Real talk, did they ever? I don't know much about Reddit gold but as much as I always thought fph was 'winning' and that most people are shitlords whether they act on it or not (and I still think these things to a point), I don't think losing fph has that much of an impact on Reddit. I don't go there as much, but I doubt that EVERY one of the 150k plus people abandoned the site. Maybe I keep going back because I hang out in the niche hobby forums with like 400 people, that can't be easily replicated here.