Too right. I looked up my BMI for my fattest, which was 11 and a half stone, and it was literally 24.5 - not even "overweight". I looked like a chubby bastard, and had zero muscle.  My BMI is 19 now, and even then I am still on a cut because I reached a 32 inch waist.... Fat people get one thing right when talking about BMI - it IS inaccurate. Its way too fucking generous.