Don't hesitate to ask questions or for help with develoanon3606750899g your contribution - it's what we are here for. You can tweet @anon
More info about the research project http://bit.ly/26JAEZv
"
2,6599,2016-05-03T14:31:05.000Z,5618,anon1491650132,anon70625510,"Reference about the 911 adhoc response system?
@anon
Curious if we have any link to the story, for further info?
Good luck tomorrow at re:publica <3
"
1,5599,2016-04-27T05:10:12.000Z,5599,anon1491650132,anon1491650132,"1) Are you navigating deep changes in your community and want to make sense of them?
2) Interested in communities-provided care services (social, health, technology based)?
3) Want to connect with peers and chat about actual solutions?
OpenCare is a project run in collaboration with cities, maker spaces, research institutes, academia, communities on the ground in Europe, and especially individuals, which means each and every one of us. Starting now and throughout the next year we are building a community of Fellows with genuine interest in care and availability to share their experience and projects in different corners of the world.
We'll dedicate Monday's online meetup to explain, ask and learn more about the Op3nCare Fellowship program awarding writing and research awards of up to 20 000 euros during the next year.
As usual, the time for our call is Monday at 4:30 PM CET here: https://meet.jit.si/opencare (courtesy of edgeryder Eirinimal!)
Date: 2016-05-09 17:30:00 - 2016-05-09 18:30:00, Europe/Amsterdam Time."
1,673,2016-04-26T10:54:34.000Z,673,anon70625510,anon70625510,"The team: High resolution Photos + Updated 1 paragraph bios in profile.
Noemi Sanon3760936673tiu: community manager since 2012 with skills in online coordination and helanon3606750899g people find their way. Runs Op3nHangouts, our weekly community calls.
Nadia EL-Imam: UX designer and creative strategist, with experience in develoanon3606750899g ambitious narratives and building global collaborations. Runs OpenCare social media channels.
Natalia Skoczylas: our hyper mobile project manager; experienced in proposals writing, partnership building and finding funding opportunities across the network. Runs OpenCare weekly newsletters.
..you? Get in touch if you want to join Op3nCare communication team!
Timeline for key OpenCare engagement activities in 2016-2017
add here 1 slide / visualization
Regular activities you can participate in
1. CountOnMe for social media: You get an email with 3 headlines, you share them with your networks and send in your own news in return through a simple email reply. These are picked up by the official ER social media accounts (>3400 followers on facebook and twitter alike) and become the next day’s network headlines which are again spread by everyone in the list.. It’s fast and cheap. Sign up for CountOnMe here.
2. The weekly newsletter: Goes out to the whole Edgeryders community to engage them in the project. The Newsletter is sent out every Saturday morning with news for the coming week. You are expected to add your own project - related news. How: find the upcoming newsletter-in-progress in the Social Media Group. Add your own OpenCare news (events happening the NEXT week) in the comments.
3. Translate OpenCare.cc static pages: We need project copy in another language, consider uploading your own in the google drive and it will go online.
4. Frame a Challenge about Care: From April to November we will keep launching new challenges - about one or two a month, asking the community to contribute their stories and become Op3nCare Fellows. Challenges are not limited to a number or topics, so you can improve their copy or propose entirely new ones.
5. One Working out Loud blogpost each month: summarizes Op3n Care events led by various community members or team members; shares insights from the online conversation and ends with a Call to action explaining how anyone can get involved at that stage.
5. One trimestrial Webinar each: Please come up with an \#opencare related topic for a webinar to be held by you. This is important because it is ""goodies"" like these that power an effective engagement campaign. The presentation can be a version of what you presented during LOTE5/The first consortium meeting.
6. Challenge Responses: Please upload your own contribution to the challenges active now. Submit a new story (see Menu on the left).
A birds eye view of an OpenCare month of communication and outreach
No action required.
"
1,33726,2016-04-05T09:26:18.000Z,33726,anon1731172575,anon1731172575,"## Leoni befragt Philipp
Also ich muss sagen, dass ich nicht in dieses Projekt gegangen bin und mich mit Care beschäftigt habe. Eher habe ich mich mit Hacking Utopia beschäftigt. Also was wäre ein Utopia und wie könnte man das Hacken? Also wie könnte man Utopien entwickeln.
Pflege ist für jemanden da zu sein. Wohlwollend für jemanden da zu sein, wohlwollend auf jemanden einzuwirken. Ein sehr persönliches Bsp. Wäre von meinen Großeltern. Mein Opa ist an Alzheimer erkrankt. Das hat sich über drei oder vier Jahre hanon1056199097zogen. Meine Mutter wollte es so stemmen, dass sie zuhause bleiben und nicht ins Altersheim kommt. Und Pflegebedürftig bedeutet Macht abzugeben. Und pflege heißt in diesem Fall abrufbar zu sein und so zu priorisieren, dass sich alles um die eine Person dreht.
Manchmal bedeutet, dass Oma Nachts mit Taschenlampe einzusammeln. Oder Situationen im Haushalt, wo sie den Herd einfach angelassen hat und etwas Feuer fängt.
Ich weiß nicht, ob ich das gut einschätzen kann, inwiefern es mein Leben beeinflusst hat. Ich war ja relativ jung, als es mein Leben beeinflusst hat. Wir sind bei den Großeltern eanon1056199097zogen. Meine Mutter fand das gut, dass ich auf dem Land aufwachsen konnte und ich als Kind versorgt wurde. Und dann sind die Großeltern älter geworden. Mein Opa ist gestorben und meine Oma demenzkrank geworden.
Der Pflegebegriff, den ich mit dem Alter verbinde ist nochmal ein anderer als der von Kindern. Aber beide Arten von Pflege – also Pflege generell ist mit Liebe verbunden. Meine Mutter hat mich geliebt, genauso wie sie ihre Eltern geliebt hat. Diese Liebe gibt einem auch Kraft und die braucht man auch. Sonst ist das ja schwer zu stemmen. In unserem System wird das Verhältnis dann durch Geld kompensiert. Aber da sieht man ja auch, dass es Mängel gibt. Da sieht man z.B., dass Pfleger die Zeit sehr eng sehen – sie sind für 10 min. da und nicht länger. Und dieses schnell-schnell homediensten oder Karitas, das sehe ich auch bei uns im Dorf. Da sind mal ältere Leute und da kommt ein Auto vorbeigehuscht und das steht dann mal da für 10 min. und ist dann wieder weg. Da stehen größere Unternehmen dahinter, da geht es um Jobs, da geht es um Geld. Die haben ihren durchgetakteten Plan.
Der Begriff „Pflege“ ist der gleiche nur der Inhalt ist anders. Der Glaube – also nicht im religiösen Sinne – der Glaube daran, dass die Person es doch noch alles mitbekommt, was um sie passiert ist auch wichtig. Man denkt ja, dass solche Personen gar nichts mehr mitbekommen. Und da hatten wir auch Glück. Wir haben eine Pflegerin über das Internet gefunden, die meine Oma schon im frühen Stadium kennengelernt hatte. Und ich habe gemerkt, dass sie sich gut verstehen, als sie meine Oma zum Lachen gebracht hatte. Das darf man auch nicht unterschätzen. Meine Oma hatte auch sehr helle Tage. Aber das war alles sehr abrupt. Plötzlich hat sie nicht mehr reagiert. Und ich würde es daran messen, dass die Pflegerin mit meiner Oma wirklich Scherze machen konnte.
Als ich meine Oma in der Situation im Schnee reinholen musste, als sie dachte, dass sie Milch holen wollte. Und ich will nicht lügen, es war für mich als kleiner Junge auch wie ein Abenteuer da im Schneegestöber rauszugehen. Und ein bisschen Angst hatte ich auch. Als ich die gefunden hatte, war ich sehr wütend – einfach nur wütend. Aber dann habe ich verstanden, dass sie einfach in einer andere Art Zeitzone war manchmal. Sie sprach von ganz anderen Danon1056199097n.
Sehr konkret hing das Alzheimer mit dem Tod meines Großvaters zusammen. Früher gab es sehr strikte Rollenverteilungen. Als mein Großvater verstarb ist ihre elementare Stütze weggebrochen. Und sie konnte es nicht mehr verarbeiten. Sie hatte auch eine Art Schlaganfall, bei dem sie auch öfter meinen Namen gerufen hat. Sie war da auch länger im Krankenhaus. Danach hat sie immer mehr abgebaut.
Die ganze Zeit über drei Jahre hatte lustige Situationen, schöne Situationen aber auch ganz klar traurige Situationen. Lustig war bspw., dass Haushaltsgegenstände versteckt wurden und dann an Orten aufgetaucht sind an denen man es nicht erwartet hätte. Meine Mutter besaß Kaschmirpullower, die meine Oma in die Kochwäsche geschmissen hatte. Meine Mutter war sehr ruhig in solchen Situationen
Bügeleisen angelassen, Kabel verschmolzen. Da muss man eben schnell reagieren. Und auch Verwechslungen, bei denen meine Oma Menschen verwechselt hat.
Meine Mutter ist Grundschullehrerin. Sie hat versucht mich relativ aus diesen Umsorgungen herauszulassen. Aber wenn sie auf Elternabenden war, musste ich mich bspw. um Oma kümmern. Im frühen Stadium konnte man noch Brettspiele mit ihr spielen. Sowohl die Pflegering als auch der jetztige Mann (damals Freund) meiner Mutter haben sich sehr aufopfernd mitgekümmert.
Wenn wir uns der Aufgabe nicht angenommen hätten, dann wäre es für meine Mutter eine schlimme Last gewesen, dass sie es nicht gewollt oder gekonnt hätte. Meine Oma im Altersheim zu lassen wäre sehr schwierig gewesen für meine Mutter – mit der Gewissheit zu leben, dass sie nicht da war.
Für meine Mutter war die Situation natürlich schwierig. Es gab große Einschränkungen im Alltagsleben.
## Honey befragt Leoni
**Wie glaubst du könnte man Pflege in unserer Heutigen Welt angehen?**
**In der näheren Umgebung?**
Ich muss niemanden pflegen.
Es ist pflege sich mit Freundin zu unterhalten.
**Bei dir selbst?**
Sich bewegen, den Körper Pflegen. Die Psyche Pflegen.
**Warum musst du dich pflegen?**
Damit ich gesund bleibe.
**Ist es ein Problem das Menschen dieses Bedürfnis nicht haben?**
Unterschiedlich. Solange du keine Probleme hast musst du dich nicht darum kümmern.
Es kann passieren, dass du MS hast.
Ich wie? nicht ob eine Leib, Seele Trennung Sinn macht. Man kann im Gehirn zeigen, das psychische Probleme sich Körperlich Häusern. Wir haben sie nur noch nicht verstanden. Man kann Körper und Geist nicht trennen.
**Körperkult?**
Sport und Bewegung ist Pflege, aber man muss unterscheiden. Dreimal die Woche rennen gehen kann nicht gesund sein. Für manche Menschen eventuell schon. Es geht um die reine Bewegung Für die Durchblutung, den Sauerstoffgehalt, die Haut, die Sonne bekommt. Für den ganzen Körper.
**Bewegungsunfähigkeit.**
Ich hatte eine Bekannte die im Rollstuhl saß. Sie musste alle zwei Stunden nach Hause an eine Ladestation. Eigentlich könnte sie Laufen, doch sie hat Spastiken und traut sich nicht ohne den Rollstuhl zu laufen. Sehr motivierend finde ich die Läufer der Paralympics.
**Stellst du deine Pflege vor die Pflege anderer?**
Das steht in einem Jing-Jang Verhältnis. Wenn im Flugzeug der Druck fällt, wird dir auch gesagt, dass du zuerst selbst die Maske anziehen sollt und dann anderen.
Nur in wenigen Situationen wiederspricht mein Pflegebedürfnis dem der anderen. Das Problem ist wenn Leute nicht genug bekommen.
**Wir helfen der Menschheit damit?**
Nein, das Mittlere Management, macht nichts anderes als andere Leute zu beobachten. Ich denke die Meisten Menschen wollen etwas Sinnvolle tun.
**Wie verändert das das Verhältnis zu anderen, Familie.**
Es ist ein Wechselspiel. In einer Großfamilie ist es egal ob zu einem Pflegebedürftigen Kind noch ein alter dafür kommt. Menschen sind eher dafür gemacht in Rudeln zu leben. Es muss ja nicht Zwangsläufig die Familie sein sondern eine Gruppe Menschen, der man sich anschließt.
Pflege ist ein Verhältnis. Menschen machen nichts, was sie unerträglich finden. Auch bei kleinen Kindern. Wenn du dir das Objektive Betrachtest ist es sehr hart. Rund um die Uhr Betreuung, Nachts Ausstehen. Pflege ist nie Einseitig.
## Philipp befragt Honey
Habe noch nie mitbekommen dass es transdisziplinäre Zusammenarbeit gibt
Thema war sekundär
Jede Interaktion mit der Umwelt ist Pflege
Pflege beruht auf Erfahrung und die haben wir in uns, man kann den Umgang mit der Umwelt antrainieren, wenn ich mit der Weise wie ich mit der Welt umgehe zufrieden bin, dann ist es auch wie eine Pflege für mich selbst
Insgesamt ist das kapitalistische System in uns ein Chaos ausgelöst
Wir stehen als Generation ständig im Mittelpunkt
Gesellschaft wertet ständig und Geld bewertet Danon1056199097
Man kann keine Verantwortung für 300 Leute übernehmen und man sucht sich schon genau aus zu wem man seine Verbindung aufbaut
Ich rede mit mir selbst über Zeitmanagement obwohl das eigentlich natürlich sein sollte
Die Intuition wird immer schwächer, man muss immer eine Grundlage von Pro und Contra für alle seine Entscheidungen haben
Wirtschaft beeinflusst die Politik sodass die die Leute beeinflussen schneller in den Hamsterkäfig zu gelangen. In unseren Studiengängen entwickelt man dazu schnell ein Bewusstsein und versucht dagegen anzugehen.
Tendenz zur Meconomy immer mehr Freiberufler weil die Leute realisieren dass sich die Aufgabe für Menschen die sich nicht um mich kümmern? Das gleiche gilt auch für die Pflege, man würde ja nicht irgendwelche Leute pflegen die einen permanent fertig machen, es sei denn da ist wieder Geld als Kompensation
Ich beschäftige mich sehr stark damit ob man auch ein gesundes Unternehmens-Mitarbeiter-Verhältnis hat, der Mensch kann nicht mehr als 150 Leute in seinem Umkreis verstehen.
Deswegen beschäftige ich mich auch viel mit Holokratie, wo sich alle in kleineren Holons verbinden. Sogar die Gründer arbeiten in Holons.
Aber die Tendenz ist dass es wenige große Konzerne gibt, die alle Konkurrenz schlucken. Damit liegt die Entscheidungskraft bei wenigen Leuten die sehr komplexe Entscheidungen treffen.
Das funktioniert vielleicht bei Lebensmitteln die immer gebraucht werden wo sich dann wenige Konzerne die Macht teilen
Die großen Konzerne haben keine Empathie mehr und daher werden sie sehr skrupellos.
Du muss ständig vernetzt sein und die Außenwelt fordert das auch die ganze Zeit von dir
Es gibt so eine Sperrrate, ab 750.000 oder mehr kriegst du das nicht mehr mit, Geld ist dann nur noch Macht und es gibt nur noch diese Parameter zum darin denken.
Sie oder er (der Manager/in) die pflegen ihren Machtstatus. Das ist eine einseitige Interaktion alles dazu herum ist Leere, ein schwarzes Loch. Menschen um sie herum sind alle nur noch Zahlen, egal ob es jetzt der Ehepartner oder die Assistentin ist."
2,33764,2016-04-25T11:39:24.000Z,33726,anon1491650132,anon1731172575,"Caring for loved ones (Alzheimer, dementia..)
Thanks for sharing this @anon
She was lucky because she had a large family and they all shouldered this, but for the two people who lived side by side with her it was immensely difficult. I don't know if it has to do with the medical infrastructure in a place, but where I come from it's always the family who takes care of ill members, never long term professional services, mostly out of duty and love.
You say you don;t know how it has affected your life, but maanon1932026148 you know how it has affected your mom's life? To give you an idea, my family was so unprepared to cope with this that the new roles they were finding themselves in completely messed up the family. It had to do with matriarchal/ patriarchal figures not being so present anymore and then younger ones having to cope with a ton of things and make decisions that they felt unprepared for.
A takeaway point from your story: love and laughter, the authentic ones, make for an important variable in any care relationship, just to keep that in mind.
"
2,7849,2016-04-25T09:18:50.000Z,668,anon1526983854,,"In practice, though...
Well, hard to disagree with what you write here. I am curious about the practice of care, though. What does it look like for you? How do you personally give and receive care? Is it babysitting for a friend? Is it spending time with a sick relative? How does that experience influence your views?
"
2,7803,2016-04-25T07:13:12.000Z,669,anon1491650132,,"Working in groups?
Hi @anon
Also, @anon
How can we, others in the community, help?
"
2,9446,2016-04-16T16:58:46.000Z,663,anon1526983854,,"So why?
Hello @anon
"
4,12342,2016-04-24T21:23:00.000Z,11090,,,"How can learn people in this society to be tolerant and patient with others. These are characteristics that I see missing for example in the context of design.
"
5,16089,2016-04-17T10:10:56.000Z,663,anon1491650132,,"Does your personal experience help your thinking?
@anon
"
1,4913,2015-10-26T10:43:16.000Z,4913,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"**_Available in: :gb: [English](#en) / :it: [Italian](#it)_**
----------
## :gb: **_English version_**

You enter the [Metropolitan Community Clinic at Helliniko](http://www.mkiellinikou.org) from a nondescript parking lot in suburban Athens, in an area that hosts a decommissioned American military base. It does not look like much. But it is. It is a very big deal indeed.
The MCCH saves people. It provides health care to down-on-their-luck Greeks who have no access to public health care and no money to pay for private clinics. There are many such people, because in Greece access to the national health service is tied to employment. When Greeks lose their jobs, they have a grace period of one year: they'd better find another job within that period, because if they don't they are out of health insurance. If they fall sick, they have to come up with something, or die.
It's not just Greeks. It turns out in every European Union countries but the United Kingdom and Italy, employment is a pre-requisite for access to health care. But Greece was hit hardest by the 2008 crisis: many more people than elsewhere have turned into long-term unemployed. Everyone is struggling: “We had poor people ten years ago, too – shrugs Maria, a psychologist volunteering at MCCH – but at that time people could fall back on their families, or their neighbors, for help. Not anymore: their families and neighbors are themselves in trouble, and there's little they can do. People are getting desperate.”
In 2011, some senior doctors started comparing notes, and they saw a perfect health care storm brewing at the horizon. “We knew something very bad was coming, and people would die – says Maria – so we decided we must do something.”
“Something” in this case turned out to be the MCCH itself. This is a very strange animal as health care providers go.
* [b]It has no legal existence[/b]. Its literature proudly proclaims: “ MCCH is a volunteer organization without Legal or Taxable status and it is not a 'Non-Profit-Making-Organisation'.” Maria: ""We are technically illegal"".
* [b]It does not accept donations in money[/b]. It does accept donations in kind: medicines, equipment, blood sample analyses.
* [b]It operates from a building that belongs to the Municipality of Helliniko-Argyropoulis.[/b] Though none of its employees works in the building, the Municipality still pays the electricity and phone bills that the MCCH generates. My heart goes out to the anonymous “bureaucrat hacker” that entrusted a government building to an informal group of citizens, which by definition cannot sign contracts or participate in tenders.
* [b]It is very autonomous with respect to institutions and power[/b]. MCCH was recently proposed for the European Parliament European Citizen's Prize 2015, but they very publicly turned it down. Reason: ""Europe is an important cause of the problem we exist to address. Don't give us awards, change your policy"".
* [b]It treats only people who have no access to the public health care system[/b]. One exception: low-income families with many children, who are living hand-to-mouth on 450 euro a day and simply cannot afford to buy medicines (Maria: “It happens”).
* [b]On top of diagnosis/prognosis, MCCH supplies free medicines, baby food and nappies.[/b]
* [b]It has 300 volunteers[/b], of which a little over half are doctors of various specialisations and pharmacists.
* [b]It operates with practically no hierarchy and no management[/b]. People decide by themselves what role to play, by joining one of several groups (about 10 members to a group) which exist to carry on specific tasks (like onboarding new patients). An organising committee does its best to keep people on the same page. A weekly meeting votes on general issues. A mailing list deals with specific matters.
* When they are not volunteering with MCCH, [b]volunteers exchange services and small favours through a time bank[/b]: two massages against one hour of English lessons etc.
[b]There are now 68 such clinics in Greece[/b]. Take a moment to think about what this means: in four years, thousands of enterprising Greeks with no money, no command structure and who do not even know each other have created a parallel health care system that succeeds where the public health service and private sector services both fail: it keeps reasonably safe the poorest strata of the population. Notice that the Greek health care budget in 2011 was over 6 billion euro.
Wait. Self-organised people with no money and no organisation that beat credentialed, moneyed professionals at their own game? We've seen this before. It was Wikipedia outcompeting Encyclopedia Britannica. It was OpenStreetMap pushing to the curbs Garmin and TomTom. It was Facebook groups coordinating disaster relief after the Nepal 2015 earthquakes and the Tbilisi 2015 flash flood, way before the government and NGOs could get their act together. It was Internet-coordinated young newcomers changing the rules of the political game, and even bringing down entire regimes who seemed to have all the power and all the money, in Egypt, Tunisia and Ukraine.
We have a word for these phenomena: we call them disruption. They are associated with supplying goods or services in a new way, that substitutes collective intelligence and distributed effort for vertical organisations. This new way happens to be vastly more efficient than the old ones.
I think the time has come for disruption in health care, and in care services in general. Why? Because, as the OECD pointed out, per capita health care expenditure grows much faster than GDP. In 1970, health care absorbed a respectable 5.2% of the GDP of the average OECD country. In 2008, it absorbed 10.1% (source). The system is under strain, and often – like in Greece, it reacts by denying care to those who most need it.
This is morally unacceptable, wasteful and stupid – especially when the Metropolitan Community Clinic at Helliniko and so many other experiences like it, in the world of care and outside it, has proven how much farther communities can go in taking care of their members when they are enabled to do it.
So, we are getting involved. Edgeryders has partnered up with five world-class organisations in research (University of Bordeaux, Stockholm School of Economics, ScimPulse Foundation), welfare policy-making (City of Milan) and digital fabrication (WeMake) to find, learn from, and enhance the experiences like MCCH all around the world. Our goal is a model of community-driven care services, based on modern science and open technology, but with the low overhead and human touch that communities can provide and large bureaucracies cannot. Our project is called OpenCare; the European Commission has generously agreed to support it through its Collective Awareness Platforms programme.
Whoever you are you are welcome to join us. After all, if you are human, you have considerable experience of giving and receiving care, and that makes you an expert. If you want to participate, or simply to know more, [start here](https://edgeryders.eu/t/welcome-to-opencare/4858).
Photo: Theophilos Papadopoulos on flickr.com
----------
## :it: **_Italian version_**
Si entra alla Metropolitan Community Clinic di Helliniko da un anonimo piazzale di parcheggio alla periferia di Atene, in un'area che ospitava una base militare americana, oggi abbandonata. Non sembra molto impressionante. Ma lo è. È un luogo molto importante.
La MCCH salva vite. Fornisce assistenza sanitaria a persone sfortunate che non hanno accesso alla sanità pubblica, né denaro per pagarsi quella privata. Ci sono molte persone in questa situazione, perché in Grecia l'accesso al servizio sanitario nazionale è legato all'occupazione. Quando un greco perde il lavoro, mantiene l'assistenza sanitaria per un anno: se dopo un anno non ha trovato un altro lavoro, perde il diritto di accesso al servizio sanitario nazionale. Se si ammala, deve inventarsi qualcosa, o morire.
Non sono solo i greci. In tutti i paesi europei, tranne il Regno Unito e l'Italia, la condizione di occupato è un pre-requisito per accedere all'assistenza sanitaria. Ma la Grecia è stata colpita più duramente dalla crisi del 2008: molte più persone che altrove si sono trasformate in disoccupati a lungo termine. ""C'erano poveri anche dieci anni fa – ci dice Maria, una psicologa che fa volontariato a MCCH – ma a quel tempo le persone in difficoltà potevano chiedere aiuto alle famiglie, o ai vicini. Oggi anche le loro famiglie e i loro vicini sono in difficoltà, e non possono fare molto per aiutare gli altri. La gente è disperata.""
Nel 2011, alcuni medici hanno cominciato a confrontare le loro esperienze, e hanno visto una tempesta perfetta prepararsi all'orizzonte. ""Sapevamo che qualcosa di molto brutto era in arrivo, e che della gente sarebbe morta – racconta Maria – Quindi abbiamo deciso che dovevamo fare qualcosa.
""Qualcosa in questo caso è risultato essere la MCCH stessa. Si tratta di uno strano animale nello zoo dell'assistenza sanitaria.
- Non esiste legalmente. Il suo materiale proclama fieramente: ""MCCH è un'organizzazione volontaria senza status legale e non tassabile, e non è una 'organizzazione not for profit'."" (Maria: ""Tecnicamente siamo illegali"".)
- Non accetta donazioni in denaro. Accetta invece donazioni in natura: medicine, attrezzatura, analisi di campioni di sangue.
- Occupa una palazzina di proprietà del Comune di Helliniko-Argyropoulis. Nonostante nessuno dei suoi dipendenti lavori lì, il Comune paga le bollette dell'elettricità e del telefono generate da MCCH. Il mio cuore batte per l'anonimo ""burocrate hacker"" che ha consegnato un edificio pubblico a un gruppo informale di cittadini, che per definizione non può e non vuole firmare contratti o partecipare a bandi.
- È molto autonoma rispetto alle istituzioni e al potere. MCCH è stata proposta per un riconoscimento del Parlamento Europeo chiamato European Citizen's Prize 2015, ma l'ha rifiutato in modo molto pubblico. Motivazione: ""L'Europa è una delle cause del problema che esistiamo per risolvere. Non dateci premi, cambiate la vostra politica.""
- Tratta solo pazienti che non hanno accesso al servizio sanitario nazionale. Un'eccezione: famiglie numerose a basso reddito, che vivono con 450 euro al mese e semplicemente non hanno denaro per le medicine. (Maria: ""Succede."")
- Oltre a diagnosi/prognosi, MCCH fornisce medicine, cibo per neonati e pannolini gratis.
- Ha 300 volontari, di cui un po' più della metà sono medici di varie specializzazioni e farmacisti.
- Funziona praticamente senza gerarchie e senza managers. Ciascun volontario decide da solo in quale ruolo impegnarsi. Lo fa unendosi a un gruppo: ciascun gruppo ha circa 10 membri e esiste per occuparsi di svolgere un compito specifico (per esempio c'è un gruppo di accoglienza nuovi pazienti). Un comitato organizzativo fa del suo meglio per tenere ciascun gruppo informato e allineato con gli altri. Una riunione settimanale vota su temi generali. Una mailing list si occupa di temi specifici.
- Quando non fanno volontariato con MCCH, i volontari si scambiano servizi e piccoli favori attraverso una banca del tempo: due massaggi contro un'ora di lezione di inglese etc.
Oggi ci sono 68 cliniche organizzate così in Grecia. Prendetevi un momento per assorbire le implicazioni di questo fatto: in quattro anni, migliaia di greci intraprendenti, senza denaro, senza una struttura di comando, senza neppure conoscersi, hanno creato un servizio sanitario parallelo che riesce dove il servizio sanitario pubblico e la sanità privata falliscono: mantiene in relativa sicurezza gli strati più poveri della popolazione. Da notare: lo stato greco ha speso in sanità oltre 6 miliardi di euro nel 2011.
Aspetta un attimo. Masse di persone auto-organizzate, senza soldi e senza organizzazioni, che battono professionisti attentamente selezionati e ben pagati sul loro terreno? Scena già vista. Era Wikipedia che strabatteva Encyclopedia Britannica. Era OpenStreetMap che, reganon3760936673do i propri dati, vaporizzava il business di Garmin e TomTom. Erano gruppi su Facebook che coordinavano le iniziative di soccorso poche ore dopo il terremoto in Nepal e l'inondazione di Tbilisi di questa primavera. Erano i giovani inesperti e coordinati via Internet che cambiavano le regole del gioco politico, arranon3406688078do ad abbattere interi regimi in Egitto, Tunisia e Ucraina.
Abbiamo una parola per questi fenomeni: li chiamiamo disruption. Sono associati con la produzione di beni o servizi in un modo nuovo, che sostituisce le organizzazioni verticali con l'intelligenza collettiva e lo sforzo distribuito. Accade che questo modo nuovo è enormemente più efficiente di quelli vecchi.
Credo che sia arrivato il tempo della disruption nell'assistenza sanitaria, e nei servizi di cura in generale. Perché? Perché, come ha spiegato l'OCSE, la spesa sanitaria pro capite cresce molto più in fretta del reddito prodotto. Nel 1970, la sanità assorbiva un rispettabile 5.2% del PIL del paese sviluppato medio. Nel 2008 ne assorbiva il 10.1% (fonte). Il sistema è sotto stress, e spesso – come in Grecia – reagisce negando i servizi a chi ne ha più bisogno.
Questo è moralmente inaccettabile, dissipativo e stupido – specialmente quando la Metropolitan Community Clinic di Helliniko, e molte altre esperienze simili, hanno mostrato la capacità delle comunità di prendersi cura dei propri membri quando si permette loro di farlo.
Quindi, ci mettiamo in gioco. La mia nanoimpresa sociale, Edgeryders, si è associata con cinque organizzazioni di classe mondiale nella ricerca (Univeristà di Bordeaux, Stockholm School of Economics, ScimPulse Foundation) nelle politiche sociali (Comune di Milano) e nella fabbricazione digitale (WeMake) per trovare le esperienze come MCCH in tutto il mondo, imparare da loro, e se possibile perfezionarne il modello. Il nostro obiettivo è contribuire a un modello di servizi di cura community-driven, basati sulla scienza e la tecnologia moderna, ma con i bassi costi amministrativi e il tocco umano che le comunità hanno e le grandi burocrazie, sia pubbliche che private, no. Il nostro progetto si chiama OpenCare; la Commissione Europea ci ha creduto abbastanza da sostenerlo attraverso il programma Collective Awareness Platforms.
Chiunque tu sia, sei il o la benvenuta a unirti a noi. Dopo tutto, noi umani, tutti, abbiamo un'esperienza considerevole nel dare e nel ricevere cura, e questo fa di noi degli esperti. Se vuoi partecipare , o semplicemente saperne di più, parti da qui.
Foto: Theophilos Papadopoulos su flickr.com"
2,10231,2015-10-26T11:56:16.000Z,4913,anon3612872438,anon1526983854,"Care beyond the concept of ""clinic"" and hospital
Hi all,
interesting example, the self-organizing of the greeks.
I would push the concept a bit further.
Some years ago, I listened to a talk by John Thackara about how hospitals and clinics were becoming unsustainable for many reasons and he explained how we should move forward and think about a distributed type of care, re-design care without hospitals. The talk I'm sharing with you is the one he did at Mayo clinic and it's worth a watch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRMYGBNIv_4
(here's a infovis he shows in the video about Obama Care http://kevinanon295122297.house.gov/uploadedfiles/obamacarechart.pdf )
He explains how ninety five percent of healthcare happens outside hospital or the doctor’s surgery - in the home, and in the community. Collaborative service networks are emerging- from child care, to dementia support - that empower people to work in equal and reciprocal relationship with professionals and without needing hospitals.
He also gives the example of Cuba and how they spend on 5% of what americans spend and reach the same level of health.
Then shows how he applied design thinking in UK working on Alzheimer and dementia and starting from the point of view that health and wellbeing are properties of social-ecological-context and not a something you ""deliver"" like a pizza.
Communities need to be nurtured and supported and it's by being ""in them"", not by doing things ""to them"" that change happens.
I didn't have time to look for documents of his research, but im sure there's something more on the topic, we could collect.
best
Zoe
"
3,16546,2016-04-19T11:17:25.000Z,4913,anon3088980631,anon1526983854,"Cooperative Integral Catalunya
Interesting - thanks - another example which might be worth a look: http://cooperativa.cat/en/cooperative-public-system/health/
"
4,17235,2016-04-23T14:09:33.000Z,16546,anon1526983854,anon3088980631,"Some broken links...
Thanks @anon
"
6,21856,2016-04-23T14:06:46.000Z,20113,anon1526983854,,"Exactly
Welcome, @anon
But what do you mean by ""skilled and well placed partners who are willing and able to act as brokers within the system to get things done""? Do you have any example in mind?
"
1,5570,2016-04-19T09:03:55.000Z,5570,anon1491650132,anon1491650132,"
Present: @anon4054968747 @anon1526983854, @anon413297907 @anon3914374234 @anon1743371374 @anon1491650132 @anon3895445472 @anon2435658896, Silvia
Agenda for the call:
1. Alberto’s Big Picture for Open Care Year 1: we need to collectively contribute to a post publicly outlining our work this year. If no one wants to do it, Alberto volunteers to write it
Related topic here: Documentation.
Even from last weeks call we discussed some of the constraints in bringing stories from the very ground (In Milano) online and the barriers to participation.
Alberto: It is worrying that documentation is perceived as hard to get, as we wrote it in the proposal and now have to execute.
Rossana: We are waiting to hear from people we are engaging and who would be more comfortable to tell us things that may be private. On the 4th of May we are starting activities of co-design with Milano communities and it would be a better time to collect stories. Also, video operator needs time to process the material etc.
Costa: we are not active on the website, but we will as soon as we have confirmation from the community and partners we engage.
The offline activities are not aligned at the moment with online activities.
Our 1 hour events are not enough to onboard them - Milano events are not conversations yet, they go one way. These activities are more of a warmup, our hope is to get their attention in the co-design sessions.
Eirini: I know of this EU funded project (crappy UX> sorry). http://www.innovvoice.com/ it's platform where you can post your challenge/problem and then receive comments and collaborate further on the develpment of some projects (the hacking @anon
2. Costa & Co. proposal for a new Open Care landing page (complementary to the one we have now)
A very hard project because it is a meta-project: we strive not to build something, but first understand what is the right approach to solving a problem.
We propose a new landing page above the content and landing pages already there. A one page website - very simple and clear and explain OpenCare in one minute to anyone. Link to proper resources so people can get more involved. Hosted outside of edgeryders.eu .
Example: https://openideo.com/
Alessandro: user story example “If I’m a developer and want to dig right into the code - I should be able to access the github rep immediately”
Needs to answer key questions: What is OpenCare? How can I find more info? Who is doing it?
Tools have to be as simple as possible.
WeMake are preparing a clear HowTo guide mapanon3606750899g the environment of relevant projects in the Care field (DYI, Maker world). Should speak to people who are not accustomed to online tools, but also the more skilled in using Internet tools.
the reason of a landing page
- this is a redirect, that helps people find relevant information, and we aren't creating a new destination.
- the ""elevator pitch"" is hard to get
- it is hard to find answers to these questions:
- what is opencare?
- how do I get involved?
- who is doing it?
landing page design criteria
- it shows in a brief intuitive way what the project is and it redirects to online spaces of the project
- it will answer these questions:
- what is opencare?
- how do I get involved?
- where can I find more info?
- who is doing it?
- picture
- statement that describes the project
- call to action button: share your story
- call to action links:
- opencare community page
- opencare research page
- (github repo)
- (youtube channels)
- twitter feed
- partners logos
to do & roadmap
- we'll use github pages (as a start using WeMake organization page)
- the repo can later be transfered to Opencare organization page on github
- we have a nice template (similar to OpenIdeo)
- we'll post it on the research page and we'll manage the issues using the repo issue un github
- only in english for now (a simple page is easier to be translated)
- before the next community hangout will be publish and shared on the research page
Alberto, Patrick, Noemi were OKish with building a new page, and paging here @anon70625510 for input too. Advantages: removes the technical constraints imposed by Drupal. Disadvantages: Content Experiments cannot be used – testing of comparative performances of different landing pages impossible. One more thing that can break and needs maintenance. Edgeryders does not take responsibility for web pages outside of its website.
This was about it. Everyone, let us know what you think as we're collecting input before and after each meeting, so that we save some time (one hour is not enough to get everyone's oanon3606750899ions on topics).
Next call is on Monday, 16:30 CET. (check the Meetups page for updated event)
PS @anon4054968747 can you please re-post the link to the online room we will be using and any other useful info? I will make sure to include it in the event page. Thanks so much, and again, let us know if this conversation made sense to you at all :-)"
2,9962,2016-04-19T09:54:11.000Z,5570,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"OpenCare landing page
@anon2435658896 / @anon3612872438 / @anon
Hello everyone,
It's a shame I missed this community call, because, ahem, well... I starting creating an OpenCare landing page myself. I developed it recently to see what and how we could do to provide info on the project to the public.
I had hoped to present it to you very soon, once its layout would have been done for good - but since you mention it, why not discussing it right now and see how we can go.
The page has some of the criteria you listed so far, and can still be developed. It is still under construction (need to add a footer with all credits / logos etc. for example), but the structure and the pages are done. Every information you see on the pages are excerpts from OpenCare's Description of Action (Annex 1 GA).
You can visit it here: https://www.labri.fr/perso/lchiodel/opencare/
It is a Wordpress-based website, which I did with my very modest means.
I share it so that we may either further use it and develop it at a higher level or get inspired from it.
For now it is hosted on my personal website at the University of Bordeaux, but the website and its back office can be transfered to another server anytime."
3,11974,2016-04-19T12:00:24.000Z,9962,anon1491650132,anon2971875139,":-)
Hi @anon2971875139, thanks for sharing your work with us. So it seems we have a bunch of designer heads around :-)
Myself, I am not one, so I basically welcome all these proposals if you think they speak better to the communities we have to engage. What's important is that they link to the conversation website on edgeryders and attempt to bring people in, so that we're not putting too much effort in informative materials, but keep focusing on their engagement function. Of course, engagement can mean different things to us partners. The way I see OpenCare is that we don't need to speak to a general ""public"", there is no public. There are people who could be community members, contributors etc, and landing pages should speak to them. The way we quantify online engagement is by site visits and conversion into online activity posts and comments. One thing proposed at the call was to test these pages and measure the results after some time.
Anyway, hope you guys can agree on this."
5,13531,2016-04-20T14:44:44.000Z,9962,anon70625510,anon2971875139,"Sweet :)
It's lovely Luce, thanks for taking the time to put it together.
I'll have a look in a couple of hours how to incorporate some of the elements onto http://opencare.cc
"
6,16440,2016-04-19T10:23:51.000Z,5570,anon4054968747,anon1491650132,"Open Source teleconferencing tool
It's https://meet.jit.si
You simply add:
/*name_of_the_chatroom*
For example you can include this in the event page: https://meet.jit.si/opencare
and people should be able to join. (it might need some page refresh when a new person joins in). I've had a call with up to 20people.
"
7,17988,2016-04-19T11:20:18.000Z,16440,anon1526983854,anon4054968747,"Thanks!
Thanks, @anon4054968747, definitely worth trying out.
"
8,21399,2016-04-19T11:48:00.000Z,5570,anon1526983854,anon1491650132,"For the record
I am grateful to @anon1526983854_simonetti, @anon1743371374 and @anon2971875139 for input. But I implore you: do not spend more than a few hours on it. When all it's been said and done, OpenCare is a difficult project. It requires very active participation from people. Doing landing pages might help incrementally, but will not change this situation.
Commercial design techniques are a bad match for this kind of problem, because they assume that ""the user"" has a 20 seconds attention span (Alberto mentioned an exact number, which might even be smaller, I forgot what it was), and requires immediate gratification. It also assumes, critically, that each ""user"" that walks away is a loss to the project. In a commercial setting, all of this is true, because the ""user"" is there to be shown advertisements.
The OpenCare kind of stuff assumes that the ""participant"" is an intelligent adult, who is measuring up with a big problem and enjoys the challenge. She is not scared of ugly interfaces and even command-line ones. She understands that it will take hours of deep reflection and engagement to even make meaningful contribution, let alone solve anything. And if she is not prepared to do that, she should walk away. We are doing no favour to her, nor to ourselves, by keeanon3606750899g people engaged who do not like our terms of engagement.
This experience, at least for me, goes back to 2008 (Costantino remembers Kublai, and that in turn stood on the shoulders of a simpler projects in 2006-2007). What I have learned is that smart, committed people gravitate to smart, committed people: that a challenging environment repels some, but signals to the others that they are being treated as thinking adults, and brings out the best in them; and that there is no way to build engagement other than handholding, seeking out actively the smartest people and leading by example – for example uploading your own care stories onto the platform. And that's where the bulk of your time and effort should go. Not artifacts, but process: community management and dogfooding.
Meanwhile, plenty of Euro projects have tried all sorts of designs and failed miserably to attract any kind of real engagement. The extent of this failure is hard to believe. It basically tanked a whole program, called E-Participation (paper). Meanwhile, Edgeryders – for all its faults – was avoiding these pitfalls. This is why we were mentioned as an example in the working paper by Fabrizio Sestini, the CAPS program officer, and the overall failure of E-Participation is one of the reasons why CAPS looks the way it does. I really do not recommend to walk the same path as the (smart, professional, motivated) people in E-Part."
9,22370,2016-04-19T13:40:58.000Z,21399,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"imho, it's more about legibility at first sight
It's not that much about being commercial or non-commercial. Having an entry point that solely bound to the OpenCare project name is a plus, just as having info about how's who in a glimpse. (And I won't hide you it is useful on the admin/reviewing side.)
"
10,23180,2016-04-20T05:03:45.000Z,21399,anon2435658896,anon1526983854,"Alessandro Contini != Alberto Simonetti
Alessandro Contini @anon413297907 was present in the last conference call and also during the consortium meeting in Brussels.He works for WeMake.
Alberto Simonetti @anon1526983854_simonetti was not present in the last community call. He works for Comune di Milano."
11,23244,2016-04-20T05:42:07.000Z,23180,anon1491650132,anon2435658896,"Mea culpa.
You're right, sorry. Alberto was present last week, hence the confusion.
"
12,24623,2016-04-20T06:45:07.000Z,5570,anon2435658896,anon1491650132,"being short - keeanon3606750899g my resources
Hi @anon1526983854,
you rember well the empiric law 1000-100-10.
As we're using the social network to interact with the future, the possible, the not-already-here community, we have to talk in many linguistic registers as wide as possible.
If you want to filter out people from first layer, this is not our case.
These years of makerspace activity taught us how to be as inclusive as possible, and try to lower the barriers to participation and engagement . We keep triyng and we improve every day how to do it.
Sleakness has not to be a ""commercial"" thing. it is just effective.
I don't really understand your friction and here we're talking of minor changes and improvement considering that @anon413297907 and @anon1743371374 have some experience too in user interface and community management.
(not using more time on this in order to be efficient)"
13,25269,2016-04-20T08:13:47.000Z,24623,anon70625510,anon2435658896,"Timing. 29 days to respond/propose alternatives?
""If you are unhappy with that landing page, by all means produce a new landing page and all the related pages (design, copywriting, concept etc) and send it to me by the end of the week. We can do an A/B test for the landing page and loo[k] at conversions. But I require the answers [t]o the questions I and Noemi have already asked, but not yet recieved responses to.""
https://edgeryders.eu/en/comment/22041#comment-22041
"
14,25458,2016-04-20T10:42:29.000Z,25269,anon2435658896,anon70625510,"fields of action
your timing proposal was a little passive-aggressive
""and send it to me by the end of the week""
also considering the we (me and zoe) pointed out that we where in China.
Over this there is also other consideration:
- hard to be precise on little task / topic (as the landing page is) without a clear big picture view
- it's a moving target (the development of the community site was ""unscheduled"" from our point of view)
- it's not our primary role, we try to rise question and issue (plan a) if nothing happen we make some extra work (plan b)
The point is still:
I expected some concise and understandable explanations about the Outreach strategy for a while then I tried to rise the flag kindly posting this post. - See more at: https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/strategy-wp1-and-wp2#sthash.kM2CkDjf.dpuf
"
15,25554,2016-04-20T14:39:08.000Z,25458,anon70625510,anon2435658896,"Explicit communication, pace and active participation.
This is a fast moving project- online engagement/social dynamics have a pace of their own and do not follow anyone's schedule. It is like riding a anon3003844599, it's up to you to stay on top of things. If you don't make a convincing case, or concrete enough suggestion in a timely manner then things move on. Some general/vague requests were made from your side. A counterproposal was posted. No response: neither questions asked from your side nor a suggested alternative time/date for follow-up discussion. And then: "" it's not our primary role, we try to raise question and issue (plan a) if nothing happens we make some extra work (plan b)"" - To me it signals you want the kind of hand-holding which no one can afford.
You would not be the first person to have a hard time keeanon3606750899g up with the fast pace with which we get things move. It is up to each one of us to take individual responsibility for staying on top of things:
- Be proactive in building answers to your questions well in time. Rather than vanishing fo long stretches of time and then expecting everyone to scramble when you finally bother to show up.
- Participate actively in the weekly community calls/hangouts as a quick way to catch up whenever you feel ""lost"". Put things on the agenda, make creative proposals, etc. Or better yet, actively put in coordination work to actively convene the partners in calls etc. Instead of waiting for e.g. Alberto, Noemi or myself to do it.
- Produce the content/material/code or whatever you feel is missing yourself. Accept that it may have become irrelevant or that people no longer have time to engage with your demands if you are too slow. You have all the material you need to produce whatever it is you want if you are unhappy with what is there for any reason. If you feel you do not understand the project or how it is meant to work, please reread the actual proposal as well as the information already produced and pointed to.
Regarding your demands/questions/complaints:
- Your demand/question ""that has been kindly flagged"" has already been responded to: https://edgeryders.eu/en/comment/22518#comment-22518
- The engagement and outreach strategy has not changed from what was presented during the consortium meeting: Fellowship program - to be eligible you need to complete challenges and you were invited to cocreate the challenges themselves. After no engagement from you for over a month, again we invited you to get involved. Not much action there either.
- It has also been communicated on multiple occasions including during the consortium meeting, that coordination and alignment of communication and outreach happens during community calls, the contents of which are documented and posted online. The discussion about outreach and engagement strategy took place several weeks ago. You did not participate in it ( in spite of our having re-scheduled the day and time around your request). The documentation was posted online and responded to by others. Again no questions asked from you regarding outreach and communication: https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare-research/hangout-4-planning-open-care-outreach-efforts
- Had you actually read and acted upon the documentation from the call you would have seen:
"
16,25882,2016-04-20T11:56:57.000Z,24623,anon1526983854,anon2435658896,"Go right ahead!
No friction, Costa. I already wrote that you (and Luce, and any other designer out there) is welcome to go ahead and improve things. That's really not a problem. My comment is titled ""Thank you"", and I mean it.
In the call, we have been discussing something that is much more worrying to me, and does have the potential for friction: this project, as most European research projects, risks losing coherence, as partners drift apart form each other. I wrote about this already last week, and hopefully we can discuss it in the next call. I just wanted to signal that, in my oanon3606750899ion, this a much more important risk than the landing page, and that it deserves much more of your attention.
"
1,5470,2016-03-18T08:30:42.000Z,5470,anon2435658896,anon2435658896,"Hi,
the conversation about the Engagement/enrollment/building the community is pretty scattered.
collection of Nadia's proposals.
https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/home
https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/how-to-participate-in-op3ncare
https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/how-op3ncare-works
https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare challenges ?
https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/op3ncare-communications-planning
https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/film-video-planning
https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/op3ncare-resources
https://edgeryders.eu/en/groups/opencare/how-op3ncare-works-work-in-progress
https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/op3n-hangout-2-how-do-we-navigate-the-tension-between-asking
Recap of the Consortium Meeting
https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/opencare-kickoff-preliminary
[Fellowship Program] Timeline and rewards each partner can offer
https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/fellowship-program-timeline-and-rewards-each-partner-can
We're analysing all these material to react/collaborate.
Is there anything NEW to be considered?
Costantino
@anon70625510 @anon1491650132
"
2,10527,2016-03-18T10:47:03.000Z,5470,anon2971875139,anon2435658896,"Thanks Costantino for summarizing it all !
Can you please ask to your post the following info related to the Consortium?
https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/opencare-domain-names-and-trademark
https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/consortium-qa
Luce
"
3,16915,2016-03-19T12:17:37.000Z,5470,anon70625510,anon2435658896,"Join the call next week?
Hi Costantino :)
During the consortium meeting I suggested could do a fellow ship program as a way of acknowledging and rewarding different kinds of participation in the project. The above are the components of information that need to be in place in order for a participant to understand the project and know how to participate in it if we are going to go ahead with the Fellowship. But I feel that we did not get a clear response as to whether the rest of the partners are behind this or not...including weMake?
Noemi and I proposed that we ought to run theme-issue focused campaign, and started discussing some possible topics. Halfway through I realised that something was still missing. I came to London to connect with Patrick, test some ideas I had and to have a deeper conversation with Ezio about direction and curation. I have summarised what I think I understood from our conversation here: https://edgeryders.eu/en/comment/22010#comment-22010
So perhaps it is time to join one of the call to tighten up coordination of communication and engagement efforts?
"
4,19616,2016-03-20T21:08:59.000Z,5470,anon2435658896,anon2435658896,"next hangout
Hi @anon
on Tuesday afternoon me and @anon3612872438 will be on a plane to Shenzhen.
I really understand that we all (see https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/open-care-as-radical-socio-technical-innovation-reflecting-on#comment-22016) are talking of core things.
But I really appreciate something like a clear (or at least simple, essential) landing page that can be not scary for newcomers.
Is the work in progress in the Op3ncare section goes in that direction?
The landing page on the workspace right now is pretty confusing
I'm not good to design these kind of things but the friction to jump in is a little too high in my oanon3606750899ion.
About this I'd suggest:
let's focus on a streamline landing page with the essentials. Later on we'll implement all the add-on information that will came from the further advancement.
One last thing about the Topic/Room that i suggest to implement in some way in the workspace. The flow of the posts is very very diverse (from admin issue, to strategic and core discussion, to Local Activity ....) and therefore, in my oanon3606750899ion, messy. Is there a way to have topic / hashtag to differentiate the view for a general public?
"
5,23363,2016-03-21T07:41:15.000Z,5470,anon3612872438,anon2435658896,"Weekly calls
During consortium meeting we discussed about weekly online meeting and we decided not to have them.
That's why I interpreted the weekly google hangouts you proposed ,as meeting you were organizing for new people to be involved, and not internal meeting.
If we want to discuss specific topics let's do a doodle to see when's the best moment to hangout.
I agree with Costantino on the fact that it would be very important for communication strategy to allow people to distinguish what is internal/team communication and what is communication to involve new people and understand more about the project. That's because we, as a consortium team, are develoanon3606750899g a specific language and insights discourse that are becoming often unclear to whom are not in the topic or didn't follow the discussion since the beginning.
"
6,24737,2016-03-21T12:04:00.000Z,23363,anon70625510,anon3612872438,"Open Project
With respect to web presence there are two separate but linked spaces
A Project Workspace ( internal/team communication): https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare
A Project Participation Space (communication to involve new people and understand more about the project) : https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/home
In order to finalise and be able to go live with the Project Participation Space, we need to ensure that we have a coherent engagement engine to power participation in it.
From you and all the other partners we need to understand the following
- which topics and questions to drive the conversations/participation around. We have proposed 3 ones to begin with here, please leave a comment with a yes/no/maanon1932026148 so and helpful reflections about them here:
https://edgeryders.eu/en/comment/22010#comment-22010 https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/suicide-prevention-dementia-refugee-health-please-validate
- what kind of participation/contribution you need, at what times and how you intend to reward those efforts: https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/fellowship-program-timeline-and-rewards-each-partner-can
- we also need to receive the call for participation for partner's activities much further in advance than has been happening so far. please post all your intended activities as events here: https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/op3n-meetups
- We need much better documentation from the partners events than people have been posting so far. As this helps people to both understand and build research insights from the contents of those events. Think LOTE5 type documentation. We need both transcripts of what was said/discussed as well as more reflective, thoughtful blogposts for each event). As a reference please have a look at: https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5-doc.
- At the consortium meeting we proposed pooling together required contributions, activities etc and rewards into a fellowship program that can be offered to would-be participants. This would need to be tweaked again to meet the requirements of the partners, but roughly: https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/the-op3ncare-fellowship-program
"
7,25314,2016-03-21T21:50:14.000Z,24737,anon70625510,anon70625510,"Calls are tuesdays at 16:30 CET
This is the time we have agreed we can be available. Any and all topics for discussion can be had during those calls. They are for the coordination of the work, but in the spirit of truly open those calls are open for anyone who wishes to drop in. If there are questions or ssues or things to work on together, that is the available slot. We do this to cut down coordination costs, doodles etc. Same day same time every week.
"
8,25518,2016-03-21T22:09:22.000Z,25314,anon3612872438,anon70625510,"when was agreed?
unfortunately i'll never be able to participate because I have a similar call for another project on the same day of the week at same time :(
when did the decision take place and in which thread? You say ""we"" meaning the consortium or edgeryders?
best
Zoe
"
9,25578,2016-03-22T13:42:10.000Z,25518,anon70625510,anon3612872438,"During LOTE5
I think it was during the actual consortium meeting. 16:30 CET is a time that works well across several timezones. I am hosting the weekly calls and only working one day a week on OpenCare. If you prefer the Monday instead that is also an option. I don't care which day, only that it is the same day same time every week otherwise things get very messy very quickly. And early in the week = can plan for rest of it.
"
10,25610,2016-03-22T13:47:49.000Z,25578,anon70625510,anon70625510,"NB curt responses today
Attention being pulled in multiple directions because of Brussels incidents. Tone reply /= anything other than need for speedy comms.
"
11,26604,2016-03-21T20:34:18.000Z,5470,anon2435658896,anon2435658896,"Namig
I know it's not super super important but I suggest to go with
Opencare (main site)
and
Op3ncare as Project Workspace
if my previous proposal of having topic/hashtag or onother kind of structure of this workspace is not possible or very difficult.
As said before: I'll priorityse a simple streamline page with as less (and clear) information as possibile and enrich it along these week. agile.
"
12,27194,2016-03-21T21:45:12.000Z,26604,anon70625510,anon2435658896,"Redirect domain vs redo a lot of work
We are not going to change all the content of the opencare group. What we can do is redirect the opencare.cc domain so it points to https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/home
Regarding categorisation/ structuring of the workspace this is on the way, but the priority is finalising all the content of the public facing website i.e this: https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/home
If you are unhappy with that landing page, by all means produce a new landing page and all the related pages (design, copywriting, concept etc) and send it to me by the end of the week. We can do an A/B test for the landing page and loo at conversions. But I require the answers o the questions I and Noemi have already asked, but not yet recieved responses to.
"
13,28215,2016-03-23T13:01:38.000Z,5470,anon1491650132,anon2435658896,"A How To
Hi all, first thanks for your points addresing the online spaces and where we lack clarity. Listening to the comments, like @anon
As the person primarily responsible with community management - includes the OpenCare people already on Edgeryders but also new ones in the team and the broader network - I am putting together a community management plan that helps us:
1) navigate the project space ourselves (a routine as per Zoe's suggestion in Brussels; incorporate also hash-tags as per Costa's suggestion)
2) understand how to welcome new people (we are all community builders in OpenCare and I suspect we will learn to do it better and better, even if you don't yet see yourselves as such).
It is here:
https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/guide-for-building-our-online-community (check for a consistent version on April 1st)
It should be more relevant as we finish the public participation space (Op3nCare) where simple information will be posted to help you guys welcome people into the project. But that is dependent on your answers to the questions listed by Nadia above.. so looking forward! We will slowly move into our team routines as that info becomes clearer.
"
14,28621,2016-04-20T11:59:55.000Z,28215,anon70625510,anon1491650132,"Link to Guide for building online community is broken
https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare-research/guide-for-building-the-opencare-online-community
"
15,29362,2016-04-20T06:29:09.000Z,5470,anon2435658896,anon2435658896,"collecting bits of information
Hi,
only now we’re starting to understand the implementation of these actions.
This approach was really hard to understand for many reasons:
- during the consortium meeting you announced to us that you’re working on a bunch of documents and a prototype of the websites
- during the last weeks there were some posts asking for feedbacks on single pieces of this bigger plan (not having the proper feedback as you probably noticed)
- the folder Op3nCare Outreach and Engagement in the Opencare consortium shared Drive was not visible (at least to me) not giving me the opportunity to see that all these documents (and feedback) was part of a bigger thing
During the consortium meeting we explained to you WeMake’s roadmap, doing our best to summarize at least the following months (these months) in a single slide of our presentation
I expected some concise and understandable explanations about the Outreach strategy for a while then I tried to rise the flag kindly posting this post.
I think that we really need to have some moments or tools or format (written or live) to let the other partners be informed about the next months implementations of the project having the 10 miles overview in order to allow us to plan participation.
We, as a consortium, have already planned the next open call of April 28th.
I hope to find better (in terms of effectiveness) and more fluid (frictionless) information strategy.
Costantino
"
16,29657,2016-04-20T08:34:27.000Z,29362,anon70625510,anon2435658896,"Specific questions?
The weekly calls and the documentation from them is how we fine tune coordination and align our various efforts.
This where we discussed outreach including dates: https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare-research/hangout-4-planning-open-care-outreach-efforts
- you are very welcome to leave questions, comments add your own schedule/important dates etc
This is the guide for how we build the online community: https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare-research/guide-for-building-the-opencare-online-community
"
17,30179,2016-04-20T12:51:23.000Z,5470,anon1526983854,anon2435658896,"Here is a recap
I re-read the proposal (recommended, it's very very useful) and put together a short description of the engagement strategy, mapped onto the delivery structure contained in our Grant Agreement:
https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare-research/the-opencare-engagement-strategy-at-a-glance
I hope that's clearer now.
"
1,661,2016-04-12T14:22:22.000Z,661,anon1831568896,anon1831568896,"Globalization made us move and travel a lot. people are changing countries all the time. When you take a closer look at these people you realize how different the motivations of moving are, and depending on the motivation how different the goals and approaches are.
If you decide to go into another country because you are interested in the culture you will most definitely integrate yourself and be open for the odds and difference you will come across. If you are forced to move though, for example because there is a war in your home country the situation is completely different.
So on one hand we have the people who are moving maanon1932026148 even because it looks good in your cv if you have lived in Stockholm for a while and then we have people who are forced to leave their countries for economic reasons or/and because its dangerous for them to stay.
So lets think about the people who are forced to leave their countries, lets say they move to Germany. Maanon1932026148 because they have heard of Germany somewhere but maanon1932026148 even out of a coincidence because the help Organisation they first came across was German and then they where broad to Germany. If you think about coming into a country without even finding the culture interesting beforehand you can imagine that there are a lot of weird things and habits you will come across. Also from seeing the other culture you will change the view on your own culture. seeing the differences will make you understand your own culture from a new point of view. like for example if you see people eating with knife and fork and you usually eat with chopsticks thats a moment where you separate from the others and realize just what your culture is actually about.
This I find very interesting these cultures in cultures. I feel like there might even be a completely new interpretation of your own country. I can only think about food examples right now, like if you go to a restaurant and get „typical food“ and then you go to the country and they will never serve you that food, because its a new invention born out of a new interpretation from your own country and culture.
What I find really interesting also is the second Generation. They are born in a society and raised by two probably completely different point of views. They inhabit two cultures, two languages, two patterns of behavior. I see it as a great advantage but also it must be super hard to find yourself between these two poles. So hard to make stuff „right“ especially if right here and right there are the compete opposite.
If I think about my friends who are born in two cultures i have a deep respect for why they have already been through sometimes already in their childhood and what they are now. Its so amazing if you are able to understand two cultures and then maanon1932026148 even distance yourself and analyze the differences. Take the pieces that you like most and combine them. Its definitely a creative task. Well thats maanon1932026148 my naive way of seeing it because im not that much involved and even if i have been traveling a lot its very superficial and maanon1932026148 far from really understanding something.
What i´m asking myself is how to show what a great advantage the fusion of two culture can be. Not a clash of culture more a mergence. If you think about this in a really basic way a completely different point of view could probably open your eyes and make you creative.
Hacking and Making
To approach this task its important to firstly hack the habits of a culture.
Seeing stuff through the eyes of someone else is a really good step. When i visited my grandma this weekend i broad an old friend with me. My grandparents house is something so familiar to me that i lost the ability to see how interesting they actually are and how much cultural value they have. My friends curiosity had a huge impact on me. We had a very close look at all the objects in the house and talked a lot to my grandma about the past.
I understood my own origin in different way. And saw my culture through the eyes of someone else.
SO the questions that I'm asking myself are:
How can we show how great the merging of two cultures can be? fusion not clash of cultures
How can we overcome prejudice? or make use of prejudice?
How can we manifest respect and acceptance?
How can we be at eye level with one another ?
How can we make people look through the eyes of someone else?
How can we use the odds and peculiarities of a culture in a creative way?
and probably a lot more to come..
"
2,8668,2016-04-13T19:07:43.000Z,661,anon1491650132,anon1831568896,"""Culture in culture""
Heya, thanks for the piece of thought.
It reminded me of the story of Rete G2 shared by @anon
I find that food and arts are great equalizers in terms of making room for different identities to co-exist in a way that birthes new ones.
"
1,5485,2016-03-23T12:58:21.000Z,5485,anon1491650132,anon1491650132,"The purpose of this document is to help OpenCare project team and community members learn and master basic practices to help build a global network around the project. We outline core processes and tools deployed via https://edgeryders.eu and encourage anyone to step up and use these resources.
Table of Contents
We maintain two separate but linked spaces on the web:
A Research Workspace: edgeryders.eu/opencare-research
- displays basic information about Open Care as an EU funded project;
- contains all team communication threaded discussions
- interactive, live feed of the project
- designed in the spirit of openness (anyone can come in and share content) and ""working out loud"" (format which the team is committed to)
A Community space: opencare.cc
- for community members, old and new people or anyone wishing to understand more about how to participate in the project
- highly curated information about the project
- designed to explain to the broader community what opportunities the project provides
- redirects visitors to a space on edgeryders.eu and is also easily accesible from the main menu of the website (see it on the upper left side)
A proposed routine for quickly finding relevant info by project partners:
- Check your email notifications from contact@anon
- On the platform, start from the workspace. Filter content by clicking on ""Posts"", ""Wikis"", ""Tasks"" etc. so you only see those.
A proposed routine for making sure others see your content:
- Use the platform mentions in your texts - ""@anon
- To make it easier to find content in the working group, consider naming your new posts using the following structure (it makes it easier to find content by using the search form on Edgeryders):
[tag: Meta | Comms | Logistics | Events | Consortium | Reporting | Urgent etc] + title of the post
The simplest way is to point people to the Community site.
If someone learns about the project and lands on Edgeryders, there are several ways in, described in the How To Participate page: they can sign up on our mailing list, create a user account on the platform and follow or produce content to become involved. For people who prefer voice interaction, we have Meetups and a weekly Community Call through VOIP. All these are listed on the Meetups page.
All people who are signed up on edgeryders.eu become community members and agree to the Edgeryders official user, privacy and content licensing policy, made visible to them upon signup. Members can post on the website, a point at which they are officially welcomed by community managers. @anon
OpenCare is building its own consent funnel for participation. This is being developed by ScImpulse.
If you want to learn about Edgeryders community management practices, would like to share the work or become a community manager yourself join us here.
However, most Open Care project partners are someone's contact point for the project i.e. when we speak about OpenCare in public presentations, events, open consortium meetings, or when simply sharing information online. Open Care will be different things to different people - it will be general i.e. a way to come together around new care systems; or specific i.e. research looking into dementia and supporting the carers. And so on. It's your own responsibility to gauge potential interest from someone and point them to relevant information.
If there isn't relevant information available online, don't wait for others to do it! Go ahead and set up a post proposing a copy to be added to the Community base and edgeryders.eu admins will do it.
As we are spread all over the world, we meet and interact with Open Care community members here online, more than in any other settings. Publishing posts, reading each other and leaving comments to one another's contributions is how most of the interaction happens.
Content in OpenCare in shared in response to challenges. Challenges are assignments: we describe a problem (for example: what is your experience of giving and receiving care?) and ask the community to respond.
Good practice that you can adopt as much and as often as possible:
Only users who have created an account on Edgeryders and are logged in with their username and password can submit stories.
When submitting a story, the user is taken through a number of steps in order to clarify which challenge the story is answering, what personal question is the person trying to figure out, who would be an audience that they prefer, and what general topics they want to file the story under. The editing interface makes it possible to input text, links, to upload images or to embed video or audio files (using the HTML source).
When users create a new piece of content, the other community members who have contributed previously in OpenCare will receive an email notification. Same is true when someone comments other stories.
For a project with such a strong social networking element, it is absolutely essential that people can interact without mediation nor delay: having someone translate everything we post would be not only impossibly expensive: it would dampen interaction and feedback, making the Open experience quite miserable. To get around this problem, we have agreed to encode some rules in the social bargain of Open Care.
These are:
- you are welcome to write in your own language. People can always get the gist of what you are writing by running it through Google Translate; however, we encourage you to write in Euro English, the lingua anon317670948 the majority of young Europeans use when they move about. I wrote Euro English, and I specifically don't mean the Queen's English: the former is an inclusive, connecting language that most youth speak enough to communicate, the latter is just another language, with its own solid grammar, pronunciation niceties and idiosyncrasies. There are many more people that speak Euro English, than people who speak the Queen's English.
- Community members agree to be tolerant of each other's grammar or spelling mistakes. No one is allowed to look down at anyone else for this. We are not stupid or under-educated, we are just writing in a foreign language. Our effort to communicate deserves respect.
- Community members who are native speakers of English are kindly requested to keep in mind they are part of a global community, and make their own effort to write in a simple, clear manner.
Given the sensitivity of a topic like care, we are encouraging members to feel confortable writing online, but we are aware that this may not be the case for everyone. All our team members are aware of this setback and make it possible for people to submit materials or write their personal stories in two ways: 1) creating a user profile which is not linked in any way to their real identity and uploading content from that account or 2) emailing stories and have one of the Open Care curators upload for them.
All written content submitted in the OpenCare online spaces will be aggregated, coded and analysed by researchers and in agreement with our Data Strategy. For details about the Open Care research, see our original proposal available here (pp.18-19).
Meetups are offline or offline activities and events where community gets together. OpenCare partners and members are encouraged to run OpenCare activities and announce them as Meetups on the Community Space. They can be as small as a presentation at an conference, or a community Meet and Greet.
Partners are already receiving invitations to tell about OpenCare in conferences, university lectures, hackathons etc. Our criterion for accepting or rejecting these invitations is their potential for engagement. We do not recommend accepting last-minute invitations: allow a minimum of two weeks lead time. This way, all of us involved can spread the news that someone in our team is going to be presenting in venue X on day Y, and reach out to others who might join you.
Please post all your intended activities (online/offline, public meetings, conferences etc) as events in the Community space:
1. Click here.
2. Enter the information you have prepared for your session. Make sure you also include an image to act as a logo, it will make your event look better on the page. Logos for events are available here.
3. Enter your preferred date and time in the relevant fields.
4. Click Save, you're all set. The event will be listed on the Op3nCare Meetups page.
Now the next step is to build interest and discussion around your event, email and share the link in your own networks. Use \#op3ncare so we can help spread it through the Op3nCare social media accounts.
Hangouts are weekly, online and open events where anyone can join.
As of April 2016, hangouts happen every Monday at 4:30 PM CET. We are still looking for that perfect open source videoconferencing solution, so check the Events page and follow the instructions there.
Also known as Op3nCare community calls, they serve two purposes at the same time: team coordination and welcoming new people. If you're attending the next, make sure to set the agenda by leaving comments to them. Every weeks call will be listed on the Op3n Meetups page.
If you would like a call exceptionally scheduled, feel free to propose it, write, upload it, and run it (see Communicating your events above).
If you are running an activity in Open Care that needs a separate community event, feel free to propose it, write it, and run it (see Meetups section above).
The OpenCare research team is committed to publishing regular public posts to help community members keep track of what is going on and be able to plug in at any time. Posts in the OpenCare workgroup marked as such in their title (e.g. [Working out loud] Name of post). They are summaries of what needs your attention every 2 weeks, feeding in and out of the community calls. Written by @anon
An OpenCare list of supporters and interested people is growing. We send curated content collaborated by community to the list members no more than once a month. Sign up here.
If you want to include something in it, get in touch with Noemi.
Communication in Open Care is not centralized, it is distributed among all consortium partners, so we are using the channels collectively. To get access to the login info, get in touch with Nadia.
Shared project identity visuals, cover photos, thumbnail, partners logos etc are listed publicly here. Feel free to use, modify, re-purpose them as you wish (see License below).
A live repository of project updates is the workspace:OpenCare Research.
A repository of project documentation (including Consortium Agreement), copy, materials, photos, cover pages and other miscellaneous is located in the OpenCare shared Disclaimer
The oanon3606750899ions expressed in this website are the responsibility of their author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official policy of Edgeryders as a company, its directors, members or the organisations cooperating with it.
OpenCare by OpenCare Consortium is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
"
2,8795,2016-03-31T09:31:33.000Z,5485,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"April 15th - another deadline coming
Hi everyone,
We have another deadline (upcoming deliverable) :
WP2, Deliverable 2.1: Deployed, tested OpenCare online space on the production server
What we need to submit : presentation of the platform (structure, motives, scientfic outcomes) + links to the Op3nCare workspaces
When: by April 15th (if possible). We are already late - just let me know if this date sounds realistic or not.
"
3,11471,2016-03-31T09:41:38.000Z,8795,anon70625510,anon2971875139,"Why late?
The online space is live: http://opencare.cc what other work you are seeing being done is tweaks. Unless I am completely missing something?
Presentation of the platform: Do you have a template or questions we need to answer more specifically? It will not take long to do this and certainly before April 15 should not be a problem.
"
4,15606,2016-03-31T10:27:48.000Z,5485,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"Presentation
We are late according to the EC, since the platform was planned in the Annex 1 of the GA to be fully operational by the end of February and we should have submitted information by that time.
I think the delay may be acceptable by the EC, since we can explain in our reports that the platform was mainly ready in due time, that edgeryders introduced it during the kick-off, with extra adjustments related to users' comments/experiences being carried out in March.
Unfortunately, I don't have any specific template nor guidelines about the way we should present the plateform, the content is free.
We could prepare some short presentation (1 to 2 pages) using these themes: structure, motives, scientfic outcomes.
It could then relate to the Description of Action and could be used again for public dissemination (maanon1932026148?).
"
5,17609,2016-03-31T10:41:39.000Z,15606,anon70625510,anon2971875139,"Ok Ill set up a deck of slides
and we can put in the stuff we need there. Will try to get done by monday.
"
6,20758,2016-03-31T11:00:31.000Z,5485,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"Great, thanks !
Just let me know when you are ready. :)
"
7,24664,2016-04-06T12:18:50.000Z,5485,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"Any news ?
Hi Nadia,
Any news concerning the platform presentation ?
I know you've been busy those days - if you need more time, just let me know :)
"
8,25278,2016-04-06T13:48:24.000Z,24664,anon70625510,anon2971875139,"yes busy.
sorry. Back at end of week.
"
9,25457,2016-04-06T13:52:18.000Z,25278,anon70625510,anon70625510,"Necessary?
@anon
"
10,25553,2016-04-06T20:39:32.000Z,25457,anon1526983854,anon70625510,"Not sure – but here's an idea
The deliverable is the platform itself, not a report about the platform.
Here's a suggestion: this very wiki could serve as the documentation to that deliverable. We clearly need it, so time spent on it is not wasted; and it tells users and the team how to navigate the OC community space. So maanon1932026148 stick a Horizon 2020 logo into it; add a couple of screenshots (Nadia's slides, I guess), and send the EC, I don't know, a good-looking PDF file containing the link to the wiki?
@anon
"
11,25594,2016-04-07T05:03:09.000Z,25553,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"See things as a reviewer
Here is my view of things, and I am sure this is what Luce has in mind when asking any of us to provide reviewing material. @anon
The idea is to go as smoothly as possible with the reviewing process. The platform and its content -- as suggested by Alberto -- of course tells the story by itself, it's all there ! And it is a living thing, you see the organism in full if you take time to look at it in action.
But, but, *reviewers* (and I ask you to believe me, I've played that role quite a few times). You have to put yourself in the skin of a reviewer when deciding what/how/why to deliver. Think of this person, reading about OpenCare a week before the review (sometimes more, but reading ahead of time doesn't mean giving more time reviewing the project). Think of this person who wants to get information in a synthesized way, yet who wants to get a ""feeling"" about what's going on.
So, my take is, it's worth to put up a short, crisp, one or two pager that gives an overview of the deliverable. That tells this person where to go on the portal and what is to find there. You guys are professionnals at communicating ideas with so much enthusiasm. I am sure you all know what I am talking about.
I know time flies like an arrow. Reviewers don't like to dig for information, they don't like it when they need to summarize things themselves. Plus, when letting them do the work there is a risk that they don't focus on the right thing -- because yes, they come with their own set of glasses, with their domain of expertise that do not necessarily fit ours a 100% percent ... and well, OpenCare is quite a unique ""assemblage"" of people, isn't it?
"
12,25619,2016-04-07T07:29:00.000Z,25594,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"We have that
You misunderstand me, Guy. I propose to point [reviewers, the Commission] not to the platform itself, but to this wiki. Which is a 1200 words document that describes the processes – exactly your two pager. But with one advantage: we need it anyway, so it is in our best interest to write it clearly. This gets us rid of the hollow feeling of writing a deliverable that no one cares about, just another box ticked, that I have sometimes felt when doing funded research.
Makes sense now?
"
13,25632,2016-04-07T07:41:10.000Z,25619,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Well then --
-- we are on the same anon3003844599length (sounds French, ""sur la même longueur d'ondes""). I shouldn't be surprised after all :-) A two-pager wiki works fine. @anon
Anyway the point I make remains relevant for all subsequent deliverables. Adopting a reviewer-compatible standpoint makes reviewing material more efficient.
"
14,26912,2016-04-07T07:52:30.000Z,5485,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"One important aspect
Guy, I agree with you, we have to put ourselves in the reviewers' shoes when we have to submit information on the project to the Commission.
Alberto, if you wish to use the content of this wiki, this is fine with me, but my point is the following: this mini-presentation is also a mean now to come clear to the Commission but also to the public about the scientific interest of putting up this platform.
When I mean public, I do think of the people already following the project, who may find the wiki just fine, but I also think that each partner could further use this documentation to bring people here together, using our own networks.
"
15,27305,2016-04-07T08:02:10.000Z,26912,anon1526983854,anon2971875139,"Agree
Ok, settled then:
- We improve the wiki.
- We point the Commission to the wiki
- We spread its content. We normally spread content in the form of links: in practice, it means that you share (by email, or Twitter, or whatever) a short message that says ""We have made XYZ, it's really interesting. Check it out here: [link]."" If the [link] points to our own online space, even better: people who are intrigued can very easily find out more, and even start participating.
@anon
"
16,28433,2016-04-07T08:54:36.000Z,5485,anon1526983854,anon1491650132,"Questions on the wiki
I have done a first editing pass. I have some question.
The most important: we are now live, but our consent funnel is not ready. ScImpulse has designed it, but not yet deployed. Is this OK? @anon4116418727, what do you say as the person in charge of ethics?
General question: it seems the wiki is written with the OpenCare team in mind, but in the beginning it says
The purpose of this document is to help OpenCare project team and members joining edgeryders.eu [...]
Less important: what do we mean by ENGAGEMENT TOOLS WE ARE USING - DASHBOARD? There is no dashboard other than this, but that has got nothing to do with social media, meetups etc. I propose to eliminate that.
@anon
"
17,28717,2016-04-07T11:16:55.000Z,28433,anon1491650132,anon1526983854,"Engagement dashboard
Thanks for updating the wiki with more relevant info. The dashboard was meant to be a nice page/visualization with all the places people can engage with. At the moment this is probably all the community space - with its different pages. Scraanon3606750899g the formulation from the wiki then.
"
18,29010,2016-04-11T08:12:52.000Z,28433,anon2971875139,anon1526983854,"Ready to go?
Hello,
As I see you keeanon3606750899g the wiki updated - just tell me when we are good to go with the delivery to the EC. Thanks ! :)
"
19,29028,2016-04-12T10:28:21.000Z,29010,anon1491650132,anon2971875139,"This iteration done!
anon3606750899g @anon
"
20,29036,2016-04-12T12:05:26.000Z,29028,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"Great !
I'll double-check and submit it :)
Thanks again,
Luce
"
21,29521,2016-04-08T17:47:57.000Z,5485,anon281534083,anon1491650132,"Make this wiki more prominent?
Given its improtance, shouldn't this wiki be linked around the top of the OpenCare Research page? ALso, I would put a link to Nadia's recent presentation someplace prominent as well.
As Guy said about what reviewers want and don't want, it's also crucial to always remember how fresh eyes will see the site and what actions they are likely to take once they get here.
"
22,30299,2016-04-08T18:11:00.000Z,5485,anon281534083,anon1491650132,"I found it on the other OC page
https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare-community/resources
I have to admit I get them sort of mixed up. But I can also see that if you go to the ER homepage, then click projects you can see the two choices. But now I would say, given the importance of OC, why not put a discreet link to it righ there on the first page and avoid that extra clicking?
"
23,30437,2016-04-09T11:34:53.000Z,30299,anon1491650132,anon281534083,"Thanks for the suggestion
Added on the Op3nCare homepage! I guess I was expecting this wiki to reach more structure and consistency. If there are things we're missing or questions we should answer in it don't hesitate to add them.
"
24,30872,2016-04-13T12:38:31.000Z,5485,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"One last thing to do
Hello,
@anon
I will therefore need you to explain in a paragraph why links to the OpenCare platform are submitted in in April instead of February (planned in the DoA).
As I already posted, it sounds acceptable to explain that the platform was mainly ready in due time, that edgeryders introduced it during the kick-off by the end of February, with extra adjustments related to users' experiences being carried out in March.
You also have to describe the impact this delay has on your activity as foreseen for WP2 (using more person-months, needing extra staff, or else).
"
25,30986,2016-04-13T13:36:32.000Z,30872,anon70625510,anon2971875139,"We decided to prioritise the work of doing outreach
As part of our outreach and engagement work, Edgeryders brokered an agreement with the College of Architecture, Media and Design at Berlin University of the Arts (UdK Berlin) around a new course in which we involve students in the OpenCare research project: http://hackingutopia.cre8tives.org/about/
The agreement was finalised in mid february. While the website was already online by then as agreed, we decided to prioritise preparation of the course as an effective outreach and engagement opportunity and to finalise validation of the website design and contents based first experiences of using it as the primary collaboration, interaction and documentation space for the course activities. My documentation from the first day of the opening 4-day workshop: https://edgeryders.eu/en/you-and-me-and-everyone-we-know-the-many-faces-of-care
The Final exhibition has now been announced http://www.designtransfer.udk-berlin.de/en/projekt/hacking-utopia/
Exhibition has now been announced here:
"
26,31346,2016-04-18T14:52:51.000Z,5485,anon2971875139,anon1491650132,"Submitted !
WP2, Deliverable 2.1: Deployed, tested OpenCare online space on the production server - SUBMITTED :)
A copy of the document is stored under the OpenCare Admin file, see Deliverables.
"
27,31691,2016-04-18T15:26:16.000Z,5485,anon2774142051,anon1491650132,"Good work
Thanks Luce for reporting on the successfull submission of deliverable 2.1
It's not as if I did not know about it :-) I added a few words myself to the accompanying document. I invite all to have a look, the few additions I made to Nadia and Alberto's text aimed at facilitating the work of reviewers: helanon3606750899g them to get the idea, identify the relevant resources and in this case easily access them on the web.
"
1,5563,2016-04-18T10:22:42.000Z,5563,anon3895445472,anon3895445472,"This is described as ""a dialogic event for Health and Social Care Professionals and concerned Citizens who want to work together to transform Care in the UK.""
Date: 2016-04-27 10:45:00 - 2016-04-27 11:15:00, Europe/London Time.
URL: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/our-power-to-create-the-new-story-of-care-tickets-22646477223"
1,655,2016-04-05T09:36:32.000Z,655,anon1566739727,anon1566739727,"English translation here.
Was bedeutet für dich care?
Ich würde sagen dass es auf jeden fall dieser gedanke mich wahnsinnig fasziniert, ganz stark ganz individuell bei uns selbst anzufangen und erstmal dafür zu sorgen dass wir in der glücklich sind mit dem was wir machen um das auf andere menschen zu übertragen und überhaupt in der lage zu sein diese unterstützung weiterzugeben an diejenigen die uns umgeben. Weil ich an mir selber einfachm merke dass ich wenn ich selber überfordert bin oder nicht glücklich bin, dass ich dann komplett zumache und gar nicht so zugänglich bin für die menschen um mich herum und ihre bedürfnise wahrnehmen kann und meine rolle erfüllen würde so wie ich das wollen würde. Und das hat für mich auch ganz viel mit den strukturen in denen wir uns bewegen zu tun. Ich beschäftige mich viel mit dem gedanken wie will ich leben und wie will ich arbeiten weil ich das selber noch nicht weiß. Weil die modelle in meiner arbeit oder uni mich nicht erfüllt haben und ich nicht das gefühl habe mein potenzial nicht voll ausfüllen zukönnen. Weil ich mich frage: für wen mache ich das eigentlich? Das war meist in meinem leben: andere zufrieden zu stellen, also meine eltern oder die erwartungen der gesellschaft zu erfüllen. Also eine gewisse rolle zu spielen. Und ich merke dass ich da einfach immer so an diesen punkt komme dass ich so blockiere und so einen shutdown kriege und dann einfach zwei wochen nicht weiterarbeiten kann – weil ich die relevanz einfach auch nicht habe etwas zu tun, das eben auch nicht gesellschaftlich wirksam ist.
Diese trennung von leben auf der einen und arbeit auf der anderen seite finde ich persönlich ganz schwierig weil wir den größten teil unseres lebens ja mit arbeit verbranon1056199097n müssen oder auch wollen aber das heisst dass die arbeit die wir tun, sollte ja auch irgendwie integriert sein in unser leben und ich habe das gefühl dass sie es eben nicht tun.
Hast du ne idee wie das für dich funktionieren könnte?
Ja, also auf jeden fall fnde ich so ansätze wie die sicherung der existenz, sei es in form von nem grundeinkommen, dass du einfach etwas tun weil du es einfach tun möchtest. Ich glaube daran dass wir menschen schon das bedürfnis haben etwas zu tun, an etwas zu arbeiten, nicht primär weil wir geld verdienen wollen, sondern weil es etwas ist was wir tun möchten. Und das rauszufinden, was wir wirklich tun wollen, das wäre wichtig für mich. Was würde ich tun wenn ich nichts tun müsste? Ich glaube, dass wir nie in diesen Zustand wirklich kommen weil wir uns immer darum sorgen müssen, wie bezahle ich meine miete, wie bezahle ich mein essen ... es bleibt kein raum mehr dafür danon1056199097 zu tun die wir tun würden wenn wir uns nicht darum sorgen müssten, was wir tun müssen um zu überleben. Gut und überleben... wir befinden uns ja schon in nem system das uns unser existenzminimum mehr oder weniger sichert, was ber immer auch verbunden ist mit barrieren und einem gewissen stigma....
Das du dann auch zu wenig geld hast und zu wenig selbstvertrauen um das zu tun was du tun willst. Auch wenn du hartz 4 beziehst musst du dich permanent rechtfertigen für deine situation, du musst xy viele bewerbungen schreiben um dich zu bemühen, irgendwie eanon1056199097gliedert zu sein und kannst jetzt nicht irgendwie sagen ich beziehe hartz 4 und mache jetzt kunst und schreibe ein buch, weil das system einfach nicht funktioniert.
Care wäre für mich ein zustand von selfcare und dann ausgehend davon zeit und ressourcen zu eröffnen um für andere da zu sein oder andere in irgend einer form zu bereichern für das was ich selber tun kann.
Also erst indem du für dich selbst sorgst kannst du auch für jemand anderen sorgen?
Ja, also erst wenn du nicht abhängig bist von bestimmten sachen bist du erst in der lage dazu, für andere da zu sein und dein potenzial auszuschöpfen. Vor allem auch zeit, die zeitressource ist ein wichtiger faktor, um für andere da zu sein.
"
2,9505,2016-04-17T10:25:19.000Z,655,anon1491650132,anon1566739727,"What is your entourage like?
Oh, this is familiar. I've read so many stories on Edgeryders where young people ask this very same questions, myself included. Then what helped me was spending time with others and realising that we're all in the same boat and this is not a personal dillemma, it's a collective one. Finding each other really gives you a sense of support, somehow it helped my mind get over the fact that there is a problem. Then things would only get easier in time, because you surround yourself with people who are like you - not only that they feel the same (most everyone does!) but that they talk about it in the same uncompromising way. What is your entourage like?
Have you read @anon
Oh an @anon
"
1,5559,2016-04-15T10:00:58.000Z,5559,anon70625510,anon70625510,"
You may remember that some time ago I mentioned that @anon
More specifically the frustration with outdated design education that ill prepares students to be able to do meaningful work with their skills and talents. We feel that this should start already during their education so by the time they have graduated they are already up and running their own exciting projects that really contribute towards tackling some of the bigger challenges which affect us all. After a lot of work over the past couple of months, especially by Susa, the partnership agreement between Edgeryders and UDK was finalised and last week we launched the first ever edition of this course with a four-day intense workshop.
Over the next six months each student will be working on design research and product development process that departs from the OpenCare topic and methodologies. They will be doing it in synch with the phases of the larger OpenCare research project. The course participants' documentation and individual reflections from each day are uploaded in the Op3nCare Community Homebase where you are very welcome to leave comments helanon3606750899g them develop their thinking and projects. Or better yet: follow the course and take on the tasks yourself! it's a fun way to unleash some of your creative urges while maanon1932026148 picking up some new skills...and contributing to the common good :) You may even be eligible for the new fellowship program we are building!
Why do this? You get to see the OpenCare topic and challenges from many different perspectives and help shape the students research and product development work so they really are contributing to the Opencare research project. For the students getting feedback from you is an unparalleled way to discover new knowledge and broaden their horizons about what is happening in the fields relevant to all our work.
The results of the students work will be exhibited in Berlin at Designtransfer UDK and it looks like some of them might run crowdfunding campaigns on StartNext.
Opening: Wednesday, 20 July, 19.00
Exhibition: 21 July– 24 July, 10.00–18.00
Address: Designtransfer UdK, Einsteinufer 43-53, 10587 Berlin
Concept: GastProf. Susanne Stauch/ID2 & Nadia EL-Imam/Edgeryders
Team: GastProf Dr. Martin Kiel/GWK, Prof. Jozef Legrand, KM Sarah-Lena Walf, KM Johanna Dehio, Valentina Karga, Svenja Bickert-Appleby, Ludwig Kannicht, Laura Straßer, Björn Weigelt
Date: 2016-07-20 19:00:00 - 2016-07-24 18:00:00, Europe/Brussels Time."
1,659,2016-04-09T17:12:46.000Z,659,anon1612430491,anon1612430491,"
1. What is the problem/question you are trying to solve/explore? Frame it as a design question!
How to not push someone to a place or activity but make it come to them?
What actually pulls you towards something, towards doing something?
2. State the ultimate impact you would like to have. What would make you feel like you did something meaningful with your time?
We would like to understand what motivates people to do stuff that they enjoy doing.
3. What are some possible solutions to your problems or ways to answer your question? Think broadly. It's fine to start a project/learning process with a hunch or two, but make sure you allow for surprises.
What does personal motivation in general mean? What makes people like (care for) something? What sparks interest and motivation in people? What creates flow?
How can we break the logical answer mechanism in people? What interview techniques spark an elaborate answer beyond „because I like it!“
4. Write down some of the context and constraints that you are facing. They could be geographic, technological, time-based, or have to do with the population you’re trying to reach.
Since we haven’t decided on a population that we would like to support, we might face these constraints later. Though we don’t have a precise question that could lead to a fuzzy challenge. We still need to find a point to start a design intervention from.
5. Does your original question need a tweak? Try it again.
What are the mechanics behind the moment/process of people being driven towards doing something they care about. It is about the point between an intrinsic intention and an action.
"
2,7992,2016-04-10T16:15:50.000Z,659,anon1491650132,anon1612430491,"A recommended reading
Hi @anon
There are more insights from working in Nepal which might be of help to you. Here it is: Earthquakes create movements - but can we?
"
3,11202,2016-04-10T20:15:42.000Z,7992,anon1612430491,anon1491650132,"Thanks! @anon
Thanks Noemi! I will look into it!!!
"
3,14782,2016-04-09T11:55:07.000Z,5518,anon1491650132,,"How to create events in the community space
Hi @anon
For reference, maanon1932026148 the Guide we set up will help you in the use of the online environment
"
4,20197,2016-04-09T13:13:03.000Z,5518,anon2435658896,,"For the past events
Hi @anon1491650132,
do you think we need to create Meetups post also for past events?
"
5,23762,2016-04-09T13:39:05.000Z,5518,anon2435658896,,"Meetups issue
Hi,
is it possible to allow comments to Meetups?
Hi think that it's the right place to post question or comments about the Meetups!
What do you think?
@anon
"
6,24916,2016-04-10T16:37:40.000Z,23762,anon1491650132,anon2435658896,"I don't know
I was wondering too. The reason why comments are now disabled in the Meetups is to focus all conversations there on stories (Challenges page) with all the pages read-only for easy navigation by first time users..
Ideally we post documentation after the events in our research group.
This is still open for ideas, there's no best solution, what do you think?
"
1,660,2016-04-10T13:32:56.000Z,660,anon200914115,anon200914115,"what does care mean to you?
Umsorgen, Allgemeinwohl
- wenn es Teilen einer Gesellschaft schlecht geht, für sie gesorgt wird (im Optimalfall von denen den es besser geht)
- nicht nur wenn es irgendwelchen Menschen schlecht geht, sondern allgemein für das Allgemeinwohl zu sorgen
Wie achtest du auf Andere oder wie willst du, dass auf dich geachtet wird?
- nicht nur, dass mir geholfen wird wenn es mir schlecht geht sondern, dass darauf auch geachtet wird
- ich habe immer das Gefühl, dass Care der Staat durch Krankenkassen dafür zuständig sind
- ich denke immer an meinen Nachbarn, der ein psychologisches problem hatte, aber sich keiner darum gekümmert hat
Wie carest du?
- ich care so, als dass ich sensibel auf mein Umfeld bin
- utopisches Endziel ist: dass es alle aufeinander aufpassen und niemand allein gelassen wird
- wenn der Carebedürftige ein Gesicht bekommt und ich eine Beziehung zu der Person aufbauen kann, wird besser gekehrt
Wann ist care keine Last?
- Aufgaben spielerisch verpacken
- Verantwortung verteilen
- Perspektive: Aufteilung Notleidender und Helfender… dass die Rollenverteilung immer so fest ist
wie trägst du dazu bei, dass der Einstieg von Leuten in eine Gruppe vereinfacht wird?
- Austauch
- wieder: Rollenverteilung: extern intern
"
2,7942,2016-04-10T15:06:14.000Z,660,anon1491650132,anon200914115,"Look forward to learn more
Hi @anon
Good luck with your course!
"
1,5540,2016-04-09T18:28:18.000Z,5540,anon3227838693,anon3227838693,"BRIEF \#2
HU = Hacking Utopia Project UDK
OC = OpenCare Research Project
Task#1: Team meeting
Deliverable: HU
Time: 1.5 hours
Deadline: asap
Watch: Marlieke Kieboom http://bit.ly/1qE4EFW
Instructions:
1. considering the theme you picked for your FEED FWD research, identify the people you want to design for and where you can find them.
2. think of a welcoming, trust building ""open office"" idea you could easily pop up in the environment where you will do your research.
3. prepare some questions according to our FEED FWD INTERVIEW GUIDE (LINK) to help you understand more about the people's context.
4. Define roles in the team: preparation, documentation (written/foto/video), transcription, upload
- - - -
Task#2: Feed Fwd Field Trip
Deliverable: HU/OC
Time: collect 10-15 stories
Deadline: Monday, 9.5. (ideally a couple of days before, see Task#3)
Make: Build Open Office
Instructions:
1. go out and do it!
2. stay in your roles within one interview but make sure to switch roles throughout the task (1 person speaks, 1 person takes notes, 1 person takes photo/video)
3. take notes about the process: what went well, what failed, why, discuss it in the team, learn and share in the next group meeting.
- - - -
Task#3: Transcription of Interviews & Upload
Deliverable: HU/OC
Time: 1-2 days
Deadline: Monday, 9.5.
Instructions:
1. check out the interview guideline (HERE) and do your transcription accordingly
2.
3.
- - - -
Task#5: (ongoing) Research- General/Intuitive
Deliverable OC / HU
Time: open
Deadline: Monday 9.5.
Instructions:
1. Based on the topic and question defined in your design challenge, do online research looking for relevant and inspiring Groups, Projects, Places, Products, Technologies, Tools, Services or Infrastructures.
2. Collect everything in a thoughtful text with images and links, if possible by 25.4.
3. Upload the post as a first step towards building your case studies here bit.ly/23gdz1i
4. If you want feedback, further references etc on what you presented during day 1, just upload your speaker notes- we’ll sort out the rest.
5. Please respond to questions and feedback from your peers as well as members of the edgeryders/opencare community team who can help you to develop sharp case studies through their input
- - - -
"
1,5539,2016-04-09T17:52:11.000Z,5539,anon3227838693,anon3227838693,"BRIEF \#1
HU = Hacking Utopia Project UDK
OC = OpenCare Research Project
Task#1: sign up for project (missing information)
Deliverable HU
Time: 2 minutes
Deadline: Sunday, 10.4.
Instructions: Community manager's not: URL removed for privacy
- - - -
Task#2: Personal Profile
Deliverable OC
Time: 1/2 hour
Deadline: Sunday, 10.4.
Instructions:
Make it easier for us to connect you with one another based on complimentary interests and skills by completing your personal profile on edgeryders.eu:
1. Login to the platform https://edgeryders.eu/en/user/login
2. Go to your profile page: bit.ly/1MilNyk
3. Upload your picture (the portraits that Bjorn took are all available to download here)
4. Update your bio with the following information (from the collaboration mosaic exercise we did on the last day of the workshop: http://bit.ly/23kttrx)
a. Your practical skillset (pick from list / add what's missing)
b. What you are interested in learning during this course
c. What you are interested in offering/contributing
- - - -
Task#3: Upload content from workshop
Deliverable OC / HU
Time: 1 hour
Deadline: Tuesday, 12.4.
Instructions:
1. Pull out your documentation from the listening triads on care (exercise from day 1 when you were split into groups of three)
2. Open a word processing document and write down your reflections around one or more of the following themes in the context of care (if you didn't talk about care or one of the questions we had on the wall, repeat the conversation on skype or talk to yourself):
1. People on the move.
2. Boosting one another’s mental and spiritual resilience
3. Hacking and Making
4. Open Science and Technologies
5. Communities & interpersonal relationships
6. Food cultures
3. Copy-paste and upload your reflections here bit.ly/1VcakTB
- - - -
Task#4: Frame your design challenge
Deliverable OC / HU
Time: 1 hour
Deadline: Tuesday, 12.4.
Read: HCD Field Guide p. 31-33 (http://www.designkit.org/resources/1 or dropbox)
Instructions:
1.Repeat the exercise ""Frame your design challenge"" by picking one of the questions from the list we came up with on day 2 (http://bit.ly/1N10AsZ) and uploading your responses to the questions on this page: bit.ly/1oGV3fw
2. Please respond to questions and feedback in the comments as we will give you feedback on your question
3. Refine your question by the 25.4.
- - - -
Task#5: Research- General/Intuitive
Deliverable OC / HU
Time: open
Deadline: Monday 2.5. (if possible Monday 25.4.)
Instructions:
2. Based on the topic and question defined in your design challenge, do online research looking for relevant and inspiring Groups, Projects, Places, Products, Technologies, Tools, Services or Infrastructures.
3.
4. Collect everything in a thoughtful text with images and links, if possible by 25.4.
5. Upload the post as a first step towards building your case studies here bit.ly/23gdz1i
6. If you want feedback, further references etc on what you presented during day 1, just upload your speaker notes- we’ll sort out the rest.
7. Please respond to questions and feedback from your peers as well as members of the edgeryders/opencare community team who can help you to develop sharp case studies through their input
- - - -
Task#6: Personal Profile on cre8tives.org
Deliverable HU
Time: 1 minute
Deadline: Sunday, 24.4.
Instructions:
sign up on cre8tives.org and we do the rest
"
1,5535,2016-04-09T13:16:52.000Z,5535,anon2435658896,anon2435658896,"The second free hands-on workshop of the \#opencare series will take place this next Thursday 7 april in Milan at ‘5 Forum delle politiche sociali’. Come and learn how to create an \#IoT \#opensource service to monitor and take care of your loved ones remotely.
Here Forum program in italian:
http://mediagallery.comune.milano.it/cdm/objects/changeme:56745/datastreams/dataStream1980833562874032/content?pgpath=/SA_SiteContent/PARTECIPA/FORUM_INIZIATIVE/Forum_delle_politiche_sociali/5_Forum
If you have the possibility to come, drop us a line: opencare@anon
Date: 2016-04-07 14:00:00 - 2016-04-07 14:00:00, Europe/Rome Time."
1,650,2016-04-04T21:13:53.000Z,650,anon3227838693,anon3227838693,"What is care? To start with such a question a lot comes to mind. Especially after this intense first day of our project kick-off at Sauen, with all these great thoughts, ideas and reflections about what it means to be a human being. I am personally fascinated by the cognitive dissonance I find myself stuck in. This applies to so many aspects of my life. Yes, talking is easy, acting takes effort. It's the same with design, having a nice idea over a glass of wine in the evening? No big deal. But bringing it into life, really doing it and going against all obstacles is a totally different thing. It needs energy, dedication, belief, trust, confidence, help. You need to CARE about it enough to put it into action. So that's one aspect of care. That something/someone has enough value or meaning for somebody to be considered with putting real physical action into it. Usually this is the fact when we are affected personally. When it's a personal thing. When we are involved. When we are touched. When we are concerned.
The expression ""taking care of something"" as a German is a rather rational, dry and goal-oriented task. It somehow misses the core of its literal meaning which is a soft, emotional and gentle interaction. So how do we define this word? How does the culture we live in put it into action? How is it valued, honored? Who should we care for, what should we take care of and most importantly: what is so dear to us that we want to take care of it? Are we being taken care of enough to give something back? We discussed the question of how can something seemingly burden full turn into a joyful engagement. How can we overcome this cognitive dissonance and what is that undefined obstacle that holds us back. Because it's not laziness. It's not carelessness. Maanon1932026148 it's a combination of helplessness (of where to start, what to focus), being overwhelmed (by one's own life and tasks) and alone (with an ambition too big for one person). And maanon1932026148 the answer of today is community.
"
3,14454,2016-04-07T21:22:48.000Z,650,anon1491650132,anon3227838693,"The grey areas
Thanks @anon
"
1,493,2016-04-01T09:06:06.000Z,493,anon959394994,anon959394994,"_Post was originally authored by Dougald Hine on 2013-10-30 08:39:00 +0100_
In one of his darkly observant essays on the fall of the Soviet Union and its lessons for present-day America, Dmitri Orlov advises against being a successful middle-aged man :
> When their career is suddenly over, their savings gone and their property worthless, much of their sense of self-worth goes as well. They tend to drink themselves to death and commit suicide in disproportionate numbers. Since they tend to be the most experienced and capable people, this is a staggering loss to society. (Reinventing Collapse, p.122-3)
The spike in mortality that accompanied the fall of the Soviet Union has few parallels in history. Between 1987 and 1994, life expectancy dropped from 70 to 64, and the group whose likelihood of dying increased most sharply was, indeed, working age men. In other words, despite the material hardships of the period, it was not the weakest and most vulnerable who died in greater numbers, but the physically strong: what was most deadly about the collapse was not the disappearance of the means of staying alive, but the lack of ends for which to stay alive.
Europe is not going through a Soviet-style collapse. (Or not yet: a report from UBS Investment Research in September 2011 estimated the costs of a break-up of the Eurozone at 40-50% of weaker countries’ GDP in the first year and 20-25% of the GDP of countries like Germany. For comparison, the total fall in GDP during the break-up of the USSR is estimated at 45%, spread over the years from 1989 to 1998.) The point I want to draw from Orlov, however, is that there is a powerful and complex interrelation between how we make a living and how we make sense of our lives. The consequences of an economic crisis can both lead to and be made worse by the crisis of meaning experienced by those whose lives it has derailed. If this is the case, however, perhaps it is also possible that action on the level of meaning might stem and even reverse the consequences, personal and social, of failing economic systems?
The figure of the ‘graduate with no future’, identified by Paul Mason, has the advantage of youth, yet in other ways she resembles Orlov’s successful middle-aged man. People are capable of enduring great hardship, so long as they can find meaning in their situation, but it is hard to find meaning in the hundredth rejection letter. The feeling of having done everything right and still got nowhere leads to a particular desperation. Against this background, the actions of those who might identify with Mason’s description - whether as indignados in the squares of Spain, or as Edgeryders entering the corridors of Strasbourg and Brussels - are not least a search for meaning, for new frameworks in which to make sense of our lives when the promises that framed the labour market for our parents no longer ring true.
Four years ago, in ‘The Future of Unemployment’, I suggested that it might be helpful to distinguish three types of need which, broadly speaking, we have looked to employment to provide. I want to return to this model as a way of structuring a search for examples of effective action on the level of meaning. Departing slightly from the original terms, I would summarise these types of need as follows:
- Economic/Practical: How do I pay the rent?
- Social/Psychological: Who am I in the eyes of others?
- Directional: What do I get out of bed for in the morning? And where do I see myself in the future?
Those who find it difficult to access the labour market are also likely to find answering these questions more difficult. The stories shared on the Edgeryders platform during 2011-12 illustrate the variety of ways in which young people find their access the labour market limited: not only through unemployment, but underemployment, casualisation and the prevalence of short-term contracts, the increasing cost of education in certain countries, the role of unpaid internships as a path to accessing certain industries. Where skills and qualifications have been acquired through formal education, many find themselves unable to secure work that makes use of these; where skills are acquired informally, the challenge is to represent these effectively to potential employers. Above all, the situation is defined by the interaction between two major processes: a long-term change in the structure of European labour markets, offering new entrants a poorer deal than had been the case for their parents’ generation, has been exacerbated by the effects of the economic crisis that began in 2008.
If the situation of those struggling to access the labour market can be expressed in terms of the three types of need set out above, we might note that the last two belong primarily to the domain of meaning: our ability to answer them is closely related to our ability to make sense of our lives. Based on this, I suggest that we look for two stages in projects that might constitute effective action on the level of meaning: first, the ability to substitute for employment in providing social identity and a sense of direction; and, second, the potential for this to lead to new means of meeting practical needs.
With this structure in mind, I want to consider briefly a few examples which I think offer clues to what this may look like in practice.
Centers for New Work: During the collapse in employment in the US auto industry in the early 1980s, the philosopher Frithjof Bergmann worked with employers, unions and community organisations in Flint, Michigan to create the Center for New Work. ‘We are in the beginning of a great scarcity of jobs,’ Bergmann argued, ‘but not of work.’ Instead of making redundancies, he proposed that employers share out the remaining jobs on a rotating work schedule. Workers would alternate between extended periods in traditional industrial work and similar periods pursuing ‘New Work’. The latter included local production to meet practical needs, but also the right of everyone to spend a significant amount of their time pursuing a personally meaningful project.
Access Space: In Sheffield, England - another post-industrial city, similarly hit by unemployment in the early 1980s - the artist James Wallbank and friends set up what has become the UK’s longest-running free internet learning centre. As described by NESTA, ‘The centre brings together old computers and new open source software to create a radical, sustainable response to industrial decline and social dislocation.’ In conversation, Wallbank has emphasised to me the importance of the social and directional role of participation at Access Space: for those who have been long-term unemployed, the change in the shape of their lives on becoming a regular participant is often huge; by comparison, the change from being a regular participant to entering employment is relatively small. From my own observation, another key aspect of the Access Space model is the power of its insistence on self-referral: this means that participants are drawn from a range of social and economic backgrounds, rather than exclusively from a target group identified by its deprivation. This means that participation at the centre provides an alternative to - rather than a reinforcement of - a negative social identification.
West Norwood Feast: In 2010-11, the agency I founded led a project to co-create a community-owned and -run street market in south London. This experience reaffirmed my sense of the power of what people can do when they come together to work on something that matters to them. In particular, talking to those involved, I was struck by how positively many of them experienced using their skills as part of the Feast, when compared to their experience in regular employment. Might it be that work that takes place outside of employment is more likely to be experienced as meaningful? And, if so, why? Several possible answers exist. The psychologist Edward Deci famously demonstrated that being paid for a task tends to decrease our intrinsic motivation, a phenomenon he explains in terms of the shift of the ‘locus of motivation’. Meanwhile, as I argued in ‘The Future We Deserve’, the logic of maximising productivity has made industrial-era employment an unprecedentedly anti-social form of work. More practically, though, are there ways we can build a better relationship between meaningful work and our ability to pay the rent?
House concerts: The music industry has been through huge disruption since the 1990s, not least as a result of the rise of filesharing. The solo bass player Steve Lawson is an example of an independent musician who has spent his career develoanon3606750899g new models for making a living and documenting the realities of this on his blog. He sells downloads of his albums on a pay-what-you-want basis and makes ‘house concert’ tours on which he plays in the front rooms of fans, many of whom have first met him online. Reading his accounts of this, two things are clear: first, that these models, drawing on the strengths of networked technologies, allow for a far more meaningful relationship with his audience than was possible in the music industry of the pre-Napster era; and, second, that house concerts also make touring economically viable for independent musicians in a way that was harder when playing traditional venues. Are there other areas in which socially-embedded grassroots economies can thrive where high-overhead conventional economies struggle? (For another take on the potential of low-overhead economic models, see Kevin Carson’s The Homebrew Industrial Revolution.)
The Unmonastery: One of the projects to emerge from the first phase of Edgeryders was a proposal for something called an Unmonastery: ‘a creative refuge bound to host problem solvers and change makers, who together work to solve (g)local problems, in exchange for board and lodging.’ At present, this proposal is being developed by a group that met through the Living on the Edge events in 2012. The initial response suggests that young people are willing to take a step down in their material expectations, if this is banon3760936673ced by sufficient security and autonomy to pursue work which they believe matters. The challenge will be to develop a vehicle for this willingness which is capable of ‘interfacing’ with existing institutions and accessing resources, which can achieve a reasonable degree of stability, and which does not devolve into a mechanism for exploitation. Daunting as this sounds, it is likely that we will see more experiments along these lines in Europe in the years ahead. (Edventure: Frome, which launched in October 2012, has parallels to the Unmonastery model, although framed in educational terms.)
Five years into the current crisis, the default future for much of Europe is a world of longer hours and lower wages. Economic regeneration as we have known it could hardly keep up with the social costs of industrial decline, even during periods of sustained growth. That economic collapse can lead into and become entrenched by a collapse of meaning is not just a post-Soviet story, but one that can be traced in many of Europe's former industrial regions, not least the areas of South Yorkshire where I once worked as a journalist.
The scale and harshness of those realities makes me hesitate: I do not want to overstate the case for the examples I have discussed here. Yet I would suggest that they may offer clues, at least, towards another kind of regeneration: what might be called a ‘regeneration of meaning’. There is no guarantee that this will happen, nor that, if it does, it will take the kind of form we would wish to see. However, for those who consider the possibility worth exploring, I have a few questions:
- What would it take for this to coalesce into something serious?
- How far along is it already? (Is it further than we/others assume, due to its illegibility?)
- Where are the other examples that would build the case?
- What are the dangers? (For example, could the Unmonastery inadvertently become the workhouse of the 21st century?)
Image credit: Listening to the Walls - Photo by Bembo Davies, Institute of non-toxic propaganda"
2,6719,2016-04-06T21:48:48.000Z,493,anon1526983854,anon959394994,"It goes back to communities
Great post :-)
It seems to me that the experiences you describe are all community-based. It's always people, it's always peer-to-peer. People give each other acceptance, encouragement, sense of direction. This a lot more resilient than being socially validated by how much money you make – if only because the people in these experiences have two ways to get acceptance and validation, one through material achievement and one through the community.
So, probably, this is the best path to making all this become ""somethings serious"": invest on develoanon3606750899g as many ways as possible for people to regenerate meaning and validation for each other.
"
3,14419,2016-04-07T20:04:25.000Z,493,anon1491650132,anon959394994,"Timeless piece of writing
This is informing so many directions in which Edgeryders have been looking and approaches that we've supported over the past years.
Paging @anon
"
5,18389,2013-01-30T11:53:00.000Z,17595,anon1526983854,,"a friendly anarchic reply
Petros, this is really a friendly anarchic reply! I commend you, sir. :-) And yet, I disagree. If you spent three years getting FreeLab off the ground, you are NOT going to be happy if you come under pressure to move it somewhere else. Not everything is costlessly mobile…
"
6,15588,2013-01-30T12:59:00.000Z,493,anon1526983854,anon959394994,"question 4
I’d like to have a go at your question 4. The immediate danger seems to me that of an ever-deepening disconnect between insiders and outsiders, people that live according to the job paradigm and people that do not. It is easy to imagine public budget officials with an “austerity or die” mandate do the math: let people like Petros at Freelab do their thing! This way, they won’t come to us asking for welfare services, and it’s not like they are ever going to pay much taxes anyway. But then, of course, there is no reason for any of the two groups to be loyal versus the other one. Given that two mutually unloyal tribes occupy the same physical space, things could get ugly.
Am I being too paranoid?
"
8,20760,2013-01-30T17:50:00.000Z,493,anon3197531486,anon959394994,"Great to see you’re here :)
Hi Dougald,
Great to see you’re here :)
First of all I feel compelled to start with your last sentence and the reference to ‘the Workhouse of the 21st century’. My home town has one of the few and the best preserved workhouse of the country. Recently there has been a bid the renovate and repurpose the space as a diaspora and geneological centre. I freely consult with the consultant on this project, a tipperary councillor named Brian Rafferty. I approached the team originally from the perspective that the heritage and true history of the situation would have to be honored if the project was to be a success and that in certain ways it must become the antidote to the perception of hardship that most people percieve it as being (and which, in all honesty, is an accurate perception of the elusive reality of that history).
The point that was important for me to make was that the workhouses were publically announced as the first form of organized social welfare in the country. That they served a community purpose and that in the remaking of this space there should be a strong element of that social aspect. I will not get nto the injustices in Irish history here, thats not my aim at all, and yet that is not to say that I am not fully aware of the situation as it was in reality.
I suggested to the team a number of plausable possibilities. One was that, given the proximity of the workhouse to one of the poorest housing estates in the town, that there could be a Montessori school that operates according to the social enterprise of a specified successful Dublin company who are part of the SETF (Social Enterprise Task Force) in Ireland. I also suggested, having picked spuds for local organic farmers back in the day, and having heard how they interact with the bigwigs of Tescos and SuperValue, that a local Community supported market could operate in the courtyard; that the Irish should follow the Greek Potatoe Revolution. As chance would have it
I read yesterday on my friend Lisa’s facebook that she bought a bag of organic potatoes at my formeer employers organic shop for €2 less than the supervalue equivalent. My comment in reply was “Community supported markets, local produce, undercut Tesco, nuff said!”
In addition to this the idea has been raised to me that a forest would be good to banon3760936673ce the atmosphere in the surrounding area. Some 3000 bodies (probably more) are buried in the fields aling the rear and side of the building. A ceremony, a tree planting, and a forest made in the fields available to the rear is an event that can give a whole community, indeed a nation, a sense of meaning, and can serve an honorary and calming purpose and service to its site and situation.
I have spoken with Slow Food Youth Ireland and to other members of the Cloughjordan Ecovillage (where Vinay lives quite a bit – hi Vinay) aswell as to members of a volunteer/selfemployment company called Local-Switch about their possible interaction with any potential project that could come of this also. Naturally, Edgeryders came up, and Brian was vaguely interested but
I’m not sure that he understands the potential of the situation. He agreed that the vision is there, but claimed that there was a lack of focus…that I could not “be all things to all men”.
The old generation of project manager are still in linear process and thinking hierarchically in too sharp a focus. Given your examples above concerning participation versus payed work I can see how the reallocation of resources in a distributed manner can fuel a distributed process whereby each of the participating entities can work together to achieve the best result. In the local setting you have to work with whats actually there. And so figuring that out is paramount (thats my answer to question 1 *ushaiddi/netention).
Once we know whats there we need some kind of intermediary, like an Unmonastery who can go in and actually apply the medium for that primary issue and bring the people concerned to the same table with some notion of a potential reality, or a series of potential realities for them to work toward. It appears that the beuraucrats cannot think like this, they need to, at the very least, see its potential and deregulate and/or reregulate as necessary.
When you ask how far along this is already I would say that it is very far along, and that through digital loops such as Edgeryders and the various thinker and tinkerer networks emerging online there will soon be an emergent software to cater to the needs of these communities to map assets and resources in ways that will far accelerate certain modes of production, namely socio-cultural production within circular economies where products become services and work becomes life (again)
Given Alberto’s concern I would like to offer that yes, there are two distinguishable interest groups emerging…and yet it is in the interest of both to actually survive. Once thats assured, at least, there is still the concern of surviving without persisting in some crisis nightmare where even the highest amongst the ‘have’s’ are worriedly watching. For the neccesary banon3760936673ce to occur the system has to be let find its own level, a level currently beyond the banon3760936673cing power of the present socio-productive organization. Ideally, it can be recognized that different is not adverse, and that new is not to be feared, that just because its different doesn’t mean you won’t enjoy it or that you may not actually come to learn and grow of the experience. People forget the passion that got them to their ‘comfort’. We still need infrastructure, power, sustenance, education, culture, health services etc… Same-same… But different.
You ask what are the dangers? I won’t direct my attention there. Whats the use when there’s so much potential to work with in the space of life between? People get aggressive over contradictive ideology, but when it comes to social situations and the proof of the collective pudding the lesson that history teaches us is that, so far at least, things have been getting steadily better for people. If we can move with the times and with the ‘decisive technology’, then we can shed our preoccupation with the abstract personal and with the symbolic and move into a deeperly lived, and more fully conscious, Life.
Personally I believe that the route leads through culture and is a move, with the help of the head, to and through the heart and hands. I’m working on a little something north of Berlin in May that will hopefully help me understand (and show a whole bunch of others at the same time) how different cultural groups can come together in a mutually supportive space to exchange values, and value, and crosspolinate to create a new space that is equally educational, packed with arts and culture, and productive of socially changent ripples. More about that later…I think its a very good example of what you ask for in your third question.
Thanks for this Dougald, its a fine contribution. See you on the round.
"
9,24129,2013-02-04T13:35:00.000Z,493,anon1839840820,anon959394994,"Storify
Here is my storify of comments leading up to, and devolving from this link being sent to me.
http://storify.com/exiledsurfer/thoughts-on-regenerating-meaning"
11,26170,2013-02-06T10:12:00.000Z,493,anon1689441345,anon959394994,"I was speaking to a Spanish friend about this article. He was saying that even if “economic growth” returns to Spain, it will only work for those people who were encouraged during the boom to climb as far as they can on the higher education ladder to get “graduate jobs”. In fact, those who could afford to do so have kept climbing during the crisis – using Master/Phds as “waiting rooms” while they were unemployed, and using their parent’s homes & support as “waiting rooms” to avoid paying a premium on the crisis (i.e. high interest loans, flat evictions, etc). They’ve accumulated social & financial capital that provides a cushion. Those, however who were encouraged to leave school and go straight into the boom industries like construction, now have no industry or education to fall back onto and for the most part, given their parents were also employed in boom industries, they have no financial / support cushion either.
What struck both of us was the irony of the situation, that people talk about the need to re-focus on the real economy (“making stuff”) to avoid a future boom & bust. Yet those with the skills to “make & build stuff” are not only at a disadvantage because their industries have crashed, but because they haven’t accumulated enough educational capital to compete even for jobs that haven’t required this (most barman in Barcelona are graduates).
The Center for New Work, West Norwood Feast & Access Space are all examples of mobilising skills which involve “making stuff” so perhaps for this to coalesce into something serious is to create these spaces in communities which have been dependent on manon169343781al industries which have since died and find a way of supporting not just young people to develop & resource these spaces, but their families too? (Some areas like in ex-mining villages have kept a community self-resourcing approach as a result of young people & families working together, but many areas don’t have this)
"
1,648,2016-04-01T08:20:09.000Z,648,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Four years ago, as we were planning our move to Brussels, Nadia and I decided to look for flatmates. Most of our friends and family members were rather puzzled: not many couples decide to share their apartment, though they can afford not to. We, however, thought it completely logical. Nadia is Swedish and I am Italian: at the time we lived in Strasbourg, France. That made us a migrant nuclear family, completely cut off from the network of emotional and material support that our friends and families of origin could offer. We were simply too isolated in our Strasbourg apartment, nice though it was; and we decided to try something different. So, we rented a much bigger apartment than we needed and asked the Internet for someone to share it with.
Four years on, we think the experiment worked. For the last three years we have been living with Kasia and Pierre, a young couple of expatriates (Kasia is Polish, Pierre French). We really enjoy the co-habitation: the home feels more animated, and not a day goes by that we don't chat at least a little bit, over coffee or breakfast. We enjoy the big, airy living room overlooking the city. And, frankly, we appreciate that our lifestyle is really good value for money: thanks to the economies of scale implicit in family life, we pay a reasonable rent for a really nice space.
Along the way, we discovered that what makes our living together so enjoyable is that we are so different from each other. We come from four different countries; we are of different ages (Pierre, the youngest, is 19 years younger than me, the oldest); we have very different jobs (Kasia is a dental nurse, Pierre is the manager of a fashion boutique, whereas Nadia and I both belong to the ""what is it that you do, again?"" tribe); Nadia and I travel a lot, whereas Kasia and Pierre tend to be in town most of the time.
This works well on many levels. On a purely practical level, when we travel we love the thought that the home is not empty, and in the event of some misfortune (think plumbing failure) they can intervene; and I am sure they enjoy the privacy and the extra space. We pay for electricity, phone and the Internet, they pay for the cleaning services – less paperwork to do. We have an extra room, which normally serves as Nadia's and my office; but it doubles up as a guest room for the guests of all of us.
But there is more to co-habitation than practicality. Kasia and Pierre are lovely people: and, crucially, they are different people from Nadia and myself. We live out the city in different ways. We have different takes on almost everything, from French politics to Belgian beer. Comparing notes with them is always interesting, and I really value their insights and wisdom. Not that we spend all that much time together. I think our co-habitation unfolded in the right sequence: we started by a default attitude of rigorous mutual respect of each other's privacy and spaces. Then, over time, we grew closer, started to share the occasional meal, the occasional outing; we met each other's friends and families, lovely people to the last one. Guess what: we have built a sort of familial-like arrangement in a foreign city, among people who were originally complete strangers to one another.
It's working well. So well that, when a year ago our landlord announced that he was reclaiming his apartment and we would have to move out in the summer, we decided to stay together, and to look for a new place as a four-people household. Eventually, we got more ambitious and thought, what the hell, we might as well grow the family. If four people can live so well together in a larger apartment, how would it work with five, or six, or seven in an even larger one?
It works well, it turns out. We moved to a lovely loft, and were joined by a third couple (Belgian-Italian). Giovanni and Ilaria have since moved on for family reasons, but we enjoyed their company while we lived together. Their place has been claimed by Thomas, a young French engineer.
We do this for totally egoistic reasons: we enjoy each other's company, we save money, we live in style. At the same time, we are aware that we are working our way through solving a global problem. Planet Earth has 230 million international migrants; intra-EU migrants like us are 8 million. Many of Europe's young people simply cannot afford to hold their ground: their work, education paths, and love lives lead them to migrate. When they do, they, like us, lose their supporting networks, and it is really hard to rebuild them. Living together, especially in diversity – the older with the younger, the sporty with the mobility-challenged, the academic with the blue-collar worker – becomes a platform for sharing our different abilities, and being able, as a household, to solve many different problems, both emotional and practical.
None of this is new. You have heard it all before – at social innovation conferences and workshops, for example, and typically by people who live in middle-class nuclear families. But we have decided to walk this particular talk; it will probably not be the right choice for everyone, but it is the right choice Nadia, Kasia, Pierre and myself; and I strongly believe it might be right for many others. I encourage you to at least consider it for yourself: as more of us make this choice, the real estate market will respond, giving us more spaces suited to our particular lifestyle (in Brussels, for example, is very difficult to find large apartments with 3 or more bathrooms!). So, who wants to join?
"
2,8933,2016-04-01T09:18:44.000Z,648,anon1491650132,anon1526983854,"Curious how this could work for less resourceful newcomers
Hi @anon
So: together when you want to be, but apart when you want to be apart.
It seems like your group has found just the right banon3760936673ce between couple intimacy and social sharing of the space, which is something that would scare many of us grownups. There is something about growing mature that makes one more and more into their own ways, and less willing to take on 'adventurous' lifestyles. Maanon1932026148 it's not obvious now how that pays off tenfold in the long term (i.e. family surrogates).
Do you think this setup can work if not all of you were middle class (as precarious or as unstable as middle class can be)? If someone joins but they soon fall off because of too low earnings, will the rest be able to catch them?
"
3,10701,2016-04-06T21:22:49.000Z,8933,anon1526983854,anon1491650132,"Not in this case
Direct income support is not part of the package in our group – at least not at this stage. We do help each other financially, but this is mostly a consequence of the economies of scale that exist in family life. The other part is a willingness to cut each other slack; this all started with us accepting to sub-rent to recent migrants, who did not have jobs yet. We trusted them to make it happen, and they did. Later, when we grew from four to six, same thing again: one of the two new people did not have a job, but we took them in all the same.
But in the long run, the deal is that you have to pull your weight. Maanon1932026148 in the future we will have become so attached that we will change the deal. Who knows? Certainly this setup gives us a couple of shots before we have to give up completely. For example, we could sub-rent the extra room, and take the additional income from everyone's rent. Maanon1932026148 the reduced privacy would be a sacrifice worth making to keep each other close, already now. Depends who you ask, I guess :-)
"
4,14141,2016-04-07T05:50:02.000Z,648,anon4259720994,anon1526983854,"Love it!
Some case studies showcasing the benefits of shared living.
"
1,656,2016-04-06T17:10:44.000Z,656,anon2331944500,anon2331944500,"1. What is the problem/question you are trying to solve/explore? Frame it as a design question!
How do the differences between family relationships influence the concept of care?
Family is the space in which we learn to care about other people and in optimal situations are being care for from others. Apart from the abstract idea of a close all-loving family, the reality often looks different and a multiple of imbanon3760936673ces can arise within and across different families. Viewing care as a fundamental good necessary to every human being, different family structures influence the social life of people and create misunderstandings across all the ecosystem. Someone who does not, for whatever reason, have access to care from his “natural” family, has to seek somewhere else, but meets the difficulty to be part of a society in which different types of care are structure and differentiated, i.e. typically hard emotional situations that need a specific type of care are dealt with the family members. Outside of these close circle, misunderstanding arise as why people should care and how to communicate the need for it.
Different family-backgrounds often produce individuals who deal with their emotional life differently. We live in a time where family relationships are being redefined and even though alternative families (single mother, single father, same gender marriages, etc.) are officially being more accepted in the open discourse, the psychological and practical implications are being overlooked. For example, turning your friend or lover into the main care giver—role officially being taken by your parents and/or brother/sisters—still carries social stigmas and difficulties in assessing the fluid role-relationship in play.
2. State the ultimate impact you would like to have. What would make you feel like you did something meaningful with your time?
Re-think the traditional role of the family as a protection-space and care-giver; deconstruct its traditional proposes and definitions and underanon3606750899 the imbanon3760936673ces, paradoxes, holes in the system. Center care as an extremely important aspect of our lives, a fundamental good which can have a domino-effect on all other aspects of our lives when not dealt with properly. Create a common linguistic understanding of different family backgrounds and correlate them to the psychological and social implications they carry out. Care is a fluid good and can be shared without the traditional format of a family.
3. What are some possible solutions to your problems or ways to answer your question? Think broadly. It's fine to start a project/learning process with a hunch or two, but make sure you allow for surprises.
The definition of family might be broaden or the caring role and relationship be redefined. At the end, the important aspect is to awaken a conscious thinking about caring and its connection to vital energy, well-being and social possibility with other people. The intimacy by which we hide some aspects of our emotional life must be addressed with the hope a post-traditional exchange system can born out of it.
4. Write down some of the context and constraints that you are facing. They could be geographic, technological, time-based, or have to do with the population yo're trying to reach.
Initially the question should be limited geographically and anthropologically to the western world. In future, a more global approach could be used.
5. Does your original question need a tweak? Try it again.
How do the differences between family relationships influence the social life and exchange of care between individuals?
"
2,6682,2016-04-06T20:54:24.000Z,656,anon1526983854,anon2331944500,"DIYing the family?
Hello @anon
I am not sure I understand you completely, but you seem to be saying something like: what you call the natural family is the default locus of care. But some people do not have access to that. They have to make their own, so that they can reproduce that locus.
The traditional way to do this was this: you would leave your parents' house, marry, settle down with your spouse and have children. This produced a ""one size fits all"" world, with most families were very similar to each other in composition. You seem to be saying that now this is untenable, and families should be (and in part are) allowed to be more diverse, like a Lego construction made of different-looking pieces. A DIY sort of family, heavily customized. Is this broadly correct?
Because if so, you might be interested in my own quasi-familial thing in Brussels. I love my original family very much, but none of them live in the same country as I do!
https://edgeryders.eu/en/living-social-in-brussels-co-living-as-a-lifestyle-for-grown-ups
"
1,5524,2016-04-06T14:14:13.000Z,5524,anon1743371374,anon1743371374,"
I am Moushira. One of the OpenCare crew from WeMake, and it is time to introduce myself :). Once upon a time I was an architect, building and exploring alternative building techniques with communities in the desert of Morocco and the mountains of Sinai in Egypt. Three years ago, I got a masters in interaction design, and then Arduino started to change my life :). Since then, I have been working on different things, including a project for an opensource laser cutter, called
Risha, that operates via mobile phone. I am also working on another project that helps introduce Bedouin women and kids in the mountains to smart textiles, and I am a consultant to the Wikimedia Foundation (the one that runs Wikipedia), working on helanon3606750899g find out what readers want (because no body knows yet, imagine!).
As part of OpenCare team from WeMake, where I am working on both the strategy and the harvesting of the online community and helanon3606750899g the people define projects that they want to implement. Moving on, I will help with physical prototyanon3606750899g aspects. I believe Opencare is a wonderful initiative, that reminds us of simple solutions that can make a difference in our lives, yet nobody thinks about them, because nobody knows those exists at first place. Many thanks to @anon
I speak Arabic, English, French and Spanish (proficiency is in the same order :). I am Egyptian, and these days I live between Alexandria and Dahab (a small city in Sinai)
Nice to meet you everyone, please let me know if you have any questions.
Moushira
"
2,6492,2016-04-06T15:06:40.000Z,5524,anon2971875139,anon1743371374,"Welcome :)
Hi Moushira,
Welcome to the team ! Hope we'll get to know you soon :)
Luce
"
3,10652,2016-04-06T18:03:43.000Z,6492,anon1743371374,anon2971875139,"Thanks!
Lets see how we can grow a happy OpenCare community :)
"
4,13986,2016-04-06T19:52:53.000Z,5524,anon477123739,anon1743371374,"Welcome
Thanks for introducing yourself. I look forward to hearing more about your project and seeing what WeMake!
Alex
"
5,19654,2016-04-06T20:10:25.000Z,5524,anon1491650132,anon1743371374,"Join our weekly call?
Hi @anon
Hope to see you on Monday at our regular online hangouts 16:30 cet? https://edgeryders.eu/en/op3ncare/op3n-meetups
"
6,21681,2016-04-06T20:50:24.000Z,19654,anon1743371374,anon1491650132,":)
Nice meeting you ""virtually"" as well, @anon
"
7,23395,2016-04-06T20:41:06.000Z,5524,anon1526983854,anon1743371374,"Welcome, too
:-)
@anon
"
1,651,2016-04-04T21:54:20.000Z,651,anon1831568896,anon1831568896,"what can we as designers do? designing not only objects, but situations, society
designing society.
how can we create a community where everyone respects each other? helps each other?
don’t loose the fun!
if i am happy i can give so much more love to other people. What People? who am i in contact with?
am I caring with a smile? how much does my smile give to the bus driver?
what makes me happy?
caring doesn’t only mean to give but also to be able to receive. to connect stay in touch.
be authentic, honest.
never loose the ability to laugh about yourself.
I am not going to change the world.
too negative
I want to think about solutions that are sustainable and lead our society to better approaches.
better.
We need to be working together and help each other. thats actually the only way to get out of this fucked up World.
"
2,10611,2016-04-06T14:31:40.000Z,651,anon1491650132,anon1831568896,"Looking forward to read more.
Thanks for your thoughts @anon
My name is Noemi, and myself learning to live daily with a smiling face. Not very easy, but I enjoy being in my home environment - and the feeling of safety which it gives. Here is my story, looking forward to read you. By the way you can Edit your post anytime should you want to add more info about yourself. Cheers!
"
2,10561,2016-04-06T14:14:24.000Z,495,anon1491650132,,"What do you currently do?
Hi @anon
I look forward to visiting again, art festivals there are a favourite of mine.
"
2,10160,2016-04-05T18:22:35.000Z,5465,anon1491650132,,"Anyone to contact for sharing a story?
Hi @anon
I'm thinking it would be helpful to get a sense of how people you engage are responding and what we can offer as a community.
"
2,9977,2016-04-05T11:21:00.000Z,649,anon1491650132,,"Failure can be a path to activism, nicely said.
Nice to meet you @anon
I don't speak German so I used google translate to understand your post (English translation here). If I got it well, you have said wise words: we don't need to reach the care utopia with normalized approaches, but with trial and error. Are simulator workshops something to look into with more detail then? Any other tells or resources you know, do tell. that would be useful to OpenCare where we are supposed to look into promising ideas and prototype them - but prototyanon3606750899g in the ""lab"" so to speak could mean a due dilligence fail test (?) hm.
"
1,654,2016-04-05T08:42:57.000Z,654,anon1612430491,anon1612430491,"
Wie glaubst du könnte man Pflege in unserer Heutigen Welt angehen? In der näheren Umgebung?
Ich muss niemanden pflegen.
Es ist pflege sich mit Freundin zu unterhalten.
Bei dir selbst?
Sich bewegen, den Körper Pflegen. Die Psyche Pflegen.
Warum musst du dich Pflegen?
Damit ich gesund bleibe.
Ist es ein Problem das Menschen dieses Bedürfnis nicht haben?
Unterschiedlich. Solange du keine Probleme hast musst du dich nicht darum kümmern.
Es kann passieren, dass du MS hast.
Ich wie? nicht ob eine Leib, Seele Trennung Sinn macht. Man kann im Gehirn zeigen, das psychische Probleme sich Körperlich äußern. Wir haben sie nur noch nicht verstanden. Man kann Körper und Geist nicht trennen.
Körperkult?
Sport und Bewegung ist Pflege, aber man muss unterscheiden. Dreimal die Woche rennen gehen kann nicht gesund sein. Für manche Menschen eventuell schon. Es geht um die reine Bewegung Für die Durchblutung, den Sauerstoffgehalt, die Haut, die Sonne bekommt. Für den ganzen Körper.
Bewegungsunfähigkeit.
Ich hatte eine Bekannte die im Rollstuhl saß. Sie musste alle zwei Stunden nach Hause an eine Ladestation. Eigentlich könnte sie Laufen, doch sie hat Spastiken und traut sich nicht ohne den Rollstuhl zu laufen. Sehr motivierend finde ich die Läufer der Paralympics.
Stellst du deine Pflege vor die Pflege anderer?
Das steht in einem Jing-Jang Verhältnis. Wenn im Flugzeug der Druck fällt, wird dir auch gesagt, dass du zuerst selbst die Maske anziehen sollt und dann anderen.
Nur in wenigen Situationen wiederspricht mein Pflegebedürfnis dem der anderen. Das Problem ist wenn Leute nicht genug bekommen.
Wie helfen der Menschheit damit?
Nein, das Mittlere Management, macht nichts anderes als andere Leute zu beobachten und zu kontrollieren. Ich denke die Meisten Menschen wollen etwas Sinnvolles tun.
Wie verändert das das Verhältnis zu anderen, Familie.
Es ist ein Wechselspiel. In einer Großfamilie ist es egal ob zu einem Pflegebedürftigen Kind noch ein Alter dafür kommt. Menschen sind eher dafür gemacht in Rudeln zu leben. Es muss ja nicht Zwangsläufig die Familie sein sondern eine Gruppe Menschen, der man sich anschließt.
Pflege ist ein Verhältnis. Menschen machen nichts, was sie unerträglich finden. Auch bei kleinen Kindern. Wenn du dir das Objektive Betrachtest ist es sehr hart. Rund um die Uhr Betreuung, Nachts Ausstehen. Pflege ist nie Einseitig.
Pflege hat viele Gesichter und ist längst kein einseitiges Ding, keine Einbahnstraße. Alle Interviews die wir heute geführt haben unterscheiden sich stark voneinander im Stil aber die Ergebnisse und Antworten sind alle sehr persönlich. Die Details der Geschichten variieren und der Schwerpunkt, das eine ist politischer als das andere.
"
1,653,2016-04-05T08:33:19.000Z,653,anon2331944500,anon2331944500,"The following is a transcript of a dialog held during a Workshop on Open Care in Sauen, Germany. Jan is a student of social and business communication, while is a Dennis product design student, both at the Berlin University of the Arts. We focus on the skills our academic background could contribute to the project, and how our different approaches and skill-set can cooperate in a fruithfoul way.
Dennis asks, Jan answering
D: Wie siehst du unser Seminarthema aus GWK-Perspektive?
J: Für mich ist das alles nichts neues, es entspricht dem, was wir im Studium zum Inhalt haben. Wir erarbeiten oft Ideen und Konzepte im Framework,um wirtschaftlich funktionieren zu können. Z.B. finde ich das Unmnastery Projekt interessant. Ein Austausch sollte stattfinden, so dass jeder davon profitieren kann. Best for both.
Ich wünsche mir mehr praktisch zu arbeiten, damit ich etwas Neues kennen lerne, vielleicht wäre es einfacher bereits
eine Idee vorgegeben zu bekommen und diese umzusetzen. Die Kommunikation zwischen GWK und Designer sollte stätig stattfinden,um das Projekt zu optimieren.
Man kann Marketing nicht nach Regeln durchführen, es gibt kein Rezept, mann muss versuchen neue Wege zu finden und kreativ zu werden. Learning by doing wist immer wieder ein interessanter Ansatz.
D: Überschneidet sich die Motivation des Auftraggebers auch mal mit derjenigen des GWKlers?
J: Das unterscheidet sich von Fall zu Fall. Es gibt zwei Fälle: Man arbeitet zusammen und hat die gleiche Motivation am Projekt, nur daß einer eher die Idee und die Vision hat, während der andere sich um das Praktische kümmert; um die Kommunikation. Beidseitiges Interesse amselben Projekt ist quasi der ideale Fall. Wenn das nicht der Fall ist, ist der Marketer bloßer Dienstleister, der nicht hinter der Sache steht.
"
1,494,2016-04-04T21:08:33.000Z,494,anon70625510,anon70625510,"Today I had the pleasure of meeting and introducing students from GWK and UDK to the OpenCare project themes and the design (presentation slides available here). What follows are my notes from the final round of discussions in an intense day. Each quote is the transcription of what one individual said. I will be writing a separate post, or possibly even series of posts as the conversations were very rich and offered a lot of things to think about and explore around care.
“It was a good experience, I liked meeting people from different backgrounds and the possibility for working together… Discovering what we each are good and not good at, and how they can fit together. As well as what these different backgrounds creates as a perspective towards the project”
“For me exploring new projects and ways of working is not new, so changing my setup is not new. Converting ideas to communities. Setting up a framework that people can work within. But for product designers is not the case. I could understand Nadia’s language well..It could be good to translate the language and vocabulary used by the OpenCare project into language easier to use for product designers. Designers are mostly visual, other disciplines less so. Some bridging of languages could be helpful.”
“We were discussing the questions on the wall- what care means on fundamental level to us. Under which conditions care is being granted in a community and what that means for us. When discussing integration of people into a group, the separation you make in the beginning affects the integration project...You say there is an external person who should adapt to the community itself, instead of thinking about creating something new from scratch out of the welcoming community and new individials. Especially when you talk about care...you always do the labelling that there is someone who needs help, and I am one to provide help. Maanon1932026148 getting rid of these labels is important. Also we talked about how social relations to certain people are necessary for providing some kinds of care. And how to solve challenges of providing care for people we don’t already know. You touch people physically (as we did in the opening session today) and it changes relationship immediately e.g. free hugs in public spaces: This changes something very fast. Especially in regards to refugee topic….Before helanon3606750899g there should be a contact, a communication with people before offering help whether you know they need or not.”
“ We started different no thinking about projects, but our own experiences being people on the move.
- Being somewhere where you chose to go
- Being somewhere you didn't’ pick: job, being refugee, being moved by parents...how it affects your mindset
What is the difference between these two in terms of care on the move?
One person was talking about being in china for job of her father to experience completely difft culture and not being free to decide to go there….vs choosing to move to a new city voluntarily in a city where many different cultures in Kreuzberg. Just getting to know different food and culture at a very young age and getting to know this in a playful way without much prejudice in your head”
“We started off by talking about situations in our lives where we have given care, or seen other people receiving care. Who are those people who have taken on traditional care of caregiving? We quickly started talking about feminist issues and women being caregivers through history. We also talked about the rewards, how giving care is valued, if valued at all or you get financial remuneration…”
“We were all answering the question of why we chose the different topics and why we chose them. Mine was about being on the move and the point that is for me very importan is the idea of doing something fo the first time and you have to cope, no matter if you have to do a job or ...you are always doing for the first time. Found a sory in newspaper about caregivers and they tried to set up school for nurses where they given puppets they have to be with for weeks before working with humans. Switch perspective. I found a flyer which was something like a manon169343781al for shopanon3606750899g in supermarket in the fifties..they were handing flyers out about how to behave and shop in he supermarket and now people are complaining about refugees not knowing how to behave the first time...there is an arrogance... What is possible with products etc to switch perspective and lose embarrassment etc around doing something for the first time. People “misbehave” because. The first time I met a Syrian guy was during the refugee crisis, it was first time experience for both of us, no just him.”
“We were mostly talking about first time experience of meeting some guys from syria. How can we start meeting people on a high level and not relationship that we are giving, and they are receiving donations. That we are both receiving and giving care.”
“We started talking about experiences and what think about care, or what we need for our self to be cared for or give care. I found that we had really different ways of talking or explaining. I had difficulties to say what I was thinking and they only understood me when I made examples. And they totally understood me. But when Nema started talking, she could really articulate herself without giving examples. It’s really interesting as a product designer.”
“We talked about personal experiences. Because of this we came to many topics- like how it is to be a European or come from another continent. It was nice because we had an open chat with one another, so we had some long discussions. It was nice to hear about other people’s stories because sometimes you don’t talk about it for long, but when you do it for one hour and you have some perspectives on how to give care for refugees but also what it’s like to be a foreigner in Germany.”
“Unter sich haben sie die kulturellen Unterschiede nicht wirklich gemerkt, wenn man gemeinsam mit vielen Kulturen aufwaechst. Der einzige Unterschied, der immer da bleibt, und erfahrbar ist, ist der kulinarische Unterschied. Vielleicht ist die Perspektive eines Kindes die beste: Unvoreanon1056199097nommen Danon1056199097 aufnehmen, ohne sie direkt zu beurteilen. Gerade als Kind ist es eine grosse Bereicherung, auf so viele unterschiedliche Kulturen zu treffen. Fuer die Erziehung und die Ausbildung der eigenen Persoenlichkeit ist es absolut foerderlich, in Konfrontation mit vielen Kulturen aufzuwachsen.”
“We had a discussion about “stranger danger”. Which I have recently been having with people from older generations. When it comes to refugee crisis , even people I know that normally would act very human and never put themselves above another suddenly are afraid when refugees come to the country. In part it is because of the lack of contact; they don’t come naturally to a place where exchange could happen in an uncontrived way. How could this be set up, or how could it happen? We talked about how younger people can be a connector, how it needs a connector...there are many of us who want to engage but don't because the connection is needed and doesn’t happen without being designed. When travelling connecting is very easy, but in your own town you rarely have deep conversations with people you don’t know. Openness as a mindset is very interesting to see how society is structured n our head. How this huge fear that comes out of nowhere. Media says you should have fear now, that the new is threatening. I love my Grandma but when it comes to this topic I think omg we should not even talk about this topic and I have no idea how to change things. I think it’s a lot of empathy, we had a huge fight...it was all about him not letting what’s happen...not wanting to feel it...keeanon3606750899g it theoretical. The next day there was a change of perspective. It’s also overwhelming for many people, related to make yourself vulnerable and allowing yourself to feel. It’s a very delicate and sensitive how to do this contact and get them in touch with their feelings.”
“We were talking about different languages. To map out what we can as GWK and product designers (UDK) and to figure out what is the responsibility towards what we are studying. Until now what designers were doing and what we were studying was just about making things beautiful. Are we even responsible towards building towards big visions the way OpenCare is doing? As designers we are always looked upon in a very belittling way - as though we are not capable of contributing to the big issues. But I believe it is part of our responsibility as designers to do this work, because ideally we are focusing not on profiting from it but we can do it just to help. Everyone knows we should help, but no one really does it and people still have prejudices and discriminate. Not many of us know how it is to lead a refugee’s life. How many of us have been discriminated against? For me I was born in Germany, but for a moment I thought well all the refugee circus that is going on has nothing to do with me and I thought it is the responsibility of larger organisations like NGos and the Government to deal with...I asked myself what capacity do I realistically have to help. Then I realised that as someone born in Germany, I walk around the street I hear people discriminating against Asians. And I realised it does affect me, and it is my responsibility to help...It is about the right to be a creative and work not just for profit, but to help others and how this is deeply human at its core.”
“I think it is always important to find new symbiotic relationships between people. One Project I’ve come across is one in which there were two groups: one group who wanted to learn English but didnt have connections to do so, and the other group was old lonely group from America. These two groups were able to talk to each other via skype. The Old people had the joy of talking to somebody who was interested in learning. And the young people learned English. It’s very nice to see people caring about each other that way.”
“For me it was very interesting to hear what makes something seem foreign and why we feel home. What makes this happen?”
“We were still thinking about what is th goal of being a designer and what is a design process...what is the difference to art or to management/managers job? We came to the point that an artist is focusing on showing problem and designer is trying to find solution and manager is more focused on company’s project and not so much on helanon3606750899g people. It’s a beginning of a discussion.”
“We were not talking about the differences between student areas. It was interesting seeing how there was a lot of variation in how interviews were conducted in the different groups as well as within the group were different. I think what I found was that we had very different styles of leading interviews and how different results. I realised I am used to lead an interview and how it has become my only way for me. And it was really interesting to see there are different kinds of ways to lead an interview. I learned how to lead interviews in design thinking...you are asking for stories and ask 5 times why. It’s completely differnt thing when trying to understand a person. It was a very good experience. And apart from that my main insight is that care is always interactional, its not a one way street. The system of capitalism is making it a one way street because there s wlays money in and something out. It’s not evolutionary.”
“We talked about the relationships that we have with people from Syria that we know and the experiences we have with them. We try to know why German people are so scared of foreigners and why the German people are sometimes so closed also in a friendship. For example my first time was not so easy to make friends here, german people are really closed the first time..they are not so open to stangers.”
“It was really intersting hearing about your experiences and the difficulties you had. Very interesting to talk from a personal perspectives and the fears you have.”
“We discussed the five questions we were given. What I noticed te most that care is a very difficult term. We couldn;t find a term for care in german. This is one part that makes the discussion very interesting but also very difficult. A whole lot of people are going in a direction towards the refugee topic, that seems to be very close to people. I heard about a book from two journalists about political language: some words and terms that are used are producing certain realities. When you use some words regularly especially in the media, it becomes a reality and then there is no alternative. Translating care into a german word, and speaking about it means very different thing.”
“We also tried to approach the topic from a more general angle, what care really means for us. We came to conclusion that care, giving and receiving, is a basic human need and a human right. It’s not a one-way street, but we need to talk about care as a devalued thing in our society. There are people who really love to give are and do not have the right to get something for it. We thought about how to make people who give care more visible. How can we provide some kind of reward or value for the volunteers. And of course we went in the feminist direction but I think it is a really important thing to value care as a huge thing in society.”
“Care which we translated into Pfleger. Has not only to do with caring about other people and also for yourself. Is it important to care for yourself first or the other way around? It’s a challenge to care for huge number of people at once. Monetization and how it affects our view on people around us: that we cannot be more intuitive because we think about how we can be most effective.This question where german politicians are saying we have to take care of our people, and not just give everything away. Same thing at a different scale. We have to look at how we distributed in different ways. I would like to see politicians say how they care for themselves, I would like to see them living a lifestyle which shows people how to live a healthy life.”
"
1,5479,2016-03-21T14:56:22.000Z,5479,anon70625510,anon70625510,"After discussing with colleagues and community members in Edgeryders, I propose we “zoom in” from care in general to three specific instances. This will make the discussion more concrete and more relevant to the people out there whom we wish to connect and work with. The price we pay is that we might discourage people with interesting cases that do not fall into this taxonomy (eg. Helliniko). We suggest:
- Social and or health care of refugees in Europe (Challenge brief here)
- Prevention of Suicide in the hacker community (Challenge brief here)
- Helanon3606750899g both caregivers and care receivers in dealing with dementia (Challenge brief here)
They are a good match for OpenCare, because:
- They involve people in vulnerable situations where dynamics in community connections, or lack of, play a significant role. Can Guy/Alberto's network science perspective help us to make visible and understand these social flows?
- They involve some interaction with the formal health and social care system, conditions as well as norms/behaviors in society at large. Can anon948101822k and Tino's approach help us make sense of this and translating it into institutionally comprehensible language?
- They involve and require a deep understanding of healing and medical practice, especially the ethical considerations for both caregivers and care recipients. Can Marco, Massimo's and other's work in the field and in the lab help us to identify and understand how to deal with these issues? In the research as well as in the intiatives themselves?
- The city as a place and institutions is where all of these interactions and relationships live (or do not). Can Lucia and Rossana and others in the city of Milano help us understand how a city can make visible and enable promising approaches and nurturing the people who drive them?
- Can we design interventions offer workarounds to the obstacles these intiatives, and the indivuals they attempt to support (caregivers and care recipients)? What forms could these interventions take in order to unlock more care in the different situations (artefacts, communication, services, processes, upskilling, administrative and legal hacks, policy changes and or something else? Here I think the anon1056199097nuity and very particular skillset of Costantino, Zoe and others in the weMake constellation could make a very important contribution.
Please validate them or counterpropose others. We need to move on.
"
2,6774,2016-03-21T17:37:03.000Z,5479,anon3612872438,anon70625510,"comments on two domains
Hi Nadia,
We agree with what you propose, we have a couple of comments regarding two of the domains:
- social/health care to refugees
Why focus only on refugees and not on migrants in general? Or if we don’t want to call them migrants and refugees, let’s call them something like people in movement without papers: Sans-Papier
- Prevention of Suicide in the hacker community
This target is a bit too tight on hackers and becomes then necessary define what is a hacker and we think we could get stuck in this conversation (ie. why only hackers and not makers? what are really hackers?) .
Why don’t we focus on the domain of mental distress (or psychological distress) in high-tech service sector?
best
Zoe
"
3,10741,2016-03-21T18:29:00.000Z,6774,anon1526983854,anon3612872438,"Mostly agree
Opening domains allows us to capture potentially more great examples. For example, there is probably nothing to be gained by restricting to hackers the suicide prevention story (we are looking into it as part of a different piece of work we are doing in Galway: apparently, suicide is endemic in the West of Ireland). If we just look into suicide prevention, we can still fetch all of the stories coming from the hacker community.
On the other hand, suicide prevention is more suited to community-driven solution than treating mental distress. Why? Because it's about someone being there at the right time, pulling the suicidal person away from the brink. This presents interestingly specific challenges. In this case we might lose some focus if we move over to ""mental distress"".
"
4,13542,2016-03-21T18:29:34.000Z,6774,anon70625510,anon3612872438,"Agreed, thanks. First up- dementia
Ok,
People on the move makes a lot of sense. It includes people who move for any number of reasons. But we then need to give people some examples of what might fall under that, e.g. People fleeing war, People moving abroad to study, working mostly online and living in different parts of the world etc.
I'll prepare the docs for the other two, for now, have a look and contribute to shaanon3606750899g the brief to would be participants for the dementia related initiatives in this shared document?
Another helpful contribution would be to share your own reflections on this after the workshop we both participated in during lote5. I'm doing the same further below in the same document
"
5,15411,2016-03-30T14:42:49.000Z,5479,anon1491650132,anon70625510,"Reaching out to medical practitioners
In order for briefs to be efficient in terms of engaging people to relate deeply and submit stories, they need to be rock solid in providing background information about the topic - short and well packaged, but to the point and credible. It is that background info that helps us contextualize issues and ask very good questions. It seems that especially for dementia and suicide, it would be great to have people with medical training sharing information or pointing us to useful resources.
Any way you guys can share the drafts linked above with your networks asking people what is it that they find most important to ask when it comes to coming up with effective, community solutions?
Also, let me know if you know professionals that are also good writers whom we can approach for writing stories in response to the themes - personal experiences and takes on the issue (example of a contribution)
"
1,5463,2016-03-15T21:12:54.000Z,5463,anon70625510,anon70625510,"
During today's call @anon281534083 , @anon
- We discussed three cases:
- The Diabetes implant: What was an illegal hack in 2012, is now a solution that is available for others. How did this happen? What kind of legal hoops did they have to jump through?
- Im many EU countries the welfare infrastructure was designed for populations with planned groth. With more refugees arriving you both have an increase in number of people to care for, and different kinds of needs which is being framed as the source of "" chaos in the system"". Perhaps it would make sense to look at how health- and social care is being managed both in the camps and temporary receoption centres, as well as in the mainstream healthcare providers.
- Is there a distincting between the NHS overall (long term) and the temporary refugee situation: Is it just a question of money, or are/were there some things that can be improved? How does a clinic in Brixton cope with a situation in which you have five hundred people who have just walked to Calais and have broken feet? In addition to the Epidemological situation.
- We need raw data about how the healthcare situation is currently being managed, but from first hand sources...ie go out and ask people on the ground. How many doctors, nurses and others are currently active in caring for the new arrivals? Where are the resources coming from, is it mainly charities? Is this information already out there and is anyone aggregating information about the different intiatives providing care services to people?
Some early ""conclusions"":
- When it comes to DIY solutions to health- and social care problems, there is a key tension between asking for permission and asking for forgiveness. Who/how can and should we convene around finding legal/administrative hacks for existing DIY solutions to health- and social care problems?
- An obvious path towards achieiving impact is to find, acknowledge and draw support towards people who already are doing important work. This has to happen online on the edgeryders.eu platform in order for us to fullfull our obligations and to stay true to our mission. Does it make sense to run the project in 3-month cycles consisting of the following steps?
- People reach out to little known but promising initiatives and ask them about their work and post the documentation on platform where we can help edit them into really compelling stories. These stories are designed as informative case studies with a specific call for action from the broader community.
- We share their stories online and engage the internet in making sense of the challenges they face, as well as identifying fixes/hacks/solutions/new projects. Part of this is sharing specifications, doing requirements engineering and the necessary background research to determine viability of different proposals.
- We build a number of small, focused events in which people existing intiatives with designing and build the identified fixes/hacks/solutions and projects. Kind of like the workshop on Collaborative Inclusion...but taking place over a couple of days, in a hacker or makerspace, where you leave having built something that works. Two projects to begin with: BBC Frontline Documentary on Two UK Doctors Helanon3606750899g Refugees | Dutch Volunteer Turns Refugee Boats and Life Jackets Into Backpacks .
-
BBC Frontline Documentary on Two UK Doctors Helanon3606750899g Refugees - See more at: https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/bbc-frontline-documentary-on-two-uk-doctors-helanon3606750899g-refugees#comment-21988
-
BBC Frontline Documentary on Two UK Doctors Helanon3606750899g Refugees - See more at: https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/bbc-frontline-documentary-on-two-uk-doctors-helanon3606750899g-refugees#comment-21988
"
2,10261,2016-03-15T23:45:00.000Z,5463,anon888039120,anon70625510,"Hangout ideas
Hangout was good. Started in 'appear.in' but it was really laggy so we moved to Google hangouts.
My feeling was that I'd be more likely to put effort into the open care thing if I believed it would come up with concrete results (e.g. helanon3606750899g people / reducing suffering) , if it was just making a big document that got read and largely ignored, I'd feel it was a waste of time, and I think everyone will share this feeling.
I think Nadia agreed, and said that we could/should try to get some concrete change from this project (as well as fulfilling the minimum requirements of providing the research / ideas / documentation.)
For the research part, I thought the only way to actually know what is going on would be to go to places where health care is needed, and talk to people first hand. Get a feel for their situation. (Rather that trusting info sources from others). So I think we could get people to visit anywhere that seems like it might lack good health care and talk to people in need, and the people giving the care. e.g. Refugee camps, impoverished inner city areas where there are too many people and not enough doctors / hospitals. Rural areas where it's hard for people to get health care. Go to places, talk to people get first hand accounts, do surveys and get numbers.
For stats / raw data , I'd want to know:
* How many doctors/clinics/hospitals there are in the area.
* How the health care is funded: (is it governments paying with taxes? Charities? The communities themselves dealing with the problems, without outside help?)
* How do people get to the health care when they need it? distance? cost?
* How long do they have to wait? satisfaction with the care they receive?
* How many people need care and are not getting it?
etc.
Someone (forgot name) asked an important question: Does our client (client?) care about the situation in America, or because it's EU money do they not care about far away places, with maanon1932026148 completely different situations / cultures?
For the UK, an important question i would like answered is: 'how good is the NHS?' Are they doing the right thing, and only limited by lack of money, Or could their methods / efficiency be improved? If so, how? How could they improve? Better software / organisation? a change in culture?
(I know they wasted a ton of money on software, cos they gave money to some lame suit and tie company instead of getting real hackers that smoke weed. But I guess that's really a separate issue.)
To me, the most exciting idea would be to get hackers involved in health care. Healing people is (often / can be) easy when you apply creativity and radical tech and hacker problem solving mentality.
I think an important question raised was 'is the legal side preventing this from happening more? Or will it get in our way?'
Maanon1932026148 hackers are put off operating on people cos they might get sued if it goes wrong? Or 'pretending' to be a dentist is illegal and only people with official training should be allowed to mess with teeth?
(Issues with stuff like law getting in the way of common sense hacking with pacemakers cos of stupid patent laws / lack of open software ?)
Nadia said we can find people with expert legal knowledge, and see what the situation is.
(Common wisdom is that dentistry is very difficult and takes 7 years training, or whatever. I can see why this makes sense. It *is* very difficult and can get very bad results if it goes wrong, so obviously 'amateurs' should not hack teeth.
However, I actually think this is not as obvious as some may think. When talking about starting a radical hacker community on an island, one of the points that came up, is can we really mange without any outside help? What if someone has tooth problems, should we consider this when deciding on location? I said 'we can't do dentistry, it's too hard' but some in our crew actually thought it was not beyond the realms of possibility. He would have to spend a few hours reading, and time making specialised equipment (drills, maanon1932026148 X-ray machine, etc) and make our own morphine (actually that's the easy bit, but general anaesthetic can be tricky/dangerous). So anyway, I'm not suggesting it will be common place in the near future for people to get their teeth fixed at hackerspaces. Just wanted to point our that genius hackers can do amazing / crazy high tech things if they have the time. Nothing is beyond us. So I imagine it could be very feasible for hackers to help with more simple aspects of health care, and there is no reason that they should not be allowed to do so. )
Also mentioned: hackers making rucksacks for refugees.
What about shelters for homeless? I've always been keen on squatting, using tech knowhow to get abandoned buildings into liveable states.
This is not directly health care, but you can argue prevention is better than needing to cure. E.g. if people are living on the streets or extreme poverty where they can't keep warm and dry, and wash, of course they are more like to get sick and have many health problems.
So the thing that excites me the most is getting hackers involved in radical change like this.
Nadia said that actually getting positive change was something we could and should be doing (even though technically we don't have to DO anything, just provide research / ideas).
So she suggested that I could help organise an event in London, where we get hackers together, and see what we can do.
So I think a big event with lots of hackers would be good.
Nadia mentioned planing to do something in London, and in June. Not sure why London (just cos I was keen to help, and i know London?) or were you thinking of doing something in London anyway? and why June? dunno. but anyway, that seems feasible.
The minimum i would expect from this, is just lots of brainstorming / ideas by smart hackers that we can document and add to the report.
The best case, would be if something more long term came out of it, and they ended up improving health care in London.
London hackspace would be the logical place to host it (and I know the members and trustees very well).
So if you guys think that sounds like it's worth doing, I will contact them and see what they feel and if there is any support / excitement about the idea. They would probably allow the space to be used for free, but if we wanted a lot of people and for more than one day, it could be a nice gesture to offer to donate some money from the grant for use of the space. (it's entirely non-profit and run by members) (they did look into charity status, but decided against it)
Normally it's members only, but they will make exceptions for special events (and a lot of the people interested would be members anyway).
I know one or two members that are involved in edgeryders, so I would also contact them.
What do you think?
"
3,12058,2016-03-16T14:39:58.000Z,10261,anon888039120,anon888039120,"Another location idea
EMF is August 5th - 7th 2016, Guildford. https://www.emfcamp.org/
We could do something there. @anon
"
4,12424,2016-03-30T00:08:23.000Z,12058,anon390916512,anon888039120,"EMF
Just caught this @anon888039120 - don't know if @anon
I've been considering emfcamp. I'm part of a mobile hackspace/workshop project and back in Janon169343781ary made the proposal to do something with our workshop at EMF, but nobody else appeared interested.
I've been thinking about doing some kind of fantastical area at an event for a while, something inspired by madmax, solarpunk and https://archive.org/details/NomadicEcoVillages - not quite sure how/if that would fit in with OpenCare, although I guess it could?
anon3606750899ging @anon
"
6,13703,2016-03-16T17:39:28.000Z,10261,anon888039120,anon888039120,"When the left gets funded
"
7,13880,2016-03-17T14:51:28.000Z,10261,anon70625510,anon888039120,"On the road
Peter thanks for taking the time to post your nots above. Would like to really read and reply to your questions, share reflections etc but am on the road till Sunday. Will post in soon
"
1,5491,2016-03-24T17:10:06.000Z,5491,anon3612872438,anon3612872438,"@anon
The title is Know thyself and our world in the digital era and focuses on the increasing knowledge through personal sensors, and how this form of open learning in a digital era can be applied to an area of shared concern – the environment. the meeting will focus on the ubiquity of and the knowledge to be gained from personal sensors, and how this information can be applied to address issues of real concern.
the 3-day meeting is part conference and part hands-on. We're in the Innovation in open science project team and we'll:
""Explore hacker/maker space projects in digital health and the environment. Imagine a gathering where we will tackle the theme of the Assembly by making something together in a state-of-the-art maker space. Luanon3606750899g Xu and Francois Grey, with the help of esteemed leaders in the maker world such as David Li and anon948101822c Pan, will guide participants in a brainstorming session to build software or make objects in a space with equipment such as 3-D printers, sewing machines with conductive thread, microcontrollers, sensors, the works! ""
The team will be lead by Luanon3606750899g Xu and Francois Grey (active in open hardware community at canon1932026148rlab - read more here http://cds.cern.ch/journal/CERNBulletin/2016/11/News%20Articles/2137964?ln=en ) , and will actively engage with the maker spaces in Shenzhen.
More after the event.
In the meanwhile some bits about Sage Bionetworks and also the reason why we accepted invitationa and we'll talk about Opencare:
Inspired by open-source software models, Sage Bionetworks co-founder Stephen Friend builds tools that facilitate research sharing on a massive and revolutionary scale: https://www.ted.com/talks/stephen_friend_the_hunt_for_unexpected_genetic_heroes
John Willibanks of Sage Bionetworks about medical data https://www.ted.com/talks/john_wilbanks_let_s_pool_our_medical_data?language=en
"
2,7364,2016-03-24T18:41:04.000Z,5491,anon281534083,anon3612872438,"The CERN link
Says ""denied"" when I try to go there. The TED links work ok.
"
3,14604,2016-03-25T02:36:15.000Z,5491,anon3612872438,anon3612872438,"Try this
http://cds.cern.ch/journal/CERNBulletin/2016/11/News%20Articles/2137964?ln=en
Copy and paste in browser
"
4,20087,2016-03-25T02:43:51.000Z,5491,anon281534083,anon3612872438,"That works
thanks!
"
2,8496,2016-03-09T09:28:41.000Z,5432,anon70625510,,"Photos or it didn't happen :))
Kidding aside. Very curious how you are structuring this event, what communication materials you have sent to whom and then what people actually say/do during the event.
The reason being that if we can learn from one another, then we can help others maanon1932026148 do the same workshops/event where they are based....
"
4,15487,2016-03-09T11:43:54.000Z,5432,anon1491650132,,"Great promotional gif
Loved it and added it to our visual
"
5,20873,2016-03-10T09:04:20.000Z,5432,anon2435658896,,"Liscio Ambrosiano with Claudio Merli
Claudio will be our rockstar!!
https://www.youtube.com/embed/38kYygIvfzk"
1,5462,2016-03-15T18:10:34.000Z,5462,anon281534083,anon281534083,"http://www.rferl.org/content/lesbos-migrants-turning-boats-into-backpacks-dutch-volunteers/27587663.html
is a link to a story about a Dutch woman who made a super clever hack of the junk boat and lifejacket parts to make backpacks out of them using a few simple tools, which she then taught to the refugees. An excellent maker story solving a real problem without having to get too high tech or even ask for wither permission or forgiveness..
"
2,6917,2016-03-21T20:46:43.000Z,5462,anon2435658896,anon281534083,"cool
This is very cool, we should bring Nagler into the conversation!
@anon
"
1,5469,2016-03-17T14:19:47.000Z,5469,anon281534083,anon281534083,"https://securitybrief.com.au/story/information-security-professionals-may-not-be-prepared-iot-after-all/
As you might expect, the IoT is fraught with security holes and a growing population of users who are rather unconcerned about it - mainly because they don't know and don't think about it enough. But do you want someone hacking into your Google Car? This article points out that many IoT devices and projects don't even know all that connect to them.
"
2,10467,2016-03-17T15:02:06.000Z,5469,anon888039120,anon281534083,"Yeah
I'm more worried about people hacking into my computer. My computer is part of me / my brain. OSs have always been exploitable. The fact that everything is connected to internet all the time makes the problem worse, but not a new thing.
I don't care so much if they hack my car. What are they gonna do? Make it drive off a cliff? Unlikely. Yeah, sure, it's a bit scary if someone can hack into your pacemaker and switch it off remotely, but how many people are this evil? Not so many. If you wanna be evil and kill people, it's not difficult to get a gun. That's just a fact of life, humans are weak and vulnerable.
So my point is: This IoT security panic is being blown out of proportion. It's nothing new.
Sure we will fix it, but it's probably going to take A.I. There is no easy solution. Telling everyone to stop using Microsoft would be a good start, if you care about security.
"
3,16891,2016-03-19T01:57:30.000Z,5469,anon888039120,anon281534083,"case in point
http://metro.co.uk/2016/03/15/hackers-could-take-over-your-dildo-and-make-it-go-berserk-expert-warns-5754496/
"
1,5471,2016-03-18T09:15:43.000Z,5471,anon2435658896,anon2435658896,"The first free hands-on workshop of the \#opencare series will take place this next Friday 18 March in Milan at ‘Fa la cosa giusta’. Come and learn how to create an \#IoT \#opensource service to monitor and take care of your loved ones remotely.
here in italian:
http://wemake.cc/2016/03/15/opencare-a-fa-la-cosa-giusta/
if you have the possibility to come drop us a line:
hello [at] wemake.cc
with @anon413297907 @anon
Date: 2016-03-18 16:00:00 - 2016-03-18 20:00:00, Europe/Rome Time."
2,10502,2016-03-18T09:17:01.000Z,5471,anon2435658896,anon2435658896,"on Facebook you can share this link
https://www.facebook.com/wemake.cc/posts/1150451201640742
"
1,5461,2016-03-15T17:32:18.000Z,5461,anon281534083,anon281534083,"http://www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/proginfo/2016/10/frontline-doctors
Is a link to a writeup on an hourlong BBC documentary I watched while I was in Amsterdam last week. I didn't see a link to watch it online, though the synopsis is very good. It would be interesting to follow up with those doctors to see what they are doing about all this now.
"
2,10128,2016-03-15T18:06:30.000Z,5461,anon477123739,anon281534083,"it was a very good documentary
Hi John,
I watched it when it was on TV in the UK. It was very powerful and interesting, certainly worth following up with them.
The link to watch it through the UK BBC iPlayer service is here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b073jh6b
I think it's only available to UK IP addresses, but i'm sure that won't hold you back, a simple VPN will get past that.
You can also follow the link and buy it as a video download for about $2/2Euro if you're feeling generous.
It s a couple of months old (they did their journey at the beginning of the year) so they visited the Calais camp which is now very different and in the process of being forcibly cleared by French Police and government officials. Sadly this will just mean that it's even more difficult to treat and assess the conditions of the refugees as they are most dispersed around the area and the clinic and social services that had been set up by volunteers and 3rd Sector orgs have been dismantled and closed.
If you wanted to organise a meeting or discussion with them i'd be happy to act as an intermediary, or scribe so we could share with the rest of the community.
Alex
"
3,11986,2016-03-15T19:42:10.000Z,10128,anon70625510,anon477123739,"Are they in the UK?
Hiyah Alex,
was just writing up my notes from the call and saw this. I'm going to be in London from tomorrow through to Sunday.
1) there's a dinner Im hosting (Ezio will be there as well) if you you'd like to join us. I've rented an airbnb so if you need a place to crash you're welcome to stay there too
2) I'd love to meet them, with you also if you have time? I've no problem getting to where they are and if you'd like to join me that would be even better :)
Let me know?
<3
"
4,12695,2016-03-16T14:36:50.000Z,11986,anon477123739,anon70625510,"Damn!
Hi Nadia,
That would be amazing, but i think i have to work tonight and tomorrow daytime which means i can't do anything. I'm waiting to hear back, in which case i might be able to come down tonight, but it's 50/50 at the moment.
I'm busy from early friday morning as i'm going to the wilds of Scotland for a week to write poetry and read EU cultural documents!
Alex
"
1,5460,2016-03-15T08:04:19.000Z,5460,anon784612129,anon784612129,"OpenCare Kick-off Meeting
February, 25th 2016, Brussels
Participants:
Institution
|
Name
|
University of Bordeaux (UBx)
|
Luce Chiodelli
Guy Melançon
Adeline Barre
Olga Ivanova
|
Edgeryders (ER)
|
Alberto Cottica
Nadia El-Imam
Noemi Sanon3760936673tiu
Ezio Manzini
John Coates
Sam Muirhead
|
WeMake (WM)
|
Costantino Bongiorno
Zoe Romano
Cristina Martellosio
Elisabetta Mori
Alessandro
|
SCImPULSE Foundation (SF)
|
Marco Manca
Massimo Mercuri
|
Stockholm School of Economics (EHFF)
|
anon948101822k Lakomaa
Tino Sanadaji
|
Comune di Milano
|
Rossana Torri
|
Minutes:
Kick-off meeting agenda:
Source: https://edgeryders.eu/en/groups/opencare/february-25th-first-consortium-meeting-a-proposed
Epic goals - Introduction by Alberto (ER)
Review of proposal objectives - as expected by the EC because listed in the DoA and real objectives of the OpenCare project:
High-impact paper on community-driven care & welfare reform
-> wikinomics -> book? -> Influencing the world
+ Sanon3606750899-off of the project -> OpenCare clinic?
+ Introduction of the hackers’ culture into EU research projects
Learn by doing to deploy collect intelligence to design care services
EC interest in funding the programme -> how to summon collective intelligence for policy-making
-> Provide a scenario on a realistic scale
-> Software stack
Use hackers as a model – why?
1. Low-level of formality between partners
2. Written communication – traces of conversations easy to find and collect
3. Avoid e-mail for transparency and common knowledge (sharing experiences)
4. Skype meetings every 2 weeks – to be confirmed
5. Everything except private information shall be posted on the forum = we have to think about the way we communicate online.
Partners shall use the online forum but also organize it, using tags/subgroups.
Possible to uncheck the groups for which partners receive notifications, if they wish to make it stop.
Tools, procedures: project management - by Luce (UBx)
Detailed information on grant management in the powerpoint presentation held by UBx.
Partners mostly beginners with EU research projects (all partners except UBx + Comune di Milano)
UBx engages to:
- Upload resources for project management:
Survival kit to the EC requirements (coming soon – draft to be revised)
+ Time sheets examples
+ Template of a Data Management Plan as provided by H2020
+Gantt with deliverables
- Inform partners of important milestones/events (such as when the payment will be done). Information will be provided online on the OpenCare workspace to avoid similar recurrent questions from all partners.
- Get in touch with partners to review their plans of using the funds (staff costs, use of other direct costs, and eligibility of expenses) either during the kick-off meeting or through Skype meetings.
Alberto (ER) will take care of the DMP update for submission in June 2016.
EC template posted in the GDocs
EC review: could be organized in October / November in Lisbon (information given by Loretta).
To be organized in Brussels with the PO + expert evaluator of the EC
Ethics – by Marco (SF)
Scimpulse Foundation = Responsible for ethics.
- Ethics Advisory Board: one person is appointed, another one to be recruited (work in progress).
- Consent form: Questionnaire to de designed and filled in for each participant (to make sure he/she knows the frame of the project) -> draft in progress, inspired by other similar documents. Its submission has to match the launch of the OpenCare platform.
Self-evaluation form - Objectives: keep it as lean and understandable as possible, while keeanon3606750899g it legally viable.
Transparent and dynamic solution that would preserve the community ownership of the conversation/information space.
Security of data – by Alberto (ER)
- Data storage: on the ER server located in Germany
- Data secured through https
- Matthias = contact person.
Sensitive data will be put on a specific server - diagram of the process to be sent by Marco.
Previous information on the topic posted by Alberto on the ER online forum:
- Data stored on ER own server.
- Server in Germany – best data protection law in Europe.
- https all around (end-to-end encryption)
- Data handled by a stack of software which is open-and-free (so the code can, in principle, be audited) and stewarded by substantial development communities (Drupal, MySQL, PHP, Apache and Linux – so the code is audited in actuality).
- ER moderators policing the activity feed every day, several times of day.
- ER explicit terms and conditions - see
- One known security bug: https://edgeryders.eu/en/edgeryders-dev/task-1508 (Fix that spammers can add posts, edit wikis as anonymous users)
- Does not affect credentials, and is easy to fix on a case-by-case basis reverting to the latest legit version of the wiki.
Source: https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/task-6025 (Let Marco know about privacy and data protection on Edgeryders)
Presentation of partners
Comune di Milano – by Rossana Torri
Detailed information in the powerpoint presentation held by Comune di Milano.
City of Milan aims at develoanon3606750899g business models:
- Labours policies, development policies -> sharing economy to help city's goals, maximize the potential of projects
- Digital environment, fab labs -> to help empower people
OpenCare within the framework of Welfare di Tutti -> Milan local incentive.
City of Milan is associated with WeMake as local pilots for empowering people -> include group of citizens to help them become protagonists of the project
- Reconnect society and overcome target-oriented approach by groups of needs
- Simplify access to services
- Support collaborative services delivery
Portal by Comune di Milano -> WEMI (Welfare di Milano)
City of Milan -> engages local users as a specific task. Active communities already involved and used to collaborate to tell about needs of care -> strongly embedded in specific areas of Milan
Give support to existing networks of care -> towards development of new community-driven social care
Location for implementation: Villa Pallavicini - Culture and social issues center. Italian language courses, bike classes, prepare driving licenses (from users’ demands).
How to engage people?
- Intentionally exclude institutional meetings (round-tables etc.), starting from the habitat and status of the people concerned by the incentive.
- Clusters of practices to identify and engage people from their current needs.
- Soft intermediary for other agencies (associations)
Janon169343781ary to June 2016 -> engaging 2 to 3 communities for workshops
- March for exhibition in Milan on sustainable lifestyle to make dissemination of the project
- April - Social policy
2 co-design sessions with people from these communities to make heterogeneous groups (students, hackers, social workers) to have feedback also from other participants
-> will help select ideas for prototyanon3606750899g
Main goals:
- Public administration: OpenCare = good opportunity to reconnect traditional system with communities in need
- Test concrete tools
- Leveraging collective intelligence
- New public policy rooted in OpenCare approach
- Help reform local welfare in Milan
WeMake – by Zoe and Costantino
Detailed information in the powerpoint presentation held by WeMake.
WeMake = lab for experimentation and innovation to build a new type of job.
- People-oriented
- Tech-oriented
Aims:
- Help people learn by themselves (horizontal learning)
- Open Source at the basis of WeMake (WM rule: something is not really shared if not documented and put online)
- Collaboration with institutions, schools, young people,
- Helanon3606750899g companies and people develoanon3606750899g prototypes,
- Bridge between culture(s), technology
- Social impact
Design, prototyanon3606750899g, documenting
Sharing documentation is caring and creating engagement through dissemination
Documentation for WM is allowing people with no tech background to access technology
Graphics, schemes, videos, storytelling, images, etc.
Epic goals:
- One prototype living beyond the project without injection of public funds
- Playbook (manon169343781al on how to do prototypes)
- Help others contribute
- Plug-in -> another stakeholder wanting to invest to create conditions to prototypes on a larger scale
- Consolidate process of knowledge to be able to design and keep technology-designed care services on the market
Next activities: warming up local communities, foster online discussions
Codesign sessions in May 2016
EHFF – by anon948101822k and Tino
Detailed information to be provided by EHFF (powerpoint presentation to be shared).
Presentation of economic models related to health care industry – increase of health costs / increase of demand from population though apparent better efficiency at treating diseases.
Next consortium meeting 20th-21st of June?
Edgeryders – by Nadia and Alberto
Mini-website for the project hosted by ER – almost complete, cache version on the ER servers during development.
Implementation soon (Feb/March 2016)
Question of language and integration: local communities involved in the project (community around WeMake for ex.) are not necessarily familiar with English. How to integrate them into the community?
University of Bordeaux – Scientific aspects by Guy
- Cartographic analysis
- SNA / SSNA - semantic analysis of conversations
- Maintain OpenCare platform
- Ethnographic analysis of conversations
- Using Tulip and Detangler tools
- Also references to Edgesense conversation network analysis tool developed by ER
- Masters of Network for LOTE5 : Presentation of Tulip, Detangler and method to be implemented during the OpenCare project
Engaging communities – launch of the OpenCare platform
- Nadia -> engagement based on motivation of people, social filtering of good ideas according to engagement and development.
- Ezio -> define open care - legitimation to give advice to people = people who have some knowledge on care.
- What does define opening care?
- Higher-level of consciousness about opening care
- Define the concept of open care
- Define the use and structure of platform - showing personal stories of what it can be
- Alessandro -> guidelines to help everyone think on how to design prototypes. Community manifesto?
- Ezio - try to simply communication - common language?
- Glossary, discussion rules
- Take some cases, select some of them which are telling stories the best
- Accept different interpretations of care - need for 3/4 examples to justify why they are the fixed point on which to have a conversation
- No formal definition but permits everyone to contribute
- Select the ones that are the less ambiguous in telling a story
- ER will get some stories and examples
Next meetings
- Next meeting in Stockholm: foreseen the week of 20-21 June (but difficult for Guy)
- Meeting in Milan: originally planned in October, should be organized in November (Costantino to confirm)
To-do-list as agreed during the kick-off meeting
Action to be taken
|
Partner in charge
|
Deadline
|
|
Scimpulse
|
February
|
|
Scimpulse
|
March
|
- Collect stories and examples of interpretation of care
|
Edgeryders
|
March
|
- Launch of the online OpenCare platform
|
Edgeryders
|
March
|
- Dissemination of the OpenCare project through local workshops
|
WeMake + Comune di Milano
|
March
|
- Review grant management with all partners according to their specific needs
|
UBx
|
March
|
- Verify the existence of trademarks on different versions on the project name: Opencare, OpenCare, Op3ncare, Op3nCare, Op3nC@anon
|
UBx
|
March
|
- Upload resources for grant management on the OpenCare workspace
|
UBx
|
March
|
- Grant access to all partners on the EMDesk platform
|
UBx
|
March
|
- Confirm asap the date of the next meetings
|
EHFF and WeMake
|
March
|
Upcoming deadlines (see DoA – Annex 1 GA)
Milestone
|
MS14
|
WP6
|
SCImPULSE
|
Two ethics advisors appointed
|
Feb 2016
|
Feb 2016
|
Delivrable
|
D61
|
WP6
|
SCImPULSE
|
Consent funnel
|
March 2016
|
March 2016
|
Milestone
|
MS1
|
WP1
|
Edgeryders
|
Onboarding structure up and running
|
March 2016
|
March 2016
|
Milestone
|
MS5
|
WP2
|
Edgeryders
|
Conversation-ready online space
|
March 2016
|
March 2016
|
Milestone
|
MS15
|
WP6
|
SCImPULSE
|
Consent to participation and use of data approved and published
|
March 2016
|
March 2016
|
"
2,9901,2016-03-15T08:06:23.000Z,5460,anon784612129,anon784612129,"@anon
"
3,11877,2016-03-15T08:56:53.000Z,9901,anon2971875139,anon784612129,"Thanks @anon784612129 !
"
1,5440,2016-03-10T09:34:20.000Z,5440,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"[Moving forward with WP5 Tasks 5.2]
http://www.csc.ncsu.edu/faculty/healey/tweet_viz/tweet_app/
We have mentioned it would be interesting to provide sentiment analysis feedback to those who would monitor conversations taking place on the forum.
I am interested in finding an appropriate sentiment landscape, I thought the experiment by C. Healy would be worth trying. You enter words, the app scrapes twitter for you and then displays a cloudpoint (points correspond to tweets). Go play!
I am also interested in your feedback about the utility of such a viz. How would you intuitively use such a represntation? Just look at it? Drive the navigation between posts (here tweets) from that viz? Query the posts and get back to the authors' neighborhood (in the crowd of all authors)? Etc.
"
2,15809,2016-03-10T16:56:33.000Z,5440,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"Be sentimental
Open your heart.
Imagine you read posts, you are trying to understand what is going on in the Op3nCare crowd, maanon1932026148 looking how newcomers are doing, maanon1932026148 looking for places where lively debates take (took) place.
How does the sentiment scale used in the demo serves your search? How would you go from the sentiment map to the data you are looking for?
Come on guys, be generous, tell me all -- I need it to fuel WP5. Thanks!
"
3,20919,2016-03-10T17:26:44.000Z,5440,anon70625510,anon2774142051,"Include a customised offer into the fellowship package?
See discussion here? https://edgeryders.eu/en/opencare/fellowship-program-timeline-and-rewards-each-partner-can
"
4,24285,2016-03-10T23:46:20.000Z,5440,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Not for me
I am no fan of sentiment analysis.
I tried with several words (""edgeryders"", ""edgeryders OR opencare"", ""stewardship"", but I can't seem to learn anything of substance.
Hope that was not too disappointing, @anon2774142051...
"
5,25117,2016-03-11T09:17:00.000Z,24285,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"When sentiment analysis hits the fan
@anon
My guess is you don't see value in sentiment analysis because up to now you have been able to track almots every and each of the users, and probably every and each post/comment on edgeryders.eu -- this is no surpirse, it's your job as a community manager!
What if the community grows, what if the volume of excange makes it so that you cannot afford to track each individual or post?
Maanon1932026148 ""sentiment"" is not the good way of thinking about how to use this technology. And maanon1932026148, it's true, sentiment coloring is not that useful.
Let's give it a second chance.
- What if, on top of the topics that people discuss, I can tag some posts/comments as being ""oanon3606750899ions"", ""knowledge sharing"", ""second"", ""contradict"", etc.?
"
6,33416,2016-03-11T10:51:22.000Z,25117,anon1491650132,anon2774142051,"Me, I'm a content freak
I would potentially find it useful only if it can complement the semantic analysis - so on top of us finding what concepts are related and talked about most, we also have a map of feelings around those concepts that puts care priorities in a whole different light. Or the layers you mention (""oanon3606750899ion"" ""contradict"" etc). But if you have an ethnographer analysing the more in-depth conversation, isn't that covered? @anon3077117708 is involved in mapanon3606750899g tweets in online consultation processes, maanon1932026148 he has some insights for how insightful twitter conversations can be for research purposes? http://localnets.org/
"
1,5438,2016-03-09T23:02:37.000Z,5438,anon390916512,anon390916512,"Imported back from the hackpad: https://lote5.hackpad.com/FRI-1100-1230-Interoperability-or-Death-Talk-by-Meredith-Patterson-npSydPvJjk4 Thanks to all note takers.
FRI 11:00 - 12:30 | Talk by Meredith Patterson
This session was about Protocols for Human to Human interaction. The Meatspace equivalent to conflicts in internet history is process lock-in and lack of common language.
Meredith suggests that we bake in failure-handling:
- Figure out error codes and named exceptions: What kinds of errors would you be dealing with?
- Hardware exceptions: Are they resumable or non-resumable (recoverable or non recoverable- error from which we can recover?)
- Exception handling: unwinding stacks (first in last out). Rewind back to just before things exploded and then play them really slowly to understand how things went wrong
- To create conditions for manageable failures, use progressive enhancement: start simple and then build on that
- Have a way to determine and close failed projects/ dead projects.
- Understand that collapse is also a form of self-organized criticality (not only when iniialives take off)
- Learn to identify Anti-patterns: THE SOLUTION THAT LOOKS OBVIOUSLY RIGHT BUT IS ACTUALLY WRONG.
Pragmatics in linguistic research.
Lessons learned from 40 years of software development
- Organizations which design systems are constrained to produce designs which are copies of the communication structures of these organizations
-Organisations act to defend their incentives. When people are going to fight over protecting their incentives, the turf they will be doing it on, landscape of contention, will be interoperability.
- Reference: Conway’s law
NIST (standard body in US that certifies cryptographic technology): They have a very formal and rigorous process. Turned out DUAL PC RBG was backdoored and NSA manipulated NIST into certifying it.
Lots of ways to fail (in Engineering)
- Open: Means you can still pass things through when control fails. E,g, Valve gets stuck open and all water flows through it
- Closed: When control fails, all traffic is blocked
- Safe: what causes minimal harm, is a question that can only be answered if you know what in the system can cause harm
1. Interoperability.
Video of Eddie Izzard on the church of england.
If asked to choose between cake or death? Clearly you would pick death.
But when it comes to getting people interact/cooperate it sometimes seems like people would pick death, rather than learn to interoperate.
sandstorm.io cloud based collaboration tool with good fine grained security
1. Interoperable, adj. Capable of being used or operated reciprocally.
2. Reciprocity?
When two or more people understand what the other one is capable of doing, what they have the time and resources to do= legibility. e.g. web services
Reliability is a big concern.
3. How about in technologies? - Interfaces that communicate above in a clear and structured way (APIs. usage (), WYSIWG, language references)
- Robustness: the absence of unmitigable surprise. It’s a field of study.
- Explicit is better than implicit e.g “The Zen of Python”
The Zen of Python, by Tim Peters
Beautiful is better than ugly.
Explicit is better than implicit.
Simple is better than complex.
Complex is better than complicated.
Flat is better than nested.
Sparse is better than dense.
Readability counts.
Special cases aren't special enough to break the rules.
Although practicality beats purity.
Errors should never pass silently.
Unless explicitly silenced.
In the face of ambiguity, refuse the temptation to guess.
There should be one-- and preferably only one --obvious way to do it.
Although that way may not be obvious at first unless you're Dutch.
Now is better than never.
Although never is often better than *right* now.
If the implementation is hard to explain, it's a bad idea.
If the implementation is easy to explain, it may be a good idea.
Namespaces are one honking great idea -- let's do more of those!
4. So how did we get here? A deep dive into the history of internet (tech-related) conflicts and how they were resolved...
1970’s Protocol interoperability : formally defining machine protocols was very useful in the Bell labs environment.
protocol is an agreement between machines about how to interact
- How to solve conflict? Editor wars (vi/emacs) (still ongoing)
- Parallels to protocol interoperability in meatspace is process. May be explicit or implicit. People have to agree on how they’re going to do a thing if they’re going to do it together, before they start doing.
- Common knowledge: I know that you know the I know, over and over. Formal definition of common knowledge is infinite regress
The protocol/process of this session is a lecture - everyone is happy to sit and listen to Meridith for an hour - in a different context Meredith talking for an hour would not be acceptable.
The 1980s Architectural compatibility
IBM defined a hardware format for the PC - it was easy to copy. Apple has done the same, but tightly controls hardware, you cannot buy their components on the market.
IBM tried to protect through courts and eventually lost.
- meatspace: how you are going to set standards within the organizations.
The 1990s Presentation-layer compatibility
Each browser manon169343781facturer was coming up with their own dialects of html and layout and styling of webpages.
Microsoft tried to dominate the protocol making process.
Embrace (internet is great were gonna help) Extend (look at all these great new features) Extinguish (you cant know how they work) They lost.
You use different language depending on who you are trying to express to (the Pope, a squatter, your gran).
People react depending on how things are presented depends on what you say and who is the audience.
part of what makes collaboration hard. It’s not just what you say, it’s also how your audience is primed to receive it.
The 2000s DRM wars
Meme: oh you like the kindle?
meatspace equivalent = process lock-in. Process (and understanding of language) develops based on what works danger that it stops at some stage and does not develop following the context in which it develops.
Error correction exception handling
one in software is unwinding the stack the last one in is the first one out.
Pull things off until you find something that works
IN meatspace try and rewind to before the conflict and replay and see if you can sort it out has worked well for Meredith.
Canon1932026148r crime laws in the US are a good example of laws(process) not develoanon3606750899g written for how things used to be.
…And back to today
- stuff mostly just works. Dont have to look at a manon169343781al or look at the help.
- Mainly because of common language, Http. Parallels to Elio’s suggestion
- There is a lot going on under the hood that you don’t see
All the big stuff today
Twitter, Facebook,Reddit, Slack
All centralized they work, make money (from advertising)
centralized and are vulnerable
if you not paying you the product
-Centralisation works, makes money and is vulnerable.
DIGG: Pulled down post containing dvd encryption key. Community went nuts. - almost every post had the key pasted in it.
REDDIT: Firing of employee who ran AMA made users go beserk, users hit back by making content private.
TWITTER: Troll problems
"
2,8996,2016-03-10T00:56:02.000Z,5438,anon1526983854,anon390916512,"What a bad miss
Thank you so much for posting this, Darren. I am heartbroken to have lost this session. It relates to my own work on Protocol:
https://edgeryders.eu/en/unmonastery/protocol-01-engineering-human-to-human-interaction-for
I'll ask Meredith in person...
"
1,5431,2016-03-08T22:42:01.000Z,5431,anon3612872438,anon3612872438,"Hi all,
we are excited and preparing last things for the press conference taking place on the 9th of March at 11am at Palazzo Marino (Milan's major palace) with Comune di Milano team and WeMake team.
After the event we're going to share a report here on Edgeryders.
best
Zoe
"
3,11354,2016-03-09T09:11:00.000Z,8436,anon70625510,,"Small correction
Ciao Alberto,
thanks for sharing the slides. Due cose. Edgryders ha piu di 3000 members. E poi e intergenerazionale, non solo giovane :)
"
4,13624,2016-03-09T09:30:16.000Z,8436,anon2971875139,,"Hi Alberto,
Great presentation !
I would like to point at just one tiny detail - Could you please add in your presentation (maanon1932026148 at the end?) the following information?
- European Commission logo (available here: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0BxnwAmGNB9t9N2x0UE9ZeUx5eVE)
- The project credits : ""This project has received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 688670.""
All partners within the project are compelled by the European Commission to display them on every communication related to the project.
Thank you !
Luce
"
5,13751,2016-03-09T10:26:18.000Z,13624,anon70625510,anon2971875139,"Helpful info
I'm preparing some template slides with standardised information about the project where people can then add their own content for their public presentations. So we all know we're ""safe"" in terms of fullfilling grant agreement requirement for comms while still enabling decentralised workflow :))
"
6,13794,2016-03-09T10:29:31.000Z,13751,anon2971875139,anon70625510,"Great idea, thanks !
I could also lend you a hand with this - just let me know :)
"
8,13846,2016-03-09T14:39:44.000Z,13840,anon2971875139,,"My bad - here is another link
Hi @anon
Sorry for the bad link - You can get the whole EC package of logos in JPEG format from here: http://ec.europa.eu/dgs/communication/services/visual_identity/img/standard/standard-pos-jpg-high-all.zip
Source: http://ec.europa.eu/dgs/communication/services/visual_identity/index_en.htm
"
9,15328,2016-03-09T09:06:20.000Z,5431,anon70625510,anon3612872438,"Ok tweeted about this
Looking forward to hearing what happened, especially how you guys introduced the project (got slides or presentation notes?) and which questions people asked!
"
11,24113,2016-03-09T16:18:31.000Z,5431,,anon3612872438,"WeMake Slides - Press Conference @anon
"
12,26603,2016-03-09T17:50:16.000Z,5431,anon1526983854,anon3612872438,"Great job!
You guys in Milano rock. Well done!
"
1,5405,2016-03-03T16:11:36.000Z,5405,anon70625510,anon70625510,"Talk to me excercise:
the point of the excercise is that there are some implicit information about care.
The group slit up in 3 people groups
one people ask question
one people answer question
one people is documenting
each session is 20'
Workshop Notes (Contributed by Pauline)
Going from the personal and going global to create
- Common ground (everywhere)
Providing care is providing empowerment for you and the other, helanon3606750899g build steps to autonomy.
Create expectations?
Responsibility?
When does storytelling create empathy? What are the conditions? That it create a connexion to the other person’s circumstances.
Common experiences – if I have been through an experience, am I more equipped to support the other facing that experience?
→ If I was a combatant, I can share my story first then be better equipped to support the combatant I work with.
→ Create a link through storytelling fro better care?
The connexion depends on each particular case – dependency? There is a very personal experience. It is very different when your web of personal experiences are involved.
→ The relationship to distance and care is not as simple; it may be easier to care for someone who is not personally involved.
→ Idea of proximity and whether it is helpful or not
Idea of expectations from a particular context: only support certain things in certain circumstances. You only want to care about certain things at certain times so there is the question of:
- Timing
- Context when shared?
Important concepts for care (therefore to include into storytelling practice):
- Why you help and whether you are more helped yourself.
Burden of care should be spread among people.
Sharing care experiences.
What does this mean for narratives of care?
- Create a context for storytelling.
→ Get to know each other + basic needs?
→ Expectations
→ Communication and identity/sculpture
- Showcase the offer and manage expectations. But how?
→ Communication around culture
→ Storytelling could also be the basis on which you build the context for care.
- Frame it as a tool for empowerment.
- Shared intentions and part of context.
What stories?
- Does the narrative approach scale as well as we think it does?
→ Can you actually bring it global? Yes if you recognize the identity and scaling issue?
- Narrative pattern – ‘imagine a world where…. Oh yeah by the way it already exists…’
- Carriers of narratives – Fiction of narratives, fables, archetypes or a story pattern (David and goliath, or the fool, the hero who goes on a quest). Look at propaganda in the LRA.
→ Are there universal stories?
→ But is it personalized better?
→ Note on George Lucas mythologist
Conclusion:
Space for care includes a variety of aspects that one should banon3760936673ce nut still take action.
- Storytelling as a tool not a universal answer
Passive, Active, Proactive
Give - Receive | Request - response = Communication space around care (actively caring)
They are a lot of difficulties in communicating around care.
Stories – legends - can be a tool to not directly address the issue but rely and build on universal stories.
What then would be 5 steps to design your context of care?
→ Current future vs ideal future
"
2,7673,2016-03-04T14:47:00.000Z,5405,anon3041581084,anon70625510,"This was a surprisingly effective approach
I had used the 3-person 'storytelling' approach before (possibly at another LOTE?) but I really found it effective here. Maanon1932026148 because our current societal view of care can at times be very practical and mechanical: you take a symptom to a professional, and procedure or medication is applied... There's not often much chance for deep reflection. So this was a nice chance to gradually eke out insights from our collective experience, we started on a relatively basic level and then by the end we had covered a lot of ground, a sense of trust and intimacy was developed we got into some very interesting questions (and answers!)
Here are my notes from the first interview, with Constantino asking Lorenzo about his experiences with care.
"
3,14804,2016-03-04T18:04:02.000Z,5405,anon1526983854,anon70625510,"Impressive!
Either Lorenzo has a very clutter-free brain or you took great notes. Or both. Either way, this is really insightful.
"
4,20248,2016-03-06T19:35:30.000Z,5405,anon2435658896,anon70625510,"yes that session was quite impressive
!!
"
1,5255,2016-02-03T10:49:18.000Z,5255,anon1491650132,anon1491650132,"There's a reason you want to come to Brussels ... so where will all the gold nuggets we collectively dig out go to after LOTE5?
Have you ever been involved in a conversation or event where you solve all the challenges of the world (or at least the most important ones) - particularly late at night at the pub? Your head explodes with fireworks, you find all the solutions and you know exactly what to do - then you wake up the next morning and you've forgotten everything?
Harvesting (which is a term from ""The Art of Hosting Conversations that Matter"") is an attempt to collect and make sense of our collective conversation and the patterns that emerge from them. Documenting what you learned helps other participants, who either couldn't attend the very session, because they attend one happening parallely, and it lowers everyones *fomo*. And you create a lot of value for those who can't attend LOTE5 at all - how does that sound? So here we go ...
The Self Organisation Tool for Documentation and Harvesting
Topic/ Session |
Who's documenting |
Where to find the notes/ video/ photo other material |
Day 1 - Thursday |
|
|
|
Preflections: Exploration into the social soil of LOTE5 - what brings you to Bxl? |
Kaja |
Why the hell am I going to Bxl?
(discussion link so far, definite link with summary of answers will be provided later) |
|
|
|
Fuck up night Brussels, let's get into the groove! |
|
Pictures album here on facebook and here. |
|
|
|
whatever else you'd like to document that happened on thursday (chose your own title and erase my blabber below) |
|
|
possibility: pictures of what happened on thursday |
|
|
possibility 2: my travel fails |
|
|
possibility 3: what I learned already on day 1 and happily want to share with the LOTE crowd |
|
|
etc. |
|
|
|
|
|
LOTE5. First impressions. ""Am I staying?"" |
Hannes |
tbc |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Day 2 - Friday |
Session |
your name + contact |
link to the material |
C A R E |
|
|
How to cope with meltdowns in communities (John Coate) |
@anon
|
Hackpad
John's speaker notes
|
Collaborative inclusion.
How migrants-residents collaboration can produce social values. A reflexive design exercise. (Ezio Manzini et al.) |
Evajoy |
Session Documentation by @anon1526983854
|
Collaborative inclusion. Part 2 |
@anon
| |
Collaborative inclusion. Part 3 |
|
|
|
|
|
OpenCare files: system failures in health and social care and how to go about it (tba) |
@anon
| Hackpad |
|
|
|
F I N A N C E / C U L T U R E |
|
|
unFailing Massive Collaboration: Open-Sourcing Everything (Tom Markam) |
@anon
| Hackpad |
Interoperability Or Death? (Meredith Patterson) |
@anon
| |
How can we dare to fail more? workshop with Daniel Kerrigan |
Evamus |
Hackpad: How can we..
|
|
|
|
D E V E L O P M E N T |
|
|
The pedagogy of development in the Global South, workshop by Piotr Dzialak |
@anon
| to be determined |
Failure of Israeli - Palestinian negotiations: the peace industry and the endless peace process, discussion with Omar Shehabi |
Diana Dan |
? |
unFailing to improve the refugee care system in Armenia, talk by Anna Kamay |
@anon4259720994 |
On Edgeryders platform |
The Tyranny of Benevolence - Moving beyond charity based approaches in reception and inclusion of refugees (Nadia EL-Imam |
|
|
Failures in development in Colombia - sneak preview and talk with the director (Jochem Casier) |
Diana Dan
Noemi |
Hackpad (by N.) |
Soirée Molenbeek |
|
|
|
|
|
whatever else you'd like to write about |
|
|
please add your own title as in ""what the birds told me on the way to the venue"", ""my interview with person X"" or whatever |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Day 3 - Saturday |
Session |
your name + contact |
link to the material |
C A R E
|
|
|
MASTERS OF NETWORKS: NETWORKS OF CARE hackathon for network scientists, doctors and patients to make sense of collective intelligence using network science and data (Led by Guy Melançon and the University of Bordeaux) |
@anon
| Hackpad: Masters of Networks |
MASTERS OF NETWORKS |
|
|
MASTERS OF NETWORKS |
|
|
Open Care Files |
|
On Edgeryders |
|
|
|
DEMOCRACY/FINANCE/CULTURE & CREATIVE INDUSTRIES
|
|
|
The EU and its people: a failure in democracy, talk by Walter van Holst and Kirsten Fiedler |
@anon
| |
Death and the organisation - stories from beyond the grave, sharing session with Patrick Andrews |
@anon
| to be defined |
Fail lessons from European Capitals of Culture. An open discussion with Robert Palmer, Ilaria d'Auria, Raluca Ciuta, Niall O'Hara, Magda Bucur |
Noemi, Alberto |
Session Notes: unFailing European Capitals of Culture (includes unconference session) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
D E V E L O P M E N T |
|
|
Let’s build a damn dam! workshop by Piotr Dzialak |
|
|
Shark Infested Waters: Publicizing Failures in Development. Talk and discussion with Christine Pu |
|
|
Living in a megacity: Cairo as a patchwork of individual solutions. Workshop with Hegazy Mohamed |
|
|
|
|
|
Glocal bottlenecks in complementary currencies, panel discussion: Marek Hudon and representatives of Belgian sharing economy |
|
|
|
|
|
Disco Soup & Burn Your FuckUps |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Day 4 - Sunday |
Storytelling workshop: Narratives of Care 2016 (all day)
|
Nadia, Pauline |
On Edgeryders |
more space for participants' reflections of ""Narratives of Care"" |
|
|
more space for participants' reflections of ""Narratives of Care"" |
|
|
'Destroy Your Idea - Can You Change Your Mind’ workshop by Kira Van den Ende |
Hannes |
tbc, intenting to document one session 'properly' |
Failure in Doing Good - Effective Altruism’ talk and workshop by Kris Martens, KULeuven |
|
|
Distributed architectures for decentralized data governance |
Fabrizio Sestini |
Post |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
LOTE5 - Eating McKinsey's Breakfast |
Jimmy's personal reflections |
Post |
After \#lote5: Where do we even begin to talk about failures in care? |
Nadia's personal reflections |
Post |
""What was LOTE5 for me?"" |
Hannes |
tbc |
|
Merel |
tbc |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Hello and welcome to the ""Harvesting and Documentation Department"" of LOTE 5!
You will find out sooner or later, so I can as well tell you right away: I love questions and the power they carry. I thought the documentation/harvesting process could benefit from the following ones, before we dive deeper into ""how? who? when?"":
-
What would be useful for me to remember from the time we spend together and learn?
-
What is useful for us as a community to remember from the 3,5 day that we are going to spend together?
-
What do we need to share/feed-back and to whom?
-
What is useful for our longer term learning and what would be useful to share with others / similar networks etc.?
-
How widely could our learnings serve?
In this wiki you will find some information (and a little instruction on how the data collection is going to be organised, please read below) about how we're going to capture what's going to happen in Brussels. Harvesting can happen on the level of creating a record or memory (the purpose of this wiki, mostly) - as well as looking for emerging patterns and meaning (will happen on site, primarily).
I'm excited to harvest the crops we've been tending to and will water and nurture in the course of the following weeks!
Possible Roles
The roles are suggestions. Find your own and preferred way to document - and let us participate in each others learnings! If you have an idea for another role - please share. This is just the beginning and I'm eager for (and we are dependent on) your input. :)
*session journalist
(got it, he? You document one or several sessions that you attend. Everyone who couldn't come, but is interested in the material, will be a grateful bunny and love you forever.)
*day journalist, who captures the flow and what happened besides the sessions/talks
(This event isn't only about what's been talked about during the sessions. So much happens in between, and it would be wonderful to have a couple of people who would like to write a little bit about the flow of the day. Yes, it's cool to go back to the sessions' material after some weeks, but it's also very valuable to read through the flow again and remember the moments in between. Isn't that what un-conferences are about ...?)
*photographer
*video journalist
*investigative interviewer of someone who caught your interest during the event
Bios of participants will be made available on site. Pick someone and ask them what you'd like to investigate on further. If you're into trying out something new: Pick someone you're least likely to talk to, normally.
*seekers for questions, patterns and nuggets
The Art of Powerful Questions - very worth reading: click me!
If you're in a hurry and just want an idea on the power of good questions: just a little something on questions
*whatever other way you're going to come up with and whatever you feel called to collect
(I have seen harvesting in form of poems, songs, best dirty jokes from the smokers corners ... whatever you find worth spreading / adding to the information pool / being remembered and carried forth. Remember to have fun and look for what inspires you. If you get bored by what you're documenting, you should probably pick another point to look from. Another question that really calls you. Something that iches and wants to be explored. Find your own point to look from and let us participate in what you see.)
How to collect the harvest?
1. attend LOTE. That would help.
2. takes notes/record things in whatever format that works for you best (written, pictures, video footage ...)
3. upload your harvest in whatever form you prefer: edgeryders.eu/lote5-doc
The upside of creating a posting/document and link it: The discussion of the sessions can continue in the very thread, add their gold nuggets etc., so the pool of wisdom (ha, how does that sound?!) can potentially grow. If you document one of the sessions, please make sure the session title is also part of the post title.
4. document with others in realtime: lote5.hackpad.com/ (you may need to create an account to see the full list of pads in the lote5 collaction)
When is this due?
It can be tough for some people (like me) to juggle being fully present at the event and delivering the outcome asap. So don't stress out during LOTE itself. The goal would be to have the material uploaded until approx. 2 weeks after the event.
Please add yourself to the wiki!
If you'd like to document a session (woohoooo!!), please add your name next to the session title. In case more session are being added and aren't on the wiki yet, add it! (if the wiki runs out of rows at some point and you don't know how to edit, give @anon
If you'd like to document something that is no session, please find a title for it yourself, add it and also write down your name. This is not a binding contract. Play with it and be courageous. Add your shiny selves and dare to share your learnings. Worst case: You fail. Which would be good, especially if you share it, so the rest of us can get a bit of relief from our own fears of fucking things up. You'd do me a favour, at least. And you'd earn the courage crown! :)
Thank you for joining the documentation and harvesting team! It would be wonderful if you filled your name in as early as possible, so us documentation and reflection freaks can chill out about this. Thanks! :)
علاج الصداععلاج الزكام طبيعيا في المنزل يقول البعض انه ليس هنالك علاج الزكام بطريقة طبيعية في المنزل ولكن هذا ليس صحيحا هناك طرق طبيعية تعالج الزكام بسهولة علاج وجع الراس علاج الكحهطبيعيا في المنزل الكحة او السعال هي واحدة من أكثر المشكلات الصحية شيوعا عندما يكون هناك انسداد في الحلق أو الممرات الهوائية العليا علاج الحمىعلاج الحمى في المنزل الحمى هي ارتفاع درجة حرارة الجسم أعلى من المعدل الطبيع لحرارة الجسم . درجة حرارة الجسم الطبيعية هي مختلفة عن الأطفال من البالغين علاج القرحة علاج قرحة المعدة طبيعيا في المنزل قرحة المعدة هي قرحة أو آفة تتطور في بطانة المعدة ويمكن أن يحدث أيضا في الجزء العلوي من الأمعاء. تخفيف الوزن طريقة صنع عصير الليمون والشاي لتخفيف الوزن الناس أصبحوا الان أكثر وعيا من الآثار الصحية تجاة الوزن الزائد ويبحثون عن وصفات مبتكرة يمكن أن تساعدهم على فقد بعض من الوزن علاج الزكامعلاج الزكام طبيعيا في المنزل يقول البعض انه ليس هنالك علاج الزكام بطريقة طبيعية في المنزل ولكن هذا ليس صحيحا هناك طرق طبيعية تعالج الزكام بسهولة"
2,6693,2016-02-09T05:43:35.000Z,5255,anon1526983854,anon1491650132,"Collaborative real-time note taking
Hello @anon
I would like to suggest a way to organize the session journalism. I will definitely use it when I document – I guess I might start with John Coate's session. Let's see if you like it.
- Create a Hackpad with the same title as the session (like this). Do this well ahead of time. Hackpads are a mix betweeen a word processor and a wiki. You write into it as you would in a word processor; it has revision history and supports multiple authorship like wikis. The difference is that many people can edit it at the same time. There are many such tools: Google Docs, PiratePads, TitanPads etc. They are all OK, though ideally it's best to use just one for the whole conference. We used Hackpads at LOTE4 and it went quite well. If you want, I can elaborate on why I think it turned out to be an appropriate tool.
- When the session starts, point the documentation team people in the room to the Hackpad. If there is more than one person, we can take notes together on the same document. That's a lot of fun, because you see the notes grow before your eyes: people intuitively synchronize (if you are already writing something I leave it alone and add something else I had not had the time to note before, etc.)
- Connect all Hackpads so that it is easier to navigate from one to the other, I need to look better into their data model: maanon1932026148 this can be done by making a collection; or maanon1932026148, like at LOTE4, you can have a single Hackpad per conference day, with pre-made headers for each session.
"
3,10711,2016-02-09T09:25:22.000Z,6693,anon1491650132,anon1526983854,"LOTE5 workspace on hackpad
The collection @anon
It is public, but in order to edit it people need to log in. Some try and ask for an invite?
@anon
"
4,13711,2016-02-17T17:37:54.000Z,6693,anon2599889874,anon1526983854,"Hack that pad ...
Hello @anon
I like the suggestion, since I guess you're suggesting it, because worked at previous LOTEs, so go ahead! Why change a running system. Just some comments & questions:
1. Sounds good, will you post every single link to the wiki then in advance, too (or is it one link for all sessions, referring to \#3?)? Will there be a little time in the very beginning of the event when everyone is gathered so that you could walk people through a short introduction into Hackpad? I expect lots of people to join the documentation team kinda spontaneously on the spot, so they might appreciate a short ""how to"", if they never heard of Hackpad (the name alone can be a bit intimidating, as it *slightly* implies you gotta be techy). I'm thinking of the pen and paper crowd here and of how to best invite people in case this is a new form of doing things for them.
2. Good idea for people who like the communal documenting idea. I'd like to add that people should still be encouraged to find a good banon3760936673ce between trying this if they like, but not feel pushed if they prefer to do it in another way. For me, it would be very distracting to listen to the session while co-documenting with others. I would easily get lost in trying to read other people's contributions - and have a lot of fun doing it - but get distracted. So yes, point to the Hackpad, and leave space for alternatives, so that people can do it the way they do it best.
Who would do this ""pointing out"", then? Can the speakers be asked to refer to the Hackpad link / Documentation thread in the beginning? No one of us will be around at every session, so how can this work best for all?
Would it help to have a ""how to document / Hackpad"" poster in the room as a backup plan, so people can look up the basics there? Like this, for example:
- Like co-documenting with others? Go to: https://lote5.hackpad.com/ and find the session. Group Hackpad on!
- Like to document individually? Enjoy. After you're done, please upload this here: ""link in forum to be defined where the postings about sessions will be set up"" and find the session you'd like to contribute your documentation to.
Or so ...? Don't know. How did you do it in the past so that it was clear where the documentation goes to? Before every session? Once at the very beginning of the event?
3. Would that mean that it's one large hackpack-document in the end? Would it then still be possible to link to individual parts of it, for example to add a link to the hackpad for session X to thread about session X?
More on general documentation/harvesting questions/coordination in next comment.
Cheers
Kaja
"
5,13726,2016-02-18T20:10:00.000Z,13711,anon1491650132,anon2599889874,"Ok, bullet pointing
UPDATED: Or we could set up a new group on Edgeryders ""LOTE5 Harvest""?
I love how thorough you are. Ok so:
- I've asked Alex to put the link to the hackpad on the back of nametags. The LOTE5 hackpad is a collection of pads (documents). One is able to create a different pad for each session, with its own link and content about the session. Its individual link we can add here in your table afterwards.
- We'll be explaining documentation at the beginning of the event + ask the people who volunteered here to remind others in the individual sessions (we should have a small gathering earlier on Thursday before LOTE starts and it gets crowded).
- Great idea for How To posters in each room, it's on my to do list..!
"
6,13793,2016-02-20T18:40:38.000Z,13726,anon2599889874,anon1491650132,"on time (thursday)
Hey Noemi
regarding: ""We'll be explaining documentation at the beginning of the event + ask the people who volunteered here to remind others in the individual sessions (we should have a small gathering earlier on Thursday before LOTE starts and it gets crowded).""
Just for the planning of when to explain documentation (and the harvesting aspects): I will have to attend a organisational call for an Art of Hosting event between 7 and 8:30 pm on thursday,
so I won't be available during those 1,5 hours.
Looking at the programm, the general introduction is between 5 and 6 pm. If we gather the docu crowd right afterwards, we can well be finished with that before 7 pm. Works? Or anytime before that, of course.
And if day wasn't full enough already, of course, I cook on thursday ;) (but hope to do it as early as possible, preferably even before the afternoon.).
"
7,13813,2016-02-20T19:48:09.000Z,13793,anon1491650132,anon2599889874,"Between 6 and 7 sounds OK
@anon
Sorry I havent answered your last email, have been drowning a bit trying to answer other stuff. @anon
"
8,13820,2016-02-20T20:35:21.000Z,13813,anon2599889874,anon1491650132,"drowning too ...
*sigh* And see, how good I am at staying away from the forum in order to get some rest? ;) Damn!!
Wednesday at 10 sounds good for me! Just on a note that doesn't belong here, but if you talk to Ireinga about times anyway ...
if it's more practical that one dish gets cooked on Wednesday evening, I can also do that, if enough help is around.
"
9,16914,2016-02-17T18:09:40.000Z,5255,anon2599889874,anon1491650132,"on space and sharing learning
Hey again
Two questions (for the moment), anon3606750899g @anon1491650132:
On space:
I read that the venue is a maze :) It would be very good to have a big wall for the things that will be written on post-its etc., so this now is about the pen and paper side of the game ...
It would be perfect if there was enough space next to that wall so people could form - more or less spontaneous - chair circles if they feel like sharing something (or if someone like to invite, which I for example like doing, sometimes, but it can of course also be opened by anybody else). It is nice to have a space for these things. Is that something you happened to planned for? Like a retreat area or so?
On sharing the learning:
In the program it says ""share your learning"", at the end of the day. What did you plan to do there? I mean ... will it be hosted in any way or will people be given time to socialize and things will happen on their own? Just curious what that programm point means :) If you don't want to spoil the mystery, that's okay, too ;) I like surprises.
Have a good evening, everyone!
Kaja
"
10,17128,2016-02-18T19:54:46.000Z,16914,anon1491650132,anon2599889874,"Hm
@anon
Share your learnings: nothing planned in particular, it's usually that at the end of the day it makes sense to reconvene. We don't have formal ""curators"" to round things up, but @anon
"
11,18239,2016-02-19T09:36:32.000Z,17128,anon2599889874,anon1491650132,"Link
Okay, thanks! See you on wednesday then.
Logistics wiki: So far, the link for uploading is the [LOTE5 workspace](/c/workspaces/lote5), will there be a sub-section like ""/docu"" or so? Otherwise, I imagine the threads will be scattered all over the forum and it'll be hard to find them.
Posterwise:
I'd like to alter the wording a bit, because ""enjoy"" can be interpreted in the slightly cynical direction of ""well, if you think that's a good idea, enjoy yourself!"" :)
I didn't mean it that way, when I wrote it, and I'd like to be clear and apprechiative about what people chose to do. What I meant was to encourage people to
do what they want, so please change to ""That's great, too!"" instead of ""Enjoy.""
Suggestion for wording:
> ""Like to document in another way? That's great, too! After you're done, please upload your material here: [LOTE5 workspace](/c/workspaces/lote5)
>
> Look whether a post for the session already exist there.
>
> If so, add you material to the post.
>
> If not, open one and start the documentation of that session.
>
> Tadaah!
Tadaah probably optional, but I hope you get the idea. ;) Intention: make process as easy and clear for everybody, also those who either weren't present
at introduction or couldn't be bothered then, but then get interested in contributing afterwards and can't remember what was said about the ""how to"".
Or am I making this more complicated than necessary? Previous lote experiece based feedback welcome!
Logistics \# 2: Since you liked the posters idea ... For the overview of what is being documented and making things as easy as possible:
Would it be possible to also have a printed version of the documentation wiki excel where people add their names to the sessions?
That would be hanging somewhere on a well visible wall and people can walk up there and add themselves spontaneously. Again, for the pen and paper crowd
who're not into checking everything online all the time.
The ""worst"" thing that can happen is that we have people parallely signing up online and on the paper version."
12,18640,2016-02-19T11:27:04.000Z,18239,anon1491650132,anon2599889874,"Better than subsection of LOTE5..
..a new group: LOTE5 Harvest. Basically when clicking there all posts/wikis/documents will be documentation only. I also assigned this wiki to that group. So we have a clean slate. Works? @anon
"
13,18819,2016-02-19T13:13:00.000Z,18640,anon2599889874,anon1491650132,"you are the pro reg. the techy side of things ...
... so I think a group is perfect. I most probably meant that when writing ""sub section"", hehe. Still not totally getting the forum's structure.
One request @anon
There is a difference, which I don't expect to be clear yet (because I didn't break it down in detail probably, and it's a little tough to
find the right words right now due to time shortage), but it's important for me to rather point to the documentation side for now,
even though it might seem I'm splitting hair. :)
In a nutshell: how to document is on track already and it seems like it's going to work.
Harvesting, on the other hand, is a process that is not going to happen in its full potential at LOTE (as I had to realize), due
to different reasons (number of people present at LOTE with AoH harvesting experience, process design compatibility ...).
So what's going to happen are some sprinkles of harvesting. It will rather be flower picking than harvesting the entire field,
if that allegory helps. Yes, I know, I called it ""harvesting"" myself, in a moment of overestimating (ignoring?) possibilities.
Typical utopians trap! *sigh*
Therefore, I expect the amount of documentation threads to dominate - so it would be more correct to call the group accordingly.
I'm not be able to explain this in more detail right now, sorry, even though I'd love to. Looking forward to talking about this to you in person.
Thanks!
Kaja
"
14,19632,2016-02-18T09:20:18.000Z,5255,anon2178703328,anon1491650132,"HOw to add myself?
Hi, I'd like to help document the Master of Networks session, but I can't edit above. How do I do it?
"
15,21676,2016-02-18T10:20:00.000Z,19632,anon1491650132,anon2178703328,"Edit button above the menu
Hey, hope this helps:
"
16,22574,2016-02-20T12:53:21.000Z,21676,anon2178703328,anon1491650132,"Thanks!
Thanks Noemi, it worked! Now I still have to figure out the hackpad thingy. I'm a little confused, can you confirm me that it is going to be part of the edgeryder group?
"
17,23005,2016-02-20T13:03:53.000Z,21676,anon2178703328,anon1491650132,"Hackpad also figured out
"
18,23097,2016-02-19T09:38:54.000Z,19632,anon2599889874,anon2178703328,"Yay!
Thanks for joining the session journalists :) Looking forward to reading all about that session, which I probably won't be able to join, myself.
You're actively lowering my fomo - phew!
"
19,23430,2016-02-18T15:17:09.000Z,5255,anon821296424,anon1491650132,"My contribution
Hello all,
Nice to meet you. I just joined, and would like to let you know that I am willing to document (let me say I will be a session journalist, but also seeking questions, patterns and the flow of) the workshop on ""The pedagogy of development in the Global South"". I hope that doesn't coincide with the ""Collaborative inclusion"" session, as that was my main reason to attend. But we shall see when we come to that.
Looking forward to see you on Thursday.
Annick
PS: sorry for posting it as a comment but I have no idea how to otherwise let you know what I can contribute here.
"
20,26911,2016-02-20T20:36:39.000Z,5255,anon2599889874,anon1491650132,"The Art of Powerful Question
I added it to the Wiki, but just in case there's no notification:
If you're interested in The Art of Powerful Questions, please this way.
Enjoy!
"
22,29520,2016-02-25T09:43:08.000Z,5255,anon1491650132,anon1491650132,"Meetup documenters 18:00 today Merab room
Hi all, it seems we have ourselves a team!
With @anon
If you are at SmartBe for LOTE launch on Thursday, right after we will meet in Merab room, at 18:00 or immediately after the welcoming and before dinner. See you there!
"
23,30298,2016-03-04T10:43:53.000Z,5255,anon2599889874,anon1491650132,"wow, all the action ...
Hejhej!
I'm really impressed to see how effortlessly the notes are flowing in and how the documentation is taking shape and growing steadily. Seeing all that action on the docu team is awesome! :)
As always, someone has to lag behind, and that's going to be me, damnit! I'm trying to ignore a flu while working double shifts to make up for my last week's absence because at Lote and next week's because of Art of Hosting Karlskrona. Will try to be back a little later in March with typed up notes and reflections on the event in general ... after jumanon3606750899g on another tree for a week!
"
1,5196,2015-12-07T10:13:30.000Z,5196,anon1941345029,anon1941345029,"
In collaboration with: |
|
About
The migration issue is here to stay. Europe is the place-to-go for several millions of women and men. This will not change in the next decades. The challenge is to think about this not as a threat, but as an opportunity. That is, to imagine how migration can become a driver of innovation towards a younger, more dynamic, more cosmopolitan and, at the end of the day, more resilient Europe.
No one knows whether, and how, this positive perspective could become real. The only wise move to do is to consider this broad view, i.e. the possibility of a new cosmopolitan Europe, as a design-orienting scenario: a shared vision on the basis of which to experiment local solutions, to discuss them and to use them to feed a broad social learning process. And this is what we attempt here.
""Collaborative inclusion"" is a reflexive design exercise to explore how collaboration between migrants and residents can strengthen the social fabric. More precisely, we look at what kinds of collaborative services (intended as result-oriented collaborations among different actors) can produce social, cultural, economic value.
Answering this question will lead us to another one: how to conceive and/or evaluate collaborative service capable to produce such multiple value? This reflexive design exercise adopts three simple evaluation criteria. A service is considered ""better"" when:
- Each migrant has more scope to express his/her ideas, and to choose what to do and how.
- He/she is active and uses better his/her sensitivity, skills and knowledge in the service.
- He/she produces more, better results for him/herself, for other migrants and for the whole resident community.
These three criteria, which come from design for social innovation experiences in different fields of application, are quite simple. We suspect that most services deployed in Europe to dealing with migration fail all three, quite spectacularly.
Who should participate
We only ask that participants do their best be critical, creative and committed. No specific information or competence on migration issue is required. We believe we all have firsthand experience at coming to terms with migration. Many of us are migrants (especially in Brussels!); the others are part of host communities. We are all citizen experts. Additionally, some of us have extra skills (design) or experiences (hosting newcomers in their homes). We specifically welcome:
- refugees or ex-refugees.
- people who can translate to and from Arabic.
- people who are involved in projects aimed at facilitating the welcome and insertion of migrants and refugees (example: there are many projects in the Techfugees project directory).
- designers.
We already have some participants in all these categories, but the more the better!
When, where and how to participate
Collaborative inclusion is part of the Living On The Edge 5 community gathering. It takes place on February 26th 2016 in Brussels, at SmartBE. To participate, click the ""Attend"" button on the top right if the page, then download the Notes for Participants and have a look at them before the event.
Background notes: designing for social innovation
Design question: given European problems and the way they are perceived in Europeans’ everyday life, how migrants can be part of these same problems solution? How can migrants and other resident actors collaborate to improve their quality of the life?
Hypothesis: In the complexity of the present society we can already find promising examples of migrants-residents collaboration: collaborative initiatives demonstrating how the search of migrants’ inclusion can be turned in a collaborative service, and therefore, in the exploration of new ways of living and working.
Methodology: The exercise is in two steps: (1) to consider and discuss a number of promising examples, and (2) to improve them and/or use them as triggers for brand new proposals.
Specificity: We build on our previous experience in design for social innovation, and aim to verify its usefulness in creating value for both the migrants and the whole society. This leads us to work in three main directions, that translate into three main criteria for the conception and evaluation of the services the group will come up with:
- User-centered approach (as precondition): solutions must consider each migrant as a free individual. That is, it must be based on his/her right and concrete possibility to express ideas, and choose what to do and how.
- Capability approach (as main design guideline): solutions must be based on migrants’ active participation. More precisely, they should enable them to use at best their sensitivity, skills and knowledge.
- Multiple-value production (as result to be achieved): solutions must achieve some practical and social results for all the involved actors (migrants and residents) and for society as a whole (in terms of physical and social commons improvement).
Aims
The aim of the workshop is not to invent new solutions (it will be impossible to do it in a serious way in this context) but to start form some existing promising practices, to imagine and present ideas and actions to amplify their potentialities.
Where:
- Promising practices are initiatives that are already operating in the collaborative inclusion spirit. That is, living examples of how collaboration between migrants and local communities can solve problems and generate values for all (the same migrants and the whole society).
- To amplify potentialities means to give promising practices visibility and support. That is, (1) to increase their possibility to be positively recognized by larger number of people (among both migrants and residents), and (2) to improve the (social, cultural, normative, technical, and economic) environment so that it could become easier for the given promising practices to consolidate and last in time, and for other similar initiatives to start and flourish.
Ideas and actions means everything can be conceived in terms of communication, services, places, events and performances that could give that specific practice, and its produced values more visibility and/or that could produce for that same practice, or for other similar ones, a more supportive environment
Workshop structure
The workshop is organised in three moments:
- 10.00 Setting the scene and promising practices presentations
- 11.00 Group work (in 5 parallel groups) (including lunch)
- 15.00 Group presentations and discussion
- 16.00 End
Working groups brief
A facilitator will help each working group for extra speed, fluidity and fun. Each group will work on one promising case study of a service for refugees and migrants. Given this, each group outline one or more ideas/actions to amplify its potentialities. The focus can be on:
- Visibility, to make the values a given promising practice (directly and indirectly) produces more visible and attractive.
- Support, to make its environment more favourable, for the same promising practice and for other similar ones.
Expected results for workgroups are:
- Each group conceive 2-3 ideas/actions and the communicative artefacts needed to present them. These ideas/actions must be motivated and presented indicating the main involved actors, outlining their organization and their technical and economic viability.
Activities of working groups activity will be divided into three phases:
Phase 1: Understanding and representing (the case, its actors and its values)
- Outlining the promising practice organization form, focusing on the values it produces (for the migrant and for the local community)
- Identifying the involved actors, focusing on migrants (and creating personas).
- Defining the related journey of experience, focusing on its main touch points
Phase 2: Generating ideas (on how to give visibility and support to the case)
- In-depth discussion of the produced values, focusing on their strengths and weakness.
- Generation of ideas (for example, each group member indicates an idea. These individual ideas are clustered in groups with similar meanings and discussed by the working group to find the first 2-3 better ones.
- Ideas consolidation, with the definition of: main involved actors, outlining their organization and their technical and economic viability.
Phase 3: Making visible (producing communicative artefacts to present the group results)
- Group members prepare the 2-3 ideas/actions presentation, considering the need of a very short, 5’ presentation.
Before the workshop
Each participant is invited:
- to search for promising case and select, at least, one example that, in his/her view, is (totally or at least partly) coherent with the three previously indicated criteria of conception and evaluation.
- to write a short presentation of the selected example (name, place, main promoters, goals and values produced for the migrants and for the society), add a photo and edit the whole in an A4 format (only one sheet). Upload it in the website and bring a paper copy to the workshop venue.
Possible references:
Reading the references is not obligatory at all! But it may help you to get into the flow and enjoy it more.
Design&society:
- Ezio Manzini, Design when Everybody Designs”, MIT Press 2015
- John Thackara, How to Thrive in the Next Economy: Designing Tomorrow's World Today, Thames&Hudson Ltd, 2015
Migration&innovation:
- http://citiesofmigration.ca
- https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/socialinnovationeurope/it
- http://www.techfugees.com
Feel free to suggest more!
Team
- Ezio Manzini. Designer, interested in social innovation and sustainability. Collaborates with the OpenCare project. More
- Yara Al Adib. Designer. Originally from Syria. More
- Gido Van Den Ende. Expert on the history of migration in Europe. Currently hosting refugees in his Dilbeek home. Vishall Jankie. User experience- and service designer at Namahn. Passionate about human-centered design, travelling and surfing. anon4157656950anos Monastiridis. Professional interests in citizen participation, systems thinking and design for transformation. Also with Namahn. Mousab Alshikh. Professional in the furniture industry & economic analysis, he fled the war in Syria to make a new life in Belgium. Rand Abu Fakher. A student in music and sound engineering, she had to interrupt her studies due to the war. In Belgium, she returned to one of her favourite pastimes: designing jewellery. Orwa Isaac. In his work, he would like to combine ideas from the West and the East. He wants to build a future in Belgium for himself and his family. “Hope and setting goals is the key to success.” Virginia Tassinari. She has always been interested in connecting the world of philosophy and design. In her work at LUCA arts, Virginia mainly focuses in her projects, teaching and writing on the relationship between social innovation and philosophy, practice and theory.
Contact anon1526983854 [at] edgeryders [dot] eu if you want to join the team.
How to get a ticket!
Tickets for this event do not cost money, but you need to complete some small tasks. It's easy!
1. If you don't already have one, sign up for an edgeryders account here: http://bit.ly/1SKCYtZ
2. Leave a comment below to introduce yourself and let us know you want to come!
4. Someone will say hello and suggest some small tasks you should complete for a ticket!
5. When you finish the tasks, we will send you the ticket
6. Khalas! See you at the workshop :)
Date: 2016-02-26 10:00:00 - 2016-02-26 16:30:00, Europe/Brussels Time."
2,7756,2015-12-08T15:24:48.000Z,5196,anon3227838693,anon1941345029,"Mr. Manzini, do it again in Berlin in April, please!
I am currently organising a product design project at UdK Berlin around the OpenCare topic and would love to invite you to Berlin from April 4-8 to support us with your knowledge and input. The project is a cooperation with Nadia and it would be super awesome if you could come! The project aims at providing the research project with first ideas/products/services to work with further on. I have organised this place for the workshop and look forward to your response! Thank you!
"
3,15750,2016-01-19T21:15:58.000Z,5196,anon4216492773,anon1941345029,"Would love to help
Greetings :) My name is Yara, i am a service and social designer and have experience facilitating workshops. I am Syrian who seeked refuge in Belgium a year ago and so currently working and living in Belgium. I would love to help and contribute both as a designer and as a refugee during the event and in this workshop in particular.
"
4,17677,2016-01-19T21:42:44.000Z,15750,anon1526983854,anon4216492773,"Yes, do come!
@anon4216492773, thank you so much for this offer! Yes, you are just the person we need. Welcome aboard! We will make you a co-host of the event, together with @anon1941345029.
Where are you based? In a few days it would be nice to make the final decisions on this workshop and open up registrations. If you are in Brussels, we could even meet in person, maanon1932026148 also with @anon70625510, @anon"
5,20882,2016-01-19T21:51:28.000Z,5196,anon4216492773,anon1941345029,"Sure thing!
Thank you @anon1526983854 for the warm welcome! I would love to be co-host with @anon1941345029! I am based in Antwerp and work in Brussels. Keep me in the loop on the time of the meeting, preferably after 6, since I work full time. Tell me what time and medium suites you best :)"
6,22152,2016-01-19T21:54:56.000Z,20882,anon1526983854,anon4216492773,"Done :-)
Only one point of concern: no problem scheduling a meeting after 6, but the actual workshop will be during the day. At the moment it is scheduled at 10.30 pm Friday morning, the 26th of February (program). Will that be a problem?
"
7,24205,2016-01-19T22:02:20.000Z,5196,anon4216492773,anon1941345029,"No Problem
Good you told me @anon1526983854, I can take that day off then, no problem :)"
8,25096,2016-01-19T22:18:07.000Z,24205,anon1526983854,anon4216492773,"Ok, we're in business then!
Excellent, @anon4216492773!
We'll be in touch very soon. Meanwhile, there are two things you could do to prepare this:
- Register for the LOTE5 event... wait, you already did! Well done. By helanon3606750899g with the workshop, you earn a LOTE5 ticket (the conference is not free, but you cannot buy a ticket with money).
- Add a short bio – it goes the conference website. Three or four lines is ideal. You can put it in your Edgeryders profile: https://edgeryders.eu/en/user, then click on the ""Edit profile"" tab. You'll find a link that says ""Personal info"". Click there, and write in the ""Bio"" field, then hit Save. You can also add your own website, Twitter handle etc.
Thanks a lot!"
9,26124,2016-01-21T09:06:02.000Z,5196,anon4216492773,anon1941345029,"Updates
@anon1526983854 Done! Buzz me when you would like to have that meeting and please don't hesitate to contact me if there is anything else I can assist with
Sorry I am not super active on the platform in the mornings, due to work, but I try my best to keep me self notified and posted :) Grazie Millie :)"
10,27877,2016-01-31T14:55:46.000Z,5196,anon2339841247,anon1941345029,"Take part to the reflexive design exercise
Hello,
Just a few words to let you know that I intend to take part to the exercise but on a part-time basis as I'm busy in the morning.
As part of the orgaizing team of the ""Hack with Refugees"" event, I can also share briefly as requested the main elements of this activity and how it connects with the three main criteria for the conception of services.
Kind regards
Philippe Drouillon
"
11,29129,2016-02-03T10:36:43.000Z,5196,anon3176867678,anon1941345029,"Intersting project
Dear all,
Unfortunately I am only able to attend on the weekend! A link and a project that seems for me promising is https://kiron.university they set up a free online university of refugees - I guess a great way to supporting the transformation of a problem into an opportunity. Hope to meet at the weekend and all the best!
Adrian
"
12,29562,2016-02-10T23:37:25.000Z,29129,anon1526983854,anon3176867678,"Thanks anyway
Thanks @anon3176867678. seems like a great project!"
13,29996,2016-02-11T13:38:23.000Z,5196,anon4259720994,anon1941345029,"Looking forward to the workshop
I work for a non-profit social enterprise alliance that employs different strategies aimed at improving the lives and well-being of the thousands of Syrian-Armenians impacted by the ravaging war in Syria. I'm the only representative of the platform in Armenia and I multitask(social housing project in Dilijan, independent social workers' unit in Yerevan, writing blog posts, helanon3606750899g some extremely vulnerable families to integrate, etc) and volunteer as much as I can. Here's my session at LOTE5, feel free to join or be a part of the team :-)
What's the difference between the team and the participants in this workshop though? @anon1526983854"
14,30327,2016-02-11T14:38:00.000Z,29996,anon1526983854,anon4259720994,"The team is willing to work harder :-)
... otherwise there is no difference! It's more me wanting to communicate that there is a small group committed to driving it. You are welcome to be on the team yourself :-) There has been a separate Skype so far. The next one is Sunday 14th. Do you want to participate?
"
15,30445,2016-02-11T19:51:01.000Z,30327,anon4259720994,anon1526983854,"Sure sure, this is what I wanted to know :-) Count me in! What time is the call? Will do my best to participate!
Cheers
"
16,30486,2016-02-13T12:12:54.000Z,30445,anon1526983854,anon4259720994,"15.00 CET
@anon4259720994 it is at 15.00 CET on Skype. Can you make it?"
17,30498,2016-02-13T20:42:08.000Z,30486,anon4259720994,anon1526983854,"Will do my best to join you!
"
19,31548,2016-02-16T13:55:05.000Z,5196,anon2590712900,anon1941345029,"I want to attend
Hi,
I want to attend this exercise as citizen with a design background.
I hear a lot about the refuges in the media but have never met one. It seems like they are kept in a bubble, and so am I! Bearing in mind that many have just went trough a traumatic experience, it's good to be keep in a protective bubble. But at the same time we have to learn to trust each, break the bubbles and cooperate.
I am not sure on the three criteria for the cases we have to bring, what are they?
Cheers,
Merel
"
20,31838,2016-02-17T11:41:39.000Z,5196,anon1532057528,anon1941345029,"I would love to attend
Hi all, I am Nastasja, Polish-German from Berlin, living currently in Brussels. I am project manager working mainly in communication and organization of cultural events. I was participating at the hack-with-refugees weekend a couple of weeks ago where we developed a project idea on the integration of refugees in the job market. The idea consists in valorising professional skills and qualifications by supporting refugees to develop their first CV in Belgium, translated and adopted to the Belgian job market in face-to-face meetings. We are currently working on the development of an adopted tool/method together with psychologists and HR specialists and we are aiming to collaborate with Fedasil and public authorities in Belgium. I would love to participate to this event, meeting inspiring people, contribute with my perspective, broaden my horizon and collecting further ideas for our social inclusion project. Looking forward to meet you!!
"
21,32101,2016-02-19T14:06:20.000Z,5196,anon3392305329,anon1941345029,"would like to participate in the worshop next friday
Hello!
My name is Florianne. First a bit about my professional life... I work in public health with migrant communities in Barcelona, Spain. My background is humanitarian worker in refugee camps and conflict affected areas (mainly in Africa) for various institutions. I have recently come back from Lesbos volunteering with the refugees with some friends with similar backgrounds. We were inspired by the work done by the volunteers taking on a huge share of the work of receiving the refugees alongside the usual suspects of the trade. We did feel that this amazing energy could be better harnessed to provide a follow up for people arriving so that they are not left stranded and without help once they leave Greece, or when they arrive at their destination. Taking stock of all the local groups and projects that are currently working to help refugees, we did wonder: What happens to people who do not speak any european languages or even arabic? What happens to the ones who do not read and write, or use internet? Is there a way to provide information on resources available along the way to refugees/migrants at their point of entry so that the ones who are less 'networked' are not stranded? We are thinking of these questions as we prepare to go back to the local volunteer groups we worked with in Greece. We have also started to linking families we have met in Greece with people willing to meet them at their point of destination. I don't know if these are themes of interest for this workshop, but in any case I am quite interested to hear from all of you if you think I could contribute on behalf of our little group.
Best wishes!
"
22,32200,2016-02-20T11:12:55.000Z,32101,anon1526983854,anon3392305329,"Welcome aboard
Hello Florianne, welcome aboard.
We are delighted you want to participate. Please register for the event: in the text itself you will find the instructions. We expect a full house.
"
23,32238,2016-02-20T12:15:16.000Z,32200,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Registration bug...
Sorry, scrap that. I just noticed a registration bug. Your registration is noted, Florianne. Likewise, those of Merel and Nastasia.
"
24,32256,2016-02-20T15:06:41.000Z,32238,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Registration bug solved
The ""Attend"" button is back. If you want to register, use it. Merel, Natasia, Florianne and Joe Camacho are considered as registered.
"
25,32296,2016-02-20T12:36:11.000Z,5196,anon1526983854,anon1941345029,"Participants notes now ready
The team has produced participants notes for the Collaborative inclusion workshop. You can download them here. Please have a look at them before the event for more enjoyable, smooth participation.
Be advised that we expect a full house for this event. Be on time!
"
27,32718,2016-02-22T11:17:26.000Z,5196,anon413297907,anon1941345029,"I'd love to attend as well
Hello all,
I'd love to join the workshop.
In a way I have been a migrant for the past three years of my life. I didn't leave my country because of major social/political/economical issues. I left looking for something different because I couldn't fit in anymore with the cultural and social constraints I was surrounded by in my home country. A blessed and privileged migrant sure, still I can share part of the feeling of being alien and alienated.
As part of the team working on the OpenCare project I'm confident we will have the chance to include migrants (and hopefully refugees) in the conversation and to involve them in the designing of the prototypes.
I believe the workshop would be a good way to set the right mind set and get inspired on how to reach and involve the communities of migrants.
Cheers
"
28,32899,2016-02-25T14:51:55.000Z,5196,anon3885526833,anon1941345029,"I'd love to come!
Hello, my name is Eva and I'm an MA student in Leuven. I'm going to be writing my thesis on socio-cultural integration for refugees - so this event is perfect, as it's so focussed on my interests! What can I do to get a ticket? Looking forward to it!
"
29,32931,2016-02-25T16:42:56.000Z,32899,anon70625510,anon3885526833,"Sign up for documentation duty and then show up :)
Instructions for documentatin and how to add yourself to the team here: https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5/documentation-harvesting-of-lote-what-why-how
See you tomorrow :)
"
30,32940,2016-02-25T17:36:17.000Z,32931,anon3885526833,anon70625510,"Thanks, I've added my name to the list to document the Collaborative inclusion event about migrants-residents collaboration. I won't be using the hackpad but I'll upload my notes to the shared file afterwards - hope that's ok! How do I get my ticket?
"
31,32945,2016-02-25T23:01:57.000Z,32940,anon1526983854,anon3885526833,"Just come
And talk to Noemi.
"
32,32952,2016-02-25T16:29:37.000Z,5196,anon3956905734,anon1941345029,"Mapanon3606750899g initiative
Hi there,
I thought I would share the ""Jungle Maps"" initiative in Calais/Dunkerke, which I find an interesting initiative to unfold realities behind migration :
https://twitter.com/Jungle_Maps and
https://www.facebook.com/junglemapanon3606750899g
"
33,32979,2016-02-25T16:43:47.000Z,32952,anon70625510,anon3956905734,"Cool, joining us?
If so and you need a ticket...documentation tasks for a ticket :)) https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5/documentation-harvesting-of-lote-what-why-how
"
34,32998,2016-03-03T18:11:40.000Z,5196,anon1526983854,anon1941345029,"Documentation uploaded
https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5-doc/documentation-collaborative-inclusion-how-migrants-residents
"
1,5408,2016-03-03T17:51:54.000Z,5408,anon70625510,anon70625510,"
![]()
On February 28, we came together in Brussels for the first Narratives of Care Storytelling workshop.
What started with a simple question which developed into deep conversations that are still ongoing days after everyone went home. Pauline kindly contributed her notes from the discussions and I uploaded them here. Also Ezio summarised his own reflections around care from a different, but related, discussion here.
From the different conversations I draw the conclusion that a big part of building effective storytelling for our individual care-related initiatives is designing contexts for care that work for us. As care givers and receivers:
How to do this effectively? Is it the same for regardless of which kind of initiative you are communicating around, or not? Are there significant cultural differences around care and communication that need to be taken into account or no?
This brunch is an opportunity to research and prototype answers to these questions together in a nice and relaxed environment with delicious things to eat!
Bring yourself, your project and anyone you want to invite along. Just let me know a day in advance so I can plan for enough food :))
Date: 2016-03-12 11:00:00 - 2016-03-12 11:00:00, Europe/Brussels Time."
1,5406,2016-03-03T16:17:29.000Z,5406,anon70625510,anon70625510,"
![]()
On February 28, we came together in Brussels for the first Narratives of Care Storytelling workshop.
What started with a simple question developed into deep conversations that are still ongoing days after everyone went home. Pauline kindly contributed her notes from the discussions and I uploaded them here, Ezio Manzini summarised his own reflections around care from a different, but related, discussion here.
From the different conversations I draw the conclusion that a big part of designing narratives is designing contexts for care that work for us. As care givers and receivers.
How to do this effectively?Is it the same for regardless of which kind of initiative you are communicating around, or not? Are there significant cultural differences around care and communication that need to be taken into account or no?
This brunch is an opportunity to research and prototype this together in a nice and relaxed environment with delicious things to eat :)
Date: 2016-03-12 11:00:00 - 2016-03-12 11:00:00, Europe/Brussels Time."
2,7212,2016-03-03T17:37:42.000Z,5406,anon1526983854,anon70625510,"I will be traveling...
... but it seems like a great idea. Where is it?
"
3,10900,2016-03-03T17:44:22.000Z,7212,anon70625510,anon1526983854,"At our space in Brussels :))
A number of us got into really deep conversations, which I think everyone needed some time to process. But it is a conversation in progress, so I thought it might be a good idea to continue. Plus everyone's so cool, it would be nice to meetup again :)
"
1,5392,2016-03-01T16:55:59.000Z,5392,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/23/health/a-do-it-yourself-revolution-in-diabetes-care.html?smid=tw-share&_r=0
This is pretty amazing: an entire open source ecosystem, from sensors to apps to insulin, emerging from patients.
Where do we want to store all this stuff?
"
2,6667,2016-03-02T08:03:01.000Z,5392,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Incredible story
Great, great story.
It is however reported as a solo heroic strive rather than as a community effort. The article does mention the ""biotech hacker space Counter Culture Labs"", and then the Open Insulin project, but makes it sound as if the individual initiative were what mattered in solving the situation.
I would be interested to know more about the story, and learn about the collective effort that was put in. (Although it could well have been the result of individual effort after all.)
On ""where to put this stuff"", I suppose we should start archiving these stories somehow. My guess is a wiki would do it ok (but I understand ER wikis have been used as single page wikis most of the time). A (collection of) hackpad (or anything similar) would probably be fine.
"
3,10762,2016-03-02T15:20:26.000Z,6667,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"""Solo heroes""?
Solo heroes are not what I see, Guy. One guy writes code to upload the data to the cloud. Someone else reuses it. A third person starts a systematisation of the code to create an open source ecosystem. Then that ecosystem is enlarged to drive a pump, so you get an open source artificial pancreas. Then the insulin... I see it as very collective!
"
4,14203,2016-03-02T18:24:00.000Z,5392,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Mea culpa
I can't explain why I got it all wrong. Went back to the news article and read it carefully this time. Even made a network map of the story to claim your forgiveness ... (would be even more convincing if animated).
"
5,17129,2016-03-03T17:36:08.000Z,14203,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Accidental breakthrough?
You seem to have stumbled into networks as a storytelling technique. Of course all visualisations tell stories, but in OpenCare we are telling stories of collaboration and interconnectedness, so networks work particularly well. Is it worth doing some work on, trying to come up with self-explanatory visualizations?
"
6,19932,2016-03-03T16:15:51.000Z,5392,anon3612872438,anon1526983854,"nice mapanon3606750899g!
@anon2774142051 how did you make it?
it's generated or drawn and from what data you found in the article?
thanks
Zoe
"
7,23566,2016-03-03T17:21:10.000Z,5392,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Tulip it is
I re-read the paper and made myself a map of the story with Tulip, extracting names of persons and/or organizations by hand. The grouped nodes with outer/inner labels is one of the marvelous things you can do with the software :-)
"
1,5260,2016-02-03T18:22:35.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"https://www.youtube.com/embed/2-9z0i5fuvE?rel=0
Why
Care happens in networks. People take care of each other. They seek advice, medical help and moral support from each other. They exchange knowledge and share resources. They meet, interact, and work together. And, of course, no human can live well if he or she disconnects from the fabric of society at large (in recent times, care also happened in big bureaucracies, but that approach has issues. Here we look for something better).
We think that this ceaseless exchange is collective intelligence at work. Network analysis is a useful tool to understand this process, and perhaps find ways to improve upon it. Thinking in networks is a great way to generate fresh, relevant questions. How do you know your network is going in the right direction? What is a “direction” in this context? Is everyone following the same path? Do people group into sub-communities? What are the focus of these (sub) communities?
What
We come together to find out how networked humans can better take care of each other.
To do this, we study result-oriented conversations. Conversations are networks: people are its nodes, and the exchanges are its links. It you don't believe us, click here to explore the Edgeryders conversation network (allow a few seconds for the data to download). But conversations are networks also in another sense: each exchange contains some concepts. Example of concepts useful in care are: well-being, syranon1056199097, diabethes, fitness, prosthetics, etc. We can represent concept in a conversation as a network. Concepts themselves are its nodes; two concepts are linked if they are in the same exchange.
Person-to-person conversation networks tell us who is talking to whom. Are there individuals who act as ""hubs""? Why? Can we use hubs to improve the process, for example asking them to spread important knowledge?
Concept-to-concept conversation networks tell us how the different concepts connect to each other. Are there surprises? Do apparently unrelated concepts tend to come up in the same exchanges? Anomalies might mean something interesting is going on. In fact, spotting anomalies is how John Snow invented epidemiology in 1854.
The fascinating part is this: by looking at the network, we can extract information that no individual in the network has. The whole is greater than the sum of the parts. Collective intelligence!
How
We look at conversation data taken from Edgeryders and build them into a network. We use open source software for network analysis. We then visualize and interrogate the network to see what we can learn. Our final aim is to prototype methodologies for extracting collective intelligent outcomes from conversations.
One great output from the workshop would be to unleash our imagination, and specify design & requirements:
- What views works best? It'll be useful to build it as a mockup if we do not already have it -- use color pens, paper, clips, cardboard and build it into a mock-up!
- For what tasks? Do we need to move things around? Pile them up to trigger comparison of things on-the-fly? Lasso an item to trigger some computation? -- use post-it notes, cut and paste pieces of paper, draw arrows to turn tasks into real actions (on a screen!).
- Using what ingredient (data)? What should we feed the system with to accomplish these analytical tasks? -- write them down, cut & paste, associate them with specific tasks, embed them into views.
The workshop is a unique opportunity to have a design participatory workshop -- we want it to be a source of inspiration to design and build the next generation EdgeSense dashboard!
Who should come
Masters of Networks is open to all, and especially friendly to beginners. Patients, network scientists, doctors, hackers and so on all have something to contribute. But in the end we are all experts in this domain. We all give and receive care in the course of our lives, and all humans are expert conversationalists. There's an extra bonus for beginners: networks are easy to visualize. And when you visualize them, as we will, they are often beautiful and intuitive.
Trust us. We have done this before (check out the video above).
Data
We have a dataset drawn from a large conversation that took place on the Edgeryders platform in 2014. It consists of 161 posts and 910 comments, authored by 128 different people. All posts and comments have been annotated by a professional ethnographer. This leaves us with an ontology of relevant concepts: we can use it to build the network.
That conversation was not about care. We will need to be clever, and use different data to figure out a methodology to apply to a future conversation about care.
Agenda and challenges
The agenda is simple:
Visualization challenge. Create informative and beautiful visualizations starting from our data. Skills needed: design, dataviz, netviz. Coordinator: @anon2774142051 (you can call me Guy)
- Its not only about creativity and beauty, it's about interactivity -- a map seen as a malleable object so you can squirk information out of it.
- It's also about being able to specify graphical design from the tasks you'd need to conduct on the data and its representation on the screen.
- How is a node-link view useful? How would you intuitively like to manipulate, filter or change it at will when exploring it?
- Would you feel you need to synchronize the view with a bar chart on some statistics? A scatterplot to figure out if things correlate?
Interpretation challenge. How many conclusions and hypotheses can we ""squeeze"" from the data? Skills needed: social research, ethnography, network science. Coordinator: @anon
- Interpretation is at the core of the process. You play with data, you map it, and iteratively build hypothesis. In the end, you dream you would have provable claims.
Quality challenge. Can we think of simple criteria to filter the data for the highest-quality content only (eg: only posts with a minimum number of comments, or of minimum length)? Does the filtering change the results? Coordination: @anon
And more. But we insist that every group has a coordinator, who takes responsibility for driving it, sharing the relevant material (examples: software libraries, notes for participants, pseudo code...). If we only have two coordinators, we'll only have two groups. If you think you can lead a group, get in touch with us!
Tentative schedule
- 9h30 - 11h - @anon
- 11h - 12h30 Teams give it a first shot
- The viz team will play a game building their ideal visual dashboard using pen and paper, cardboard -- explaining why these features may turn to be essential when exploring or analyzing network data.
- The interpretation team output is critical: the directions they will provide has decisive impact on how data will be used, massaged and turned into visual representations.
- The qualitative team plays a similar role, feeding the intepretation team with high quality content -- their recommendations will make even greater sense if we can link them with paths of interpretation.
- 12h30 - 14h Feed your brain with proteins and glucids.
- 14h - 16h Teams go back to work and build a proof-of-concept of the ideas /hypothesis they came up with in the morning session.
- Cross-fertilization of ideas with the other teams is encouraged. People may wish to change teams to widen their experience and knowledge.
- Teams prepare a short summary of their findings/conclusions that will be presented during the wrap-up session.
- 16h - 16h30 Wrap-up. Team presentation, plenary discussion.
Who is facilitating
When it is, where it is and how to participate
Masters of Networks 4: Networks of Care is part of LOTE5. It takes place on Saturday, 27th February 2016 at Brussels Art Factory, SmartBE. Sign up by clicking the ""attend button. Leave a comment below to let us know what your skills are, we'll put them to good use! We particularly need people to help us with the documentation of what is done.
How to prepare
Have a look at Detangler, and play with the map just to get a feeling of what can be done. If you have questions, write them as comments to this post.
What happens next
A project called OpenCare will convene a large-scale conversation about care. The work in OpenCare will make good use of the insights generated during Networks of Care.
Date: 2016-02-27 08:30:00 - 2016-02-27 08:30:00, Europe/Brussels Time."
2,9597,2016-02-03T18:34:56.000Z,5260,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Moved everything here
@anon2774142051, I rewrote your text for outreach purposes. Do change what you don't like. I also had to move the content to a newly created event for technical reasons.
@anon4116418727 and @anon
"
3,11773,2016-02-03T18:49:04.000Z,9597,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Thanks
Good. Thanks for helanon3606750899g. You have a talent it would take me yet another life to learn :-)
"
4,12592,2016-02-03T18:53:20.000Z,11773,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Hey :-)
Funny, I always say the same of you.
"
5,13674,2016-02-04T12:04:30.000Z,9597,anon3471410614,anon1526983854,"enrolling
hi anon1526983854!
Can I facilitate even if I must leave at 1 pm?
"
6,13766,2016-02-04T12:18:56.000Z,13674,anon1526983854,anon3471410614,"Yes
I see your role as helanon3606750899g to shape questions, i.e. map the methodology we'll be working with onto care in general and OpenCare in particular.
"
7,16321,2016-02-04T13:43:21.000Z,5260,anon3471410614,anon2774142051,"all right
I'm in
"
8,17900,2016-02-04T14:54:30.000Z,16321,anon1526983854,anon3471410614,"So...
... please click on the ""Attend"" button. While you are at it, please do the same on the LOTE5 event here. @anon
"
9,18145,2016-02-18T09:58:41.000Z,17900,anon3914374234,anon1526983854,"Ok
I did it for the LOTE event.
Unfortunatly I have to fly back to Milan on Friday evening...
Lucia will stay for MoN till Sat morning.
"
10,21472,2016-02-05T17:18:22.000Z,5260,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"""Yes, but what will we DO?""
@anon2774142051, my friend: our text is clear and nicely written, but it is not a work program. I added a tentative agenda section. Please look it up and see if you think it makes sense. If it does, assign yourself as the coordinator of a challenge... or maanon1932026148 let's decide to do only one challenge, so we can hack together!
I kind of like the idea of the quality challenge.
Input from all participants welcome! @anon
"
11,23632,2016-02-10T12:29:00.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"Need a hand
@anon
I was about to edit the text of the event, but I thought I should double-check -- I admit I have but no experience in organizing things the way it takes place on edgeryders.eu
- I already asked for a list of attendees, thinking I could possibly format the workshop according to the audience.
- I could probably refine the different challenges accordingly.
- I thought I should share the data ahead of time for those who wish to have alook at the material we'll be using. I have a set of JSONs, and I also uploaded everything into a Neo4j database. Neo4j is nice because it allows to readily visualize the data without really doing anything special (but install neo4j).
- Note: the JSONs I have include much more content than what you describe. I guess the few hundreds users and comments you mention were obtained by discarding but items of interest (I see this as being part of the process).
"
12,25035,2016-02-13T11:41:22.000Z,23632,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Certainly!
"
13,26131,2016-02-10T19:05:25.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"Coordinator for interpretation challenge
@anon
Guy
"
14,26992,2016-02-11T12:13:21.000Z,26131,anon1491650132,anon2774142051,"Flattered but..
Thanks @anon2774142051. The only issue I see is that I have to moderate the European Capitals panel Saturday starting 2PM.
I would also recommend @anon
"
15,27326,2016-02-11T16:25:52.000Z,26992,anon2774142051,anon1491650132,"How about teaming up
Thanks @anon
How about teaming up with @anon
@anon
Guy
"
16,27450,2016-02-12T19:14:33.000Z,27326,anon2350529763,anon2774142051,"count me in
sure will be there.
"
17,27509,2016-02-16T17:34:51.000Z,27450,anon2774142051,anon2350529763,"Good
@anon
Looking forward to meet you at LOTE5.
Guy
"
18,27882,2016-02-14T21:46:21.000Z,5260,anon2178703328,anon2774142051,"Network newbie with graphic and statistics background
I am relatively new to networks, but i'm working on a serious project with networks and i have a background in graphic design and in statistics. I can program in R but won't be able to bring a laptop.
I am particularly interested in the visualisation challenge and looking forward at meeting you all!
"
19,28486,2016-02-16T17:36:20.000Z,27882,anon2774142051,anon2178703328,"Grrrrreat!
@anon
Looking forward to code in your company :-)
Guy
"
20,28739,2016-02-17T11:07:59.000Z,28486,anon2178703328,anon2774142051,"Thanks Guy! That is certainly true.
"
21,29132,2016-02-17T11:47:46.000Z,5260,anon2178703328,anon2774142051,"Question about Detangler
I was having a look at Detangler and I don't understand what the coordinates x and y stand for. I can see scatter plots and bar plots but I don't know what they tell about the network. Can someone help me out?
"
22,29998,2016-02-17T13:17:15.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"It's all in the interaction
Hi @anon
First thing you need to know is that nodes on the left panel (substrates) are the main focus. Those substrates relate to one another through nodes on the right panel (catalysts). Catalysts are the ""reasons"" why substrates relate to one another. In the demo example, people get connected because they co-participate to political lodges (you may have recognized names from the so-called Paul Revere night ride from the American revolution). The quest is to try to figure out, for instance, who was in a position to reach all of those guys pretty quickly (in order to organize a mutiny before the British authority could counterfeit them).
The x, y position of nodes is decided in the following way: nodes on the right panel are displayed using a force-directed layout (ask me if you have no idea what that is). There is no absolute meaning in the x or y value, nodes are just positioned so as to have a readable display. Nodes on the left panel are positionned according to how they relate to nodes in the right panel. The layout attemps at mimicking the layout on the left, substrates are positionned ""around"" the catalysts to which they correspond (although catalysts are not embedded in the panel. The reason is to make the selection more natural: when you select substrates at the top in the left panel, you may expect the corresponding catalysts to be located at the top in the right panel.
The main feature is the easy selection of substrates or catalyst using the lasso.
We'll be using Detangler with substrates=people and catalysts=topics, for instance.
Enjoy!
"
23,30328,2016-02-21T09:05:17.000Z,29998,anon2178703328,anon2774142051,"thanks!
Thank you for the explanation Guy, now it starts to make sense. I know more or less what a force directed layout is, although I'm not familiar with the maths behind it."
24,30637,2016-02-17T19:46:41.000Z,5260,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"MoN4 stage-setting conference call!
@anon2774142051, are you free for an hour on Friday, say 15 to 16? I would like to touch base with you on the finishing touches to MoN4.
"
25,31167,2016-02-17T23:34:14.000Z,5260,anon2400895282,anon2774142051,"I'm in
Hi everybody,
I'm sorry for the long silence but it's been a long any busy period for me.
I just wanted to confirm I'll be attending MoN4 with @anon2851090535 (we have accomodation sorted).
We also made some progress with python, relatively to my last updates on ER, but not recently. I'm planning to get back to the code next weekend and I'm confident I'll be able to give you a better update, then.
I can't wait to meet you in person :)
Cheers,
s t e
"
26,31549,2016-02-18T06:22:00.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"Friday 3pm -- ok
3pm - 4pm and more if necessary.
I guess you had a look at the (tentative) agenda, and also saw I wish to give MoN4 a participatory design workshop twist.
Do we open the call to all, or keep it between facilitators (@anon
"
27,31702,2016-02-18T16:36:31.000Z,31549,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Open
... so, on Google Hangout, because you can join them with just the link. No Skype.
"
28,31839,2016-02-18T14:36:56.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"How do I extract the STF posts
Is there a tag or something I can grab so I know a post is relevant to STF.
I also need to be helped on the ethno posts, which for now I cannot really exploit.
We'll talk about all this tomorrow I guess.
"
29,32102,2016-02-19T00:01:19.000Z,5260,anon2400895282,anon2774142051,"A bit confused
I finally took some time to read thorugh the most recent program and comments and I am a bit confused...
We started having a plan, with @anon2851090535, about what could be done with the Wikipedia data we managed to mine but I see there's no mention of Wikipedia at all, in this page, so I was wondering whether you're giving up on that end or it was just left aside for the moment, or... ?
Again, I'll be catching up with the code stuff this weekend. In the meanwhile, I'd ask: are you planing to have just 2 hours of prototyanon3606750899g for the proof of concept? Ain't it a bit too shrinked?
I see that properly structuring ideas is the most relevant aspect of the hackathon, but I fear that not having enough time to make them into proper, working pieces of code might risk to end up producing mainly fluff... I hope I won't sound harsh in saying this, I would just hear what's your take
"
30,32201,2016-02-19T14:09:21.000Z,32102,anon1526983854,anon2400895282,"But, hackathon
@anon
First, this is a hackathon, and that means we enjoy a lot of freedom. If you have done preparatory work on Wikipedia data, you are more than welcome to lead a track on Wikipedia data! We'll treat it as we treat the other tracks – in fact, I might drop my quality challenge and join it myself. We also reserve the right to keep hacking into Sunday – I'll definitely do it if we really get going.
Second, the time limitations will be mitigated by several factors. The first one is good preparation – join the MoN4 call right now to find out more. The second one is the usual trick of all hackathons: we just stay in touch (through GitHub and other channels) and finish our work in remote. The third one is the LOTE5 freedom that I mentioned above. We should be OK.
"
31,32239,2016-02-20T14:45:30.000Z,32201,anon2400895282,anon1526983854,"Sounds Good
Hi @anon
What you say makes sense and is reassuring. I'm trying to re-organize the several proofs of concept which we put in place with @anon2851090535, to have a unified simple tool that we might use to query wikipedia and store responses to a database, for later visualization.
Based on what we managed to fetch via the API, here's what I was thinking:
* we have a list of the medicine pages
* for each page, we can query the pageviews, the links to other wikipedia pages and the translations into other languages
* for each link to other wikipedia pages, we can tell whether they're medicine pages or not; if they are, we can record they're semantically connected
* for each page translation we can repeat the above queries and store the relative data
With the stored info we could try to analyze:
* which pages are connected, assuming their sub-network might represent a certain topic
* which pages (in absolute and relatively to a certain sub-network) have most views
* for each topic or sub-network, what is the weight of a specific language in the overall page count
Things we might learn:
* higher page counts of certain topics might represent higher interest and/or practice of autodiagnosis for such topics (I'm aware that what's actually relevant is how to tell between the two but we can investigate this further)
* existance of page translations in certain languages might imply a geographical and/or ethnographical relevance for certain areas and/or ethnies
* higher page counts for a certain topic, in a certain language, might be relevant too
Thinking of Edgesense and ways to use it (maanon1932026148) differently than what it was designed for, we might have nodes representing pages as ""semantic knots"" (more than ""bits of conversation"") and connections representing their semantic affinity. Edgesense could then be used to analyze whether the sub-regions it finds match the ones we found as wikipedia's internal links (mentioned above).
We could also visualize page counts for each sub-region and each node, both as a global count (including all languages) ans as a ""filtered"" count, per ethnographic group.
Finally, if we imagine this visualized in three dimensions, we might have:
* a planar XY mapanon3606750899g, with all the English medicine pages, where all connections are visualized and semantic sub-regions are highlighted (the distributions of nodes in 2D space wouldn't necessarily have a geographical meaning)
* a Z layering, where at each depth/height we have a ""language plane"" which shows which of the English pages are translated in a certain language
Connections would exists across layers, giving a ""volumetric"" representation of medicine semantic networks.
I guess this last bit might sound particularly abstract or confusing, until I manage to sketch a graphic prototype. I hope I'll be able to do it soon, on paper at least, to try explain the idea a bit better.
If anything of what I wrote makes sense to any of you, let me know :)
"
32,32257,2016-02-20T16:12:06.000Z,32239,anon1526983854,anon2400895282,"These are two hackathons, not one!
I think I understand. You want to do two things.
- A multiplex network of pages connected by links. The multiplex part takes advantage of wikidata: we know that ""influenza"" in English is the same thing as ""grippe"" in French through Wikidata. So, we can follow all the links from ""influenza"" and all the links from ""grippe""; these will induce two networks, one English-speaking and the other one French-speaking"". The networks might be different, and we can analyze that difference. In practice, you have a multiplex network in which each language is one layer of the multiplex.
- A page count exercise. Page counts have a separate collection method, that we discussed and fiddled around back in 32C3.
- If both exercises are successful, you have a multiplex network of medical pages in Wikipedia, each of which is associated to a number in terms of page counts per unit of time. You could then map this information onto the network, even visually:
What I like about the approach is that it is relatively simple to compute correlation coefficients across different versions of (medical) Wikipedia. Correlation betweeen two languages is high if the probability of being connected of two random pages in language A, conditional to those two pages being connected in language B, is close to 1. Notice that you could do this without even looking at page counts! It seems like a lot of work for one day of hacking, but if that's what you want to do, go for it.
"
33,32263,2016-02-22T23:17:43.000Z,32257,anon2400895282,anon1526983854,"""Multiplex Network"" sounds sleek! :)
I had no idea that was called a multiplex network but I googled it and, yes, it looks exactly like what I was thinking.
When I mentioned a 3D visualization, I had in mind exactly this:
where each coloured layer is a language, each dot is a page, each link between pages sybolizes a semantic affinity. @anon
Regarding @anon
On one end, that's why I hoped we would have had more than 2 hours of programming; but after what @anon
On the other end, I was trying to produce as much code and db data as I can, to have a good base to start with (and to share with everybody else, obviously).
So far I have most of the code in place to do the data mining. I had to go through a few iterations, as we have limited db storage (free account on mongolab) and I needed to find a way both to do quick grouped queries and to store the results efficiently enough. I think I'm pretty close: I could store around 25K entries in around 6Mb (of 200Mb we are allowed) in a few hours. These entries count 4.5K English pages and all their available translations in any language. This means that within 24h we should be able to populate the db with all the pages, from scratch.
This does not include the page counts, though, which require a separate query and I'm still figuring out if there's a way to optimize those (ie. not sending a query per page).
I'll test this later or tomorrow, but I'm confident I can get decent results in reasonable time.
This partially answers @anon2774142051's question about what I'm storing. In terms of page counts, both because of time and storage restrictions, I was thinking to store sample counts for a given period (ie. 1 month of pagecounts, per day), instead of a tighter sampling.
I thought that, for the sake of demonstration, any timeframe can be used to prove the concept, and we can assume that the real measures will then take place on more accurate/representative data.
Do you think it is acceptable, as an assumption?
Does it still sound too scary? I trust your judgement guys, seriously
"
34,32266,2016-02-23T08:46:00.000Z,32263,anon2774142051,anon2400895282,"Multiplex it is
@anon
Yes, multiplex. I find this a convenient concept, probably more buzzwordy than deep -- anything is multiplex if you think about it ... it depends on what you are ready to term a layer ... We'll have plenty of time to chew about this.
You got things right. There are several ways to compute similarity between entities described by a ""bag of words"" (which you can actually see as embedded in a high-dimensional vector space ...). The better your index (words associated with entities), the better the similarity measures, from which you usually derive a topology by linking similar enough entities. As for the pagecount, I would expect larger time span to lead to somehow uniform pagecounts over all pages, while finer time spans may indicate when/if pages are simultaneously consulted.
The link structure you consider, the similarity measure you computeIt all depends on what question/task you are supporting.
As I see it, you have done quite a lot of work and will be bringing fantastic material to the workshop. This may well open the door to interesting future collaboration. I mean, people usually get together to finish up what has been done during the workshop, sometimes ending as blog posts, repots, or even scientific publications. In this case, my feeling is we may have things to say to the academic crowd. @anon
"
35,32268,2016-02-20T16:18:54.000Z,32239,anon1526983854,anon2400895282,"Mentions module
The mentions module started acting up after we upgraded the site to the newest version of Drupal Commons and is currently disabled. See here.
"
36,32297,2016-02-19T07:00:00.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"Blame it on me
Hi @anon
you are right, we decided in the end not to include anything about Wikipedia/data in the final program,
mainly because we feared there wouldn't be much to investigate. The motto for MoN is to have clear domain questions together with data, and then mine and visualize the data in ways that can help refine the questions, then iterate until you reach some sort of answers.
We had also included the EdgeRyders conversation data from the beginning, in order to also have a chance to look at this type of data -- although what we have for the moment is less concerned with care. It is that type of data OpenCare has planned to deal with (people interacting and discussing issues -> socio-semantic network).
Pagecounts did not seem to offer a tangible opportunity to look at how people perform self-diagnosis. So we (@anon
--
Now, regarding your comment on the risk of being ""shrinked"" by time ... well, it is real. Previous MoN sessions expanded over two full days. This time, we had to cope with lots of constraints both on the OpenCare and LOTE5 side. To help with this, I will make data available later today, hopefully with some code snippets, so we can save time and still do some work.
Hope this helps.
"
37,32382,2016-02-20T14:58:55.000Z,32297,anon2400895282,anon2774142051,"Zero Blame
Seriously, I hope I didn't give the wrong impression. I can only appreciate the organic way topics naturally adapt, here on ER, depending who's active in the discussions. I wasn't for a while, so it's legit that the topic might have faded in favour of others :)
I was asking, simply because I had spent some time on the Wikipedia thing and I thought something interesting could be observed (or we could at lease try). I tried giving a hint of my thoughts above, as a reply to @anon
Peace :)
s t e
"
38,32464,2016-02-19T13:01:00.000Z,5260,anon413297907,anon2774142051,"my skills
Hello!
I'd like to attend the session and I think my skillset will be a good fit for the viz or interpretation team:
- paper prototyanon3606750899g / brainstorming
- D3js (HTML, CSS)
Looking forward to join and hack :)
"
39,32540,2016-02-19T15:38:53.000Z,32464,anon2774142051,anon413297907,"Paper prototypes, yeah!
Hi @anon
please join, I'll be more than happy to have you on board, I am most sure you can contribute with great design ideas and/or improvements, and even paper mock-up!
d3 is so great, would be nice to have some of our stuff put up on the web too.
See you in Brussels next week
Guy
"
40,32623,2016-02-20T17:05:28.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"Let's do it!
@anon
It's seems you have already done part of the work, and about all of the thinking. Then go ahead, I'll register to your session :-)
I am quite sure I will learn from your experience. And if I understood correctly, you already have put up a db registering pageoucnts on an hourly basis -- all great news.
Looking forward to see you in Brussels next week.
"
41,32719,2016-02-24T14:35:00.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"Getting ready
To those of you who plan to attend to Mn4, and more particularly to those I expect to actively ""play"" with networks:
@anon
We will be using the Tulip network viz framework. Tulip can be downloaded from its homepage (follow the download link). Other options are also possible, but we might enjoy Tulip's python scripting capabilities. The Tulip API is quite intuitive, although the doc could be improved. I'll be there to help.
Here is a file you could load after installing Tulip (install is easy, unroll the .exe or .dmg depending on the OS you are using). The file contains users, posts and comments, together with associated tags. All networks in this file connect different types of entites, users to posts or comments, comments to tags, etc. That's why it is named ""bipartite"".
Our task will be to explore how we may then model interaction between users, inferred from the available traces (comments to posts, by whom, etc.).
Once we have a user-to-user file, we will then want to use Detangler to inspect tags around which interaction takes place. I plan to make some code available to ease the process of producing Detangler files from user-to-user networks built with Tulip.
"
42,32762,2016-02-25T02:47:05.000Z,32719,anon2350529763,anon2774142051,"am having problem with installing tulip on ubuntu...am still new with ubuntu so might need some help. will try again in the morning though
"
43,32829,2016-02-25T08:15:59.000Z,5260,anon2774142051,anon2774142051,"Asking for help
I am not that used with Linux myself.
Did you have a look at the sourceforge forum? In case you do not find proper help, please send email to Patrick Mary <mary@anon
Guy
"
44,32900,2016-02-27T15:53:57.000Z,5260,anon2178703328,anon2774142051,"Hackpad: please read and make improvements
Hi all,
It was really great meeting you today! I have written a report on the spot on the hackpad for this group.
Please have a look and make adjustments.
Enjoy the rest of the meetup and see you all online soon!
Rossella
"
45,32932,2016-03-01T10:15:10.000Z,32900,anon1526983854,anon2178703328,"Hackpad updated
Great work, @anon
The main thing we need now is the code for the Wikipedia track by MoE and Dora.
"
46,32941,2016-03-01T10:25:30.000Z,32932,anon2851090535,anon1526983854,"Wikipedia code
Hi there, thank you so much for the event, it was a nice experience!
Our Wikipedia code is a branch of the spaghetti-open-data GitHub repository. The branch is called ""dev-anon2400895282"" and I think Moe has already sent a merge request.
You can browse the code here: https://github.com/FuturoAnteriore/visualizing-self-diagnosis/tree/dev-anon2400895282
Cheers!
"
47,32946,2016-03-01T10:37:40.000Z,32941,anon1526983854,anon2851090535,"Thank you!
It was great to meet you Dora, you guys are really impressive and we hope we'll stay in touch.
I have not seen pull requests yet...
"
48,32953,2016-03-03T14:08:20.000Z,5260,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Documentation uploaded
https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5-doc/documentation-masters-of-networks-networks-of-care
"
1,5403,2016-03-03T14:07:54.000Z,5403,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Imported from the hackpad: https://lote5.hackpad.com/SAT-0930-1045-MASTERS-OF-NETWORKS-NETWORKS-OF-CARE-hackathon-for-network-scientists-doctors-and-patients-to-make-sense-o-vxaFSnxaNTg. Thanks to all note takers, especially Rossella B.
This is the main conversation
https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5/masters-of-network-4-networks-of-care
You can download Tulip from here
http://tulip.labri.fr/TulipDrupal/
You can download the data file here https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B7HgdYQcOLwncWhwQ3lKdmZXMmM/view
The data we have are about edgeryders users, which posts they posted and who reacted
we want to see how they interact, so we want to link them to one another
Tulip
If you click on ""user to post"" in tulip, you see emphasized the users that have written the original post, and which posts they wrote, linked to that user.
If you click on one of the posts you see information about the post, the text, the date, the title, plus some information that is internal to the software and is not so interesting for us.
Semantics
Edgeryders supports in-platform etnographic tagging. Ethnography is a qualitative method to analyze texts and attach tags to the texts that represent what the text says. The tags have to be standardized, so different researchers can be consistent in the use.
In the past ethnographic researches where limited because it was costly to gather the texts via interviews and transcripts. They are not statistically representative.
Edgeryders supports in-platform etnographic tagging. Of course, most content in Edgeryders is NOT ethnographically tagged: ethnography is expensive, and we only do it as part of contracts in which ethnography is used to lift collective expert advice from the conversation.
Online the texts are already written, so they don't need to be transcribed, and the ethnographers' codes can be kept together with the texts.
These tags are composed of super-classes (f.i. ""Topic"" or ""Place"") and they can be nested, and for each super-class you can entry different values (f.i. ""Charity"" or ""Cairo"").
An example: the users writes ""Our task will be to explore how we may then model interaction beween users,"" -> the ethnographer attaches the tag ""interaction"" . This tag is added in the html code of the platform, directly linked to the original text.
When this happens, a semantic layer is added to Edgeryders content. We can add semantics to the social network representation of the Edgeryders conversation: not just ""who is talking to whom"", but, adding semantics, ""who is talking to whom about what"".
Edgeryders data
On Edgeryders, the ethnographic data are linked to other kind of data, like the profile of the users (age, location etc), the circumstances surrounding the text. We have these ethnographer-coded data only for a specific conversation (because we had financing to gather it). We want to do this again in Open Care.
Of course you do not have all the information about the context of a conversation, for instance you don't know what happened besides the online platform. We will still miss a lot, and make misinterpretations.
Question (Ezio Manzini): what is the object that you are observing? Is it a conversation on Open Care or is it a conversation on Open Care in the context of the Edgeryders platform, and such and such.
A problem about ""large scale conversations"": a large number of users does not imply that many people will participate in the conversation. In the course of a EU project called CATALYST we learned that almost no threads have more than 10 participants, even in ""large communities"" like Loomio, with 10K users.
We should rephrase the question says Ezio, one that is more precisely the question that can be answered by this tool. Yes, but we need to use the tool to discover the question. You have some questions and in the process you will discover more questions.
Network
We have users who initiate posts and reply to posts with comments. We have ethnographers who will tag some of the texts. We want to discover how people interact and what the conversations will be about.
When you click
- ""user to user"" in Tulip you actually see the people who interact (have a conversation).
- user to comments: which comments they made
- ""post to groups"" you see the posts that have been added in the group.
- user to tags tells you which users are talking about a tag - if you believe in collective intelligence you need more than this because you still don't know if these users are talking to each other -> you want to see the conversations between the users that contain this tag, that is when the semantic is important
- we also want to link concepts to other concepts
Here you an see if a tag was interesting and if it was important. When people share something or comment is a different thing. Relevance can become important as well. (This previous has to do with sentiment analysis) But it is not the core of what we want to do in Open Care. It can be important to single out the people who talk about a topic.
idealistic idea of human interaction. Deep conversation, rather than big data.
User-to-tags networks are not easy to interpret. Guy and Benjamin Renoust introduced semantic edges show me only the edges that include ""real action"" as tag. another idea is visualising two networks, one of people to people and one of tags to tags. if you 'lasso"" a topic you sese the network of people who talked about it. if you lasso two topics you see the people who talked about either (but you can switch view and see who talked about both). if the people have been talking to each other about the tag then the edge becomes red as well, otherwise only the node. If you select a user you can see the tags he's been talking about.
In this version of the network, people are connected if one of them reacts to the other's post of comment. If someone reacts to a comment to somebody's else's post, then he'll be connected to the author of the comment but not to the author of the post. It is possible with these data to make different choices.
Start from a tag, say ""open-source software"" and
- see if the people talking about it are also talking to each other. If so, we can speak of an emergent group of specialists, emergent because it ""happened"", nobody assigned them to do that. The word ""group"" is critical here: if people were just speaking about open source software in isolation, they could be in total disagreement and not even know about it, but if they are talking to each other about open source software there can be a convergence going on, like when Wikipedians weed out mistakes in the encyclopedia's articles.
- lasso those guys and see what else they are also talking about, and get an indicative map of how this emergent group of experts sees the topic.
The present data are ""post-mortem"" of the conversation. The ideal situation is to be able to analyze the conversation with this tool almost ""real-time"", let's say on a daily basis. This, however, has the problem that ethnographic research does not really work that way: ethnographers find it easier to maintain consistency if they work in batch.
Guy: The tool could influence people to do more if it was available. It can be a user tool, besides a research tool. Alberto: However the Edgesense tool was made available to the community, and there do not seem to be that many people looking at it.
Edgesense
https://edgeryders.eu/sites/all/modules/contrib/edgesense/static/dashboard.html
The color coding are the nodes that are more connected to each other that to other members of the group. If you are very active you have ""your own"" group. For instance Noemi, her group is not exactly a star but very central.
The links are directional: two nodes can be linked by two curved lines, one from node a to node b, the other in the opposite direction.
You can show by degree (number of connections), select only the edges that link to and from the moderators. You can also hide them and see that the network is still holding. Some people fall out, but the giant component remains.
OpenCare narrative
This example also helps clarify Ezio's question above. What is the question that this network representation can answer? The sociology of the network. It helps manage the group. The network we saw on Tulip, it might be worth spending some time to find a bridge between what the tool can do, and the general question ""what is open care"". IN which ways can it be helpful?
This network is updated real-time. What would be a proper time frame for a semantic coding? The coding needs some consistency. So the ethnographer will say you make a conversation and then we tag it. The project on open care does not include a real-time semantic coding. That is a lot of work and would be a big addition to the project, needing its own financing.
Keywords. Quality tracking. Network authoritativeness. You could use the latter to filter what the ethnographer has to code, so the method becomes scalable. Not by using robots (not working with ethnography) but because you use network math to filter the content.
Author generated tags can work if implemented with auto-prompting and proper incentives, Harry Hanon3760936673on3606750899 has published on this about Delicious. Ethnography would not agree, Alberto believes., we can't trust it, although we can try it. But the added values is in small numbers, because then it can be used by smaller communities as well.
Ezio: the tool also needs to help develop some intervention. For instance spotting the emergent group of experts could be a useful intervention for the Comune di Milano. We need to develop a narrative like that about the tool we saw in Tulip for Open Care. Alberto believes he has a narrative, a strong hypothesis. Collective intelligence. Small scale collective intelligence. Problems are local, resources are local. So if we have a permanent think-tank on a platform and a cheap way to harvest from it, then we have a tool for a local community to use. You can identify the emergent groups of experts on specific topics and look at them rather than having to make a large scale study.
Instead of going up, going big I'm trying to go down, go deep, focus on a small group of people, without drawing a line around them (because then you'd loose the openness).
Ezio: I've never posted. It would be different if someone would ask around if they have something to say. Now I am here and I talk to people, I feel committed. But now I understand that we have to write because if we talk now we cannot register what we say. Alberto: This is the open. You commit to make the things you said available to people you did never even meet.
Ezio: we are collectively writing a document. You should know who the contributors are. At a certain point, you can say this is the book we wrote and these people wrote. The way this book was written has made it possible to work in a certain way. Alberto: yes, in the end, the ethnographic report will say we had these number of people and...
Ezio: if I want to participate I have to write and I have to be very attentive. Alberto: you can also choose to be a marginal author, just have a role along the side. And you still are a coauthor. Also the cook who made the lunch at the Lote5 meeting mattered in the making of the book.
Ezio: co-design process. These tools could be part of the solution. We are now a network and there could then be a network of nurses doctors etc. This discussion can in a similar way happen among care-givers? Costantino: the conversation will not be the result of this group, but of a larger group. But the network of care-givers might be not committed, skilled, or motivated to use an online tool.
As an example it is possible to use the results of the ethnographic study to feed the discussion at the Comune di Milano. Alberto: Ideally you bridge across. Costantino: this is the hard part. If the discussion is not well documented and published in the coming days, then the online community will miss it. And viceversa. So the tricky part is right here. How can we bring them across each other. In terms of artifact, in terms of codesign, our committment is to at least make transparent what are the needs of the people that we are meeting, how are the codesign sessions organised. Upload the design of a artifact online so that other people can contribute. Many levels: design, conversation... We are going far beyojnd ER as it was right now. We are not only creating a book or a report we are also committed to create real prototypes. So we need to go one step forward, so that we have the tools to manage not only the online conversation but also the other levels. But the online conversation is key to all this.
Alberto: we are not trying to invent a new methodology, just trying to do it well. The online community is key because of permanency, findability, linkability...
A discussion about Wikipedia, the major difficulty is that we do not own that platform so we can't control. I'm in a village and need info, i go to wikipedia, and ER might use that.
You can't brief too much in terms of what will emerge in terms of design.
People in Milano have clear problems: Where do I leave my kids. You try to solve, and the solutions kind of work and we try to use this process to make it better.
The process that we are following here is not the prototype. The prototype we talk about is some care solution. Online the local problem in Milano goes global and someone from France can intervene in the conversation. The prototyanon3606750899g part is in Milan, but care issues are similar all over the world.
In the Spot the Future project we saw the the international interaction was very valuable. The capability of transferring the knowledge by solutions found abroad to other context is exactly the point that makes it possible to finding new solutions.
Afternoon session
Two groups: quality of data and Wikipedia data
Quality of data session
We used Tulip and Detangler to explore a semantic network dataset similar to the one that will be used for Open Care. We filter our data according to two proxies for quality:
- post/comment length as quality: discard all posts and comments under, say, 100 characters. This would only keep thoughtful contribution.
- user pagerank as quality: pagerank or other eigenvector centrality measures are often associated to correlate to authoritativeness. So, we can reduce the network to the contributions made by the highest-ranking individuals.
The hypothesis is that the reduced semantic social networks would not be much different from the non-reduced ones. If that is confirmed, the methodology is scalable: if you get a ton of content, just filter it for quality, and work only on the top-quality 15%.
We walked through the exercise and found that our reducing code works. However, we found inconsistencies in the data (many comments and posts with apparently no text – though, when we checked them on the Edgeryders platform, of course the text was there!). We do not feel confident to draw any conclusion. The group resolved to redo the exercise starting from a fresh extraction. Guy Melançon is taking the lead for this.
Wikipedia session
We made a sketch of a graphic representation of the medical articles on wikipedia in all languages. The larger the node, the more often a page has been visited and links represent the hyperlinks between pages. We use this representation to explore the data and look at emerging patterns. For instance we will compare the structure of the networks in the different language to see if there might be cultural or geographical properties that can lead to interesting research questions.
The code for the Wikipedia session can be found here: https://github.com/spaghetti-open-data/visualizing-self-diagnosis
"
1,5139,2015-12-28T16:34:47.000Z,5139,anon281534083,anon281534083,"
In any community, conflict is inevitable. It can be destructive or it can be an opportunity.
How a group, and the individuals in it, deal with conflict is often the difference between the kind of breakthroughs that make a community stronger or the kind of meltdowns that turn an endeavor into a “late great.” In this session we’ll explore how to cope with meltdowns to optimize opportunities and avoid self-destruction.
This Keynote will be held by John Coate, an original member of the Farm community (Wikipedia), the largest and most successful hippy commune ever (still in existence, and doing great, though it is now a cooperative rather than a collective). Because of his experience at community organising, he was recruited into the WELL, Stewart Brand's and Larry Brilliant's groundbreaking virtual community – and so became the world's first professional online community manager. He then went on to found and direct SF Gate, the world's first big city news website. Later still, he moved on, becoming Development Director for the Electronic Frontier Foundation; and on again.
How you can register for this session
This session takes place at 9:15 AM on Friday, February 26th.
1. If you don't already have one, sign up for an edgeryders account here: http://bit.ly/1SKCYtZ
2. Leave a comment below to introduce yourself and let us know you want to come!
4. Someone will say hello and suggest some small tasks you should complete for a ticket! When you finish the tasks, we will send you the ticket.
5. See you at the workshop :)
Image Credit: Photographer unknown, sourced from this site.
Date: 2016-02-26 09:15:00 - 2016-02-26 10:00:00, Europe/Brussels Time.
URL: http://anon281534083.com"
2,9136,2016-01-05T17:26:34.000Z,5139,anon1491650132,anon281534083,"!!
I do hope this means you are slowly reaching the decision to come, John. Fyi I took the liberty to add your session as a keynote at the beginning of the event on Feb 25th (see draft program here), but of course it depends on your preference and future changes. Let me know if you have a preference for a different slot, starting anytime in the afternoon of the 25th or 9 am the following days.
"
3,15855,2016-01-05T18:00:32.000Z,5139,anon281534083,anon281534083,"I'm still trying
I am working on scheduling a major surgery in Janon169343781ary that will hopefully allow me enough recovery time that I can still come and do this. I can only say at this point that it is my intention and very strong wish to make it.
"
4,17751,2016-01-06T14:25:21.000Z,15855,anon70625510,anon281534083,"Just saw the message
Happy new year John. Hope this one brings you lots of love and health. Fanon1056199097rs crossed!
"
5,20395,2016-02-20T09:14:29.000Z,5139,anon602631834,anon281534083,"Projector needs
Hi John!
I'm trying to prevent technical errors from occuring and for that I'd like to know whether you'd like (a) a projector for your keynote (b) sound (not sure I can guarantee this) and (c) anything else?
Also if you're back in good health and would still like your biking tour of Brussels, we can make that happen. Question is when.
:-)
"
6,24006,2016-02-20T17:27:23.000Z,5139,anon281534083,anon281534083,"Projector
I have a Macbook Pro and an projector adapter, so hopefully it will all work. I have a bunch of slides that are text - they are phrases or ideas. So could get along without them, but I think they are helpful. I won't need sound.
I gave a talk a couple of years ago that was recorded and is available to view as a .mov (Origins of Online Community: http://anon281534083.com/Origins%20of%20Online%20Community%20Sydney%202013.mov) at anon281534083.com that tells stories about how my journey and online community began. It is loaded with photos. I recommend to whomever attends to view it first. I think it's pretty entertaining. Also there is a set of podcasts from a long interview I gave to German public radio that really goes into detail. Because of those ad because I only have 30 minutes, I will not be repeating all that is in those pieces.
I feel pretty good so far. I'm in treatment (prostate cancer), but the heavy stuff won't start until later in April. So I ought to be able to bike ok. Weather permitting. I am otherwise a healthy person.
"
7,26127,2016-03-03T11:48:15.000Z,5139,anon1526983854,anon281534083,"Documentation uploaded
https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5-doc/documentation-how-to-cope-with-meltdowns-in-communities-john
"
2,8123,2016-02-20T09:26:42.000Z,5223,anon602631834,,"What are your needs :-)
Hi Meredith!
What are your technical needs? Will you use a projector during your talk? Are you bringing your computer/expecting audience to bring theirs?
Cheers!
"
1,5229,2016-01-27T11:02:07.000Z,5229,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"This is a wiki. Please edit, add etc. at will.
Ground rules
Each session is introduced by someone. Please prepare your introductions, and let us know how much time you need for it. 20 minutes is a good time for and introduction. People to make introductions are suggested, but if you want to make one step forward and say so.
Each session is documented in real time. Please everyone contribute to shared note-taking (see below).
Please note: Edgeryders have booked a camera person to take short interviews of each of you. We’ll use them for the project’s minisite. This will happen at the Storytelling Workshop on Sunday 28th. Please flag it if you are not staying, we’ll find a solution.
Saying hello properly: team dinner on 24th
We are organising a team dinner on the evening of the 24th. Save the date, information is coming.
Agenda
Documentation
We will be using Google Docs to take notes of what is being discussed during the meeting. It helps us take notes collaboratively, minimizing effort and time spent passing notes around. All notes are automatically saved, and in one place.
Our shared folder is this: Documentation - 1st Consortium Meeting: http://goo.gl/c9Ha92
- to access it, click on the link above and if is not shared with your email address yet, you will be asked to require permission.
- to take notes, open the document corresponding to our topic discussion and start tyanon3606750899g. Feel free to organise and format the document as you please. When you type, other people might type simultaneously with you, and you will see colored cursors moving around and adding information, in real time.
- create new documents or upload other materials in the folder as you wish: see NEW red button on the left.
- don't worry about saving the document. Google docs automatically saves the newest versions of the document.
"
2,7270,2016-01-27T15:33:59.000Z,5229,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Welcome Luce Chiodelli
@anon
Obviously, she will partner up with Olga on item ""How to work together"".
I am sure Luce will take time to say a word about herself soon -- the official start for her is next Friday.
"
3,10961,2016-01-27T17:23:47.000Z,7270,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Italians rule the world
... and so do MCR fans, apparently. Welcome @anon
This link is dedicated to Luce: everyone else, open at your risk.
"
4,12407,2016-01-30T10:02:49.000Z,10961,anon2971875139,anon1526983854,"Hey there !
Hello everybody,
I would like to thank @anon2774142051 once again for placing his trust in me, and @anon
Working with you on this research project will be my new challenge and I’m very eager to start! I’ll team up with @anon
Olga stays your contact person for the establishment of the consortium agreement.
I’ll be replacing her step by step as your contact person for all administrative and financial matters during the project.
We will get to meet you in Brussels for the kick-off meeting.
I’m happy to join the OpenCare team and meet you soon!
Luce
"
5,12902,2016-02-02T15:34:25.000Z,12407,anon1491650132,anon2971875139,"Welcome from me too!
So nice to meet you @anon
So for anything platform related or where information is stored here on edgeryders, don't hesitate to reach out (see Contact bar on my profile) or at anon1491650132[at]edgeryders[dot]eu
See you soon in Brussels!
"
6,14540,2016-01-27T17:05:09.000Z,5229,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Experience multidisciplinarity
May I add a word after Alberto's introduction.
One strength of OpenCare is our diversity.
This means the 10:00 session ""What we'll do"" is in a sense critical. We have to open our minds and see the pictures drawn by colleagues when describing their universe and contributions to OpenCare. Conversely, this means we each have to make special efforts so listeners have a crunch and jump in.
Guy
"
7,20862,2016-02-02T14:17:00.000Z,5229,anon4116418727,anon1526983854,"What we’ll do: goals, epic goals, project narrative...
...can I ask you what is the policy for ""active contributions""? Are we meant to prepare small presentations (I would guess around 15minn each, by dividing what's left after the 20minn of introduction for the number of expected contributors)? Or are we meant to have a nicely chaotic conversation? :)
"
8,22144,2016-02-02T14:34:44.000Z,20862,anon1526983854,anon4116418727,"Neither
I propose:
- Everybody re-reads carefully the Grant Agreement Annex 1, i.e. what we have committed to doing.
- With that in mind, prepare a statement of your organisation's own goals. But not 15 minutes: more like 5. Guy and I will propose overall goals.
- Then we need to spend some time just bouncing world views off each other.
Why this session? In terms of what we must deliver, the situation is clear: that's detailed in the GA, nothing to talk about. But in terms of how these activity fit into the bigger picture of what we all are trying to do, that's a different story. We explore together what each of us sees just outside of OpenCare, and how our other activities and OpenCare can help each other and feed into each other. The project of an OpenCare clinic is an example: that's not a deliverable of OpenCare, but if we did manage to make one it would add incredible value. Conversely, OpenCare would lend an OpenCare clinic a very large value. I conclude it does not make sense to just think project management and deliver the project. We must to that, but as we do it we must never lose sight of the bigger picture. Hence the insistence on goals.
Works?
"
9,22639,2016-02-03T10:43:04.000Z,22144,anon4116418727,anon1526983854,"Works for us. Looking forward
"
10,23822,2016-02-11T11:07:51.000Z,5229,anon3612872438,anon1526983854,"is this an open meeting?
can we invite interested people that are not part of the consortium?
I'd leave the slot at 15pm free so we can use it if we are going slow on previous sessions or we need to discuss a specific topic coming up during the day.
looking forward to meet you all.
best
Zoe
"
11,24913,2016-02-11T11:13:14.000Z,23822,anon1526983854,anon3612872438,"Not open
In the sense of: no event page, no link to join it etc. This is because it's mainly a team building exercise. Exceptions allowed on a case-by-case basis. LOTE5 care track provides opportunities for the consortium to interact with non-consortium people. In general, I suggest you rather invite them to the care track public events that you like.
We'll probably do it in our own office (the Edgespace), and try to make it cosy and relaxed.
"
12,26909,2016-02-11T11:18:35.000Z,5229,anon3612872438,anon1526983854,"ok great
Then these are the open meetings of Opencare during LOTE5 :
https://edgeryders.eu/opencare/kickoff-meeting-program
"
13,27304,2016-02-11T11:29:28.000Z,26909,anon1526983854,anon3612872438,"This is more up-to-date
https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5/program
Look to the left column, on care.
Still a few changes to make (like the OpenCare files, that we just agreed upon), but almost there.
"
14,28430,2016-02-18T15:56:07.000Z,5229,anon2435658896,anon1526983854,"Streaming / Hangout
Hi,
can we organise a private streaming/hangout for the people in our teams that are not in Brussels?
Do we have enough bandwidth? Are we all using microphones?
@anon
"
15,28715,2016-02-18T18:04:29.000Z,28430,anon1526983854,anon2435658896,"No streaming
We do not have the resources to do this. Also, we insist on LOTE being very participatory. You can really not do LOTE from home.
"
1,5267,2016-02-06T16:07:50.000Z,5267,anon2599889874,anon2599889874,"Dear fellow participants of Fail - un#Fail at the end of this month in Brussels!
Get used to being asked questions :)
This is an attempt to find out what's happening in the ""social soil"" among us, the LOTE5 participants, already. And since someone has to start ... here we go.
Failure. Success. Wow, what a wide and rich topic.
My guess is, since you're about to spend 3,5 days of your life in this area of inquiry, it touched something. You might be as intrigued as me, because something wants to be explored on an intellectual or emotional, collective or personal level. What we apparently share is an interest for failure (success?) and I assume that we also share a common interest in ""let's make more sense of this!"". I might as well be wrong, and that's exactly what I'm trying to find out.
So, would you please let me know
Why are you coming to Brussels?
I can tell you my ""why"". If you're challenged by emotional content, leave this page NOW. Then better don't read, just reply :) Don't tell me I didn't warn you.
I'm very excited to meet you all soon, but what the ""why"" brought up for me, hasn't been an easy ride so far. As soon as I stepped into the topic of failure, my relationship to it got a lot clearer and it was not always pretty to face. I had not been aware how much of a chicken I was, how eager I was to avoid failing (or what I perceived as such).
One example: I teach a very efficient self-help method to release stress and other emotional baggage. Some years ago, I was asked by the manager of our local branch of a huge swedish clothing company to coach their team, so they could handle the daily stress in the store better. I was over the moon - and dead shit scared. Too scared. GODDAMNIT!!
When reflecting now on the topic of success vs. failure, I realized: This thing called failure, that many of us fear, but to a different degree, is what has kept me from doing lots of things in the past. Wasn't this one of my ""biggest"" failures so far: letting the fear of it take control? I believe so.
This is what brings me to Brussels. I want to de-demonize the ""F"", address it more directly and with others instead of within my isolated brain. Talk about it. Listening deeply to others and share the humanness behind the story of failure/success, find the questions that open up new spaces, look at the assumptions we hold individually and collectively and mold this thing called ""failure"" into another form. Rewrite the story of success and make more peace with this perceived threat. In the end, it's my decision which story I live in, what failure means to me and how I let the meaning I give it affect my life.
That's why I'm coming. Partly. It was, what caught my attention. Now I'm really happy that other topics I care about are being touched: Care, for example. I'm very interested in the topic of how to unfail ""care"", since I work in this area, and I'm not on the edge, but far far off it. And the 3. ""why"" is that I want to have a blast with all of you :)
And why are you coming? :) In case you think you gotta soul strip now, too: naah! I just want to know what is ""in the room"" already. Partly because that's an aspect of harvesting during the event. (Check the Documentation/Harvesting wiki out, it's what the cool kids do!)
See you soon and have a nice weekend
Kaja
"
3,14040,2016-02-09T05:26:55.000Z,5267,anon1526983854,anon2599889874,"It's the only way I can think
I am a bit impatient with social conventions prescribing us to tiptoe around stuff. If I disagree with someone, I'll just say it rather than beating about the bush. If someone thinks I'm talking bullshit, I am grateful for them to call bullshit on me, rather than politely nodding. Nobody ever learned anything by watching others nod politely. What I'm trying to say is that I cannot think properly unless I am allowed to call a spade a spade, and unless people around me do the same.
At most professional conferences and events, there is no incentive to speak the truth. You can glimpse some truth from most people; and you can get the occasional honest talk from a few. But in general everyone is supposed to tell everyone else how amazing they are. This is how the game is played. But this failure stuff is liberating. It creates a context in which the incentive to hustle is greatly reduced. So you get much healthier, better food for the collective thought.
At least, that's the theory. We'll soon find out.
"
4,19820,2016-02-09T15:08:28.000Z,5267,anon477123739,anon2599889874,"Saying 'No' almost never succeeds
My expectations for the event couldn't be more open. As a new entrant to the ER community i'm fascinated by the structures and conversations i see around me on the site and i constantly have to force myself to delve further into various parts of the community to discover new aspects of it. The whole experience has been one of engagement, education and enlightenment. There has to be a next step though...
Without the face-to-face aspect though it does seem rather... inhuman (i'm a touchy-feely arty sort of person so i crave human interaction to gain understanding)
I work in the performing arts, both with theatre and poetry, as a performer, producer and manager. Failure is at the core of our philosophy of creation. No-one gets the words right first time, no film or drama springs fully formed into life. We try, we fail, we discuss, we try again. Sometimes, even when we're absolutely certain we've got it right THIS TIME, we fail, or we change our minds and do it differently.
We often talk within industry meetings about the 'freedom to fail', the chance for individuals, companies and even major institutions and buildings to take risks, and be able to fail. Yet we remain a very risk-averse community. Failure is freedom.
I'm very keen to discuss with people the difference between 'failure' (not succeeding at all) and 'failing' (not achieving everything you set out to do) as this is where i often find myself banon3760936673ced as an individual.
Saying yes to a crazy conference in Brussels in February full of people i've never met? offering to cook for 100+ people? couch surfing? I think saying 'NO' would have been the true failure.
"
5,24657,2016-02-17T14:22:15.000Z,5267,anon1491650132,anon2599889874,"Like Alex above, I agree there must be something else to these online interactions that make us speak of ""community"". I've seen it every year since LOTE1 (I've been to and helped organise all of them), and it's what fuels the sentiment that I am not failing in my work as someone that is personally vested in all this.
I need social interaction as a cure to failing in social interaction (the kind that is on the failing-failure continuum Alex mentions). I increasingly find the offline world intimidating and often take digital routes to solve problems that can be solved via a simple phonecall. Talking about this won't help, but doing something about it, which is spending time with people, will.
Oh, and cccording to @anon
"
6,26593,2016-02-18T16:25:00.000Z,5267,anon70625510,anon2599889874,"Figuring out how to (avoid) dealing with others :)
One of the areas in which I suppose I am failing is human-to-human interaction. I have my own ideosynchratic way to look at outcomes and I am really only interested in interacting within that context (unless it's with people with whom I am close which include several people in Edgeryders). Others in the Edgeryders board of directors will testify as to my general impatience with long discussions and consensus based decision-making. Maanon1932026148 through the event I could get some insight into how to interact with/relate to others in this kind of open space without having to deal with/ put up with conversations and contexts in which I have no interest. So I can figure out how to live with my failures with minimal impact on others :)
"
1,5281,2016-02-10T23:19:51.000Z,5281,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"
We need to become better at designing collaborative services. We dream of a welfare built and delivered by communities, alongside the state and the market. We all, at some point in our life, give and receive care. We are all citizen experts, with firsthand knowledge. The question is: how do we access that knowledge and turn it into action?
We asked Ezio Manzini, perhaps the world's most senior academic designer for social innovation, to mount a workshop that does just that. Everyone is welcome. People who attend will use their experience of care to imagine and prototype ways that existing services could be improved. We decided to focus on services to refugees and migrants: we know several and feel for them, and there is a lot of room for improvement.
A beautiful thing happened: people got in touch with us offering to help. We ended up with a dream team of designers: @anon
Ezio and the team are adamant: no reinventing the wheel. We want to start from existing services, and look for ways that smart communities could improve them. We are in contact with several people who are running services and initiatives targeted at helanon3606750899g these newcomers (thanks Yara!), but we could use a few more (we'll split into working groups). So, here's how you can help:
- If you are involved in a project targeted at migrants or refugees, consider joining us as a case study. We will be respectful and absolutely not imply that you are doing things wrong. It's about learning, not judging. Just get in touch with me, or anyone from the team.
- If you know one of these project, consider being its ambassador at the workshop. Talk to them, get information, so that you are in a position to represent it.
- You can also participate simply as yourself, with no particular project to represent. There are still some places left.
The workshop is free, but registration is required. Go here to register. There is also a Facebook page.
I would love for @anon
"
2,7780,2016-02-11T08:12:19.000Z,5281,anon4259720994,anon1526983854,"I'm in as I said before. Where am I supposed to register on the website you mentioned @anon
"
3,11108,2016-02-11T08:39:05.000Z,7780,anon1526983854,anon4259720994,"Great! Register here:
https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5/collaborative-inclusion-how-migrants-residents-collaboration-can
A few words on what's going on in Armenia would also be welcome. Please enter them as a comment to the event (same link as the registration). It's perfectly OK to enter it simply as a link to some other web page. I imagine a sort of ""landing strip"": when someone makes it across the border, they are somehow channeled into taking a series of steps towards safety first, and integration later. These steps are not obvious. My analogy is what happens in Milan to anon948101822trean newcomers: an informal network of people (many of whom anon948101822trean-Italians) takes newcomers in charge as they take the first baby steps. They need to be picked up at the point of entry (railway or bus stations): telling them ""take the Metro Line 2 and get off at Lambrate"" is not going to work, even if you have a common language to communicate in, because they do not know how to use public transport. So, people call each other to go pick up complete strangers at 5.00 in the morning, ask friends for spare beds and couches as newcomers take aim for the next step, which in Italy is typically trying to get to Sweden/Germany/wherever. I know this from @anon
"
4,12347,2016-02-11T09:57:42.000Z,11108,anon4259720994,anon1526983854,"Done! Well, your example from
Done! Well, @anon
"
5,12822,2016-02-11T10:39:00.000Z,12347,anon1526983854,anon4259720994,"Read it
But it actually says that civil society does this sort of thing: that would be you (and presumably others) ""acting as a social worker"". What am I missing?
"
6,13050,2016-02-11T13:00:23.000Z,12822,anon4259720994,anon1526983854,"I work for a non-profit social enterprise alliance that employs different strategies aimed at improving the lives and well-being of the thousands of Syrian-Armenians impacted by the ravaging war in Syria. Basically this is a link with the Diaspora Armenians that takes care of fundraising to partially fund the budget for rental subsidies of the refugees in Armenia(together with UNHCR and other donors).
I'm the only representative of the platform in Armenia and I multitask(social housing project in Dilijan, independent social workers' unit in Yerevan, writing blog posts, helanon3606750899g some extremely vulnerable families to integrate, etc) and volunteer as much as I can.
"
7,15096,2016-02-11T13:24:57.000Z,5281,anon602631834,anon1526983854,"The 'go here to register link'
Send me here: http://support.refugeesemancipation.com/en/
"
8,17396,2016-02-11T13:26:31.000Z,15096,anon70625510,anon602631834,"thanks, fixed it now
<3
"
9,20644,2016-02-12T20:30:48.000Z,5281,anon70625510,anon1526983854,"Came across another cool project to build on!
@anon3612872438 you wouldn't happen to be involved in this or know about it? I would love to set something like this up in Brussels. For selfish purposes mainly: Tailored is just better and more creative than buying some ready made off the shelf stuff!
"
10,24085,2016-02-13T10:53:33.000Z,5281,anon3612872438,anon1526983854,"yes, it's my collective Serpica Naro organizing the event
It's a very local event.
Noor is a refugee, waiting for a permit and he's collaborating with us in the Serpica Naro Lab and soon also at Wemake to use industrial sewing machines. Buttons were created with the lasercut here at wemake.
He's not producing the shirts during the event. He's taking measurements and orders. He will then produce the shirts in the next weeks.
We can think of involving him during the consortium meeting in Milan :)
Zoe
"
11,25041,2016-02-13T12:11:01.000Z,24085,anon1526983854,anon3612872438,"Brilliant
Ping @anon
"
12,26595,2016-02-13T12:27:33.000Z,5281,anon1161452144,anon1526983854,"Resources pool
I have been working in several projects with refugees at the local level. One of the issues emerging was a strong need to was to facilitate the coordination and distribution of resources, which at the moment runs in a very centralized way - through institutions or small, voluntary coordination groups (which usually create a bottleneck).
We (Transition Town Witzenhausen, Ecobytes, local Refugees working group and coordination) have started a project to provide a resource pool, where not only institutions working on refugees support, but also the refugees themselves and other individual citizens can use to exchange and connect directly what they need or have to offer.
The project has gotten some funding from a German Ministry and resulted in the teilink platform, currently a standard Sharetribe marketplace, which we are self-hosting and plan to further develop/extend in exchange with the institutions on our network during this year (and depending on financial resources we manage to get for it).
"
13,27189,2016-02-13T13:05:18.000Z,26595,anon1526983854,anon1161452144,"Can anyone attend?
Nice work, @anon1161452144. Can anyone attend the workshop?
"
14,27397,2016-02-13T13:40:09.000Z,27189,anon1161452144,anon1526983854,"Maanon1932026148. When exactly would it be and could travel costs be covered? I would ask my colleagues for interest/availability, possibly could myself go there during LOTE5, especially if it could bring value to other running projects (site development).
I just saw you also have freifunk as an interest for this. We also have a local group in Witzenhausen and got recently a small fund for providing Freifunk to refugees accommodations.
"
15,27484,2016-02-14T11:11:10.000Z,27397,anon1526983854,anon1161452144,"26th
The workshop is on the 26th of February. We have a community fund with some travel support.
"
1,5329,2016-02-10T23:46:56.000Z,5329,anon70625510,anon70625510,"Community members leading curation, communication and engagement for the OpenVillage Festival!
We believe that the future of health and social care is community-based and participatory. We are committed to the idea that care should not necessarily be handed down from institutions to the people but can emerge organically from the people according to their needs.
The OpenVillage Festival is a highly participatory festival showcasing working solutions and demos produced by community members, as well as pathways for working together towards their sustainability. It will take place in 19-21 October 2017 in Brussels and represents the culmination of the OpenCare 18 month research that involves hundreds of original initiatives.
Aiming to deepen community collaboration, during March - April May 2017, the SCImPULSE Foundation will appoint 3 “students” to support communication and engagement for the OpenVillage. We use “students” in the Latin sense, of people that will apply themselves to the subject, as fellows of SCImPULSE Foundation, and not in any sense as an indication of career status.
What you will get if selected:
- A bursary appointment: Up to 15000 Euro to reimburse your working time, distributed on the basis of winners’ financial needs
- A travel budget: Up to 5000 Euro, to be authorized in advance by due justification.
Process and timeline:
- Collect Submissions in the form of opencare stories, comments to stories and proposals for OpenVillage | 15 Mar - 31 May
- Review of submissions | ongoing
- Announcement of winners | ongoing
- First draft of project/exhibits descriptions submitted | May 2017
- Final session and project descriptions submitted | 15 July
- Final Report detailing the value chain of the project/s the appointee worked with, and documenting the “receipt” to reproduce it (resources, community engagement mechanisms, pitfalls to avoid) | 2 weeks after the OpenVillage Festival
Who can participate? Anyone with a story of an open and participatory project of health/social care, who is interested in online and offline collaboration for social good.
Selection Criteria
We will consider individuals who have demonstrated interest in and alignment with opencare in the following ways (each item will receive a score from 0 the minimum, to 5 the maximum, which will be summed to define the final score used to choose the winners):
- are registered on edgeryders.eu and have contributed a story on the OpenCare community page. NB: All the stories submitted previously in 2016 and 2017 are being considered.
- are operating at the grassroots level or are heavily interacting with such groups are open in their work, use of methodology, technology, results (public and transparent communication, open processes for participation, commons licensing, open source code etc.)
- their contribution is validated in positive responses by their peers in the opencare community (as seen from the Comments section)
- have storytelling and content production skills for presenting the opencare initiatives to various community groups and audiences
- demonstrate willingness to collaborate with others and use online environments for communication, engagement, documentation of work and social media
What happens if I am selected?
You will be working closely with the Edgeryders team to build the OpenVillage. Allocate a minimum of 3 days per week to fulfill your commitment and make sure you are available to attend the event in October 2017.
Where do I start? Join the process of building the OpenVillage!
- Share your experience from care-related initiatives in your community, with reflections around how they relate to the topics and themes of opencare. Create an account on edgeryders.eu and post your story here.
- Demonstrate your interest in the work of opencare practitioners. Read three stories about other opencare initiatives and leave thoughtful comments on each one here (you'll need to scroll down).
- Demonstrate your general knowledge about the field. Propose a theme, session or exhibit that you would like to see happen as part of the OpenVillage and name a number of projects or people whom you would like to see involved. Create a post in the OpenVillage coordination group.
- Use \#opencare and \#scimpulse hashtags to tweet your project and your proposal, as well as attract attention and support for your work!
The applications are accepted on a rolling basis, but the sooner you start and complete your application, the higher your chances!
For more information come to our weekly online community gatherings on Wednesdays at 18:00 CET here or contact This page was last updated on May 9th 2017.
For details about the previous Fellowship program in 2016 go here.
Partners
This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 688670
"
1,5263,2016-02-05T08:31:12.000Z,5263,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"
Lots of things are happening in Edgeryders. Many of us have a hard time keeanon3606750899g track of everything. This is a general update on where we are; what we learned; what we expect to be doing next; and how you can be involved in it. Warning: it's quite long, about 2,600 words. Expect about 10 minutes reading time. Here we go!
What we have done
Let's set the start of the latest work cycle at November 1st 2014. During the previous summer we had concluded the Spot the Future project. In October the Italian city of Matera, home of the first unMonastery and one of our key partners, was crowned European Capital of Culture 2019. In late October we returned to Matera for Living On The Edge 4. We allowed ourselves a small celebration and started looking around for what was next. And that turned out to be:
- Develoanon3606750899g a presence in the European Capitals Of Culture scene. It just made sense. Edgeryders had made a big, acknowledged contribution to the Matera success story. Some people in the community are artists, and many more care about culture. By being global, we are well positioned to help candidate cities to position their bids on the European scene. There are two or three ECOC competitions every year. And the most compelling argument of all: in this space, we could work with Robert ""Bob"" Palmer. Bob is Europe's most senior cultural policy expert. We all stand to learn much from him. So we built something we are calling the Edgeryders Culture Team. Its first post-Matera success was getting hired by another candidate city, Bucharest. The city's bid earned it the inclusion in the shortlist of candidate ECOCs still in the race for 2021.
- Getting better at helanon3606750899g smart, resilient civic processes to grow. We set up shop in Kathmandu, Nepal, and joined in the grassroots relief effort after the 2015 earthquake. Matthias and Natalia, who led the effort, ended up working side by side with incredible grassroots groups. Many of these reach deep into rural Nepal, where neither government, nor established NGOs, nor media would go. Smart, committed, resilient, these groups might be the backbone of Nepal's emergent alternative leadership. Later in the year, we worked with the United Nations Development Programme and United Nations Volunteers to develop a new, radical program of community-driven, bottom up urban planning. With the help of our global community, we discovered and reached out to civic innovators in Armenia, Belarus, Egypt, Georgia, Morocco and Ukraine. As often before, this work left us in awe of just how good people are at self-organizing, even in difficult circumstances.
- Adding capacity for analysis to the Edgeryders platform. With the support of the Rockefeller Foundation, we developed and tested Open Ethnographer, a Drupal module for in-platform ethnographic coding. It works. We also collaborated with a European Commission-funded research project called CATALYST. CATALYST's mission was to develop software, that would extract collective intelligence from online conversations. We did some testing for them, and ended up adopting two of their applications. This makes us better at delivering collective intelligence outcomes from the Edgeryders conversation.
- Engaging in a sales push. As we felt we had delivered – even overdelivered – on our first batch of projects, we tried to get more of them. The idea was to provide more meaningful, paid work for members of the Edgeryders community to take on. Get paid to be radical, do adventurous stuff and attack big problems: that's what most of us aspire to. But that did not go so well. We spent a lot of time negotiating and writing proposals. Sometimes we were successful, like in the examples above. But often, too often we just wasted valuable time in unsuccessful bids. We lost two procurement competitions in Italy, one in the UAE, and one in Belgium. We partecipated in five proposals for European research projects, losing three of them and getting kicked out of another one. We did win the one where we had invested the most, though.
What we have learned
- Open online conversations can be an engine of collective intelligence. For me, this is the single most important lesson I have learned in Edgeryders. Every single time we convene around an interesting question and are enabled to act upon it, we make progress. The conversation acts as a sort of artificial intelligence. It discovers new allies, even on unfavourable terrain; processes scenarios in parallel; reveals rough consensus. It is hard to get it started, but when it gets going it really is powerful.
- Text is data. Collective intelligence in Edgeryders is a human thing. Its engine is human conversation, and it is humans interpreting its results. But technology helps in various ways. The most important one is this: with technology, we can understand conversations at a larger scale than without it. This opens up exciting possibilities. It also means we are, in our own way, a data company. I have been saying this since 2013, but the past year has made this intuition more concrete.
- Sustainability is hard, but achievable. At the core of Edgeryders there is a symbiotic relationship between an online community and a small social enterprise. The community contains the skills, the drive, the experience. The company transforms online debate into expert advice, powered by collective intelligence. Expert advice can be packaged and sold. The Edgeryders company styles itself a mutant boutique consultancy company; it makes the sales. It then gives back to the community, in the form of work opportunities that are meaningful and paid (in financial year 2014-2015 we have paid out hard cash to about 40 edgeryders, not counting company directors). This is the theory. In practice, selling is hard. Clients think we are interesting and innovative, but would rather not be the first ones to adopt. We have to be honest, and tell them this is new and experimental. It may fail. Worse: collective intelligence does not take orders; if online debate sees an inconvenient truth, it will throw it in your face. So, we tell them: if you are not prepared to face hard truths, don't hire us. Many clients feel this is too scary. A few do take the plunge. So far they seem to be happy, and come back for more business. So it's working, kind of. People in the company are putting in a lot of unpaid work. We may fail due to mistakes or bad luck, but sustainability is certainly possible in principle.
- Deploy. International consultants jet over to foreign capitals; stay at four-star hotels with English-speaking staff; have meetings with government officials; jet back; write the report. Edgeryders rents homes and moves in for months at a time. We hang out in the local hackerspaces, venture out to remote villages, build trust, spend time. It's necessary to gain trust and learn to see with the eyes of the local changemakers. It's also more fun. It just feels right: we may have a different role, but the people we meet in our missions are exactly people like us. They could be Edgeryders. Some have become Edgeryders, in fact. So we treat them as peers, learn from each other, refuse to think of them as passive ""beneficiaries"" of what our clients are trying to do. There are people in Edgeryders who value adventure, and will only do work if they can do it this way. This gives us an edge: we can do stuff that vanilla consultants can't. We have a lever for reinventing international consultancy!
- Community is powerful. Collective intelligence is what happens when the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. Collective smarts need not only smart individuals, but also a smart way for individuals to interact. The great lesson we learned from monasticism: human-to-human rules for interaction are important. We have found a name for a coherent collection of such rules designed to encourage the emergence of collective intelligence: Protocol. I believe good Protocol is the single most important ingredient of an online community. I also find Edgeryders has, in general, good Protocol. Snianon3606750899g, name-calling and rhetorical smoke curtains are almost unheard of. At the same time, people are outspoken, if respectful, in their expressions of disagreement. When Edgeryders is at its best, people argue hard enough to discourage wishful thinking and unsubstantiated claims, but not so hard as to demoralize each other. Action carries more prestige than talk, and no one has veto power over anyone else. Rapid progress ensues. A sign that this is working well: it produced ""blanket endorsement"", with some of us willing to support financially complete strangers to take part in an Edgeryders event. This conveys a powerful message: ""If you are Edgeryders, I trust you, whoever you are.""
- Community is fragile. One or two defectors with good rhetorical skills can break Protocol and upset a whole community. We had some episodes of this in Edgeryders. While unimportant in themselves, they were upsetting and time-consuming. We have learned never to take Protocol for granted, and to defend it at all costs. This means having low tolerance for trolling. If people do not feel completely at ease with Protocol, they should feel free to leave in friendship. This happened last year with some of the people involved in Matera's prototype unMonastery. Bickering about consensus decision making versus do-ocracy was improductive and frustrating. So they created their own organization, and now we have two variants of the unMonastery, one committed to consensus, the other to do-ocracy. Great! We can experiment with two alternative models, and learn from both.
- Dyson sphere. There's plenty of skilled people in the Edgeryders community. Together, we can supply a wide range of products and services. Whenever the Edgeryders the company needs to hire, or buy a service, we try to buy it from the community. We try to recirculate every euro that we get from clients, so that it helps some community project stay up. We think of this as building a Dyson sphere around the primary client; together, we can catch and reuse most of its economic energy. Example: we hired @anon1161452144 to do work on our platform, and are planning to move its hosting over to the Ecobytes collective. This helps us, because we get a better platform and better services. It also helps Ecobytes' cash flow. Double win!
- Take responsibility for the boring admin stuff. At the onset of the Edgeryders company, a member on the board of directors took on responsibility for all things legal and financial. That was a bad idea. The person made sure he was the only one with access to the bank account. This resulted in a complete lack of transparency about Edgeryders legals and financials. The rest of us in the board underperformed, too. We let him get away with this behaviour for a long time, because we were conflict-averse. When we finally applied pressure to set up transparent accounting, he resigned. He refused to release records, so we had to report it and him to the British tax authority and rebuild them. As we did so, we discovered unpaid bills, unrecorded income, unjustified payments (including to himself), out-of-date legal records and other pleasantries. This is not one person's failure, though we did pick a bad apple. The whole board has legal responsibility. It was our mess, and we had to clean it up. We decentralized accounting and finances, and increased transparency. We redid the company website disclosing relevant information, recruited advisors from the community with oversight capacity and are now taking turns running the accounting software. Accounting and finance are boring, but we have to take responsibility for them. Dumanon3606750899g it on a ""money guy"" (or woman) is irresponsible.
What's next and how you can be part of it
- Platform overhaul. As Edgeryders evolves, the edgeryders.eu platform must evolve too. We have started a major overhaul. The look and feel will change, and many tedious bugs will die. We estimate that the next incarnation of edgeryders.eu will go live some time in March 2016, and serve us until the end of 2017. After that, though, we might have to switch to a completely different core tech. Drupal 7 won't be here forever. In about one year we will start discussing out long term option. You can be part of the current effort helanon3606750899g @anon1161452144 test his development site. Follow updates and take on tasks on the Edgeryders Development Group.
- LOTE5. Fail/unFail, the 5th episode of Living On The Edge is coming soon to Brussels. We have partnered up with Antiheroes, part of the community since 2014, to build an event centered on failure. @anon
- OpenCare. This was our one successful European research proposal. It's big: 1.6 million euro, of which a bit under 300K administered directly by Edgeryders. It's also exciting. Look it up, stay in touch, let us know if and how you want to collaborate. As always, we'll advertise any opening positions on the Edgeryders platform.
- Flagship projects. We want to build ""flagship projects"": big, bold, sustainable stuff, proposed by the community. If the idea is right, we might be able to build support and momentum around it. OpenCare is an example of a flagship project; the unMonastery is another one. There is space for a few more; get in touch and let's talk. But remember: if it's your project, you have to lead.
- Incubator/accelerator. So far Edgeryders-the-company has been emergent, with almost no strategy. We don't take debt. We don't seek investors. We don't seek core funding. We have no business plan. We take on paid work, trying to blend it in the community's interests as we go. We refused to do all the usual social startup stuff of investor pitching and spreadsheet compiling. That freed up time and energy to develop our product and test its viability. We now have a product: collective-intelligence powered expert advice, hacker style. We tested it, it's viable. Now what? We'd like to try and do more of it, faster. We are hackers (Matt, Vinay), researchers (Noemi, Asta, myself), designers (Nadia), organisation experts (Patrick, John). We need to boost our business skills and contacts if we are to run a ""real"" company. But we are educable, so we are considering incubators/accelerators around the world. If you work in one, or are a mentor or coach, and you would like to work with us, get in touch. We accept that some pitching and spreadsheets might ensue. Hey, the revolution is no gala dinner.
- Develop a success indicator (and trust it). Is Edgeryders successful? No one knows. On the one hand, we are not moving serious amounts of money. On the other hand, we do seem to have some access to power players and some recognition as trailblazers. I would like to combine monetary (contracts signed?) and non monetary (access to high-level people?) into a sort of ""life force index"" for Edgeryders. And then, make decisions on the basis of how the index moves. If you like this, let me know and we'll take it from there.
- More sales. We are working hard to get new contracts and new clients. We'll be announcing deals as we close them. Do you know of someone that might be interested in hiring Edgeryders as consultants? Hire yourself into the company, we'll help you seal the deal.
Edgeryders is so new and strange that I can't tell whether it's headed for stardom or disaster. Both, maanon1932026148. Either way, it's an interesting journey, and I look forward to finding out where it ends.
"
1,5013,2015-11-18T10:52:55.000Z,5013,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Some time ago we agreed to schedule our kickoff meeting at the same time as the Living On The Edge 5 Edgeryders event, to take advantage of that particular effort. That means 25-28 February 2016.
What's missing is a schedule of our activities, and time is getting tight if we are to engage with other people out there (and we are). I propose we do two things.
One day of talking. This would be a closed-door meeting for the consortium only. Closed-doors means we all are welcome to invite external people (for example with a view to future partnerships), but other than that we will just have a regular meeting. We will cover collaboration procedure and tools; admin; and detailed planning on the first six months of so of the project. We will also schedule the second consortium meeting.
One day of doing. This would be an open-door event scheduled within LOTE5, which anybody can attend – the more the merrier. Call it the first of the OpenCare onboarding workshops. Here we have several possibilities. I see at least three very attractive things we could do:
- Masters of Networks. A hackathon based on network methodology and data. @anon2774142051 and myself have some experience in delivering those – of course we would need care-related network data. See this short video to get an idea of what happens at Masters of Networks events.
https://www.youtube.com/embed/2-9z0i5fuvE?rel=0
- A workshop on designing community-driven care services. This could be led by Ezio Manzini.
- One or more talks to present the project by conveying the urgency of the issue. I would love a talk by @anon4116418727 on healthonomics, for example – how incentives are very seriously warped in this field. @anon
My preference would be for doing all of the above, and perhaps even more. Maanon1932026148 @anon
- Closed door meeting: 24th February.
- Masters of Networks: 25th of February, within LOTE5
- Design workshop and talks: 26th of February, within LOTE5.
What does everyone think?
"
2,7449,2015-11-19T15:11:17.000Z,5013,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Milano too
Also anon3606750899g @anon
"
3,20085,2015-11-19T15:41:10.000Z,5013,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Masters of Networks 4 -- is one day enough?
Wow, thanks for putting that great and stimulating video -- and I am not saying that because I appear on the screen. I think it is a good way to publicize the event and attrack more people.
My experience is that MoN need at least two days to produce anything juicy. The first day is usually dedicated to handle data, trigger and massage ideas, the second day is often useful to take a distance, have a second look at the available visualizations (often made late at night after dinner ...).
We usually work around network data provided by domain experts, together with questions they have around their communities (part of the game is to properly spell out these quesitons).
We could also try to put our hands on welfare data -- would that be available through national opendata portals, for instance? We can work network data *and* any other kind of data, and hopefully mix them.
So my question/proposal is to have MoN spread over Feb 25 ad Feb 26. That being said, it may be possible to squeeze things into 1 1/2 day to keep everything within 3 full days ?
"
4,23692,2015-11-19T16:17:10.000Z,5013,anon3612872438,anon1526983854,"Smart objects with Arduino?
Hi all,
nice plan!
WeMake can contribute with a talk to present some interesting projects and approaches around the topics of care and makers culture.
As the plan is already pretty interesting, do you think there will be time to have an additional hands-on activity? (minimum 4 hours for an introduction on a technology and its potential - or 8-10 hours if we want to try and prototype something).
If there is time, the easiest thing (without having the machines of a fablab) would be to bring to Brussels 10 Arduino kits we usually use for our workshops on which 20/25 people from different backgrounds could be activated in understanding what does it mean to work on smart objects.
best
Zoe
"
5,24856,2015-11-19T16:54:29.000Z,23692,anon2774142051,anon3612872438,"Hands-on, yeah!
I'd be delighted to have a hands-on workshop,
I understand we need to find a viable compromise and share time between all activities. But I personally would benefit from getting involved with what you guys do. Because ""doing things"" is at the center of OpenCare, I am ready to compress the MoN part and mayeb keep it to a introductory activity to future MoNs ...
???
"
6,26580,2015-11-19T17:07:21.000Z,5013,anon4116418727,anon1526983854,"Here I am...
Thank you @anon
I would agree with @anon2774142051: let's keep the MoN to a demo/introduction for future activities. Could data sources like the following be useful for the demos?
http://www.oecd.org/social/expenditure.htm
http://data.worldbank.org/topic/health
http://www.gapminder.org/data/
Concerning my lecture, there is a lot we may want to discuss: from the incentives you mention, to the warped ways we account for the costs... The role of informal care, and the exorbitant overheads of bureaucracy in institutional care...
But let me ask, before I promise anything: How much time would you plan on dedicating to each lecture? Shouldn't we somewhat align the topics to the day we insert the lectures in (as inspiration for MoN, or for the design hackaton)?
Listening on this channel now ;)
"
7,27180,2015-11-21T08:12:04.000Z,26580,anon2774142051,anon4116418727,"Good start -- but ...
I had a quick look at the data, I could download datasets from the OECD, I saw there a tons of data on the WB portal, I have some ideas what GapMinder offers.
The essential ingredient I need to be able to build an interesting and useful demo is ""questions"". What type of information/knowledge may we expect to get out of these datasets? We could ""replay"" things similar to GapMinder, but then how better would that be than simply listening to Rosling's videos (and he is a heck of a speaker)?
How can these datasets be used to reveal something useful for OpenCare?
"
8,27392,2015-11-21T11:34:55.000Z,27180,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Questions
We have been thinking about Wikipedia pageviews as an indicator of (partial) disintermediation in diagnosis; people look up pages on medical condition to make sense of the symptoms they feel.
A network science version of this would be to:
- (basic, but by no means easy to implement) draw a network of health-related Wikipedia pages (page A in connected to page B if it contains a link to page B). This can be seen as a representation of the concept space as seen from ""the crowd"".
- (advanced) draw a network from a comparable academic dataset. This can be seen as a representation of the concept space as seen from credentialed experts.
- compare the two networks. Are there differences?
"
9,27481,2015-11-23T10:12:07.000Z,27392,anon4116418727,anon1526983854,"The kind of data...
The kind of data we would need for that kind of analyses does not seem to be usually available through wikipedia/wikimedia statistics (see -> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Statistics AND http://stackoverflow.com/questions/5323589/how-to-use-wikipedia-api-to-get-the-page-view-statistics-of-a-particular-page-in).
In facts, while I was trying to figure out what they could share with us, I haven't been able to find any documentation of how they would store less-than-anonymised-and-aggregated data about traffic...
"
10,27579,2015-11-23T10:16:38.000Z,27180,anon4116418727,anon2774142051,"I see your point...
I see your point @anon2774142051, but let me get this straight: are we still planning to give a demonstration of the techniques arsenal, or are we aiming at answering actually meaningful questions?
I am afraid if we embark in the second, not only will it take a bit more to figure out what to ask, but the MoN will fall back to the initial condition of requiring at least a couple of days to produce anything better than a shabby collection of conflicting-half-thought visualisations (Hans is not just good because of the questions)...
Or am I overestimating the task?
"
11,27596,2015-11-23T10:41:57.000Z,27579,anon2774142051,anon4116418727,"Good point
You are absolutely right, and a bit wrong :-)
The value of visualization strongly depends on the motivation one has to explore the data. Dozens of different visualization can be built form the same dataset.
WHat I am suggesting is not to undertake a quest for question on the occasion of the workshop, but to have them beforehand so I can prepare a ""show"" that would demonstrate the arsenal, based on real and convincing motivations.
I also had a look at what could be done using the wikipedia pages, as suggested by Alberto. I am still unsure about the feasibility (putting our hands on usage statitics could be quite difficult).
So, I am still interested in hearing people about how the oecd data could be useful for OpenCare.
"
12,27605,2015-11-23T13:48:57.000Z,27596,anon4116418727,anon2774142051,"OK there...
So we both agree wikipedia is shaky ground... I will try to contact somebody at the Wikimedia Foundation to ask them whether the data could even be collected in the form we might need, but not for the LOTE5 deadline.
I will try to think of something about the OECD exercise instead, to contribute to the ""brainstorming"" ;)
Marco
"
13,27618,2015-11-23T16:16:31.000Z,27596,anon1526983854,anon2774142051,"Statistics are easy
Page view stats are easy. Wikipedia maintains hourly dumps of all page views stats (documentation).
The difficult part is disentangling the pages about care from the pages about everything else. This cannot be done directly (it is not a field of the dataset); it has to be done by association. There are two ways to do that:
- by ontology. There is a Wikiproject Medicine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:WikiProject_Medicine which even maintains its own statistics page. It follows that there is somewhere a piece of code that knows how to tell pages which are part of this project from pages which are not (""Medical articles are determined to be those NS0 articles tagged within the scope of WP:MED according to a category dump at the time of report generation""). Somewhere, someone has that code and could give it to us.
- by emergence, based (you guessed it) on the network of links connecting different entries to each other. Within Wikipedia, you can expect to see pages about medicine to cluster into a community of pages more closely connected to each other than to the rest of the encyclopedia. Something like this seems to be done by tools like WikiLoopr (try it: for example http://www.wikiloopr.com/diabetes)
There are at least three interesting questions concerning OpenCare that you could address by looking at Wikipedia data:
- Which entries are people looking up (hint: not necessarily the ones you would think)? Is that indication of self-diagnosis going on? What can we learn about that (example: are some countries more inclined to do that than other countries?). This is a non-network question.
- How does collective intelligence in Wikipedia relate pages about care to each other? How does this compare to a similar web of relationship, but derived from academic datasets? This question pertains to networks of documents (Wikipedia entries) connected by hyperlinks (somebody did it in 2007).
- How does collective intelligence proceed in building that content? This question pertains to a network of Wikipedians connected by affiliation (having edited the same page).
There are many visualizations to look up for inspiration.
Any of this is to your liking, @anon2774142051, @anon4116418727 and all?
"
14,27620,2015-11-25T14:10:04.000Z,27618,anon4116418727,anon1526983854,"What I am not sure of...
What I am not sure of is the following: since the traffic is only saved as aggregated data (as in ""number of page visualisations"") rather than in detailed form (as in ""the same anonymous user has visited the following pages in sequence""), how do we build a meaningful network being blinded to their co-occurrence?
...so we have, on one side the visualisation load, and on the other the content relatedness... the latter being a bit less an expression of crowd intelligence than search co-occurrences would be, since the entries in wikipedia (and the edits) tend to be subdued to references...
"
15,27621,2015-11-26T10:01:50.000Z,27620,anon1526983854,anon4116418727,"Non-network
If you re-read my comment above, @anon4116418727, you will see that data on pageviews are non-network (item 1). Data on patterns of linking across entries (2) and collaboration on different entries (3) naturally induce networks.
"
16,27622,2015-11-27T12:17:16.000Z,27621,anon4116418727,anon1526983854,"yes...
...I am just unsure how would we interprete the possible analyses, being unable to access the hidden confounders acting on them...
...should we maanon1932026148 think of a bootstrapanon3606750899g pipeline, testing several (realistic?) weightings/architectures of confounders, to get a distribution of trustworthiness of the models (and their interpretations)?
Just running one analysis on the data doesn't seem to me any better than just formulating an informed prejudice... maanon1932026148 different, but not better.
"
17,27623,2015-12-01T08:45:01.000Z,27622,anon1526983854,anon4116418727,"Move the debate
@anon4116418727, @anon2774142051 and anyone else interested: let's move the debate on MoN to a different thread. This one has become long, messy and difficult to search.
"
18,28203,2015-11-19T17:39:00.000Z,5013,anon3471410614,anon1526983854,"my2cents
hi
I like the 3 days structure, day1 closed door, day2 MoN, day3 Ezio Manzini ws + our contributions.
I'm not sure about dedicating 2 days to MoN but, even if I watched the video, I've never experiences something similar. I definitely wouldn't miss Manzini ws on designing community driven care services!
I can bring with pleasure (afternoon day3 if I understood well) the point of ""welfare in the city"" and the challenging that the public system is facing!
"
19,29354,2015-11-19T18:42:28.000Z,5013,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Sequential == good
We have a fundamental tradeoff. On the one hand, we can reach the maximum amount of people by doing several things in parallel: data geeks might like MoN better, whereas designers will flock to Ezio etc. But on the other hand, we need to learn from each other and share tools, and we cannot do that if, say, Marco is talking about healthonomics in one room at the same time that Zoe is hacking devices in another room.
I recommend prioritising mutual learning over engagement. Doing things in sequence, which is normally inefficient, in this case is good (we will probably increase work in parallel as the project progresses). So, two possibilities:
- The @anon
- Posponing MoN to the second consortium meeting (Bordeaux in May?) to focus on workshop-y stuff and talks.
The third alternative, that of doing a two-day MoN but nothing else, I do not really like. I love networks, but I do not think non-geeks need some extra love at this stage. Do you agree, @anon
@anon4116418727 and @anon
@anon3612872438: do you want us to look into an alliance with the Brussels makers? This seems like an easy win: equipment is there and we have more makers coming into contact with the Belgian makers. Perhaps you know some already – and we do know @anon
"
20,29655,2015-11-20T12:38:08.000Z,29354,anon1491650132,anon1526983854,"Fitting Lote5
All, great to see enthusiasm jumanon3606750899g through the roof. Like @anon
I'd like to propose a small adjustment: it seems there's agreement for Day 1 to be meeting-style. Given that Day2, the 25th is the launch day for Living on the Edge conference, we have to consider a broader audience making contact for the first time. It would be great to use it as OpenCare context setting and public launch: an overview on care fails rather than data. I suggest planning Manzini's, Lucia's, Marko's and other talks+ maker workshops from the team here, and leave MoN for 26th, when it can run in parallel with other Lote sessions.
@anon4116418727 the easiest to manage is if you let us know how much time you would need at a minimum, rather than the other way around. If you know that you are giving a talk on the day of OpenCare official public launch in front of a v mixed audience, what picture would you like to paint the most?
"
21,29766,2015-11-23T10:35:24.000Z,29655,anon4116418727,anon1491650132,"I could just...
I could just present a simple introduction to the principles of medicine, contrasting them with the everyday experience of medical practices as they are commonly seen... This could serve the purpose of discussing failures, AND of highlighting our yet poor framing of what we do, at once.
The number of arguments touched may vary quite a bit, but let's say that starting from being allowed 30 minutes of lecture on, I believe it could start piecing together for the audience. It would be nice to have some time immediately after the lecture buffered for questions, allowing also for relaxed interruptions during the lecture. I usually get the feeling that asking people to wait for other lectures to conclude before asking questions let's their curiosity drain away...
I should be comfortable with people interacting with me in quite a few languages (English of course, Italian of course, French, Spanish, Portuguese, and I could even venture accepting questions in Dutch although quite uncomfortably =P...) but I am only able to reply fluently and timely in English and Italian ...this should be communicated to those attending... or we should identify some volunteer (informal) interpreters ^_^
"
22,29806,2015-11-23T13:50:11.000Z,29766,anon1491650132,anon4116418727,"Your call!
@anon4116418727 so it would seem you will need around an hour, Q&A included. But it will be really your call. I suggest once you have decided on a title and a couple paragraphs to describe your session you upload it as a proposal to the program. Here are all the instructions and questions to help you refine it. Of course you'll always be able to change it, but it gives people an introduction and a way to talk to you prior to Brussels because we'll be circulating the link. You can also post or link to resource and readings so we come better prepared.
"
23,29823,2015-11-25T14:11:31.000Z,29806,anon4116418727,anon1491650132,"Great...
...I will take care of this on Friday. Thank you for pointing the resources out for me.
"
24,29856,2015-11-23T13:42:37.000Z,29655,anon4116418727,anon1491650132,"I could suggest...
Hi @anon1491650132, all
I could suggest a lecture about the weird ways from fundamental research to ""innovation"" from a researcher here in ATLAS/CERN from the University of Geneva? He is doing R&D in medical technologies, but the story (I believe) is more interesting for us than the subject of research itself...
How would you feel about it?
"
25,30173,2015-11-20T10:50:23.000Z,5013,anon3612872438,anon1526983854,"Alliance
@anon1526983854 we have special kits plug and play to fast prototype with Arduino, sensors and actuators that's why it would not be necessary to ask for equipment. for sure It would be nice to involve them for networking on opencare!"
27,30950,2016-02-03T10:41:57.000Z,30771,anon2774142051,,"Any data available?
@anon
I had not noticed this post among the long discussion about the organization of the kick-off.
Does Milano have any data we could use to investigate how the Welfare di tutti initiative is doing? Any conversations among participants, any traces of activities related to this initiative?
Would be great to use this as an ingredient for the MoN4 workshop. There is still time to include this to the workshop.
Guy
"
28,31013,2016-02-04T11:26:10.000Z,30950,anon3914374234,anon2774142051,"Welfare di tutti
Hi Guy
I'm not sure we can provide useful data for the MoN4 (the kind of data that you mentioned). Sorry for this, probably later...
Anyway we'll talk about it with Seble and colleagues in the Dept. of Social Policy.
In the next weeks they should launch the new platform of the project Welfare di tutti, that should work also as a collector of conversations among participants.
For sure we'll bring in Brussels some informations and updates on the running project ""Welfare di tutti"" and its potential synergies with Opencare.
Rossana
"
29,31271,2015-11-24T19:10:00.000Z,5013,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Closing proposal
Ok, guys, thanks for the intense debate. Let me try to summarize: I think we are almost there, but there is one final decision to make.
- Wednesday 24th: closed-door consortium meeting
- Thursday 25th: LOTE5 begins with a track on failing/unfailing in care. Talks and design workshops go here.
- Friday 26th: Master of Networks – Care Edition
- Saturday 27th/Sunday 28th: LOTE5 unconference (for those who want to stay on, it's a lot of fun).
The final decision concerns the workshop-shaped stuff. At the moment we have three things:
- Manzini: designing community-driven care services. I will speak to Ezio tomorrow, but I guess this can be done in, say 3-4 hours.
- WeMake: open hardware for care. Minimum 4 hours
- Masters of Networks: minimum one day
Again, it seems we have one thing too many. In principle we could do Manzini and WeMake on Thursday and MON on Friday, but that would not leave a lot of breathing space to the talks. So, we can do two things:
- pospone the WeMake seminar a later consortium meeting, and replace it with a talk on open hardware and care.
- pospone Masters of Networks to a later consortium meeting, and replace it with a talk on network science, collective intelligence and care.
I would not pospone (a) the talks and (b) Ezio's workshop, because they are both channel of outreach and onboarding.
What do you guys think? @anon2774142051 @anon3612872438 vote 1.
We're super ok to postpone the hardware workshop in a later consortium meeting.
I'm very excited to learn new things!
Costantino
"
31,31907,2015-11-24T23:07:54.000Z,5013,anon2656437829,anon1526983854,"The schedule
I was informed by Nadia that the conference would begin February 25. I have planned accordingly and have other assignments in Stockholm the 24th (and will be arriving in Brussels Wednesdat night). Therefore, I would suggest that we'll hold any consortium meetings February 25-27.
"
32,31996,2015-11-25T08:47:35.000Z,31907,anon1526983854,anon2656437829,"Conference != consortium meeting
@anon
That leaves the ""one day of talking"", the closed-door part of the consortium meeting. We scheduled it the day before the conference because it makes sense for OpenCare – get the consortium on the same page first, then we all go blend with the people who come for LOTE5 (we project 100-200 participants) – and because the whole Edgeryders team will be running around to keep the show going.
Sorry for bluntness, but are you sure you cannot reschedule your Feb 24th commitment? This would really help a lot.
"
33,32033,2015-11-25T11:37:03.000Z,31996,anon2656437829,anon1526983854,"Consortium meeting
Had it been possible I would have done so. Now I have organized activities in Stockholm before the LOTE5-conference in order to make it possible for me to attend the conference.
I guess the alternative is to hold the OpenCare meeting at another date.
"
34,32154,2015-11-25T14:10:11.000Z,5013,anon3914374234,anon1526983854,"Closing proposal
Hi guys
our Agenda seems very rich and inspiring!
Hoanon3606750899g Lakomaa will find a good solution for the date and let us know.
In the meanwhile me together with Lucia and Domenico are convinced that the proposed program could work very well:
• Wednesday 24th: closed-door consortium meeting
• Thursday 25th: LOTE5 begins with a track on failing/unfailing in care. Talks and design workshops go here.
• Friday 26th: Master of Networks – Care Edition
We too are so curios to discover MoN, and looking forward to meeting you
Arrivederci!
Closing proposal
Closing proposal
"
35,32223,2015-11-25T14:16:51.000Z,32154,anon4116418727,anon3914374234,"I like the final proposal as well.
@anon2435658896, is there any action that can piggyback this meeting in preparation for the maker-workshop we are postponing? Even something easy, like collecting hacking challenges in a ""suggestion box"" during the coffee-breaks? I understand LOTE5 will attract a lot of people...
:)
"
36,32280,2015-11-25T14:20:11.000Z,32154,anon2656437829,anon3914374234,"Not possible
As I have previously mentioned, it is not possible to change since I'm responsible for a seminar in Stockholm the 24th (scheduled for that date in order for me to be able attend the Brussels conference, which accordng to ER, was to be held March 25-27).
If you think it is appropriate, feel free to hold the OpenCare meeting without me.
"
37,32343,2015-11-26T10:52:31.000Z,5013,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Final call – please all consortium partners speak their mind
We are almost there.
There are two ways that we can resolve this.
- Go ahead as planned, but take care to fill in @anon
- Move everything one day down. Closed doors on 25th, talks on 26th, MON 27th. This has three disadvantages: (a) Day 3 happens on a Saturday – not a problem for me, but it might be for some people; (b) the Edgeryders team is probably going to be incomplete due to the burden of organising LOTE5; (c) Guy has to leave the MON room at 4 pm on Saturday afternoon.
It's a very close call between these two, for me. If I have to pick one, I'd say 2, but my priority is that we all participate as much as possible in all activities to maximize mutual learning.
"
38,32399,2015-11-26T11:21:44.000Z,32343,anon3914374234,anon1526983854,"Final call
Option n 2 (25th-27th) is ok for Comune di Milano!
"
39,32506,2015-11-26T13:27:20.000Z,5013,anon2656437829,anon1526983854,"Option 2
... is obviously prefarable to me. I will be in Brussels until Sunday.
"
40,32657,2015-11-26T17:13:15.000Z,5013,anon2435658896,anon1526983854,"option 2
Hi,
I prefer option 2 in order to start with the full team in full steam ;)
"
41,32741,2015-11-26T19:30:06.000Z,5013,anon70625510,anon1526983854,"2
Important to start in alignment from the get go..
"
42,32848,2015-11-27T10:47:22.000Z,5013,anon1526983854,anon1526983854,"Closed
Ok, let it be written in stone. Option 2 it is.
The OpenCare consortium meeting will take place in Brussels in February 2016, and consist of:
- a closed-door meeting on Thursday 25th
- a day of knowledge sharing and outreach through talks and a workshop on designing care services on Friday 26th.
- a day of knowledge sharing and outreach through a Masters of Networks hackathon on Saturday 27th.
"
43,32916,2015-11-27T11:04:39.000Z,5013,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Great start
Good,
forward the details so we can all take care of our travel and lodging arrangements early enough.
"
44,32965,2016-01-19T08:23:33.000Z,5013,anon2774142051,anon1526983854,"Arriving on Feb 23 late afternoon - leaving Sun 28
Hi all,
I am preparing my trip to Brussels for the kick-off meeting, and I am considering travelling by train which would actually be so good that I could return on Sunday (instead of Saturday as originally planned).
Also, I am considering arriving on Feb 23 (Tuesday) late afternoon. I would like to take advantage of begin ""close"" to EdgeRyders (as well as all other interested partners/parties) so I can interact with those involved/interested in Task 5.x (ethnographic coding; EdgeSense functionalities). We could also pamper the MoN4 session ahead of time.
Let me know whether anyone will be available. I plan to stay at the Radisson as suggested by Alberto - if anyone has any better suggestion, please shout it out loud :-)
"
45,33010,2016-01-19T09:53:26.000Z,5013,anon2435658896,anon1526983854,"WeMake crew - Arriving Feb 24 afternoon - Leaving Feb 28
Hi all,
the WeMake crew (@anon3612872438, @anon
And we have plenty of time to enjoy Lote5.
We'll sleep in an Airbnb near Brussel Midi station pretty close to the venue. ((We'll host also Matanon1201778428 Uguzzoni another Edgeryders from Milano, not yet related to opencare))
"
1,5220,2016-01-25T11:02:21.000Z,5220,anon2256444689,anon2256444689,"Have you ever answered a question like ""What are you working on?"" or ""So, who do you work with?"" with ""Well, uhm, it's complicated""? Then, this workshop is for you.
Are you profoundly empathetic, an amazing out-of-the-box thinker or a deep analytical thinker?
Then, this workshop needs you.
A. What's going to happen?
As part of the Storytelling Workshop: Narratives of care 2016, @anon
You can participate as either ""Story"" or as ""Storyteller"":
Story
Your ""story"" will become the center of an investigative group exercise. The messier your ""story"", the better the workshop will be. Perhaps you are working on a project, but aren't really sure what it is or have difficulty explaining it to people? Perhaps you are stuck in some kind of dilemma or conflict that you find difficult to get past? Perfect! We will take a significant amount of time to figure out what is going on and help you get on your way (again).
The outcome of the workshop (for you) will be text, diagrams, video and pictures that you can use to explain your story when those questions come up once more.
What kind of story? any story, but reflect on how it ties to health/social care+ technology +communities
Storyteller
A good storyteller is in the first place someone who can listen to someone's story (even if it is your own). You'll then get to ask questions, investigate, analyze, try to distil the essence of a story, receive feedback and start from the beginning again. Until we get it ""right"".
You'll learn and practice all sorts of skills valuable for telling your own stories when they need it. And of course you will discover all sorts of projects other people are working on. But mostly, you will have the deep satisfaction of having been able to help someone.
B. Participants Registration
Please follow the instructions on the event page: Storytelling Workshop.
C. What else?
We will practice some experimental identity/co-counseling methods in between story sessions. The goal here is to see if you can discover new, profound truths about your own story.
You will also be invited to provide feedback on the workshops methods themselves. Since they are quite new and/or relatively unknown, we welcome improvements and commentary.
Your output from the workshop: a professional kit
At the end of the day, we will have fleshed out together a number of strong narratives on care. In this case, this means engaging stories that participants can showcase later on to build support for their project. The person behind the ""story"" will gain:
- a hi-resolution photograph
- text and diagrams illustrating the story
- a short video recording
For the video, we will add a ""scribe"" and a ""confessional"" (video) booth. Only one participant can really be the focus during a certain period (I'd say min 30 minutes), so it restricts how many projects could be ""processed"". However, that also means people can participate without being the ""focus"", by being simply storytellers.
Licensing
All material produced, including notes from the session.. will be published under a creative commons license on edgeryders.eu (we'll need a signed release form from each participant at beginning of workshop)
What should you bring along?
Ideally, a laptop per story, so we can start writing them down straight away and maanon1932026148 publish by the end of the day some of them. (Natalia)
facilitators, add here, please. (DSLR cameras, special clothing etc)
Want to help organize this event and join a global team?
- Help translate the application from into French and Dutch, and update the FB and ER event pages with a more detailed breakdown of the session + get invitation to activists and others doing relevant work.
- Help with the participants communication: only participants who have filled in the form by 23/2/2016 can join us.
- Send out two email reminders with what participants need to send us in advance and what they need to bring with them (nice clothes, makeup, laptops, cameras, digital files with logos etc etc)
- Spread the word!
- Event on Edgeryders: https://edgeryders.eu/en/lote5/storytelling-workshop-narratives-of-care-2016
- Event on fb: https://www.facebook.com/events/872193402902331/
"
2,10195,2016-01-25T11:05:33.000Z,5220,anon2256444689,anon2256444689,"There you go
Hi @anon
"
3,16629,2016-01-25T11:12:35.000Z,5220,anon602631834,anon2256444689,"I NEED THIS
Better said, we need this, I think. Of course!