Title,_operated-by,_job_website,Project status,Types of outputs,Transparency,Format,Process,Disciplinary fields,Review requested by,Reviewer selected by,Review coverage,Reviewer identity known,Competing interests,Public interaction,Author response,Decision,_verified
PREreview,"Leadership Team: Daniela Saderi, Samantha Hindle, Monica Granados; Fiscal Sponsor: Code for Science and Society",https://www.prereview.org,Active,Preprints,Open identities|Open interaction|Open reports|Single blind,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Comment moderation|Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review,All disciplines|Life Sciences,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Editor or service,Not included,Yes,No,Other scale or rating,Unverified
preLights,The Company of Biologists,https://prelights.biologists.com/,Active,Preprints,Open identities,Free-form commenting,Pre-publication review,Life Sciences,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Public,Not included,Yes,Yes,None,Unverified
Peeriodicals.com,The PubPeer Foundation,https://peeriodicals.com/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open interaction,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Comment moderation|Post-publication review,,,,,,,,,,Verified
Hypothesis,,http://hypothes.is,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints|Privately shared manuscripts,Double blind|Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports|Single blind,Annotations|Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Comment moderation|Journal integration|Post-publication review|Pre-publication review|Professional editors,All disciplines,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Specific aspects,Editor or service,Not included,Yes,No,None,Unverified
Plaudit,Flockademic,https://plaudit.pub,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Annotations|Quantitative scores|Structured review form,Journal integration|Post-publication review,All disciplines,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Public,Not included,Yes,No,Binary decision,Verified
Peer Community In,Peer Community In non profit organization,https://peercommunityin.org,Active,Preprints,Double blind|Open identities|Open reports|Single blind,Free-form commenting,,All disciplines,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
SciRate,SciRate Collaboration,https://scirate.com/,Active,Preprints,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation,Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores,Pre-publication review,All disciplines,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Public,Checked,Yes,No,Other scale or rating,Verified
Author-led peer-review trial by eLife,eLife,https://elifesciences.org/articles/36545,Completed,Journal accepted manuscripts,Open identities|Open reports|Single blind,Structured review form,Pre-publication review,Life Sciences,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
mSphereDirect,mSphere,https://msphere.asm.org/content/1/6/e00307-16,,Journal accepted manuscripts,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Pre-publication review,Life Sciences,Authors,Authors,Complete paper,Public,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
bims: Biomed news,"The Open Library Society, Inc.",http://biomed.news/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts,Open identities|Open participation|Open reports,,,Life Sciences,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Public,Not included,No,No,None,Verified
Select Crowd Review,Thieme & Filestage,https://www.thieme.de/de/thieme-chemistry/select-crowd-review-136859.htm,Active,Privately shared manuscripts,Single blind,Annotations|Free-form commenting,Pre-publication review|Professional editors,Chemistry,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
biOverlay,,https://bioverlay.org,Completed,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open identities|Open participation|Open reports|Single blind,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Post-publication review|Pre-publication review,All disciplines|Computer science|Life Sciences,Non-authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Not included,No,No,Binary decision,Verified
Nature open peer review trial,Nature,https://www.nature.com/nature/peerreview/debate/nature05535.html,Completed,Privately shared manuscripts,Open identities|Open participation|Open reports,Free-form commenting,Comment moderation|Journal integration|Pre-publication review,All disciplines,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",,,,,,,Verified
Nature double blind peer review trial,Nature,https://researchintegrityjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s41073-018-0049-z,,,Double blind|Single blind,,Pre-publication review|Professional editors,All disciplines,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,No,Binary decision,Verified
Interactive Public Peer Review,Copernicus Publications,https://publications.copernicus.org/services/public_peer_review.html,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Preprints,Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Journal integration|Pre-publication review,All disciplines,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper|Specific aspects,Editor or service,Checked,Yes,Yes,Binary decision,Unverified
Episciences,CCSD (Center for Direct Scientific Communication) [CNRS ; INRAÉ ; Inria ],https://www.episciences.org/,Active,Preprints,Open interaction|Single blind,Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores|Structured review form,Journal integration|Post-publication review|Pre-publication review,All disciplines,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
Faculty Opinions,Science Now,https://facultyopinions.com/prime/home?,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open identities|Open reports,Annotations|Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Post-publication review,Life Sciences,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Checked,No,Yes,Other scale or rating,Unverified
reffit,Greg Hale,https://reffit.com,Completed,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs,Open identities|Open participation|Single blind,Annotations|Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores,Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review,Computer science|Life Sciences,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Public,Not included,Yes,No,None,Unverified
F1000 Research,,https://f1000research.com,Completed,,Open identities|Open interaction|Open reports,Structured review form,Post-publication review,Life Sciences,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
Involving patients and the public in the peer review process,BMJ,https://www.bmj.com/campaign/patient-partnership,,Journal accepted manuscripts|Privately shared manuscripts,Open identities|Open reports,Free-form commenting,Journal integration,Life Sciences,,,,,,,,,Verified
Publons,,https://publons.com/,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Verified
Effects of training on quality of peer review: randomised controlled trial,BMJ,https://www.bmj.com/content/328/7441/673,,Privately shared manuscripts,,,,Life Sciences,,,,,,,,,Verified
Impact of assessing during peer review the consistency between the CONSORT checklist & the submitted manuscript on the completeness of reporting,David Blanco's PhD project under supervision of Erik Cobo at Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya and Jamie Kirkham at Liverpool University and in collaboration with BMJ Open.,https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03751878,,,Open identities|Open reports,Free-form commenting,Journal integration,Life Sciences,,,,,,,,,Verified
Impact of a short form of the CONSORT checklist for peer reviewers to improve the reporting of randomised controlled trials published in biomedical journals: a randomised controlled trial,,http://www.nowebsite.ch,,Journal accepted manuscripts,,,,,,,,,,,,,Verified
Transparent Peer Review,"Operated by Wiley, together with Publons and ScholarOne (both part of Clarivate Analytics).",https://www.wiley.com/network/researchers/submission-and-navigating-peer-review/progressing-towards-transparency-more-journals-join-our-transparent-peer-review-pilot,,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs,Double blind|Open identities|Open reports|Single blind,Structured review form,Professional editors,All disciplines,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Unverified
Effect of open peer review on quality of reviews and on reviewers'recommendations: a randomised trial,BMJ,https://www.bmj.com/content/318/7175/23,,,Open identities,Free-form commenting,Journal integration,Life Sciences,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
Axios Review,,https://dynamicecology.wordpress.com/2015/03/05/axios-review-is-working-you-should-try-it/,Completed,Preprints|Privately shared manuscripts,Double blind|Single blind,Annotations|Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Journal integration|Pre-publication review,Life Sciences,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Not included,No,Yes,Binary decision|Other scale or rating,Verified
Peerage of Science,Peerage of Science Ltd,https://peerageofscience.org,Active,Other scholarly outputs|Preprints|Privately shared manuscripts,Double blind|Open interaction|Open participation|Single blind,Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores|Structured review form,Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Journal integration,All disciplines|Life Sciences,Authors,"Editor, service, or community|Self-nominated",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,Yes,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
protocols.io,protocols.io,https://www.protocols.io/,,Other scholarly outputs,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation,Annotations|Free-form commenting,Post-publication review,,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Specific aspects,Editor or service,Not included,Yes,Yes,None,Unverified
Publishing review reports (PRR),Elsevier,https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-08250-2,,Journal accepted manuscripts,Open identities|Open reports|Single blind,Free-form commenting,Comment indexing|Professional editors,,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
External Tests of Peer Review Validity Via Impact Measures,American Institute of Biological Sciences,https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frma.2018.00022/full,,Journal accepted manuscripts,,,,Life Sciences,,,,,,,,,Verified
Grassroots Journals,Victor Venema,https://grassroots.is/,,Other scholarly outputs,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports|Single blind,Annotations|Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores|Structured review form,Comment moderation|Post-publication review|Professional editors,All disciplines|Earth & space sciences,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper|Specific aspects,Editor or service,Not included,Yes,No,None,Unverified
Science Open Reviewed,,https://science-open-reviewed.com/webapp/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Preprints,Open identities,Free-form commenting,Journal integration|Pre-publication review,All disciplines,Authors,"Authors|Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Unverified
In Review,Springer Nature and Research Square,https://www.springernature.com/gp/authors/campaigns/in-review,Active,Preprints,,Annotations|Free-form commenting,Journal integration|Professional editors,,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
WikiJournal User Group,"Thomas Shafee, EiC WikiJSci",https://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/WikiJournal_User_Group,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Preprints,Double blind|Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports|Single blind,Annotations|Free-form commenting,Post-publication review|Professional editors,All disciplines,Non-authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,Yes,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
"Karma Credits (and Blockchain/Cryptocurrency Incentives) for Reviewers, Editors, Authors",JMIR Publications,https://jmir.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/115001104247,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Verified
Blockchain for Peer Review,,https://www.blockchainpeerreview.org/,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Verified
IRRIDs: International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID)?,JMIR Publications,https://jmir.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/360003797672,,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs,,,,,,,,,,,,,Verified
Peer Feedback,"Ron Vale, Tony Hyman, and Jessica Polka",https://asapbio.org/peer-feedback,,Preprints,Open reports,Free-form commenting,Journal integration|Professional editors,Life Sciences,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,None,Verified
HIRMEOS - open peer review experiment,"OpenEdition (CNRS, EHESS, Aix-Marseille Université)",https://oep.hypotheses.org/2122,,Other scholarly outputs,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Annotations,Comment moderation|Post-publication review,Humanities|Social science,,,,,,,,,Verified
PLOS Channels,PLOS,https://channels.plos.org/,Completed,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open participation,,Post-publication review,All disciplines,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Public,Not included,Yes,No,None,Verified
SciPost,SciPost Foundation,https://scipost.org,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open participation|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Comment moderation|Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review|Pre-publication review|Professional editors,All disciplines|Physics,Authors,"Editor, service, or community|Self-nominated",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,Yes,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
"Open Peer Review, BMC Group","BMC Group, Springer Nature",https://www.biomedcentral.com/about/advancing-peer-review,,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs,Open identities|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Pre-publication review|Professional editors,,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Unverified
"Transparent peer review, Nature Communications",Nature Communications,https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms13626,,Journal accepted manuscripts,Double blind|Open reports|Single blind,Free-form commenting,Pre-publication review|Professional editors,All disciplines,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Unverified
Perceptions of open access publishing: interviews with journal authors,BMJ,https://www.bmj.com/content/330/7494/756,Completed,,,,,,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Specific aspects,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
Journal of Open Source Software: Bot-assisted Open Peer Review,Open Journals,https://joss.theoj.org,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Privately shared manuscripts,Open identities|Open interaction|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Automation|Pre-publication review,,Authors,Authors,Complete paper|Specific aspects,Editor or service,Not included,No,Yes,Binary decision,Unverified
Research Square,Springer Nature,https://www.researchsquare.com,Active,Preprints,Open reports,Free-form commenting,Comment indexing|Comment moderation|Journal integration|Pre-publication review|Professional editors,,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Unverified
Review Commons,EMBO and ASAPbio,https://reviewcommons.org,Active,Preprints,Open reports,Structured review form,Journal integration|Pre-publication review|Professional editors,Life Sciences,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,Yes,None,Verified
o'Peer,Jess H. Brewer,http://opeer.org,In preparation,Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Double blind|Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports|Single blind,Annotations|Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores|Structured review form,Automation|Comment indexing|Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review,All disciplines|Physics,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Not included,Yes,No,Other scale or rating,Unverified
Sinai Immunology Review Project,The Precision Immunology Institute at the Icahn School of Medicine (PrIISM),https://observablehq.com/@ismms-himc/covid-19-sars-cov-2-preprints-from-medrxiv-and-biorxiv,Active,Preprints,Open identities|Open reports,Structured review form,Automation,Life Sciences,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Editor or service|Public,Not included,Yes,No,None,Unverified
The Winnower,,https://thewinnower.com/,Completed,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores,Comment moderation|Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review,All disciplines,Authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Editor or service,Not included,Yes,No,Binary decision,Unverified
PeerLibrary,,https://peerlibrary.org/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints|Privately shared manuscripts,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Annotations,Comment indexing|Post-publication review,,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Specific aspects,Public,Not included,Yes,No,None,Unverified
Rapid Reviews COVID-19,The MIT Press,https://rapidreviewscovid19.mitpress.mit.edu/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Preprints,Open identities|Open reports,Structured review form,Automation|Comment moderation|Journal integration|Post-publication review|Pre-publication review|Professional editors,Life Sciences,Non-authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,No,No,Other scale or rating,Verified
CrowdPeer,,https://www.thecrowdpeer.com,Active,Preprints,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Comment moderation|Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review,Life Sciences,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Public,Not included,Yes,Yes,Other scale or rating,Unverified
Qeios,,https://www.qeios.com,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review,,Authors|Non-authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper|Specific aspects,Public,Not included,Yes,Yes,Other scale or rating,Verified
Researchers.One,"Harry Crane, Ryan Martin",https://researchers.one/,Active,Other scholarly outputs|Preprints|Privately shared manuscripts,Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Free-form commenting,Post-publication review|Pre-publication review|Preregistration,All disciplines,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper|Specific aspects,Editor or service,Not included,Yes,Yes,None,Unverified
SciBase,"SciBase, Inc.",https://scibase.co/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints,Open participation,Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Comment moderation|Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review,Chemistry|Life Sciences,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Public,Not included,Yes,No,Other scale or rating,Unverified
ScienceOpen,,https://www.scienceopen.com/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints|Privately shared manuscripts,Open identities|Open interaction|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Comment moderation|Journal integration|Post-publication review|Pre-publication review,All disciplines,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Not included,No,Yes,Binary decision|Other scale or rating,Unverified
Octopus [Currently in prototype phase],,https://octopuspublishing.org,In preparation,Other scholarly outputs,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports,Free-form commenting|Quantitative scores,Comment indexing|Comment rating (meta-evaluation)|Post-publication review,All disciplines,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Specific aspects,Editor or service,Not included,Yes,Yes,None,Unverified
PeerRef,,https://www.peerref.com/,Active,Other scholarly outputs|Preprints|Privately shared manuscripts,Open identities|Open interaction|Open reports,Structured review form,Pre-publication review,,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Displayed,No,Yes,Other scale or rating,Verified
Red Team Market,"Leo Tiokhin, Daniel Lakens",https://redteammarket.com,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Other scholarly outputs|Preprints|Privately shared manuscripts,,Annotations|Free-form commenting|Structured review form,Comment indexing|Comment moderation|Post-publication review|Pre-publication review,Social science,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Not included,No,Yes,None,Unverified
Crowd preprint review,ASAPbio,https://asapbio.org/crowd-preprint-review,Active,Preprints,Open identities|Open interaction|Open reports|Single blind,Annotations,Post-publication review,Life Sciences,Authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper,Editor or service,Not included,No,Yes,None,Verified
Effect on peer review of telling reviewers that their signed reviews might be posted on the web: randomised controlled trial,BMJ,https://www.bmj.com/content/341/bmj.c5729,Completed,Privately shared manuscripts,Open identities,Quantitative scores,,,Authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Public,Checked,No,Yes,Binary decision,Verified
PubPeer,The PubPeer Foundation,https://pubpeer.com/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Preprints,Open identities|Open interaction|Open participation|Open reports|Single blind,Free-form commenting,Comment moderation,,Non-authors,Self-nominated,Complete paper|Specific aspects,Noone|Public,Not included,Yes,Yes,None,Unverified
2019 Novel Coronavirus Research Compendium,Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health,https://ncrc.jhsph.edu/,Active,Journal accepted manuscripts|Preprints,Open reports,Structured review form,Post-publication review,,Non-authors,"Editor, service, or community",Complete paper,Editor or service,Checked,Yes,No,None,Unverified