My ex-wife has the Athletic box ticked on her POF profile because 25 years ago she was a high school state champion distance runner, even though her current BMI is approaching 30 and it ain't muscle. She's like Al Bundy holding onto his high school glory of 4 touchdowns in one game, except he managed to stay a reasonable size as he aged. I think she will always see herself as that 17 year old athlete. Sad.