Everyone has their preference, however it really is up to the girl! I'm not doing my makeup for men, I'm doing it for me, or even other girls. It makes me feel confident and it can be a cool form of art too. Whenever a man tells me I should wear less makeup or something or that they prefer me to look more natural, I usually tell them that I would prefer if they kept their mouth shut. Nothing drives me crazier than a man who polices the way a girl does her makeup or dresses, etc. when the woman never asked for his opinion. Not trying to be rude towards your comment, I'm not sure how I could word this in a more polite way. I just wouldn't recommend telling women irl that.