Again I point out to you that there are circumstances where breaking protocol is warranted. They DO exist.  You know it and I know it. The question is whether or not this was one of those circumstances. I believe it was, you believe it wasn't. That's fine.  But you don't get to take that position and then conveniently ignore the responsibility that comes from taking it. By that I mean, you are saying the whole crew should therefore be subject to a guarantee of becoming infected.  Ok then, fine.  But then you also should be required to explain what happens next?  Seriously.  Now you've got a carrier full of thousands of infected people.  What happens next? Seriously, until you can answer that question, you're no different than the fat alcoholic who is criticizing the NFL quarterback from the comfort of his lazyboy. Again I say: "it's not the critic who counts, it's the man in the arena."