{ "access": { "embargo": { "active": false, "reason": null }, "files": "public", "record": "public", "status": "open" }, "created": "2024-11-18T09:08:38.413473+00:00", "custom_fields": { "journal:journal": { "title": "Is groundbreaking research disruptive? The covariation of disruption indices with researchers' self-assessments" }, "meeting:meeting": { "acronym": "STI2024", "dates": "18-20 September 2024", "place": "Berlin, Germany", "session": "3", "session_part": "10", "title": "28th International Conference on Science, Technology and Innovation Indicators", "url": "https://sti2024.org/sti-conference/index.php" } }, "deletion_status": { "is_deleted": false, "status": "P" }, "files": { "count": 1, "enabled": true, "entries": { "STI_2024_proceedings.pdf": { "access": { "hidden": false }, "checksum": "md5:9cd622ab41acf6588b60fffff41b8e31", "ext": "pdf", "id": "dc0cd266-b2fc-45a9-9d07-e0a3b10d63a9", "key": "STI_2024_proceedings.pdf", "links": { "content": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/files/STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/content", "iiif_api": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/full/full/0/default.png", "iiif_base": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf", "iiif_canvas": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878/canvas/STI_2024_proceedings.pdf", "iiif_info": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/info.json", "self": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/files/STI_2024_proceedings.pdf" }, "metadata": {}, "mimetype": "application/pdf", "size": 202935, "storage_class": "L" } }, "order": [], "total_bytes": 202935 }, "id": "14170878", "is_draft": false, "is_published": true, "links": { "access": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/access", "access_grants": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/access/grants", "access_links": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/access/links", "access_request": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/access/request", "access_users": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/access/users", "archive": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/files-archive", "archive_media": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/media-files-archive", "communities": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/communities", "communities-suggestions": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/communities-suggestions", "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14170878", "draft": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/draft", "file_modification": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/file-modification", "files": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/files", "latest": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/versions/latest", "latest_html": "https://zenodo.org/records/14170878/latest", "media_files": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/media-files", "parent": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170877", "parent_doi": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14170877", "parent_doi_html": "https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.14170877", "parent_html": "https://zenodo.org/records/14170877", "preview_html": "https://zenodo.org/records/14170878?preview=1", "quota_increase": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/quota-increase", "request_deletion": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/request-deletion", "requests": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/requests", "reserve_doi": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/draft/pids/doi", "self": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878", "self_doi": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.14170878", "self_doi_html": "https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.14170878", "self_html": "https://zenodo.org/records/14170878", "self_iiif_manifest": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878/manifest", "self_iiif_sequence": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878/sequence/default", "thumbnails": { "10": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/full/%5E10,/0/default.jpg", "100": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/full/%5E100,/0/default.jpg", "1200": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/full/%5E1200,/0/default.jpg", "250": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/full/%5E250,/0/default.jpg", "50": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/full/%5E50,/0/default.jpg", "750": "https://zenodo.org/api/iiif/record:14170878:STI_2024_proceedings.pdf/full/%5E750,/0/default.jpg" }, "versions": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/versions" }, "media_files": { "count": 1, "enabled": true, "entries": { "STI_2024_proceedings.pdf.ptif": { "access": { "hidden": true }, "ext": "ptif", "id": "db3c8f65-2b89-4c71-9f26-cb597d83afde", "key": "STI_2024_proceedings.pdf.ptif", "links": { "content": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/files/STI_2024_proceedings.pdf.ptif/content", "self": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/14170878/files/STI_2024_proceedings.pdf.ptif" }, "metadata": null, "mimetype": "application/octet-stream", "processor": { "source_file_id": "dc0cd266-b2fc-45a9-9d07-e0a3b10d63a9", "status": "finished", "type": "image-tiles" }, "size": 0, "storage_class": "L" } }, "order": [], "total_bytes": 0 }, "metadata": { "creators": [ { "affiliations": [ { "id": "05591te55", "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "05591te55", "scheme": "ror" }, { "identifier": "grid.5252.0", "scheme": "grid" }, { "identifier": "0000 0004 1936 973X", "scheme": "isni" } ], "name": "Ludwig-Maximilians-Universit\u00e4t M\u00fcnchen" } ], "person_or_org": { "family_name": "Leibel", "given_name": "Christian", "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "0009-0006-6893-4901", "scheme": "orcid" } ], "name": "Leibel, Christian", "type": "personal" }, "role": { "id": "researcher", "title": { "de": "WissenschaftlerIn", "en": "Researcher" } } }, { "affiliations": [ { "id": "05ydjnb78", "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "05ydjnb78", "scheme": "ror" }, { "identifier": "grid.11046.32", "scheme": "grid" }, { "identifier": "0000 0001 0656 5756", "scheme": "isni" } ], "name": "University of Passau" } ], "person_or_org": { "family_name": "Tekles", "given_name": "Alexander", "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "0000-0001-8765-9331", "scheme": "orcid" } ], "name": "Tekles, Alexander", "type": "personal" }, "role": { "id": "researcher", "title": { "de": "WissenschaftlerIn", "en": "Researcher" } } }, { "affiliations": [ { "id": "032jh6m87", "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "032jh6m87", "scheme": "ror" }, { "identifier": "grid.425896.4", "scheme": "grid" }, { "identifier": "0000 0004 0444 9534", "scheme": "isni" } ], "name": "Nordic Institute for Studies in Innovation, Research and Education" } ], "person_or_org": { "family_name": "Aksnes", "given_name": "Dag W.", "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "0000-0002-1519-195X", "scheme": "orcid" } ], "name": "Aksnes, Dag W.", "type": "personal" }, "role": { "id": "researcher", "title": { "de": "WissenschaftlerIn", "en": "Researcher" } } }, { "affiliations": [ { "id": "01hhn8329", "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "01hhn8329", "scheme": "ror" }, { "identifier": "grid.4372.2", "scheme": "grid" }, { "identifier": "0000 0001 2105 1091", "scheme": "isni" } ], "name": "Max Planck Society" } ], "person_or_org": { "family_name": "Bornmann", "given_name": "Lutz", "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "0000-0003-0810-7091", "scheme": "orcid" } ], "name": "Bornmann, Lutz", "type": "personal" }, "role": { "id": "researcher", "title": { "de": "WissenschaftlerIn", "en": "Researcher" } } } ], "description": "

The study by Park et al. (2023), which found that disruptive innovations in science have been
declining since the end of World War II, triggered a public debate about an apparent lack of
major scientific achievements in the modern science system. However, could it be that not all
important contributions to the progress of science are captured as “disruptive” by the metric
used by Park et al. (2023)? Their metric, the disruption index, might not be suitable for
identifying major scientific achievements (groundbreaking research). In this study, we tested
whether the disruption index (two variants: DI1, DI5) corresponds with researchers’ self-
assessments of their own work as groundbreaking. The results of the study show that the
researchers define groundbreaking science as research that is novel and important. Furthermore,
the results reveal that the DI1 and the DI5 fail to identify publications that have been defined as
groundbreaking science by the researchers.

", "funding": [ { "award": { "number": "256223", "title": { "en": "R-QUEST" } }, "funder": { "id": "00epmv149", "name": "The Research Council of Norway" } }, { "award": { "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "http://www.bibliometrie.info/", "scheme": "url" } ], "number": "16WIK2101A", "title": { "en": "Kompetenznetzwerk Bibliometrie" } }, "funder": { "id": "04pz7b180", "name": "Federal Ministry of Education and Research" } }, { "award": { "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "http://www.bibliometrie.info/", "scheme": "url" } ], "number": "16WIK2101B", "title": { "en": "Kompetenznetzwerk Bibliometrie" } }, "funder": { "id": "04pz7b180", "name": "Federal Ministry of Education and Research" } }, { "award": { "identifiers": [ { "identifier": "http://www.bibliometrie.info/", "scheme": "url" } ], "number": "16WIK2101C", "title": { "en": "Kompetenznetzwerk Bibliometrie" } }, "funder": { "id": "04pz7b180", "name": "Federal Ministry of Education and Research" } } ], "languages": [ { "id": "eng", "title": { "en": "English" } } ], "publication_date": "2024-11-15", "publisher": "Zenodo", "related_identifiers": [ { "identifier": "10.1162/QSS.a.462", "relation_type": { "id": "ispublishedin", "title": { "de": "Ist ver\u00f6ffentlicht in", "en": "Is published in" } }, "resource_type": { "id": "publication-article", "title": { "de": "Zeitschriftenartikel", "en": "Journal article" } }, "scheme": "doi" } ], "resource_type": { "id": "publication-conferencepaper", "title": { "de": "Konferenzbeitrag", "en": "Conference paper" } }, "rights": [ { "description": { "en": "The Creative Commons Attribution license allows re-distribution and re-use of a licensed work on the condition that the creator is appropriately credited." }, "icon": "cc-by-icon", "id": "cc-by-4.0", "props": { "scheme": "spdx", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode" }, "title": { "en": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International" } } ], "subjects": [ { "subject": "Bibliometrics" }, { "subject": "CD index" }, { "subject": "Disruption index" } ], "title": "Groundbreaking research and disruption: Empirical results on the correlation between assessments of groundbreaking research by peers and disruption index scores" }, "parent": { "access": { "owned_by": { "user": "1220636" }, "settings": { "accept_conditions_text": null, "allow_guest_requests": false, "allow_user_requests": false, "secret_link_expiration": 0 } }, "communities": { "default": "5f4a906c-3cd9-403b-9398-56db38217efc", "entries": [ { "access": { "member_policy": "open", "members_visibility": "public", "record_submission_policy": "open", "review_policy": "closed", "visibility": "public" }, "children": { "allow": false }, "created": "2024-07-30T11:41:01.890231+00:00", "custom_fields": {}, "deletion_status": { "is_deleted": false, "status": "P" }, "id": "5f4a906c-3cd9-403b-9398-56db38217efc", "links": {}, "metadata": { "curation_policy": "", "description": "Community for the 28th International Conference on Science, Technology and Innovation Indicators (STI 2024) held September 18-20, 2024 in Berlin, Germany.", "organizations": [ { "id": "01hcx6992" }, { "id": "01n8j6z65" }, { "name": "Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research (ISI)" }, { "name": "European Network for Indicator Designers (ENID)" }, { "name": "Robert K. Merton Center for Science Studies" } ], "page": "

Community for the 28th International Conference on Science, Technology and Innovation Indicators (STI 2024) held September 18-20, 2024 in Berlin, Germany. The proceedings will consist of submissions accepted for oral presentations.

", "title": "STI 2024", "type": { "id": "event" }, "website": "https://sti2024.org/sti-conference/index.php" }, "revision_id": 5, "slug": "sti-2024", "updated": "2024-07-30T11:50:36.625956+00:00" } ], "ids": [ "5f4a906c-3cd9-403b-9398-56db38217efc" ] }, "id": "14170877", "pids": { "doi": { "client": "datacite", "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.14170877", "provider": "datacite" } } }, "pids": { "doi": { "client": "datacite", "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.14170878", "provider": "datacite" }, "oai": { "identifier": "oai:zenodo.org:14170878", "provider": "oai" } }, "revision_id": 5, "stats": { "all_versions": { "data_volume": 18872955.0, "downloads": 93, "unique_downloads": 69, "unique_views": 82, "views": 89 }, "this_version": { "data_volume": 18872955.0, "downloads": 93, "unique_downloads": 69, "unique_views": 82, "views": 89 } }, "status": "published", "swh": {}, "updated": "2026-03-16T09:19:42.026739+00:00", "versions": { "index": 1, "is_latest": true } }