I'm 6 foot 3 and weight 160 lbs, so my BMI is 20.  I make above a 95 on my pt test in the military every year.  You're really telling me I'm a weak little faggot if I don't gain 40 lbs?  That's fucking stupid.  I would have to have nearly 80lbs of muscle.  I have met VERY few people at 25 BMI who are not fat, and they're super obviously in shape if you take one look at them, like all they do is eat chicken, protein, and go to the gym. You sound like one of the fats who tries to say "it's not fat, I'm just swole!"