INTERNATIONAL LABOUR OFFICE STUDIES AND REPORTS Series N (Statistics) No. 25 (Revision of No. 19) THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS A Review of the Statistical Work of the International Labour Office and of Various International Statistical Conferences MONTREAL, 1943 PUBLISHED BY THE INTERNATIONAL LABOUR OFFICE, 3480 University Street, Montreal, Canada Published in the United Kingdom for the INTERNATIONAL by P. S. King & Staples, Ltd., London. LABODR OFFICE Distributed in the United States by the INTERNATIONAL.LABOUR OFFICE, Washington Branch, 734 Jackson Place, Washington,^.C. PREFACE Good labour statistics are essential to both the framing and the administration of progressive social policy. To serve this purpose fully the statistics of employment, unemployment, wages, cost of living, family expenditures, industrial accidents and other aspects of industrial life and labour must be accurate and complete; and they must be comparable both within and between the different countries. Progress towards this goal is necessarily gradual but it can be hastened by pooling the experience of the several countries and by formulating international standards based on the lessons of that experience. The work already accomplished in this direction through the International Labour Organisation forms the subject of the present report; and it is hoped that by presenting in convenient form the recommendations of successive international conferences of experts on labour statistics the report will serve to furnish practical assistance to statisticians and to stimulate further progress towards the international standardisation of labour statistics. Since the publication in 1934 of the first edition of this report, summarising the work of the International Labour Office and of a series of International Conferences of Labour Statisticians in this field, a number of new developments have taken place. The most important of these is the adoption by the International Labour Conference in 1938 of a Draft Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work. This Convention established a set of minimum standards on these subjects to which the different Governments may adhere by appropriate action, thus converting into a definite obligation the production and publication of statistics in these fields in accordance with these standards. Besides this Convention, the present revised edition of this report adds the recommendations of the International Labour Office Committee of Statistical Experts on international comparisons of wages, food costs and rents, as well as extracts from the reports prepared by the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations, on which the Office is represented, on the statistics of the gainfully ii INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS occupied and of housing. In the revision the analysis of the work of the Office in the whole field of labour statistics is amplified and brought up to date. As before;, the report includes the resolutions and recommendations on wag;e statistics of the two Conferences called by the Social Science Research Council, and those on housing statistics of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Union of Towns, in all of which the International Labour Office collaborated. In the revision, the resolutions are arranged by topics and chronologically under each topic, instead of chronologically according to the dates of the respective meetings, as in the original edition. It is believed that the present arrangement, by bringing together all the resolutions under each topic, will make the volume of greater service to all those interested in the international standardisation of the different branches of labour statistics. A key is given in the Appendix showing the topics considered at each of the International Conferences of Labour Statisticians. An index is added to make the materials conveniently accessible. CONTENTS Page PRBFACB i PART I THE WORK OF THE INTERNATIONAL LABOUR OFFICE AND OF THE INTERNATIONAL STATISTICAL CONFERENCES IN THE STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS INTRODUCTION 1 I. CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS II. EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT 9 III. WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 16 Money Wages Index Numbers of Wages Total Wages and Salaries Hours of Work 16 19 20 20 12 IV. COST OF LIVING 22 V. INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS OF REAL WAGES AND COST OF LIVING. 24 Wages Elements of Remuneration other than Wages Cost of Living Food 25 26 27 28 Rents 30 VI. FAMILY LIVING STUDIES VII. INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS 31 VIII. HOUSING 35 IX. COLLECTIVE AGREEMENTS 37 X. INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES 38 XI. EMIGRATION AND IMMIGRATION 39 XII. YEAR BOOK OF LABOUR STATISTICS 41 : CONCLUSION 33 46 PART II DOCUMENTARY TEXTS I. THE CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS FOR PURPOSES OF LABOUR STATISTICS 1. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1923 2. Resolution of the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, April 1925 49 49 50 vi II. INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS 3. Resolutions of the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1926 50 4. International Scheme for the Presentation of D a t a by Industry (or Occupation), framed by the International Labour Office.. 51 5. Excerpts from the Report of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations on Statistics of the Gainfully-occupied Population 52 6. Minimum Nomenclature of Industries recommended by the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of N a t i o n s . . 65 STATISTICS O F EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT 67 7. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Labour ¡Statisticians, Geneva, April 1925 III. IV. STATISTICS O F W A G E S AND H O U R S O F W O R K 70 8. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Labour ¡Statisticians, Geneva, October 1923 70 9. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Statisticians convoked by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America, January 1929 71 10. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Statisticians convoked by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America, May 1930 11. Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work adopted by the International Labour Conference a t its 24th Session, June 1938 85 12. Proposed Recommendation suggested by the Fifth International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1937. . . 13. Proposals Calling for Further Action 95 96 C O S T OF L I V I N G I N D E X N U M B E R S 98 14. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, April 1925 15. International Convention relating to Economic Statistics, of 14 December 1928, adopted by the International Conference relating to Economic Statistics called by the League of N a t i o n s . . 16. Recommendation of the International Conference relating to Economic Statistics called by the League of Nations V. 67 INTERNATIONAL L::VING COMPARISONS OP R E A L W A G E S AND COSTS 83 98 100 100 OF 101 17. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, April 1925 101 18. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Statisticians convoked by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America, January 1929 101 19. Resolutions of the Fourth International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, May 1931 104 A. Statistics of Elements of Remuneration Other than Wages 107 20. Resolution of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, First Session, Geneva, 12-15 December 1933 107 CONTENTS B. Statistics of the Cost of Living vii 108 21. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Statisticians convoked by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America, May 1930 C. Statistics of the Cost of Food 108 109 22. Resolution of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, First Session, Geneva, 12-15 December 1933 109 D. Statistics of Rents 23. Resolution of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, First Session, Geneva, 12-15 December 1933 Ill Ill 24. Resolutions of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, Second Session, Geneva, 16-18 December 1935 112 25. Resolutions of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, Third Session, Geneva, 6-7 October 1937 114 VI. VII. M E T H O D S OP FAMILY L I V I N G E N Q U I R I E S 26. Resolutions of the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1926 116 27. Recommendation of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, First Session, 12-15 December 1933 118 STATISTICS OF INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS 28. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1923 VIII. HOUSING STATISTICS 29. Recommendations of the Committee of Statistical Experts convoked by the International Union of Towns ( M a y 1 9 2 8 ) . . . . 30. Excerpts from Recommendations of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations IX. STATISTICS OF COLLECTIVE AGREEMENTS 31. Resolutions of the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1926 X. STATISTICS OF INDUSTRIAL D I S P U T E S 32. Resolutions of the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1926 XI. 116 STATISTICS OF MIGRATION 33. Resolutions of the International Conference of Migration Statisticians, Geneva, 3-7 October 1932 119 119 122 122 128 134 134 138 138 143 143 A P P E N D I X : Key to Topics considered at each International Conference of Labour Statisticians 149 INDEX 153 PART I The Work of the International Labour Office and of the International Statistical Conferences in the Standardisation of Labour Statistics INTRODUCTION From the outset, the International Labour Office, having as one of its duties "the collection and distribution of information on all subjects relating to the international adjustment of conditions of industrial life and labour" 1 undertook to compile and publish statistics in these fields. Obviously, if these labour statistics were to have significance, the first task was to study the methods of compilation in the different countries with a view to bringing to light differences in techniques employed and to appraise the importance of these differences. Such a comparative study naturally suggests ways of improving the statistics by adopting the best methods, and an immediate objective, therefore, was to obtain a consensus of opinion on which methods were the best. An objective scarcely less important was a greater degree of comparability in the statistics of the different countries. The result of comparing labour statistics in different countries was thus to emphasise the importance of international standardisation. The work of the Office in this direction has followed a number of different techniques. In the first place, a series of International Conferences of Labour Statisticians has been called by the Office to make recommendations as to the best methods of compiling data on the various topics in the field of labour statistics. These have been supplemented by a conference on housing, called by the International Union of Towns, two conferences called by the Social Science Research Council of the United States, in all of which the Office collaborated, as well as a conference on migration statistics called by the Office. All these conferences of statisticians have adopted resolutions specifying statistics which should be gathered on labour topics. In this connection may be mentioned the work of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations, appointed in accordance with the terms of the League's Convention concerning Economic Statistics; this Committee, on which the Office is represented, has issued a number of reports dealing with international standardisation of statistics, including two on topics of labour statistics discussed in the present report. 1 Article 9 of the Constitution of the International Labour Organisation. 2 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS A second lim; of development has been the appointment by the Governing Body of the International Labour Office of a Committee of Statistical Experts, to advise on international comparisons of wages and cost of living, as well as to make preparation for international conferences: the resolutions of this Committee have broken new ground in this difficult field of international comparisons. A third development in the technique of international standardisation, is the adoption by the International Labour Conference of a Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work. A fourth type of effort consists of direct and indirect aid to the statistical offices of the different governments including missions to different countries, and other less formal methods of consultation and collaboration, which have carried forward the work of international standardisation. A fifth group of efforts consists in collaboration with other international organisations in the standardisation of statistics. Finally, the whole series of statistical publications of the Office, culminating in the Year Book of Labour Statistics, tend to stimulate interest in this standardisation and record its progress. Each of these lines of development will be discussed briefly. The first of a series of international conferences of official statisticians engaged in the compilation of statistics relating to labour was called in 1923 by the International Labour Office following a suggestion to this effect made by certain governments. This was followed by other conferences in 1925, 1926, 1931 and 1937. All the principal industrial countries sent representatives. The decisions of these conferences in no way committed the governments, nor was it intended to prepare a code of strict and complete rules for the classification and compilation of statistical data. Their aim was merely to point out the general lines to be followed in the different branches of labour statistics and to make suggestions as to the direction in which improvements should be made when opportunity arose. These suggestions, representing the considered views of the responsible experts in the field, would, it was believed, have great weight in influencing the future development of labour statistics in the direction of better data and of greater uniformity. At the first Conference (1923) the agenda covered statistics of wages and hours of labour, statistics of industrial accidents and the classification of industries and occupations; the agenda of the second Conference (1925) comprised, in addition to a second discussion on the classification of industries and occupations, the question of cost-of-living statistics and the statistics of employment and unemployment; the agenda of the third Conference INTRODUCTION 3 (1926) dealt with methods of compiling family budgets, the statistics of collective agreements and those of industrial disputes. The fourth Conference (1931) dealt with the question of international comparisons of real wages, and the fifth (1937) formulated a proposal for a Convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work, and referred it to the International Labour Conference which, in 1938, adopted the Convention. These conferences, together with those on migration and housing to be discussed in the next paragraphs, covered almost the whole field of what is commonly known as "labour statistics". 1 On each of the above-mentioned subjects the Office made and circulated to the delegates a preparatory technical study of the aims and objects of the statistics under discussion and the methods adopted in the different countries, together with suggestions for improving their value and comparability. 2 Independently of the conferences of official labour statisticians, certain other conferences of similar nature, in which the Office closely collaborated, were held in 1928, 1929 and 1930. At each of these meetings the International Labour Office was invited to take part: it undertook the secretarial work and the Statistical Section of the Office supplied memoranda on the subjects of the agenda. The first of these was a meeting of a committee of statistical experts (from 10 European countries) called by the International Union of Towns at Munich in 1928, in order to lay down guiding lines for statistics of housing.8 The two others were convened in 1929 and 1930 by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America, to study the statistics of wages, and experts from six industrial countries—the United States, Canada, France, Germany, Great Britain and Italy—were invited. 4 Closely related to these was a special conference of statisticians 1 See Karl PRIBRAM: "The Scope of Labour Statistics", in International Labour Review, Vol. XIV, No. 4, Oct. 1926, pp. 476-488. 2 See below under each topic for detailed list of references, including the discussions of the conferences. ' In the case of the Committee on housing statistics, the memoranda of the experts and the resolutions adopted were published in the official organ of the International Union of Towns (L'Administration locale, May-June, 1928). See also below under Housing, p. 35. 4 In the case of these two Conferences, copies of the memoranda supplied by the representatives of each of the countries and the memoranda presented by the International Labour Office, together with a report on the existing wage and costof-living statistics in each of the countries represented, were published in a volume entitled International Wage Comparisons, issued in 1932 in Great Britain by the Manchester University Press, and in the United States by the Social Science Research Council. The resolutions of the first Conference, together with a short account of its work, were published in the International Labour Review, Vol. XIX, No. 4, Apr. 1929, pp. 522-539; the resolutions of the conferences are given in full in Part II of the present report. 4 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS dealing with emigration and immigration called by the International Labour Office1 in October 1932. In connection with these conferences and their resolutions, the work of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations, in which the International Labour Office participated, should be mentioned. 2 This Committee was established and constituted in accordance with the provisions of Article 8 of the International Convention relating to Economic Statistics of 1928, which was adopted by the International Conference relating to Economic Statistics called by the League of Nations. The membership of the Committee, appointed by the Council of the League, included statisticians from the different countries with well developed statistics, and representatives of the International Labour Office and the International Institute of Agriculture. The practice normally adopted by the Committee was to submit preliminary recommendations concerning statistical methods to the Council of the League oi Nations for comment by the Governments and to formulate definitive proposals in the light of the comment received. Two of the reports of this Committee, those on the gainfully occupied population and on housing are in the field covered by the present study; and in Part II excerpts from these reports, including definitions and classifications recommended, together with the reasons for the recommendations, are presented. A second line of development in the work of international standardisation was the appointment by the Governing Body of the International Labour Office, in accordance with a recommendation of the Fourth International Conference of Labour Statisticians, of a Committee of Statistical Experts. This Committee was organised as a committee of technical experts to advise the Governing Body on matters particularly relating to problems of international comparisons of wages and cost of living, to prepare for International Conferences of Statisticians and to consider special problems referred to it by the Governing Body. Though its functions were thus somewhat narrowly defined, the Committee has adopted a series of recommendations which have pointed the way to fruitful lines of development in the difficult problems of international comparisons of wages, cost of living, food costs, and rents. Its 1 For a discussion of this Conference, see "Report of the Conference on Migration Statistics", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXVII, No. 1, Jan. 1933, pp. a 1-24. For a review of the work of this Committee, see Michel HUBER: "Le Comité d'experts statisticiens de la Société des Nations (1931-1939)", in Revue de l'Institut international ¿a Statistique, 7th year, livraison 2/3, 1939, pp. 117 e/ seq. A brief account is given in Charles K. NICHOLS: "The Statistical Work of the League of Nations in Economic, Financial and Related Fields", in Journal o} the American Statistical Association, Vol. 37, No. 219, Sept. 1942, pp. 336-342, esp. 339-340. INTRODUCTION 5 work, furthermore, in preparing for the Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work is of noteworthy importance. The Committee held meetings in December 1933, December 1935, and October 1937; plans for a further meeting in the spring of 1940 had to be dropped owing to war conditions. The agenda of the first meeting included international comparisons of the cost of food and rent, family living studies, and elements of remuneration other than wages; at the second meeting the agenda covered international comparisons of rents, and the proposal for an international convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work, which was subsequently discussed by the Fifth International Conference of Labour Statisticians in 1937 ; and at the third meeting, the topics discussed included again international comparisons of rents, the systématisation of statistics of wages and hours of work published by the Office, and a proposal for an international enquiry on wages and hours of work in the textile industry. The last mentioned project had been referred to the Committee of Statistical Experts by the Governing Body of the Office, following a discussion of the subject by a special committee of the Tri-partite Technical Conference on the Textile Industry which was convened by the Office and which met in Washington in April 1937.1 The third line of development of the techniques for international standardisation is represented by the adoption by the International Labour Conference in 1938 of the Convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work. This Convention incorporates a minimum programme for statistics in this special field and the States Members of the International Labour Organisation were invited to ratify it and to signify by so doing their willingness to collect the statistics on this minimum plan and submit them to the Office.2 The preparation of this Convention involved three stages: first, a consideration in detail by the Committee of Statistical Experts of a draft of the proposed articles of the Convention prepared by the Office ; secondly, the approval of the Convention by an International Conference of Labour Statisticians called for the purpose and including experts from the different Member States, and 1 For a discussion of these three meetings, see Michel H U B E R : "Le Comité d'Experts statisticiens du Bureau international du Travail (1933-1939)", in Revue de l'Institut international de Statistique, 9th year, livraison 3/4, 1941, pp. 104-112. For the report of the Committee on Statistics of the Tripartite Technical Conference on the Textile Industry, see The World Textile Industry, Economic and Social Problems, Vol. II, Studies and Reports, Series B, No. 27 (Geneva, 1937), pp. 273 et seq. * See J . W. Nixon: "An International Convention on Statistics of Wages and Houre of Work", in Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Vol. CI, Part IV, 1938, pp. 730-735. 6 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS finally, its adoption by the Twenty-Fourth Session of the International Labour Conference at which the Governments, workers and employers of the Member States were represented. A fourth phase of the activity of the International Labour Office has been the sending of experts to various countries for consultations with regard to the further development of labour statistics. In particular a series oí visits to various American countries arranged during 1940, 1941 and 1942 may be cited as an illustration., In this type of effort may be included also the numerous less formal activities in the way of specific aid to the statistical offices of the different countries, supplying documents, references, or special memoranda on different topics as requested, and serving as a clearing house of information on the standardisation of labour statistics. A fifth phase of activity has been the collaboration of the Office with other international organisations interested in international standardisation or in specific fields of labour statistics. Besides the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations, the work of which has already been mentioned, the Office has collaborated with the Health Organisation, the Permanent Committee on Road Traffic, and the Institute of Intellectual Co-operation of the League, and with other international organisations and committees, including in particular, the International Statistical Institute and the recently formed Inter-American Statistical Institute. The exact scope and influence of each of these forms of collaboration might well be made the subject of special study, but for present purposes it perhaps suffices to call attention to the variety of these activities and the importance of their influence as a whole. Finally, the series of publications by the International Labour Office in the field of statistics and statistical methods is itself an important medium of international standardisation. These include reports on statistical methods in the various fields, as described in detail in the succeeding sections; other studies present the statistical materials available on specific topics. Many articles in the International Labour Review are devoted to statistical problems. The section of the Review devoted to statistics presents current data on cost of living, employment and unemployment, hours of work and wages. The Year Book of Labour Statistics, which dates formally from 1935-361, presents in comparable form the data from as many countries as possible on each of the main fields of labour statistics. From a study of the statistics published 1 See below, pp. 41, 44, for a discussion of the predecessors of the Year Book of Labour Statistic). INTRODUCTION 7 in the Review since 1921, and in the Year Book of Labour Statistics during the period since 1935, the progress made in the international standardisation of the statistics of labour can be shown. As more and more countries publish statistics on various topics the scope of the tables in the Year Book is extended. The Year Book thus serves both to measure progress, and to stimulate the development of statistics in the various countries in the form adopted in this annual volume. This account of the work of the International Labour Office would be incomplete and give perhaps a false impression if it were to disregard the primary element in the whole picture, namely, the desire on the part of the several countries to perfect their own statistical measurement of the status, progress and problems of labour. The International Labour Office has served as an agency through which this desire could find expression and could be translated into effective action. The demand for more and better statistics arising in different countries from the broadening recognition of their importance has been reflected in the adoption by various international meetings of experts of resolutions calling for improvements in data on the subjects with which they have been concerned. Thus the Conference of the American States Members of the International Labour Organisation held at Santiago de Chile in 19361 urged the development of statistics on the cost of living and family living studies according to plans to be developed by the Office, and a similar Conference held in Havana in 19402 called upon the Office to take steps to secure uniformity in all labour statistics and urged the Member States to ratify and give effect to the Convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work. In a series of resolutions on various topics the International Labour Conference at several sessions has called for better and more uniform labour statistics in the different countries. 8 But the force of the whole movement is perhaps best exemplified in the series of International 1 See Labour Conference of the American States which are Members of the International Labour Organisation (Santiago de Chile, January 1936), Record of Proceedings: Resolution concerning the cost of living in American countries (No. 9), p. 293. Other resolutions affecting statistics dealt with the question of uniformity in methods of investigation into the conditions and costs of the nutrition of workers (Resolution No. 11, ibid., p. 295); the establishment or extension of central bureaux of social statistics, particularly with regard to wages, cost of living, unemployment, industrial accidents, occupational diseases, and labour disputes (Resolution No. 23, ibid., p. 300), and with regard to statistics of the agricultural population (Resolution No. 25, ibid., p. 301). 2 Second Labour Conference of the American States which are Members of the International Labour Organisation, Hanava (Cuba), 21 Nov. to 2 Dec. 1939, Record of Proceedings, p. 267, Resolution No. XX. 3 For the text of resolutions of the International Labour Conference on points dealing with statistics, see The International Labour Code 1939, pp. 543-4, 555-6, 8 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS Conferences of Labour Statisticians in which officials responsible for labour statistics in the various countries have met for the common purpose of unifying the course of development and advancing the international standardisation of labour statistics. The results of the movement are shown in the expansion and steady improvement during the past twenty years of the labour statistics published in the different countries. In the following pages, each branch of labour statistics is discussed in detail, and references are given to the various statistical publications of the International Labour Office. I CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS: THE GAINFULLY OCCUPIED This topic of classification of industries and occupations is in a sense preliminary and of general character since it relates to the way in which labour statistics in the various fields may be classified or organised. The gainfully occupied or the employed, for example, may be classified according to the industry in which they are employed or the occupation which they perform; wages may be arranged according to the industry or occupation of the wage earner; strikes according to the industry to which the establishment affected belongs. For purposes of international comparison, it is obviously desirable that the materials available in the several countries be classified or organised along similar lines. In preparation for a discussion of the classification of industries and occupations at the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians in 1923, the Office published a report summarising the classifications in use in a number of countries and presenting the principles underlying the different uses of such a classification.1 The Conference in its resolutions emphasised the distinction between classification by industry and by personal occupation and pointed out that, for purposes of classifying the occupied population, the primary classification should be according to industries with subdivisions by occupations, suggesting, however, that to give full details by occupation a second separate classification, by occupations, may also be necessary. The Conference drew up a list of main divisions—primary production (agriculture, mining, etc.), secondary production (manufacture and construction), and services (transport, commerce, administration, etc.). 2 1 Systems of Classification of Industries and Occupations, Report prepared for the International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 1 (Geneva, 1923). 2 For the discussions at this Conference, see International Conference of Labour Statisticians: Report, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 4 (Geneva, 1924), pp. 8-30. 10 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS At the Second and Third Conferences in 1925 and 1926 attention was given to the list of industries; the Second Conference recommended that the Office draft a provisional list for use in labour statistics 1 , and the Third suggested that the details of the specific content of each industry group as used in the classifications of the different countries be compiled as a further step in the direction of a uniform list.2 In response to the resolution of the Second Conference the Office prepared a provisional list of the principal branches of economic activity, for the purpose of presenting in a uniform order the data available in respect to wages, employment and unemployment. The list (latest revision) is given in Part II (pp. 5152). A further study of the subject has been undertaken by the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations—on which the International Labour Office is represented—to which the whole question of preparing a scheme of classification of industries was referred in accordance with the provisions of the International Convention relating to Economic Statistics. 3 This Committee has considered the problem of industrial classification in relation to the gainfully occupied population. On this subject its final report in 1938 recommended a uniform definition of the "gainfully occupied" and two lists of industries—a minimum list and a detailed list—for purposes of classifying the gainfully occupied in a uniform manner for international comparison. The minimum list is given in full in Part II (pp. 65-66), together with the pertinent resolutions of the Committee, and the recommended definition. With regard to a similar list of occupations for purposes of international comparisons, the Committee decided against any attempt (for the time being) to draft such a list since it considered that an occupational classification was primarily of national rather than of international statistical interest. In this connection, the statistical work of the Office relating to the gainfully occupied population may be discussed. A series 1 For the discussions at the Second Conference, see Report on the Proceedings of the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 8 (Geneva, 1925), pp. 40-70. In this connection reference may be made to R. H. COATS: " T h e Classification Problem in Statistics", in International Labour Review. Vol. X I , No. 4, Apr. 1925, p p . 509-525. 2 For the discussions at the Third Conference, see Report on the Proceedings of the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 12 (Geneva, 1926), pp. 86-91. 3 This Convention was adopted in 1928 by the International Conference relating to Economic Statistics called under the auspices of the League of Nations. Manley O. HUDSON (ed.): International Legislation: A Collection of Texts of Multipartite International Instruments of General Interest beginning with the Covenant of the League of Nations, Vol. IV, 1928-1929, pp. 2575-2589, esp. 25822583 (Washington, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 1931). CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 11 of brief articles in the International Labour Review during the period 1935 to 1940 reviewed the statistics of the occupational censuses in the different countries as these became available, pointing out differences in definitions of gainfully occupied and presentting a series of tables, so far as possible, according to a uniform plan. 1 Tables showing the gainfully occupied in the different countries of the world, based on a uniform definition including unpaid family workers, so far as the data in the original sources permit, are published in the Year Book of Labour Statistics beginning with Volume II (1937). Tables are also given showing the gainfully occupied classified by industry or occupation groups in accordance with the classifications adopted in the sources. The 1941 Year Book includes a table of the percentage gainfully occupied according to the age groups recommended by the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations. 2 1 See, for example, International Labour Review, Vol. X X X V I I I , No. 5, Nov. 1938, pp. 706-714, and references there cited. * See also "A Comparison of the Gainfully Occupied Population by Sex and Age in the Various Countries of the World", in International Labour Review, Vol. X L I , No. 5, May 1940, pp. 541-550. Mention may be made of two special articles: J. W. N I X O N : "On the Statistics available concerning the occupied population of the world and its distribution", in Revue de l'Institut international de Statistique, 1938, livraison 3; and "Statistical Survey of Non-Manual Workers", in International Labour Review, Vol. X X X I V , No. 2, Aug. 1936, pp. 244-274. See also below, Part I I , p. 64. II EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT UNEMPLOYMENT The Office: prepared a report on Methods of Statistics of Unemployment for the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians in 1925.1 The resolutions of this Conference recognised that the best basis for unemployment statistics was formed by the comprehensive schemes of unemployment insurance, but where these did not exist, statistics from workers' organisations and from public employment offices would furnish valuable data. In countries where satisfactory information from these sources was not obtainable, the Conference recommended that special enquiries should be made from time to time, preferably at the time of the general population census. 2 Mention should be made also of the Recommendation adopted by the International Labour Conference in 1935 concerning unemployment among young persons, which urged that unemployment statistics should show sex, age, and occupation, persons who had never been in employment being classified separately and according to the occupation for which they had been trained or in which they had applied for employment. 3 The statistics of unemployment depend to a large extent upon the systems in force for relieving unemployment, and on the definition of "unemployed". With the extension of the scope of unemployment insurance, the scope of adequate statistics of unemployment has continually increased. 1 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 7 (Geneva, 1925). See also, Methods of Compiling Statistics of Unemployment: Replies of the Governments, Studies and Reports, Series C, No. 7 (Geneva, 1922). Mention should also be made of the provision embodied in Article I of the Unemployment Convention, 1919, according to which each Member State ratifying the Convention undertakes to communicate to the Office all available statistics and other information concerning unemployment. See The International Labour Code 1939, p. 543. 2 For the discussions at this Conference, see Report on the Proceedings of the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 8 (Geneva, 1925),pp. 48-67. 3 For the text of this part of the Recommendation see The International Labour Code 1939, p. 541. EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT 13 The Office publishes statistics of unemployment in the International Labour Review and in the Year Book of Labour Statistics.1 In general, two main problems occupy the principal attention: the numbers unemployed—wholly and partially—and the percentages unemployed based on the sum of the employed and the unemployed. Special problems include unemployment trends by industry or occupation, unemployment among women and young persons, and seasonal movements in the percentages of unemployment.2 In publishing the periodical statistics of the numbers unemployed, the Office emphasises that they relate to recorded unemployment only, and are not a complete census of the unemployed ; that therefore the figures are more useful in indicating whether unemployment is increasing or decreasing in any country than in showing the absolute level of unemployment at any given date. In this connection the Office reviewed the results of censuses of unemployment in various countries in articles in the International Labour Review in 1933 and 1935.3 In recent years the Office has devised an international index of unemployment in which the fluctuations of some 15 important countries (recently 13) are combined by a suitable system of weighting into an index number to show the general movements in the level of unemployment.4 1 See also, Statistics of Unemployment in Various Countries 1910 to 19ZZ, Studies and Reports, Series C, No. 6 (Geneva, 1922), and Unemployment 19201923, Series C, No. 8 (Geneva, 1924). For a discussion of the different types of statistics, see the introductory notes to chapter on "Employment and Unemployment" in the Year Book of Labour Statistics. For detailed notes on the methods of the statistics, see I.L.O. YearBook, 1934-35, Vol. I I : "Labour Statistics", pp. 169-183, and corresponding references in the Year Book of Labour Statistics. 2 See for example, "Movements of Unemployment and Employment in Different Industries and Occupations", in International Labour Review, Vol. X X V , No. 3, Mar. 1932, pp. 399-414; Henri F u s s : "Unemployment and Employment among Women", ibid., Vol. X X X I , No. 4, Apr. 1935, pp. 463-497; and "An International Index of Unemployment", ibid., Vol. X X X I I , No. 1, July 1935, pp. 118-119. s "Some Recent Censuses or Estimates of Unemployment", in International Labour Review, Vol. X X V I I I , No. 1, July 1933, pp. 46-61, and Vol. X X X I I , No. 6, Dec. 1935, pp. 826-850. Also Robert R. NATHAN: "Estimates of Unemployment in the United States, 1929-1935", ibid., Vol. X X X I I I , No. 1, J a n . 1936, pp. 49-73. i For a full account of the methods adopted and the results obtained, see John LINDBERG: "An Attempt to Construct International Measures of Unemployment", in International Labour Review, Vol. X X V I , No. 4, Oct. 1932, pp. 491-512; and idem, "Some Problems in the Construction of Index Numbers of Unemployment", ibid., Vol. X X I X , No. 4, Apr. 1934, pp. 472-499; "National and International Index Numbers of t h e General Level of Unemployment", ibid., pp. 557-571; and "World Index Numbers of Unemployment", ibid., Vol. X X X I X , No. 1, Jan. 1939, pp. 118-129, and "World Level of Unemployment", Ibid., No. 6, June 1939, pp. 812-813. 14 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS EMPLOYMENT 1 Comparatively little attention has been given by the Conferences to the subject of employment as such. The censuses of the gainfully occupied including employers, persons working on own account, as well as the employed and unemployed give the fundamental data on the employed as a part of the gainfully occupied population ; the problems of the statistics of the gainfully occupied have been discussed briefly in the preceding section, and are dealt with in the excerpts from the report of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations, reproduced in Part II (pp. 5266). For the rest, the statistics of the employed have been treated in the Conference resolutions almost as if they were implied in the statistics of unemployment: the calculation of percentages unemployed implies corresponding percentages employed, and totals of the two groups together. With specific reference to employment, the Second International Conference (of 1925) included a short resolution to the effect that "information as to the state of employment should also be published periodically, if possible monthly, based on returns made by a representative number of employers". Reference may be made also to resolutions dealing with actual and normal hours of work. Apart from these the subject of statistics of employment is also referred to implicitly in resolutions dealing with industrial disputes and industrial accidents, in describing the exposure data required. In order to calculate frequency and severity rates of industrial accidents, for example, data on the total man hours (or man days) of employment or average number of persons employed in the corresponding industries and occupations, must be available. These resolutions, while they do not describe in detail the methods by which the statistics are to be obtained, give certain definite specifications as to the objectives sought. Statistics of employment are published by the Office in the International Labour Review and in the Year Book of Labour Statistics. The statistics are derived from returns from sickness insurance statistics of persons employed or covered by the insurance, from unemployment insurance statistics and from employers (establishments). Some of the special problems of employment data are indicated in the introductory remarks to the section of the Year Book of Labour Statistics dealing with statistics of employment. The statistical series showing fluctuations are of two main types: (1) those showing changes in the numbers of employed 1 See also "Gainfully Occupied", p. 9; "Hours of Work", pp. 20-21. EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT 15 persons and (2) those showing changes in the total number of hours worked. Index numbers of employment are given for different industries for a limited number of countries in the I.L.O. YearBook prior to the appearance of the Year Book of Labour Statistics and for a somewhat larger number of countries in the latter publication. As in the case of unemployment, a world index of employment has been constructed by the Office, to show the trends and changes in the general level of employment. 1 1 See John LINDBERG: "Some Problems of International Employment Statistics", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXXV, No. 5, May 1937, pp. 608-642; and "International Index Numbers of Employment", ibid., Vol. X X X V , No. 5, May 1937, pp. 724-733; also "World Indexes of Employment", ibid., Vol. X L , No. 1, July 1939, pp. 125-134. Ill WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK MONEY W A G E S The subject of wages was one of the topics on the agenda of the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians in October 1923, for which the Office submitted a report on Methods of Statistics of Wages and Hours of Labour.1 This Conference adopted resolutions covering the types of wages or earnings statistics to be collected, as well as on index numbers of wages as discussed below. The two Conferences of Statisticians convoked by the Social Science Research Council2 in 1929 and 1930, considered the question of wage data in conjunction with the index numbers of wages and the difficult problem of international comparisons, a subject which is discussed further below. Following these, the Fourth International Conference of Labour Statisticians in 1931, in a series of resolutions addressed to the Office, reviewing the problems of international comparisons of real wages, included as part of this broader topic details as to the wages data to be collected. Of special importance was its recommendation that the question of the supply of data on wages and the cost of living required for international comparisons of real wages be considered with reference to the framing of a convention that would bind governments ratifying it to collect and supply information at regular intervals. Following up this suggestion, the I.L.O. Committee of Statistical Experts, itself organised in accordance with a recommendation of this Fourth Conference, considered the plan for a convention at its second session in December 1935; the Fifth International Conference of Labour Statisticians in September-October 1937 formulated a 1 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 2 (Geneva, 1923). For the discussions at this Conference, see International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Studies and2 Reports, Series N, No. 4 (Geneva, 1924), pp. 30-47. _ See International Wage Comparisons. Documents arising out of Conferences, held at the Intel-national Labour Office in Jan. 1929 and May 1930, convened by the Social Science Research Council of New York. Manchester University Press (1932). An account of the First Conference is also contained in "An International Conference on Wage Statistics", in International Labour Review, Vol. XIX, No. 4, Apr. 1929, pp. 522-539. WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 17 draft Convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work for the consideration of the International Labour Conference ; and the 24th Session of the International Labour Conference meeting in June 1938 adopted the Draft Convention which is given in full in Part II (pp. 85-94). The Convention set forth a minimum programme of wages and hours statistics to be compiled by each ratifying State, the results of which were to be forwarded to the International Labour Office. By this means it was hoped to promote the adoption of this minimum programme by the various countries. 1 The texts given in Part II include also certain supplementary resolutions which were adopted by the Fifth International Conference of Labour Statisticians, but which by reason of the limitation of the agenda could not be considered by the International Labour Conference. They include also the recommendations, based on resolutions adopted by the Fifth Conference, which were referred by the International Labour Conference to the Governing Body of the Office to be sent out by the Office to the different Governments for further consideration, in accordance with the procedure prescribed in the Convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work. Prior to the First Conference in 1923 the Office had commenced the study of wages and wage changes in different countries. The International Labour Review for January 1923 contained the first of a series of such studies 2 , while in 1922 a first report on Wage Changes in Various Countries, 1914-1921 was published. 3 In these special reports, emphasis was laid upon the difference between wage rates and earnings, and on real earnings as distinct from 1 For a discussion of this Convention, see J. W. N I X O N : "An International Convention on Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work", in Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Vol. CI, Part IV, 1938, pp. 730-735. See also " T h e TwentyFourth Session of the International Labour Conference", in International Labour Review, Vol. X X X V I I I , No. 3, Sept. 1938, pp. 350-355; and International Labour Conference, Twenty-Fourth Session, Geneva, 1938, Record of Proceedings, pp. 34-35, 292-295, 646-670. By 1 August 1942, the Convention was in force for Denmark, Sweden, South Africa, Australia, Norway, Netherlands, New Zealand, Switzerland, Egypt and Mexico. The Convention is divided into six Parts; Members ratifying it may exclude from their acceptance (a) any one of the Parts II, III or IV; or (b) Parts II and IV; or (c) Parts III and IV (Article 2). Exclusion is effected by appending a declaration to ratification; such a declaration may be cancelled at any time by a subsequent declaration. Pursuant to this provision, Australia, New Zealand and South Africa have excluded Part II from their acceptance; Denmark, Egypt, Norway, Sweden and Switzerland have excluded Part I I I ; and Egypt, South Africa and Switzerland have excluded Part IV. Part II covers earnings and actual hours of work and Part I I I time rates of wages and normal hours of work in mining and manufacturing industries; Part IV deals with wages and hours of work in agriculture. 2 International Labour Review, Vol. VII, No. 1, Jan. 1923, pp. 80-95. 3 Studies and Reports, Series D, No. 2 (Geneva, 1922); No. 10, Wage Changes in Various Countries, 1914-1922 (Geneva, 1923); No. 16, Wage Changes in Various Countries, 1914-1925 (Geneva, 1926). 18 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS money earnings. In these early articles and reports, wages and hours of labour were treated country by country. This arrangement was continued in articles in the International Labour Review.1 The number of countries supplying information gradually increased, and in 1929 an international table covering 12 countries showing changes in the general level of wages within each country was presented. 2 In 1931 international tables 8 were given showing the movements of wages in the principal industries and occupations in different countries. Data on wages in a number of specific occupations in the principal cities as of October of each year have been obtained since 1924 by means of special enquiries addressed to the statistical offices of the different countries and have been published in the International Labour Review.4 Since the publication of the Year Book of Labour Statistics (and its predecessor Vol. II: Labour Statistics of The I.L.O. Year-Book, for 1934-35), these tables have been incorporated in it. Special monographs relating to specific industries were published for the textile industry and agriculture. 6 In addition special enquiries have been made into wages and hours of labour in the coalmining industry, by means of questionnaires, in 1925, 1927, 1929, 1931 and 1937. The questionnaires, drawn up with the aid of a special committee, were sent to the various Governments, together with details of the terms used. By this means it was sought to obtain internationally comparable data. 8 Special reports on the world textile industry and on the world coal-mining industry included data on wages and hours of work in different countries in 1 May 1928 to May 1929. International Labour Review, Vol. XX, No. 1, July 1929, pp. 113-125; Vol. XXI, No. 1, Jan. 1930, pp. 117-127. 8 International Labour Review, Vol. XXIV, Nos. 2-3, Aug.-Sept. 1931, pp. 294-302; Vol. XXVI, Nos. 2-5, Aug.-Nov. 1932, pp. 255-267, 431-437, 562-577, and 716-738. 4 Up to 1930 the data were obtained at more frequent intervals. The report on the enquiry for October 1941 was published in the International Labour Review, Vol. XLVI, No, 5, Nov. 1942, pp. 638-653; each such report refers to the preceding report. * "Wages and Hours of Work in the Textile Industry (Cotton and Wool)", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXX, No. 3, Sept. 1934, pp. 387-418; "Statistics of Wages of Agricultural Workers in Various Countries, 1927-1934", ibid., Vol. XXX, Nos. 5-6, Nov.-Dec. 1934, pp. 692-708, 844-865. 6 The results of the first enquiry were published in a volume Wages and Hours oj Work in the Coal-Mining Industry, Studies and Reports, Series D, No. 18 (Geneva, 19281, and those for 1927, 1929 and 1931 in the International Labour Review, Vol. XX, No. 4, Oct. 1929, pp. 539-562; and No. 6, Dec. 1929, pp. 840855, errata, p. 903, and Vol. XXI, No. 1, Jan. 1930, pp. 89-108; Vol. XXIII, No. 5, May 1931, pp. 644-666, errata, p. 937; and Vol. XXVIII, No. 3, Sept. 1933, pp. 371-394. The volume on the coal-mining industry contained the results of a further enquiry; see The World Coal-Mining Industry, Studies and Reports, Series B, No. 31, 2 Vols. (Geneva, 1938). See also "The European Lignite Industry", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXII, No. 6, Dec. 1930, pp. 752-772; Vol. XXIII, No. 1, Jan. 1931, pp. 25-Ì7. 2 WAGES AND HOURS OP WORK 19 these industries. 1 The Maritime Statistical Handbook2 published in 1936 included details of wages and wage rates for the merchant marine personnel in all the maritime countries of the world. The Office has also published from time to time summaries of the results of the general wage censuses referred to in paragraph 5 of the resolutions of the First Conference.8 INDBX NUMBERS OP W A G E S The resolutions of the First International Conference of Statisticians of October 1923 included a recommendation to the effect that "index numbers should be computed to show the general course of changes in nominal wage rates and in actual earnings". 4 The two conferences of statisticians called by the Social Science Research Council adopted a series of resolutions dealing with index numbers of wages. The first Conference (1929) divided the subject into three main topics and considered index numbers of wages as measuring fluctuations (1) in one of the elements determining the standard of living, (2) in the remuneration per hour of work, and (3) in the labour cost per unit of production. In detail, its recommendations were designed to throw light upon six different aspects of wage index numbers: (1) changes in the standard of living of the working classes as a whole, (2) changes in the fluctuations in the standard of living as between different industries and occupations in the same country, (3) as an aid to forecasting economic conditions, (4) to measure earnings per hour in respect of work of comparable character and efficiency, (5) for measuring labour cost per unit of production, and (6) to measure variations in the proportion of the national income formed by wages. The second Conference called by the Social Science Research Council (1930) emphasised certain specific points important in the collection and organisation of the data, in particular stressing the differences between rates and earnings, the importance of the industries covered, the problem of including or excluding women's rates in a general index, and the influence on the index of changes in the relative proportions of the industries, etc., which are included in the index number. 1 The World Textile Industry: Economic and Social Problems, Studies and Reports, 2 Vols., Series B, No. 27 (Geneva, 1937); The World Coal-Mining Industry, 2 Vols., Series B, No. 31 (Geneva, 1938). 2 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 21 (Geneva, 1936). 8 For a general discussion of the problems of wage statistics, see Umberto R I C C I : " T h e Compilation of Wage Statistics", in International Labour Review, Vol. X I I I , No. 4, Apr. 1926, pp. 489-505. 4 For a discussion of the resolution on wage index numbers and a synoptic analysis of the methods of compilation adopted in different countries, see J. W. N I X O N : "Index Numbers of Wages: A Survey", in Revue de l'Institut internationale de Statistique, Vol. I, No. 1, Jan. 1933, pp. 39-53. 20 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS The Convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work includes articles prescribing index numbers of the general movement of earnings per hour, and where possible per day, week or other customary period, and of the general movement of rates of wages per hour or per week to be compiled by the countries ratifying the Convention (articles 12, 21). With special reference to index numbers of real wages, that is, indices combining indices of nominal wages with those of the cost of living of wage earners' families, the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians in October 1923 included a general recommendation to the effect that the changes in actual earnings should be related to changes in the cost of living. The whole subject of measuring; changes in the cost of living is treated in section IV, (pp. 22-23) while that of international comparisons of real wages and of the cost of living is discussed in section V (pp. 24-30) below. In particular, the resolutions of the Fourth Conference of Labour Statisticians in 1931, though directed specifically to the problems of international comparisons of real wages, contain many recommendations applicable to the compilation of national indices of real wages. Index numbers of nominal and real wages are published at quarterly intervals in the International Labour Review and in the Year Book of Labour Statistics. At the date of their first publication only 12 countries were included; in the Year Book for 1941 they extended over 34 countries; in many cases with separate series for different industries, for both sexes, for males and females, and showing wage rates or earnings per hour, or earnings per day, week or month. T O T A L W A G E S AND SALARIES The first Conference of Statisticians called by the Social Science Research Council in 1929 adopted resolutions dealing with the measurement of changes in the proportion of the national income formed by wages, or by the remuneration of labour as a whole. A special study of the statistics of total wages and salaries was published in the International Labour Review for September 1936.1 Annual figures on the subject have been given in the Year Book of Labour Statistics since 1937. HOURS OF W O R K 2 Since the subject of hours of work has been dealt with at the International Conferences of Labour Statisticians in close connec1 "Statistics of Total Wages and Salaries", in International Labour Review, Vol.2 XXXIV, No. 3, Sept. 1936, pp. 391-410. See also Employment, pp. 14—15. WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 21 tion with that of wages—on account of the relation between earnings and hours worked—the topic is included here under the heading Wages and Hours of Work. The First Conference adopted resolutions concerning the collection of data on normal and actual hours of work, giving the principles following which the statistics should be obtained. 1 Since in practice normal hours correspond to full time wages, and actual earnings to actual hours, the close relationship between hours and wages is clear as well as the need for the collection of hours data in connection with wages. The Convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work followed the same plan with more detailed specifications of the exact scope of the data to be collected. Statistics of hours of work were published by the Office in a series of reports for different countries 2 , and subsequently in the statistics section of the International Labour Review and in the Year Book of Labour Statistics. These figures give, in general, average actual or full time hours of work per week (or per day, or per month) as well as index numbers showing the trends; in some countries distributions of hours of work are given; in many countries details are given by industries or occupations. 3 A special report on Hours of Work in Postal Services was published in 1935.4 1 1 See references cited in note 1, p. 16. Hours of Labour in Industry: Germany, Studies and Reports, Series D, No. 4, (Geneva, 1922); No. 5, Hours of Labour in Industry: Belgium (Geneva, 1922) No. 6, Hours of Labour in Industry: France (Geneva, 1922); No. 7, Hours of Labour in Industry: Great Britain (Geneva, 1922); No. 8, Hours of Labour in Industry: Italy (Geneva, 1923); No. 9, Hours of Labour in Industry: Switzerland (Geneva, 1923); No. 11, Hours of Labour in Industry: Netherlands (Geneva, 1923); No. 12, Hours of Labour in Industry: Czechoslovak Republic (Geneva, 1924); No. 14, Hours of Labour in Industry: United States (Geneva, 1925). See also references cited in notes 4-6, p. 18. 3 Normal hours of work were obtained for selected occupations in the October enquiries beginning with that of 1932; see "Wages, Hours of Work and Other Factors in the Remuneration of Workers in Certain Towns in October 1932: I", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXVII, No. 6, June 1933, pp. 815-838. Statistics of actual hours of work were published for the first time in the Review, Vol. XXXI, No. 2, Feb. 1935, pp. 265-289. The Year Book of Labour Statistics, 1941, includes 4 tables dealing with hours of work; general level of hours of actual work; general level of normal hours of work; hours of work by industries, and normal hours of work in 30 occupations in October 1940. 4 Studies and Reports, Series D, No. 21 (Geneva, 1935). IV COST OF LIVING 1 At the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians the subject of cost of living was approached in general terms m a resolution recommending that index numbers of the purchasing power of wages should be calculated "by relating changes in actual earnings to changes in the cost of living", the two series being comparable. The subject of Cost of Living Index Numbers was placed on the agenda a.t the Second International Conference, and the Office prepared a report on Methods of Compiling Cost-of-Living Index Numbers.2 The Conference adopted a series of resolutions covering the methods of construction, basis and other points for cost-of-living indices. 3 In particular, recommendations were made as to the use of family living studies as a basis for weighting the indices for the different elements in the cost of living. Most of the other references to cost of living in the various resolutions given in Part II (see index) are concerned specifically with international comparisons of cost of living, which are discussed below. Reference should be made, however, to these on account of the bearing they have on cost-of-living statistics in each country. The Office commenced the regular publication of cost-of-living figures in the International Labour Review in its first number, in January 1921. These utilised the series of cost-of-living index numbers as developed in each country. Special articles on problems of cost-of-living indices and notes on methods employed in different countries have appeared in the International Labour Review from time to time. 4 1 See also V. International Comparisons of Real Wages and Cost of Living, p. 24; VI. Family Living Studies, p. 31. 2 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 6 (Geneva, 1925). 3 For the discussions at the Conference, see The Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 8 (Geneva, 1925), pp. 7-20, 35-37. i See Ugo G I U S T I : "Methods of Recording Retail Prices and Measuring the Cost of Living in Italy", in International Labour Review, Vol. IV, No. 2, Nov. 1921, pp. 257-274; Felix K L E Z L : "Methods of Calculating Index Numbers", Md., Vol. X, No. 2, Aug. 1924, pp. 236-262; and E. C. SNOW: " T h e Practical Interpretation of Index Numbers", ibid., Vol. X I , No. 2, Feb. 1925, pp. 180-199. COST OP LIVING 23 During the period prior to the great depression of the early 1930's, the base used by most countries for cost-of-living indices was 1914, to show prices in relation to a pre-war level, and to facilitate international comparison conversions were made by the Office to this base where the original series used some other period.1 Beginning with the volume of labour statistics issued as Part II of the I.L.O. Year Book in 1934-1935, which immediately preceded the first Year Book of Labour Statistics, the cost-of-living figures as well as other economic series have been converted to a uniform base of 1929 as the year of reference.2 The Year Book of Labour Statistics included data on the cost of living in forty-three countries in 1935-1936, and in fifty-three countries in the 1941 edition. In most years, figures on the trends in costs of important sub-groups, food, fuel and light, clothing and rents have also been presented. 1 The question of the year to be chosen as the base was considered by the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians which recommended that the Governments, in collaboration with the I.L.O., agree to adopt the same year as base for the calculation of a new series of index numbers, and suggested the year 1930 as suitable for these purposes. Subsequently the first Conference called by the Social Science Research Council in 1929 considered the same problem from the point of view of wage statistics; they emphasised the importance of uniformity, but did not specify any particular year. The problem was considered also by the International Conference relating to Economic Statistics called by the League of Nations, which referred the question to the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League: this Committee at its second session in December 1933 held that it was, at that time, premature to establish a uniform base subsequent to the war of 1914-1918 for purposes of economic statistics. 2 The Statistical Year Book of the League of Nations has also adopted the year 1929 as the year of reference for indices. V INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS OF REAL WAGES AND COST OF LIVING In this section only those aspects of the topics of real wages and cost of living will be discussed which relate to international comparisons. 1 Obviously, however, the basic data already discussed under wages and cost of living are also relevant to comparisons between countries. In the First and Second International Conferences of Labour Statisticians {1923, 1925) the problem of international comparisons was raised in connection with the work of the Office in carrying further the international comparisons of real wages in selected cities commerced by the British Ministry of Labour. In particular, the Second Conference adopted a resolution embodying certain suggestions for the work of the Office.2 The whole problem was considered further by the first and second Conferences of Statisticians (1929, 1930) called by the Social Science Research Council. The Fourth International Conference of Labour Statisticians (1931) reviewed the whole subject and adopted a series of resolutions addressed to the Office on various specific details of methods to be followed in comparing, internationally, money wages and real wages. In addition, as noted elsewhere, the Conference recommended the establishment of a Committee of Statistical Experts, to advise the Office in its work on wages and costs of living. All these resolutions, including those of this Committee dealing with wages, food, and rent comparisons, are given in Part II (pp. 101115). This outline of the development of the resolutions, however, needs to be supplemented by a review of the development of the statistics. The enquiry of the British Ministry of Labour, which was taken as the starting point, consisted in ascertaining the wages of adult 1 See Felix KLEZL: "International Comparisons of Real Wages", in International Labour .Review, Vol. XII, No. 4, Oct. 1925, pp. 467-483. 2 For the discussions at the Second Conference, see The Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 8 (Geneva, 1925), pp. 21-34, 37-39. INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 25 male workers in a series of about thirty occupations in a large number of towns, together with the retail prices of a number of articles of common consumption, in order to permit calculations of the purchasing power of wages. In 1924 the Office undertook its first enquiry of this type: the results, published in October 19241, attempted to express the relative purchasing power of average wages or earnings for a standard (48-hour) week in the different cities with reference to London as a base. The elements in this method included the wage data, on the one hand, and the cost-of-living data—a list of important food items, with an adjustment for rents—on the other, in conjunction with a method of expressing the final results in terms of an index, with London as base. It was soon found, however, that the wage data were not homogeneous or strictly comparable in all respects: some of the data were for earnings, some were for wage rates; in some cases they referred to minimum, in others to predominant, rates; and moreover, the money wages themselves did not always fully express the total remuneration of the workers—the amount of which is affected by payments for holidays, family allowances, allowances in kind, and the value of the social insurance contributions. In carrying out the successive studies, a series of improvements was introduced in the techniques and methods—as discussed in the reports of these investigations. Tables of these international indices of wage comparisons were published during the period from 1924 to 19302 in conjunction with data on wages, retail prices of important food items, and percentage spent for rent as shown in family budget studies. These indices were presented as merely rough indications of relative wages, and their defects were of course apparent both to the Office and to those who might attempt to use them. The further development of the subject and the various steps taken to advance the materials and methods available will be discussed under the headings Wages, Elements of Remuneration Other than Wages, Cost of Living, Food and Rents. WAGES The first plan adopted to secure materials usable for purposes of comparison involved obtaining wage data for a list of selected 1 "Comparison of the Levels of Real Wages in Certain Capital Cities", in International Labour Review, Vol. X, No. 4, Oct. 1924, pp. 630-652. * See in particular, in addition to article cited in preceding note: "Wage Rates and Retail Prices in Various Cities", in International Labour Review, Vol. X I , No. 1, J a n . 1925, pp. 103-110; Vol. X I , No. 4, Apr. 1925, pp. 561-572; Vol. X I I , No. 1, July 1925, pp. 96-106; and "Comparison of Real Wages in Various Countries", ibid., Vol. X X I , No. 4, Apr. 1930, pp. 557-566. 26 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS occupations in specific industries at a given time in the chief cities of the principal countries. This was commented upon in the Resolutions of the Second Conference (1925); the first Conference of Statisticians called by the Social Science Research Council proposed certain additions to the list. The Fourth Conference (1931) also urged the extension of these materials. For the rest, the Fourth Conference and the Convention concerning statistics of wages and hours of work urged the development of the basic statistics of time rates of pay and actual earnings as fundamental to international comparisons of real wages. The materials available and published by the Office have already been described in the section on Wages. They include the wages for 30 occupations in October of each year for the principal cities in the different countries, as published in the International Labour Review (since 1924) and in the Year Book of Labour Statistics, and average wage rates and earnings, by industries and occupations in the several countries, as published in the Year Book of Labour Statistics. Special mention should be made of the investigations of the coal mining and textile industries, with their information on wages in these industries in different countries. 1 ELEMENTS OF RÉMUNÉRATION OTHER THAN W A G E S This question was touched upon in one of the resolutions of the Fourth Conference relating to wage comparisons between countries operating under different systems of social insurance, family allowances, paid holidays and other points, and was referred by it to the Committee of Statistical Experts. The Committee at its first meeting (Geneva, 12-15 December 1933) adopted a resolution on the subject as given in Part II, pp. 107-108. Statistics dealing with the subject are meagre. T h e principal materials available in Office publications are a special report dealing with wages, hours of work and other factors in the remuneration of workers in certain towns in October 19322, and the reports 1 5 See references cited above, notes 4-6, p. 18 , and note 1, p. 19. "Wages, Hours of Work, and Other Factors in the Remuneration of Workers in Certain Towns in October 1932: I" (Money Wages, Hours of Work), in International Labour Review, Vol. XXVII, No. 6, June 1933, pp. 815-838; II (Family Allowances, Holidays with Pay, Employers' and Workers' Contributions to Compulsory Social Insurance Schemes), ibid., Vol. XXVIII, No. 1, July 1933, pp. 104-121; III (The Interpretation and Combination of the Data, Conversion of the Data for the Purpose of Comparisons between different Towns and Countries), ibid., Vol. XXVIII, No. 2, Aug. 1933, pp. 265-284. See also "Holidays with Pay for Private Employees", ibid., Vol. XXIV, No. 6, Dec. 1931, pp. 713-741, and references therein cited. For special problems of non-monetary remuneration of agricultural workers see "Statistics of Wages of Agricultural Workers in Various Countries, 19271934", ibid., Vol. XXX, Nos. 5-6, Nov.-Dec. 1934, pp. 692-708, 844-865. Also, for example, "Allowances in Kind given to Farm Labourers in the United States", ibid., Vol. XX, No. 4, Oct. 1929, pp. 562-567. INTBRNATIONAI, COMPARISONS 27 dealing with wages of workers in coal mines in the series of studies already referred to.1 COST OP LIVING The resolutions of the second Conference of Statisticians called by the Social Science Research Council in 1930 dealt with the question of international comparisons of costs of living; they recommended that new family living studies be made whenever necessary to furnish recent data on family expenditure, and made certain proposals as to the methods to be followed in making comparisons of living costs. The Fourth International Conference in 1931 also emphasised the need for new family living studies. In regard to comparisons of cost of living, these resolutions included a recommendation that the Office ask the statistical authorities in each country to furnish data on rents of working-class families in the towns for which data on wages and prices were obtained. Certain resolutions were directed also to the specific methods of comparison. In addition, as already noted, the Conference recommended that a Committee of Statistical Experts be established to assist the Office in the work of developing wage and cost-of-living statistics. It may be noted that in the resolution of the Fourth Conference, recommendations were phrased in terms of food, fuel and light, and rents; for purposes of ascertaining weights, family living studies of working-class families were recommended. These resolutions thus recognised the practical difficulties in the way of any complete comparison of costs of living on an international plane. The recommendations of the Committee of Statistical Experts have considered the problems, thus far, primarily in terms of the two most important elements, food and rent, as discussed below in the succeeding sections. The figures of retail prices of a list of commodities in different towns in various countries, usually as of October of each year, have been obtained and published since 1924.2 During the period 1924 to 1930 when indices of comparative real wages based on selected occupations in certain cities were published by the Office, an attempt to take differences in costs of living into account took two forms, the first based on the cost of 1 See citations in note 6, p. 18. See also "Annual Holidays with Pay for Miners Employed in Coal Mines", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXI, No.2 2, Feb. 1930, pp. 219-243. See, in addition to references cited in note 1, p. 25, "Wage Rates and Retail Prices in Various Cities", in International Labour Review, Vol. XI, No. 1, Jan. 1925, pp. 103-110; No. 4, Apr. 1925, pp. 561-572; Vol. XII, No. 1, July 1925, pp. 96-106, and similar articles in subsequent volumes of the Review. 28 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS baskets of a list of food items to represent food consumption of wage earners' families in the different regions, and the second based on this cost as adjusted to take account of differences in the proportion of the family budget spent for rent. The whole problem of comparative costs of living was raised in the enquiry carried out by the Office to compare the cost of living of a certain category of workers in Detroit (U.S.A.) and those in fourteen European towns in January 1931.1 The methods adopted and the problems encountered in the course of the enquiry were discussed in the report and in an article in the International Labour Review entitled "An International Enquiry into Living Costs". 2 In its subsequent work on this subject, the Office has devoted its attention to the problems of comparing food costs and rents as a preliminary stage to the solution of the more complex problem of the costs of living as a whole. 3 Food In the first work undertaken by the Office in the international comparison of real wages, as already noted, the source data available for comparing costs of living were limited to the costs of a list of important foodstuffs and the final results were presented in two forms, one based on relative food costs only and the other including an adjustment for rent. 4 The method followed in these food cost comparisons included calculations based on regional food budgets averaged so as to give a single figure with London as a base. In October 1929, the method of making comparisons of food costs was modified by the use of an international basket. The international basket was established by taking the average consumption in workers' families per consumption unit in the different countries included in the comparisons; the basket of foods was priced in each city and the ratios of these costs in the case of any two cities gave the desired ratio of food costs. In the original list of foodstuffs, some 25 articles were priced 5 , but in 1933 the list was 1 A Contribution to the Study of International Comparisons of Costs of Living, Studies and Reports, Series N , No. 17 (Geneva, 1932). The enquiry is often referred to as the Ford-Filene enquiry since it originated in a request for information made to the International Labour Office by the Ford Motor Company Ltd. (London) and was financed by t h e Twentieth Century Fund (President—Mr. Edward A. F I I . E N B ) . 2 By H. STAEHLB, in International Labour Review, Vol. X X V I , No. 3, Sept. 1932, pp. 313-363. 3 For an examination of certain methodological problems, see Robert M. WOODBURY: "Quantity Adjustment Factors in Cost-of-Living Ratios", in Econometrica, Vol. 8, No. 4, Oct. 1940, pp. 322-332. 4 "Comparison of the Levels of Real Wages in Certain Capital Cities", in International Labour Review, Vol. X, No. 4, Oct. 1924, pp. 630-652, esp. p. 652. 6 "Comparison of Real Wages in Various Countries", in International Labour Review, Vol. X X , No. 4, Oct. 1929, pp. 580-588. INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 29 reduced to 14 by omitting the least important items. 1 Data on the cost of this food basket in a list of cities were published each year. A study embodying the results of an enquiry undertaken to ascertain the cost of living in various European cities on the same standard as that of employees in the Ford factories in Detroit adopted the method of the geometrical average of the Laspeyres and Paasche indices, the so-called "ideal" formula of Fisher, as the best measure of the relative cost of living (and hence also of the cost of food) between two cities.2 Apart from the resolutions of the Fourth Conference, dealing with the general problem of international comparison of real wages, which contain some provisions relating specifically to data on food consumption and prices, and those of the Third Conference relating to family budget studies, the problems of food cost comparisons are dealt with in resolutions of the Committee of Statistical Experts to which the whole question was referred by the Fourth Conference. A special report dealing with the theoretical problems of international comparisons of food costs was prepared for the first meeting of this Committee in 1933.3 This report suggested the establishment of regions of good comparability; the relative costs of food between cities within each region would be based on a comparison of the costs of the regional food basket in these cities. Finally, the whole problem was reviewed in a report on International Comparisons of Food Costs, originally prepared for a meeting of the Committee of Statistical Experts called for the spring of 1940; when this meeting had to be abandoned the comments and suggestions received by mail from the members of the Committee were noted and the report was published in the Statistics Series. This report proposed the group basket method, in which the Fisher formula is used as a means of comparing each pair of countries, substituting, however, in the calculations the group basket to which the country is allocated on the basis of similarity of proportionate consumption for the local basket of each country. 4 International indices of comparative food costs on this basis are 1 "An International Comparison of the Retail Prices of Certain Important Foodstuffs, July 1929 to Oct. 1932", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXVII, No. 4, Apr. 1933, pp. 530-538. 2 See note 1, p. 28. 3 International Comparisons of Cost of Living. A Study of Certain Problems connected with the Making of Index Numbers of Food Costs and of Rents, Part I, "International Comparisons of Food Costs", by H. STAEHLE, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 20 (Geneva, 1934). 4 International Comparisons of Food Costs, by Robert Morse WOODBURY, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 24 (Montreal, 1941). See also Robert Morse WOODBURY: "International Comparisons of Food Costs", in International Labour Review, Vol. XLIII, No. 2, Feb. 1941, pp. 153-173. 30 INTERNATIONA!, STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS included in trie Year Book of Labour Statistics, 1941, for 25 countries for prices and exchange rates of October 1938. Figures for a smaller number of countries for October 1940 are given in the International Labour Review for April 1942.1 Rents2 The Fourth International Conference of Labour Statisticians in 1931 adopted a resolution containing specific recommendations on the subject of rents for purposes of international comparisons of costs of living. The International Labour Office Committee of Statistical Experts, established in accordance with the suggestion of the Fourth Conference, considered tlie problem of rents at each of its three sessions and adopted a series of resolutions advising the Office in its research activities in this field. In particular, a series of standard housing units was defined in terms of the availability of certain items of equipment—bathroom, toilet and running water— and these in conjunction with the number of rooms in the dwelling furnish a frame of reference to make possible the collection of statistics of rents related to size and quality of dwellings along uniform lines in different countries. The theoretical problems of rent comparisons are discussed in a special report prepared for the Committee and in a special article in the International Labour Review} The Office carried out a survey of statistics of rents in certain towns in 1932, the results of which were published in the Review. Subsequently, at the suggestion of the Committee of Statistical Experts, rent statistics for the standard housing units, as established by the Committee, were collected, the survey for 1936 covering a number of towns in some 20 countries. The results were published in the Review and in The Year Book of Labour Statistics, 1939.4 1 s Vol. XLV, No. 4, Apr. 1942, pp. 472-474. For the statistics of rents as part of the cost of living see above, pp. 22-23, IV. Cost of Living; as part of expenditures, see below, pp. 31-32, VI. Family Living Studies; as an element in housing statistics, see below pp. 35-36, VIII. Housing. The Committee of Experts on Housing Statistics at its meeting in Munich, 1928, adopted a definition of rent (see under VIII. Housing). * International Comparisons of Cost of Living. A Study of Certain Problems Connected with th-e Making of Index Numbers of Food Costs and of Rents, Part II, "International Comparison of Rents", by R. GUYB, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 20 (Geneva, 1934), pp. 107-146; and R. GUYE: "A Further Contribution to the International Comparison of Rents", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXXIV, No. 5, Nov. 1936, pp. 569-593. 4 "International Statistics of Rents in Certain Towns", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXVIII, No. 2, Aug. 1933, pp. 248-264; "Retail Prices and Rents in Certain Towns and Countries in October 1933", ibid., Vol. XXIX, No. 6, June 1934, pp. fi59-865; "Retail Prices and Rents in Certain Towns in 1934", ibid., Vol. XXXI, No. 3, Mar. 1935, pp. 428-136; "Workers' Dwellings in Certain Towns: An Enquiry into the Quality, Rents, and Conditions of Occupation of Workers' Dwellings", ibid., Vol. XXXIV, No. 5, Nov. 1936, pp. 686-702; "Rents of Workers' Dwellings in Various Towns, 1936-37", ibid., Vol. XXXVIII, No. 6, Dec. 1938, pp. 840-861. VI FAMILY LIVING STUDIES The subject of family budget enquiries was approached indirectly at the Second International Conference in 1925 in connection with the problem of cost-of-living index numbers. The Conference adopted a resolution to the effect that the weights should be based, so far as possible, on working-class consumption in the districts or among sections of workers to which the index numbers related, and pointed out that the best method of obtaining such data was through family living enquiries. For the Third Conference in 1926 the Office prepared a report on Methods of Conducting Family Budget Enquiries1 and the Conference adopted a series of resolutions on the subject. 2 At the Fourth Conference, these resolutions of the Third Conference were referred to, with the recommendation that where enquiries had not been made during the preceding ten years new enquiries should be undertaken on lines laid down in the resolutions. In following up the work of the Third Conference, the Office adopted a programme of analysing and publishing in the International Labour Review the results of the various important family budget enquiries soon after their appearance; these analyses called attention to the chief characteristics of these studies, and by presenting these results according to a uniform pattern suggested the importance of covering at least the basic points which were dealt with in these summaries. The analyses were themselves summarised in November 1933 in a general review of the chief enquiries conducted in the previous ten years. 8 A special analysis of food consumption per consumption unit in wage earners' families according to the results of family living studies appeared in the Review in December 1933.4 A second general summary was published in 1 2 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 9 (Geneva, 1926). For the discussions of the Third Conference see Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 12 (Geneva, 1926), pp. 12-37, 92-98. * "Recent Family Budget Enquiries", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXVIII, No. 5, Nov. 1933, pp. 635-672. 4 "Food Consumption of Working-Class Families in Certain Countries", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXVIII, No. 6, Dec. 1933, pp. 870-876. 32 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS 1939 covering not only the general expenditure but also food expenditure and consumption habits 1 ; this was followed in June 1940 by a special summary of enquiries relating to families of the unemployed2, and in April 1941 by a summary of enquiries relating to families of agricultural workers. 8 In 1940 a revised report on Methods of Family Living Studies: Income—Expenditure—Consumption brought the material on methods up to date; it included a special chapter devoted to food and dietary surveys. 4 A special report, prepared for the 1942 PanAmerican Sanitary Conference at Rio de Janeiro 5 , included a survey of dietary studies in American countries together with a chapter on Methods of Dietary Surveys. 6 Comparative data on certain aspects of family living—sources of family income, percentage expenditures on chief groups, food consumption per consumption unit—are published in the Year Book of Labour Statistics. 1 "An International Survey of Recent Family Living Studies": I (Income and Expenditure), and II (Food Expenditure and Consumption Habits), in International Labour Review, Vol. X X X I X , Nos. 5-6, May-June 1939, pp. 662-705, 814-846. 2 "An International Survey of Recent Family Living Studies": III (Families of Unemployed Workers), in International Labour Review, Vol. X L I , No. 6, June 1940, pp. 645-662. » "An International Survey of Recent Family Living Studies": IV (Families of Farmers and Agricultural Workers), in International Labour Review, Vol. X L I I I , No. 4, Apr. 1941, pp. 474-491. 4 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 23 (Geneva, 1940). s Robert Morse WOODBURY: Food Consumption and Dietary Surveys in the Americas, Results—Methods, Report presented by the International Labour Office to the Eleventh Pan-American Sanitary Conference held at Rio de Janeiro, 7 to 18 September 1942 (Montreal, 1942). 6 In addition to the references already cited, see J. W. N I X O N (Rapporteur): "Preliminary Report of the Committee on Family Budgets", in Revue de l'Institut internationale de Statistique, 4th year, 1936, No. 1, pp. 4 5 - 6 1 ; and Workers' Nutrition and Social Policy, Studies and Reports, Series B, No. 23 (Geneva, 1936). VII INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS A report on Methods of Statistics of Industrial Accidents was prepared for the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians in October 1923.' This Conference adopted certain general resolutions on the question of international standardisation of statistics of industrial accidents, e.g. concerning the classification of accidents by industry, cause, extent and degree of disability, location of injury and nature of injury. 2 Recommendations were made also as to the form of calculation of frequency and severity rates. Subsequent conferences have not dealt further with the problems of industrial accident statistics. The activities of the Office, however, include special articles in the International Labour Review*, two reports on methods of compiling statistics of accidents in coal mining and on railways4, and analyses of industrial accidents in different countries, A first analysis of industrial accident rates in 30 countries was published in an article in the Review for December 19316; this included details of the definitions and methods utilised in the different countries. A Report on Industrial Accident Statistics*, issued in 1938, supplemented and expanded these figures, and brought them up-to-date. Comparative tables were presented on accident 1 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 3 (Geneva, 1923). * For discussions at the Conference, see International Conference of Labour Statisticians: Report, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 4 (Geneva, 1924), pp. 49-63. * J. W. NIXON: "Some Problems of Statistics of Accidents as Illustrated by the British Statistics", in International Labour Review, Vol. XVIII, No. 6, Dec. 1928, pp. 731-739; idem, "The Measurement of Risk in Connection with Labour Statistics", Vol. XVII, No. 5, May 1928, pp. 633-650; ibid., "Industrial Accidents", Vol. XXIV, No. 6, Dec. 1931, pp. 751-787. * Methods of Compiling Statisticsof Coal-Mining Accidents, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 14 (Geneva, 1929), and Methods of Compiling Statistics of Railway Accidents, Series N, No. 15 (Geneva, 1929). 'International Labour Review, Vol. XXIV, No. 6, Dec. 1931, pp. 751-787. A preliminary survey covering 21 countries was published in the January 1931 issue, Vol. XXIII, No. 1, pp. 87-110. 4 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 22 (Geneva, 1938). 34 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS rates in coal mining, metal mining, all mining, quarrying, industry, agriculture and railways.1 Beginning; with 1940, comparative tables of fatal accident rates in coal mining and all mining (including non-fatal rates in some countries), industry and railways have been published in the Year Book of Labour Statistics. 1 Reference may also be made to a statement adopted by the Committee of Experts on Safety in Coal Mines (Geneva, 21-24 Nov. 1938) published in The International Labour Code 1939, p. 737. Vili HOUSING» Although the statistics of housing fall somewhat outside the scope of labour statistics as this term is generally understood, housing conditions are an important factor in the standard of living and rents an important element in living costSi The latter topic has already been discussed in connection with international comparisons of costs of living. Housing statistics are basic to the development of a housing policy of national and local authorities in their efforts to improve housing conditions. The interest of the Office in statistics of housing has led to its participation in the work of two Committees, the Committee of Experts on Housing Statistics of the International Union of Towns and the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations. For the meeting of the former in Munich in May 1928 the Office prepared a report on Methods of Compiling Housing Statistics.2 Its resolutions on statistics of housing are included in full in Part II, which includes also extracts from the report of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League proposing a detailed plan of housing statistics. The resolutions of the two Committees in part overlap: both give definitions of room, dwelling, occupant, and household; the former includes a definition of rents, as well as a recommendation concerning statistics of dwellings classified according to the amount of rent paid. Both give detailed specifications for censuses of dwellings and for their classification according to certain important characteristics—number of rooms, equipment, and occupancy. The problem of standardisation of these statistics is important not only among different countries but also in the same country between the different branches of these statistics (censuses of buildings and dwellings, statistics of the housing market, and statistics of rents), which are often within the competence of different departments. 1 See also Rents, p. 30 above. * Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 13 (Geneva, 1928). 36 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS The different statistics of housing as published in the different countries have not yet been included in the scope of regular compilations by the Office. In a study of housing policy in Europe1, however, the principal results of the censuses of dwellings as well as statistics of housing construction for the years 1920-1927 were given systematically, following the proposals of the resolutions of the Committee of Experts in Housing Statistics. Reference has already been made to the results of the surveys of rents in the principal towns of different countries in the section dealing with international comparisons of rents. The importance of similar classifications of dwellings in housing censuses and i:i current statistics of rentals paid must be emphasised not only for comparisons of rental costs in different communities but especially in international comparisons. 1 Housing Policy in Europe, Studies and Reports, Series G, No. 3 (Geneva, 1930); see also, R. GUYE: "Post-War Building Difficulties and Housing Policy in Europe", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXIV, Nos. 2-3, Aug.-Sept. 1931, pp. 200-227. IX COLLECTIVE AGREEMENTS The Office prepared a Report on Methods of Compiling Statistics of Collective Agreements for the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians. 1 The resolutions on this topic adopted by the Conference are somewhat similar to those on industrial disputes and recommend detailed methods, definitions and classifications for these statistics. 2 Very few countries, however, have elaborated this branch of labour statistics, which depends to some extent on the forms of trade union organisation and the labour legislation of the country. 3 Annual figures on this topic were compiled by the Office up to 1935 showing, both for the number of new agreements concluded during the year and the number in force during the year, the number of establishments and workers covered. Only a few countries (11), however, could be included in these statistics. 4 1 Studies % and Reports, Series N, No. 11 (Geneva, 1926). For the discussions at this Conference, see The Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 12 (Geneva, 1926), pp. 838-57. For a discussion of the statistics in Germany, see W. WOYTINSKY: "New Statistics of Collective Agreements in Germany", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXIII, No. 4, Apr. 1931, pp. 506-532. 4 For notes, sources, etc., of these statistics, see The I.L.O. Year-Book, 193435, Vol. II: Labour Statistics, pp. 162-163, 245-247. X INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES A Report on Methods of Compiling Statistics of Industrial Disputes was prepared for the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians. 1 The resolutions adopted by the Third Conference included recommendations that full details of industrial disputes classified by industry, method of settlement, by results, by importance (i.e. number of establishments, number of workers and number of days lost) should be published at least yearly in each country. 2 The method of classification recommended for each of these characteristics was given in detail. The Office has not attempted to analyse the available statistics by all the criteria indicated above, but has limited itself to publishing figures showing the number of establishments, number of workers involved and number of days lost.8 In the Year Book of Labour Statistics, 1939, figures for some 35 countries were included. In some countries, however, industrial disputes have been forbidden by law. The statistics are of interest chiefly in showing the loss caused by this form of interruption of work. A comparative table showing for 19 countries the loss caused (in man days) by industrial disputes in certain branches of industry —manufacture, mining, transportation—in relation to the persons gainfully occupied in these branches was published in the International Labour Review in May 1938.* 1 8 Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 10 (Geneva, 1926). For the discussions at this Conference, see Studies and Reports, Series N, No.8 12 (Geneva, 1926), pp. 38-85. See also "Industrial Disputes", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXVIII, No.4 1, July 1933, pp. 92-99. "Days Last through Industrial Disputes in Different Countries", in International Labour Review, Vol. XXXVII, No. 5, May 1938, pp. 674-678. For an earlier analysis on similar lines, see E. J. RICHES: "International Comparisons of the Time Lost through Industrial Disputes", in Economic Record (Melbourne), Vol. IX, No. 17, Dec. 1933, pp. 226-234. XI EMIGRATION AND IMMIGRATION As far back as 1921, the International Emigration Commission set up by the First Session of the International Labour Conference at Washington, 1919, passed resolutions recommending inter alia, that the various Governments should communicate regularly to the Office all available information concerning emigration and immigration. As a sequel to this, the Fourth Session of the International Labour Conference in 1922 adopted a Recommendation requesting the various Member States to communicate all available information and also invited the International Labour Office to make every effort to facilitate an international co-ordination of migration statistics. 1 As a consequence of these decisions, the Office compiled and published the data as articles in the International Labour Review and in the form of special studies. 2 A special Conference on Migration Statistics was called in October 1932.3 For this purpose, a study of the methods adopted in different countries was prepared and published. 4 The resolutions adopted by the Conference dealt with the definition of a migrant, the various methods of collecting the information, and the methods of classifying the data. In the international tables compiled annually by the Office, and published in the Year Book of Labour Statistics it has not been possible to analyse the data by all the different criteria indicated by the Conference. Emigration and immigration figures are given separately, and subdivided as far as possible 1 For the text of this Recommendation, see The International Labour Code 1939, pp. 555-556. ! These studies were published as follows: Migration Movements 1920-1923, Studies and Reports, Series O, No. 1; Migration Movements 1920-1924, Studies and Reports, Series O, No. 2; Migration Movements 1925-1927, Studies and Reports, Series O, No. 4. See also "Migration Movements", in International Labour Review, Vol. X X , Nos. 2 and 5, Aug. and Nov. 1929, pp. 259-283 and 719-740. 3 An account of this Conference is contained in "An International Conference on Migration Statistics", in International Labour Review, Vol. X X V I I , No. 1, J a n . 1933, pp. 1-24. 4 Statistics of Migration: Definitions—Methods—Classifications, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 18 (Geneva, 1932). 40 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS into nationals and aliens, and into continental and intercontinental movements. The different sources of migration statistics enumerated by the Conference are also clearly indicated: port statistics; declarations of residence; frontier control; coupons detachable from documents (e.g. passports), etc.1 1 In addition, mention should be made of an article b y L. VARLEZ: "Seasonal Fluctuations in Migration", in International Labour Review, Vol. X V I I , Nos. 4 and 5, Apr. and M a y 1928, pp. 486-514, 671-686; an article by Imre FERENCZI: " A Historical Study of Migration Statistics", ibid., Vol. X X , No. 3, Sept. 1929, pp. 356-384; NATIONAL B U R E A U OP ECONOMIC R E S E A R C H : International Migra- tions (New York, 1929), Vol. I of which contains statistics compiled on behalf of the International Labour Office with introduction and notes by I. FERENCZI; and World Statistics of Aliens, Studies and Reports, Series O, N o . 6 (Geneva, 1936). XII YEAR BOOK OF LABOUR STATISTICS Finally, the recommendation of the Fourth Conference that an annual volume on wages and prices should be published which would be in essentials a development and amplification of the tables published at regular intervals in the International Labour Review has been realised by the publication of the Year Book of Labour Statistics. The statistics in this volume are not confined to wages and prices, but extend to other branches of labour statistics with which the Conferences of Labour Statisticians have dealt, including employment and unemployment, cost of living, family budgets, food consumption, industrial disputes, emigration and immigration, and industrial accidents. In addition, a chapter on the gainfully occupied gives basic figures for the labour supply, and tables furnished by the Economic, Financial and Transit Department of the League of Nations give information on exchange rates, wholesale price indices, and world indices of production necessary to furnish a background for the adequate interpretation of the data in the other tables. The Year Book, commencing formally with the 1935-36 issue, was a natural outcome of the work of the International Labour Office in the field of labour statistics. The first number of the International Labour Review (Jan. 1921), contained statistical material on wholesale and retail prices, cost of living and unemployment; a special article on wage changes appeared in April 19231; and from January 1924 a separate section in the Review was devoted to statistics. Supplementing this material were the statistics published in the various special studies on employment and unemployment 2 , wages3, and migration. 4 The first volume » Loc. cit., Vol. VII, No. 4, pp. 577-603. Statistics of Unemployment in Various Countries 1910 to 1922, Studies and Reports, Series C, No. 6 (Geneva, 1922); Unemployment, 1920-1923, No. 8 (Geneva, 1924). ' Wage Changes in Various Countries 1914-1921, Studies and Reports, Series D, No. 2 (Geneva, 1922); No. 10, Wage Changes in Various Countries 1914 to 1922 (Geneva, 1923); No. 16, Wage Changes in Various Countries 1914 to 1925 (Geneva, 1926). * Migration Movements 1920-1923, Studies and Reports, Series O, No. 1 (Geneva, 1925); No. 2, Migration Movements 1920-1924 (Geneva, 1926); No. 4, Migration Movements 1925-1927 (Geneva, 1929). 3 42 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS TABLE I. SCOPE OP TABLES AND NUMBER OF COUNTRIES 1 COVERED Subject Population Gainfully occupied Structure of the gainfully occupied population: industrial status, and industry or occupational groups 2 Sex and age groups 3 II. Employment and unemployment 4 General level of employment Indices of numbers employed: A. Mines, industries, transport, commerce, etc B. Industries Indices of total hours worked in industries Employment, by industries General level of unemployment 5 Unemployment, by industries 6 III. Hours of work (ieneral level of hours of work A. Hours actually worked per worker B. Range of hours actually worked: percentage distribution. C. Normal hours Hours worked by industries A. Average hours actually worked B. Range of hours actually worked: percentage distribution. C. Normal hours' Hours of work in October (normal) IV. Wages (ieneral level of wages A. Hourly rates or earnings B. Daily, weekly and monthly earnings 8 Wages by industry or occupation A. Hourly rates or earnings B. Daily, weekly or monthly earnings 9 Wages per hour in October, in selected occupations Total wages and salaries V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. Cost of living and retail prices Cost of living, general indices 10 Retail prices of foodstuffs, fuel, in October 11 Family living studies Sources of family income (wage earners' families)". Direction of expenditures (wage earners' families) 12 . Direction of expenditures b y income classes Average food consumption 14 Migration Emigration and immigration Net intercontinental migration Labour relations 16 Industrial disputes (strikes and lockouts). Industrial accidents Mining 1 ndustry Railways > As countries are counted those which had separate status at the time the Year Book was issued or have been shown as separate countries in subsequent editions. Where dashes are shown, no table on the subject was published in the Year Book. ' In 1937-1938 a special summary table showed the gainfully occupied according to industrial status, with 19 and 24 countries respectively. « In 1937, the gainfully occupied were shown for different age and sex groups; in 1941, the percentages gainfully occupied by sex, for three age groups, 15-19, 20-64, and 65 and over. 4 In addition, world indices of employment were given for 1937 to 1941, and world indices of unemployment for 1935-36 to 1941. 5 In addition national indices (of degree of unemployment) are given for 16 countries for 1935-36, 1937 and 1938. • In 1937 and 1938, figures of unemployed by sex were given for 18 countries. 7 By industries or occupations. 8 Including earnings per shift, and insured daily or weekly wage. • Wages in agriculture, 21 countries in 1935-36, 22 coun- YEAR BOOK OF LABOUR STATISTICS 43 IN THE YEAR BOOK OF LABOUR STATISTICS, 1935-36 TO 1941 N u m b e r of countries for which statistics on the specified topics are shown in Year Books of 1935-36 1937 1938 1939 1940 1941 1942 — 35 42 44 44 46 50 — 18 17 22 — 29 — 30 — 33 IS 32 18 23 23 24 26 26 32 32 — — — 10 33 17 — — — 16 32 17 17 16 — 17 32 17 18 18 12 17 31 17 16 23 12 17 31 16 18 29 13 23 31 17 18 29 13 26 30 17 13 10 — — 12 12 10 6 — 11 14 12 6 — 11 15 15 8 8 9 17 17 8 7 15 8 9 9 10 3 7 26 — 5 26 — 5 21 17 17 8 7 15 10 — 5 19 4 — 21 3 — 23 14 12 6 — 12 10 3 7 23 26 17 16 28 18 15 21 — 27 19 15 30 19 16 23 21 31 19 24 29 20 16 24 21 31 19 24 28 20 15 27 21 29 24 20 24 18 11 27 21 34 26 27 27 18 16 23 26 34 26 27 27 18 16 20 27 43 24 44 26 48 25 51 32 52 35 53 31 56 35 11 20 8 14 15 21 14 — 15 22 18 — 21 26 22 17 23 27 — 21 24 30 — 26 25 32 29 29 63 21 59 21 60 23 60 23 60 23 60 23 61 23 33 35 35 35 — — — — — — — — 14 20 20 14 20 21 14 20 21 9 H — — tries in 1938; wages in coal mines, 7 countries in 1938. i° Group indices for the same number of countries were published in 1935-36, 1937, 1938 and 1939; indices for food only in 1941; in 1942, for 54 countries. 11 Figures on monthly rents of workers' dwellings in 19 countries were published in the Year Book for 1939. Indices of international comparisons of food costs were published in the Year Book for 1941 for 25 countries; 12 in the Year Book for 1942, for 19 countries. For non-manual workers' families in 10, 13 and 13 countries in 1939, 1940 and 1941 respectively. 1S For non-manual workers' families in 11, 14 and 15 countries in 1939, 1940 and 1941 respectively. The distribution of food expenditures (vas given for 12 countries in 1935-36 and 16 in 1937. » In 1935-36, according to income classes. 16 In 1935-36, figures on collective agreements in force were given for 7 countries, and for collective agreements, renewed, or modified for 10 countries« 44 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS of the I.L.O. Year Book in 1930 contained a few tables on cost of living, wages and unemployment, scattered through the text in connection with the various topics. In subsequent volumes the scope of these tables was expanded: in the I.L.O. Year Book for 1932 labour statistics appeared in 5 appendices with 8 tables; in 1933, an entire Appendix II was devoted to labour statistics, with 5 groups of topics; in 1934-35, Labour Statistics appeared as Volume II of the I.L.O. Year Book: and in subsequent years, the Year Book of Labour Statistics appeared as an independent publication. Table I portrays the changes in scope of the tables of the Year Book, showing the number of countries included in the principal tables given in each edition. As a complement to this, and to give a background of the expanding scope of these statistics, table II shows the changes in the number of countries covered in the tables of the International Labour Review from 1924 to 1935 (prior to the publication of the Year Book). The increase in the number of countries is not presented as in any sense an exact measure of the improvement in the various statistics over the period; it reflects in part a greater diligence on the part of the Office in obtaining the data and a desire to include as many countries as possible instead of merely the principal ones: it remains true, however, that the improvement in these statistics is both real and important, and that the drive for better statistics in the several lines in the different countries is the principal factor in the broadening scope of the tables. A point of especial interest throughout the series is TABLE I I . NUMBER OF COUNTRIES COVERED IN TABLES ON SELECTED TOPICS IN THE INTERNATIONAL LABOUR REVIEW, 1 9 2 4 - 1 9 3 5 1 Number of countries for which statistics are shown in the International Labour Review Subject 1924 1925 1926 1927 1928 1929 1930 1931 1932 1933 1934 1935 Employment (general level) Unemployment 4 (general level) 19 Wages: General level Wages in October» Cost of living and retail prices: Cost of living 22 Retail prices in October» 3 3 5 5 5 6 8 11 14 16 23 19 19 22 22 23 27 29 28 30 32 34 16 20 21 23 27 25 16 20 18 18 17 15 18 20 22 20 19 23 27 34 34 35 37 38 39 39 38 38 16 20 19 18 17 17 19 21 21 23 23 1 Selected topics only as specified. The number of countries is that of the table which was the first on the specified topic published during the year. s In some cases for a month other than October. YEAR BOOK OF LABOUR STATISTICS 45 the wide differences between the coverage of the different series: most countries have cost of living figures, but a much smaller number have good employment, unemployment and wages data. Together these two tables thus give a rough picture of the progress accomplished in the international standardisation of labour statistics, as more and more countries develop and publish statistics on the various topics which can be included in the comparative tables. The expanding scope of the materials available in the different countries reflects also the growing interest in labour statistics on the several topics. CONCLUSION In this short introduction to the resolutions which follow, it has only been possible to touch briefly on the scope of the resolutions adopteid and on the work of the Office in publishing the various statistics, in describing the methods adopted, and in analysing the results; the reader is referred to the detailed studies on particular subjects listed in the notes on the foregoing pages for fuller information o.a these questions. The introduction has, however, been sufficient to show that the Office has not been inactive in endeavouring to obtain, as a help to the solution of the problems with which it is called upon to deal, full and comparable statistics on all subjects which affect the conditions of labour. For many countries, statistics on many branches are still not available at all, or are available only at very irregular intervals, and even the most highly industrialised and best-equipped countries have serious gaps in certain of their statistics. The resolutions given in the following pages may, in specific fields, fall short of completeness and desirable detail—gaps which future conferences may be expected to fill. As a whole, however, they set high standards as a goal to be reached by the labour statistics of the several countries. Considerable progress towards the application of these resolutions has been made, and together they form a scheme which will lead, it is hoped, to still further improvements in the future. PART II Documentary Texts I THE CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS FOR PURPOSES OF LABOUR STATISTICS 1. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1923 [f] (1) Occupied persons should be classified in the first instance according to the industry in which they are employed, and within each industry they may be further classified according to their individual occupations. When it is not possible to give this double classification in sufficient detail to show the total number of workers in each individual typical occupation, it is necessary to make a second classification of all occupied persons according to their individual occupations, so that for comparative purposes two separate classifications will be available (a) by industry and (b) by individual occupation. \_2\ (2) Industries should be classified into the following main divisions : (a) Primary Production Agriculture, pasturing, forestry, hunting, fishing, etc.; mining, quarrying, etc.; i.e. extraction of minerals. (6) Secondary Production Manufacturing industries, etc. ; i.e. the transformation or modification of materials, together with the construction of buildings, roads, etc., and the repair of finished products. (c) Services Transport and communication; Commerce, finance, and trade; Public administration and defence; Professional services; Domestic service and personal services for which remuneration is paid; supply of board and lodging. [3] (3) In classifying manufacturing industries the establishment considered as a technical unit should be taken as basis. 50 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS M (4) In the absence of an agreed classification of industries and as a preparation for such a classification, and in order to facilitate international comparison, the groupings of industries used in the different: countries should be so subdivided that it would always be possible to secure separate information concerning an adequately complete number of industries included in a provisional list drawn up in alphabetical order, which might be prepared by the International Labour Office after consultation with any statistical services or organisations which might usefully assist in this work. K l (5) It is desirable for purposes of international comparison that each country should publish definitions of the occupational, industrial and other terms most commonly used in that country in connection with its labour statistics. 2. Resolution of the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, April 1925 jjf] The Conference, realising, as it did in 1923, that it is not possible at the present time to reach an agreement as to the scientific bases of an international classification of industries, but recognising that it is necessary to ensure in the immediate future some form of international comparison, at least for the principal industries, Recommends that pending the time when a complete classification becomes possible there should be drawn up, after consultation with the various statistical services and international organisations concerned, a. provisional list of the most important industries. In order that the question of drawing up a more complete list of industries which would serve as a base for international statistical comparisons might be thoroughly investigated, The Conference recommends the International Labour Office to invite the Governments to examine the draft classification which has been submitted to them, and to inform the Office of the difficulties which they would experience in adopting it, calling attention to cases where the draft list might be reduced or expanded. 3. Resolutions of t h e Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1926 DG (1) This Conference recommends the International Labour Office to elaborate the list of the most important industries submitted to it so as to show in greater detail the contents of each industrial group in the different countries, obtaining from the Governments any necessary information on the subject. This amplified list should be submitted in due course to the different Governments for their information and comment. CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 51 [<?] (2) The Conference also recommends the International Labour Office to pursue its endeavours in collaboration with the League of Nations and the International Statistical Institute to compare the existing classifications and to promote their gradual readjustment in the direction of greater uniformity and better comparability. 4. [_9] International Scheme for the Presentation of Data by Industry (or Occupation), framed1 by the International Labour Office Primary Production: I. Agriculture, etc. A = Agriculture fishing). II. (including forestry, hunting, and Mines. B = Mines (including quarries and oil wells). Secondary Production: I I I . Industries (manufacturing, construction, etc.). C = Metal (metallurgy, mechanical and electrical engineering, construction and repair of vehicles, ships, etc.). D = Brick and stone, pottery and glass. E = Building and construction. F = Wood (felling, floating, saw-milling, and woodwork, including furniture). G = Paper and printing. H = Textiles. I = Clothing (including boots and shoes). J = Skin, leather, and rubber. K = Chemicals. L = Food, drink and tobacco. M = Water, gas and electricity (production and distribution). Services: IV. Transport and communications. N = Land transport (road and rail). O = Navigation (inland, maritime and air). P = Post, telegraph and telephone. 1 First published in the International Labour Review, Vol. X X V I I I , No. 3, Sept. 1933, pp. 414-415; the list was adopted provisionally for the purpose of presenting the labour statistics published by the Office in a uniform order. The list given is the latest revision. 52 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS V. Public administration. Q R VI. = Street cleaning, police, fire and other public services not mentioned above. = Public administration (properly so-called). Commerce, personal and professional services, etc. S T = Commerce, banking and insurance. = Hotels and restaurants, domestic service, laundries, hair-dressing, etc. U = Entertainments, sports, etc. V = Professional services, education, etc. Not Classifiable: X Y = Miscellaneous. = Occupations covering several branches, e.g., clerks, general labourers, etc. 5. Excerptsi from the Report of the C o m m i t t e e of Statistical Experts of t h e League of N a t i o n s o n Statistics of t h e Gainfully Occupied Population 1 Definitions and Classifications Recommended A. DEFINITION OF THE GAINFULLY-OCCUPIED POPULATION I. Definition £l02 For the purpose of international classification, any occupation for which the person engaged therein is remunerated, directly or indirectly, in cash or in kind—i.e., any principal remunerated occupation or any secondary occupation which is the sole remunerated occupation of the person concerned—is to be considered as a gainful occupation. Housework done by members of a family in their own homes is not included under that description, but work done by members of a family in helping the head of the family in his occupation is so included, even though only indirectly remunerated. The occupation of persons working in labour camps or other similar institutions, or engaged in unemployment relief work, is to be considered as a gainful occupation. [ i í ] The particulars given should be based, generally speaking, on the occupation at the moment of the census. A person who 1 LEAGUE OF NATIONS: Studies and Reports on Statistical Methods, No. 1: Statistics of the Gainfully-Occupied Population. Definitions and Classifications recommended by the Committee of Statistical Experts (Official No. C. 226 M. 128. 1938 (C.E.S. 127) Appendix I; Ser. L.O.N., Pub. II, Economic and Financial, 1938, II. A. 12). CLASSIFICATION OK INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 53 has recently exercised a gainful occupation is to be considered as still engaged in that occupation even though, by reason of sickness, injury, vacation or inability to obtain work, he may, at the time of the census, be temporarily not working. \_12~] Young persons of working age and not at school, who have never actually exercised a gainful occupation, are not to be treated as part of the gainfully-occupied population, even though they may be seeking work and consequently included in statistics of unemployment. It is, however, desirable that censuses should be so taken that the number of young persons so situated can be ascertained. //. Distinctions in the Gainfully-Occupied Population Required for International Comparison \_13~] For reasons stated above . . . [not reproduced here], it is essential, in order to bring within the range of international comparability the totals of the gainfully-occupied population, that the following groups and sub-groups be shown separately among the persons conforming to the definition of Section I. Gainfully-Occupied Population. \_14~] (1) All persons gainfully occupied in the above-defined sense . . . with the exception of those specified in group 2 below. [_15~\ (2) Members of families, whatever their degree of relationship, aiding the heads of their families in their occupations, showing separately: (a) Wives (6) Wives (c) Other (d) Other farmers. of farmers; of persons other than farmers; members of farmers' families; members of families of persons other than [_16~] The term "farmers" shall be deemed to apply exclusively to the heads of enterprises classified under Chapter I of the Nomenclature of Industries. It is to be understood, however, that a person who works for the head of his family is to be classed under group 1, if the information regarding his personal status, or other available information, justifies the inference that he receives regular wages for that work. III. Persons Not Considered as Gainfully Occupied \_17^\ For the same reasons which necessitate the classification set forth [above] it is essential that among those not conforming 54 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS to the definition of persons gainfully occupied, or, by reason of the system current in their countries, not included in the record of persons gainfully occupied, the following groups and sub-groups be shown separately: Population Not Recorded as Gainfully Occupied. \_18~\ (1) Members of families of working age, capable of work and not attending school, distinguishing: (a) Wives (6) Wives (c) Other (d) Other farmers. of farmers; of persons other than farmers; members of farmers' families; members of families of persons other than [_19~\ (2) All other persons, including persons living on private means or maintained by their families or from public or private resources—e.g., rentiers and pensioners, annuitants, landlords; children, including those attending school, and students, whether living with their parents or guardians or not; aged, sick or infirm persons living with their families or in hospitals, sanatoria ór asylums; inmates of prisons. Persons only temporarily unoccupied should be included in the occupied population. IV. Definition and Classification of the Unemployed \_20\ The Committee examined the difficult problem of the classification of persons who at the moment of the census are unoccupied owing to lack of work, and decided to recommend a definition of the gainfully-occupied population which should be inclusive of such persons. \_21~\ Persons recorded at the census as unemployed should be classified according to their last occupation. In national tables, the Committee thinks it advisable that such unemployed persons should be counted separately, as classification by their most recent occupation may give an erroneous idea of the importance of some branches of economic activity which are on the decline. For the reasons given below, the Committee has not made this distinction in the international programme. \_22~] In conformity with the general principle according to which information provided should be based on the occupation at the time of the census, the persons and unemployed men working in labour camps and similar institutions, or on unemployed relief work should be classified in a special category and not according CLASSIFICATION OP INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 55 to their particular task at the date of the census (a principle applying also to the classification of persons undergoing military service). In view of the great differences existing between the systems for relieving unemployment in the various countries (establishing labour camps, organising public works, granting subsidies to existing industries, etc.) the Committee does not believe that the separation from other "gainfully-occupied persons" or individuals receiving assistance of the kind indicated would increase the accuracy of international comparisons. [23] The Committee realises that the above recommendations do not allow of a bird's-eye view of a country's unemployment situation, or of the total number of persons potentially belonging to a particular branch of activity or having a particular occupation. The picture provided by a census, however, can be only of an instantaneous nature and cannot throw light on all aspects of the problem of unemployment. For this purpose, a special census of unemployed would be necessary. B. T H E D I F F E R E N T SYSTEMS OF CLASSIFYING THE GAINFULLYOCCUPIED POPULATION \_Z4\ By a recommendation of the International Conference relating to Economic Statistics, the Committee was asked to study the question of systems of classification of the occupied population by industry and by personal occupation, and the distribution of the occupied population according to occupational status (i.e., employers, employed, etc.). The Committee has accepted the view, already expressed by other conferences of statisticians, that a classification according to the three following principles: (a) (&) (c) By branches of economic activity; By personal status; By individual occupation is necessary to obtain an adequate picture of the economic and social structure of the population. \j25~] As regards classification by branches of economic activity, the Committee has endeavoured, for the reasons given in paragraph C, to apply this principle as strictly as possible. In particular, it has been anxious to avoid overlapping of this principle with that of individual occupation ; and, for that reason, the Committee's classification by branches of economic activity will be found not to include a section for the "liberal professions", which was included in the classifications drawn up by the International Conferences of 56 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Labour Statisticians convened by the International Labour Office in 1923 and by the International Statistical Institute in 1925. l [,26] The Committee wishes to emphasise that, from the international point of view, the first two principles should be applied in the form of a cross-classification, in which persons belonging to the same branch of economic activity are distinguished in accordance with their personal status within that branch. C. CLASSIFICATION BY BRANCHES OF ECONOMIC ACTIVITY I. Object and Nature of this Classification [27] The Committee's recommendations with regard to the classification by branches of economic activity assume that the census cards or schedules contain a question, or even several questions, on the nature of the establishment in which the occupation is carried on. Information obtained by means of the question regarding the individual occupation only does not enable the grouping recommended from the international point of view to be carried out. On the other hand, a question regarding the individual occupation furnishes supplementary information which is very useful, and sometimes even indispensable, for grouping persons by branches of economic activity, especially in cases where different branches of activity are carried on within the same establishment. [28] The Committee is of the opinion that the main object of a classification by branches of economic activity for the purposes of statistics of the gainfully-occupied population is to show the absolute and relative importance of the various branches of industry. 2 It should be understood that industries are carried oh in establishments, and that a branch of industry should therefore comprise all the persons occupied in a given kind of establishment, regardless of what individual occupation they perform within that establishment. T h a t being so, it is the aim of the classification by individual occupations to show how the personnel belonging to a given branch of industry is composed from the point of view of individual occupations, and to supply, if desired, total figures for all persons exercising the same individual occupations. The Committee thinks that any procedure under which persons might, on account of their individual occupation, be assigned to another branch of industry than that in which they are actually employed would distort reality, and lead to rather meaningless results from every point of view. 1 By recommendation IV of the International Conference relating to Economic Statistics, the Committee was asked to take these classifications into account. 2 For convenience, the term "industry" is frequently used throughout this statement for a.ll branches of human economic activity. CLASSIFICATION OP INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 57 [29] The Committee wishes to make this point of principle entirely clear, because it is of the utmost importance for the international comparability of the various branches of economic activity and because its practical application involves, in certain cases, great difficulties. II. Definition of "Establishment" [30] For the reasons set out above, a classification of persons by branches of economic activity requires a classification of establishments, which in turn presupposes a definition of the term "establishment". [31] The term "establishment" is used hereafter not merely in connection with production, transport and commerce, but as covering also all units belonging to other branches of economic activity. For instance, schools, lawyers' offices and dentists' consulting-rooms are covered by the term "establishment". [32] There are three different conceptions of an establishment to be distinguished. [33] (1) The narrowest conception is that which is based on the technique of the work and which considers an establishment as comprising all persons working together under a certain direction and in closely related individual occupations. Under this conception, the furniture repair shop of a public administration, the painting shop of a motor manufacturing plant, the shops where wooden models are made in engineering works, would become separate establishments, and the persons occupied therein would be assigned, e.g., to the furniture, building and woodworking industries respectively. [34] (2) The second conception is based on the place at which the work is performed and considers all persons working together in the same factory or works as belonging to one and the same establishment. [35] Under this conception, the above "establishments" (painting shop, furniture repair shop, etc.) would not be recognised as separate establishments, and the persons occupied therein would be assigned to the branch to which the whole factory belongs. [36] (3) The third conception is based on the legal and financial organisation of the enterprise and considers all persons working together under the control of the same concern as belonging to one and the same establishment—e.g., the various branch shops belonging to the same entrepreneur. This conception, which has considerable importance for censuses of industrial and commercial establishments, is, in practice, not used for censuses of the gainfully-occupied population and can therefore be disregarded here. 58 INTERNATIONA!, STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS [_37~] For the reasons outlined above under C, I, the recommendations of the Committee are based on the second conception of an establishment. It is the success or the failure of the factory as a whole which mainly governs the situation of an occupied person; the "technical" establishments as defined under I have no independent life of their own. The persons are thus dependent on the development of the branch of industry to which the factory as a whole belongs, and it appears therefore reasonable to show these persons and their individual occupations in the framework of an industrial classification which takes the factory as a whole as the unit to be classified. In addition, this conception is the easiest to follow with the methods of a census of the gainfullyoccupied population. Q?£] There is no doubt that the practical application of the principle stated above meets with serious difficulties. The principal difficulty arises in connection with establishments combining a number of different activities. The Committee does not believe that indefinite or defective information as to the nature of an establishment (or of that part of an establishment in which the occupation is carried on) can be improved by the insertion in the census cards or schedules of a definition of "establishment", however unchallengeable such a definition might be from a theoretical standpoint. The following considerations are, therefore, intended to serve rather as guiding principles for the preparation of the material than for the collection of the basic data. \J9] In order to ascertain the nature of any given establishment and, if necessary, to allocate the individuals to the different branches of an establishment, the statistical offices are frequently compelled to take the individual occupation as a criterion. Information from other sources (census of establishments, registers of establishments, list of addresses, etc.) may also be useful in this connection. \jf02 As international comparisons of the results are largely dependent on this distribution, by branches of establishments, being carried out according to uniform principles in the different countries, the Committee believes it to be desirable to indicate general guiding lines, even though a strict application of uniform rules may sometimes be found very difficult. \jtl2 The following conditions may lead to the combination of different branches of activity in a single establishment—on the assumption that all persons working together in the same place, factory, workshop, etc., belong to such an establishment: \i42~\ (1) An establishment may include branches of an accessory character working in connection with the main process of production or forming a part of that process. CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 59 Examples.—The manufacture of wooden models in an engineering works, a printing press in a cigarette factory, or painting and upholstering shops in motor manufacturing works, a small repair shop in a commercial business. [43] (2) A number of successive stages of production, transformation or distribution may be combined in the same establishment. Examples.—Carding, spinning and weaving may be carried on in one establishment; a mine combined with a blast furnace, a rolling mill and an engineering works; an agricultural enterprise combined with a dairy manufacturing cheese, a factory combined with a retail shop. (Such small establishments as bakers', butchers', etc., shops, in which the retail sale is to a large extent carried on by the members of the family of the head of the establishment, who help sometimes in the manufacture and sometimes in the sale, are not considered here. In the case of these establishments, the retail sale should be treated as accessory, and consequently assimilated with the cases under (1).) [44] (3) Two branches of economic activity of a different technical character may be carried on in the same building and under the direction of the same proprietor without the existence of an economic relationship of the kind mentioned under (1) and (2). Examples.—A flour-mill and a sawmill depending on the same motive power, a butcher's shop combined with a hotel, a motor-car sales establishment combined with a repair shop which cannot be considered as accessory. [45] If combinations of type (2) or type (3) come under the same group in the International Minimum Nomenclature of Industries, it will not affect the international comparison of results whether the different branches are, or are not, shown separately. Where, however, the different branches fall into different groups of the Minimum Nomenclature, the Committee thinks that the persons belonging to each branch should be grouped with that branch. Persons working in a mine, for example, should be shown separately from those working in associated metallurgical or engineering works: but persons working in combined carding, spinning and weaving establishments may be shown together, since the Minimum Nomenclature comprises these branches of industry in a single group. 60 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS [462 Combinations of type (1) above should not be split up, and all persons should be classified in accordance with the nature of the principal branch—e.g., persons engaged in the carpentering or upholstering or painting shops of motor manufacturing works should all be classified under the motor industry. [473 It goes without saying that the splitting-up of different branches of an undertaking creates almost insuperable difficulties in dividing between them, in appropriate proportions, the administrative and operative staffs of the services that are common to these different branches. But the effect of uncertainties thus arising on the international comparison of results is small as compared with the effect resulting from the allocation being made in one country according to branches of establishments, while, in another, persons occupied in all branches of an establishment are classified under its principal branch. [482 It should also be made clear here that the juridical form of ownership does not influence the definition of an establishment. For example, printing works, gasworks and shipyards belonging to a public authority are not to be considered as a branch of "public services"; they should be treated in the same way as private establishments of a corresponding character, but counted separately in the respective groups. III. International Minimum Nomenclature of Branches of Economic Activity1 1. Purpose and Length of the Nomenclature. [.49] The main purpose of an international classification of branches of economic activity is to facilitate the comparison of national statistics. The Committee considers that, in practice, the best means of attaining this purpose would be for every country to give the necessary details for regrouping the items of its national classification in accordance with an international plan of classification, and publishing the results of this regrouping as a supplement to its own classification. [502 The Committee has deemed it advisable to establish an international nomenclature of medium length, enabling a reasonably clear picture to be obtained of the economic structure of each country. This nomenclature comprises forty-five chapters grouped in nine sections. The Committee recommends that, for each country, in addition to the results of its census according to its own national 1 See below, pp. 65-66. CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 61 nomenclature, there should be published a supplementary table grouping the data according to these forty-five chapters as the indispensable minimum for international comparison. A key, indicating which items of the national nomenclature are included in each chapter, should accompany this table. {51} In the case of twenty of the forty-five chapters, the Committee has distinguished two or more items. The total number of items in the nomenclature thus reaches ninety-four. 1 The indications of the contents of certain items should not be regarded as complete ; generally speaking, they are given only in cases in which doubts may arise as to the allocation of a particular branch of economic activity. The Committee considers it desirable that, in statements drawn up for international comparison, each country should publish separate data for every item which is of any considerable importance in its own economic life. 2. Principles of Classification. {,52} The main principle of grouping adopted by the Committee for the broad framework of the nomenclature is that of the technical organisation of the work in the various establishments and branches of industry. This can best be illustrated by the following scheme: I. II. III. Primary production: A. Agriculture, forestry and fishing; B. Mining and quarrying. Transforming industries: A. Manufacturing industries; B. Building and other construction. Services: A. Transport and communication; B. Commerce; C. Hotels and personal services; D. Public services and other services of general interest. {53} In the nomenclature itself, the form of presentation . . . has been selected for reasons of convenience and only the eight following sections are distinguished separately: A. B. C. 1 Agriculture, forestry and fishing; Mining and quarrying; Manufacturing industries; Not reproduced here; see note 1, p. 65. 62 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS D. E. F. G. H. Building and other construction; Transport and communication; Commerce; Hotels and personal services; Public services and other services of general interest. \_54~] To these, a ninth section is added for activities inadequately described. [_55^\ The main principles which can be applied to the grouping of manufacturing industries are: (1) The nature of the raw materials used; (2) The use of the products; (3) The technique of the work done. [_56~\ The Committee is therefore of the opinion that . . . the grouping of manufacturing industries should be based primarily on a combination of the raw material principle with the technique of work—this combination indeed forms the basis of the organisation of many establishments. In the case of industries producing articles ready for consumption to which in many cases the above principles cannot reasonably be applied, the use of the products should be taken into consideration. [.572 In the sections relating to primary production and manufacturing industries, the order of chapters follows as far as possible the order adopted in the "Minimum List of Commodities for International Trade Statistics". D. CLASSIFICATION BY PERSONAL STATUS [582 The Committee recommends the classification set forth below or any other classification in which the following groups are distinguished : [592 (1) Employers: Persons working on their own account with paid assistants in their occupation. [602 (2) Persons working on their own account, either alone or with the assistance of members of their families. [6Í2 (3) Members of families aiding the heads of their families in their occupations. [622 (4) Persons in receipt of salaries or wages: (a) Directors and managers; CLASSIFICATION OP INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 63 (6) Other persons in receipt of salaries or wages, distinguishing, if possible, between : (Î) Persons in receipt of salaries; (w) Wage-earners. [_63] This distinction between the employers in group 1 and the persons in group 2 makes it necessary, in the case of countries which do not take a census of establishments simultaneously with a census of population, for the cards or schedules used for the latter purpose to contain a special question or note as to whether or not a person employs paid assistants or only members of his family. [64] The Committee realises that, generally speaking, there is little reliable information regarding the separation of group 4 (a), "Directors and managers", from other persons in receipt of salaries. As some countries include directors and managers in the group of "employers", the distinction of group 4 (a) from group 4 (ò) is important for the compilation of comparable data. It may be noted in this connection that all State and local officials, irrespective of their rank in the administration, should be grouped under 4(0). \_65~] The Committee's proposed subdivision of group 4 (b) into persons in receipt of salaries and wage-earners is only optional. The Committee does not think it possible to lay down definite criteria which would enable the distinction to be made uniformly in all countries. It is aware that this distinction, which is a matter of some difficulty even in the case of national statistics, cannot, for a variety of reasons (differences of legislation, of systems of social insurance, etc.) yield results that are altogether satisfactory or comparable from the international point of view. But, as difficulties of classification arise only in the case of a relatively limited proportion of the individuals concerned and as the informative value of the distinction is considerable, the Committee reached the conclusion that such an optional distinction should be recommended. [_66~\ The proposed classification by personal status, which corresponds in the first instance with the status of persons occupied in agriculture, mining and manufacturing industries, transport and commerce, should be applied to all branches of economic activity in order to permit of the preparation of aggregate figures for the various groups. Although such aggregates, without subdivisions by branches of economic activity, have not very much significance for groups 1, 2 and 4 (a), aggregates for groups 3 and 4 (6) appear to possess real significance. 64 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS E. CLASSIFICATION BY INDIVIDUAL OCCUPATIONS [67] [The Committee did not believe it practical or desirable to prepare a detailed draft nomenclature of occupations for purposes of international comparison, while realising the value and importance of such a classification in national statistics of the gainfully-occupied population. For national purposes, the best solution, in the Committee's opinion, is a classification giving an enumeration of the important occupations within each branch of economic activity, supplemented by a restricted list of occupations that are common to a number of different industries: aggregate figures for all industries together can then be compiled for the more important occupations.] F. CLASSIFICATION BY S E X , A G E AND MARITAL STATUS [68] The Committee recommends that, for each chapter of the classification by branches of economic activity, and for each group of the classification by personal status, the gainfully-occupied population should be subdivided first of all by sex. The data for each sex should then be subdivided according to age and marital status. [69] The grouping by age should include the following groups: (a) Under 15 years of age; (ò) 15-19 years of age; (c) 20-64 years of age, divided, if possible, into two sub-groups: 20-44 years of age (preferably subdivided into five-year or ten-year divisions); 45-64 years of age; (d) 65 years of age and over. [70] The Committee is of the opinion that, for the purpose of international comparisons, it is essential to have total figures for the two groups (a) and (d) but that details as to branches of economic activity and personal status, which are of great importance for groups (6) and (c) have less importance for groups (a) and (d). [71] If a complete grouping by marital status (unmarried, married, divorced, widowed) cannot be achieved, at least the married group should be shown separately. [72] Group B, 1, of the non-gainfully-occupied population— i.e. members of families of working age, capable of work and not attending school—should, in like manner, be subdivided according to sex and age. CLASSIFICATION OP INDUSTRIES AND OCCUPATIONS 65 6. Minimum Nomenclature of Industries recommended by the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations 1 [73] MINIMUM NOMENCLATURE OP INDUSTRIES Section A.—Agriculture, I. II. III. IV. V. Forestry and Fishing Agriculture and stock-breeding. Forestry, hunting and trapping. Fishing. Section B.—Mining and Quarrying Mining and quarrying of coal, ores and other minerals, n.e.s. Quarrying of stone and other materials used principally for construction. Section C.—Manufacturing VI. VII. VIII. IX. X. XI. XII. XIII. XIV. XV. XVI. XVII. XVIII. XIX. XX. XXI. XXII. XXIII. Industries Manufacture of food. Beverage industries, distilleries. Tobacco industries. Manufacture of animal and vegetable oils and fats, including margarine. Chemical industries, n.e.s. Manufacture of rubber. Manufacture of wood and cork. Pulp and paper mills; manufacture of paper articles. Printing and bookbinding; photography. Skin, hide and leather industries. Textile industries. Manufacture of wearing apparel and of made-up textile goods, n.e.s. Production and supply of electricity, gas and heat; water supply. Manufacture of mineral fuels. Manufacture of non-metallic minerals, n.e.s. Smelting, casting, rolling, forging and drawing of base metals. Manufacture of articles of base metals, n.e.s. Manufacture of machinery, including all electrical appliances and means of transport by land, water and air. 1 LEAGUE OP NATIONS: op. cit. (see above, p. 52), pp. 21-22. A detailed list with illustrative examples is also given, pp. 22-32. 66 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS XXIV. XXV. XXVI. Manufacture of instruments, clocks and watches, and jewellery. Other manufacturing industries, n.e.s. Manufacturing industries not adequately described. Section D.—Building XXVII. Building and other constructional work, including repair and maintenance of structures, n.e.s. Section E.—Transport XXVIII. XXIX. XXX. XXXI. XXXII. and Other Construction and Communications Rail transport. Road transport. Water transport. Air transport. Post, telegraph and telephones. Section F.—Commerce XXXIII. XXXIV. XXXV. Wholesale and retail trade. Finance, banks, insurance. Agencies for other purposes, n.e.s. Section G.—Hotel and Personal Services XXXVI. XXXVII. Provision of lodging, food and drink. Undertakings for cleaning and maintenance of goods and premises, care of the person. X X X V I I I . Household and personal services. X X X I X . Recreation and amusement, sport. Section H.—Public Services and Other Services of General Interest, N.E.S. XL. XLI. XLII. XLIII. XLIV. Medical and hygienic services. Education, religion, arts and sciences, n.e.s. National defence. Labour camps and similar organisations. Public services, n.e.s., and other services of general interest. Section J.—Activities not Adequately Described XLV. Activities not adequately described. 1 1 The Report also gives details of the different industries and items to be included in each group of industries. It gives also, in many cases, reasons on the basis of which the Committee based its recommendations. The members of the Committee are given on page 5. II STATISTICS OF EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT 7. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, April 1925 UNEMPLOYMENT STATISTICS {74} (1) In countries in which a widespread system of unemployment insurance exists the information obtained from the working of such a system forms the best basis for unemployment statistics. {75} (2) These statistics should furnish the following information as a minimum : (a) Annually, the total number of workpeople insured against unemployment, which should be related so far as practicable to the total number of workers. (6) Monthly, the total number of unemployed on a given day in receipt of benefit, and the total number of insured workers unemployed (whether on benefit or not) on the same day. (c) Monthly, the percentage that on a given day the total number of insured unemployed (whether on benefit or not) forms of the estimated number of insured workpeople. (d) Annually, the total amount paid during the year in benefits. {76} A method according to which, as in the Netherlands, a percentage is calculated between the number of days of unemployment during one week and the total number of days of work which might have been performed is one which is worthy of attention. {77} (3) Where statistics based on unemployment insurance, compulsory or voluntary, are not available, it is desirable to obtain from workers' organisations the following information: (a) Monthly, the total number of unemployed on a given day and the percentage they form of the total membership covered by the enquiry. (6) Annually, the number of workers covered by the enquiry as a percentage of the total number of workers in the corresponding industries or occupations. 68 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Even when statistics based on unemployment insurance become available it is desirable, for purposes of comparison, to continue trade union statistics as long as they are reliable. {78] (4) The statistics derived from public employment offices should give: (a) The number of workpeople registered on a given day of the month as seeking work, with the total number of vacancies remaining unfilled on the same day. (è) The number of workers' applications registered, of vacancies notified, and of vacancies filled, during the month. {79] (5) Employment exchange statistics should be compiled so that as far as possible unskilled workers are distinguished from other classes of workers. {80] (6) Information as to the state of employment should also be published periodically, if possible monthly, based on returns made by a representative number of employers. {81] (7) In countries in which satisfactory information concerning unemployment cannot be obtained by the means indicated above, it is desirable that an attempt should be made to obtain at the general population census, or at an industrial or occupational census, information as to the amount of unemployment, or that special enquiries relating to the whole population or to an adequate sample thereof should be made from time to time with a view to ascertaining the number and condition of the unemployed. {82] (8) The statistics indicated in the preceding resolutions should distinguish males and females and should, so far as possible, give figures for separate occupations in the case of statistics arising out of the activities of employment exchanges, and for separate occupations or industries as may be most convenient in the case of trade union and insurance statistics and in the case of special industrial or occupational enquiries. The classifications used should be based on the classifications adopted in the general population census in so far as these are applicable to employment exchange operations. {83] (9) It is desirable, for comparing statistics of unemployment internationally: (a) That precise and detailed information should be published and kept up to date as to methods adopted in compiling the various statistics of unemployment; in particular, each country should indicate any legislative or administrative changes affecting the value of its unemployment statistics; STATISTICS OP EMPLOYMENT AND UNEMPLOYMENT 69 (£>) That copies of all forms and questionnaires used in collecting the various statistics should be forwarded to the International Labour Office; (c) That in each country an enquiry should be made to determine, as exactly as possible, the representative value of the unemployment statistics in relation to the "ideal statistics" which would give, at any date, the total number of unemployed in relation to the total number of workers. For this purpose it is agreed: (t) that the ideal population "field" to which the statistics should relate should be all persons whose normal means of livelihood is employment under contract of service as well as those persons not hitherto wage earners who seek to become so; (it) that the unemployment measured should exclude that due to sickness, invalidity, participation in trade disputes or voluntary absence from work, and should be limited to unemployment due to lack of employment or to lack of work while in employment; (Hi) that the necessary and sufficing condition for being enumerated as unemployed is that the individual must have been not at work for one day at least. [_84~\ (10) It is desirable that the different statistics of unemployment (insurance, trade union, and employment exchanges) should be presented together, preferably in graphic form, so that they might be co-ordinated and checked one with another and as clear and correct an idea as possible of the fluctuations in unemployment obtained. [_85~] (11) Statistics of short-time employment should, if possible, be given separately from those of whole-time unemployment IK STATISTICS OF WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK* 8. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1923 [86] Detailed statistics of rates of wages, of actual earnings, and of normal and actual hours of labour should be collected and published in each country as frequently as possible, account being taken of the special circumstances and conditions obtaining in each case. With a view to facilitating international comparisons, the responsible authorities in each country should, as far as practicable, observe the following principles: [87] (1) At regular intervals, and a t least once a year, there should be published: (a) Statutory minimum rates'; (ò) Rates fixed in collective agreements; (c) Rates accepted by organisations of employers and workpeople for typical categories of workers. [_88^ (2) In order to provide an indication of the general course of wage movements, information should be published at more frequent intervals as to the nature and amount of any changes resulting from alterations in the statutory minimum rates or arranged between organisations of employers and workpeople. Particulars should be given of changes in the normal hours of labour and of alterations in the level of piece work rates. [89] (3) At regular intervals, not less than once a year, average actual earnings and actual hours of labour during a year or a typical period in a year should be given for each of the principal industries, and based on data supplied by representative employers or establishments. [90] (4) From the data indicated above, index numbers should be computed to show the general course of changes in nominal wage rates and in actual earnings. Index numbers of the purchasing power of the wages should also be calculated by relating changes in actual earnings to changes in the cost of living, the necessary precautions being taken to ensure that the two series of data are comparable. 1 See also V. International Comparison of Real Wages. STATISTICS OP WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 71 The nominal wages employed in computing the index numbers should be given in every case. [9f\ (5) At less frequent intervals general wage censuses should be taken, information being obtained from the pay sheets of establishments to show rates of wages and the actual earnings in a typical week. The information should be given by industries, districts, occupations, and sex, and a distinction should be made between adults and young persons. [92} Until the principles enunciated above have been applied in the different countries, statistics of wages and hours of labour should at least give: (a) Current rates of wages (hourly or weekly) and normal hours of work of typical categories of time workers; and at regular intervals averages weighted according to the number of workers to whom the data apply both for such categories and for all categories combined; (b) Actual and full-time earnings and hours of labour for typical categories of workers, especially those paid on piece work; such statistics should be available for sample periods, at least once a year; (c) Real wage index numbers based on nominal wage and cost-of-living index numbers. [93] In order that the International Labour Office may make tentative comparisons of the level of real wages in the different countries, the competent statistical authorities of each country should furnish the International Labour Office at regular intervals (if possible monthly) with statements, in a form to be agreed upon, showing for the capital cities of their respective countries: (i) the time-rates of wages and normal weekly hours of labour current in a limited number of typical occupations; and (M) information as to the prices of a limited number of those items upon which the income of working-class families in most industrially developed countries is largely spent. 9. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Statisticians convoked by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America, January 1929 INDEX NUMBERS OF W A G E S [94] The Committee is fully aware that in the majority of countries the available data are too limited for all the requisite conditions for the compilation of satisfactory index numbers of 72 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS wages to be fulfilled. However, it considered it desirable in the circumstances to discuss the conditions to be observed in order that index numbers of wages should, as far as possible, be adapted to the purposes for which they may be used. It seemed to the Committee that such an examination was useful not merely from the point of view of statistical theory, but also from the practical point of view, because many countries are at present passing.through a period in which wage statistics are being reorganised on fresh bases, and it may be very useful for these countries to have certain guiding principles for the collection and tabulation of their figures. Moreover, even if it appears that the programme outlined is incapable of realisation at the moment, it will, nevertheless, have a certain practical utility because it will make clear the extent of the reservations to be made when interpreting necessarily incomplete series of wage index numbers, whether existing or to be drawn up in the future. [95~\ The Committee unanimously recognised that the compilation of index numbers of wages must proceed along perceptibly different lines as regards both the data to be taken into account and the methods of collection and tabulation, according to the purpose for which the index numbers are to be used. \_96~] It would consequently serve no useful purpose to attempt to establish an index number for wages for all purposes; on the contrary, it is necessary to consider separately the establishment of different indices corresponding to different purposes. [_97~] There are three obvious and very distinct purposes for which index numbers of wages may be required: (1) to determine one of the elements for measuring fluctuations in the standard of living; (2) to calculate the remuneration per hour of work; (3) to calculate the labour cost per unit of production. [98] Within each of these purposes, the object may be to determine the fluctuations in wages in time, or to make comparisons between different districts or different countries. In accordance with the task entrusted to it, the Committee, generally speaking, considered chiefly the first of these points of view, that is to say, the variations in wages in time within a country. [99] At the same time, international comparisons of the remuneration per hour of work seemed so much more valuable than comparisons in time in a single country, that the Committee felt impelled to examine certain specially difficult points raised by this question. STATISTICS OP WAGES AND HOURS OP WORK 73 [1002 For each of the purposes mentioned above, a distinction must be made according to whether the index is considered as applying to the working class as a whole, or as an indication of the variations occurring in different industries or classes of workers, independently of the influence which the relative importance of these different industries or classes of workers may have on the general wage averages. For example, if index numbers of wages are considered as one of the factors to be taken into account in estimating the standard of living of the workers, then the aim may be to measure separately the variations in the standard of living of skilled, semi-skilled, or unskilled workers; or the variations occurring among the workers as a whole, which may arise to a considerable extent from the fact that skilled workers may be at present much more numerous than formerly. The Committee therefore considered it desirable to keep in mind these two points of view. A similar distinction may be made, and was in fact taken into account by the Committee, in considering the labour cost per unit of production. [.1012 In the same way a calculation of the remuneration per hour of labour may be concerned with the remuneration for any hour, or for an hour of the same nature (normal or supplementary work, skilled, semi-skilled, or unskilled work) and of the same efficiency in regard to either individual qualifications or technical equipment. The Committee, in view of the limited time at its disposal, restricted its examination to the latter point of view. [1022 In addition to the three main purposes analysed above, there are two others for which index numbers of wages have been employed. There is, first, that of measuring the variations in the total amount of wages as a percentage of the national income, and secondly, that of using them as one of the factors in economic forecasting. The Committee was of opinion that this latter purpose was particularly important, and therefore gave it special attention. [1032 It must be understood that when the Committee states that index numbers of wages may be used for measuring the standard of living or the remuneration for an hour of work, or again as a factor in economic forecasting, it does not thereby imply that they represent the only factor to be taken into account for the purpose in view. It is obvious that the index numbers of wages can only be one factor, and that other measurements must also be taken into consideration. In particular, the index number of the cost of living must be considered when estimating the standard of living or the real remuneration for an hour of work, and, similarly, the level of prices when the index numbers of wages are to be used 74 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS in calculating the labour cost per unit of production. In the same order of ideas the Committee unanimously decided (as the second Conference of Labour Statisticians had done) that the data concerning actual earnings should be taken for preference, save in exceptional cases, in examining the question of the standard of living. £.104] The Committee was unanimously of the opinion that in determining the standard of living no attempt should be made to allow for the subjective cost of labour, which it is quite impossible to measure; on the contrary, the term "standard of living" should retain the connotation which it generally has in economic science, namely, that of material well-being. In order to avoid any misunderstanding the Committee would even have adopted the suggestion of using the term "purchasing power" instead of "standard of living", if it had not been that it considered it more practical to retain the commoner expression which is more familiar to the majority of workers, rather than employ a technical term whose exact significance is probably fully grasped only by specialists. £105] The Committee did not claim to deal with all the important points, but was content to consider for each type of index : (1) the wages data (rate of wages, average wages, or actual earnings) to be taken into account in each case; (2) the industries or classes of workers to which these data should refer; (3) the areas from which returns should be collected; (4) the period during which the data should be gathered ; (5) the method of arriving at the index numbers, that is, the weighting of the various classes or industries, the choice of the basic period, etc. £106"] Generally speaking, the Committee wishes to emphasise the importance, whenever a series of index numbers of wages is published, of giving a detailed explanation of the principles adopted with reference to each of the five points enumerated above, and of all the other factors which may be essential for a true interpretation of the index numbers. Q/073 Finally, while the Committee, in accordance with the task entrusted to it, considered in particular the fluctuations of wages within single countries, it also frequently emphasised the fact that comparisons between different districts and different countries were no less important, and might even be of greater value. STATISTICS OF WAGES AND HOURS OP WORK 75 I.—Construction of Indices to Measure Changes in the Standard of Living of the Working Class as a Whole (1) Choice of Type of Wage Data. Hl08~} If the standard of living is used in its generally accepted sense of material well-being, it is evident that for the purpose of constructing wage index numbers to measure changes in the standard of living of the working class as a whole, the ideal type of data to be used should be actual annual earnings, or earnings for a shorter period representative of annual earnings. [iOP] Experience in certain countries shows that in fact changes in actual earnings may differ from changes in rates of wages and in average wages per hour. But this does not exclude the fact that in other countries changes in rates of wages may be considered as approximately representative of changes in actual earnings in certain industries and under certain conditions. [_110~\ While recognising that, in normal conditions, the standard of living may be considered proportional to actual earnings, it must be recognised that changes in hours worked and other social conditions equally affect the standard of living, and the accuracy of an index number based on actual earnings. In these cases, it would be desirable to take hours of labour into consideration. (2) Industries and Categories of Workers to be Included. \_llf\ For the construction of such index numbers it would be desirable to consider changes in the wages of the wage-earning class as a whole; but as in practice this would be rarely possible, it is necessary to select certain industries and categories of workers which would be representative of the wage-earning class. In this case it will be necessary to indicate clearly the industries and categories of workers covered by the statistics. [112} If it is desired to measure the standard of living of the wage-earning class as a whole, it is indispensable to include agricultural workers, as well as workers in industry proper. But as in most countries statistics of the cost of living of agricultural workers are not available, it will be necessary, when one wishes to compare index numbers of wages with index numbers of the cost of living, to consider separately the workers in industry proper. (3) Choice of Districts. \_113} Where it would not be possible to cover the whole country, districts should be chosen so as to be representative of the 76 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS whole country. If adequate consideration is not given to this very important point, there is the danger that wage index numbers will be compiled which are not representative of the actual situation, either from the point of view of the levels of wages of the wage-earning class, or from the point of view of their changes. (4) Frequency of Compilation. {114] From the point of view of the practical use of these statistics, it would appear reasonable that the frequency of compilation should be determined in relation to the stability of economic conditions, compilation being less frequent when these conditions are more stable. l_115~\ From the point of view of facility in collecting the statistics and for the purpose of ensuring their accuracy, there may be certain reasons, as is shown by the experience of a number of countries, for the compilation of the statistics at frequent intervals, even when economic conditions are stable. \_116~\ In any case, it is opportune to determine frequency of compilation in relation to the systems of wage payment in use in the different countries, selecting periods for which the wage payments may be considered complete. Generally a period of one month (or four weeks) would appear to be the most suitable, and to be satisfactory in relation to other general uses of the wage index numbers. Where the supply of information depends on the good will of the employers, it is necessary to take care that the statistics for successive periods relate to the same establishments. If this condition cannot be realised, it would become necessary to obtain also statistics for the preceding period in order to enable the figures for successive periods to be connected by the chain method. [117~\ When a system of payment includes supplementary items of remuneration that cover more than one period of normal payment, it is necessary to allocate such items proportionately among the normal periods that they cover or to average them over the whole period intervening between one such supplementary payment and the next. (5) Method of Compilation. [_118} As to the method used in establishing these index numbers, the most precise consists in relating the total actual earnings compiled or calculated for a given period to the corresponding actual earnings for the period taken as base. These averages may be compiled per worker, or better, per member of the family, if it is STATISTICS OP WAGES AND HOURS OP WORK 77 possible to include the earnings of other members of the family.1 The last consideration, which may be important in international comparisons, does not, however, have any appreciable effect on time comparisons in a country. \_119] The calculation of a simple or a weighted average index number for the various industries and occupations, the weights remaining constant during the various periods, may lead in certain circumstances to false conclusions, for they do not take into account the movement of workers from one industry to another and from one occupation to another. These movements may in certain cases be of great importance. In consequence, it may be necessary to use separate indices for the different industries, and in combining them to revise the weighting as often as possible so as to take account of these changes. For such a series of index numbers, the choice of base period does not influence the index number. [_120~\ It would be desirable, however, that all countries should adopt a common base period and for various reasons a post-war period is favoured. This does not exclude, naturally, the possibility for certain countries of constructing a series with pre-war bases. The fact that in various countries statistics of wages are in their infancy or in course of being organised, and also the fact that in various countries economic conditions are not yet stable enough, hinders the fixing at present of the most appropriate base period common to all countries. In a general way it would be preferable not to choose the first period for which the enquiries are made, as in general the first enquiries are not the most exact. II.—Construction of Index Numbers of Wages for Measuring, in each Country, the Changes in the Fluctuation in the Standard of Living in Different Industries or Occupations \_12f\ It is of interest for certain purposes to measure fluctuations in the standard of living, not of the workers as a whole, but in different industries or occupations, without taking into account fluctuations in the standard of living of the workers as a whole, which may arise from variations in the numerical importance of different industries or occupations. In this case, the same methods are to be recommended as to the choice of wage data, of localities, and of periods. 1 These averages will usually be compiled per earner, b u t when it is possible to obtain the information they may also be compiled per family. In this case the average size of the family should be given, expressed, if possible, in terms of "adult men". 78 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS III.—Calculation of Index Numbers of Wages as an Aid in Forecasting Economic Conditions (1) Choice of Data. \_122~] In countries which do not possess well-organised statistics of unemployment, overtime, and short time, or in countries where the wage rates are fixed for a determined and fairly lengthy period, the statistics of earnings have advantages for following economic fluctuations. In countries for which the statistics of unemployment, etc., are well organised, and where rates of wages can be changed according to economic conditions, it may be useful to consider rates of wages also as an index for economic forecasting, as, at the beginning of a crisis, these rates may vary according to the orders received by establishments, and consequently may constitute a more sensitive index than that of actual earnings. (2) Industries and Categories of Workers. Q/2J] In every country it is necessary to take into consideration the industries and categories of workers whose variations in wage rates or actual earnings are the most sensitive ; the work of choosing the industries and categories the most appropriate for these studies must be left to the specialists of each country. Certain industries even of less economic importance, like the luxury trades and printing, may give interesting information in this field, whilst industries which receive orders long periods in advance, and may in certain cases be the most important ones from the economic point of view, may be less suitable for forecasting. ^_124\ In each branch of industry the best organised establishments which can estimate with the greatest certitude the future development of the market should primarily be considered. (3) Choice of Localities. \_125~^ In order to establish economic forecasts, it is advisable to take into special consideration certain centres or localities which, either because of the concentration of industry, or because of some special development, or for other reasons, are, as experience has shown, the first to show symptoms of crisis or of economic revival. (4) Frequency. \J26~\ The interval chosen should be as short as possible. (5) Method of Compilation. \_127~\ It would be advisable, even if it were desired to reduce the various information into one index, to publish separately the STATISTICS OP WAGES AND HOURS OP WORK 79 information for the various industries, occupations, and localities, so that all necessary information would be available for the interpretation of these indices. IV.—Compilation of Index Numbers of Wages to Measure Earnings per Hour in respect of Work of Comparable Character and Efficiency (1) Choice of Data. [128} It may be assumed that the best method theoretically would be to determine separately the average wages per hour of normal work and the average wages per hour of overtime, and then to eliminate the influence of varying amounts of overtime by combining these two averages in a constant ratio. [129} As in many countries it is not possible in practice to distinguish between normal and overtime earnings, the most practical method is to calculate a single average by dividing the aggregate amount of actual earnings — for normal and overtime work, including special allowances, payments in kind, etc.—by the total number of hours worked. The objection to this method of calculation is that changes in the payment per hour worked may result from a mere change in the proportion of overtime worked to normal hours; this objection being the more important, the more significant the changes in this proportion. (2) Industries and Categories of Workers. \_130~] The comparison aimed at is one between certain categories of workers belonging to selected occupations who work with approximately similar equipment and under similar conditions in different countries or in different periods. It must be recognised, however, that the individual workers who perform the same occupations in different countries and in various periods may diverge in varying degrees from the average worker in respect to individual skill and efficiency. This objection will be the more important in practice, the more restricted the number of occupations and the number of workers considered. [131] Even if the comparisons between different countries may on this account be open to doubt, it may well be that the variations in time shown by these index numbers may be comparable. (3) Localities. [132'] It may be assumed that the localities should be representative of the conditions of the whole country. Consequently it may 80 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS not be sufficient to limit the statistics to capital or principal cities, because the differences, in this respect, between these and the rest of the country may be more or less great according to the country or the period considered. (4) Frequency. \il33^\ If it were possible to determine separately the average wages per normal hour and per hour of overtime, it would be desirable to secure data as frequently as possible. Since in general such data are not available, it will be necessary to take rather long intervals so that the different circumstances influencing the amount of overtime work might arrange themselves out. (5) Method of Calculation. H134] It goes without saying that the different occupations chosen for international comparisons will comprise different numbers of workers in different countries, and that these differences will not be similar in all countries and will even present considerable variations from country to country. \^135~J¡ Since the index numbers are to be used to measure the changes in the earnings per hour of work of a given nature and given efficiency, it will be necessary to calculate as many special index numbers as there are from this point of view different categories, and then to compute an average of these index numbers. \_136~} It is evident that the index numbers calculated for different categories of workers should be weighted according to the number of workers in each category. A practical difficulty in comparing the index numbers in different countries arises from the fact that the numbers of workers of each category would vary from country to country, and that there is no reason for taking as basis the number of workers in one country rather than that in another country. In order to avoid this difficulty, it might be advisable to repeat the calculation as many times as there are countries, using in turn the weight corresponding to the conditions prevailing in each country. \_137~} The results of the calculation will show whether the application of the different methods of weighting will produce significant deviations. V.—Compilation of Index Numbers of Wages for the Purpose of Measuring the Labour Cost per Unit of Production \^1382 If the unit of production is taken in the sense of a unit of value, the determination of labour cost per unit of production consists in calculating the percentage of the total value of produc- STATISTICS OF WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 81 tion represented by the aggregate wages paid. It is evident that even if in some countries and in certain branches of productive activity firms already furnish data of this kind, it is not possible to expect at present an extension of these enquiries over all branches of economic activity and all countries. In this respect the Committee, while hoping that this will be possible in respect to an increasing part of production and increasing number of countries, considers that the collection of data on wages, cost of labour, and cost of production should be organised as far as possible so as not to give rise to fears or opposition on the part of the firms concerned. Even if this opposition to supplying such detailed information is sometimes due rather to habits or traditional ideas which are no longer justifiable, it is necessary in any case to take account of them because the sincere collaboration of the heads of firms constitutes an exceedingly useful element in ensuring the accuracy of the data. \_139~\ In any case the possibility may be considered of measuring the variations, between different periods or different localities, in the labour cost as an element in the total cost of production. There are, in fact, several countries which conduct censuses of the value of production for the whole country or for industry as a whole, or for industrial production, or for manufacturing, or for large industries, or even for agricultural production. For these countries it would be possible to establish index numbers showing the variations in the value of the production as between different periods. If it should be possible to establish, in addition to this series of index numbers, another series of index numbers relating to aggregate wages paid to the workers covered, it would be possible to state whether the value of production has increased more or less rapidly than the aggregate wages bill, and consequently whether the percentage of wages in the total cost of production has increased or decreased during this period. [_14Cß Similarly, it is possible to proceed to comparisons between different countries, provided that the data concerning the production of these countries are comparable between themselves; it is, however, difficult to satisfy this condition. \^14f\ It is evident that this method may be applied either to production as a whole or to certain special branches of production, or further to a particular industry. It is obvious that care should be taken in interpreting the variations in the percentages showing changes between different periods as well as between different countries, because these variations or differences may be due to extremely different circumstances, such as differences in machinery and equipment, in natural conditions, in the efficiency of labour, etc. 82 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS [_142~] In compiling these index numbers, it is convenient to proceed as follows: \_143~] (1) To take as bases the actual earnings—that is to say, the aggregate and not the average earnings. [_144~\ (2) and (3) If it is not possible to take into account all localities and industries concerned, to choose representative localities and industries. [145~\ (4) To obtain records of wages for the same periods as for the censuses or evaluations of production, which can only be effected at rather long intervals. [,1462 (5) To adopt for the index numbers of wages the same base as for the index numbers of production, and to follow in respect of weighting the principles specified under I and II, according as it is proposed to make, or not to make, allowance for the effects of differences i a the importance of the production of different industries. VI.—Compilation of Index Numbers of Wages for Measuring the Variations in the Proportion of the National Income Formed by Wages [_147~] The percentage of the value of production represented by the aggregate wages of labour may have a very different significance according as it applies to primary production (extractive industries, forestry or agriculture) in which the consumption of the products of other industries is of small importance, or to manufacturing industries in which an important part of the value of the product is due to raw materials or semi-manufactured products. This inconvenience might be avoided if the total wages are related not to the total value of production but to the value of the net product of industry. [_148~\ The relation between the aggregate earnings of labour as a whole and the national income is of particular interest from theoretical and practical points of view. \_149\ As regards the choice of data concerning wages, industries, localities, the frequency of collection, and the methods of calculating the index numbers, the principles indicated under V may in general be applied. \JL50\ However, it is to be observed that the comparisons between different countries may be in practice more frequent and less difficult in this case. In fact, many countries in which comparable data concerning the value of production are not available calculate approximately the amount of national income. \_15f] Per contra, the comparisons as between different periods would probably be less frequent in the present case because the STATISTICS OP WAGES AND HOURS OP WORK 83 variations in the income can be evaluated with sufficient accuracy only at fairly long intervals. 10. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Statisticians convoked by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America, May 1930 INDEX NUMBERS OF W A G E S \_152~] 1. The construction of index numbers to measure the movement of wages, although designed primarily for use within a country, is of importance also for the international comparison of wages. Any divergence between the movement in two countries is the reflection of a significant change, and may be a cause of further change in the economic relations of the two countries. It is important, therefore, that indices of wage movements in different countries should be made available for purposes of comparison, and the Committee welcomes the initiative of the International Labour Office since the last Conference in publishing together all the available indices of wage movements. {_153} 2. The Committee are of opinion that the indices published should take three forms. {_154} (a) It is desirable, whether a single numerical index is compiled or not, that as much as is practicable of the detailed information on which such numerical indices may be based should be published. The problems in the elucidation of which wage statistics are required are so numerous and varied that it is not possible to meet all the needs that may arise. It is, therefore, important that such material as exists should be made available for the use of students, and not merely numerical indices based on this material. Full publication of details is necessary also to prevent misunderstanding and misuse of indices. [_155~] (6) A general index, inclusive of as much of the available material for each country as can be obtained regularly, should be constructed, where the material is adequate. The publication of such an index, however, would be dangerous unless accompanied by an indication of the movement of wages in the chief component industrial groups. Such more detailed indices should, where possible, give separately the movement of wages of skilled or unskilled and male and female workers. \_156~] (c) A special index for each country embodying the movement of wages in certain selected industries for the special purpose of international comparison. This index might be modelled on the index set forth in the American report 1 , combining the 1 Report submitted to the Conference. 84 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS indices for general manufacturing, railways, building and coal mining. Representative rates for these groups can probably be found among the wage statistics of most countries1 ; but whatever combination is included, it should be restricted to industries in which wages are determined by purely industrial conditions, industries in which wages are influenced by political considerations being excluded. [.757] 3. The Committee would call attention to certain desiderata in the presentation of statistics. Where possible actual figures of wage rates or of averages of wage rates should be given, as well as the index or indices of change in wage rates, since it is possible for actual wage rates to remain unchanged, while the index number in which they are combined changes on account of some alteration in the proportion of different classes of workers, or the rise to importance of some hitherto unimportant industry. [ i 5 # ] Tables should be accompanied by notes warning the reader of the limits within which and purposes for which the figures may be used. References to the official publications of the different countries from which the figures are taken or the indices compiled should always be given. [\í5P] The Committee wishes to stress the Recommendation of the 1929 Conference that statistics of both rates of wages and earnings should be compiled. Pending collection of such comprehensive statistics, they recommend that rates and earnings should be given wherever they are available; that it should be made clear whether the figure given represents wages or earnings where only one is available'; and that where rates only are embodied in the index, the relation between earnings and rates, in the years for which figures of earnings are available, should be given. They suggest also that it may be advisable to omit from any index based exclusively upon rates, occupations in which it is known that the divergence between earnings and rates is considerable. [160] Where possible the data on wages should be compiled and published monthly, as is already done in certain countries. This is necessary to make possible the study of seasonal fluctuations. [J6Í] Both hourly and weekly rates and earnings should be given when possible. [_162~\ In any industry or occupation in which a large proportion of women is employed, it is desirable that a separate index number of women's wages should be compiled. Where only a small proportion of women are employed, this would be impracticable; but in this case it should be stated whether the women's rates are included or excluded from the index for the industry or occupation STATISTICS OP WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 85 which is given. Statistical authorities should print full and repeated explanations of the principles on which, and the methods by which, any indices which they publish are constructed. 11. Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work adopted by the International Labour Conference at its 24th Session, June 1938 Draft Convention [No. 63] concerning statistics of wages and hours of work in the principal mining and manufacturing industries, including building and construction, and in agriculture. [/tfj] The General Conference of the International Labour Organisation, Having been convened at Geneva by the Governing Body of the International Labour Office, and having met in its Twenty-fourth Session on 2 June 1938, and Having decided upon the adoption of certain proposals with regard to statistics of wages and hours of work in the principal mining and manufacturing industries including building and construction, and in agriculture, which is the sixth item on the agenda of the Session, and Having determined that these proposals shall take the form of a Draft International Convention, and Having determined that, although it is desirable that all Members of the Organisation should compile statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked which comply with the requirements of Part II of this Convention, it is nevertheless expedient that the Convention should be open to ratification by Members which are not in a position to comply with the requirements of that Part, adopts, this twentieth day of June of the year one thousand nine hundred and thirty-eight the following Draft Convention which may be cited as the Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work, 1938: PART I.—GENERAL PROVISIONS. Article 1. \_164~] Each Member of the International Labour Organisation which ratifies this Convention undertakes that: (a) it will compile as required by this Convention statistics relating to wages and hours of work; 86 INTERNATIONA!, STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS (6) it will publish the data compiled in pursuance of this Convention as promptly as possible and will endeavour to publish data collected at quarterly or more frequent intervals during the succeeding quarter and to publish data collected at intervals of six or twelve months during the succeeding six or twelve months respectively; and (c) it will communicate the data compiled in pursuance of this Convention to the International Labour Office at the earliest possible date. Article 2. \_165~\ 1. Any Member which ratifies this Convention may, by a declaration appended to its ratification, exclude from its acceptance of the Convention : (a) (6) (c) any one of Parts II, III, or IV; or Parts II and IV; or Parts III and IV. 2. Any Member which has made such a declaration may at any time cancel that declaration by a subsequent declaration. 3. Every Member for which a declaration made under paragraph 1 of this Article is in force shall indicate each year in its annual report upon the application of this Convention the extent to which any progress has been made with a view to the application of the Part or Parts of the Convention excluded from its acceptance. Article 3. [.166"] Nothing in this Convention imposes any obligation to publish or to reveal particulars which would result in the disclosure of information relating to any individual undertaking or establishment. Article 4. \_167~\ 1. Each Member which ratifies this Convention undertakes that its competent statistical authority shall, unless it has already obtained the information in some other way, make enquiries relating either to all, or to a representative part, of the wage earners concerned, in order to obtain the information required for the purpose of the statistics which it has undertaken to compile in accordance with this Convention. 2. Nothing in this Convention shall be interpreted as requiring STATISTICS OF WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 87 any Member to compile statistics in cases in which, after enquiries made in the manner required by paragraph 1 of this Article, it is found impracticable to obtain the necessary information without the exercise of compulsory powers. PART II.'—STATISTICS OF AVERAGE EARNINGS AND OF HOURS ACTUALLY WORKED IN MINING AND MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES. Article 5. \_168^\ 1. Statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked shall be compiled for wage earners employed in each of the principal mining and manufacturing industries includirig building and construction. \_169] 2. The statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked shall be compiled on the basis of data relating either to all establishments and wage earners or to a representative sample of establishments and wage earners. [_170] 3. The statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked shall: (a) give separate figures for each of the principal industries; and (ò) indicate briefly the scope of the industries or branches of industry for which figures are given. Article 6. \171~\ The statistics of average earnings shall include: (a) all cash payments and bonuses received from the employer by the persons employed ; (6) contributions such as social insurance contributions payable by the employed persons and deducted by the employer ; and (c) taxes payable by the employed persons to a public authority and deducted by the employer. Article 7. \_172~] In the case of countries and industries in which allowances in kind, for example in the form of free or cheap housing, food or fuel, form a substantial part of the total remuneration of the wage earners employed, the statistics of average earnings shall be supplemented by particulars of such allowances, together with estimates, so far as practicable, of their money value. 88 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Article 8. [_173] The statistics of average earnings shall be supplemented, so far as practicable, by indications as to the average amount of any family allowances per person employed in the period to which the statistics relate. Article 9. \_174\ 1. The statistics of average earnings shall relate to average earnings per hour, day, week or other customary period. [ i 7 5 ] 2. Where the statistics of average earnings relate to average earnings per day, week or other customary period, the statistics of actual hours shall relate to the same period. Article 10. \il76~] 1. The statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked, referred to in Article 9, shall be compiled once every year and where possible at shorter intervals. [_177~\ 2. Once every three years and where possible at shorter intervals the statistics of average earnings and, so far as practicable, the statistics of hours actually worked shall be supplemented by separate figures for each sex and for adults and juveniles; provided that it shall not be necessary to compile these separate figures in the case of industries in which all but .an insignificant number of the wage earners belong to the same sex or age group, or to compile the separate figures of hours actually worked for males and females, or for adults and juveniles, in the case of industries in which the normal hours of work do not vary by sex or age. Article 11. [_178] Where the statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked relate not to the whole country but to certain districts, towns or industrial centres, these districts, towns or centres shall, so far as practicable, be indicated. Article 12. \_179~\ 1. Index numbers showing the general movement of earnings per hour and where possible per day, week or other customary period shall be compiled at as frequent and as regular intervals as possible on the basis of the statistics compiled in pursuance of this Part of this Convention. STATISTICS OF WAGES AND HOURS OP WORK 89 [_180~] 2. In compiling such index numbers due account shall be taken, inter alia, of the relative importance of the different industries. [I81] 3. In publishing such index numbers indications shall be given as to the methods employed in their construction. PART III.—STATISTICS OF TIME RATES OP WAGES AND OF NORMAL HOURS OP WORK IN MINING AND MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES. Article 13. [_182] Statistics of time rates of wages and of normal hours of work of wage earners shall be compiled for a representative selection of the principal mining and manufacturing industries, including building and construction. Article 14. [1832 1- The statistics of time rates of wages and of normal hours of work shall show the rates and hours: (a) fixed by or in pursuance of laws or regulations, collective agreements or arbitral awards; (ò) ascertained from organisations of employers and workers, from joint bodies, or from other appropriate sources of information, in cases where rates and hours are not fixed by or in pursuance of laws or regulations, collective agreements or arbitral awards. [184] 2. The statistics of time rates of wages and of normal hours of work shall indicate the nature and source of the information from which they have been compiled and whether it relates to rates or hours fixed by or in pursuance of laws or regulations, collective agreements or arbitral awards, or to rates or hours fixed by arrangements between employers and wage earners individually. [185] 3. When rates of wages are described as minimum (other than statutory minimum) rates, standard rates, typical rates, or prevailing rates, or by similar terms, the terms used shall be explained. [1862 4. "Normal hours of work", where not fixed by or in pursuance of laws or regulations, collective agreements or arbitral awards, shall be taken as meaning the number of hours, per day, week or other period, in excess of which any time worked is remunerated at overtime rates or forms an exception to the rules or custom of the establishment relating to the classes of wage earners concerned. 90 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Article 15. \_187~\ 1. The statistics of time rates of wages and of normal hours of work shall give1: (a) at intervals of not more than three years, separate figures for the principal occupations in a wide and representative selection of the different industries; and (6) at least once a year, and if possible at shorter intervals, separate figures for the main occupations in the most important of these industries. £1882 2- The data relating to time rates of wages and of normal hours of work shall be presented, so far as practicable, on the basis of the same occupational classification. \_189~\ 3. Where the sources of information from which the statistics are compiled do not indicate the separate occupations to which the rates or hours apply, but fix varying rates of wages or hours of work for other categories of workers (such as skilled workers, semi-skilled workers and unskilled workers) or fix normal hours of work by classes of undertakings or branches of undertakings, the separate figures shall be given according to these distinctions. \_190"} 4. Where the categories of workers for which figures are given are not separate occupations, the scope of each category shall, in so far as the necessary particulars are given in the sources of information from which the statistics are compiled, be indicated. Article 16. {.19Q Where the statistics of time rates do not give the rates per hour but give rates per day, week, or other customary period: (a) the statistics of normal hours of work shall relate to the same period; and (6) the Member shall communicate to the International Labour Office any information appropriate for the purpose of calculating the rates per hour. Article 17. [.192"] Where the sources of information from which the statistics are compiled give separate particulars classified by sex and age, the statistics of time rates of wages and of normal hours of work shall give separate figures for each sex and for adults and juveniles. STATISTICS OP WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 91 Article 18. {193} Where the statistics of time rates of wages and of normal hours of work relate not to the whole country but to certain districts, towns or industrial centres, these districts, towns or centres shall, so far as practicable, be indicated. Article 19. {194} Where the sources of information from which the statistics of time rates and of normal hours of work are compiled contain such particulars, the statistics shall at intervals not exceeding three years indicate: (a) the scale of any payment for holidays; (b) the scale of any family allowances'; (c) the rates or percentage additions to normal rates paid for overtime; and (d) the amount of overtime permitted. Article 20. {.195} In the case of countries and industries in which allowances in kind, for example in the form of free and cheap housing, food or fuel, form a substantial part of the total remuneration of the wage earners employed, the statistics of time rates of wages shall be supplemented by particulars of such allowances, together with estimates, so far as practicable, of their money value. Article 21. {196} 1. Annual index numbers showing the general movement of rates of wages per hour or per week shall be compiled on the basis of the statistics compiled in pursuance of this Part of this Convention, supplemented, where necessary, by any other relevant information which may be available (for example, particulars as to changes in piece-work rates of wages). {197} 2. Where only an index number of rates of wages per hour or only an index number of rates of wages per week is compiled, there shall be compiled an index number of changes in normal hours of work constructed on the same basis. {198} 3. In compiling such index numbers due account shall be taken, inter alia, of the relative importance of the different industries. {199} 4. In publishing such index numbers indications shall be given as to the methods employed in their construction. 92 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS PART IV.—STATISTICS OP WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK IN AGRICULTURE. Article 22. {200} 1. Statistics of wages shall be compiled in respect of wage earners engaged in agriculture. [20f\ 2. The statistics of wages in agriculture shall: (a) (6) be compiled at intervals not exceeding two years; give separate figures for each of the principal districts ; and (c) indicate the nature of the allowances in kind (including housing), if any, by which money wages are supplemented, and, if possible, an estimate of the money value of such allowances. [2023 3. The statistics of wages in agriculture shall be supplemented by indications as to: (a) the categories of agricultural wage earners to which the statistics relate; (6) the nature and source of the information from which they have been compiled; (c) the methods employed in their compilation; and (d) so far as practicable, the normal hours of work of the wage earners concerned. PART V.—MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS. Article 23. [_203~] 1. Any Member the territory of which includes large areas in respect of which, by reason of the difficulty of creating the necessary administrative organisation and the sparseness of the population or the stage of economic development of the area, it is impracticable to compile statistics complying with the requirements of this Convention may exclude such areas from the application of this Convention in whole or in part. £204] 2. Each Member shall indicate in its first annual report upon the application of this Convention submitted under Article 22 of the Constitution of the International Labour Organisation any areas in respect of which it proposes to have recourse to the provisions of this Article and no Member shall, after the date of its first annual report, have recourse to the provisions of this Article except in respect of areas so indicated. \_205~] 3. Each Member having recourse to the provisions of STATISTICS OF WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 93 the present Article shall indicate in subsequent annual reports any areas in respect of which it renounces the right to have recourse to the provisions of this Article. Article 24. [206] 1. The Governing Body of the International Labour Office may, after taking such technical advice as it may deem appropriate, communicate to the Members of the Organisation proposals for improving and amplifying the statistics compiled in pursuance of this Convention or for promoting their comparability. [207"] 2. Each Member ratifying this Convention undertakes that it will: (a) submit for the consideration of its competent statistical authority any such proposals communicated to it by the Governing Body; (ò) indicate in its annual report upon the application of the Convention the extent to which it has given effect to such proposals. PART V I . — F I N A L PROVISIONS. Article 25. [208"] The formal ratifications of this Convention shall be communicated to the Secretary-General of the League of Nations for registration. Article 26. [209] 1. This Convention shall be binding only upon Members of the International Labour Organisation whose ratifications have been registered with the Secretary-General. [210] 2. It shall come into force twelve months after the date on which the ratifications of two Members have been registered with the Secretary-General. [211] 3. Thereafter, this Convention shall come into force for any Member twelve months after the date on which its ratification has been registered. Article 27. [212] As soon as the ratifications of two Members of the International Labour Organisation have been registered, the SecretaryGeneral of the League of Nations shall so notify all the Members of the International Labour Organisation. He shall likewise notify them of the registration of ratifications which may be communicated subsequently by other Members of the Organisation. 94 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Article 28. [.213] 1. A Member which has ratified this Convention may denounce it, after the expiration of ten years from the date on which the Convention first comes into force, by an act communicated to the Secretary-General of the League of Nations for registration. Such denunciation shall not take effect until one year after the date on which it is registered. [214] 2. Each Member, which has ratified this Convention and which does not, within the year following the expiration of the period of ten years mentioned in the preceding paragraph, exercise the right of denunciation provided for in this Article, will be bound for another period of ten years and, thereafter, may denounce this Convention at the expiration of each period of ten years under the terms provided for in this Article. Article 29. [215] At the expiration of each period of ten years after the coming into force of this Convention, the Governing Body of the International Labour Office shall present to the General Conference a report on the working of this Convention and shall consider the desirability of placing on the agenda of the Conference the question of its revision in whole or in part. Article 30. [216] 1. Should the Conference adopt a new Convention revising this Convention in whole or in part, then, unless the new Convention otherwise provides: (a) the ratification by a Member of the new revising Convention shall ipso jure involve the immediate denunciation of this Convention, notwithstanding the provisions of Article 28 above, if and when the new revising Convention shall have come into force; (6) as from the date when the new revising Convention comes into force this Convention shall cease to be open to ratification by the Members. [217] 2. This Convention shall in any case remain in force in its actual form and content for those Members which have ratified it but have not ratified the revising Convention. Article 31. [218] The French and English texts of this Convention shall both be authentic. STATISTICS OF WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 95 12. Proposed Recommendation suggested by the Fifth International Conference of Labour 1Statisticians, Geneva, October 1937 \_219~] Whereas the Convention on Statistics of Wages and Hours is necessarily limited in scope to statistics which are sufficiently developed to permit of a substantial number of Members entering into definite obligations in respect thereof; and Whereas it is of special importance that every effort should be made further to improve statistics of wages and hours of work; The Conference, with a view to completing the provisions of the Statistics of Wages and Hours Convention, recommends that each Member should give effect to the following provisions: [220] 1. (1) Statistics of time rates of wages and of normal hours of work and/or statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked should be compiled in respect of wage-earners engaged in transport, commercial or trading establishments, and administrative services. [221] (2) Statistics of salaries and hours should be compiled for salaried employees, excluding persons holding positions of management. [222] (3) These statistics should be compiled as far as possible at the intervals specified in the Statistics of Wages and Hours Convention in respect of statistics relating to persons to whom that Convention applies. [223] 2. (1) At least every ten years, statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked should be compiled for each of the principal occupations in each industry. [224] (2) These statistics1: (a) should show the number of workpeople grouped according to the amount of their earnings; and (6) should be given by sex and by age groups. [225] 3. (1) Statistics showing the aggregate amount of wages and salaries paid per annum in each of the principal industries in mining and manufacture, including building and construction, and as far as possible for other branches of economic activity, should be compiled regularly and where possible at annual intervals, and distinguishing as far as possible between wages paid to wageearners and salaries paid to salaried employees. 1 Paragraph 1 of this text and certain provisions of the other paragraphs were outside the scope of the subject included in the Agenda of the 24th Session of the International Labour Conference, June 1938, and could therefore not be considered by it. 96 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS (2) An approximate indication should be given of the extent to which the returns are representative of all employed persons. [_226~\ 4. Statistics showing average annual earnings of workers in each of the principal industries in mining and manufacture, including building and construction, and as far as possible for other branches of economic activity should be compiled at intervals of three years, distinguishing as far as possible between wages paid to wage earners and salaries paid to salaried employees. [227~\ 5. The statistics of time rates of wages should so far as possible be accompanied by indications as to the number of workers covered, as well as by any information which may be available as to the relation between the time rates of wages and actual earnings. \_228] 6. The statistics compiled in pursuance of this Recommendation should be published and communicated to the International Labour Office as prescribed by the Statistics of Wages and Hours Convention for the statistics compiled in pursuance thereof. 13. Proposals Calling for Further Action 1 {229} 1. (1) At least once every ten years, the statistics of average earnings and of hours actually worked relating to wage earners employed in the principal mining and manufacturing industries, including building and construction, should give separate figures for each of the principal occupations in each industry. [230~] (2) These statistics: (a) should show the number of workpeople grouped according to the amount of their earnings ; and (b) should be given by sex and by age groups. [23f\ 2. (1) Statistics showing the aggregate amount of wages paid per annum in each of the principal industries in mining and manufacture, including building and construction, should be compiled regularly and where possible at annual intervals. 1 Based on the text of the proposed Recommendation suggested by the Fifth International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, 1937. The International Labour Conference at its 24th Session, June 1938, adopted a resolution requesting the Governing Body of the International Labour Office to arrange for these proposals to be examined in accordance with the procedure laid down in Article 24 of the Convention, and meanwhile to communicate them to Governments. On 2 February 1939 the Governing Body instructed the International Labour Office to communicate the proposals to Governments for their information and noted that action should be taken in accordance with Article 24 of the Convention in due course after the coming into force of the Convention. STATISTICS OF WAGES AND HOURS OF WORK 97 [_232~\ (2) An approximate indication should be given of the extent to which the returns are representative of all employed persons. [233] 3. Statistics showing average annual earnings of workers employed in each of the principal industries in mining and manufacture, including building and construction, should be compiled at intervals not exceeding three years. [234] 4. The statistics of time rates of wages should so far as possible be accompanied by: (a) indications as to the number of workers covered, and (è) any information which may be available as to the relation between the time rates of wages and actual earnings. IV COST OF LIVING INDEX NUMBERS! 14. Resolutions of t h e Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, April 1925 COST-OF-LIVING I N D E X NUMBERS (intended to measure changes in the cost of living in a given country at different periods) [23f] (1) In each country statistics should be published showing changes in the cost of living. They should cover the food, clothing, heating and lighting, rent, and miscellaneous groups. Each group should include the most important items of consumption, and especially those articles the price changes of which may be taken as representative of changes in the prices of articles not included. [236~] Separate index numbers should be published for each of the groups and general index numbers for all the groups combined. In calculating these index numbers weights should be used proportionate to the relative importance in consumption of the items in each group and of the different groups. Changes in the cost of living in a given period should be calculated by using weights which remain unchanged throughout the period. When changes in consumption render the weights inappropriate a new series of index numbers based on new weights should be calculated. [_237~\ It would be desirable that as far as possible the information published should enable the differences which would result in the index numbers from the inclusion or exclusion of direct taxes to be determined. [238~\ (2) A series of national index numbers, calculated by using weights based on the consumption of industrial workers generally, should be published. In cases where desirable, index numbers may also be calculated for other classes of workers. [239] In countries in which there are marked differences in economic conditions in different districts or among different sections See also V. International Comparison of Real Wages. COST OF LIVING INDEX NUMBERS 99 of the working classes, it is desirable that separate index numbers should be published for such areas and classes. In these cases the weights used should, as far as possible, be based on working-class consumption in the districts or among the sections of workers to which the index numbers relate. [240] It may be convenient that the national index should be computed by combining the separate indices, account being taken of the relative populations in the different groups. [_241~] (3) In view of the existing inadequacy of statistics of consumption, the most satisfactory method of determining the weights of the different items and groups appears to be that based on a standard family budget obtained as the result of an enquiry into the average expenditure of a number of families during a given period. [242] Where statistics of family budgets are not available, statistics of aggregate consumption may be of some value in the determination of the relative importance of certain articles of consumption in the country as a whole, account being taken of the fact that certain articles are used for purposes other than human consumption. [243] Theoretical budgets computed from all information available may also be used. [244] (4) Care should be taken to ensure that the quality of each item for which prices are obtained at different dates and the methods of collection and calculation remain unchanged during the period covered. [2452 (5) Index numbers should be computed as often as may be necessary having regard to the extent to which prices are changing. In present conditions they may with advantage be computed at monthly intervals, but under more stable conditions their publication at less frequent intervals may be adequate. [246'] (6) It is desirable that in those countries in which no family budget enquiries have been held since 1920-1921 such enquiries should be undertaken as soon as economic conditions are sufficiently favourable, and, if possible, not later than the year 1928. [247"] (7) It is desirable that the Governments, in collaboration with the International Labour Office, should agree to adopt the same year as base for the calculation of a new series of index numbers. I t is suggested that the year 1930 would be suitable for this purpose. [248] (8) It is of great importance that the principles adopted in the selection of articles and of the different qualities of such articles, in the collection and computation of the price data and 100 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS in the fixing of the weights, should be indicated in full detail when such index numbers are first published, also the precise data to which the index numbers refer. 15. International Convention relating to Economic Statistics, of 14 December 1928, adopted by t h e International Conference relating to Economic Statistics called by the L e a g u e of N a t i o n s 1 VI. INDEX NUMBERS OP P R I C E S [249] Index numbers: (6) Showing the general movement of the cost of living, to be compiled and published at least quarterly. \_250] The cost of living indices may be based on data relating to a single town or to several towns selected as being representative and taken either separately or collectively. [251] Each statement of index numbers mentioned above shall contain a reference to a short official publication showing the items the prices of which have been used, and the methods employed in the calculation of the indices. 16. R e c o m m e n d a t i o n of t h e International Conference relating to Economic S t a t i s t i c s called by t h e League of Nations 2 S_252~\ IX. That, with a view to ensuring the comparability of index numbers referred to in Article 2-VI of this Convention, the same year or period should be taken as a basis for such index numbers in all countries, and that the Committee of Experts, taking into consideration the work of the International Conferences of Labour Statisticians convened by the International Labour Office and the work of the International Institute of Statistics, should investigate this matter and prepare a report thereon, which should be circulated to the Governments of all the High Contracting Parties. 1 LEAGUE OP NATIONS: International Conference relating to Economic Statistics (Geneva, 1928), International Convention, Article 2, p. 4 (Ser. L.O.N. Pub. 1928. II. 52). * Ibid., Final Act, Recommendation IX, p. 76. V INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS OF REAL WAGES AND COSTS OF LIVING 17. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Labour Statisticians, April 1925 £255] The Conference recognises the great theoretical and practical importance of the international comparisons of real wages which were initiated by the British Ministry of Labour and the interest of the researches which have been subsequently carried on by the International Labour Office and which have certainly led to progress in this sphere. \_254~] The Conference, however, expresses the opinion that, since these figures cannot be considered as representative of the real differences in the workers' standard of living which exist from country to country, it is desirable that a second series of index numbers should be published along with the first, measuring the relative standards of living of the working classes in the different countries. In this case it would be necessary to base the calculations on the actual earnings of working-class families and to take account of the differences in the physiological needs of the population due chiefly to climate and race. [255'] The International Labour Office, in publishing these index numbers, should give in the greatest detail the original figures, the methods of calculation adopted, and any reservations necessary. The different countries should send to the International Labour Office the fullest information, together with a detailed description as to the nature and value of their figures. 18. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Statisticians convoked by t h e Social Science Research Council of t h e United States of America, January 1929 INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS OP W A G E S I [256} (1) The Committee is impressed by the fact that a great variety of wage statistics is collected in the various countries. 102 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS In general these statistics may be described as statistics of earnings or of wage rates. Some countries are strong in statistics of rates, others of earnings. It is desirable that records of the movement both of rates of wages and of earnings should be available. The Committee therefore recommends t h a t : (a) the countries which are weak in statistics of earnings take steps to add to those statistics by collecting statistics of earnings, for the principal occupations as well as for the chief industries, and of total hours worked from which it would be possible to compute earnings per hour, and that (6) the countries which have concentrated on statistics of earnings improve their figures of wage rates and of changes in wage rates. \ZS7"\ (2) I t is evidently of the greatest importance that the expressions "earnings" and "rates of wages" should have the same meaning in the statistics of the different countries. With this object the Committee recommends t h a t : (a) the statistics of the different countries indicate clearly what is understood by the expressions "rates of wages" and "earnings", and particularly what are the payments in money and in kind which are included in "earnings"; (6) at intervals, special enquiries should be undertaken to show what are the differences between the rates of wages and average wages (earnings) of different branches of industry and categories of workers. \ZSB~\ (3) The Committee is of the opinion that attention might be particularly directed to defects in the information at present available in the various countries if the International Labour Office would compile an annual statement, if possible in tabular form, by industries, either of wage rates or earnings or both. The statement should, if possible, also include for the various industries in each country the full-time and actual hours together with their distribution. It is considered that the publication of such information would encourage the various countries to supplement their statistics as to rates or earnings or both, and that in course of time the annual statement would gradually improve until it would provide material for more adequate comparisons. II \_Z59~\ The Committee is impressed by the limitations of the present quarterly statistics of wages published by the International INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 103 Labour Office, due to the fact that few industries and occupations in, generally, only one city in each country are included. [_26(f\ The Committee believes that it would be possible to improve the statistics by adding to the number of occupations and of localities. It therefore recommends that the Conference invite the International Labour Office to consider whether these defects could possibly be remedied by asking the national authorities concerned to supply them with additional information necessary for this purpose. [26 f\ The Committee has selected a few additional occupations which appear not unsuitable for immediate inclusion. These are named in the annex to these Recommendations. The Committee also considers that the number might be further increased. \_262~] The Committee also ventures to suggest that the International Labour Office might be asked to consider the possibility of consulting with competent bodies in the several countries as to whether other localities could be added to the present list, and the further question whether it might be possible to indicate more definitely the divisions of industry to which some of the occupations included belong and to omit any localities which are not really representative of any country as a whole. \_263~] The occupations proposed for addition are confined to non-localised industries. It might be possible also to include occupations from other non-localised industries, such as railway transportation, and also commercial and municipal employees. Localised industries such as iron and steel, textiles, mining, and shipbuilding can only be dealt with by consultation with the representatives of the several countries, and certain occupations which come under this head and the towns in which they are found might also be added to the list. \_264] If fuller information on the lines indicated is obtainable, the collection and publication of statistics for localised and nonlocalised industries on a half-yearly or yearly basis might be adequate. [265^} ANNEX Building Industry: TransportStructural iron workers. Tram and bus drivers. Concrete workers. Tram and bus conductors. Electric Power Distribution: Motor drivers (van and lorry). Electrical engineers. Horse drivers. Electrical Installation (Buildings): Electrical fitters. 104 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS 19. Resolutions of the Fourth International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, May 1931 INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS OP REAL WAGES \_266~\ This Conference, recognising the value of the information as to wages and prices which has in the past been collected by the International Labour Office for the purpose of calculations relating to the purchasing power of wages in different countries, and taking account of the resolutions adopted by the Governing Body at its Fifty-first Session, with the object of improving the bases and methods of compilation of such statistics, makes the following recommendations: [2671, (1) The International Labour Office should continue to collect and publish particulars of wages, in a representative selection of towns, industries and occupations in those countries for which information is obtainable; the statistics hitherto published should be extended, as far as possible, and in publishing the information the Office should give detailed particulars as to the sources, nature and scope of the data included. \_268^\ (2) Information as to earnings per unit of time are preferable for purposes of international comparison but can generally be furnished only as a result of special enquiries. Governments should make these enquiries on uniform lines on the basis of the resolutions adopted by the first International Conference of Labour Statisticians and should supply the information to the Office. Comparisons based on this information should be made and published by the Office. \_269~\ (3) Time rates of wages and piece-work basis time rates as established by collective agreements or other arrangements can be furnished by many countries without special enquiry. These are of value for purposes of international comparison and should be collected and published. \_270\ (4) In principle, it is undesirable to compare rates of wages in one country with actual earnings in another; but where, owing to incomplete information, rates of wages in certain countries have to be compared with earnings in other countries, any available information as-to the relation between the level of rates of wages and earnings should be used to correct the figures of wage rates. \_271), (5) In addition to the data as to money wages referred to in the foregoing paragraphs, particulars should be supplied with regard to the amounts of family allowances, if any, paid to the various classes of workpeople. \272~\ (6) The International Labour Office should continue to collect and publish statistics of the retail prices of the articles of INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 105 food consumed by working-class families in the towns for which particulars as to wages are collected; particulars should also be collected of the prices of fuel and light in these towns. The statistics hitherto published should be extended as far as possible and in publishing the information the Office should give such indications as can be obtained as to the scope of the data. [2732 (7) In view of the desirability of including, in the data relating to cost of living, information as to the relative level of rents in each country, the International Labour Office should invite the statistical authorities in each country to furnish regular information with regard to the average rents of the predominant types of working-class dwellings in the towns for which statistics of wages and prices are supplied, together with a description of the accommodation provided and of the general character of the dwellings covered. The International Labour Office should study the possibility of obtaining one or more standard units of housing for the various purposes of international comparison. [2742 (8) In those countries in which no family budget enquiries have been made during the last ten years, such enquiries should be undertaken at the earliest possible date, on the lines laid down in the resolutions adopted at the Third Conference of Labour Statisticians in 1926. [275^ (9) The wages and prices information referred to in the preceding paragraphs should be collected and published by the International Labour Office at annual intervals. The Office should address each year to the statistical offices of each contributing Government a questionnaire soliciting the fullest possible particulars of wages and retail prices and rents relating as nearly as possible to the month of October. In view of the fact that there are important seasonal variations in the prices of certain foodstuffs, such prices should be obtained several times a year. [2762 (10) The information so obtained should be tabulated in a form facilitating ready comparison, and should be published, at the earliest possible date, in a special annual volume. This volume would be, in essentials, a development and amplification of the statistical tables published by the Office at regular intervals in the International Labour Review. It should include, as regards wages, tables both of rates of wages and of earnings. It should include explanatory notes regarding the source, nature and scope of all the figures given, and should set out and illustrate the various possible methods of combining the data so as to yield any desired indices of relative real wages. This Conference believes that such a volume would increase in scope and in importance with each addition to the range of information obtained ; and would form from 106 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS the outset the nucleus of what must become in due course an authoritative source-book of comparable international information regarding wages and retail prices in all industrially developed countries. \_277~] (11) Following upon the publication of this volume, there should be prepared and published in the International Labour Review an article in which the data contained in the published volume should be discussed from the standpoint of determining the relative levels of purchasing power of wages in the various countries. In this article the difficulties of the procedure should be fully and frankly disclosed. Indices on various bases should be given, with the purpose of indicating the various points of view from which comparisons can be made and of preventing a n y one figure being regarded as authoritative for all purposes. ' [278~\ In view of the fact that the index numbers of purchasing power of wages serve different national purposes, it is impracticable for the International Labour Office to compute all the comparisons which are possible between a series of countries and between different occupations and industries. The series of index numbers compiled by the Office should be illustrative of the methods by which the data may be used for computing further series. [27PJ (12) In any statistics which may in future be compiled by the International Labour Office as to the relative purchasing power of wages in different countries, account should be taken of the diverse circumstances and conditions of the workers in different countries resulting, for example, from differences: (a) in systems of wage payment; (b) in the nature and amount of payments supplementary to wages, such as family allowances and paid holidays; and (c) in systems of social insurance. Alternative series of index numbers should be so far as possible computed to show the effect of the inclusion or exclusion of such items. [280~\ (13) The calculation of these index numbers by the use of information as to working-class consumption furnished by family budget enquiries should be made not only as hitherto on a fixed international budget but also on the basis of various national or regional budgets. \_281~\ (14) The Conference realises that comparisons cannot usefully be made between countries of widely differing habits and customs; and that the closer are the consumption habits in different countries, the more trustworthy are the comparisons likely to be. \_282~\ (15) The Conference is unable to recommend the proposal to compare countries of dissimilar conditions by progression through countries with intermediate conditions owing to the lack of information on such conditions at the present time and to the absence of any criterion for measuring the degree of dissimilarity among the intermediate countries. INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 107 [283~\ (16) in all comparisons between two or more countries, however, allowance should be made for the difference in articles consumed in each of the countries by basing the calculations successively on the list of important articles consumed in one country and the list of important articles (but not necessarily the same articles) consumed in the others. {.284} (17) It is also desirable that as regards certain articles of food for which direct comparison of prices as between one country and another is impracticable, the International Labour Office should explore the question of supplementing the present method of calculation by a method in which account would be taken of the possibilities of comparisons of prices on a basis of nutritive value. R E COMMENDATION £2852 The Conference recommends that the Governing Body place the question of the supply of the data required for the purpose of these international comparisons of wages and cost of living on the agenda of a future International Labour Conference with a view to the framing of a Convention binding the Governments which ratify it to collect and supply the information at regular intervals. £286~] It recommends that a small committee of experts representing the competent national statistical authorities might be set up. The function of this committee would be to assist the Office in its work of developing and publishing wage and cost-ofliving statistics and in preparing for any future international conference which might appear desirable in the near future. A. STATISTICS OF ELEMENTS OTHER THAN OF WAGES REMUNERATION 20. Resolution of t h e C o m m i t t e e oí S t a t i s t i c a l Experts of t h e International L a b o u r OSice, First Session, Geneva, 12-15 December Í933 [287~\ The Committee, Having examined the results of the latest enquiry into elements of remuneration other than wages (family allowances, paid holidays, employers' and workers' contributions to compulsory social insurances) carried out by the Office in conformity with the resolutions of the Fourth International Conference of Labour Statisticians, as a complement to its enquiry into wages, makes the following recommendations : 108 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS \_288~] 1. In order that the results of such enquiries may serve really useful purposes, particularly in contributing towards a complete explanation of the data relating to wages, it is desirable that the national statistical services of all the countries which collaborate in the annual enquiry into wages should be able to supply more complete information on these elements of remuneration, and should furnish more exact information as to the sources, character and scope of the figures, so as to enable the portion which these different factors form of the total remuneration of the workers to be evaluated; [_289~] 2. The Office should continue its work with a view to elaborating methods appropriate for arriving at such evaluations, taking into consideration the different hypotheses which may be adopted in this respect; \_290~] 3. In view of the nature of these different elements and the lack of adequate information, it is not essential that the simultaneous calculation of several index numbers of wages, showing the effect of including or excluding these factors, should be repeated each year. It would be sufficient to recall, in the analysis dealing with the wages tabulations, the general character of the supplementary remuneration of this kind existing in each country, and periodically to revise the available information and these calculations by special enquiries at intervals of some years. B. STA TISTICS OF THE COST OF LIVING 21. Resolutions of the Second International Conference of Statisticians convoked by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America, May 1930 [20 JQ I. In view of the fact that international comparisons of cost of living which are the bases of all international real wages comparisons are defective because of the lack in various countries of adequate recent comparable budget studies, the Committee recommends that the various countries which have not made family budget enquiries within the last five years be requested to make new and comprehensive studies of the budgets of workingclass families; to conduct these enquiries as soon as possible (and not later than the end of 1932) ; and to take account of the studies on these subjects issued by the International Labour Office and recommendations made by the several Conferences of Labour Statisticians. [2P2J II. In order to supplement international real wage comparisons and to throw further light on actual living conditions among workers in various countries, the Committee recommends INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 109 that a descriptive detailed study be made (carefully planned and very limited in scope) of the mode of life (work, wages, lodging, dress, dietary, amusements, etc.) of typical high- medium- and low-paid workers in various countries, such as railway workers, miners, builders, etc. [,2932 H I . In order to see how far different methods of comparing real wages agree with one another, the Committee recommends as desirable: [294] (a) while awaiting new budget enquiries, to consider the compilation of these comparisons on the basis of the budgets of the principal countries included in the comparison, instead of grouping the budgets, or using an international budget; such comparisons might be made once a year; [2P5J (ò) when results of family budgets are available, to make allowances as far as possible in indices based on food, fuel and lighting, for rents and other items of expenditure; the results of these allowances should be indicated separately; [2962 (c) in the case of countries where there are outstanding differences in the mode of living in different districts, to use as far as possible, where comparisons relate to wages in different towns, the budgets of the towns considered, and, where comparisons relate to wages in the country as a whole, the national budget; £297'] (d) that in view of the fact that cost-of-living index numbers depend more on the prices than on the composition of the budgets, and that retail prices of the same article vary considerably according to quality, precautions be taken with a view to ensure that, as far as possible, the comparability of prices is maintained. It would be desirable before making comparisons that the statistical offices of different countries be requested to furnish detailed information as to the quality of the articles indicated in the budgets, and for any observations to which these budgets may give rise from the point of view of international comparisons. C. STATISTICS OF THE COST OF FOOD 22. Resolution of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, First Session, Geneva, 12-15 December 1933 [298~} 1- As regards the cost of food, the Committee recommends that: The International Labour Office continue; (a) Its theoretical research, not only on the lines indicated 110 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS in its memorandum (CES 1/3/1933), but also in other directions and particularly from the point of view of physiological standards; (b) Its practical studies, and the periodical publication of international indices of the cost of food. [_299\ 2. Before indicating some of the principles on which it is possible to express an opinion at present, the Committee recognises that, on the one hand, the absence, in very many cases, of recent enquiries into family budgets classified according to incomes and localities, and showing both the expenditure and the quantities consumed, and, on the other hand, the defects in the statistics of retail prices, present serious obstacles to the application of any method of comparison. [300] In order, however, to enable the International Labour Office to utilise all the data of sufficient value available in the different countries, the Committee recommends that in each case the procedure applied should be that which is best adapted to the character and the value of these data. It is nevertheless obvious that relatively summary methods can alone be used when the data necessary for more refined calculations are at present lacking. The following principles therefore apply only to comparisons relating to the countries in which the statistical information available enables more elaborate methods to be applied. [301] 3. In accordance with the recommendations of the Fourth International Conference of Labour Statisticians, the comparisons should be made on the basis of national or regional budgets of family expenditure ; further, indices obtained by different methods should be calculated and published simultaneously. [302] For the purpose of these index numbers, there should be included within the same "region" only those countries, parts of countries, or towns in which the habits of consumption and the price systems are sufficiently comparable; in the first place, the percentage of the total food expenditure represented by the expenditure on articles of common consumption should be sufficiently high ; the further criteria suggested in the above-mentioned memorandum may then be applied, and account taken of variations in comparability according to the level of incomes. [303] In principle, "regions" should be formed by towns and not by countries; consequently, they should not necessarily be constituted in such a manner as to cover the whole of a country; they may, for example, include certain towns and exclude others belonging to the same country. When, however, the available data do not admit of the separata consideration of several towns INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 111 within a country, a single town or an average covering several towns may be taken, and in this case, in default of appropriate data, it will be admissible to utilise, for the purpose of weighting, average quantities relating to the country as a whole. Geographical proximity and comparability from points of view other than that of food consumption may be taken into account in allocating a town to one region or another in those cases in which it is almost or wholly a matter of indifference to which region a town is allotted. It will be expedient to restrict the number of regions as far as possible. [304] In order to reduce the calculations involved, the number of towns should be reduced so far as possible to the capital and, where necessary, some other representative towns in each country. [305] 4. In each "region" a town should be chosen as "regional centre", well comparable with the other towns in the "region". The Office is invited to prepare a primary system of "regions" which will serve as a basis for its calculations. The Office might, in addition, study other systems of "regions" with a view to the ultimate adoption of the system which would yield the best results. \_306~] 5. For the comparisons within each region, it will be sufficient to calculate one index between each town and its regional centre. [307] 6. For comparisons between the regional centres a formula should be adopted which takes account of the consumption in each of them. Indices of this kind should be accompanied by an indication as to the degree of confidence which can be placed in them so as to avoid any misinterpretations. [305] 7. For the calculation of an index relating to two towns belonging to different regions the Committee is of opinion that it is impossible to formulate a general rule applicable to all cases. If questions of this nature arise, the Office should select in each particular case, the method of calculation which appears the most appropriate. [30P] 8. The publication should include any necessary reservations, and the Committee expresses the opinion that it should contain not only the computed indices, but also the original data used in the calculations. D. STATISTICS OF RENTS 23. Resolution of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, First Session, Geneva, 12-15 December 1933 \_310} As regards statistics of rents, the Committee: 112 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS Considering that in international comparisons of cost of living it is of prime importance to be able to include expenditure on rent, since this may appreciably modify the relative positions established on the basis of the cost of food alone; Considering that the problem needs to be explored more exhaustively both from the theoretical and from the practical point of view, before the publication of index numbers of rent is undertaken ; Having examined with the greatest interest the memorandum (CES 1/4/1933) submitted by the International Labour Office, in which, after a very complete discussion of the principal methods of calculation which might be considered applicable in this hitherto little explored field, the results of various application of these methods are analysed and compared ; Considering that this preliminary work of exploration and the results of these experiments were essential for the purpose of determining the difficulties of the problem, and that the evidence at present available does not appearto admit of the use of very refined methods; Recommends That the Office should continue its work on this question, that it should especially endeavour to find methods which, even though approximative, can be readily applied to a large number of countries, and in particular, that it should examine: \_311~] (a) The correction to be made to the figures of rents per room in order to allow for the differences in the prevailing types of dwellings in different towns, especially as regards the size of the rooms, and for this purpose should seek the collaboration of the statistical offices in a number of countries. \_312~\ (b) The relation which exists between the amount of rent per head in the predominant types of working class dwellings in each town. 24. Resolutions of the C o m m i t t e e of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, Second Session, Geneva, 16-18 December 1935 [_3132 In the first place, the Committee recommends that, in the collection of the data designed to serve as the basis for such comparisons, information should be obtained which will enable the predominant types of dwellings in each town to be classified, on the one hand according to their general standard of accommodation, and, on the other hand, according to the number of habitable rooms. [314] As regards the first of these points, the Committee recommends that the following approximate classification should be adopted: INTERNATIONA!, COMPARISONS 113 (a) dwellings with bathroom, private w . c , and water laid on in the dwelling; (b) dwellings with private w.c, and water laid on in the dwelling (but without bathroom) ; (c) dwellings in buildings containing a number of tenements, with w.c. common to several dwellings on the same floor, and water laid on either in the dwelling or on the same floor; (d) dwellings in houses containing one or two families; with closet in common outside the house, and with water laid on, either inside each dwelling or common to both families; (e) dwellings in buildings containing a number of tenements, with exterior closets, and water supply in common. \_315] As regards the second point, dwellings of one, two, three, four, five and six rooms should be separately distinguished. The rooms taken into account should be habitable rooms generally (dining-room, sitting-room and bedroom) including the kitchen, but not corridors, bathrooms, sculleries, etc. [_316] It should be understood that, in each town covered by the statistics, data relating to rents need only be collected for the predominant types of working-class dwellings in that town. £317] In the second place, having regard to the marked variations, between different towns, in the size of the rooms, the Cornmittee considers that rents distinguished only according to the numbers of rooms do not form a sufficient basis for comparisons. The Committee accordingly recommends that particulars of the rents of each category of dwelling should be accompanied by an indication of the total floor-space of each type of dwelling (exclusive of cellars and attics unsuitable for use as living-rooms), and that on the basis of these particulars, index numbers should be compiled, for each type of dwelling enumerated above, showing the relative level of rents expressed (a) per room and (ò) per square metre of total floor-space. £318] The data collected regarding rents, and the two series of index numbers, should be accompanied, when published, by a full explanation of their significance and interpretation. £319] It should be observed that it would not be necessary to repeat the enquiries relating to floor-space on each occasion when particulars of rents are collected. When representative particulars, on this subject, have once been obtained, they will generally be valid for a period of several years. [320] The Committee recommends that the International Labour Office should now take the necessary steps, in collaboration with the national statistical authorities, to collect data, on the 114 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS basis of these proposals, as to the rents of working-class dwellings in different countries. In particular, the Office should compile a list of the particulars which should, as a minimum, be obtained when special enquiries as to rents are made, and also on any occasion when a general housing census is taken. The data necessary for the calculation of the index numbers should be transmitted to the International Labour Office at regular intervals and, if possible, at least every two or three years. \_32f] The Committee also recommends that the Office should continue its theoretical studies, not only along the lines indicated in its memoranda, but with the further object of making international comparisons of expenditure on rent; in particular that it should study the criteria which are necessary for ensuring comparability, and the question of classifying the various towns in regions of good comparability; and also recommends that the results of these studies should be submitted to a further meeting of the Committee. 25. Resolutions of the C o m m i t t e e of Statistical Experts of the International Labour Office, T h i r d Session, Geneva, 6-7 October 1937 [322] 1. The Committee have examined the results of the further enquiry into rents of working-class dwellings in different towns carried out by the Office in accordance with suggestions made by the Committee at its previous session. Data have been obtained for 20 countries covering about 60 towns. An examination of these data and of the problems which have arisen concerning their compilation in certain countries represented on the Committee has shown that it is desirable to revise slightly certain of the "standards" which were drawn up for the purpose of distinguishing dwellings according to their principal characteristics. Thus, the Committee recommends that a distinction be made in Standard A (dwellings with bathroom, private lavatory and running water) between dwellings consisting of a house and those consisting of a flat. Further, a special category might eventually be adopted for dwellings in Standard A (flats) in which the cost of heating supplied by the landlord is included in the rent without the possibility of deducting it. On the other hand, the Committee suggests that the Office should reconsider the definition of Standard C 1, for which a very small number of data have been received, and, in particular, should examine whether it would not be possible to cover a category of dwelling more prevalent in certain countries by slightly modifying this definition, especially as regards the expression "shared lavatory outside the house". INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS 115 [_32f\ As regards the general definition of a dwelling considered at present strictly as a separate architectural unit, the Committee thinks that this definition should be made more flexible so as to cover parts of a house originally intended for one family but now occupied by two families without being separated architecturally. Finally, the Office should examine in further detail the procedure to be adopted as regards the various services (water, hot and cold; maintenance of common passages; heating; lighting; kitchen equipment; etc.) which may be included in the rents, or for which supplementary charges may be made. \_324~\ 2. As regards the floor space of the dwellings, the Committee, after having re-examined the question and in particular the character of the data available in different countries, recommends that account should be taken only of the area of living rooms (including kitchen) excluding subsidiary accommodation (such as passages, corridors, lavatories, bathrooms, verandahs) as well as cellars, attics, lofts, etc. When the only particulars available refer to the floor space of the main parts of the dwelling (that is to living rooms and adjoining subsidiary accommodation but excluding attics, separate lofts, cellars, etc.) these data might be used after deducting a certain fixed percentage corresponding to the proportion generally borne by this subsidiary accommodation as a whole; this percentage, necessarily arbitrary, would be fixed by the Office in consultation with experts on the subject. This correction, however, should be made only for flats and not for dwellings consisting of separate houses, in which cases the percentage deduction would be much more variable. [325] 3. The Committee endorses the recommendation made at its previous session concerning the further development of the work of the Office on the question of international comparisons of rents as one of the elements of international cost of living comparisons. For such studies it is necessary that comparable information should be available on housing conditions in the different countries. It would therefore appear very desirable that housing censuses, undertaken in many countries at the time of the general population censuses, which form the most important source of information on this subject, should be standardised as completely as possible. The Committee having been informed of a decision of the Assembly of the League of Nations concerning studies by the Secretariat on the subject of housing, and of the work which is being undertaken on this subject by other international organisations, decided to await the results of these studies before proceeding further with the examination of this question. VI METHODS OF FAMILY LIVING ENQUIRIES 26. Resolutions of the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1926 METHODS OF FAMILY BUDGET ENQUIRIES 1 \_326~] (1) In order to provide adequate information with regard to actual standards of living, enquiries should be conducted at intervals generally of not more than ten years into the income, expenditure, and conditions of living of families representative of large homogeneous sections of the population. [ 3 2 / ] The families should be selected to include a sufficient number from different income classes within the sections of the population under consideration, and also from different industries and districts. It is preferable to ask for less detailed information rather than to reduce the number of families covered by the enquiry. [328] (2) In order that the results of the enquiries may be as complete and comparable as possible, information should be based on daily records of income and expenditure kept by a member of the family for a period of twelve months. [329] Where it would be impracticable to obtain annual records, every effort should be made to secure from as large a number of families as possible budgets covering at least four periods of not less than a week, one in each quarter, or two periods of at least a fortnight in different seasons of the year. These records would supply adequate information regarding items of expenditure which recur daily. In the case of items of income and expenditure (clothing, furniture, etc.) which recur only at considerable intervals, annual records kept by a smaller number of families or information on which annual estimates could be based should be sufficient. [330] Special forms or account books should be distributed to the families for their use in making these records of income and expenditure. It is desirable that competent persons should be ap1 For a discussion of the change of terminology from "family budget enquiries" to "family living enquiries" see Robert Morse WOODBURY: Methods of Family Living Studies, International Labour Office, Studies and Reports, Series N, No. 23 (Geneva, 1940), pp. 2-3. METHODS OP EAMILY LIVING ENQUIRIES 117 pointed to visit the families during the course of the enquiry and advise them regarding the keeping of the records. £3312 (3) The records should show the district in which the family resides, the industry and occupation to which members of the family who are gainfully occupied belong, and the composition of the household, including the sex of each member and the age of juvenile members. They should show in sufficient detail the nature of the housing accommodation. \_332~] Information should be given for each important item of income and expenditure. By income should be understood earnings in money and kind, sums received from boarders and lodgers, from insurance funds, pensions, and investments, together with income from allotments or in the form of gifts. The chief items of income and expenditure should be specified on the forms, or account books, distributed. In the case of items of expenditure, the quantity purchased, as well as the cost, should be recorded wherever practicable. Where a family includes boarders, lodgers, or domestic servants, information should be given to show the proportion they represent in the family consumption. In the calculation of expenditure, the cost of maintenance of domestic servants should be added to their money wages. £3332 (4) In compiling the results of an enquiry, if the number of budgets secured is adequate, separate averages should be given for important districts and industries. Families of manual and non-manual workers should be shown separately. Averages calculated for different income groups should be shown. £334] In addition to averages per family and for families classified according to size, the data expressed in terms of some more precise unit of consumption, for example the consumption of an adult male, should be given. For reducing data for families of different size to terms of a common unit, it is desirable, where suitable scales showing the relative consumption of persons of different age and sex are available, to apply one scale to food commodities and a second scale to other items. £335'] The tabulated results should show the average income from different sources, and the quantity of and expenditure on each of the chief commodities consumed. Separate information should be given for each item of income and of expenditure which constitutes on the average not less than 1 per cent, of total income or expenditure. Other items of interest may be shown separately as desired. The items òf expenditure should be classified into the following groups: food, clothing, housing accommodation, fuel and light, furniture and furnishings, and miscellaneous. It is desirable that payments of direct taxation should be given as a separate 118 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS item. It is also desirable to determine the nutritive value of the principal articles of food together with the cost of a thousand calories of each commodity. £33<f\ Where the sole object of an enquiry is to provide weights for the calculation of cost-of-living index numbers, satisfactory results may be obtained from a less detailed investigation than that indicated above. Information regarding district, industry, composition of family, and expenditure upon each of the several items to be included in the index numbers only is necessary. It is desirable, however, to have, in addition, information as to quantities. rjJ373 The results will be tabulated to meet the requirements of the series of cost-of-living index numbers which it is proposed to publish in each country. Thus if separate series of cost-of-living index numbers are to be published for a number of districts or categories of workers, the results of the family budget enquiries will be tabulated separately for each district or category; if a single national index is to be calculated, the results may be shown in the form of general averages only. 27. R e c o m m e n d a t i o n of t h e C o m m i t t e e of S t a t i s t i c a l Experts of t h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l L a b o u r Office, F i r s t Session, 12-15 D e c e m b e r 1933 [338] The Committee of Statistical Experts emphasises the fact that statistical enquiries into international comparisons of the cost of living and the purchasing power of wages cannot be undertaken without information as to the family budgets of the working classes. In view of the fact that in many countries no family budget enquiries have been undertaken since a period now more or less remote, which fact substantially impedes the Office in its investigations, the Committee draws special attention to the resolutions adopted by the Second and Third International Conferences of Labour Statisticians, which recommended that all countries should conduct enquiries into family budgets at regular intervals and on a uniform, or in any case comparable, basis. In order to increase the value of these enquiries, it is desirable that they should be carried out simultaneously, and at periods as near to each other as possible. VII STATISTICS OF INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS 28. Resolutions of the First International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1923 (1) CLASSIFICATION OF INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS [339] Industrial accidents should be classified according to the industry of the injured worker, the cause of accident, the extent and degree of disability, the location of the injury, and the nature thereof. [.340] (a) The classification of industrial accidents according to the industry of the injured worker should conform to the list indicated in paragraph 4 of the Resolution concerning the Classification of Industries 1 , with such subdivisions as will allow special consideration to be given to industries with a relatively high accident rate. [.3412 (b) The classification of accidents according to the cause of accident should as far as possible be in accordance with the table given below, with such subdivisions as may be considered necessary. (i) Machinery: (a) Prime-movers; (fi) Transmission machinery; (c) Lifting machinery; (d) Working machinery; (ii) Transport: (a) (b) (c) (iii) Railways ; Ships; Vehicles; Explosions; fire; i See \4J. 120 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS (iv) (v) (vi) (vii) (viii) (ix) (x) (xi) (xii) (xiii) Poisonous, hot, or corrosive substances; Electricity; Falls of persons; Stepping on or striking against objects; Falling objects; Falls of ground; Handling without machinery; Hand tools; Animals; Miscellaneous. [342] (c) In the classification of accidents according to the extent and degree of disability a distinction should be made between fatal and non-fatal accidents and between temporary and permanent disabilities. [34J] Temporary disabilities should be classified according to duration, and uniformity should be obtained by using the following groups: (i) 2 weeks or less; (ii) over 2 and up to 4 weeks; (iii) over 4 and up to 13 weeks; (iv) over 13 weeks and up to 6 months; (v) over 6 months and up to 1 year; (vi) over 1 year and up to 2 years; (vii) over 2 years and up to 3 years. [344] Permanent disabilities should be classified by degree, and uniformity should be obtained by using the following groups: (i) under 20 per cent, disability; (ii) 20 and under 40 per cent.; (iii) 40 and under 60 per cent. ; (iv) 60 and under 80 per cent. ; (v) 80 and under 100 per cent. ; (vi) 100 per cent. [345] Permanent disabilities should be classified at the time they are recognised as such. [346] (d) The location of injury should be clearly distinguished from the nature of the injury. The most suitable classification is that of the common anatomical divisions of the body, namely: (i) the head ; (ii) trunk ; (iii) upper extremities ; (iv) lower extremities; (v) general. Each of :hese groups should be subdivided if necessary. Q?47J (e) The nature of the injury should be classified as follows: (i) contusions and abrasions; (ii) burns and scalds; (iii) concussions; (iv) cuts and lacerations; (v) punctured wounds; (vi) amputations; (vii) dislocations; (viii) fractures; (ix) sprains and strains; (x) asphyxiation; (xi) drowning; (xii) other injuries. [348] Note. In publishing the above statistics a note should be added on the following points: (a) (ò) The scope of the legislation; The system of insurance (compulsory or optional); STATISTICS OF INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENTS 121 (c) The nature of the accidents included; (d) The methods of reporting the accidents and of compiling the statistics; (e) A summary of the benefits given to the injured or to their dependants. [349] In countries in which industrial diseases are compensated as accidents they should, wherever possible, be distinguished separately in the tables. (2) ACCIDENT R A T E S r [3502 F ° industrial and international comparison it is essential to calculate frequency rates and severity rates. [351"] (a) The frequency rate should if possible be calculated by dividing the number of accidents (multiplied by 100,000) by the number of hours of working time. [352} (b) The severity rate should similarly be calculated by dividing the number of working hours lost (multiplied by 100,000) by the number of hours of working time. [353~] Where practical difficulties prevent the calculation of the number of hours of working time, this number should be replaced by the number of full-time workers (i.e. the number of working days divided by 300) or the average number of workers, as may be best suited to the economic and social needs of the country or industry concerned. Vili HOUSING STATISTICS 29. Recommendations of the C o m m i t t e e of Statistical Experts convoked by the International Union of Towns (May 1928) I. GENERAL DEFINITIONS {354} Dwelling.—The dwelling comprises a separate collection of rooms which, for whatever purpose they may be in use, are at the. date of the census intended for occupation by one family and have separate access to a street or to a common passage or stairway. Detached rooms which are clearly intended to form a part of the dwelling should be counted as part of the dwelling. \_355} Premises not intended for habitation but in use as such should be separately counted and should be reckoned as as many units as there are families in occupation. {356} Habitable buildings.—Habitable building comprises every property standing by itself or completely separated from other properties by party walls, intended as a whole or in part for habitation or in use for this purpose. Huts, tents, carts, caravans, boats and barges, which are in use as dwellings but which cannot be included in this definition, should be classified separately. {357} Rooms.—A room, defined as a space entirely enclosed, should be distinguished as follows: [358} (1) Habitable rooms, i.e. rooms intended to be actually inhabited, such as bedrooms, rooms in which meals are habitually eaten and rooms reserved for the common life of the family. The kitchen (unless by reason of its limited size it should be reckoned as a subsidiary room) should be reckoned as a habitable room. Attics and servants' quarters should be reckoned as habitable rooms when they are in fact habitable. {.359} (2) Subsidiary rooms (sanitary accommodation, bathrooms, corridors, verandas, attics, lofts, wash-houses). HOUSING STATISTICS 123 [360~] Occupants.—An occupant comprises every person who is habitually in occupation of the dwelling at the date of the census. Persons who although absent at the date of the census are ordinarily in occupation should be included, and persons who are only in temporary occupation should be excluded. \J361~y Household.—The household consists of an independent group of persons enjoying a common domestic life. [_362} A distinction should be drawn between the family household and the non-family household. It would appear most easy to draw the line of demarcation at the point where the number of boarders exceeds the number of the permanent members of the household (including domestic servants). In this connection it is more important to have regard to the actual participation of any person in the life of the family than to the form of contract between the inhabitants. II. CENSUS OF D W B L U N G S [363"} 1. Classification of dwellings. — Dwellings should be classified as follows : £.364} A. According to the purpose for which they were intended and the purpose for which they are in use : (1) Dwellings intended for the occupation of family households; (a) in use as such ; (6) not actually in use, i.e. vacant and available for occupation. (2) Dwellings intended for the occupation of nonfamily households; (a) in use as such ; (ò) not actually in use, i.e. vacant and available for occupation. (3) Premises not intended for habitation but in use for this purpose. [[JÖ5] B. According to their size measured by the number of habitable rooms and classified as follows : 124 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Dwellings with 1 habitable room u 2 rooms ii It 3 ti a 4 ti u 5 II ti 6 it U 11 7 and more (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) [JtfiT] It is also desirable that, in the above categories, the existence of kitchen, sanitary accommodation or bathroom should be indicated wherever possible. [.3672 2. Classification of habitable buildings.—A. Habitable buildings should be classified according to the proportion of the building occupied by dwellings : (1) habitable buildings primarily utilised as dwellings; (2) habitable buildings primarily utilised for purposes other than dwellings but which contain a certain number of dwellings. [368} B. Habitable buildings primarily intended for the occupation of family households or utilised for this purpose should be classified as follows: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) C6) Habitable buildings containing 1 dwelling " " " 2 dwellings " " " 3-4 " " " 5-10 " " " " " " 11-20 21 " a n d over. [36&2 3. Classification of occupants according to the characteristics of the dwellings and habitable buildings which they occupy.—The occupants of dwellings intended for the occupation of family households should be classified as follows : A. According to the size of the dwellings which they occupy, arranged in the same categories as in II 1 B. B. According to the character of the habitable buildings arranged in the same categories as in II 2 B. ß?70] 4. Combined classification according to the number of rooms and the number of occupants of a dwelling.—The occupants of dwellings intended for family habitation should be classified both according to the number of habitable rooms contained in the dwellings which they occupy and according to the number of persons occupying the dwelling as in the following table: HOUSING STATISTICS 125 Number of occupants occupying dwellings of : In dwellings inhabited by 1 habitable room 2 habitable rooms 3 hab- 4 habitable itable rooms rooms 7 hab6 hab- itable itable rooms rooms and over Total 1 person 2 persons 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 and over T otal [_37lJ Dwellings should be classified according to the same principle in a similar table: Number of dwellings Dwellings occupied by 1 hab- 2 habitable itable room rooms 3 habitable rooms 4 habitable rooms 7 hab6 hab- itable itable rooms rooms and over Total 1 pen on 2 pers ons i 3 i 4 i 5 i 6 7 i 8 i 9 10 t 11 and over T otal [_372~] 5. Classification according to density of occupation.— The density of occupation should be calculated in the case of each dwelling by dividing the number of occupants by the number of habitable rooms. [37'3j Dwellings in each of the size categories II 1 B should then be classified according to their degree of density of occupation as follows: 126 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS Dwellings occupied by 4 or more persons per room " " 3 persons but less than 4 per room it W l\ II II << II -2 << I* II II 4 II II II II 2 " " " " less than 1 person per room. [374} Occupants should also be classified according to the density of occupation of the dwellings which they occupy, using similar categories. C-?75] 6. Classification of dwellings according to the number of households in occupation.—Dwellings in each of the size categories II § 1 B should be classified according to the number of households in occupation. [376} 7. Definition of rent.—The term "rent" should be taken as signifying only those charges which strictly relate to the letting of the premises, including any charges which may be made for the services of caretaker, etc., where such charges are not included in the net rent. All additional charges for lighting and heating the dwelling should, on the other hand, be systematically excluded. Rates and taxes payable by the tenant should be given separately. In cases where it is not found possible to observe these distinctions, indications should be given which would show the margin of error involved. [377} When a dwelling is occupied bv two or more households, each household paying rent directly to the landlord, the total of any rents so paid should be recorded. Rents paid for furnished apartments and rooms, and rents paid for portions of dwellings which are sub-let should be separately recorded. £37<?J 8. Classification of dwellings according to the amount of rent paid.—Dwellings which are rented by family households should be classified according to the amount of rent paid, making use of a certain number of groups (between 10 and 20) which should be drawn up in accordance with a uniform plan in each country, having regard to prevailing conditions. This classification should be combined with a classification of dwellings according to their size in the categories suggested in II 1 B. \_379~] The number of occupants of dwellings should also be classified in a double classification, according to the amount of rent paid and to the size of the dwelling occupied, making use of the same categories. [380} 9. Distinction between dwellings subject and not subject to rent restrictions.—In countries where the restrictions as to the amount of rent which may be charged for dwellings, imposed during, and immediately after, the war are still in force, or still exert a marked influence on the level of rents, it is important that in the HOUSING STATISTICS 127 classification of dwellings, as also in the classification of occupants, a distinction should be made between dwellings which are subject to and those exempt from these restrictions. III. PERIODICAL STATISTICS RELATING TO VARIATIONS IN THE TOTAL NUMBER OP EXISTING DWELLINGS [381} Particulars of the variations in the total number of dwellings should be regularly obtained, based on information supplied by the public authorities responsible for the supervision of new buildings (registration of completed works; inspection of completed works in order to ascertain whether they comply with the approved plans; issue of habitation permits). [382} The following particulars should be obtained at intervals not exceeding one year: [383} (a) The number of habitable buildings erected (distinguishing those erected to replace buildings demolished) ; the number of such buildings structurally altered (by enlargement, by the superposition of another storey and by interior alterations) ; the number of such buildings demolished or destroyed. [384} (b) The number of dwellings erected; the number of new dwellings brought into existence as a result of structural alterations; the number of dwellings ceasing to exist as a result of structural alterations; the number of dwellings demolished or destroyed. In each case the dwellings should be classified according to their size. [385} It is also desirable to denote, in the case of buildings erected, dwellings erected and dwellings brought into existence as a result of structural alterations, whether the works have been undertaken by (a) public authorities, (b) institutions of public utility, or (c) private enterprise. IV. PERIODICAL STATISTICS OF VACANT DWELLINGS [386} It is desirable to obtain annual returns of vacant dwellings, i.e. habitable dwellings which are unoccupied and immediately available for occupation. [387} The dwellings should be classified according to their size and in the case of dwellings intended for letting according to the rent to be charged. These particulars could be supplied by the Public Housing Offices in cases where the notification of vacancies is obligatory. 128 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS 30. Excerpts from Recommendations of the Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations1 HOUSING STATISTICS A. Definitions of Basic Units [_388~\ Rooms: As "rooms" should be regarded bedrooms, diningrooms, living-rooms, habitable attics, servants' rooms, kitchens and other habitable spaces, separated from one another by walls reaching from the floor to the ceiling and of a size large enough to hold a bed for an adult (approximately 4 square metres at least). \_38f\ Kitchenettes, corridors, verandas, lobbies, etc., not falling under the above definition, as well as bathrooms and toilets, should not be counted as rooms. \_39(f] Rooms regardless of size, if used only for professional or business purposes, should not be counted as parts of the dwelling and should not be taken into account for calculating the number of persons per room. [_391~\ Dwelling: The dwelling should comprise any structurally separated room or suite of rooms in permanent buildings used or intended for habitation by family households and having a separate access to a street or to a common passage or stairway. Detached rooms for habitation which are clearly intended to form a part of the dwelling should be counted as part of the dwelling. Rooms used only for business purposes should not be counted as parts of the dwelling. []JP2] The family household should comprise the members of a family forming the nucleus of the household, including resident domestic servants. Other persons sharing the rooms occupied by the family or having separate rooms in the dwelling, but taking their meals with the family, should be counted as members of the family household. [3P3] Persons living alone and lodgers occupying rooms of their own and not sharing in the meals of the family should be counted as separate family households. QJP4J It should be noted that, under the above definition, one dwelling may be occupied by several family households, and that the family household is not necessarily identical with the total number of persons living in the same dwelling. 1 LEAGUE OF N A T I O N S : Housing Statistics: A Minimum Programme of Housing Statistics draw n up by the Committee of Statistical Experts. Studies and Reports on Statistical Methods, No. 5 (Official number: C. 133. M. 85. 1939 (C.E.S. 145) Appendix I; Ser. L.O.N. Pub. 1939. I I . A. 6). HOUSING STATISTICS 129 [JP53 In the present minimum programme of housing statistics, only the family household is used as a basic unit. For reasons of precision, the Committee [gives also the definition of non-family household]. [3P(i] Non-family households should comprise all persons living in groups which are not to be considered as family households—e.g., in hotels, institutions, military barracks, etc. C?07] In doubtful cases, which may particularly arise in respect of pensions and boarding-houses, the border-line between the family household and the non-family household should be drawn at the point where the number of boarders, etc., exceeds the number of the family members, including servants, etc. [398~\ It should be noted that directors or the personnel of institutions, hotels, etc., occupying a separate dwelling should be counted as family households. [3992 Occupants: If the methods adopted for enumerating the population in the general population census enable the usual residents of a dwelling to be identified as distinct from the persons occupying the dwelling on the day of the census, only the usual residents should be counted as occupants. Each physical person, regardless of age, should be counted as one unit. B. Statistics Relating to the Characteristics of Dwellings [400] The Committee was of the opinion that the most important information bearing on the characteristics of dwellings is, from the point of view of international comparisons, that dealing with the number and size of the dwellings and the existence of certain types of amenities. [4012 The size of dwellings should be measured only by the number of rooms, as any other method requiring reference to the dimensions of the premises appears to be unsuitable for adoption in general censuses. [4022 As regards the amenities available' in a dwelling, the Committee recommends that they should be ascertained for each dwelling to which they structurally belong. There is no doubt that it would be equally important to show the amenities available for each household; the necessary basic information on this point is, however, more difficult to obtain in practice and has therefore been disregarded. [403] The Committee recommends that the total number of dwellings should be shown, subdivided by size into dwellings with one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight and more rooms in accordance with the definition of rooms given above. 130 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS \_404~] For each of the above groups, the tabular analysis should distinguish the number of dwellings possessing the following amenities: (1) Kitchenettes {i.e., kitchens not corresponding with the definition of rooms) ; (2) Bathrooms: (a) (ò) Private ; Common ; (3) Toilets: (a) (b) Private ; Common ; (4) Running-water supply: (a) (b) Inside the dwelling; Outside the dwelling; (5) Electricity supply; (6) Gas supply. [405] In many countries, the heating system, and especially central heating, is a matter of importance, but as international comparisons of this kind have less significance owing to differences in climatic conditions, the Committee did not include this topic in its programme. C. Statistics Relating to the Occupation of Dwellings and Rooms I. Occupation of Dwellings by More than One Family Household. [406] One of the main objects of housing censuses in several countries is to throw light on the occupation of dwellings by more than one family household, as this information is of importance in the determination of existing housing needs. The Committee therefore recommends that the number of dwellings occupied by: (a) (ò) (c) One family household; Two family households; Three and more family households should be given, at least separately for dwellings with one, two, three, etc., eight and more rooms. [407"] In addition to the total number of dwellings occupied by family households, the number of vacant dwellings should be given for the same room categories, and it should be exactly stated which kinds of dwellings have been included as vacant dwellings. 131 HOUSING STATISTICS II. Statistics Showing the Density of Occupation. [408"] The occupation of dwellings and rooms should be shown for international comparison on the basis of physical persons, adults and children being counted as equal units. Although information as to sex, age, marital status and the situation in the household is frequently available for all persons of the household, the Committee abstained from including such distinctions in the minimum programme. '•' '• [409] Statistics showing the density of occupation—i.e., the number of persons in relation to the number of rooms—are computed in different ways in various countries. They are generally based on one of the following methods: [410] (a) By reference to the dwellings as the unit, the total number of persons being related to the total number of rooms in the dwelling. [411] (ò) By reference to the household as the unit, the number of persons in a family being related to the number of rooms occupied by that family. [412] In those cases—the great majority—in which a dwelling is occupied by one household, the two methods yield the same result. In cases where more than one household occupies a dwelling, the Committee recommends that the second method be adopted, in view of the fact that the number of persons per room may vary considerably for each of the households in the same dwelling. It is understood that the kitchen, or any other room, if shared by more than one household, should be allocated to the main household in the dwelling. .. [413] The Committee recommends that the tabulation displaying family households in relation to the rooms they occupy should be in the following form: NUMBER OF FAMILY HOUSEHOLDS OF DIFFERENT SIZES OCCUPYING DIFFERENT NUMBERS OF ROOMS Number of persons per family household^ One Three etc. Ten and m o r e . . . . Total number of family households Number of family households occupying the following number of rooms 1 2 3 4 S 6 7 8 9 Total number of 10 family and housemore holds 132 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS [414} The Committee has adopted this form of presentation as it permits of calculating the total number of persons associated with each room category and the total number of rooms associated with each size of family household. At the same time, the several items can be aggregated in any desired density group, in terms either of persons per room or rooms per person; an arrangement which facilitates the application of varying national crowding or overcrowding standards. D. Other Statistics Relating to Households and Dwellings [4152 The Committee has considered various other statistics which are frequently obtained from national housing censuses, without making recommendations in respect of them for its first minimum programme. [4162 If the housing census is undertaken in connection with a census of population in which occupations are recorded, the necessary basic data for a classification of households by the occupation of the head of the household are available. The Committee is aware that such a grouping is sometimes undertaken as a means of throwing light on the housing conditions of various social groups, and emphasises the importance of such grouping. At this stage, however, the Committee does not suggest a uniform classification for that purpose. The classifications prepared by the Committee of Statistical Experts for the purpose of grouping the gainfullyoccupied population will offer certain groups which might be useful also for the purpose of housing censuses. [4172 Statistics of rents, although of importance for statistics of housing conditions, have been excluded from consideration, owing to the difficulty of defining what is included in rents in different countries and the difficulty of obtaining such information by means of a general housing census. In this connection, the SubCommittee draws attention to the compilation of rents on a uniform basis for certain selected types of dwellings which is being undertaken by the International Labour Office and its Committee of Statistical Experts. 1 [418] Statistics of the tenure of dwellings are generally required if statistics of rents are prepared. They are, however, also of considerable importance for other national purposes, especially in relation to differences between urban and rural districts and the changes in the various forms of tenure. The definitions and classi1 See " R e n t s of Workers' Dwellings in Various Towns, 1936-37", International Labour Review, Vol. X X X V I I I , No. 6, Dec. 1938; also Robert G U Y E : "A Further Contribution to the International Comparison of Rents", International Labour Review, Vol. X X X I V , No. 5, Nov. 1936. HOUSING STATISTICS 133 fications needed depend largely on legal practice and national customs; they have therefore not been included in the minimum programme. [419] Statistics of family income and their combination with housing statistics are also of great interest. As, however, only a very small number of countries compile such statistics, it was impossible to include them in the minimum programme. E. Geographical Scope of General Housing Censuses [4202 In accordance with its terms of reference, the recommendations of the Committee apply to both urban and rural housing. Rural housing conditions, however, differ substantially in certain respects from urban conditions, and in view of the particular interest which, in many countries, attaches to the problem of rural housing and of the special aspects of that problem 1 , the Committee devoted particular attention to the information on this subject which can be readily obtained on the occasion of a population census. The Committee did. not consider it necessary to define the border-line between urban and rural districts, as the validity of the comparisons which can be made from the statistics drawn up in accordance with the minimum programme is hardly affected by the different solutions of the problem. Note: In the report of the Committee of Statistical Experts the section here given under E precedes the other sections. In addition to the quotations given here the report contains a section devoted to statistics of buildings; it includes also a general statement on the reasons for its recommendations; the personnel of the Committee and its advisers are given on p. 5 of the report. 1 See, for example, the studies on rural housing being made by the Health Organisation of the League and its Conferences on rural hygiene. IX STATISTICS OF COLLECTIVE AGREEMENTS 31. Resolutions of the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1926 \_42l} In each country information concerning collective agreements and their principal contents should be collected and published in a summary form at appropriate intervals. [4222 It is desirable that any statistics compiled on the basis of this information should be compiled in accordance with the following general principles: {42f\ (1) The collective agreement should be defined, for the purposes of the statistics, as a written agreement concluded between one or more employers or an employers' organisation on the one hand, and one or more workers' organisations of any kind on the other, with a view to determining the conditions of individual employment, and in certain cases to the regulation of other questions relative to employment. [424~] (2) The number of collective agreements should be recorded at annual intervals according to the following scheme: (a) number of agreements in force at the beginning of the period of registration; (b) number of agreements concluded during the period of registration ; (c) number of agreements expired within the period of registration ; (d) number of agreements in force at the end of the period of registration. [_425~] (3) The importance of each collective agreement should be measured by ascertaining the numerical strength of the contracting parties, i.e. the number of establishments covered, the total number of workers employed in these establishments, and the number of workers covered by each agreement. STATISTICS OE COLLECTIVE AGREEMENTS 135 [4262 The extent to which workers are covered by collective agreements should be indicated by calculating the number of workers covered by agreements as a percentage of the total number of workers in the various industries. [4272 (4) The collective agreements, together with the number of establishments and of workers covered, should be classified according to their principal legal and social characteristics on the following lines: [4282 A. Nature of Contracting Parties. The agreements should be classified according to the nature of the contracting parties as follows: (a) agreements concluded between an employer and his workers ; (6) agreements concluded between one or more employers, and one or more workers' organisations; (c) agreements concluded between employers' organisations and workers' organisations. [4292 B. Scope of Application. The agreements should be classified according to the extent of the area in which they are applicable, as follows: (a) shop agreements: i.e. agreements applicable to a single establishment; (b) local agreements: i.e. agreements applicable to several or all establishments of similar kind situated in the same locality; (c) district agreements: i.e. agreements applicable to several or all establishments of similar kind situated in several or all localities belonging to a district forming an economic or an administrative unit; (d) national agreements: i.e. agreements applicable to several or all establishments of similar kind in several districts or in the country as a whole. [43Ö2 C. Subjects Regulated. The agreements should be classified in the following two principal groups: (a) agreements regulating individual conditions of employment only; (6) agreements regulating—in addition to individual conditions of employment—general matters relative to employment. In group (b) the number of agreements providing for special procedure for the enforcement of the agreement may be shown separately. 136 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS {431} The statistics should also indicate the number of agreements which regulate each subject of importance, e.g. wages, hours of work, holidays, conditions of apprenticeship, labour exchanges, works councils, conciliation and arbitration. {432} D. Duration of Validity. The agreements should be classified according to the period for which they are concluded, as follows : (a) (Ò) (c) (d) (e) (/) (g) 3 months or less; 3 to 6 months; 6 months to one year; 1 to 2 years; 2 to 3 years; more than 3 years; indefinite period. {433} E. Method of Conclusion. The agreements should be classified according to the method of the conclusion of the agreement and according to the method of negotiation, as follows: (a) Collective agreements concluded as a consequence of an industrial dispute: (i) (ii) by direct negotiations, through the intervention of a third party; (6) Collective agreements concluded as a consequence of peaceful discussion: (i) (ii) by direct negotiations, through the intervention of a third party. {434} F. Industries Covered. The agreements should be classified according to the principal industrial groups. The classification may be left to the domain of national statistics. {435} G. Industrial Importance. The agreements should be classified according to their industrial importance, as defined under (3). {436"] (a) Classification of agreements by the number of establishments covered : (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) agreements covering one establishment, " " 2 to 20 establishments, " " 21 to 100 establishments, " " more than 100 establishments. [437"} (6) Classification of agreements according to the number of workers covered: STATISTICS OP COLLECTIVE AGREEMENTS 137 (i) agreements covering less than 100 workers, (ii) " " 100 to 1,000 workers, (iii) " " 1,001 to 10,000 workers, (iv) " " 10,001 to 100,000 workers, (v) " " more than 100,000 workers. [438] A distinction should also be made between workers who are members of the organisation which is a party to the agreement and other workers to whom the agreement applies in practice. X STATISTICS OF INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES 32. Resolutions of the Third International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Geneva, October 1926 [439] In each country statistics of industrial disputes should be compiled according to the following general principles: \j440] (1) The basic unit—the case of dispute—should be defined as a temporary stoppage of work wilfully effected by a group of workers or by one or more employers with a view to enforcing a demand. Disputes affecting several establishments should be considered as one case if they are organised or directed by one person or organisation. [44f\ It is desirable to make, as far as possible, a distinction between strikes and lockouts. \_442~\ (2) The statistics should relate to disputes beginning in the period under review, and also, but separately, to those continuing from the previous period. The total of these two groups of disputes represents the number of disputes in existence during the period under review. \_443~\ (3) The importance of the dispute should be measured by ascertaining the number of establishments and of workers affected by the dispute, the duration of the dispute, and the number of man-days lost on account of the dispute. [444] The number of establishments affected should be based on the technical unit as defined in censuses of industries. [445"2 The number of workers affected should be based on the vacancies caused in the establishments affected by the dispute, and calculated by taking an average of the number of vacancies each day during which the dispute lasted, or, where this is not practicable, by taking an average of the number of vacancies recorded at weekly intervals. \jf4<f\ The duration of the dispute should be expressed as the number of working days from the date on which the dispute began in the first establishment affected to the date on which it terminated in the last one. \J44f] The number of man-days lost should be based on the STATISTICS OF INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES 139 number of vacancies caused by the dispute during each day of the dispute, or, where this is not practicable, by multiplying the number of days for which the dispute lasted by the average number of vacancies recorded at weekly intervals. [448'] (4) The disputes, together with the number of establishments and workers affected, the duration of disputes, and the number of man-days lost, should be classified according to their principal characteristics, namely: [449] A. The Matter in Dispute. The principal criterion should be the relation of the dispute to collective bargaining as follows: (a) Disputes related to collective bargaining: (i) concerning trade unionism or refusal to conclude a collective agreement; (ii) concerning conditions of employment: (1) (2) (3) (4) (b) wages, hours of labour, engagement or dismissal of workers, others. Disputes not related to collective bargaining: (i) (ii) (iii) sympathetic disputes; political disputes; others. \^450] Groups (a) (ii) may also be classified into disputes concerning general terms of future employment, and disputes concerning the interpretation of existing terms of employment. [451] B. The Result of the Disputes. Disputes should be classified according to their general result from the point of view of workers involved, as follows: (a) disputes where the workers' demands have been entirely accepted ; (ò) disputes where the workers' demands have been partially accepted ; (c) disputes where the workers' demands have been rejected ; (d) disputes where the employers' demands have been entirely accepted; (e) disputes where the employers' demands have been partially accepted; (J) disputes where the employers' demands have been rejected; (g) disputes with indeterminate or unknown result. 140 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS [452] C. The Method of Settlement of the Disputes. Disputes should be classified according to the method of their settlement on the following lines: (a) disputes settled by direct negotiations between the two parties; (ò) disputes settled by the medium of a third party: (i) through voluntary conciliation accepted by the parties to the dispute, (ii) through compulsory conciliation imposed by the law, (iii) through voluntary arbitration, (iv) through compulsory arbitration; (c) Disputes terminated without successful negotiations. [453] D. The Industries Affected. Disputes should be classified according to the principal industrial groups. The classification may be left to the domain of national statistics. [454] E. The Extent of the Disputes. Disputes should be classified according to the number of establishments affected as follows : (a) (6) (c) (d) {e) disputes affecting one establishment, " " 2 to 10 establishments, " " 11 to 20 establishments, " " 21 to 100 establishments, " " more than 100 establishments. [455] F. The Importance of Disputes. Disputes should be classified according to their importance, taking as criteria the number of workers affected, the duration of the disputes, and the number of man-days lost. [456] (a) The classification of^disputes by the number of workers affected should be as follows: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) disputes affecting less than 10 workers, " " 10 to 100 workers, " " 101 to 1,000 workers, " " 1,001 to 10,000 workers, " " 10,001 to 100,000 workers, " " over 100,000 workers. STATISTICS OF INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES 141 [457} (b) The classification of disputes by their duration should be as follows: (i) GO (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) disputes lasting less than 2 working days, from 2 to 10 working days, 11 to 50 working days, u << 51 to 100 working days, 101 to 300 working days, over 300 working days. t( If ii tt 11 If tt if tt tt It tt [458} (c) Disputes should be classified by the number of man-days lost as follows: CO (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) disputes involving the loss of less than 20 man-days, a of 20 to 1,000 man-days, tt tt tt of 1,001 to 50,000 man-days, tt tt tt of 50,001 to 1,000,000 mandays, tt tt a of 1,000,001 to 30,000,000 mandays, tt tt of over 30,000,000 man-days. it ft it it «f II it if [459} G. Amount of Wages Lost. The wage loss caused by each dispute may be estimated by multiplying the number of mandays lost by the average daily wages of the workers affected. The classification of disputes according to the amount of wages lost may be left to the domain of national statistics. [460} (5) For the purpose of comparing the risk of industrial disputes between different industries and countries, frequency and severity rates of disputes should be calculated. • [461} The exposure to risk should be expressed in terms of the number of full-time workers, obtained by dividing the total number of days worked during the period by the total number of normal working days in the same period. [462} The frequency rate should show the number of disputes 142 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS per 100,000 full-time workers. The severity rate should show the number of man-days lost per 10,000 full-time workers. {463} (6) The above-mentioned data should be published at least yearly. It is desirable, however, that preliminary figures dealing more particularly with the number of disputes should be published monthly. XI STATISTICS OF MIGRATION 33. Resolutions of the International Conference of Migration Statisticians, Geneva, 3-7 October 1932 I [464] The Conference considers that in view of the fact that migration statistics in general are, from the international point of view, still in a very imperfect state, efforts should be made in the various countries to arrive gradually at the following desiderata: [465'] 1. In principle, every act of removal from one country to another for a certain length of time should be included in the statistics of migration, with the exception of tourist traffic. [466] 2. When the removal is for one year or more the migration should be regarded as permanent migration. [467] 3. When the removal is for less than a year the migration should be regarded as temporary, frontier traffic being excluded. [468] 4. It is desirable to distinguish statistics of permanent migration from those of temporary migration. When the distinction cannot be made on the basis of definite information it should be made by presumption. [469] 5. When it is possible to distinguish between temporary migration according to its duration it is desirable that this should be done. [470] 6. Seasonal migration should be included in the statistics of temporary migration. It is desirable that it should also be shown in separate tables. [471] 7. It is desirable that each country should compile statistics of emigration and statistics of immigration. Both should, if possible, include nationals as well as aliens. [472] 8. I t is desirable that countries of transit should, if possible, draw up separate statistics of transmigrants. [473] 9. Although migration movements between territories situated in different continents but coming under the same sover- 144 INTERNATIONA!, STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS eignty are from the legal point of view of an internal character, it is nevertheless desirable that they should be given in the statistics, by way of addition, side by side with international migration movements. [474] 10. It is desirable that each country should state as precisely as possible the definitions on which its statistics are based, so that the International Labour Office may be able to indicate to what extent its definitions differ from those recommended by the Conference. [475] 11. In cases where national methods are not such as to make it possible to realise the desiderata stated above, certain omissions might be remedied by collaboration between the statistical services of two or more different countries. II [476] The methods by which migration statistics are compiled in different countries depend on the regulations to which migrants are subject. These methods accordingly vary very considerably from one country to another. [477] The Conference notes that none of the methods are entirely satisfactory or make it possible to observe the phenomenon of migration completely in all its aspects. The Conference does not think it desirable to make a choice between these various methods and to recommend one rather than another. Some, however, are clearly inadequate and should only be regarded as substitutes to which recourse is had in the absence of anything better. These include the statistics of information offices for emigrants, statistics of passport visas, statistics of steamship passenger contracts, statistics of the recruiting and placing of migrant workers, and statistics of employment permits issued to foreign workers. The same applies in a less degree to passport statistics, which were of a certain importance some years ago but which are now not so much used. [478] The Conference gave its attention in particular to port statistics, statistics of declarations of residence, statistics of frontier control, anc statistics of coupons detached from certain documents, and makes the following observations on these classes of statistics. A.—Port Statistics [479] 1. In order to make it possible to collect migration statistics, it is necessary that the passenger lists of seagoing vessels should mention the reason why each passenger makes the journey or whether or not he is a migrant. STATISTICS OF MIGRATION 145 [480] 2. Shipping companies or the master of the ship should be required to supply the competent statistical authorities with a copy of the passenger lists. [481'} 3. Before landing the master should prepare lists of immigrants in the forms prescribed by the countries of immigration. B.—Statistics of Declarations of Residence [482~] 1. In countries which record the changes of residence of their inhabitants, the declarations which are required to be made on this subject and which are recorded by the local authorities make it possible to establish statistics of migration, particularly of permanent migration. [483"] 2. It would be desirable that measures should be taken if possible to make a distinction under this system between temporary and permanent migration. C.—Statistics of Frontier Control [484~\ In those countries where a developed system for the control and supervision of passenger traffic by ports or across frontiers is in existence, migration statistics may be based on the returns obtained from the authorities responsible for this supervision. [485] It is desirable that in the case of migrants individual questionnaires stating the reason for the journey should be filled up. D.—Statistics of Coupons Detachable from Certain Documents [486] 1. In the case of countries whose nationals are required to present special documents when crossing the frontier, such documents may serve as a basis for migration statistics. [487] 2. Such documents should be issued to all migrants, if possible free of charge, and contain detachable coupons. The coupons, duly filled up, should be detached when the migrants leave or enter the country. Nationals of the country of emigration residing in a foreign country should be able to obtain such documents from the consular authorities. [488] 3. A distinction should be made between permanent and temporary migration either when these documents are issued or when the coupons are detached. Ill [489] The Conference also discussed the possibility of establishing a uniform international system. I t makes the following observations on this point. 146 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS [4902 1. With a view to obtaining complete and uniform statistics of international migration, it would be desirable that all countries should employ the same system based on the issue of an identical individual document. [4912 2. The realisation of such a system would obviously involve serious difficulties and could not be effected immediately. Further study appears necessary and the Conference suggests scientific collaboration between the competent departments of the International Labour Office and those of the International Statistical Institute, which has made proposals on this subject. IV £492^ With a view to the classification of the statistical data, it is desirable that so far as possible information should be supplied by the various countries in such a way that the international tables can include the following subdivisions: [4932 1. Distinction between continental and inter-continental migration. For this purpose it is desirable that emigrants should be classified as completely as possible according to the country of destination and immigrants according to the country from which they originally started. This distinction might be based in principle on the geographical list of countries adopted by the Statistical Year-Book of the League of Nations in the table "Area and population". [4942 2. Distinction between nationals and aliens. 1 [4952 3. As an additional or subsidiary distinction to that given above, a distinction may be made according to language, ethnic origin or the country of birth of the migrant. [4962 4. Distinction according to sex and by quinquennial age groups (under five, five to under ten, etc.). [4972 5. It is also desirable that migrants should be classified according to industrial or occupational groups. [4982 It is suggested that this classification should be made only in the case of migrants of over fifteen years of age and that the following groups should be adopted, a distinction being made between the sexes: I. II. III. IV. V. Agriculture. Mines and quarries. Manufacturing industries. Transport and communications. Other industries. 1 One member of the Conference asked that naturalised persons should be distinguished from other nationals. STATISTICS OP MIGRATION VI. VII. VIII. IX. 147 Commerce and finance. Domestic and personal service. Liberal professions. Persons without occupation or of unknown occupation. [_499~\ I t might also be desirable to include children under fifteen in this classification under a separate heading, especially in those cases where such information cannot be derived from the classification mentioned in point 4. [500} 6. I t is desirable that migrants should also be classified according to their industrial or social status: (a) Independent persons (employers and persons working on their own account). (£>) Employed persons. (c) {d) (1) (2) (3) Others. Members Directors, managers, etc. Manual workers. Salaried employees. of the migrant's family without occupation. [501} It is also desirable that this classification should be combined with the classification mentioned under 5, in order to show so far as possible the status of migrants in the various occupational groups. [,502} 7. It would be desirable that an attempt should be made to distinguish the following classes among migrants, a distinction being also made according to sex: (a) Married, widowed or divorced, unmarried. (6) Persons emigrating alone, persons emigrating with their families. [503} The following distinctions might also be made for certain countries specially concerned: [504} (c) Persons travelling at their own expense, persons travelling with financial assistance of private individuals, persons travelling with financial assistance of public authorities or private institutions. £505} (d) Persons possessing or not possessing a contract of employment. [506} (e) Persons able or unable to write (it being understood that any language may be used and that the distinction should only apply to migrants aged ten years or more). 148 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS rj5073 8. In the case of internal migration between territories coming under the same sovereignty but situated in different continents, it is desirable to make a distinction according to the continent of origin of the migrant. [50c?] 9. The statistics should be established periodically, not less than once a year and, if possible, for the calendar year. In countries where some other period is used, it would be desirable from the international point of view also to follow the calendar year, or some shorter period which makes it possible to arrive at the calendar year, and to make the geographical distribution mentioned above (point 1). APPENDIX K E Y TO T O P I C S C O N S I D E R E D AT E A C H CONFERENCE OF LABOUR International Labour INTERNATIONAL STATISTICIANS Organisation. F i r s t I n t e r n a t i o n a l Conference of L a b o u r Statisticians ( I n t e r n a t i o n a l Conference on L a b o u r Statistics), G e n e v a , October 1923. A. Classification of Industries and Occupations B. Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work C. Statistics of Industrial Accidents 49 70 119 Second I n t e r n a t i o n a l Conference of L a b o u r G e n e v a , April 1925. A. Cost-of-Living Index Numbers B. Unemployment Statistics C. International Comparisons of Real Wages D. Classification of Industries Statisticians, 98 67 101 SO T h i r d I n t e r n a t i o n a l Conference of L a b o u r G e n e v a , October 1926. A. Methods of Family Budget Enquiries B. Statistics of Collective Agreements C. Statistics of Industrial Disputes D. Classification of Industries Statisticians, F o u r t h I n t e r n a t i o n a l Conference of L a b o u r G e n e v a , M a y 1931. International Comparisons of Real Wages Statisticians, 116 134 138 SO Fifth I n t e r n a t i o n a l Conference of L a b o u r Statisticians, G e n e v a , Sept.-Oct. 1937. Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of W o r k . . . . (The text given is that of the Convention adopted at the 24th Session of the International Labour Conference, June 1938.) Proposed Recommendation 104 85 95 I.L.O. C o m m i t t e e of Statistical E x p e r t s . F i r s t Session, 12-15 D e c e m b e r 1933. International Comparisons of Food Costs International Comparisons of Rents Family Budgets Elements of Remuneration other than Wage6 109 Ill 118 107 150 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS Second Session, 16-18 December 1935. International Comparisons of Rents 112 Third Session, 3—7 October 1937. International Comparisons of Rents 114 24th Session of the International Labour Conference, June 1938. Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work, 1938 Proposals calling for further action 85 96 L e a g u e of Nations. League of Nations Committee of Statistical Experts. Excerpts from Report on Statistics of the Gainfully Occupied Population Excerpts from Report on Statistics of Housing 52 128 International Conference relating to Economic Statistics convened by the League of Nations. Extract from International Convention relating to Economic Statistics, 14 Dec. 1928 Recommendation relating to Index Numbers 100 100 Other International Conferences. International Conferences of Statisticians, convoked by the Social Science Research Council of the United States of America. First International Conference, January 1929. Index Numbers of Wages International Comparisons of Wages 71 101 Second International Conference, May 1930. Index Numbers of Wages International Comparisons of Cost of Living 83 108 Committee of Statistical Experts convoked by the International Union of Towns, May 1928. Housing Statistics 122 International Conference on Migration Statistics, October 1932. Statistics of Migration 143 INDEX INDEX Accident insurance, notes for industrial accident statistics, 348 Accidents: see Industrial accidents Adult male unit: see also Consumption unit and Average size of family earnings per family, 118 Age classification: gainfully occupied, 11 ; 68-70, 72 migrants, 496, 498-499, 506 Agricultural workers: ' family living studies, 32 and wage index numbers, 112 Agriculture: see also Economic Activity, Gainfully occupied, List of industries wages, 18; convention, 200-202 Allowances: see also Family allowances, Remuneration agriculture, 26; convention, 201 in kind, 25, 26; convention, 172 special, taken into account in earnings, 129 supplementary to wages, 287-290 and wage rates, convention, 194-195 Amenities, of dwelling: see Conveniences, Housing, Standard dwelling units Base period for index numbers: see also Index numbers Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N., 252 cost of living, 23; uniform, 247, 252 economic series, International Convention relating to Economic Statistics, 252 International Institute of Statistics, 252 I.L.O., 252 wage index, 119: same as for index of production, 146 uniform for all countries, 120 ^ Î P ! Bathrooms: see also Conveniences, Housing, Rooms, Standard dwelling units, 315 classification of dwellings, 30; 366, 404 and definition of room, 359, 389 Benefits, total paid in year, 75 Branches of economic activity: see Economic activity British Ministry of Labour: see Great Britain, Ministry of Labour Buildings: see also Housing censuses, Dwellings habitable: classification, 367-369 definition, 356 yearly data needed, 382-383 new, statistics, 381-385 Cause, classification of industrial accidents, 341 Censuses: see also Housing census gainfully occupied, 11, 14; 10-12 production, and wage date, 145 unemployment, 12-13; 81; needed, 23; by sex, 82 wages, 19; 91 Chain method, wage indices, 116 Child labour: see Age classification, Employment, Young persons Classification of industries and occupations: see also Industries, List of industries Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N., 10; 10-73; occupations, 9-11 International Conferences of Labour Statisticians, 9; 1-8 Climate, and international comparisons of real wages, 254 Coal mining: industrial accidents, report, 33-34 report of Committee of Experts in Safety in Coal Mines, 34 wages, 18, 26; in general index, 156 Coats, R. H., 10 Collective agreements: 37; 421-438 agenda of Third Conference of Labour Statisticians, 3 classification: duration, 432 industrial importance, 435-437 industries, 434 method of conclusion, 433 nature of contracting parties, 428 scope of application, 429, 438 subjects, 430, 431 definition, 423 frequency of compilation, 424 importance, 425-426 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. 154 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Collective agreements (cant.): International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Third, 37; 421-438 statistics, report on methods, 37 Collective bargaining, industrial disputes, 449 Committee o:: Experts in Housing Statistics: see International Union of Towns Committee of Experts in Safety in Coal Mining, Report, 34 Committee of Statistical Experts of I.L.O.: see also Appendix, p. 151; 6 appointment, 2, 4 duties, 2, 4 functions, 286 meetings, agenda, 5 recommendations : cost of living, 27 family living studies, 338 food costs, comparisons, 29; 298309 real wages, comparisons, 24 remuneration, other than wages, 26; 287-290 rents, 30; 310-325 recommended, Fourth Conference, 286 wages, convention, 16 Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations: see also Appendix, p. 151; 1,4, 10 age classification of gainfully occupied, 11 base period: economic statistics, 23 index numbers, 252 gainfully occupied, 14; 10-73 housing statistics, report, 35; 388420 housing studies, mentioned, 325 Commodities, minimum list for international trade statistics, 57 Conferences of American States Members of the I.L.O.: Havana, 1940, 7 Santiago de Chile, 1936, 7 Conferences of Labour Statisticians: see International Conference of Labour Statisticians Conferences of Statisticians called by the Social Science Research Council: see Social Science Research Council Conferences on Rural Hygiene of the Health Organisation of the League of Nations, 133 Consumption: see also Cost of living, Family living studies, Retail prices; aggregate, use of weights for cost of living, index numbers, 242 Consumption {coni.): family budget enquiries, use in cost of living indices, 241 habits, comparable, regional groups, 302; and international comparisons, 280-282 industrial workers, in cost of living index, 238 theoretical budgets, in index numbers, 243 working class, retail prices, 93 Consumption unit: average size of family, earnings per family, 118 family living studies, 334 Consumption unit scales: food, 334 general, 334 Contract of employment, and migration, 505 Conveniencies: see also Housing, Standard dwelling units in dwelling, 366, 402, 404-405 in standard dwelling unit, 30 Convention concerning Statistics of Wages and Hours of Work: see also Hours of Work, Wages, 2, 5, 16-17, 20, 21, 26; 163-218 on agenda, Fifth Conference of Labour Statisticians, 3 authentic texts, 218 declaration, excluding parts, 165 denunciation, 213-214, 216 exclusion of certain areas, by Members ratifying, 203-205 in force, 209-211, 213-214, 216-217 obligations assumed, 164 proposals for improving statistics, 206-207 ratifications, 208 recommended by Fourth Conference of Labour Statisticians, 285 reports t o I.L.O., 164, 191, 204 reservations, 166-167 resolution of Havana Conference, 1940, 7 revision, 215-217 Convention relating to Economic Statistics (of the League of Nations), 1,4, 10: cost of living, 249-251 index number, base period, 252 Cost of labour, subjective, rejected as basis for index numbers, 104 Cost of living: see also Index numbers, International comparisons, Retail prices agenda, 2nd Conference of Labour Statisticians, 2 elements, 235 index numbers: and direct taxes, 237 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; Dther references are to page numbers. INDEX Cost of living (cont.): index numbers (cont.) frequency, 245, 249 groups, separate, 236 methods, report, I.L.O., 22 national, by combining and weighting separate indices, 240 national, industrial workers, 238 principles, etc., stated, 248 reference to sources, and methods, 251 separate for classes and areas with marked differences in economic conditions, 238, 239 towns covered, 250 use in index of real wages, 103 weights: aggregate consumption, 242 based on consumption of class or area, 238-239 for combining groups, 236 familv living studies, 241, 336, 337 use of theoretical budgets, 243 international comparisons: agenda of International Labour Conference, 285 Committee of Statistical Experts, I.L.O., 27; 298-325 Detroit and 14 European towns, 28-29 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Fourth, 27* 272-286 methods, 280-284, 293-297 Social Science Research Council, Conferences, 27; 291-297 International Conferences of Labour Statisticians, 22-23, 27; 235-248, 272-286 related to actual earnings, 20 representative items, 235 statistics, 22-25, 27-30: and Committee of Statistical Experts (I.L.O.), 286 expanding scope, 41-45 Countries, list, Statistical Year Book of League of Nations, in classifying migrants, 493 Country of birth: see also Migration, migrants, 495 Country of destination : see also Migration, migrants, 493 Country of origin: see also Migration, migrants, 493 Density of occupancy: see also Dwellings, Housing classification, 370-374, 408-414 definitions, 372, 408, 414 Detroit, U.S.A., comparison of cost of living in, and 14 European towns, 28-29 155 Dietary surveys, report, 32 Disability, industrial accidents, classification, 342-345 Dwellings: see also Buildings, Density of occupancy, Housing, Housing census, Rents classification, 363-366, 371, 375, 378, 400-418: conveniences, 404 number of households occupying, 375 purpose, 364 recommended, Committee of Stat. Exp. I.L.O., 314-315 rent paid, 378 size, 365 by size and number of occupants, 371 conveniences, 30; 366, 402, 404-405 definition, 323, 324, 354-355, 391 density of occupancy, 370-374, 408414 number, in classification of habitable buildings, 368-369 occupation by family households, classification, 375, 394, 406 and rent restrictions, 380 size, 315: classification of dwelling, 365, 371, 403 in classification of occupants, 369370 density of occupancy, 370-374, 410-414 in housing censuses, 401 vacant dwellings, 387 standard units, 273, 314-315, 322 statistics, 35-36 tenure, housing census, 418 vacant, 386; classification and definition, 387, 407 variations in total number, 381-385 working class, predominant types, 312-313, 316; rents, 320 Earnings: see also Income, Index numbers, International comparisons, Salaries, Wage rates, Wages actual, 89: in economic forecasting, 122 index numbers, 19; 118 industries, 89 representative employers, 89 typical categories of workers, 92 annual, industries, mining and manufacturing, and other branches, 226: by industries, mining and manufacturing, 233 measuring changes in standard of living, 108 definition, convention, 171, 174; uniformity needed,257 distribution, 224 ; occupations in each industry, 230 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. 156 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS Earnings (cont.): per family: index numbers, 118 and international comparisons of real wages, 254 per family member, index number, 118 frequency of compilation, convention, 176-177, 179, 223 per hour: comparable character of work and efficiency, 128-137 categories of workers, 130-131 choice of data, 128-129 frequency, 133 industries covered, 130-131 localities, 132 hourly, 161 index numbers, 90, 179 industries, 89; mining and manufacturing, convention, 168-170, 176-178 normal, typical categories of workers, 92 occupations in each industry, 223, 229 overtime, 128-129 from payrolls, in wage census, 91 piece work, typical categories of workers, 92 sex, 177; and age groups, 224 statement, annual, by I.L.O., on defects in information, 258 per time unit, for international comparison, 268 for transport, commerce, administration, recommended, 220 and wage data, special enquiries t o show differences, 257 and wage rates, 234: comparisons, 270 divergencies, 159 both needed, 159, 256 representative of, 109 weekly, 161 per worker, index numbers, 118 young persons, convention, 177 Economic activity, branches of: see also Industry, Gainfully occupied, List of industries, Occupations in classification of gainfully occupied, 24-57: age, sex, marital condition, 68-72 industrial status, 66 occupations, 67 minimum list, 73 principles of grouping, 52-57 Economic, Financial and Transit Department of the League of Nations, 41 Economic forecasting : index numbers of wages, 102, 103, 122-127: Economic forecasting {cont.): index numbers of wages (cont.) choice of data, 122 choice of establishments, 124 choice of localities, 125 frequency of compilation, 126 industries and categories of workers, 123 Economic s t a t u s : see Industrial status Emigration: see Migration Employers: see also Gainfully occupied classification, gainfully occupied, 59, 63 Employment: see also Gainfully occupied, Hours, Unemployment agenda, 2nd Conference, Labour Statisticians, 2 and collective agreements, 426 estimate of insured workpeople, 75 full time workers, for accident rates, 353 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, 14; 80, 85 international index, 15 short-time, statistics, separate from whole-time unemployment, 85 statistics, 14-15: expanding scope, 41-45 representative employers, published periodically, 80 Employment exchanges: see also Employment, Unemployment registration of unemployed, 78 statistics, 78, 79: industries, 82 occupations, 82 sex, 82 unskilled, distinguished from others, 79 vacancies, 78 Equipment, household: see Conveniences Establishment: see also Gainfully occupied, Industries accessory branches, 42 belonging t o public authorities, classification, 48 classification: difficulties, 38-48 guiding principles, 39-48 manufacturing industries, 3 covered, collective agreements, 427, 436 definition, for classification of gainfully occupied, 30-48 divided between two or more branches of economic activity, 44-47 industrial disputes, 444, 448, 454 legal and financial organisation, concept, 36, 48 manufacturing and retail sale, 43 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers- INDEX Establishment (core/.): place of work concept, 34-35, 37-47 adopted b y Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N., 37 technique of work concept, 33 Expenditure: see also Family living studies family living studies, 330, 332, 335: grouping, 335 Exposure to risk: see also Employment, Industrial accidents, Industrial disputes for accident rates, 14; 350-353 industrial disputes, 461 Family allowances: see also Remuneration, 25, 26 convention, 194 and earnings, convention, 173 and international comparisons of real wages, 271 real wage comparisons, 279 statistics, 287-290: frequency of compilation, convention, 197 supplementing average earnings, convention, 173 Family budget studies: see Family living studies Family earnings: see Earnings, family Family household: see also Density of occupation, Dwellings, Household, Housing definition, 362: Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N., 392-395 density of occupation, 413 dwellings, 364, 406 Family income: see also Earnings, Income and housing censuses, 419 Family living studies: see also Cost of living, Dietary surveys. Housing, and names of items of income and expenditure, 27; 326-338 agenda, 3rd Conference, Labour Statisticians, 3 agricultural workers, 32 classifications, 332-334 Committee of Statistical Experts, I.L.O., 338 different districts, etc., 296 food consumption, 334-335 frequency, 326 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Third, 3 1 ; 326-337 methods, 31-32; 327-337: report, 31-32 new studies desired, 246; recommended, 291 period covered, 328, 329 quantities consumed, 299 157 Family living studies (cont.): recommended, 274 sampling methods, 327 simultaneous, recommended, 338 statistics, expanding scope, 42-43 of unemployed, 32 uniform basis, recommended, 338 weights for cost-of-living indexes, 336-337 Year Book of Labour Statistics, 32, 42-43 Farmers: see also Agricultural workers, Agriculture, Gainfully occupied, List of industries gainfully occupied, 16 Ferenczi, Imre, 40 Figuerola, José, 7 Filene, Edward A, 28 Fisher (Irving), ideal formula, 29 Floor-space: see also Rent defined, 317, 323-324 rents, 311, 317, 319, 324. Food: see also Cost of living, Dietary surveys, Family living studies, Retail prices consumption unit scale, 334 nutritive value, family living studies, 335 Food cost: international comparisons, 27-30; 298-309: Committee of Statistical Experts, I.L.O., 29; 298-309 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Fourth, 29; 272, 275, 280-284 methods, 300-309 Report, 29 Food habits, surveys, 32 Food prices: see Retail prices Ford Motor Company, Ltd., 28-29 Frequency of compilation: see also names of topics collective agreements, 424 cost of living, index numbers, 245249: and prices changes, 245 dwellings, changes, 382-385: vacant, 386-387 earnings, 86, 89, 92, 93: annual, by industries, 226-233 convention, 176-177, 179 occupations in each industry, 223, 229 per hour, 133 employment, 80 family allowances, convention, 194 family living studies, 326 holidays with pay, convention, 194 hours, 86, 89, 92, 93; salaried employees, 222 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. 158 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS Frequency of compilation (cont.): hours, actual: convention, 176, 177 occupations, 223 occupations in each industry, 229 hours, normal, convention, 187 index numbsrs, see under names of topics, e.g., Cost of living, Wages industrial accident rates, 350-351,353 industrial disputes, 463 migration statistics, 508 occupations in each industry, 223,229 overtime rates, convention, 194 real wages, 93 remuneration other than wages, 290: allocation in indexes, 117 convention, 194 rents, 275, 320; floor space, 319 retail prices, 275 salaries, 222 standard o: living (real wages), 114-117 total wages and salaries, 149; industries, 225, 231 unemployment, 75, 77, 78 wage censuses, 91 wage index: allocation for supplementary items, 117 and economic stability, 114 facility in collecting, 115 period: one month, 116 wage rates, 87, 88, 92,93; convention, 187 wages, 160: agricultura, convention, 201 in chief towns, 275 economic forecasting, 126 index numbers for economic forecasting, 126 monthly, 160 occupations, 264 transport, commerce, administration, 222 Frequency rate, industrial accidents, 350-351, 353; industrial disputes, 462 Fuel prices: see Retail prices Full time workers, for accident rates, 353; for industrial disputes, 461 Fuss, Henri, 13 Gainfully occupied: see also Unemployed, 9-11 categories for international comparisons, 13-19 census, 10-12 classification : age, 68-70, 72 branches of economic activity, 24-57, 73; and industrial status, jointly, 26: minimum list, 73 purpose, 28 principle, 28-29 Gainfully occupied {cont.): classification {cont.) industrial status, 24, 58-66 industry, 1-9, 24-57, 73 marital status, 68, 71 occupation, individual, 1, 24, 67 occupation, not attempted, 67 principles, 24 sex, 68-72 Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N., Report, 4, 11; 10-73 definition, 10-12 directors and managers, 62, 64 employers, 59, 63 exclusions, 17-19 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, 9-10; 1-8 members of families, 15 military service, and last occupation, 22 salaried employees, 62, 65 scope, expansion of statistics, 42-43 unpaid family workers, 60, 61 wage earners, 62, 65 Giusti, Ugo, 22 Great Britain, Ministry of Labour: enquiry into real wages, 253 real wage comparisons, 24,25 Group basket method, food cost comparisons, 29 Guye, R., 30, 36, 132 Habitable buildings: see also Buildings, Dwellings, Housing classification, 367-369 definition, 356 yearly data needed, 382-383 Habitable rooms: see Rooms Health Organisation of League of Nations, 6, 133 Heating: see also Cost of living, Family living studies, Rents, Retail prices classification of dwellings, 405 Holidays with pay: see also Remuneration, 25, 26; 287-290 coal mines, 27 frequency of compilation, convention, 194 and real wage comparisons, 279 Hours: see also Employment actual, 86: annual statement by I.L.O., 258 categories of workers, 92 frequency of compilation, convention, 176, 177 industries, 89 mining and manufacturing industries, convention, 168-170, 176178 occupations, 223, 229 occupations in each industry, 229 Numerical references in italic type are to the lumbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part II ; other references are to page nun jers. INDEX Hours (coni.): actual (cont.) representative employers, 89 same unit as for average earnings, convention, 175 transport, commerce, administration, 219-220 agenda at First Conference of Labour Statisticians, 2 coal mining, 18 convention, 2 1 ; 163-2IS full time, annual statement by I.L.O., 258 typical categories of workers, 92 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, 20-21 ; 86-93, 219-228 normal, 86: agriculture, convention, 202 changes, 88 classification, occupation and skill, convention, 188-190 definition, convention, 186 frequency of compilation, convention, 187 index number, convention, 197 industries, mining and manufacturing, convention, 182-199 industries, representative selection, convention, 182 occupational classification, convention, 188 occupations and industries, convention, 187 salaried employees, recommendation, 221 and standard of living, 110 time period, same as for wage rates, convention, 191 for transport, commerce administration, recommendation, 219220 types, convention, 183, 186 typical occupations, capital cities, 93 typical categories of time workers, 92 young persons, convention, 192 postal services, report, 21 statistics, 20-21: expanding scope 42-45 supplementary resolutions, outside agenda of International Labour Conference, 1938, 95 textile industry, 18 Households: see also Density of occupancy, Dwellings, Family household, Housing classification, occupation of head of household, 416 composition, family living studies, 331-332 definition, International Union of Towns, 361-362: 159 Households (cont.): definition (cont.) Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N., 392-398 family, definition, 362, 392-395 non-family, definition, 362, 396-398 occupation of dwellings, 364 occupying a dwelling, 375 Housework, and gainfully occupied, definition, 10 Housing: see also Density of occupancy, Dwellings, Habitable buildings, Housing census, Rents, Vacant dwellings accommodation, family living studies, 331 Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N., 4, 35; 388-420 International Union of Towns, Committee of Experts in Housing Statistics, 35-36; 354-387 standard units, 30; defined, 314-315: recommended, 273 revised, 322 statistics, 35-36 Conference, International Union of Towns, 1, 3 Housing census: see also Dwellings, Housing, 35-36: classifications, 416 geographical scope, 420 particulars to be covered, 320 recommendations of Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N., 388420 standardised, 325 at time of general population census, 325 Huber, Michel, 4, 5 Hudson, Manley O., 10 Identical establishments, wage indices, 116 Immigration: see Migralion Income: see also names of elements of income; definition, family living studies, 332, 335 Index numbers: see also names of topics cost of living: see also Cost of living index numbers: convention relating to economic statistics, 249-251 and direct taxes, 237 frequency of compilation, 245, 249 groups, 236 methods, report, I.L.O., 22 national, by combining separate indexes, 240 national, industrial workers, 238 principles, etc., stated, 248 references to source and methods, 251 separate for classes and areas with marked differences in economic conditions, 238, 239 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. 160 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Index numbers {coni.): cost of living {cant.) towns covered, 250 use in index of real wages, 103 and wages;, 90 weights, 236: aggregate consumption, 242 based on consumption of class or area, 238, 239 family living studies, 241, 336, 337 use of theoretical budget, 243 earnings, 19; 90: convention, 179-181 frequency of compilation, convention, 179 methods, convention, 181 earnings per hour: averages for different categories, 135 comparable character of work and efficiency, 128-137: categories of workers, 130-131 choice of date, 128-129 frequency, 133 industries covered, 130-131 localities, 132 weights, 136-137: effect of differences in different countries, 136 economic statistics, Committee of Statistical Experts, L. of N „ 252 hours, normal, convention, 197 labour cost per unit of production, 97, 98, 138-146 nominal wage rates, 90 purchasing power of wages, relative levels, 277-278 real wages, 20; 90, 92; original data to be published, 255 rents, 317, 318 wage rates, 19; convention, 196-199; methods indicated, 199 wages, 19-20: American report to Social Science Research Council, 156 base period, post-war, common t o all countries 120; same as for index of production, 146 basic data to be published, 154 changes in standard of living, 108120: categories of workers covered, 111-112 choice of districts, 113 choice of type of wage data, 108-110 frequency, 114-117 industries included, 111-112 method of compilation, 118-120 convention, 20; 179-181, 196-199 detailed indices b y sex, skill, and industry, 155 Index numbers (cont.): wages (cont.) different industries or occupations, 121 elements to be considered, 105-106 forms, 153-156 general, 155 general for international comparisons, 156 International Conferences of Labour Statisticians, 19, 20; 90-92 International Labour Review, 20 method of construction, important for international comparison, 152 notes and reservations published, 158 as percentage of national income, 102 publication of basic data, needed, 157 purposes, 94-98 separate industries and all industries, 100 skilled, 185 skilled, semi-skilled and unskilled, 100 Social Science Research Council, Conferences, 19; 94-162 source references published, 158 variable weights, for different industries, 119 and base period choice, 119 wage earners as a whole, 111-112 weights, constant, 119: problem, 100 simple or weighted average, 119 women, separate index, 162 women, whether included in general index, stated, 162 Industrial accidents: see also Industrial diseases agenda, First Conference, 2 cause classification, 341 classifications, 339-349 coal mining, report, 33-34 disability, classification, 342-345 general notes, 348 industry classification, 340 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, First, 33; 339-353 location of injury, classification, 346 nature of injury, classification, 347 railways, report, 33, 34 rates, frequency, 350-351, 353 severity, 350, 352-353 reporting, 348 statistics, 33-34: expanding scope, 42-43 methods, report, 33 report, 33-34 Industrial classification: see also Classification, Industries, List of industries, migrants, 497-499, 501 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. INDEX Industrial comparisons, accident rates, 350 Industrial diseases: see also Industrial accidents, 349 Industrial disputes, 439-463: agenda, Third Conference Labour Statisticians, 3 classification: importance: duration 457; number of man days lost, 458; number of workers affected, 456 industries affected, 453 matter in dispute, 449, 450 number of establishments affected, 454 result, 451 strikes and lockouts, 441 time of beginning, 44Z and collective agreements, 433 collective bargaining, 449 definition, 440, 442 duration, 443, 446, 457 establishments affected, 443-444, 454 frequency of compilation, 463 importance, duration, 443, 446, 457: number of establishments, 443444, 454 number of workers, 443, 445, 456 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Third, 38; 439-463 method of settlement, 452 risk, frequency and severity rates, 460-462 statistics, expanding scope, 42-43: report on methods, 38 time loss, 38 wage loss, 459 workers affected, 443, 445, 456 Industrial status: gainfully occupied, 24, 26: classification, 58-66 sex, age, marital status, 68-72 migrants, 500-501 Industries: see also Economic activity, Gainfully occupied, List of industries, Occupation classification: see also Gainfully occupied, classification, 9-11 agenda, First Conference, 2 Second Conference, 2 collaboration with League of Nations and International Statistical Institute, 8 consultations with statistical offices of different countries, 6 definitions in different countries, 5 employment exchange statistics, 82 industrial accidents, 340 industrial disputes, 453 I.L.O. report, 9 primary and secondary production, services, 1-9 scientific basis, 6 use in labour statistics, 1-8 161 Industries: {cont.): definitions, 5 list: detailed, note to, 73 minimum, 49-57, 73 provisional (I.L.O.), 4, 6, 7, 9 Institute of International Cooperation, 6 Inter-American Statistical Institute, 6 International comparisons: see also Cost of living, International indices, Rents, Wage rates, Wages and annual volume of labour statistics, 276 Committee of Statistical Experts, (I.L.O.), 2 cost of living, 24-25, 27-30; 272-286, 291-297, 298-309, 310-325: on agenda of International Labour Conferences, 285 Committee of Statistical Experts, I.L.O., 27; 298-325 I nternational Conference of Labour Statisticians, Fourth, 27; 272-286 methods, 280-284, 294-297 Social Science Research Council Conferences, 27; 291-297 earnings per time unit, 268 food costs, 27-30; 298-309: Committee of Statistical Experts, I.L.O., 29; 298-309 I nternational Conference of Labour Statisticians, Fourth 29; 272, 275, 280-284 methods, 300-309 gainfully occupied, 13-19, 70; uniform principles, 40 industrial accidents, rates needed, 350 industries, facilitated by agreed list, 4-6,8 labour cost of production, 140 occupancy of dwelling, and definition of occupant, 408 real wages, 16, 20, 24-30; 253-297: actual earnings of working class family, in relation to physiological needs, 254 agenda, Fourth Conference, Labour Statisticians, 3 British Ministry of Labour, 253 chief cities, 93 Committee of Statistical Experts, I.L.O., 24 elements, 279 and family allowances, 271 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Fourth, 266286 methods, 280-284, 293-297 sources, methods, resolutions, to be published, 254 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. 162 INTERNATIONA!, STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS International comparisons (conk): International indices: see also Food Costs, International comparisons, rents, 30; 310-325: World indices, 30 Committee of Statistical Experts food costs, 298 I.L.O., 30; 310-325 purchasing power of wages, 277-278 International Conference of Lareal wages, 25, 27; elements other bour Statisticians, Fourth, 30; than wages, 279 273, 275-277 standard units recommended, 273 International Institute of Agriculture: total wages, proportion of national represented on Committee of Statisincome, 150 tical Experts of the League of unemployment statistics, 83 Nations, 4 wage rates, 86-91; time rates and International Labour Conference, 1919 piece work basic time rates, 269 (First Session), Emigration Commiswages, 24-27: sion, 39 adult male unit in earnings per family, 118 International Labour Conference, 1922 on agenda of International Labour (Fourth Session): Conference, 285 recommendation on migration stacoal enquiry, 18 tistics, 39 Committee of Statistical Experts recommendation, unemployment of young persons, 12 (I.L.O.), 4, 24, between countries or districts, 107 International Labour Conference, 1938 per hour of work, 99 (Twenty-Fourth Session): index numbers, 156; construction Convention concerning Statistics of important, 152 Wages and Hours of Work, 3, 5, 6, International Conferences of 17; 163-218 Labour Statisticians, 24, 26; resolution referred to Member States, 253-255, 266-286 96; 229-234 occupations, 259-265 resolutions outside scope, 95 occupations, similar, 130-131 supplementary resolutions, wages occupations, variations in numand hours of work, outside agenbers of workers, 134 da, 95 Social Science Research Council, International Labour Office: see also Conferences, 24, 26; 256-265 Convention concerning Statistics of International Conference relating to Wages and Hours of Work, InterEconomic Statistics: see also Appennational Labour Organisation and dix; 4, 56; base period, 23; 249-252; passim gainful occupation, 24 base period for cost of living, agreeInternational Conference of Labour ment of Governments in collaboraStatisticians: see also Appendix for tion with I.L.O., 247 topics covered at each session, and duties, 1 names of topics, 1-4, 8, 56, 100, 108; international comparisons of real First, 2, 9, 16-17, 19-22, 24, 56; 1-5, wages, 253, 255 ; capital cities, 93 86-93, 339-353 provisional list of industries, 4, 6, Second, 2, 10, 12, 14, 22-24, 26, 74, 7,9 118; 6, 74-85, 235-248, 253-255 to receive statistics, 228 Third, 2-3, 10, 29, 31, 37-38, 118; represented on Committee of Statis7-8, 326-337, 421-438, 439-463 tical Experts of League of Nations, Fourth, 3, 4, 16, 20, 24, 26-27, 29-30, 4, 10 41, 107, 110; 266-286 statistical publications, 6 and passim Fifth, 3, 5, 16-17, 96; 219-228 unemployment statistics, methods International Conference on Migration and changes, forwarded to I.L.O., Statistics (1932), see also Appendix, 83 p. 151; 39-40; 464-508 wages, annual statement of defects, International Conferences of Statis258; d a t a for calculating forwarded ticians convoked by the Social Scito I.L.O., 191 ence Research Council: see Social I.L.O. Year Book, 18, 23: Science Research Council predecessor to Year Book of Labour International Convention relating to Statistics, 41, 44 Economic Statistics: see Convention relating to Economic Statistics International Labour Organisation: International Emigration Commission, see also International Labour Office, 39 1, 5 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. INDEX International Labour Review, 6-7: family living studies, summary, 31-32 statistics, 41, 44-45: cost of living, 22 employment, 14 food cost comparisons, 30 gainfully occupied, 11 hours of work, 21 industrial accidents, 33 industrial disputes, 38 migration, 39 rents, 30 unemployment, 13 wages, 17-18, 20, 26 International standardisation: passim techniques of I.L.O., 1-8 International Statistical Institute, 6, 56; 25: and base period for economic indices, 252 collaboration with, in classification of industries, 8 migration statistics, 491 International trade statistics, minimum list of commodities, 57 International Union of Towns, Conference on Housing Statistics: see also Housing, Appendix, 1, 3 Committee of Experts in Housing Statistics, 35-36 Juveniles: see Young persons Kitchen: see also Rooms, 366; as room, 315, 358, 388, 389 Klezl, Felix, 22, 24 Labour Camps: and definition of gainfully occupied, 10, 22 Labour cost per unit of production: index numbers, 97, 98, 138-146: aggregate earnings as basf, 143 changes, interpretation, 141 industries, 144 localities, 144 period, 145 weights, 146 as percentages of wages to total cost of production, 138-140 international comparisons, 140 price level data, necessary, 103 Labour legislation, and collective agreements, 37 ; 423, 428, 438 Labour organisations, membership, 77: statistics of employment and unemployment, occupations, 82 unemployment data, 77 workers, as percentage of total in industry or occupation, 77 Labour relations: see Collective agreements, Industrial disputes Language, of migrants, 495 163 Laspeyres, formula for index, 29 Lavatory: see Toilet, Bathroom League of Nations: see also Committee of Statistical Experts of the League of Nations, and names of organs and departments, etc. collaboration with, classification of industries, 8 organs of, collaboration with I.L.O., 6 studies on housing, mentioned, 325 Liberal professions: see also Gainfully occupied, Branches of economic activity, 25 Light: see also Retail prices, prices, 272 Lindberg, John, 13, 15 List of industries: see also Classification, Gainfully occupied, Industries, 9-10 detailed, Committee of Statistical Experts of L. of N . (note to 73) minimum, 49-57: Committee of Statistical Experts ofL. ofN., 73 principle, 52 provisional, I.L.O., 4, 6, 7, 9 Literacy, and migration, 506 Localised industries: see also Industries, and wages for specific occupation, 263 Lockouts: see also Industrial disputes, 441 Man-days: see also Employment, Exposure to risk, for accident rates, 353 Man-days loss: see also Industrial disputes, industrial disputes, 447, 458 Manufacturing industries: see also Industries, and names of topics, e.g. Earnings, principles of grouping, 55-56 Marital status: gainfully occupied, 68, 71 migrants, 502 Maritime Statistical Handbook, 19 Merchant marine, wages and wage rates, 19 Method: see names of topics: Group basket method, Representative selection, Sample, and passim Migration: see also Migration statistics Conference on Migration Statistics, 1, 3-4, 39; 464-508 definition, 465-467, 474 internal, 473, 507 International Labour Conference, 1922, 39 permanent, 466, 468 temporary, 467-470 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. 164 INTERNATIONA!, STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS Migration statistics: see also Migration, 39-40; 464-508 classifications, 492-507: emigration and immigration, 471, 493 industrial status and industry or occupation, 500, 501 nationals and aliens, 471, 494 permanent and temporary, 466470 coupons detachable from certain documents, 486-488 declaration of residence, 482-483 expanding scope, 41-44 frequency of compilation, 508 frontier control, 484-485 methods, 476-491 port statistics, 479-481 recommendation of the International Labour Conference, 1922, 39 uniform international method, 489491 Military service, gainfully occupied, 22 Minimum List of Commodities for International Trade Statistics, mentioned, 57 Mining: see Coal Mining and names of topics, e.g. Earnings Nathan, Robert R., 13 National Bureau of Economic Research, 40 National income: wages as part of, 20 index numbers, 102, 147-151 Netherlands, unemployment days in relation to possible days of work, 76 Nichols, Charles K., 4 Nixon, J. W., 5, 11, 1 9 , 3 2 , 3 3 Nomenclature: see List of industries Nominal wages: see Wages Non-family household: see also Households definitions, 362, 396-398 and occupation of dwellings, 364 Non-localised industries: see also Industries, wages for specific occupations, 263 Normal hours: see Hours, normal Number of rooms: see Rooms, number Nutritive value: see also Food as basis for food price comparisons, 284 food, family living studies, 335 Occupancy of dwellings: see also Density of occupancy, Dwellings, Housing, Rooms definition, international comparisons, 408 more than one family household, 406 Occupants: see also Density of occupancy, Dwellings, Housing, Rooms classification : character of habitable building, 369 density of occupancy, 370, 374, 408-414 rent paid, 379 size of dwelling, 369 definition, 360, 399 number, as basis of classification of dwellings, 371 and rent restrictions on dwellings, 380 Occupational status: see Industrial status Occupations: see also Gainfully occupied, Industries, List of industries classification, 9-11; 1: gainfully occupied, 24, 27, 28 housing censuses, 416 migrants, 497-499,501 wage rates and normal hours, same, convention, 188-190 definitions, 5 earnings, 229 employment exchange statistics, 82 list, of I.L.O., 9 nomenclature, not attempted by Committee of Stat. Experts, L. of N., 67 remunerated, as definition of gainfully occupied, 10 similar, wages, 130 at time of census, gainfully occupied, 11 unemployment and employment, 82 wage data from payroll census, 91 wages : additions to list of I.L.O., 260-265 international comparisons, 27 ; 130131, 134, 259-265 October, recommended as base month for enquiry of wages, prices and rents, 275 October enquiry: see also Cost of living, International comparisons, Retail prices, Rents, Wages expanding scope, 42-43 hours of work, 21 occupations, additions, 259-265 rents, 30 retail prices, 27; 93, 272 wages, 18, 26; 93 wages, extension recommended, 267: origin in British Ministry of Labour enquiry, 24 Overcrowding: see also Density of occupancy. Standards, 414 Overtime: see also Hours, Wage rates amount permitted, frequency of compilation, convention, 194 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. INDEX Overtime {coni.): average wages per hour, 128-129 and frequency of compilation of earnings per hour, 133 rates, frequency of compilation, convention, 194 Paasche, formula for index, 29 Pan-American Sanitary Conference, Rio de Janeiro, 1942, 32 Payrolls, used for wage censuses, 91 Permanent Committee on Road Traffic, of League of Nations, 6 Personal status: see Industrial status Persons per room: see Density of occupancy Physiological needs, climate and race and international comparisons of real wages, 254 food cost comparisons, 298 Piece rates: see also Earnings, Wage rates changes, 88 convention, 196 Piece work, earnings, 92 Postal Services, hours of work, 21 Pribram, Karl, 3 Production: see also Industries, List of industries primary, 2, 9 secondary, 2, 9 Public services: see also Industries, List of industries, Occupations; not including establishments in other branches of economic activity though belonging to public authority, 48 Purchasing power: see also Cost of living; of wages, 277 Quality: see also International comparisons, Retail prices items in cost of living, principles, 244, 248 precautions, for price comparability, 297 Quantities: see also Food, Family living studies; consumed, family living studies, 336 Race, physiological needs, international comparisons of real wages, 254 Railways: see also Industries, List of industries industrial accidents, report on statistical methods, 33-34 wages, in general index, 156 Rates: see also Taxes, payable by tenant, and rent, 376 Rates of wages: see Wage rales 165 Real wages: see also Cost of living, International comparisons, Remuneration, Salaries, Wage rates, Wages index numbers, 90, 92; original data to be published, 255 international comparisons, 253-297: agenda of Fourth Conference of Labour Statisticians, 3 capital cities, 93 Committee of Stat. Experts, I.L.O., 24 elemtnts other than wages, 279 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Fourth, 266286 I.L.O., 27-28 methods, 293-297 race, climate, etc., 254 Regions: see also Food costs, Group basket method, International comparisons, Rents in international comparisons, 301309; food costs, 29 rents, 321 Remuneration: see also Earnings, Family allowances, Salaries, Wage rales, Wages allowances, earnings, convention, 172-173; and time rates, convention, 194, 195 elements other than wages, 26-27287-290: Committee of Statistical Experts, I.L.O., 26; 287-290 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Fourth, 26; 271, 279 in real wage comparisons, 279 per hour, problems, 101 special allowances, taken into account in earnings, 129 supplementary items, and frequency of compilation of wage indices, 117 Rents: see also Cost of Living, Dwellings, Housing, Family living studies, Rooms per capita, 312 classification of dwellings, 378 Committee of Statistical Experts, I.L.O., 417 definition, 376-377 enquiry in towns included in wages and prices enquiry, 273; by I.L.O., 322 and floor space, 317-319, 324 housing census, 417 international comparisons, 30; 310325: Committee of Stat. Experts, I.L.O., 30; 310-325 International Conference of Labour Statisticians, Fourth, 30; 273, 275-277 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. 166 INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OP LABOUR STATISTICS Rents (cont.): Rooms {cont.y. regions, 321 number, in calculating densitv of resolutions, Committee of Statistical occupancy, 372-373, 410-414 * Experts, I.L.O., 310-325 number, in classification of dwellrestrictions, and classifications of ings, 365, 371, 403 dwellings and occupants, 380 number, in classification of occuper room, 311, 315, 317 pants, 370 statistics of vacant dwellings, 387 rooms per person, 414, see also Denand supplementary services, 323 sity of occupancy Representative selection: see also subsidiary, definition, 359 Sample Running-water: see also Housing, character of data on total wages, 225 Standard dwelling unit, 30 districts, wage index data, 113 classification of dwellings, 404 earnings and hours, 169 Safety: see also Industrial accidents establishments: coal mines, Report of Committee of actual earnings, 89 Experts in Safety, 34 actual hours, 89 employment, 80 Salaried employees: see also Gainfully family living studies, 327 occupied, Industrial status industries, time rates of wages and gainfully occupied, classification, normal hours (convention), 182 62-65 industries and categories, in wage salaries and hours, statistics recomindexes, 111 mended, 221 labour cost per unit of production, Salaries: see also Total wages and salalocalities and industries, 144 ries, Wages localities, earnings per hour indices, annual, by industries, 226 132 statistics recommended, 221-222 number of employers, employment, 80 total, industries, 225 total wages, employed persons, 232 Sample: see also Representative selection towns, for comparisons of consumpperiods, earnings and hours, 92 tion, 304 representative, earnings and hours, towns, industries and occupations convention, 169 wage data, 267 statistics, unemployment, 81 typical occupations, wages and hours, Sanitary accommodation: see Toilet, 92-93 unemployment statistics, 83 Bathroom wage earners, for wage statistics, Seasonal changes: convention, 167 food prices, and October as enquiry Retail prices: see also Cost of living, month, 275 International comparisons, October wages, 160 enquiry, Quality Seasonal migration: see also Migration, capital cities, 93 470 defects, an obstacle to international Services: see also Gainfully occupied, comparison, 299 Industries, List of industries, in clasfood, fuel and light (working class sification of industries, 2, 9 families), 272 Severity rate, accidents, 350, 352-353 food, seasonal changes, 275 methods of collection and calculaindustrial disputes, 462 tion to be unchanged, 244 Sex: see also Women October enquiry, 27 classification of gainfully occupied, quality, 244, 248; precautions, 297 68-72 statistics, expanding scope, 41-45 earnings, and actual hours, convention, 177, 224 Ricci, Umberto, 19 occupations in each industry, 224, Riches, E.J., 38 230 Rooms: see also Density of occupancy, unemployment, 82 Dwellings, Housing, Rents wage censuses, 91 definitions: wage rates and normal hours, conCommittee of Stat. Experts, L. of vention, 192 N., 388-390 wages, index numbers, 155 International Union of Towns, Size of dwelling: see also Density of 357-359 occupancy, Dwellings, Housing, habitable, 315; definition, 358 Rooms Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I : other references are to page numbers. INDEX Size of dwelling (cont.): classification of dwelling, 365, 371, 403 in classification of occupants, 369-370 density of occupancy, 372-373, 410414 in housing censuses, 401 and rent paid, in classification of occupants, 379 vacant dwellings, 387 Size of rooms: see Floor space Skill: see also Wages wage rates and normal hours, convention, 189 wages, index numbers, 100, 155 Snow, E. C , 22 Social insurance: see also Unemployment insurance contributions of employers and employees, 25-26: and relative real wages, 279 and wage statistics, 287-290 Social Science Research Council: see also Appendix, 1, 3 Conferences, 16, 19, 20: resolutions, 19: cost of living, 291-297 real wages, 256-265 wages and hours, 94-151, 152162 First Conference, 26: base for wage statistics, 23 wages as part of national income, 20 international comparisons, real wages, 24 Second Conference, cost of living, international comparisons, 27 Social status: see Industrial status Staehle, H., 28-29 Standard dwelling units: see also Dwellings, Housing, 30; 273, 314-315, 322 Standard of living: see also Cost of living, Family living studies, Housing, Salaries, Wages changes, different industries, 121 descriptive details, typical groups, 292 fluctuations, and index numbers of wages, 97, 98 hours and conditions of work, 110 and wages, 103, 104; index numbers to measure, 100, 108-120 Statistical Year Book of the League of Nations: base period, 23 geographical list of countries, for classifying migrants, 493 Strikes: see Industrial disputes 167 Taxes: see also Rates and calculation of rents, 376 direct, effect of inclusion or exclusion from index numbers of cost of living, 237 separate item, family living studies, 335 Tenure: see also Dwellings, Housing dwellings, housing censuses, 418 Textile industry: see also Industries, List of industries hours of work, 18 Tripartite Technical Conference 1937, 5 wages, 18, 26 Toilets: see also Dwellings, Housing, Standard dwelling units, 30 classification of dwellings, 322, 366, 404 subsidiary room, 359, 389 Total wages and salaries: see also National income. Salaries, Wages frequency of compilation, 149, 225, 231 industries, 225 by industries, mining and manufacture, 231-232 International Labour Review, article, 20 part of national income, 20; 102,147151 related to value of production, 139; to net value, 147 Social Science Research Council, Conference, 20; 147-151 statistics, expanding scope, 42-43 Trade unionism: see also Labour organisations, and industrial disputes, 449 Trade unions: see Labour organisations Transit migration: see also Migration, 472 Unemployed : see also Employed, Gainfully occupied, Unemployment family living studies, 32 and gainfully occupied, 11-12: international comparisons, 21 national censuses, 21 in gainfully occupied, 20: according to last occupation, 21 Unemployment: see also Employment, Unemployed agenda, 2nd Conference, Labour Statisticians, 2 census, special needed, for all aspects, 23 censuses, results reviewed, 13 days, in relation to total possible days of work, 76 definition, for statistical purposes, 83 in industrial or occupational census, 81: by sex, 81 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. 1 6 8 ' INTERNATIONAL STANDARDISATION OF LABOUR STATISTICS Unemployment (cont.): International Conferences of Labour Statisticians, 12; 74-85 international index, 13 partial, 85 in population census, 81 in receipt of benefit, 75 short-term employment, 85 special enquiries, 81: by sex, 81 statistics, 12-13: comparisons of different sources, 84 expanding scope, 41-45 ideal field, 83 methods, 83: and changes in, 83 forwarded to I.L.O., 83 I.L.O. report, 12 trade unions, 77 unemployment insurance, 74-75 young persons: recommendation of International Labour Conference, 1935, 12; seeking work, in census of gainfully occupied, 12 Unemployment Convention, 1919 recommendation, to send statistics t o I.L.O., 12 Unemployment insurance: see also Social insurance; as basis for unemployment statistics, 74-75 Unemployment relief works: in definition of gainfully occupied, 10 gainfully occupied, 22 Unpaid family workers: see also Gainfully occupied classification, gainfully occupied, 10,15, 60-61 Unskilled workers: see also Gainfully occupied, employment exchange statistics, distinguished separately, 79 Vacant dwellings: see also Buildings, Dwellings, Housing census annual returns, 386 classification, 387 classification and definition, 407 Vacations with pay: see Holidays with pay Variez, L., 40 Wage-earners: see also Gainfully occupied; classification, gainfully occupied, 62-65 Wage payment system, and frequency of compilation of wage data, 116 Wage rates: see also Earnings, Piece rates, Remuneration, Salaries, Wages, 86 changes, representative of actual earnings, 109 Wage rates {cont.): classification : occupation, convention, 188-190 skill, convention, 189 defects in information, annual statement of I.L.O., 258 definitions, 185: uniformity needed, 257 and earnings, 234: both needed, 256 both published, 159 differences, special enquiry, 257 divergencies, 159 relation, 227, 234, 270 in economic forecasting, 122 frequency of compilation, 187 hourly, 161 index numbers, 19: convention, 196-199 industries, mining and manufacturing, convention, 182-199 industries, representative selection, convention, 182 international comparisons, 86-91 nominal, index numbers, 90 notes, accompanying, 234 occupat-'ons in each industry, convention, 187 overtime, frequency of compilation, 194 piece work: changes, 88 convention, 196 time, and piece work basis time rates, for international comparisons, 269 time period, same as for normal hours, convention, 191 time, types, convention, 183-185 for transport, commerce, administration, recommendation, 219-220 types, 87 typical categories of time workers, 92 typical occupations, capital cities, wage comparisons, 93 weekly, 161 young persons: in census, 91 convention, 192 Wage statistics, and Committee of Statistical Experts of I.L.O., 286 Wages: see also Earnings, Index numbers, October enquiry, Remuneration, Salaries, Total wages and salaries, Wage rates agenda, First Conference, Labour Statisticians, 2 agriculture, 18; convention, 200-202 American report t o Social Science Research Council, 156 censuses, 19; 91 Numerical references in italic type are to the numbers of the paragraphs of the resolutions as given in Part I I ; other references are to page numbers. INDEX Wages (coni.): changes, from changes in rates, 88 classification, by industries, districts, occupations, sex and age division, 91 coal mining, 18, 26 Committee of Stat. Experts, I.L.O., 16-17 defects in information, and statement by I.L.O., 258 details for industries, occupations and localities, 127 and economic forecasting: see Economic forecasting frequency of compilation, 160, 201 per hour of work: international comparisons, 99 problems, 101 as purpose of index numbers, 97-98 index numbers: see Index numbers international comparisons: see also International comparisons, 24-27; on agenda of International Labour Conference, 285 Committee of Stat. Experts, I.L.O., 24 between countries or districts, 107 per hour of work, 99 International Conferences of Labour Statisticians, 24, 26; 253-255, 266-286 occupations, similar, 130-131, 134, 259-265 Social Science Research Council, Conferences, 24, 26; 256-265 International Conferences of Labour Statisticians, 16-17; 86-93, 219228, 266-286 International Labour Conference, 1938: Convention, 17; 163-218 Recommendations for further action, 229-234 limitations of quarterly statistics of I.L.O., 259 localities, additions to I.L.O. list, 260-264 national income, share in, 20; index numbers, 102, 147-151 nominal, 16-19; given in compiling index numbers, 90 occupations: additions t o I.L.O. list, 260-265 localised and non-localised, 263 overtime, and average wages, 128129, 133 seamen, 19 seasonal fluctuations, 160 Social Science Research Council, Conferences, 3, 16; 94-162 169 Wages (cont.): statistics, 16-20: expanding scope, 41-45 methods, report of I.L.O., 16 reports by I.L.O., 17-18 supplementary allowances, 287-290 textile industry, 18, 26 Water closet: see Toilet W. C. : see Toilet Women: see also Gainfully occupied, Sex, Unpaid family workers; wages, separate index, 162 Woodbury, Robert Morse, 28-29, 32, 116 Workers' organisations: see Labour organisations Working on own account: see Gainfully occupied, Industrial status gainfully occupied, 60, 63 World indices: see also International indices employment, 15 unemployment, 13 Woytinsky, W., 37 Year Book of Labour Statistics, 2, 6-7, 11,41-45: annual volume recommended, 4th Conference, 276 cost of living, 23 employment statistics, 14 family living data, 32 gainfully occupied, 11 hours of work, 21 index numbers, nominal and real wages, 20 industrial accidents, 34 industrial disputes, 38 international indices, food costs, 30 I.L.O. Year Book as predecessor, 41,44 migration, 39-40 rents, 30 scope, 41-44 unemployment, 13 wages, 18, 26 Young persons: see also Age classifications, Gainfully occupied, and names of topics earnings and hours, convention, 177 seeking work, and definitions of gainfully occupied, 12 as unemployed, 83 unemployment: recommendations of International Labour Conference, 1935, 12 wage data, in census, 91 wage rates and normal hours, convention, 192 • Numerical references in italic typeiLne to tha.numbers of the paragraphs.of the resolutions as given in Part II; other references are to page numbers. Publications of the International Labour Office Year Book of Labour Statistics 1942 (Seventh Year) This annual publication, now issued in a trilingual edition (English, French and Spanish), presents in tabular form the most complete data obtainable in the principal countries of the world relating to: Gainfully Occupied Population Employment and Unemployment Hours of Work Wages Cost of Living and Retail Prices Family Budgets Migration Industrial. Accidents Production and wholesale price indices, exchange rates The tables cover the last thirteen years. They are compiled from the official statistics of more than 50 countries in all parts of the world, supplemented in some cases by data obtained from private sources. Special care has been taken to include the relevant series, so far as available, for Latin Amercian countries. Recent enquiries of the I.L.O. on wages, hours of work and cost of living in various countries are reproduced in full. An introductory note to each chapter calls.attention to the principal questions of method to be borne in mind in interpreting the data, especially when utilising them for international comparisons. The statistics are presented in a systematic way with this object in view. "Indispensable to statisticians of all countries . . . Illustrates the wealth and complexity of the knowledge collected for experts to interpret . . . Through the co-ordination, and so far as possible, comparison of the official figurespublisned by different countries it is possible to gauge world economic trends in a way which was out of the question twenty years ago." —The Times, London. " . . . a valuable work for everybody concerned with social policy . . . The statistics provided tell not only the story of the great world depression, 1929. to 1935, but cover also the year 1941, a great performance, because wartime difficulties most likely hamper every statistical service." —The Standard, Wellington, N.Z. (referring to the 1941.edition). ". . . constituye una obra de consulta y de referencia en materia del trabajo en sus más variados aspectos." —Cuba Económica y Financiera. xii + 222 pages. Price: paper bound cloth bound $2 or 8s. $3 or 10s. 6d.