour No. of workers employed by contractors (estimate) No. of wage earners employed by Company 23 16 16 16 23 5,190 7,592 6,215 6,886 8,716 8,613 11,721 11,564 12,573 15,328 Contract labour as percentage of Company labour 60 64 53 54 56 1 Thefiguresare supplied by the Company and are the only ones available. • 1 Jan. of each year. on information supplied by the Company, shows that if the number of workers employed by contractors has actually somewhat increased in 1 3 See above p. 23. 30 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN recent years, so also has the number of workers employed by the Company itself and that, on the whole, the proportion of contract labour to Company labour has not undergone any significant change. The proportion of contract labour in Fields is higher than in Abadan because of the greater amount of construction work and because villagers expect to be employed on roads and pipe tracks passing through their district. CHAPTER V HOUSING HOUSING IN ABADAN The small village of a few hundred fishermen and date growers that was Abadan until about 40 years ago has developed since the establishment of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company in that area into one of the largest cities in Iran. Its population at the end of 1949 was estimated to be about 173,000, of whom 133,000 were Company employees and their dependants. Most of the remaining 40,000 were workers employed by contractors, independent craftsmen and merchants and their families. The rate of increase of this population has been generally irregular, and circumstances, especially in the last eight years, have hardly allowed sufficient time for this vast number of people to be absorbed in an orderly way. In fact, the most dramatic increase in the population of Abadan took place during and after the war when, following the tremendous expansion of the refinery, the number of Company employees was doubled, and the population of the town augmented in about the same proportion. This stream of so many men, women and children flocking into that desert corner of the earth necessarily created many social problems, of which perhaps none was so serious as that of providing decent accommodation for all. Looking objectively and soberly at the manner in which this problem has been tackled, the observer cannot fail to be impressed by the vast number of modern houses and amenities which the Company has been able to provide in a comparatively short time in spite of exceptionally unfavourable circumstances. On the other hand, it is impossible to overlook the hardships of those who are still living in tents and huts or the unwholesome overcrowding and promiscuity of the Abadan municipal districts where local landlords exploit the workers. Abadan town can be divided into two sections. The central section, which lies outside the Company areas, was built mostly by private initiative and is administered by the local authorities. It includes the market district or bazaar and the adjacent district of Ahmedabad. The 32 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN other section has been entirely developed by the Company on Company ground and is administered by Company officials. The two sections contrast greatly. On the one hand the Company areas resemble a modern European housing estate, with villas and bungalows neatly aligned along wide roads planted with trees or parks and open spaces. On the other hand the municipal districts take after the local type of urban agglomeration, where there is a great deal of congestion, and houses are generally of a very inferior type—some are built of mud. The Company has given considerable assistance to the Abadan municipality in making improvements to the roads, drainage, the layout of the town and other municipal amenities. It has installed street lighting throughout the township and it makes electricity available to the municipality at a very low cost. The electric power is distributed through substations maintained by the public authorities, and the proceeds which are collected from the consumers are used for municipal development. The Company supplies daily to the municipality one million gallons of treated drinking water at a very cheap rate. The reticulation to water points and houses in the municipal area has been financed in part by the Company and in part by the municipality. In considering the problem of housing developments in Abadan regard must be had to certain local conditions which make it difficult for large building schemes to be carried out quickly. Most of the building materials are not available directly on the spot. The Company has created a cement factory in Abadan, but bricks must be manufactured in Ahwaz, where the Company is operating a brick kiln, or brought in from Basra, because Abadan clay has proved unsatisfactory. Even sand is not available locally, and electrical and sanitary equipment and most wood fixtures must be imported from abroad. All these circumstances increase the cost of erecting houses out of proportion to that in other regions, and during the first three years of the war they actually caused the Company's building programme to be interrupted. Another factor which must be taken into consideration is that any large increase of building activities in Abadan requires the inflow of new labour, which in turn increases the number of those for whom shelter must be provided. In the Company housing estates different types of dwellings can be distinguished. The standard family house for a senior member of the salaried personnel has four or five bedrooms, two bathrooms, toilets, servant's room, store and courtyard. The standard family house for a junior member of the staff at the lowest level has three rooms, one bathroom with toilet, kitchen and courtyard. Intermediate types exist 3.3 HOUSING for staff at other levels. Bachelor salaried personnel have bed-sittingrooms with individual or communal bathroom and toilet facilities. Bachelors usually take their meals in the Company restaurants. The standard family house for wage-earning personnel is built in terraces and consists of two or three rooms, a kitchen, a standing ablution place and toilet. A number of wage-earning bachelors are accommodated in Nissen huts, and a number of apprentices live in the apprentices' hostel, which has dormitories and communal dining and living-rooms. All houses of permanent standard type are built of bricks and are provided with fans, water, electricity and sanitation services. The development of the Company's housing activities in Abadan up to the end of 1949 is shown in table IX. TABLE IX. HOUSES BUILT BY THE COMPANY AT ABADAN Houses for Rooms for married salaried bachelor salaried staff staff Houses for married wage earners Spaces for bachelor wage earners 33 709 136 78 956 Before 1934 . . . . 1936-1940 1942-1944 1945-1949 Loss on conversion1 476 875 80 883 774 54 1,229 187 — — 28 1,995 1,484 2,271 —199 Total . . . 2,314 2,244 5,579 1 — Many of the houses built during the war were of inferior type and were converted to standard type later. At the end of 1949 about 90 per cent, of all salaried staff had been given accommodation in Company houses. On the other hand out of 31,875 wage earners only 5,298, or 16.6 per cent., were in Company houses. Housing is allocated to all personnel according to a formula based on length of service and basic rate of pay. This latter element, which in a way measures the value of the men in the eyes of the Company, is, however, weighted more heavily than length of service. It thus happens that under this system men with a comparatively short record of service may be accommodated in Company houses, whereas men who have been in the service of the Company for a long period of years may not be able to profit from the many advantages of the Company housing scheme. This condition is resented particularly by the wage earners, since they have to compete for a proportionately much smaller number of houses. It may be pointed out in this connection that of the 5,580 houses for married wage earners which had been made available by the 34 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN Company up to 1949 only 3,998 were actually thus occupied at the end of that year, the balance being made up as follows : allocated to salaried staff, 750 houses ; taken over for use by non-employees, 388 ; in use as service shops and offices, 325 ; undergoing repair, 319. Wage earners pay 8 rials per day for a two-roomed house and 10 for a three-roomed house. (This charge, which includes the cost of maintenance and the supply of water and electricity, corresponds to one tenth of the artisan's basic minimum wage for a wage earner's tworoomed house and to one eighth of the artisan's basic minimum wage for a three-roomed house of the same type.) Tenure of Company houses being dependent upon employment, the tenant is obliged to move out of the premises when his employment ceases. Similarly his heirs are liable to be given notice in case of the tenant's death. In view of the acute housing shortage, the Company must obviously exercise a certain amount of discretion in making use of its rights in connection with termination of tenancy. Wage earners for whom accommodation is not provided by the Company receive 2 rials per day as a special allowance. Most of the wage earners who have not been allocated Company houses Uve in the municipal districts. There, if their wages are high enough, they may be able to rent one of the 290 houses in the new housing estate which has been built by the Karun Engineering Company in the Ahmedabad district. The roads, the sewerage system and water points serving this estate have been built at the expense of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company, and the Karun Company has undertaken in return to let these houses to oil workers at controlled rents. Though there is no electricity or water inside the buildings, this estate is perhaps the best in the city outside the Company area. The great majority of the oil workers however, live in the older overcrowded sections of the municipal districts, where more often than not the entire family or three or four bachelors occupy a single room. Rents are very high, and an attempt made by the Government to fix a ceiling to rents in relation to the statutory minimum wage has utterly failed. Finally, another group of workers lives in mud houses or huts made of all sorts of materials, or in the 360 tents which the Company put up in 1949 as an emergency measure to accommodate homeless workers. The Anglo-Iranian Oil Company is alive to the seriousness of both the human and social problems arising from this situation, and while in Abadan the Mission was invited by it to visit a new prototype of houses for lower-paid wage earners which was then under consideration and for which the necessary building materials were already on the spot. The Mission was later informed that the Company had decided to go ahead immediately with the construction of about 1,000 of these dwellings. HOUSING 35 The Majlis (Parliament), with a view to improving the housing conditions of the industrial workers throughout the country, introduced in the Agricultural Bank Act of 9 March 1949 and in the Budget Bill of 1949 provisions making it obligatory for Government and private factories employing 100 or more workers to commence at once building living quarters for their workers according to Government regulations. But since these regulations have not been issued, the provisions referred to above do not seem to have been applied yet. HOUSING IN THE OILFIELDS In the oilfield areas the Company had built, up to the end of 1949, 793 houses for married staff, 356 rooms for bachelor salaried staff and 5,591 houses for married wage earners. Accommodation was thus provided for 62.5 per cent, of the salaried staff and a little over 36 per cent. of the wage earners. From the abovefiguresit appears that, considering the Fields area as a whole, the proportion of salaried staff to whom Company houses have been allocated is less than in Abadan, whereas the proportion of wage earners accommodated by the Company is higher. Within the latter category 48.22 per cent, of the artisans, 49.19 per cent, of the skilled and 10.53 per cent, of the unskilled workers were, in 1949, living in Company quarters. At the same time 175 salaried employees and 1,034 wage earners were living in tents. The same difficulties regarding availability of building materials and high costs of construction which have been noted for Abadan exist also in the Fields area, except that in some of the oilfields local stone is used quite successfully instead of bricks. On the other hand, the construction of permanent houses in any Fields area can only be undertaken when it is certain that the area will be in production for a number of years. A test area, for instance, is provided only with temporary buildings until it is proved to be an oilfield. The houses built by the Company in Fields are similar to those of Abadan and the system of allocation is the same. Wage earners who have not obtained Company quarters are given an allowance of 1 rial a day. They usually live in mud villages more or less near the oilfield or build themselves a shelter near the place where they work, often with the help of building materials supplied free by the Company. A few houses erected by local enterprise are also available to the better-paid workers. CHAPTER VI SOCIAL SERVICES DISTRIBUTION OF FOOD, CLOTHING AND OTHER SUPPLIES The inadequacy of local farm produce and the insignificance of manufacturing industries in the neighbourhood make the population of Abadan and the oilfields dependent upon imports from distant provinces and from abroad for most of its needs in food, clothing and other commodities. This situation constantly creates new supply problems and, in any crisis, makes the conditions of the oil workers particularly vulnerable. Thus, when in 1941 an acute shortage of wheat manifested itself in Iran and at the same time all essential commodities were scarce throughout the world, supplies from local merchants broke down and speculation and profiteering at the expense of labour became intolerable. It was then that, in order to assure the continuance of refinery operations and to avoid starvation, the Company undertook for the first time to import wheat from India and to distribute bread to its personnel. It soon became apparent, however, that this limited scheme was insufficient to put a stop to the race between prices and wages, and the Company was almost forced to make itself responsible for the supply and distribution of a very wide range of goods of first necessity at subsidised prices or at prices lower than those of the local market. This vast commitment undertaken by the Company has enabled all its wage earners to buy a large proportion of essential commodities at reasonable prices. The great disadvantage of this system is that it tends to make the life of the workers even more dependent upon the Company. It seems, however, that the Company has repeatedly tried to shake off this financial and administrative burden, but that the circumstances which first prompted the introduction of the food and clothing distribution scheme have never sufficiently improved. The abolition of the scheme now would undoubtedly constitute a major catastrophe. The only alternative appears to be the creation of a co-operative movement, strong enough to enable the workers to take over the organ- 37 SOCIAL SERVICES isation established by the Company. But although encouraged by the Company, this co-operative movement has not yet made sufficient progress. Without powerful financial resources a workers' co-operative movement would hardly be in a position to carry out an undertaking of this magnitude.1 Not the least of the difficulties encountered has been, it seems, the high rate of interest on loans charged by Iranian banks. Organisation of the Scheme In Abadan there are eight Company shops for wage earners, open daily and located in the main districts so as to enable employees to make all the purchases to which they are entitled without having to go too far from home. In Fields and other outstations, shops are open on certain days of the month according to the number of employees to be catered TABLE X. MONTHLY RATIONS AVAILABLE AT COMPANY SHOPS AT THE END OF 1949 Abadan Fields areas Workers Flour Tea Sugar Rice Ghee Pulses (peas, beans and lentils) Kerosene Soap . . Charcoal Ice . . . 20 280 1,700 7 2 3 12 kg. gm. gm. kg. kg. kg. litres 500 gm. 3 kg. 190 k g . 1 20 kg. 240 gm. 1,600 gm. 7 kg. 2 kg. 3 kg. Free issue 20 litres or less, depending on lighting facilities in the employee's house 500 gm. 190 kg. ! Dependants Flour Tea . . Sugar . . Kerosene 1 10 kg. per adult (over 7 years) 5 kg. per child (under 7 years) 490 gm. per family 1,400 gm. per family 12 litres per family 10 kg. for each of first three dependants 5 kg. for each subsequent dependant 480 gm. per family 1,200 gm. per family During period June-Sept, inclusive. 1 The extent of the Company's scheme may be seen from the following approximate total quantities of major items retailed to labour per year: flour, 27,000 tons; tea, 420 tons; sugar, 1,050 tons; rice, 5,000 tons; ghee, 1,200 tons; winter suits, 50,000; white drill, 300,000 metres; shoes, 50,000 pairs. 38 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN for. Since goods in the Company shops are sold at prices lower than those in the open market, purchases are made against a ration card, which covers the workman and his dependants. Rationed items are issued against squares on the ration card, unrationed items on presentation of the card. 1 All sales are for cash. Workmen's representatives are on duty in the shops to help deal with any complaints on the spot. Table X shows the monthly rations available at the end of 1949 in the Company shops. Mutton, fish, cigarettes, tooth powder, corned beef, dates and insecticide sprayers can be purchased off the ration in Abadan labour shops. In the oilfields the items off the ration are cigarettes, corned beef and insecticide sprayers. The following items are available annually : (a) to workers (all areas) : one winter suit ; one summer suit length ; one pair of shoes ; two shirts. (b) to dependants (all areas) : 18 metres of printed cotton ; five and a half metres of white cotton cambric ; four and a half metres of black twill. Besides these main items, there are occasional extra issues of readymade clothing. Works Canteens A canteen for wage earners is operated inside the Abadan refinery by a contractor under the control of the Company's catering superintendent. The canteen is equipped to provide 2,000 hot meals a day. To respond to the demand of those workers who cannot at present be accommodated, the construction of a second works canteen is being planned by the Company. Stores, Restaurants and Laundry for Staff Employees In each residential area in Abadan there are Company stores for the sale of such commodities as groceries, meat, milk, bread, liquor and tobacco to the Company staff employees. Certain items which are still in short supply are rationed, but a considerable number of commodities are on general sale. In addition, there are Company stores for the sale of clothing and household goods to the staff. The issues of clothing are made on a points system and cover a variety of items, including shoes and materials. 1 Goods bought by the workers from Company shops are sometimes resold to local merchants and can be seen on sale in the bazaars for higher prices. SOCIAL SERVICES 39 Eight restaurants capable of accommodating 1,140 patrons have been provided by the Company for the benefit of staff employees. All senior staff may avail themselves of the services of an outside catering station either for club functions or for private parties. A laundry equipped with the most modern machinery for washing and pressing linen and clothing is operated by the Company for the benefit of all staff employees. COMPANY AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT SCHEMES With a view to increasing the supply of fresh farm produce, the Company has encouraged local cultivators by installing and maintaining irrigation pumps free of charge and by ploughing land in the initial stages, constructing drainage ditches and supplying vegetable seeds. As a result of these efforts it is estimated that some 200 acres of hitherto barren land have been made productive ; this has led to a marked increase in the supply of vegetables to the people of Abadan. In addition the Company itself has reclaimed some 175 acres of desert tracts by washing the salt from the soil, constructing drainage ditches and installing irrigation pumps. On one of these reclaimed areas, about five miles north of Abadan, the Company has established a dairy farm and is raising a herd of cows which, it is hoped, will meet all the needs of staff employees in the next few years. Elsewhere the Company maintains a poultry farm and a piggery and is growing fresh vegetables, which are made available to the staff and wage-earning employees. HEALTH SERVICES The responsibility for the planning and operation of health services in Abadan and the oilfields is shouldered almost entirely by the Company. The Company's health scheme is organised in two main branches, curative and preventive, and is directed by a chief medical officer, responsible to the Company's general management, assisted by two doctors, who are in charge of all the curative and preventive facilities in Abadan and the oilfields respectively. The only hospitals in Abadan and the oilfields, as well as the great majority of doctors, are provided by the Company. Medical attendance and hospitalisation are free for all salaried employees and wage earners. Dependants of salaried employees are also entitled to free medical treatment and hospitalisation. Dependants of wage earners and certain 40 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN non-employees are only entitled to full out-patient treatment and emergency in-patient treatment. Limited dental service and full pharmaceutical service are rendered free to all Company employees. Financially, the costs of the Company's medical services, in so far as industrial accidents and industrial sickness are concerned, are covered under the provisions of the Labour Law by the national social insurance scheme operated by the Iran Insurance Company.1 On the other hand, the costs of hospitalisation and treatment of wage earners for accidents and illness not caused by employment appear to be matched, at least in part, by the exemption obtained by the Company from the payment of its share of contributions into the Company Aid Fund.2 Curative Services in Abadan The main hospital in Abadan has 450 beds, of which 137 are reserved for the salaried staff and 313 for wage earners. There is also an isolation hospital with 150 beds (16 for salaried staff and 134 for wage earners) for various kinds of infectious diseases. Inside the compound of the refinery there are four works clinics, where the men can receive first aid and advice, and in the workers' residential quarters there are eight labour clinics which were built by the Company and are operated by the municipality. The main hospital includes three operating theatres, two maternity wards and two children's wards, and is provided with the most modern equipment, including X-ray rooms and a physiotherapy department. The medical staff of the hospital is composed of 61 specialists and medical officers, of whom 41 are Iranians. The specialists are qualified in surgery, medicine, tropical diseases, industrial hygiene, pathology, ophthalmology, venereal diseases and midwifery. In addition there are 67 nurses, 27 dressers, and a number of dispensers, laboratory assistants, health inspectors and clerical personnel. Curative Services in the Oilfields There is one hospital at Masjid-i-Sulaiman with 20 beds for salaried staff and 73 for wage earners, and one hospital at Agha Jari with 12 beds for salaried staff and 35 for wage earners. Both hospitals are provided with operating theatres, laboratories, X-ray rooms and maternity wards. In Masjid-i-Sulaiman an isolation hospital with 60 beds for infectious cases serves the whole area of the oilfields. 1 2 S e e above, p. 25. See above, p. 26. SOCIAL SERVICES 41 In the smaller fields there are small detention wards. The medical staff is composed of 22 doctors, 24 nurses, 21 dressers and a number of auxiliary personnel. Problems concerning Medical Services In advanced European countries it is assumed that the number of beds which should be available in hospitals should be between 10 and 15 per 1,000 of population. In Abadan the Company provides about 24 beds per 1,000 salaried employees and about 14 beds per 1,000 wage earners, and in the oilfields about 15 beds per 1,000 salaried employees and 7 beds per 1,000 wage earners. It would thus appear that, at least in Abadan, the number of beds available to Company employees compares favourably with that in advanced European countries ; in Abadan, however, the need for hospital beds may be greater, in view of the higher morbidity and of the bad housing conditions, which make it undesirable for sick people to stay at home, where more often than not they would have to lie on a carpet or mattress in unhealthy rooms shared with many other people. But apart from the Company employees to whom the above considerations apply, there are the dependants of wage earners—numbering about three times as many as the employees—who normally can only obtain out-patient treatment, and 40,000 other people who are neither employed by the Company nor dependants of Company employees, and to whom, except in an emergency, the doors of the hospitals in Abadan and Fields might remain closed altogether. It is true that Company hospitals do their best to accommodate as many as they can of those who are not strictly entitled to hospitalisation. It is true that the Company doctors work very long hours in order to be able to attend all patients without much discrimination. It is true that about 15 miles north of Abadan, in Khorramshahr, there is a State hospital which may be in a position to accept a certain number of people from Abadan. However, it appears that the need for more medical facilities, especially in Abadan, is still very great. In this situation it is encouraging to hear that the Company is prepared to give support in the establishment of a municipal hospital in Abadan, which would be operated entirely by the municipality, and that an extension of the Company's main hospital has been planned to include about 103 beds, further operating theatres and X-ray rooms, an electrocardiography department, a main sterilising system, lecture rooms, etc. Moreover, the Company is planning to build additional medical clinics in the Fields areas. 42 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN School Medical Service The Company has provided school dispensaries in municipal schools at Abadan and Masjid-i-Sulaiman, where the schoolchildren are medically examined at the beginning of each year and are regularly treated for trachoma. The dispensaries are controlled by two doctors and 35 assistants, all of whom are on the staff of the Company. Preventive Medical Services The Company has taken active measures to prevent and combat infectious diseases in all its areas as well as in the municipal districts of Abadan. Such measures include preventive inoculation on a large scale (in 1949, 36,389 vaccinations were carried out), quarantine treatment, provision of treated water supply, rat and dog destruction, inspection of food and slaughterhouses, and the construction of numerous bath houses for all employees and their dependants. As malaria is widespread in south Iran, a special section of the Company's health service deals solely with anti-malaria measures, including cleansing of ditches, the oiling of collections of water to kill larvae, and D.D.T. spraying. Disinfestation and sterilisation of instruments is carried out on a large scale in the bath houses, and all houses in Abadan are sprayed with D.D.T. every six weeks or two months. Finally, the Company's health department is responsible for the cleansing and incineration of refuse in its own areas and on behalf of the Abadan municipality. This is a very important measure in keeping down the breeding of flies, which in turn cuts down many diseases. The Company contributes half the expenses of the municipal district's cleansing scheme. PRIMARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATION " In 1935, 8 per cent, of labour was literate ; in 1948, 14 per cent. was literate. It is hoped that by 1955 at least 40 per cent, of labour will be literate. Illiteracy definitely holds back the various training schemes of the Company. Illiterate or semi-literate men can only with great difficulty learn the instructions and methods of handling complicated machines in modern industry." This significant statement, which can be read in a pamphlet prepared by the Company concerning the Company's educational and training schemes, illustrates only too well the need for improving the standard SOCIAL SERVICES 43 of education in south Iran not only from the point of view of the Company's interest but also and primarily in order to further the advancement of the whole population in that region. Elementary education has recently been made compulsory in Iran and is the responsibility of the Government, but lack of school buildings and of teachers has so far prevented the provision of more than a fraction of the educational facilities which would be necessary to fulfil the requirements of the Education Act. Thanks, however, to the outstanding contributions made by the Company towards meeting these requirements, Abadan ranks today among the cities of Iran where the proportion of children attending primary schools is highest.1 There are 43 primary schools in the areas of the Company's operations (20 in Abadan and 23 in Fields) and, of these, 29 were built and equipped entirely by the Company and three were built by the Company but paid for by the Government. The other schools were built and equipped either by the Government or by the local population. The number of children receiving primary education in 1949 was 9,500 in Abadan and 5,000 in the oilfields. In addition, the three secondary schools in the Company's areas have been built by the Company. Many of the schools in Abadan are housed in new permanent buildings designed and erected as schools, which compare not unfavourably with modern European school buildings ; but classes are generally overcrowded to the point that children must attend lessons in turn and even so they are often seated three and four at desks which are designed to accommodate only two. All primary and secondary schools in the area carry out exclusively the official Iranian teaching programme and are staffed by the Government. Government expenditure on public education has increased threefold from 1945 to 1949, but in order to attract and retain teachers in the area the Company has found it necessary to provide free quarters for the majority of them and to pay to all locally engaged teachers an allowance of up to 90 per cent, of their basic salary, as they are not entitled to draw the corresponding outstation allowance which is paid by the Government to teachers coming from other provinces. Again, with a view to attracting teachers, the Company pays to all those who are stationed in Abadan, an additional 25 per cent, as a " bad climate " allowance. A description has already been given in another part of this report of the most important technical educational institution in south Iran, the Abadan Technical Institute.2 1 Out of an estimated number of 18,000 children within the compulsory primary school age, the number of children attending school in Abadan in 1949 was 9,500. 2 See Chapter III. 44 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN EDUCATION FOR ADULT WORKERS A great effort is being made by the Government throughout Iran to counteract illiteracy among adult workers. In Abadan and the oilfields the Government scheme for adult education has been generously supported by the Company and has found a prompt and wide response amongst the oil workers v/ho realise that literacy will open to them new opportunities for advancement. The local education authorities provide facilities for Company wage earners to obtain the Government literacy certificate for adults, and the Company pays the fees of teachers at evening classes run in the Government schools. More than 6,000 workers were attending these classes in 1949. The Company, on the other hand, runs English classes for its workers. In the 1948-1949 session, 1,326 employees took part in the final examination of these classes. TRANSPORT A regular bus service is operated in Abadan and the oilfields to transport wage earners and staff employees to and from work, to collect school children and for social purposes. In Abadan there are two different types of buses, one, provided with seating accommodation, for staff employees and the other, with standing accommodation only, for wage earners. The bus fleets servicing Company areas are owned and maintained by the Company, but the service in Abadan is operated by a contractor. All passengers pay fares, but in Abadan (though not in the oilfields) wage earners receive an allowance equivalent to the fare to and from. work for each day they are present at work. The transport system in all areas of the Company's operations has been planned to serve the vast majority of those who have a need for it. A small number of workers living at the periphery of Abadan complain of a certain irregularity in the service, which is the cause of their being penalised for being late at work, and in the oilfields a number of workers living in villages which are too far from the production centres or which cannot be reached by road must walk or cycle to their place of work. Bicycles have been sold by the Company to its employees at reduced prices and are used by a great number of workers as their regular means of transport, especially where the country is flat, as in Abadan. Communications in Khuzistan owe much to the extensive system of roads, bridges and ferries which the Company has built there as part of its own operations. Although maintained and operated at the Company's expense, these facilities are available to the general public. i V Company shops at Ferahabad »•wat * i » • . .ff ?? Workers' children at play, Masjid-i-Sulaiman. company-built | The houses are Scene at trachoma clinic Building a workers' house at Agha J ari f\j ¡fi;;; - i. - * - * . SOCIAL SERVICES 45 RECREATION Recreation facilities of many kinds which the Company has provided for its employees help in no small measure to brighten life in the Company areas. For the European and non-European staff employees, social life is closely associated with the activities of the four clubs which the Company has built, equipped and put at their disposal in Abadan. The largest of these, with about 3,000 members, is the " Bashgah Iran ", which has tennis courts, billiards, a winter and summer bar, badminton, table tennis and volley ball as well as football and hockey grounds. It also has a library and an outdoor cinema for the summer months. Besides the Bashgah Iran there are the " Bawarda Club ", which has a main hall, reading room, library, bar, restaurant, billiards and table tennis, the "Bawarda Tennis Club "and the "Golestan Club", which has a limited membership of 300, 160 of whom are Iranians and 140 non-Iranians. There are numerous social activities during the course of each season and entertainments take the form of dances, fairs, concerts, and so on. In the field of sports, the Bashgah Iran has established a very good reputation not only locally but also at the All-Iran Games. The two swimming pools which are available in Abadan to staff employees and their families are frequented by hundreds of bathers during the warmer months. Clubs and swimming pools for staff employees are also provided in the larger and older oilfields. Recreation facilities for wage earners have not been developed to the same extent as those for staff employees, but it should be realised that in view of the thousands of persons involved such a scheme would entail a stupendous organisation. However, a great deal has been achieved by the Labour Sports Organisation, particularly among the younger element. Sports, and especially football, have taken a great hold on the young workers, and the 16 football fields provided by the Company in Abadan and those in the oilfields are fully occupied over the weekends. Athletics, hockey, volley ball, basket ball and table tennis are among other sports that are being keenly played by the Company workmen and their sons. A swimming pool for wage earners and members of their families has been recently completed in Abadan. In Masjid-i-Sulaiman the Company has built a workers' club which has a hall, a dining room, a bar and a kitchen as well as a cinema and a swimming pool. In Abadan the Company has built and operates a chain of 35 cinemas with a total seating accommodation for about 16,000. Of these cinemas two are for training, 11 for labour, 10 for labour and staff, 10 for staff only and two for seamen. 4 CHAPTER VII THE TRADE UNION SITUATION Trade unionism is of recent growth in Iran. The need for it was not felt until factory industries began to develop in the country, and such industries have grown up only in the last 25 years. Unfortunately the trade union movement has been disturbed during its short period of existence by political influences, and its organisation has been handicapped by personal rivalries. In any case, such a movement could only take root with difficulty in view of the characteristics of the people and the conditions of the country. THE TRADE UNION MOVEMENT Before the second world war, trade unionism in Iran was suppressed. From 1921 to 1941 the country was ruled by Reza Shah, whose authority was absolute. In 1941 the Shah was deposed by the Allies and his place was taken by bis son, who has encouraged the spread of democratic ideas and institutions. After the fall of Reza Shah, trade unions were formed openly, and, as was to be expected, various organisations grew up in different parts of the country. During the war little was known about the workers' organisations in Iran, but in 1945 they appeared upon the international scene at the first congress of the new World Federation of Trade Unions in Paris in September and at the 27th Session of the International Labour Conference which followed in October-November. Prominent among them was the Federated Trade Unions of Iranian Workers, headed by a Central Council and formed by agreement between a certain number of the unions on 1 May 1943. This organisation was received into affiliation by the W.F.T.U. at the Paris Congress. At that time there were four main trade union organisations in Iran» namely, the Central Council of Federated Trade Unions of Iranian Workers, which claimed to have 200,000 members ; the Central Council of Workers and Agricultural Workers of Iran, which claimed 153,000 members ; the Trade Union of Workers and Handicraftsmen of Iran (35,000) ; and the Trade Union of Workers and Peasants (10,000). All these organisations were represented at the 27th Session of the THE TRADE UNION SITUATION 47 International Labour Conference (Paris, 1945). In accordance with the Constitution of the I.L.O., the Iranian Government had been called upon to appoint one workers' delegate to the Conference and an appropriate number of advisers, in agreement with the most representative organisation of workers in the country, and it appointed Mr. Chams Sadri of the Central Council of Workers and Agricultural Workers as the delegate, Mr. Youssef Eftekhari of the Trade Union of Workers and Peasants as adviser and substitute delegate, and several other advisers, including Mr. Hosseine Tadjbakhch of the Trade Union of Workers and Handicraftsmen and Mr. Ezatollah Atighehtchi of the Central Council of Federated Trade Unions. The Central Council lodged a protest, however, against the composition of the delegation, claiming that the Iranian Government should not appoint as representatives of the Iranian workers persons other than delegates of the Central Council, and asserting that some members of the workers' delegation were not workers' representatives but Government officiais or representatives of employers.1 This situation illustrated the confusion and uncertainty which prevailed in regard to the Iranian trade union movement at the time. In its report to the Conference the Credentials Committee outlined the facts as submitted by the representatives of the various organisations and by the delegates of the Iranian Government and indicated that the Central Council of Federated Trade Unions seemed to be at that time the only organisation of a national character which had secured official recognition by the new World Federation of Trade Unions, that the four organisations in question apparently had marked political tendencies varying widely from one another, and that trade union organisation in Iran was certainly very rudimentary.1 The Credentials Committee did not, however, recommend that the Iranian workers' delegate and advisers be refused admission to the Conference. It will no doubt be remembered that the Central Council of Federated Trade Unions was closely associated with the Tudeh Party, a political movement which was believed by the Government to have come under communist influence, as also was the Central Council itself, whose General Secretary, Reza Rousta, was arrested and charged with being a communist organiser. During 1946 the Tudeh Party was accused of supporting the separatist movement in Azerbaidjan and was also held responsible for disturbances which occurred in Isfahan and among the oil workers in Khuzistan. Most of the Tudeh leaders were arrested 1 International Labour Conference, 27th Session, Paris, 1945 : Record of Proceedings, pp. 317-321. 48 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN and the party became disorganised. The Central Council continued its activity, however, though it lost much of its support. To counteract the influence of Tudeh and the Central Council, encouragement was given by the Government to the formation of a new organisation called the Federation of Trade Unions of Iranian Workers, which is known by the abbreviation of its Persian name as E.S.K.I. This organisation was recognised by the Iranian Government as the most representative organisation in the country, and in 1947 one of its representatives was appointed workers' delegate to the 30th Session of the International Labour Conference in Geneva. Two advisers were also appointed from the same organisation.1 The delegates to the 1948 and 1949 Sessions of the Conference were likewise representatives of the E.S.K.I. At the end of 1949, E.S.K.I. secured representation in the new International Confederation of Free Trade Unions which was formed after the withdrawal of a number of organisations from the W.F.T.U. LEGAL POSITION OF TRADE UNIONS Under the first Labour Law in Iran, which came into force in May 1946, provision was made for trade unions to be recognised. The articles of this Act which related to the trade unions dealt with the following subjects : formation of trade unions (Article 21) ; penalties against persons causing individuals by force or menace to join unions or preventing them from joining unions (Article 22) ; and action to be taken if a union were established in contravention of Article 21, or if it exceeded its prescribed rights or limits, or if it disturbed public order (Article 23). The new Labour Law contains provisions relating to the trade unions which may be summarised as follows : Workers and employers in the same occupation or belonging to the same undertaking may form trade unions for the defence of their occupational interests. Such unions are to be registered in accordance with special regulations. The members of the council of a trade union must be of Iranian nationality. The use of intimidation or victimisation with a view to compelling workers to join a trade union or to prevent them joining a trade union is prohibited. Trade unions in the same profession may form federations or amalgamations which will be subject to the legal provisions relating to trade unions and will enjoy the rights and privileges of such unions. 1 International Labour Conference, 30th Session, Geneva, 1947 : Record of Proceedings, pp. 361-362. THE TRADE UNION SITUATION 49 The regulations made under the Act of 1946 remain in force until further notice. They prescribe the conditions under which trade unions may be established, registered, suspended and dissolved.1 OIL WORKERS' UNIONS It would appear that the principal trade union organisations in Iran at the present time are the Federation of Trade Unions of Iranian Workers (E.S.K.I.), the Central Council of Unions of Workers and Peasants (E.M.K.A.)—which, like E.S.K.I., includes unions in the various industries—and the unions in the petroleum industry. There are also a certain number of small so-called " independent " unions. This is not the place for a complete account of the trade union movement in Iran ; suffice it to say that the main centres of trade union activity are Teheran, Isfahan, Abadan, and to a lesser extent, Masandaran. Of the two general organisations—E.S.K.I. and E.M.K.A.—it would appear that E.S.K.I. is the stronger in point of numbers. The oil workers' unions were formed as completely separate bodies and until recently had little contact with the trade union movement in the other parts of the country. Organisation was first developed among petroleum workers, as in other industries, during the war. For a time the petroleum workers were much influenced by the Tudeh Party and by the Central Council of Federated Trade Unions, but their organisation broke down after the strike and the disturbances which occurred in the industry in 1946. In Abadan a new start was made in 1947, since when there have been two separate unions, both with roots in the organisation which existed before the strike. One of them—which would seem to be the stronger—is known as the Trade Union of Workers of Khuzistan. This union has been duly registered under the Labour Law. In spite of the general character of its title, and in spite of its claim to be a union for the whole province, it is primarily an oil workers' organisation centred in Abadan, and it is hardly 1 These regulations, which were issued in February 1947, relate to the definition of a union, the conditions for the formation of a union, approval of its constitution by the Ministry of Labour, the efforts to be made to prevent a plurality of unions with the same objectives in one place, right of appeal if permission to form a union is refused, procedure for the registration and recognition of unions, amendments to union rules, federation or amalgamation, provisions to be included in union rules, prohibition of foreign nationals from holding office in unions, publication of balance sheets every six months and examination of balance sheets by the Ministry of Labour, discussion of the balance sheet at the general meeting of the union and submission of accounts to the Ministry of Labour, dissolution or suspension of unions, withdrawal of recognition if the union remains in voluntary abeyance for a period of two years, prohibition of discrimination by employers in regard to membership of a particular union, prohibition of force or threats to induce persons to join or refrain from joining a union, and advice and assistance to be given by the Ministry of Labour in regard to the formation of unions. 50 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN likely to have many members in other industries. The adviser to this union, Mr. A. G. Mohammadi, was one of the workers' delegates to the second session of the Petroleum Committee of the I.L.O. in 1948. The other organisation is the Trade Union of Petroleum Workers, which likewise is based upon Abadan. This organisation was dissolved in 1948 but has since applied to be re-registered. The Mission was informed by the Company that both organisations are recognised by the Company. The only other unions in Abadan—all of which are in process of registration—are a union for contract workers employed by private firms, a union for contractors, and a bakers' union. Contacts between the workers in Abadan and those in Fields are slight. In Masjid-i-Sulaiman—the oldest field—there is a small union which was formed early in 1949 and which is known as the Union of Workers in the Petroleum Area. This union is in process of registration and is quite independent of those in Abadan. One of the principal members of the Central Committee of the union, Mr. Abdollah Parvizi, was a workers' delegate to the second session of the Petroleum Committee. As far as the Mission was able to ascertain, there are no other unions of oil workers in the Fields area. TRADE UNION ACTIVITY Although trade unions exist among the oil workers, it cannot yet be said that their organisation is sound or that their activities are fully developed. It is, indeed, difficult to obtain a clear idea of the extent of their organisation, the nature of their activities or the policies that they pursue. The unions in Abadan and Fields claim to have several thousand members between them, and it is probable that they are in fact supported by large numbers of the workers. Contributions are collected and registers kept, but it was impossible for the Mission to ascertain how many members pay their contributions regularly and how many are simply counted as members because they have at some time or another indicated their support for the union. Clearly, however, whatever their actual membership, the unions represent large bodies of the men and are entitled to speak on their behalf. In regard to the activities of the unions, it would seem that less attention is paid than in the highly industrialised countries to the organisation of meetings, the formulation of policy, the dissemination of information and the settlement of problems by way of negotiation with the employers or with the Government authorities. Much of the work of the unions' representatives is concerned with the grievances of individual workers— THB TRADE UNION SITUATION 51 not only grievances which relate to their working conditions but also complaints in regard to housing, medical treatment, clothing, and other problems of a general and domestic character. Much of this kind of work arises in connection with the administration of the Aid Fund, out of which grants are made to workers to assist them in meeting their expenses in case of marriage, births, large families, accidents, invalidity and funerals. It is significant that the general approach seems to be to take up individual complaints rather than to deal with problems on behalf of large categories of workers or of the labour force as a whole. It was difficult to discern clearly what policies have been laid down by the three unions in Abadan and Fields and what specific programmes they are following at the moment. The two unions in Abadan do not seem to be separated by any differences in outlook or policy, e.g., in regard to the problem of craft and industrial unionism, or to the attitude to be adopted towards political parties. Their separation would appear to be due more to accidental causes and to personal rivalries. The Mission was not able to compare the policies of the unions by reference to published reports of conferences or of trade union journals, since such material is not available. Nor could it examine copies of resolutions or statements of policy adopted by meetings or demonstrations, for the same reason. However, as an indication of the problems with which the three unions are concerned, the following is a list of subjects to which one or other of them drew attention during their interviews with the Mission : housing, health and medical services, educational and training facilities, the provision of canteens, clubs and libraries, transport services, the level of the minimum wage, freedom of association, dismissals and the problem of contract labour. Of the above subjects, it would probably be true to say that those which are uppermost in the workers' minds and in the preoccupations of the unions are housing, medical treatment, the cost of living, the fear of dismissal and the problem of contract labour. One clearly marked form of activity carried on by the unions is the representation of the workers on the various joint and tripartite committees that have been established. These include the joint departmental committees set up in the plant, the factory councils, the boards for the settlement of disputes, and the High Labour Council.1 The joint departmental committees are voluntary bodies set up on the initiative of the Company, while the other forms of machinery are provided for by the Labour Law. The work of the joint departmental committees is a matter for arrangement between the Company and the workers' representatives, 1 See also Chapter IX. 52 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN while the powers and duties of the other bodies are outlined in the Labour Law and prescribed in more detail in regulations made thereunder. Except in the case of the joint departmental committees, provision is made that the workers' representatives on these various bodies shall be nominated by the unions where unions exist. This recognition of the trade unions in legal instruments is significant in a country in which both industry and trade unionism are relatively new. HANDICAPS TO TRADE UNION DEVELOPMENT Trade unionism in Iran—as in many other industrially underdeveloped countries—labours under difficulties which are not always known and understood in the countries where industry and trade unionism are well established. In Iran it is difficult for trade unions to collect contributions regularly and to maintain exact records of their membership. As a result of the widespread illiteracy, only a small percentage of the workers are able to read announcements and publications, and a still smaller percentage are capable of keeping books and accounts and conducting correspondence. These factors naturally complicate the administrative work of the unions and also the organisation of meetings and conferences and the conduct of trade union elections. They affect the oil workers' unions, of course, as well as the unions in other industries. Moreover, the general attitude of the people seems to be to regard public questions primarily from the point of view of the individual and family. It is therefore customary for the workers to treat the problems arising out of their work as personal grievances rather than as matters with which other workers may also be concerned and which should therefore be settled according to common rules. In other words, the sense of solidarity and mutual help which lies behind all trade union activity is not yet sufficiently developed to enable the unions to function with full efficiency. However, the relative immaturity of the Iranian trade union movement is not due merely to difficulties arising from the outlook, the traditions and the comparative illiteracy of the Iranian workers. There are other influences which in various ways affect circles much wider than the working class, and these influences can be readily appreciated if the historical background of the country is borne in mind. The institutions of freedom and democracy are too recent in Iran for the whole population to have realised the rights and duties which they entail. It should also be remembered that the country's internal and external situation has not yet been sufficiently consolidated to allow the executive power to refrain from resorting from time to time to exceptional security measures or to THE TRADE UNION SITUATION 53 abandon all forms of intervention in fields which in older democracies would be left entirely free from political influences. In short, the Iranian workers have only a brief experience of trade union activities in a country in which democratic forms of government are relatively new. It is to be hoped that the development of responsible trade unionism in Iran will go hand in hand with the extension of democratic institutions generally. Finally, whereas the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company has been in a position to avail itself of the experience gathered in the most advanced industrial countries, not all the other employers in Iran have yet had sufficient time to grasp and master the problems of labour-management collaboration which are involved in the operation of large-scale industry. In these circumstances it is not yet possible for workers to bring to their trade union activities an experience acquired in other fields, e.g., in local government, while even in the industrial sphere such democratic practices as collective bargaining and joint consultation are still in their early infancy. It may therefore be concluded that before the handicaps in the way of trade unionism in Iran can be overcome there will need to be both a development within the unions themselves and an improvement in the external circumstances by which the unions are affected. CHAPTER Vin LABOUR-MANAGEMENT RELATIONS Relations between the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company and its workers are regulated partly by means of voluntary arrangements and partly through machinery established under the provisions of the Labour Law. The voluntary arrangements find their expression in joint departmental committees, while the statutory machinery takes the form of works councils, arbitration boards and boards for the settlement of disputes. The Company has accepted the view that relations between employers and employed cannot be conducted in the long run on an individualistic basis. It feels that the regulation of employment relations on such a basis is unsatisfactory to management and workers alike and that it must eventually be replaced by methods and procedures for dealing with problems collectively. Accordingly the Company has considered how it may best facilitate the development of collective interests and aspirations on the part of the workers without interfering with the spontaneous growth of their organisations. JOINT DEPARTMENTAL COMMITTEES One of the steps which it has taken in this direction is to arrange for the participation of workers' representatives in the management of sports activities, clubs and welfare facilities. Another is to encourage the formation of joint departmental committees containing representatives of the workers and management. The early joint departmental committees were set up for the discussion of questions between the management and members of the staff, and the first of them began to function in 1943. Other committees were subsequently formed with a view to extending the principle of joint consultation to all sections of the staff and also to the wage earners in the different departments of the plant. It will be noted that the beginnings of this development preceded the passage of the first Labour Law in Iran, which came into force in 1946. A number of joint departmental committees were actually in operation in Abadan before the machinery provided for by the Labour Law could be put into effect. By the end of 1948 there were 34 joint LABOUR-MANAGEMENT RELATIONS 55 departmental committees in existence in Abadan. In the Fields area there were seven such committees in Agha Jari and two at Gach Saran and 23 factory councils in the other centres, of which 14 are at Masjid-iSulaiman, two at Lali, three at Haft Kel and one at Naft Safid. The factory councils in the Fields area, however, are akin to joint departmental committees and are not identical with the factory councils set up under the Labour Law. Joint departmental committees consist of not more than five representatives of the Company and not more than five workers' representatives, with the departmental manager as chairman. The workers' representatives are elected by the workers employed in the department concerned. One representative of the Company and one representative of the workers act as joint secretaries of each committee. The functions of the committees are to consider questions aflecting the persons employed in the department except those which are dealt with at a higher level or which come under the Labour Law; to consider proposals by the workers or the Company in regard to the promotion of industrial relations, improved production and efficiency ; to provide a channel of communication between the Company and the workers ; and to advise the factory councils on matters which the councils may refer to them. A feature of the joint departmental committees is that they promote the principles of joint discussion and labour-management co-operation at the lowest level—the department in which the worker is actually employed. Meetings of the joint departmental committees are held at regular intervals to discuss complaints and suggestions made by the workers and matters brought forward by the management. The subjects discussed include food supplies, accommodation, welfare amenities, the Aid Fund, promotion and discipline. Information is given by the Company on such matters as production, the medical facilities and other services available, and co-operation is asked for in regard to labour efficiency, safety organisation, the observance of regulations and so on. Matters not disposed of at one meeting are brought up again at later meetings when further information has been obtained. PROVISIONS OF THE LABOUR LAW Statutory provision for the establishment of industrial relations machinery is contained, as already stated, in the Labour Law. From the point of view of industrial relations the Labour Law is of considerable importance. It makes provision for the establishment of works councils, 56 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN arbitration boards and boards of settlement of disputes, and it also provides for the setting up of a High Labour Council. The regulations made under the Labour Law include those relating to factory councils (August 1946), the High Labour Council (August 1946), the internal organisation and procedure of the High Labour Council (September 1946) and the establishment and procedure of the arbitration boards and the boards of settlement of disputes (June 1947). In the provisions concerning the composition and procedure of these various bodies emphasis is laid throughout upon the tripartite principle, i.e., the participation of representatives of the employers, the workers and the Government. Outside the petroleum industry there is little experience of the working of joint machinery set up by agreement between the employers and workers, and it was therefore necessary for the Government to promote the formation of statutory bodies and to take part in their activities. FACTORY COUNCILS Under the Labour Law of 1946 provision was made for the establishment at each factory of a factory council composed of one representative of the workers, one representative of the employer and one representative of the Ministry of Labour. The workers' representative on the factory council was to be nominated by the union if the majority of the workers belonged to a union, otherwise he was to be selected by the workers themselves by a majority vote and under the supervision of the representative of the Ministry of Labour. The duties of the factory councils, as prescribed by the regulations made in August 1946, were to investigate individual disputes arising between a worker and his employer ; to investigate collective disputes between workmen and their employer ; to control the operations of the Aid Fund provided for by the Labour Law ; to create good understanding between workers and employers and to use special efforts to ensure the greatest efficiency in the work of the factory ; and to draft plans for accelerating work, economising time and materials and increasing production and output. Such councils were to be compulsory in factories with over 20 workers ; in smaller factories their formation was to be at the discretion of the Ministry of Labour. Meetings were to be held at least once a week on the premises of the factory. In the revised Labour Law which was passed in June 1949 and which came into force in June 1950, the provisions concerning factory councils LABOUR-MANAGEMENT RELATIONS 57 are replaced by a section providing that where a dispute arises between a worker or a number of workers in a factory and the employer, the disputes shall be referred in the first place to a factory conciliation board (in effect, the factory council) composed of the representative of the workers and the representative of the employers. This committee is to examine the question and attempt to bring the two parties to an agreement. So far, however, there has been no change in the regulations, and the factory councils continue to operate for the time being on the lines originally laid down. Factory councils have been set up in the areas of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company—both in Abadan and in Fields. Owing to the size and complexity of the operations in Abadan there are several factory councils attached to this one undertaking, and there is also a central factory council to administer the Aid Fund from which grants are made to workers in certain contingencies. Factory councils also exist in various other industries—textiles, tobacco, cement, railways, etc.—but they are not very numerous, as industrial activity in Iran is not extensive. It would seem, however, that the emphasis in their work is placed in the main upon the administration of the Aid Fund and the investigation of disputes. It is doubtful whether they have developed to any great extent their functions in regard to the promotion of production, efficiency and economy. SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES Under the first Labour Law individual disputes are settled by the factory council, whose decision is final and binding upon employer and worker alike. Collective disputes, however, if not settled by the factory council, are referred to an arbitration board consisting of one arbitrator nominated by the workers and one nominated by the employers. Provision is made for the appointment of an umpire or neutral chairman or, failing that, for a representative of the Ministry of Labour or the Department of Justice to act as umpire. If the majority of workers concerned belong to a trade union, the workers' arbitrator is to be nominated by that union. Disputes not satisfactorily settled by the arbitration board are to be referred to the local board for the settlement of disputes. In practice, however, few cases have been taken on appeal to these boards from an arbitration board. In the revised Labour Law it is provided that if the factory conciliation board referred to above does not bring the two parties into agreement the dispute is to be referred to a reconciliation committee (in effect, the former arbitration board) composed of representatives of the workers 58 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN and of the employer in the factory in question, together with a representative of the Ministry of Labour. A decision of the reconciliation committee, if unanimous, is final and binding. However, in the case of a dismissed worker, and in cases in which the plaintiff does not agree with the decision, the matter is to be referred to the board for the settlement of disputes. Provisions concerning the boards for the settlement of disputes are contained in both the original Labour Law and the new Law. Under the Law of 1946 it was provided that the boards should be composed of the local Governor or his representative, the chief of the local office of the Department of Justice or his representative, the local representative of the Ministry of Labour, two representatives of the workers and two of the employers. The board is presided over by the Governor. Similar provisions regarding the boards are contained in the revised Law. By virtue of regulations made under the Law of 1946 the workers' representatives (and those of the employers) are to be nominated by their union where a union is in existence. The board is required to meet at least once a week, or oftener at its discretion, in the Office of the Governor. The duties of the boards were defined in the regulations and may be summarised as follows : to deal with disputes not settled by the factory council and the arbitration board ; to deal with complaints from workers concerning their dismissal from employment ; to make a recommendation to the High Labour Council at the beginning of each year regarding the minimum wage to be paid during the year ; to revise this rate during the year in special circumstances ; and to prepare a list of the workers' minimum living requirements within the district concerned. It will be noted that the functions of the board for the settlement of disputes go beyond the settlement of disputes and that these bodies constitute, with the High Labour Council, the machinery for fixing minimum wages. Boards for the settlement of disputes are, of course, in operation in the petroleum industry in both Abadan and Fields. Under the original Law it was provided that no strike or lockout should take place before the expiration of the periods fixed for the operation of the machinery of conciliation and arbitration. Strikes were not to result in any wounding, beating, destruction, disturbance of public order and security or other misdemeanour. Persons contravening these provisions were to be liable to punishment under the penal laws. A similar provision has been included in the revised Law. LABOUR-MANAGEMENT RELATIONS 59 HIGH LABOUR COUNCIL At the apex of this system of committees and boards is the High Labour Council, which was set up under the Law of 1946 and which consists of three representatives of the employers and three of the workers, together with a number of representatives and advisers from various Government departments. The three workers' representatives were to be nominated by the trade union with the largest membership and the three employers' representatives by the union of private factory owners with the largest membership. The duties of the High Labour Council, as defined in the Law and in the regulations made in August 1946, may be summarised thus : to prepare Bills concerning labour questions and to prepare rules and regulations as provided for in the Labour Law; to supervise the application of labour legislation and of the Workmen's Insurance Act; to study all labour questions and to draw up schemes for creating employment, preventing unemployment, and obviating economic crises; to settle such disputes as are not settled by the authorities provided for in the Labour Law; to approve minimum wages for various categories of labour in the different parts of the country; and to supervise the administration of the Co-operative Fund and the Unemployment and Workers' Hygiene Fund. Meetings of the High Labour Council are to be held at least once a week at the Ministry of Labour in Teheran. An important change affecting the High Labour Council has been made in the revised Labour Law of 1949. Under this Law the composition of the High Labour Council remains substantially the same, though the list of Government representatives has been slightly varied. It is, however, provided that instead of being nominated by the strongest organisations the three workers' representatives and the three employers' representatives shall be elected at specially convened conferences. In the case of the three employers' representatives it is provided that the Ministry of Labour shall convene at Teheran, once a year, a conference of representatives of the employers and of the non-governmental employers' organisations registered under the Labour Law and employing not less than 500 workers each. Every employer and employers' organisation shall be entitled to one representative at the conference. The Ministry is also required to convene at Teheran, once a year, a conference of representatives of trade unions registered under the Labour Law and having not less than 100 members. Each union is allowed one representative at the conference. At their respective conferences the employers' and workers' delegates elect their representatives on the High Labour Council. 60 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN Such conferences were held at Teheran at the end of 1949. The employers' conference elected one representative from the north, one from Isfahan and one from the south—who was an official of the AngloIranian Oil Company. The three representatives elected by the workers were all delegates of E.S.K.I., which held a majority of the votes, since the voting was on the basis of one vote per union and most of the unions formed part of E.S.K.I. This result caused a certain amount of dissatisfaction among the oil workers' delegates, who felt that one of the three workers' representatives should have been an oil worker, in view of the fact that the petroleum industry is the most important in the country and employs the largest number of workers. Subsequently one of the E.S.K.I. representatives withdrew from the High Labour Council and his seat was offered to a representative of the Trade Union of Workers of Khuzistan which has its main membership among the oil workers in Abadan. The seat was, however, refused on the grounds that a representative of the oil workers should have been elected in proper form by the conference. It would appear that the acitivites of the High Labour Council have been mainly centred upon the examination of draft Bills and regulations, the fixing of minimum wages and the problems connected with the effective application of labour legislation, including the administration of the various funds. There can be no doubt that it has performed a most useful function by bringing together representatives of employers and workers to discuss with representatives of the Government at a high level the application and extension of labour legislation, the avoidance of disputes in industry, and the general problem of promoting satisfactory conditions of work. SUMMARY When the foregoing principles, practices and forms of machinery are examined in relation to the petroleum industry, it is clear that much useful experience in the development of industrial relations has already been gained, despite the fact that trade unionism and labour legislation in Iran are of such recent growth. The trade unions in Iran are still immature and inexperienced. The workers are inarticulate and unused to democratic methods. Only a small percentage of them are organised in trade unions and very few of them take an active and effective part in trade union activity. Largely because of these factors there is little genuine collective bargaining in Iran. The only reference to collective bargaining in the Labour Law is a provision that collective contracts shall be in writing and shall not be inconsistent with the labour legislation. Bakhtiari apprentice at Lali Coffee shop built by Company at Lali •M» fi? V . JÍI ,£Zì sìa- afct-J • ¡¿¿o'* <"•$..-: ^ ^ ü . ' ^ 9 « H .'.2 -> Drilling at Lali Applicants for work at labour office, Abadan LABOUR-MANAGEMENT RELATIONS 61 In the petroleum industry itself the problem of industrial relations is constantly overshadowed by the fact that the employer is a foreign company. Political and national feeling may therefore easily creep into the relations between the Company and its personnel. It would, however, appear from observations on the spot that relations between the workers and their immediate chiefs are good, and that most of the difficulties which arise are those which might be expected in view of the conditions of the job and of the area concerned. The solution of these difficulties is rendered more difficult by the widespread ilhteracy of the workers, by their lack of experience in consultation and negotiation and by the backwardness of their organisation. Difficulties no doubt arise also on the side of the Company, whose industrial relations policy has to be formulated at the top and carried out at various levels by a large number of foremen, instructors, job officers, managers, industrial relations officers and others. Clearly, in such a large organisation mistakes can be made both in the formulating and in the carrying out of an industrial relations policy. Individual officials of the Company may be just as likely to cause differences and misunderstandings as the workers themselves. It may nevertheless be affirmed that the Company has given clear evidence of its desire to promote satisfactory industrial relations by its initiative in forming the joint departmental committees, by its full participation in the work of the factory councils and other statutory bodies, and by its scrupulous observance of the provisions of the Labour Law. 5 CHAPTER IX THE WIDER SCENE When considering the problems of the petroleum industry in Iran, some regard must be paid to the conditions which apply in other industries, in other parts of the country and in other countries of the Near and Middle East. The problems of the petroleum industry, as of other industries, have to be dealt with in the light of the general circumstances and possibilities of the individual countries; it is therefore necessary to ask what standards it would be reasonable to expect in this industry—not in the world in general but in Iran in particular. It is also advisable to know how the situation compares with that in other industries of the country and in the same industry in neighbouring countries. One of the Mission's desires, therefore, was to ascertain whether the standards of the petroleum industry in Iran were typical of the country or whether they were exceptional, and how the methods adopted for dealing with the industry's industrial and social problems compared with those adopted elsewhere in the area. It is impossible to see the industry in its true perspective unless it is realised that the gigantic plant at Abadan and the installations in the oilfields—which are characteristic of the most modern developments in industrial organisation, science and technique—have been set down in a non-industrial country, far removed from other main centres of population. The industry represents something new in the country's experience, and the conditions of life and work of those employed in it are unknown to the great majority of the country's inhabitants. THE COUNTRY AND ITS PEOPLE Iran is a vast territory, as big as France, Italy, Norway and Spain combined. It is not on one of the world's great highways or crossroads but lies to one side of the routes connecting Europe and the Far East. It is therefore untouched by many of the influences which affect countries on the main lines of communication. Distances within the country are great and communications difficult. The few large cities, Teheran, Meshed, Tabriz and Isfahan, are widely separated, and the other populous THE WIDER SCENE 63 centres are more or less isolated by distances or by the difficulties in the way of travelling. In winter there are only three trains per week in each direction between Teheran and the industrial centres on the Caspian. Isfahan, the former capital of the country and one of its three biggest centres of industry, is not served by a railway at all. A telegram from Teheran to Abadan may take three days; a letter may take a week. About 70 per cent, of the country's area is made up of mountains, salt deserts and forests. Some districts, therefore, have very limited food supplies, which are supplemented, if at all, by supplies brought from other districts with great difficulty and at great expense. The climate shows considerable variations. In the north the mountain passes and railway tracks may be blocked in winter by heavy falls of snow, while in the south the tropical heat in summer may be almost unbearable, especially when the wind brings in humidity from the Persian Gulf. Iran's population is estimated to be in the neighbourhood of 17 million, whereas the combined population of the four European countries mentioned above is over 110 million. About two and a half million people live in 15 towns of 50,000 and upwards, the remaining fourteen and a half million being scattered over wide areas in smaller towns and villages. The great majority of the active population make their living from agriculture and stock raising; and only a few hundred thousand are employed in industry. It is probable that the factory workers are considerably outnumbered by the artisans and craftsmen who carry on their trades in their homes and in small workshops. Women and girls are employed in certain industries, e.g., in textile factories and in carpet weaving. There is also a good deal of child labour in factories and particularly in the workshops and bazaars. Agriculture is mainly carried on by the old-fashioned methods which have served from time immemorial. The primitive wooden plough drawn by oxen is a common feature of the countryside. There is little farm machinery, fertiUsers are scarce, and cultivation is made exceedingly difficult in most areas by the shortage of water. However, wheat and barley are grown in favourable districts, as well as rice, tea, sugar beet, fruit and vegetables. Other important crops include cotton and tobacco. Sheep, which are reared for their meat and wool, are the most numerous animals, and there are also large numbers of goats. Cows, horses, donkeys, oxen, camels and mules are important as suppliers of meat and milk or as draught animals and beasts of burden. LIVING CONDITIONS It is common knowledge that the living standards of the general population in Iran are seriously inadequate. As in other countries in 64 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN this region, there is a large amount of dire poverty, disease and misery, and this is to be borne in mind when the conditions of the petroleum workers are being considered. Owing in part to the circumstances already described, the nutrition standards of the mass of the people are low. Clothing, too, seems to be inadequate, at least in winter. Housing standards are likewise in great need of improvement. Although a good deal of new building is going on in the principal centres, the mass of the people live in primitive houses of baked mud, especially in the villages, while many of the townspeople find accommodation in single rooms. There is a great deal of overcrowding, both because of the smallness of the buildings and because the number of houses is insufficient. It is quite common for more than one family to share a small house and for a family to occupy a single room. Judged by modern housing standards, the houses themselves are for the most part deficient in the conveniences and amenities necessary for a hygienic and healthy Ufe. Except in the modern houses there is a lack of window space and ventilation. Only the larger houses in the main towns are lit by electricity or gas. Rooms are usually heated by small charcoal braziers or by kerosene stoves, for coal fires and central heating are rare. In the poorer houses there is an almost complete absence of the furniture that is known in the West. Tables and chairs are to be seen, but it is customary for the family to sit on matting and carpets on the floor. Other articles, such as bedsteads and clothes cupboards, are less usual. In winter the beds are generally made up on the floor ; in summer the family sleeps in the courtyard or on the roof. Clothes and valuables are kept in painted chests. Cooking is done as a rule in the open or in a special alcove of the courtyard ; cooking utensils are few and kitchen equipment simple. There is, as in other countries of this region, a wide gap between the well-to-do and the poor. A few people are very rich; the vast mass of the population is very poor; and there is no large and solid middle class between the two extremes. Health conditions are on a low level. There is a great deal of sickness and disease resulting from the climate and the inadequate standards of living. Trachoma, malaria and tropical diseases generally are common; tuberculosis is giving increased cause for concern; and much illness is brought about by malnutrition. Families are large in spite of the extremely high rate of infant mortality, and the pressure on accommodation and food supplies is therefore severe. There is no adequate national health service, while the health facilities in the municipalities are undeveloped as regards both prevention and treatment. Water THE WIDER SCENE 65 supplies, sanitation and sewage disposal leave much to be desired. There is a serious shortage of doctors : it would appear that about half the doctors are in Teheran and most of the remainder in the other large centres. The medical services fall far short of the requirements : there are few voluntary or public hospitals and there is a great need for more clinics of all kinds. Educational facilities are insufficient for the country's needs. By far the greater part of the population is illiterate. Efforts are being made to extend the educational system, and compulsory education for children has been provided for by law, but the majority of children do not yet attend school at all. Progress in education is slow because of the lack of school buildings and the shortage of teachers. Increased budgetary provision has recently been made for educational purposes, and a number of new schools have been opened. It will, however, take a considerable time to provide all the schools that are needed. The problem of securing enough teachers is also likely to cause difficulty, especially in the remote areas, not only because of the time taken for training teachers but also because the salaries and conditions of service are not sufficiently attractive. An intense effort to extend the educational services will be required for some years to come. Meantime it would appear that the facilities already provided are taken up with enthusiasm. The elementary schools are crowded—overcrowded, in fact—and still it is impossible to accommodate all who wish to attend; there is a growing demand for places in secondary schools; the number of university students has increased; and there is a keen desire among adult workers to attend the evening classes in which they can be educated up to elementary school standards. IRANIAN INDUSTRY Industry in Iran is neither extensive nor highly developed. The country is deficient in some of the most important raw materials for industry, though supplies of certain products, such as cotton and wool, are available. Minerals for heavy industry are either absent or unexploited, and only small quantities of some of them, such as copper ore, are produced. A little coal is obtained with great difficulty, and water power is negligible. The development of industry has also been hampered by transport difficulties, which increase the cost of both raw materials and finished products. On the other hand, the country possesses a considerable asset in its plentiful supply of oil. Some of the principal industries of Iran are old-established and traditional. These, however, are carried on for the most part in small workshops set up in the homes or in the bazaars. Factory industries 66 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN are of recent date. All the industrial plants, as distinct from the workshops, have in fact been established within the last quarter of a century. The principal centres of industry are the Teheran area and the province of Masandaran in the north, Isfahan on the central plateau and Abadan and Fields in the south. The most important industries, apart from petroleum, are the manufacture of textiles and carpets, the tobacco and sugar industries and the railways. Other industries are the manufacture of cement, chemicals, glass and various food products. Textile manufactures include cotton, wool, silk and jute, and textile factories of various kinds are found in Isfahan and in places as far apart as Meshed, Tabriz, Ahwaz and Shiraz. There is also a fair amount of handloom weaving. Carpets are traditionally hand made, and the work is carried on mainly by women and girls in small weaving sheds in such famous centres as Kashan, Kerman, Isfahan, Hamadan, Shiraz and Tabriz. Many carpets, however, are made in the mountain villages. Some of the industries are carried on in State-owned factories, which manufacture such products as sugar, textiles (cotton, wool, silk and jute), tobacco, glycerine, soap and cement. The Iranian State Railway is also a Government-owned enterprise. Most of the industrial establishments are small. The Abadan refineiy is, of course, by far the biggest. Apart from this there are a few factories employing several hundred workers and various other factories of medium size. Such plants, however, are not numerous. The predominating type of industrial establishment is the small workshop in which fewer than 10 workers are employed in making and repairing articles without the use of power-driven machinery. Most of these small establishments are run either by a single family or by a master craftsman with one or two journeymen and apprentices. It is usual for the goods to be sold direct to the customer by the craftsmen, who are manufacturers and merchants at the same time. Apart from the Government factories already mentioned, the principal factories of any size are the spinning and weaving mills in the cotton and woollen industries. These mills, since they are of modern construction, are usually light and roomy and are equipped in the main with British and German machinery dating from the 1930's. Factory industries have been introduced in Iran so recently that there has been no time for well-established industrial traditions and practices to grow up. There is no true industrial population, composed of working-class families, divorced from agricultural and pastoral pursuits and fully adapted to the ways of industry. Nor are there any industrial firms of long standing or old industrial families with deep.rooted experience of industrial methods, organisation and finance. THE WIDER SCENE 67 Accordingly, the characteristics of the petroleum workers which were described in Chapter H are broadly typical of the workers in other modern industries of the country. The lack of an industrial background, and the attachment to the old ways of Ufe, must obviously raise a whole series of problems of recruitment, labour turnover, vocational training, labour productivity, factory discipline and industrial relations. So far, the greater part of the labour force consists of first generation industrial workers; it is only now that the second generation is beginning to take its place in the various factories. The industrial employers have also had their problems, since they are relatively new to the industrial field. The oldest factories had only been in existence 10 or 15 years when the war broke out, so for about half of the period since they were opened they have had to meet the challenge of wartime and post-war conditions. Moreover, both private employers and those in charge of the Government factories have had much to learn regarding manufacturing processes, the upkeep of plant and machinery, and the conduct of industrial relations. In the textile industry, for example, as well as in other industries, the machinery, though modern, is in need of repairs and replacements. Many repairs to plants and machines have been carried out by Iranian mechanics, who have shown a great capacity for work of this kind, but the more extensive repairs and replacements cannot be performed without the aid of the makers. It would appear also that, while a high degree of mechanical skill has been developed in Iran, there is a great need of technicians possessing a thorough knowledge of manufacturing processes. As a result of these drawbacks, the various industries are faced with a serious problem of maintaining productive efficiency and holding their own against the competition of more experienced producers in some of the highly developed industrial countries. There is a great deal of unemployment in Iran, and this has led among other things to the retention of a certain amount of redundant labour in the factories with a view to avoiding further increases in the number of unemployed. LABOUR PROTECTION Legislation for the protection of labour is of recent date. References have already been made to the Labour Law which was enacted in 1946 and revised during 1949, and it is therefore unnecessary to summarise its provisions here. It might, however, be pointed out that the Law is by no means exhaustive and that it could well be extended in a number of directions. Some of its provisions, moreover, still need to be given their full implications by the issue of regulations. Far-reaching regu- 68 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN lations have already been made on certain of the matters covered by the Law, but the intentions of the Law will not be fully realised until all the outstanding regulations have been published. No less important is the question of the machinery for the enforcement of the Law. The factory inspectors and other officials charged with the supervision of the execution of the Law are too few in number and insufficiently trained, and are not equipped with adequate powers. It would also appear that the Law and the regulations made thereunder do not in all cases provide the requisite penalties for non-observance. The result is that the officials of the Ministry of Labour are sometimes powerless to secure the effective application of the legal provisions. The Ministry of Labour itself, which was not formed until August 1946, has lived through a trying period. There have already been several Ministers of Labour and there have also been times when no Minister of Labour was appointed. In these circumstances it has been difficult to develop and carry out a consistent policy. Furthermore the Ministry has been seriously understaffed, both at headquarters and in the provinces. Until the staff of the Ministry of Labour is reinforced and the legal provisions strengthened it is unlikely that the workers will receive the full protection which the Law was intended to provide. Here it might be mentioned that at the time of the Mission's visit Iran had not yet ratified any of the Conventions adopted by the International Labour Conference during the last 30 years. It is understood, however, that consideration is being given to the possibihty of ratifying some of the Conventions in the near future. THE COUNTRY'S NEEDS From the foregoing brief survey it will be seen that Iran has many heavy and pressing needs to meet. The situation of the petroleum workers cannot be divorced from that of their fellow workers in other industries. There is an all-round need for improvements on behalf of the workers in industry generally, of their families and of the population as a whole. Health services, medical facilities, housing and educational facilities urgently call for extension. Social security schemes are required to provide adequate benefits and allowances for the sick, the aged and the unemployed. Action is also required for the development of such public services as sanitation, sewage disposal, the supply of drinking water and the provision of gas or electricity for the homes. The extension of roads and railways, the development of transport services for passengers and goods, the improvement of communications and the provision of cheaper fuel for industry and the home—all these Students at adult training establishment, Abadan 5 Control room in a production unit, Gach Saran cRiiont* Iranian apprentices at Abadan workshops THE WIDER SCENE 69 urgently need attention. To do all these things will involve considerable expense and will call for the provision of technical assistance by other countries. It is encouraging to note that the needs have been recognised by the country's authorities and that proposals for tackling them are included in the seven-year plan, for which a special organisation with substantial funds has been established.1 Reverting to the petroleum industry, there is one other point to be borne in mind, namely, that many of the problems encountered by the petroleum industry in Iran are also met with in other countries of the Middle East. During the Mission's stay in Iraq, attention was drawn to a number of matters which were being dealt with by the Iraq Petroleum Company at Kirkuk on similar lines to those adopted by the AngloIranian Oil Company. These included such subjects as the construction of housing accommodation, the provision of medical and hospital services, the supply of water and electricity, the sale of food and clothing at subsidised prices, and the organisation of vocational training facilities. Many of the problems in Iraq are indeed similar to those in Iran, but there are some significant differences. For example, the problems are far bigger at Abadan, where over 30,000 workers are employed, than at Kirkuk, where 5,000 are employed; moreover Abadan has had periods of extremely rapid growth, during which the difficulties were aggravated. Again, many of the workers at Kirkuk have found accommodation in the town, which has been in existence for centuries, whereas all the housing at Abadan has had to be built since the Company began operations there. Further, much of the food needed by the population of Kirkuk can be grown locally, whereas it is quite impossible to grow enough food in the Abadan area for the requirements of the population. Other oil-producing areas which are confronted with some of the problems of the petroleum industry in Iran are Kuwait, Bahrein Island and Saudi Arabia, in all of which the companies have been faced with the need to provide housing accommodation, food supplies, health services, training facilities and so on. The Mission did not visit any of these areas, but it gathered that in all of them the problems are for the most part on a somewhat smaller scale than those in Iran. Apparently the area most nearly comparable with the oil-producing area of Iran is Saudi Arabia, where the next largest number of workers is employed and where there has been a rapid development of the industry in conditions somewhat similar to those at Abadan. 1 In connection with the seven-year plan an Iranian Oil Company is being formed to prospect for oil in the areas not covered by existing concessions. CHAPTER X CONCLUSIONS In the foregoing chapters the Mission has contented itself with describing the conditions which it found in Iran. It now remains to sum up its impressions and formulate its conclusions. The first observation to be made is that the oil industry in Iran, with its large-scale activities and its modern techniques, is not operating in an industrial area, alongside other industries, but in a remote and almost barren region, in a country in which industry is of very recent growth. The same is true, of course, of the oil industry in a number of other countries, but the point needs to be borne in mind. Regarding the oil areas in Iran, it is necessary to remember also their situation, climate and general characteristics—the desert surroundings of Abadan, the wild and rocky hills in which the oil is found, the low rainfall and the tropical heat. The great extent of the oilfields is another factor : each large field stretches for many miles, and the fields are separated from one another by several hours of driving over mountain roads. Even by aeroplane the journey from Abadan to Masjid-i-Sulaiman or from Masjid-i-Sulaiman to Agha Jari takes an hour. Abadan, though a single area, is nevertheless of the size of a very large town. Its concentration of tens of thousands of workers, nearly all dependent upon the one great refinery, is one of the most important factors to be taken into account in any attempt to understand the industry's problems. Hardly less important is the fact that the growth of this population has during certain periods been extremely rapid. Added to these circumstances are the virtual isolation of Abadan and Fields, which are far removed from the other important industrial areas of the country, and the inadequacy of communications of all kinds or of local public services. Concerning the oil workers, there is a striking difference between the qualifications which the local labour possesses and the qualities which the industry needs. The petroleum industry calls for men with every degree of skill to undertake a considerable variety of jobs, whereas the workers available in Iran were atfirstilliterate, untrained and completely devoid of any industrial background or traditions. Even now, after 40 years of CONCLUSIONS 71 activity, almost every worker taken on by the Company has to be educated, trained and initiated into the ways of industry. In dealing with this labour force account must be taken of their particular form of family life, their tribal loyalties, their attachment to nomadic habits and the influence of their ancient traditions. While mutual help is practised within the family and the tribe, there is still a need for greater co-operation over wider areas. This is one of the obstacles to be overcome in developing a sense of common interest among workers in the same grades and categories who work under the same conditions and have to face the same problems. Workers bred in such an atmosphere expect to be cared for by persons in authority; they are willing to follow a leader and to be told what they should do; they do not look for responsibility and they regard their difficulties as personal grievances which should be brought to the notice of people with influence. Their system of society for many centuries was autocratic. Their minds have been formed in what used to be called the unchanging East, but profound changes have occurred and are still occurring, sometimes with disconcerting effects. The development of modern industry in Iran implies that people whose minds are firmly set in traditional ways are exposed to powerful influences from a different world of thought and action. The fact that the old ways are so deeply rooted constitutes one of the big problems of the industry; but an even greater problem arises from the fact that the new ideas are producing profound and rapid changes in people's lives and thoughts. Clearly, therefore, the labour and social problems of the petroleum industry in Iran—and presumably in the other countries of the Middle East—are very different from those encountered in highly industrialised countries, particularly in the West. RECRUITMENT The arrangements made by the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company for the recruitment of its workers seem to correspond closely to the needs and conditions of the country. The arrangements appear to be well organised and complete. Full employment records are kept in respect of each worker, and it is therefore possible for every man's position to be considered at any time in full knowledge of the facts. There is no apparent over-all shortage of recruits for the industry, though the number of men presenting themselves for employment tends to vary considerably with the seasons. There is, however, a definite shortage of workers with the required skills. The problem of recruitment, and many of the other personnel problems, is complicated by the high 72 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN rate of turnover in some at least of the grades. It may be anticipated that as long as the general shortage of skilled labour in Iran persists, many trained workers will leave the Company's service every year in order to take jobs in more attractive areas or in their native towns and villages. Accordingly, the Company will presumably continue to enrol and train many more workers than would normally be needed for its own operations. On the other hand, it will be difficult to increase the rate at which Iranian nationals are recruited for employment in the higher categories of wage earners and as members of the supervisory staff. There is no reluctance on the part of the Company to recruit and promote Iranians for those categories. On the contrary, the Mission understands that the positions are open to all who acquire the necessary qualifications and experience. In any case, the proportion of Iranians in the Company's employment is large, even in the higher categories, and it is increasing. TRAINING The Mission was impressed by the extent of the Company's training scheme and the efficient way in which it is organised. Training is provided by the Company for every kind of job, industrial and commercial, and for every category and grade. Theoretical and practical instruction are successfully combined, and it is obvious that the courses have been carefully planned and that considerable thought has been given to the teaching methods to be employed. The Technical Institute inAbadan, which is the apex of the Company's training system, is considered to be one of the foremost educational institutions in the country. The Mission was struck not only by the arrangements for training but also by the serious and concentrated manner in which the trainees apply themselves to their tasks, whether in the Technical Institute or in the adult training centres or in the apprentice workshops. Another notable feature of the scheme is that it provides opportunities for further training for those who fail to pass their tests. The whole scheme offers an inducement to workers to improve their education and skill and thus to quahfy for increments in wages and for promotion. On the whole, the Mission formed the view that the Company's training scheme is adequate and will in time provide all the trained Iranian personnel required to fill any post in the Company's service. WAGES AND PRICES The Company's wage structure includes definite rates for every grade and category, with provision for increments after periods of satisfactory CONCLUSIONS 73 service and promotion from grade to grade. As a result, the overwhelming majority of the workers receive more than the statutory minimum wage. Such complaints as the Mission heard related not so much to the wage scales as to the relation between wages and prices. As far as the Mission was able to judge, the Company scrupulously observes the provisions of the law concerning the minimum wage ; the Mission feels, however, that a bigger effort might be made by the authorities to control the prices of essential commodities on the free market and to ensure that greater quantities of these commodities are made available. Some of the trade union representatives complained that the authorities have fixed the minimum wage on the basis of a combination of free market prices and of the prices of goods obtainable in the Company's shops, whereas they felt that it should have been fixed on the basis of the free market prices only. If this idea were adopted, however, it would seem (a) that there would no longer be any reason for the Company to continue its present policy of importing and distributing essential goods at controlled prices ; (b) that an immediate and substantial increase in wages would be necessary; and (c) that, as a result of inflationary pressure and the discontinuance of Company imports, the prices on the free market would increase in even greater proportion than wages. The consequences of such developments would be disastrous for all the parties concerned. In the Mission's view the real problem—and it is a serious one which needs the full co-operation of the Company, of the workers and of the authorities—is to maintain the purchasing power of wages. For this reason it would seem to be essential to retain the Company's food distribution scheme for the time being and to support it by effective measures of price and rent control. It would also be desirable to encourage every effort made to increase the production of food and other necessities in the Company's areas and to promote the import of such commodities. HOURS OF WORK No specific complaints were submitted to the Mission with regard to hours of work, and it would indeed seem that the hours will bear comparison with those of other industries in Iran and with those worked in the petroleum industry in other countries. Such grievances as exist can be dealt with through the existing machinery of consultation. WORKING CONDITIONS Generally speaking, the working conditions appear to be acceptable to the workers and the unions, though there are naturally a number of grievances, some slight, some transitory and others more serious. The 74 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN smaller grievances can, of course, be adjusted without much difficulty, but there are a few which are not so easily disposed of, especially those which arise out of the nature of some of the industrial processes. Requests for a more generous distribution of ice to men employed in parts of the refinery where the work is particularly oppressive, or for more frequent rest periods in hot weather for the women employed in the laundry, are examples of problems which need not present any great difficulty. On the other hand, it is clear that difficulties of a more serious nature are likely to arise in connection with processes which are by their nature disagreeable and perhaps even dangerous. The workers drew the attention of the Mission in particular to the discomforts of the men who work in dust while handling sulphur and to the anxiety of those employed in the S0 2 plant who fear that their lungs may be affected by the fumes. Work of this kind has to be done, but the reactions of the men are only to be expected. Similarly, with regard to the wearing of protective clothing by men in contact with acids, although the men know that the clothing is needed for their own protection, they feel aggrieved at having to wear it, especially in the heat of the Persian Gulf. Problems of this kind are not easy to remove entirely and they should be given continuing attention through the machinery which already exists. SOCIAL INSURANCE Social insurance provisions in operation in Iran provide (a) benefits to wage earners who suffer accidents and illness as a result of employment, and (b) benefits in case of marriage, pregnancy, large families, childbirth, burial and legal aid. The Labour Law also provides for assistance to workers and members of their families in case of accident or illness not caused by employment and for old-age and disablement benefit, but the regulations for the application of these provisions have not yet been issued and the provisions of the Law are not in force. This gap is partly filled by the various benefits provided voluntarily by the Company for its workers. The situation would, however, be eased for all concerned if these regulations could be issued and the intentions of the Law put into operation. SAFETY The Company is giving serious attention to the safety of the workers, both by attempting to make their jobs as safe as possible and by providing safety devices and protective clothing when the risks cannot CONCLUSIONS 75 be removed entirely. Although safety questions are already discussed to a certain extent by the joint departmental committees, it would be an advantage if special safety committees could be established for the various parts of the Company's operations. This would encourage safety consciousness and at the same time promote the broad idea of joint consultation between the Company and the workers. Consideration might also be given to the possibility of extending job safety training among the supervisory staff. CONTRACT LABOUR The problem of contract labour is a serious one in the oil industry of Iran by reason of the conditions of the country and of the large number of contract workers involved—over 7,000 in Abadan and over 8,000 in Fields. There is, of course, a case for letting out certain jobs to contractors, but it should not be overlooked that the workers employed by the contractors are carrying on activities which are essential for the industry. In every country in which this industry exists some work is normally done by contractors. In the industrial countries, however, the contractors' men enjoy the same protection from the law and from collective agreements as other workers, and they have their own homes. Where a contract has to be carried out in a remote district of one of these countries it is usual for temporary accommodation to be provided. In Iran, however, the workers employed by contractors are not so well protected as the Company's employees, principally because the legal provisions are not so strictly applied. The purchasing power of their wages is less, since they do not receive the same advantages as the men employed by the Company in regard to the provision of food and medical aid. The jobs of the contractors' men are also more precarious because the contractors depend almost exclusively on the Company for their business and do not as a rule have alternative sources of employment. In these circumstances the welfare of the contract labour is a matter of far greater concern to the Company than it would be in an industrial country. The Company has recognised its position in this matter by the insertion of a special clause in contracts, but it is doubtful whether this clause completely fulfils its purpose. The Mission formed the impression that more energetic action needs to be taken by the public authorities to safeguard the position of contract labour. Much could be done, for example, by the organisation of an efficient system of labour inspection to ensure the observance of the minimum statutory standards for conditions of employment and by the control of rents and prices which was suggested in an earlier paragraph. 76 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN The position would be greatly eased if the Company could reduce the amount of work done by contract labour and employ more of these workers directly. This would give a large number of workers greater protection and the right to participate in the benefits which the Company provides for its own employees. It would appear, however, that the amount if not the proportion of contract labour has recently tended to increase, in part, no doubt, in response to a desire on the part of the Iranians themselves that greater opportunities be given by the Company to local contractors. The employment of more direct labour would, of course, aggravate the Company's problems in regard to housing, food supplies, health services, etc. In the long run the remedy would seem to lie in the development of local enterprises and the assumption of greater responsibility by the public authorities for the welfare of their citizens. HOUSING Housing is the most serious problem in the Company's areas and the one which gives most cause for concern. The problem of providing houses for the oil workers is a gigantic one, especially in Abadan, because of the large numbers to be housed, the fact that there have been periods of extremely rapid increase in the population, the almost complete absence of building materials and housing components, and the shortage of qualified building labour. These factors increase the difficulty of providing houses in sufficient numbers and render the cost of building extremely high. The provision of homes for such a large population would be a major problem even in a well-organised country where there were no shortages and where all the resources of municipal and private enterprise could be mobilised. It must be recognised therefore that the Company has had a colossal task to face in coping with this situation. The difficulties were further increased by the fact that during a part of the war period the building of houses was practically brought to a standstill, though the labour force was being rapidly extended. When all this is said, however, the conclusion can hardly be avoided that a large and rapid increase in the construction of houses is both necessary and possible. The shortage of housing accommodation is one of the most serious causes of discontent in the Company's areas. In spite of the tremendous effort that has been made, the end of the programme of construction is not yet in sight. Although thousands of houses have been built and hundreds are still under construction, very large numbers of workers see no hope of securing a house for years to come. In this connection a question arises concerning the relation • •/•F. Î ' V , Section of Agha J ari oilfield MF t • wp Artisans going to work, Abadan Filling station at Ahwaz, S.W Iran Well at Masjid-i-Sulaiman, S. W. Iran k -X fe" '••• -5«'*" J * ^ " ^ " v 'A í/ÉfipinKW'it. " " CONCLUSIONS 77 between the standard of accommodation and the rate at which it can be provided. It has been suggested that if houses of a lower standard were designed, they could be built more rapidly and could accommodate larger numbers of workers. So far, however, the Company has set its face against the building of houses which are not of substantial construction and provided with water-borne sanitation, individual drinking water supplies and other necessary services. It may nevertheless be possible, without depressing the standard of accommodation below a decent level, to construct a larger number of less costly houses which fulfil all reasonable requirements. The problem is so big and so acute that only an urgent effort on a large scale can meet it. Complaints were heard by the Mission regarding the points system under which the houses are allocated. The system has hitherto worked well, but it would seem that the time has now come for it to be adjusted in order to give more weight to length of service. In present circumstances wage earners in the lower wage groups with many years of service may have to wait a long time before acquiring the necessary number of points. It would seem to be desirable to give such men an opportunity of qualifying for a house more quickly. A readjustment of the points system to permit of this would not, of course, solve the problem of shortage of accommodation. Only a much greater building effort could do that. In addition to whatever measures the Company itself might take, it would seem to be indispensable for the Government and the local authorities to encourage the greatest possible amount of private building and to insist upon adequate rent controls until a sufficient number of houses has been built. DISTRIBUTION OF COMMODITIES One of the Company's most remarkable achievements has been the organisation of its scheme for the distribution of food, clothing and other essential commodities. This has involved the purchase of articles in short supply and arrangements for importing, storing and distributing them in an orderly manner among large numbers of people. As part of this scheme it has been necessary to work out a rationing and price system, to build stores and shops, to organise transport, to open canteens and restaurants and to undertake agricultural development projects. There can be no doubt that this scheme has resulted in the provision of vast quantities of commodities which would not otherwise have been available and has contributed towards holding down prices and supporting the purchasing power of wages. In the circumstances which at present exist in the area, the continuance of the scheme would seem 6 78 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN to be an absolute necessity. If the scheme were abandoned there would soon be an acute shortage of articles of prime necessity, and prices in the local markets would soar. It is difficult to see what other arrangements could be made to supply the needs of the population of Abadan and Fields, unless the public authorities were to organise the supply and distribution of commodities on an adequate scale. One step in the right direction, however, would be the organisation of co-operative societies among the oil workers. Plans for this are already on foot and it is to be hoped that the initial difficulties will soon be overcome. HEALTH SERVICES No one who visits the Company's areas can fail to recognise the effort which the Company has made in organising its health and medical services. In addition to the usual safety, hygiene and first-aid arrangements inside the plant, there are health services for the prevention of disease and medical services for the various forms of treatment. The preventive services include drainage, sewerage, the provision of pure drinking water, anti-malarial campaigns, inoculation and vaccination and the destruction of pests; while facilities for treatment include hospitals, dispensaries and various kinds of clinics. The hospital at Abadan is claimed to be the finest in the Middle East. These arrangements are all the more important because the health services of the municipality were quite rudimentary until recently, there is no other hospital in the area, and the number of doctors and dentists other than those employed by the Company is very small indeed. A great strain is thrown upon the Company's medical services by the fact that although they were designed primarily for the Company's own employees, they are in fact used extensively by the workers' families and even by people who have no connection with the Company. It is desirable that the Company's medical facilities should be extended, and the Company is taking steps towards this end, but it is also evident that more vigorous action should be taken by the public authorities to provide for the health needs of the local population. It is therefore to be hoped that the Company's programme for the extension of the main hospital in Abadan and for additional clinics in the oilfield areas, as well as the plans for the erection of a municipal hospital in Abadan, may soon be carried out. The Mission fully appreciates the difficulties, financial and otherwise, in the way of a large-scale development of the medical services of these areas, but the needs of the local population are pressing and the facilities are still far from adequate. CONCLUSIONS 79 EDUCATION It will have been noticed that in addition to organising training schemes the Company has participated in the arrangements for the education of children and in the organisation of night classes for adults. The shortage of schools and teachers in Iran is so great that it will be many years before it will be possible to provide every child with an elementary education and to develop satisfactory arrangements for secondary and higher education. Remarkable progress is, however, being made in some areas and among these Abadan and Fields take a high place, thanks to the combined efforts of the authorities and the Company. The future industrial and social development of Iran will be influenced in a high degree by the progress which is made in the sphere of education, and the efforts put forward in the Company's areas to provide increased educational facilities will produce their reward not only for the Company but for the country generally. Continued close co-operation between the Company and the authorities in these matters is therefore to be recommended. Among the practical measures which are urgently needed are the provision of more primary and secondary schools and the training and settlement of a greater number of school teachers in these areas. TRADE UNIONS It is important to bear in mind that trade unionism in Iran is of very recent growth, and that the trade union movement is not united. It will be recalled that the main division inside the trade union movement is between the E.S.K.I. and E.M.K.A. organisations. In addition to this, however, the oil workers' unions are virtually separate, though links are now being forged between them and the organisations in other industries. Trade unions are legally recognised in Iran and are given certain important functions under the Labour Law, but it is obvious that their members still stand in fear of arbitrary administrative action and of dismissal or other forms of victimisation for their trade union activities. From statements made to the Mission it appears that the fear is genuine, though to what extent it is justified it is difficult to say. It is unfortunate that the oil workers are not united among themselves. There seems to be no compelling reason why the split in the organisation in Abadan should continue or why there should be separate unions for Abadan and Fields. It would be an advantage if there could be a single union or federation for the oil workers in Abadan and if the organisations in Fields could be associated with it. There are difficulties in the way of maintaining contact between the oil workers in Abadan and those in 80 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN Fields, and even between the workers in the different parts of the Fields area, but these could be overcome if there were a real desire for united organisation and action. Closer organisation and more effective action will presumably come as the organised oil workers develop a greater measure of genuine trade union activity. To do this, however, they will need to recognise that the personal grievances of an individual are the problems of whole groups of workers and that such problems should be decided according to common rules or principles to be applied to all who are concerned. The oil workers' unions—like other unions in Iran—also need more experience in organising, in the conduct of union business and in the formulation of policy, but such experience is not likely to be acquired quickly. Other factors which would encourage the growth of sound and responsible trade unionism among the oil workers are a development in the processes of collective bargaining (in which the joint departmental committees could play an important educative role among representatives both of the workers and of the management) and improvements in the handling of differences and disputes. Here it is not so much a matter of devising new machinery—since the existing machinery has not yet been fully tested—as of encouraging the joint examination and discussion of questions at all levels and thereby preventing differences from developing into open disputes. Much could be done to assist the oil workers in improving their organisation and acquiring greater responsibility if closer contacts could be developed between them and the trade unions of other countries. They would benefit, in particular, from a closer knowledge of the aims, purposes and methods of trade unionism as understood in other countries, the successes, failures and lessons of trade unionism, and the methods and procedures employed for the organisation and financing of unions, the holding of union elections, the conduct of meetings and the formulation and application of union policies. One matter which seems to have caused deep feeling among the oil workers' unions is their failure to secure a seat on the High Labour Council at the conference held in December 1949 for the purpose of electing the workers' representatives to this body. As the voting at the Congress was on the basis of one vote per union the oil workers were at a disadvantage and their candidate could only have been elected with the help of a number of votes from other organisations. These were not forthcoming. It is nevertheless desirable for the oil workers to be represented on the High Labour Council, since they are the largest single body of workers in the country and constitute a high proportion of the total CONCLUSIONS 81 labour force. Such representation could be secured if the other unions were willing to give due weight to the claims of the oil workers. Alternatively it might be possible either to alter the basis of voting at the Congress or to amend the regulations concerning the High Labour Council so as to reserve a seat for a representative of the oil workers. LABOUR-MANAGEMENT RELATIONS The provisions of the Labour Law concerning labour-management relations are of great importance, since they embody the tripartite principle of discussion and decision in councils and committees containing representatives of the Government, the employers and the workers. The Law itself has only been in existence since 1946, and it is still too early to express a confident opinion regarding its provisions, especially as a number of changes are only now being put into effect. It is, however, clear that bodies such as the factory councils, the boards for the settlement of disputes and the High Labour Council are needed at their respective levels, though there may be room for differences of opinion regarding their composition and their achievements. In general it may be said that the setting up of these bodies was calculated to improve labour-management relations by making provision for the regular discussion of labour problems at the plant and national levels and by providing procedures for the settlement of disputes. The factory councils give opportunities for discussing problems that arise at the plant level; they appear to deal mainly with welfare problems, grievances and minor disputes, though they are entitled to exercise certain other functions, e.g., in regard to problems of production. The Mission feels that the factory councils, whether in their present form or on a more widely representative basis, should be encouraged, both because they help to give the workers' representatives greater experience and responsibility and because they provide a channel through which the managements can give and receive information and opinions. The boards for the settlement of disputes seem to be concerned mainly with complaints regarding dismissals and with the fixing of minimum wages. The Mission was not able to form a very clear opinion as to the suitability of their composition and procedure, but it is obvious that some bodies of the kind are needed at this level. Regarding the High Labour Council, the Mission can be more definite. This body has apparently given most of its attention to the preparation of draft laws and regulations, the fixing of minimum wages, the application of labour legislation and the supervision of funds. The establishment of the High Labour Council was an important development in such a country as Iran. The Council has 82 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN great responsibilities and considerable power, and its membership therefore needs to comprise men of experience and ability who truly represent their respective interests. It is to be hoped that the departments and organisations concerned will continue to participate fully in its work. Good results may also be expected from the joint departmental committees set up on the initiative of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company. These bodies bring the process of consultation right down to earth, so to speak, since they deal with problems affecting the workers in each of the various departments of the plant and comprise representatives who are workers themselves. They may therefore be of great value in dealing with problems which the workers understand and by which they are directly affected. The joint departmental committees are not yet fully appreciated by the workers, however, and there is still some reluctance to accept them. This is due in part to a natural slowness in understanding the aims and methods of such bodies and in part, perhaps, to a certain suspicion of them among the leaders of the unions. Nevertheless the confidence of the general body of workers in the joint departmental committees seems to be increasing, even if only slowly. At present the workers' representatives tend to use the meetings of the committees too largely for the ventilation of complaints and too little for putting forward constructive suggestions, while the management places more emphasis upon the explanation of regulations and questions of discipline than upon the discussion of some of the more fundamental problems which it would be desirable for the workers to understand. Further experience of the working of the committees, however, will no doubt help to make them more effective. Generally speaking the Mission formed the impression that relations between the Company and the workers, though not completely harmonious, are developing on the right Unes. Some of the suspicion which grew up in the past has not yet been entirely dissipated. Relations are for the most part friendly on the job and there is a marked mutual respect among the workers and their immediate supervisors. It is not surprising that difficulties arise in view of the numerous opportunities for friction, and it is interesting to note that the complaints made against the Company as an employer are fewer than those which relate to its housing facilities, food and clothing schemes and health services. The Company appears to be genuinely anxious to promote good industrial relations, and in this respect its policy seems to have advanced considerably in recent years. Difficulties must still arise when such large numbers of workers are concerned, and when so many problems present themselves. The Mission is confident that if political complications CONCLUSIONS 83 could be avoided the relations between management and workers would continue to improve.1 GENERAL OBSERVATIONS It is necessary to emphasise once again that the petroleum industry in Iran is a unique feature of the country's economic life. It should also be made clear that it is an industry regarding which a great deal of misinformation and misunderstanding prevails. The general population knows little of the industry or of the conditions of its workers, and is unable to compare its conditions with those in other industries. Having regard to the great distances and to the difficulties of communication, it is not surprising that relatively few people from other areas visit Abadan and Fields to see things for themselves, but this does not suffice to explain the extent of the misapprehensions. In view of the importance of the industry to the country it would be a public service if the authorities and the press would take steps to provide the population with more information regarding the true state of affairs in the petroleum areas. The publication of factual material regarding conditions in the petroleum industry in other countries would also be helpful. At the risk of repetition the Mission feels it desirable to refer once more to the general conditions of the country—its great size, its comparative isolation, its natural resources which are so difficult to exploit, its extremes of climate and its retarded industrial and agricultural development—all of which must be taken into account when the conditions of the petroleum industry are being considered. The Mission would also recall the widespread poverty, malnutrition and disease, the low standards of housing, the inadequate educational facilities, the need for improved health and medical services and the failure to develop many of the public services, such as water supplies, sewage disposal and local transportation. Against this background the working and living conditions of the oil workers appear as an encouraging example of what can be done. Notable improvements have also taken place, of course, in 1 The International Labour Office has been informed that since the departure of the Mission from Iran Mr. A. G. Mohammadi, who was one of the two Iranian workers' delegates at the second session of the I.L.O. Petroleum Committee, has been dismissed from the Company's service. Mr. Mohammadi was adviser to the Trade Union of Workers of Khuzistan, and it appears that the Company took exception to the manner in which he organised opposition to the dismissal of a number of redundant workers. It also seems that he was obliged to leave the area by order of the local Governor. The Office has had the advantage of hearing the views of Mr. Mohammadi himself and of representatives of the Company and it has received information on the matter from its correspondent in Teheran. The Office does not consider that it is in a position to express any opinion as to the merits of the case. It feels, however, that the action taken against Mr. Mohammadi, who was an adviser to one of the trade unions, was regrettable even if the incident does not hamper the development of improved relations between the Company and its workers. 84 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN some of the other industries and these developments have been greatly stimulated by the example of the factories set up by the Government. The existence of unsatisfactory conditions in other industries and in other parts of the country does not imply that the oil workers have no cause for complaint. But the fact that such conditions are still so widespread emphasises the great effort which the oil industry has already made. It is true that the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company may be better equipped than some of the other employers to deal with industrial relations and with the social problems of its workers, and it is also true that the Company has various conditions to fulfil under the terms of its Concession, as well as moral obligations towards the country and its people. But in a sound national economy it is necessary for progress to be general and not to be confined to favoured industries or areas; improvements in working and living conditions should therefore be accelerated for all workers throughout the country. It is gratifying to note that efforts are being made to bring about some of the much needed improvements, e.g., through the machinery of the seven-year plan and the services of the Ministry of Labour. It seems to the Mission that there is a clear need for improvements in the Labour Law and for a stricter enforcement of its provisions throughout the country. The regulations for carrying out the intentions of the Law are not yet adequate and there is a strong case for a more effective system of labour inspection, which implies, among other things, better facihties for the training of inspectors. The Ministry of Labour, which is still in its infancy, needs to be given greater support, and its services, both at the centre and in the localities, require considerable reinforcement. Alongside the efforts to promote improvements in industry generally there should be more adequate arrangements for contact and co-operation between the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company and the authorities. The Mission was struck by the large number of problems which are handled by the Company, not only as an employer of labour but as a provider of public services, and it felt that there was an urgent need for more representatives of the national and municipal authorities to be co-operating in the solution of these problems with officials of the Company at the various levels. It seemed to the Mission that there was a good deal of misunderstanding regarding the nature and extent of the problems and the efforts made to overcome them, and that this should be dissipated in the interests of all concerned. In this connection the Mission would point out that the Government of Iran is^strongly critical of the Company's policy and activities in regard to some of the problems mentioned in the preceding paragraphs. CONCLUSIONS 85 The Mission has attempted to describe the situation objectively and to give an honest opinion on every point. It has not hesitated to express approval when it was favourably impressed or to draw attention to matters in regard to which more energetic action might be taken or a different policy pursued. It realises, however, that the Government might not be disposed to endorse all the favourable comments made by the Mission and that in regard to some of the subjects it would go much further than the Mission in criticising the Company's policy and actions. Furthermore, the Mission is aware that on certain questions the Government takes a different line from the Company with regard to the division of responsibility between the Company and the authorities. For these reasons it would emphasise the view expressed in the preceding paragraph regarding the need for dissipating misunderstandings. Among the subjects on which divergent views exist are wages, housing, food supplies, health services and education. The Company feels that it is fulfilling its obligations in regard to these matters and that in some cases it is doing more than can reasonably be expected of it, though it admits that there are still problems which have not yet been satisfactorily solved. It claims, moreover, that in some instances the responsibility for action lies with the country's authorities, though it is willing to co-operate in such action where possible and appropriate. On the other hand, the Government feels that the problems of the petroleum areas have been created by the operations of the Company, that the Government has already incurred heavy expenditure in these areas, and that it cannot be expected to expend more money and effort on what it considers to be a vast factory called into being by the Company. The Government maintains that the Company should pay more attention to the problems of housing, health, food supplies and education in the petroleum areas and that the Company has the main responsibility for supplying the needs of the workers and the general population. In view of the important issues involved, the Mission expresses the hope that these and other unresolved questions will be further discussed between the Company and the authorities at all levels, and that all their aspects will be kept constantly under review. Suggestions were made to the Mission by Government officials in Iran to the effect that a comparative study of some of the economic problems of the petroleum industry and of certain aspects of the industry in the producing countries, such as the problem of wages and that of royalties payable to the Governments of the countries concerned, would be of considerable importance and it would seem that consideration might well be given to the possibiHty of undertaking studies of this kind. 86 LABOUR CONDITIONS IN THE OIL INDUSTRY IN IRAN Finally, the Mission is aware that many of the problems dealt with in these pages exist in other oil-producing countries as well. It feels that the possession of more information about the conditions in these countries would be helpful to all who are interested in the welfare of this important industry. Studies of these problems would help to establish the facts, to clear away misunderstandings, and to encourage further progress. The Mission hopes that it will be possible for such studies to be undertaken. To sum up, the Mission feels that the following subjects might well receive further attention from the parties concerned : 1. Control of prices of essential commodities in Abadan and Fields. The provision of greater quantities of such commodities by increased production in these areas and by increased imports. 2. Working conditions on disagreeable and dangerous processes. 3. Issue of regulations for the application of the social insurance provisions of the Labour Law. 4. Establishment of joint safety committees. 5. Wages and conditions of employment of contract labour. 6. Acceleration of the Company's housing programme. 7. Revision of the points system for allocating quarters provided by the Company. 8. Encouragement of house building for oil workers by the Government and the local authorities. 9. Control of rents in areas where housing accommodation for oil workers is inadequate. 10. Continuance of the Company's scheme for the supply of commodities. 11. Organisation of co-operative societies among oil workers. 12. Extension of the Company's medical services. 13. Provision of more extensive public health services by the authorities in Abadan and Fields. 14. Provision of more primary and secondary schools in Abadan and Fields. Training and settlement of a greater number of school teachers in these areas. Continued close collaboration between the Company and the authorities in these matters. 15. Promotion of trade union unity among the oil workers. 16. Assistance to oil workers' unions by the unions in other countries. CONCLUSIONS 87 17. Development of collective bargaining processes and improvements in the methods of handling differences and disputes. 18. Representation of the oil workers on the High Labour Council. 19. Encouragement of the work of the factory councils. 20. Development of the activities of the High Labour Council. 21. Extended use of joint departmental committees. 22. Provision of more factual and objective information regarding conditions in the petroleum areas of Iran and other countries. 23. Improvements in the Labour Law. Stricter enforcement of the provisions of the Law. Development of a more effective system of labour inspection. Training of labour inspectors. 24. Strengthening of the Ministry of Labour. 25. Closer co-operation at all levels between the Company and the authorities. 26. Further discussion of unresolved questions between the Company and the authorities. PUBLICATION OF THE IliTERiiflTIOIIflL LABOUR OFFICE Freedom of Association and Conditions of Work in Venezuela Studies and Reports, New Series, No. 21 The report of the mission sent by the International Labour Office to Venezuela at the request of the Venezuelan Government (22 July - 1 September 1949). The two main problems dealt with are the position of trade union organisations in Venezuela and conditions of living and employment of Venezuelan workers. The conclusions arrived at by the mission are given in the last chapter. CONTENTS CHAPTER I. General Survey. Topography and Climate—Population —Development of the Petroleum Industry—The Governments of López Contreras and Medina (1936-1945)—Democratic Action Party in Power (1945-1948)—The Coup d'état of 24 November 1948. CHAPTER I I . The Position of Trade Union Organisations. The Trade Union Movement prior to 24 November 1948—Legal Status of Trade Unions prior to 24 November 1948—The Trade Union Situation after the Coup d'état—Dissolution of Trade Union Organisations—Reorganisation of the Trade Union Movement. CHAPTER I I I . Living Conditions and Conditions of Work. Labour Legislation—Collective Agreements—Social Security—Labour Inspection—Dismissal of Workers—Views of Workers and Employers. CHAPTER IV. Conclusions. Present Position of the Trade Union Movement—Living Conditions and Conditions of Work. Geneva, 1950. 185 pages Price : $1; 6s.