You bring up some good issues.  How much money goes to administration before it dwindles down to the $8k/year? The homeschooling parents pay the taxes and then pay for their children's education. From what I hear, the fees associated with going to public schooling would pay for many homeschool programs. I understand your point that you don't want the federal government dictating private education. Education is one of those issues where the best outcomes are achieved by eliminating the taxes and let people fend for themselves. People would demand more results when they are spending their own money. Parents should have the right to control their children's education. E.G. a five year old does not need to learn about pediphilia or any other perversity. The outcomes between public and private schools are significant.