As someone with a BMI right around the middle of healthy, and bf% ~14, I wouldn't feel right describing my body type as athletic.  I could get away with fit, but I feel like I'm more average.  The problem is, if I describe my body type as average, people will think dadbod, and no definition.  Still, I guess I am average... with a 250lb max deadlift. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯