Using Text Mining to Search for Neolithic Vlaardingen Culture Sites in the Rhine-Meuse-Scheldt Delta

This paper presents a study on Vlaardingen Culture (3400-2500 BCE) sites in the
Rhine-Meuse-Scheldt delta using AGNES, an intelligent search engine for Dutch and
Flemish archaeological grey literature. The aims of this paper are twofold: 1) to
provide an up-to-date overview of Vlaardingen Culture sites; 2) to evaluate the
performance of AGNES in searching for period specific sites. Vlaardingen Culture
(VLC) sites usually consist of artefact scatters without clearly discernible house
plans. These scatters are often found amongst abundant remains from later periods.
This type of ‘by-catch’ is usually not found in the metadata of archaeological reports.
It can only be recovered in full text searches. AGNES uses Text Mining and Large
Language Models to allow searches on archaeological concepts (in this case an
archaeological culture) in full texts extracted from three major repositories for Dutch
(DANS and ARCHIS) and Flemish (Onroerend Erfgoed) archaeology. This paper
presents a search for VLC sites, and a comparison of the retrieved information with a
recently compiled overview of VLC sites in the area. Using eight queries we retrieved
4532 hits, which were subdivided into: relevant hits (n=430); semi-relevant hits
(n=2133); and irrelevant hits (n=1960). We recovered thirty previously unknown
Vlaardingen Culture sites, amounting to 19% of the total number of VLC sites
(n=158). Not all sites could be found in AGNES, older archaeological sites are often
published in scientific and semi-scientific journals, theses, or books. These
publications are absent in the repositories which can be accessed through AGNES,
and by extent, they cannot be retrieved. As such AGNES does not provide an
alternative to traditional search methods. Nevertheless, most of the newly found sites
consist of sites which cannot be found by searching the metadata of reports in DANS
and ARCHIS. Therefore, AGNES proved to be an essential and effective addition to
traditional search methods. Finally, our study highlighted the fact that clear
terminology to describe Vlaardingen Culture sites is presently lacking. As such the
study provided interesting insights into the terminologies employed in
development-led archaeology.