I also completely agree. I have a B.A. in Art, and have sat through many an art critique in human anatomy. Scars, moles, etc. can really add something to a rendering. I actually think the shading on this is really well done, but there are some technical mistakes with this. The thing I find most bothersome is if you tip your head to the right to align it with her face, the ear looks like it's growing out of the side of her neck. The shoulders are also messed up. I found the critique to be accurate as well. I think this might be a case of finding fatty whale tears because that's what you are looking for.