It's easier for a dude to get to an overweight BMI via muscle mass, particularly if tall and broad. I'm 6'2 and sitting at 200 lbs right now with 15% body fat. That puts me at just shy of a 26 on the BMI scale but I'm definitely not fat. On the flip side, I'm definitely not body builder big, although my thighs are pretty massive.  Edit:  I responded with my pic for verification. Just waiting now.  Edit 2:  @duress56 and @homersimpson did you guys get my pic? I'm getting twitchy with all these pictures to comment on and being banned.