You guys are taking the no collarbone rule to literally. Its not always just about whether the collarbone is visible, but also how much it protrudes, how much of the bone you can see (in both pictures you can see the sides but you can't see where they meet in the middle), Whether you can see those two neck tendons that come down from each side of the throat and attach at the middle of the collarbones.  Collarbones don't disappear overnight.