A lot depends on skin elasticity, which is determined by age and lifestyle (smoking, dehydration, and malnutrition are bad for elasticity), and genetics. A high-but-normal BF% looks "juicy" on a very young woman, early 20's at the latest, but skin starts to sag after a certain age.  Most men find "juicy" to be highly attractive, but remember: only the very young and healthy can look that way.    Much will depend on lifestyle factors, but almost all people have to get lean to stay attractive past age 35.