{ "schemaVersion": 1, "publicationId": "1791621221970-ugz5d4k6", "title": "HCAR1-GPR81 Versus Intracellular Lactic Acid in Macrophage Inflammasome Priming", "selectedQuestion": "In macrophages exposed to lactate during TLR/NLRP3 challenge, can pH-neutral extracellular lactate be interpreted as a HCAR1/GPR81 receptor-mediated anti-inflammatory gate, or do intracellular lactate transport, acidification and lactylation/polarization state explain the same outcomes?", "analysisType": "public full-text competing-model evidence synthesis", "endpointClasses": [ "GPR81-AMPK-LATS-YAP/NF-kappaB suppression", "GPR81-independent lactate suppression and glycolytic restraint", "LDH-dependent intracellular lactate support of NLRP3 activation", "intracellular lactic acidification and NLRP3 activation", "late histone lactylation and macrophage polarization", "pH-neutral receptor-linked NF-kappaB/NLRP3 suppression", "tumor lactic-acid/HIF1a macrophage polarization" ], "records": [ { "id": "hoque-2014-gpr81-innate-immunity", "ref": "[1]", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4104305/", "pmid": "24657625", "pmcid": "PMC4104305", "file": "concept-evidence/hoque-2014-gpr81-innate-immunity.txt", "citationKey": "[1]", "system": "Primary mouse peritoneal macrophages, Kupffer cells, human monocytes and organ-injury models exposed to TLR agonists and lactate.", "perturbation": "Lactate exposure, Gpr81 loss, ARRB2 pathway tests and TLR/NLRP3 stimulation.", "endpointClass": "pH-neutral receptor-linked NF-kappaB/NLRP3 suppression", "observedEvidence": "Lactate reduced TLR4-mediated Il1b, Nlrp3 and Casp1 induction, NF-kappaB activation, IL-1beta release and caspase-1 cleavage; GPR81 and ARRB2 were required.", "interpretationLimit": "The paper itself warns that prolonged supra-physiologic lactate can induce intracellular acidosis and augment NLRP3 responses.", "role": "supports_receptor_gate", "quote": "In macrophages and monocytes, increasing concentrations of lactate reduced TLR4-mediated induction of Il1B, Nlrp3 , and Casp1 ; activation of NF\u03baB; release of IL1\u03b2; and cleavage of CASP1. GPR81 and ARRB2 physically interacted and were required for these effects.", "index": 1, "sha256": "795cb4566c5bcc59644ca93745d85e047e93739ee4d7dda62a67c86ef4915405" }, { "id": "yang-2020-gpr81-yap-nfkb-macrophages", "ref": "[2]", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7573489/", "pmid": "33123172", "pmcid": "PMC7573489", "file": "concept-evidence/yang-2020-gpr81-yap-nfkb-macrophages.txt", "citationKey": "[2]", "system": "RAW 264.7 macrophages and BMDMs treated with lactate before LPS stimulation.", "perturbation": "10-20 mM lactate, GPR81 knockdown, AMPK/LATS/YAP signaling tests, LPS stimulation.", "endpointClass": "GPR81-AMPK-LATS-YAP/NF-kappaB suppression", "observedEvidence": "Lactate suppressed YAP and NF-kappaB activation and nuclear translocation through GPR81-dependent AMPK activation.", "interpretationLimit": "This receptor route addresses LPS cytokine signaling and does not adjudicate intracellular acidification, LDH/MCT flux or NLRP3 agonist timing.", "role": "supports_receptor_gate", "quote": "These data suggest that the suppressive effect of lactate on YAP activation and nuclear translocation is mediated by GPR81-dependent AMPK activation.", "index": 2, "sha256": "7b9a335ad677af9882f0d7ae6e52dcdd58f118362d0583b966e30e185b7f97f5" }, { "id": "errea-2016-gpr81-independent-lactate-macrophages", "ref": "[3]", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5112849/", "pmid": "27846210", "pmcid": "PMC5112849", "file": "concept-evidence/errea-2016-gpr81-independent-lactate-macrophages.txt", "citationKey": "[3]", "system": "Murine macrophages and Gpr81-deficient macrophage comparisons under LPS stimulation.", "perturbation": "High lactate exposure, Gpr81 genetic loss and metabolic reprogramming assays.", "endpointClass": "GPR81-independent lactate suppression and glycolytic restraint", "observedEvidence": "Lactate inhibited pro-inflammatory signaling and metabolic reprogramming in a GPR81-independent manner.", "interpretationLimit": "High lactate and incomplete pH/osmolarity/inflammasome-timing separation prevent treating this as a universal non-receptor rule.", "role": "contradicts_receptor_necessity", "quote": "This study demonstrates that lactate inhibits pro-inflammatory signaling in a GPR81-independent fashion.", "index": 3, "sha256": "b00363859e819b1af142197427534deab29e175d19c22cc7ccc95b0b12b70d52" }, { "id": "xie-2021-lactic-fermentation-nlrp3", "ref": "[4]", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8039150/", "pmid": "33854503", "pmcid": "PMC8039150", "file": "concept-evidence/xie-2021-lactic-fermentation-nlrp3.txt", "citationKey": "[4]", "system": "THP-1-derived macrophages and BMDM inflammasome agonist systems.", "perturbation": "LDH pharmacologic or genetic inhibition, glycolysis perturbation, nigericin/ATP/MSU/alum agonists and PKR inhibition.", "endpointClass": "LDH-dependent intracellular lactate support of NLRP3 activation", "observedEvidence": "Reducing lactic acid fermentation by inhibiting LDH reduced caspase-1 activation and IL-1beta maturation after NLRP3 agonists.", "interpretationLimit": "This is endogenous fermentation during inflammasome activation, not proof that pH-neutral extracellular lactate cannot signal through GPR81 in priming contexts.", "role": "supports_intracellular_activation", "quote": "Using pharmacological or genetic approaches, we show that decreasing lactic acid fermentation by inhibiting lactate dehydrogenase reduced caspase-1 activation and IL-1\u03b2 maturation in response to various NLRP3 inflammasome agonists", "index": 4, "sha256": "ae7ffad3d18c0947bd26158f053dcc61577eea45867f01f08d0910d27a975abd" }, { "id": "lin-2026-lactic-acid-intracellular-acidification", "ref": "[5]", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13172327/", "pmid": "41932879", "pmcid": "PMC13172327", "file": "concept-evidence/lin-2026-lactic-acid-intracellular-acidification.txt", "citationKey": "[5]", "system": "THP-1-derived macrophages, BMDMs, cell-free inflammasome assays and sepsis-relevant mouse experiments.", "perturbation": "Extracellular lactic acid or HCl at acidic pH, sodium lactate at neutral pH, NLRP3 activators nigericin/ATP and intracellular pH/acidification analyses.", "endpointClass": "intracellular lactic acidification and NLRP3 activation", "observedEvidence": "Intracellular lactic acid accumulation caused cytoplasmic acidification that promoted NLRP3 inflammasome activation.", "interpretationLimit": "The claim concerns acidic/intracellular lactic acidification and explicitly differs from neutral sodium lactate conditions.", "role": "supports_acidification_failure_condition", "quote": "Accumulation of intracellular lactic acid leads to cytoplasmic acidification, which promotes NLRP3 inflammasome activation.", "index": 5, "sha256": "27f3b892ffcd71a8257c51565ef255116afa768039fae61e97ea07f7479acf36" }, { "id": "zhang-2019-histone-lactylation-macrophages", "ref": "[6]", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6818755/", "pmid": "31645732", "pmcid": "PMC6818755", "file": "concept-evidence/zhang-2019-histone-lactylation-macrophages.txt", "citationKey": "[6]", "system": "Macrophage polarization and chromatin systems measuring lactate-derived histone lysine lactylation.", "perturbation": "M1 polarization time course, lactate manipulation, histone lactylation assays and Arg1/Vegfa expression analyses.", "endpointClass": "late histone lactylation and macrophage polarization", "observedEvidence": "Late M1 macrophage polarization showed elevated histone lactylation that induced homeostatic genes including arginase 1.", "interpretationLimit": "This is a late chromatin/polarization program, not a receptor-dependence or acute NLRP3-acidification test.", "role": "boundary_chromatin_polarization", "quote": "In the late phase of M1 macrophage polarization, elevated histone lactylation induces homeostatic genes involved in wound healing including arginase 1.", "index": 6, "sha256": "9ac4c952b3c999ad90a87307cf05a153857928eeb5aa398529708dfe236120c2" }, { "id": "colegio-2014-tumor-lactic-acid-macrophages", "ref": "[7]", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4301845/", "pmid": "25043024", "pmcid": "PMC4301845", "file": "concept-evidence/colegio-2014-tumor-lactic-acid-macrophages.txt", "citationKey": "[7]", "system": "Tumor-conditioned media, bone-marrow-derived macrophages, tumor-associated macrophages and HIF1a-deficient macrophage tests.", "perturbation": "Tumor-derived lactic acid, lactic-acid concentration gradients and HIF1a loss in macrophages.", "endpointClass": "tumor lactic-acid/HIF1a macrophage polarization", "observedEvidence": "Lactic acid alone induced Vegf and Arg1 expression in macrophages in a dose-dependent manner through HIF1a-linked polarization.", "interpretationLimit": "Tumor-polarization evidence is boundary evidence for macrophage fate, not acute TLR/NLRP3 receptor-versus-acidification discrimination.", "role": "boundary_tumor_polarization", "quote": "lactic acid alone was sufficient to induce Vegf and Arg1 expression in macrophages in a dose-dependent manner", "index": 7, "sha256": "20cc99486bf5def57388389ab6352a08e48b9de7b4581fad0305b84a96349a97" } ], "sensitivityAnalyses": [ { "id": "sensitivity-decision-changing-remove-receptor", "role": "decision-changing", "interpretation": "Removing Hoque and Yang eliminates direct receptor-gate support and leaves only intracellular or polarization accounts, so receptor language becomes unavailable." }, { "id": "sensitivity-robustness-remove-acidification", "role": "robustness", "interpretation": "Removing Lin narrows the acidification warning but Lin 2021 still supports intracellular LDH/lactate contribution to NLRP3 activation." }, { "id": "sensitivity-exploratory-current-lactylation-nlrp3", "role": "exploratory", "interpretation": "A 2026 NLRP3 lactylation paper was identified in current search; it supports the plausibility of lactylation as an inflammasome route but is not central until full text is archived and coded." } ] }