Journal article Open Access

Escaping ethnocentrism in the study of word-class universals

Haspelmath, Martin

This paper discusses Sandra Chung's claim (in the same journal) that Chamorro has the three major word-classes (lexical categories) noun, verb, adjective after all, despite earlier claims that it distinguishes between Class I and Class II words. I note that there are several different ways in which Chamorro major-class words can be classified, and that there is no a priori reason for favouring one over the others. Chung's argument that Chamorro's word-classes are like English word-classes thus runs the risk of ethnocentrism. While it is true that Chamorro can be seen to have the same word-classes as English, English could equally well be seen to have the two classes that were earlier posited for Chamorro (Class I and Class II).

Files (418.3 kB)
Name Size
Comment_on_Chung.pdf
md5:a5fd5549cc52dd79b0cd44365a463e09
157.9 kB Download
Haspelmath2012_on_Chung.pdf
md5:77bd2fb4158479d614cf26dc12ee7bcb
260.5 kB Download
122
129
views
downloads
All versions This version
Views 12298
Downloads 12976
Data volume 21.1 MB12.7 MB
Unique views 11696
Unique downloads 12272

Share

Cite as