No, this is the first liar. Some of them quit.. it's like they had amnesia and forgot everything I tell them and pretend calories don't exist and they stop logging their meals. Many of them do understand what I tell them and think before they eat, they stick to it for as long as they reach their goal weight and then maintain.  But this ham has made me believe she's doing everything right... for 3 months... why???  I don't know.