Her numbers were insane and show a complete disconnect with reality. There is no female body builder showing up to competition at 5'6" and 190lbs. If chicks who workout near constantly, who literally live for muscle gains, can't even achieve the example - the whole argument falls apart. If she wanted to rip into BMI, all she had to do was measure BF% but hers probably would have shown her to be even more unhealthy than her BMI would imply.