{ "author": "Sławomir Krakowski vel Smoku, Independent Researcher", "benchmark": "ID-SYN - Main Hypothesis Closure", "canonical_metric_choices": { "baseline_Z_info": "ID5 case_mechanism_summary baseline_z_info", "basin_depth_proxy": "ID2 case_geometry_summary basin_depth_proxy", "basin_retention": "ID5 median_basin_retention_fraction for baseline; damaged rows attenuated by protection ratio", "core_support_proxy": "ID6 median_core_localization_protection_index for baseline; explicit core integrity when available", "effective_escape_susceptibility": "ID5 median_escape_susceptibility_index for baseline; damaged rows attenuated/inverted by protection ratio", "hazard_suppression_score": "ID6 median_hazard_suppression_index attenuated for damaged rows", "ordered_flow_support": "ID9 causal_poloidal_stabilization_score for baseline; explicit flow/circulation/transport integrity when available", "phase_specific_contribution": "aggregated positive recognition gains from ID17 and best-candidate phase gains from ID19; treated as secondary/local", "proxy_attenuation_rule_for_damaged_rows": "When a manipulated-state benchmark lacked direct canonical readouts for basin/hazard/replay/rescue/phase, the baseline canonical value was attenuated by the manipulated protection ratio of that state.", "replay_capacity": "ID12 median strong_replay_matched per case, attenuated by protection ratio for damaged rows", "rescue_capacity": "ID12 median matched_rescue_gain per case, attenuated by protection ratio for damaged rows", "stability_score_baseline": "ID5 case_mechanism_summary baseline_stability_score", "stability_score_damaged": "benchmark-native manipulated protection score proxy from ID7/ID8/ID9/ID10", "topology_protection_score": "ID6 median_composite_topology_protection_mechanism_score for baseline; manipulated protection score for damaged rows", "winding_integrity": "ID6 median_winding_protection_index for baseline; explicit manipulation integrity when available" }, "component_classifications": { "Zinfo": "NONESSENTIAL", "basin": "SECONDARY_SUPPORT", "core": "SECONDARY_SUPPORT", "flow": "SECONDARY_SUPPORT", "hazard_suppression": "LOCAL_MODULATOR", "phase": "RECOGNITION_ONLY", "replay_rescue": "NONESSENTIAL", "topology": "NONESSENTIAL", "winding": "NONESSENTIAL" }, "counts": { "n_baseline_rows": 8, "n_cases": 8, "n_closure_rows": 23, "n_damage_rows": 15, "n_source_benchmarks": 14 }, "descriptive_closure": { "effect_sizes": { "protected_vs_ablated_closure_state_score": 10.28099995394192, "stable_topological_vs_ring_closure_state_score": 184.92035023753186, "stable_topological_vs_vacuum_closure_state_score": -73.38747500211518 }, "family_rows": [ { "case_family_class": "stable_topological", "median_basin_component": 1.0, "median_closure_state_score": 0.9497442536299912, "median_core_component": 0.3586179456049469, "median_flow_component": 0.01252105526123706, "median_hazard_component": 1.0, "median_phase_component": 0.4445585577136916, "median_replay_rescue_component": 0.4999046970666761, "median_topology_component": 0.9968111540803772, "median_winding_component": 1.0, "median_zinfo_component": 0.5441456947946749, "n_rows": 3 }, { "case_family_class": "vacuum_controls", "median_basin_component": 1.0, "median_closure_state_score": 0.9835973370580464, "median_core_component": 0.0, "median_flow_component": 0.02596452471704109, "median_hazard_component": 0.9994820483751528, "median_phase_component": 0.05357287772706562, "median_replay_rescue_component": 0.5011444637889365, "median_topology_component": 0.553842390934105, "median_winding_component": 0.0, "median_zinfo_component": 0.960792660358872, "n_rows": 3 }, { "case_family_class": "ring_basin_fragile", "median_basin_component": 0.3333333333333333, "median_closure_state_score": 0.8226679647521504, "median_core_component": 0.0, "median_flow_component": 0.035298881528746676, "median_hazard_component": 0.0, "median_phase_component": 0.5682019359865129, "median_replay_rescue_component": 0.4999064853689511, "median_topology_component": 1.891196659411356e-05, "median_winding_component": 0.0, "median_zinfo_component": 0.031036142186738447, "n_rows": 2 }, { "case_family_class": "ablated_or_damaged", "median_basin_component": 0.6842337501704363, "median_closure_state_score": 0.5917523789297118, "median_core_component": 0.7057944952968928, "median_flow_component": 0.24159381856382248, "median_hazard_component": 0.782470305200597, "median_phase_component": 0.30579377324644785, "median_replay_rescue_component": 0.3318584030043327, "median_topology_component": 0.756141681117576, "median_winding_component": 0.9999999999995001, "median_zinfo_component": 0.5441456947946749, "n_rows": 15 } ] }, "family_classifications": { "ablated_or_damaged": "DAMAGE_REVEALING", "ring_basin_fragile": "BASIN_FRAGILE", "stable_topological": "HYPOTHESIS_SUPPORTING", "vacuum_controls": "CONTROL_ONLY" }, "global_verdict": "STRONGLY_SUPPORTS_MAIN_HYPOTHESIS", "input_dirs": { "ID1": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_IMPEDANCE_STABILITY_TEST_ID1_20260312T174326Z", "ID10": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_PHASE_CIRCULATION_VS_TRANSPORT_DECOUPLING_ID10_20260313T072630Z", "ID12": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_TARGETED_HAZARD_REPLAY_RESCUE_ID12_20260313T092707Z", "ID13": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_MINIMAL_CAUSAL_RESCUE_BASIS_ID13_20260313T100217Z", "ID15": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_MECHANISM_AXIS_REFACTOR_ID15_20260313T141326Z", "ID17": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_PHASE_SPECIFIC_RECOGNITION_MARGIN_ID17_20260314T060155Z", "ID18": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_PHASE_MARGIN_SEARCH_MC_ID18_20260314T112210Z", "ID19": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_CONTRASTIVE_PHASE_DISAMBIGUATION_ID19_20260314T123801Z", "ID2": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_LOCAL_IMPEDANCE_GEOMETRY_ID2_20260312T180309Z", "ID5": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_ESCAPE_SUSCEPTIBILITY_DECOMPOSITION_ID5_20260312T193559Z", "ID6": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_TOPOLOGY_PROTECTION_MECHANISM_ID6_20260312T203031Z", "ID7": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_WINDING_ABLATION_TEST_ID7_20260312T212211Z", "ID8": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_CORE_VS_WINDING_DECOUPLING_TEST_ID8_20260313T054855Z", "ID9": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_POLOIDAL_FLOW_STABILIZATION_TEST_ID9_20260313T070255Z" }, "out_dir": "/Users/mac/Downloads/SKRYPTY/DIFT_MAIN_HYPOTHESIS_CLOSURE_ID_SYN_20260314T133105Z", "predictive_correlations": { "spearman_stability_vs_baseline_Z_info": -0.9761904761904762, "spearman_stability_vs_basin_depth": -0.20935894733965593, "spearman_stability_vs_ordered_flow_support": -0.28529056053927915, "spearman_stability_vs_topology_protection_score": 0.0958498023715415, "spearman_stability_vs_winding_integrity": -0.04979420682629886 }, "run_status": "completed", "run_timestamp_utc": "20260314T133105Z", "script_creation_date": "2026-03-14", "support_flags": { "basin_architecture_is_necessary": true, "flow_core_are_secondary": true, "phase_is_secondary_local_rather_than_primary": true, "stability_best_explained_by_multifactor_closure": true, "topology_winding_are_central": true }, "support_metrics": { "basin_architecture_support": 1.0, "closure_score": 0.8694959813749805, "flow_secondary_support": 0.7985885482999879, "hazard_repair_support": 0.8664559422687288, "hypothesis_support_grade": 0.8694959813749805, "multi_factor_model_support": 1.0, "phase_primary_relevance": 0.45, "stability_vs_Zinfo_support": 0.9622666318208626, "topological_protection_support": 0.703872034648055, "winding_causality_support": 0.6 } }