Journal article Open Access

Wrong Side of the Yangtze River: Did a Map Mistake by the World Health Organization Contribute to Premature Conclusions About SARS2's Origin?

Chang, Whatsin Wu


JSON Export

{
  "files": [
    {
      "links": {
        "self": "https://zenodo.org/api/files/73f6a9dc-2574-4837-870b-31ad5c4d2b2d/Wrong_Side_of_the_River__Did_a_Map_Mistake_Cause_the_WHO_and_Others_to_Draw_Incorrect_Conclusions_About_SARS2_s_Origin_14Aug2021.pdf"
      }, 
      "checksum": "md5:98ee4ea9a3b54ba5f237759764ef9a28", 
      "bucket": "73f6a9dc-2574-4837-870b-31ad5c4d2b2d", 
      "key": "Wrong_Side_of_the_River__Did_a_Map_Mistake_Cause_the_WHO_and_Others_to_Draw_Incorrect_Conclusions_About_SARS2_s_Origin_14Aug2021.pdf", 
      "type": "pdf", 
      "size": 16505287
    }, 
    {
      "links": {
        "self": "https://zenodo.org/api/files/73f6a9dc-2574-4837-870b-31ad5c4d2b2d/Wrong_Side_of_the_Yangtze_River__Did_a_Map_Mistake_Cause_the_WHO_and_Others_to_Draw_Incorrect_Conclusions_About_SARS2_s_Origin_.pdf"
      }, 
      "checksum": "md5:debafc1e0adfe15c7ac08d2a5c48c562", 
      "bucket": "73f6a9dc-2574-4837-870b-31ad5c4d2b2d", 
      "key": "Wrong_Side_of_the_Yangtze_River__Did_a_Map_Mistake_Cause_the_WHO_and_Others_to_Draw_Incorrect_Conclusions_About_SARS2_s_Origin_.pdf", 
      "type": "pdf", 
      "size": 16471927
    }
  ], 
  "owners": [
    246045
  ], 
  "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.5202258", 
  "stats": {
    "version_unique_downloads": 1108.0, 
    "unique_views": 2023.0, 
    "views": 2390.0, 
    "version_views": 3855.0, 
    "unique_downloads": 506.0, 
    "version_unique_views": 3188.0, 
    "volume": 9159800445.0, 
    "version_downloads": 1252.0, 
    "downloads": 555.0, 
    "version_volume": 20640733564.0
  }, 
  "links": {
    "doi": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.5202258", 
    "conceptdoi": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.5153949", 
    "bucket": "https://zenodo.org/api/files/73f6a9dc-2574-4837-870b-31ad5c4d2b2d", 
    "conceptbadge": "https://zenodo.org/badge/doi/10.5281/zenodo.5153949.svg", 
    "html": "https://zenodo.org/record/5202258", 
    "latest_html": "https://zenodo.org/record/5202258", 
    "badge": "https://zenodo.org/badge/doi/10.5281/zenodo.5202258.svg", 
    "latest": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/5202258"
  }, 
  "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.5153949", 
  "created": "2021-08-14T18:11:58.076990+00:00", 
  "updated": "2021-11-20T13:06:27.705741+00:00", 
  "conceptrecid": "5153949", 
  "revision": 3, 
  "id": 5202258, 
  "metadata": {
    "access_right_category": "success", 
    "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.5202258", 
    "description": "<p>Did a map mistake about the location of the first published COVID-19 patient contribute to pre-mature conclusions about where SARS2&ndash;the virus that causes COVID-19&ndash;came from? This report explores that question.</p>\n\n<p>The World Health Organization recently acknowledged that the report it convened to study the origin of SARS2 featured several &ldquo;unintended errors&rdquo; about early COVID-19 patients. The errors include where the first published SARS2 patient lived at the time of diagnosis, and this error is apparent in the report&rsquo;s maps. Subsequent to the error in that report, other researchers appear to have repeated the error in their maps and corresponding analysis.</p>\n\n<p>This raises an intriguing question: did a map mistake in a report published by the World Health Organization cause the authors of that report and other researchers to draw premature conclusionsabout the origins of SARS-CoV-2?</p>\n\n<p>A specific example of where a premature conclusion appears to have been drawn by researchers who used the erroneous data that appeared in World Health Organization maps is this statement in <em>The Origins of SARS-CoV-2: A Critical Review</em>, Holmes et al (2021):</p>\n\n<p><em>&ldquo;Examination of the locations of early cases shows that most cluster around the Huanan market, located north of the Yangtze river (Fig. 1a-e)... There is no epidemiological link to any other locality in Wuhan... </em></p>\n\n<p>The analysis in the current study proceeds by first providing context about the ongoing debate about the origin of SARS2.&nbsp; That is followed by an analysis of maps from the World Health Organization&rsquo;s report on the origin of SARS2, as well as publicly available information and investigative reporting by Washington Post reporters about the location and characteristics of the first published COVID-19 patient. This study then reviews a series of heatmaps of COVID-19 infections in Wuhan, where&nbsp; each&nbsp; map&nbsp; uses&nbsp; a&nbsp; different&nbsp; methodology&nbsp; but&nbsp; all&nbsp; show&nbsp; a&nbsp; similar&nbsp; pattern&nbsp; for&nbsp; the&nbsp; progression of COVID-19 through Wuhan&rsquo;s districts, consistently showing that Wuchang district--not the district where the Huanan seafood market is located--was hottest with COVID-19 infections earliest.&nbsp; Finally, this report explores whether erroneous mapping of the first COVID-19 case contributed to premature conclusions about the origin of SARS2 and concludes by discussing research and public policy implications.</p>", 
    "language": "eng", 
    "title": "Wrong Side of the Yangtze River: Did a Map Mistake by the World Health Organization Contribute to Premature Conclusions About SARS2's Origin?", 
    "license": {
      "id": "CC-BY-3.0-US"
    }, 
    "notes": "Added: Table of first patient characteristics reported by multiple independent sources. \n\nCorrected: Error that said Peter Daszak didn't sign the Lancet letter he organized - in fact he did.\n\nKnown error: The accountant Chen from Wuchang district was not the first published COVID case: https://twitter.com/franciscodeasis/status/1397227238764990469?", 
    "relations": {
      "version": [
        {
          "count": 2, 
          "index": 1, 
          "parent": {
            "pid_type": "recid", 
            "pid_value": "5153949"
          }, 
          "is_last": true, 
          "last_child": {
            "pid_type": "recid", 
            "pid_value": "5202258"
          }
        }
      ]
    }, 
    "version": "1.0", 
    "keywords": [
      "SARS-CoV-2 origin, SARS2 origin, China, Wuhan, Wuchang district, World Health Organization"
    ], 
    "publication_date": "2021-08-14", 
    "creators": [
      {
        "name": "Chang, Whatsin Wu"
      }
    ], 
    "access_right": "open", 
    "resource_type": {
      "subtype": "article", 
      "type": "publication", 
      "title": "Journal article"
    }, 
    "related_identifiers": [
      {
        "scheme": "doi", 
        "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.5153949", 
        "relation": "isVersionOf"
      }
    ]
  }
}
3,855
1,252
views
downloads
All versions This version
Views 3,8552,390
Downloads 1,252555
Data volume 20.6 GB9.2 GB
Unique views 3,1882,023
Unique downloads 1,108506

Share

Cite as