Dataset Open Access

Manual cross-validation data for the article: "Comparison of bibliographic data sources: Implications for the robustness of university rankings"

Chloe Brookes-Kenworthy; Chun-Kai (Karl) Huang; Cameron Neylon; Katie Wilson; Alkim Ozaygen; Lucy Montgomery; Richard Hosking

These are sets of data collected from the manual cross-validation of DOIs (and related research outputs) that are sampled from Web of Science (WoS), Scopus and Microsoft Academic (MSA). For each of the 15 universities, we initially collect all DOIs indexed by each of the three bibliographic sources. Subsequently, we randomly sample 40, 30 and 30 DOIs from sets of DOIs that are exclusively indexed by WoS, Scopus and MSA, respectively, for each university. A manual cross-validation process is then followed to validate certain characteristics across the data sources. This cross-validation process was carried out by a data wrangler, on a part-time basis over a few months, for which online data was accessed from 18 December 2018 to 20 May 2019.

Files (720.8 kB)
Name Size
Documentation.docx
md5:b4fab2886de47b69925fc2908b24008e
13.7 kB Download
grid.1032.0_curtin_university.xlsx
md5:dce6b833d805378d612dd34c608edcf6
80.4 kB Download
grid.116068.8_massachusetts_institute_of_technology.xlsx
md5:b6325e4e433343b7328b2d4c08a0f5a6
27.4 kB Download
grid.11899.38_university_of_sao_paulo.xlsx
md5:a7ed38a4b691621e1b6ff3db53bcfd9a
38.3 kB Download
grid.14476.30_moscow_state_university.xlsx
md5:fecaa7ae4426eda618be884b76321919
28.0 kB Download
grid.254444.7_wayne_state_university.xlsx
md5:e4e967b930f3fab7dc0f2d7e22cbb59a
22.7 kB Download
grid.26999.3d_university_of_tokyo.xlsx
md5:130591042e2e905a3f5916938bbe50f1
27.0 kB Download
grid.30055.33_dalian_university_of_technology.xlsx
md5:ce85e3b93e4bb0a98a9bc2428c16e222
36.5 kB Download
grid.34980.36_indian_institute_of_science_bangalore.xlsx
md5:ab27cbcb515ea70613c22bf650eb4468
27.8 kB Download
grid.434933.a_institut_teknologi_bandung.xlsx
md5:92f0b8f211c6994032fc7a107d2f671b
27.2 kB Download
grid.6571.5_loughborough_university.xlsx
md5:f64245ecf6336d6d12baccf8df100a5a
95.4 kB Download
grid.7776.1_cairo_university.xlsx
md5:4b45cd96d57a6a6ddef12f6bc750992f
38.3 kB Download
grid.7836.a_university_of_cape_town.xlsx
md5:404b4c8e9de86d4967c71b9a2603415a
42.8 kB Download
grid.83440.3b_university_college_london.xlsx
md5:45986519e0972240d3dff16c65579795
27.3 kB Download
grid.8664.c_university_of_giessen.xlsx
md5:e18181fac60cfb1dd4e39eafa0f4d7d0
48.1 kB Download
grid.9486.3_national_autonomous_university_of_mexico.xlsx
md5:ca29468977f7a742a047084ace454ae4
38.6 kB Download
Manual cross-validation summary.xlsx
md5:4ef76c5a9827c34cede534902836faf3
101.0 kB Download
81
113
views
downloads
All versions This version
Views 8181
Downloads 113113
Data volume 4.7 MB4.7 MB
Unique views 7171
Unique downloads 2121

Share

Cite as