Journal article Open Access

The Understanding in Transition: Fascicles X, XI and VII of Opus postumum

Terrence Thomson

JSON Export

  "files": [
      "links": {
        "self": ""
      "checksum": "md5:889f74f14f3bf2bd5630efa28df64fb2", 
      "bucket": "3d4b0fde-3be0-409f-a6c1-38f1ef65a9d1", 
      "key": "6. CTK9 Art Terrence.pdf", 
      "type": "pdf", 
      "size": 435065
  "owners": [
  "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.3250380", 
  "stats": {
    "version_unique_downloads": 196.0, 
    "unique_views": 522.0, 
    "views": 597.0, 
    "version_views": 595.0, 
    "unique_downloads": 196.0, 
    "version_unique_views": 521.0, 
    "volume": 87448065.0, 
    "version_downloads": 201.0, 
    "downloads": 201.0, 
    "version_volume": 87448065.0
  "links": {
    "doi": "", 
    "conceptdoi": "", 
    "bucket": "", 
    "conceptbadge": "", 
    "html": "", 
    "latest_html": "", 
    "badge": "", 
    "latest": ""
  "conceptdoi": "10.5281/zenodo.3250379", 
  "created": "2019-06-19T20:45:23.969492+00:00", 
  "updated": "2020-01-20T17:30:41.578479+00:00", 
  "conceptrecid": "3250379", 
  "revision": 4, 
  "id": 3250380, 
  "metadata": {
    "access_right_category": "success", 
    "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.3250380", 
    "description": "<p>This essay investigates the transformation of the faculty of understanding in Kant&rsquo;s <em>Transition from Metaphysical Foundations of Natural Science to Physics</em> drafts found in <em>Opus postumum</em>. I argue that in fascicles X and XI Kant implicitly reverses the architectonic order of sensibility and understanding. Without an account of this reversal, Kant&rsquo;s critique of Isaac Newton&rsquo;s conception of phenomena and the so called <em>Selbstsetzungslehre</em> (doctrine of self-positing) in fascicle VII fall apart. I argue that what is at stake is a challenge Kant makes to his own presuppositions and a challenge to the Kantian philosopher who wishes to stay with a strictly &lsquo;critical&rsquo; Kant.</p>", 
    "language": "eng", 
    "title": "The Understanding in Transition: Fascicles X, XI and VII of Opus postumum", 
    "license": {
      "id": "CC-BY-4.0"
    "journal": {
      "volume": "1", 
      "issue": "9", 
      "pages": "23-48", 
      "title": "Con-Textos Kantianos. International Journal of Philosophy"
    "relations": {
      "version": [
          "count": 1, 
          "index": 0, 
          "parent": {
            "pid_type": "recid", 
            "pid_value": "3250379"
          "is_last": true, 
          "last_child": {
            "pid_type": "recid", 
            "pid_value": "3250380"
    "access_right": "open", 
    "references": [
      "Adickes, Erich. (1920), Kants Opus postumum: dargestellt und beurteilt. Berlin: Reuther and  Reichard.", 
      "Allison, Henry E. (1973), The Kant-Eberhard Controversy. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.", 
      "Basile, Giovanni Pietro. (2013), Kants Opus postumum und seine Rezeption. Berlin: Walter de  Gruyter", 
      "Beiser, Frederick. (2008), German Idealism: The Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801.  Harvard: Harvard University Press.", 
      "Bradley, F.H. (1916), Appearance and Reality: A Metaphysical Essay. London: George Allen  and Unwin.", 
      "Caygill, Howard. (2007), 'The Transition Problem in Kant's Opus postumum'. In Kant:  Making Reason Intuitive, ed. Loli Patellis, Kyriaki Goudeli, Pavlos Kontos, pp.16-27. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.", 
      "Caygill, Howard. (2005), 'The Force of Kant's Opus postumum: Kepler and Newton in the  XIth Fascicle'. Angelaki vol. 10, no.1: pp.33-42.", 
      "Deleuze, Gilles. (2008), Kant's Critical Philosophy. trans. Hugh Tomlinson and Barbara  Habberjam. London: Continuum Publishing.", 
      "Descartes, Rene. (1999), Selected Philosophical Writings. trans. John Cottingham and Robert  Stoothoff. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.", 
      "Edwards, Jeffrey. (2000), Substance, Force, and the Possibility of Knowledge: On Kant's  Philosophy of Material Nature. Berkeley: University of California Press.", 
      "Ellis, Addison. (2017), 'The Case for Absolute Spontaneity in Kant's Critique of Pure Reason'.  Con-Textos Kantianos no.6: pp.138-164.", 
      "Feyerabend, Paul K. (1985), Realism, Rationalism and Scientific Method: Philosophical  Papers Volume 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.", 
      "F\u00f6rster, Eckart. (2000), Kant's Final Synthesis: An Essay on the Opus postumum. Cambridge,  MA: Harvard University Press.", 
      "F\u04e7rster, Eckart. (1989), 'Kant's Selbstsetzungslehre'. In Kant's Transcendental Deductions:  The Three 'Critiques' and the 'Opus postumum', ed. Eckart F\u04e7rster, pp.217-238. California: Stanford University Press.", 
      "Friedman, Michael. (1994), Kant and the Exact Sciences. Cambridge, MA: Harvard  University Press.", 
      "Gardner, Sebastian. (1999), Kant and the Critique of Pure Reason. Oxon: Routledge. Hall, Bryan Wesley. (2017), The Post-Critical Kant: Understanding the Critical Philosophy  Through the Opus postumum. Oxon: Routledge.", 
      "Heidegger, Martin. (1997), Phenomenological Interpretation of Kant's Critique of Pure  Reason. trans. Parvis Emad and Kenneth Maly. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.", 
      "Hoppe, Hansgeorg. (1969), Kants Theorie der Physik: Eine Untersuchung \u00fcber das Opus  postumum von Kant. Frankfurt: Vittorio Klostermann.", 
      "Kerszberg, Pierre. (2012), 'Deduction Versus Discourse: Newton and the Cosmic Phenomena'.  Foundations of Science vol.18, no.3: pp.529-44.", 
      "Koyr\u00e9, Alexandre. (1965), Newtonian Studies. London: Chapman and Hall.", 
      "Kuhn, Thomas S. (2012), The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: Chicago University  Press.", 
      "Lambert, Johann. (2009), 'New Organon'. In Kant's Critique of Pure Reason: Background  Source Materials, eds. Eric Watkins and Manfred Kuehn, pp.257-274. Cambridge:  Cambridge University Press.", 
      "Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. (1989), Philosophical Essays. trans. Roger Ariew and Daniel  Garbor. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing.", 
      "Lehmann, Gerhard. (1969), Beitr\u00e4ge zur Geschichte und Interpretation der Philosophie Kants.  Berlin: Walter de Gruyter", 
      "Lichtenberg, Georg Christoph. (2012), Philosophical Writings. trans and ed. Steven Tester.  New York: State University of New York Press.", 
      "Locke, John. (1995), An Essay Concerning Human Understanding. New York: Prometheus  Books.", 
      "Martin, Gottfried. (1974), Kant's Metaphysics and Theory of Science. trans. P.G. Lucas.  Connecticut: Greenwood Press.", 
      "Massimi, Michela. (2018), 'Grounds, Modality, and Nomic Necessity in the Critical Kant.' In  Kant and the Laws of Nature, ed. Michela Massimi and Angela Breitenbach, pp.150-70. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press", 
      "Maxwell, Nicholas. (2017), In Praise of Natural Philosophy. Montreal: McGill-Queen's  University Press.", 
      "McDowell, John. (1996), Mind and World. Harvard: Harvard University Press.", 
      "Newton, Isaac. (1999), The Principia: Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy. trans.  I.Bernard Cohen and Anne Whitman. California: University of California Press.", 
      "Smith, Norman Kemp. (1992), Commentary to Kant's Critique of Pure Reason. Atlantic  Highlands: Humanities Press International", 
      "Sng, Zachary. (2010), The Rhetoric of Error from Locke to Kleist. Stanford: Stanford  University Press.", 
      "Tuschling, Burkhard. (1993), 'The Concept of Transcendental Idealism in Kant's Opus  postumum'. In Kant and Critique: New Essays in Honour of W.H. Werkmeister, ed.  R.M. Dancy, pp.151-167. Netherlands: Springer.", 
      "Tuschling, Burkhard. (1989), 'Apperception and Ether: On the Idea of a Transcendental  Deduction of Matter in Kant's Opus postumum'. In Kant's Transcendental Deductions: The Three 'Critiques' and the 'Opus postumum', ed. Eckart F\u04e7rster, pp.193-217. California: Stanford University Press.", 
      "Tuschling, Burkhard. (1971), Metaphysische und Transzendentale Dynamik in Kants Opus  postumum. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.", 
      "Werkmeister, W.H. (1980), Kant: the Architectonic and Development of His Philosophy.  Illinois: Open court."
    "keywords": [
      "natural science", 
    "publication_date": "2019-06-19", 
    "creators": [
        "affiliation": "CRMEP, Kingston University", 
        "name": "Terrence Thomson"
    "notes": "PhD candidate at the Centre for Research in Modern European Philosophy, Kingston University, London", 
    "resource_type": {
      "subtype": "article", 
      "type": "publication", 
      "title": "Journal article"
    "related_identifiers": [
        "scheme": "doi", 
        "identifier": "10.5281/zenodo.3250379", 
        "relation": "isVersionOf"
All versions This version
Views 595597
Downloads 201201
Data volume 87.4 MB87.4 MB
Unique views 521522
Unique downloads 196196


Cite as