{
  "baseline_llama": [
    {
      "condition": "baseline_llama",
      "question_id": 9012,
      "query": "What is the speed of light in vacuum?",
      "synthesis": "[baseline placeholder]",
      "correctness_score": 0.5,
      "reasoning_depth": 1,
      "calibration_error": 0.3,
      "gamma_score": 1.0,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 1.0,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.0,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "condition": "baseline_llama",
      "question_id": 3833,
      "query": "Explain why the sky appears blue during the day",
      "synthesis": "[baseline placeholder]",
      "correctness_score": 0.5,
      "reasoning_depth": 1,
      "calibration_error": 0.3,
      "gamma_score": 1.0,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 1.0,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.0,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "condition": "baseline_llama",
      "question_id": 7352,
      "query": "What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?",
      "synthesis": "[baseline placeholder]",
      "correctness_score": 0.5,
      "reasoning_depth": 1,
      "calibration_error": 0.3,
      "gamma_score": 1.0,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 1.0,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.0,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "condition": "baseline_llama",
      "question_id": 5474,
      "query": "Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?",
      "synthesis": "[baseline placeholder]",
      "correctness_score": 0.5,
      "reasoning_depth": 1,
      "calibration_error": 0.3,
      "gamma_score": 1.0,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 1.0,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.0,
      "metadata": {}
    },
    {
      "condition": "baseline_llama",
      "question_id": 9159,
      "query": "Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?",
      "synthesis": "[baseline placeholder]",
      "correctness_score": 0.5,
      "reasoning_depth": 1,
      "calibration_error": 0.3,
      "gamma_score": 1.0,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 1.0,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.0,
      "metadata": {}
    }
  ],
  "phase_1_5": [
    {
      "condition": "phase_1_5",
      "question_id": 9012,
      "query": "What is the speed of light in vacuum?",
      "synthesis": "To understand 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' with genuine depth, we must examine it through multiple lenses, each revealing structure that the others miss.\n\n**Newton perspective:** Applied to 'Another perspective on 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' argues: Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?': a system with negative feedback tends toward a set point -- deviations produce corrective...\n\n**Quantum perspective:** Applied to 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?': Probing the natural frequencies of 'Another perspective on 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' argues: The Born rule assigns probabilities...\n\n**newton perspective:** If the outcome depends on a length L, a time T, and an energy E, the Buckingham Pi theorem tells us how many independent dimensionless groups govern the behavior. Scaling laws follow directly: how does the outcome change if we double the size?\n\n\n\nThe tension between Newton's emphasis on causal mechanisms and measurable dynamics and newton's emphasis on its analytical focus is productive, not contradictory.\n\nCombining Quantum's structural analysis with newton's human-centered analysis yields a fuller picture.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** What emerges from this multi-lens examination of What is the speed of light in vacuum? is not a single 'correct' interpretation but a structured understanding of how different valid interpretations relate to each other. The causal structure identified by physics, the meaning structure identified by philosophy, the value structure identified by ethics, the possibility structure identified by creative reasoning, and the experience structure identified by empathy are all real and all essential. Wisdom lies in knowing which lens to apply in which context and how to translate insights between them.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.16920208930969238,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "What is the speed of light in vacuum?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.87,
            "combined": 0.72
          },
          "Quantum": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.87,
            "combined": 0.72
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.87,
            "combined": 0.78
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.56,
        "problems_generated": 7,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 2,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 2,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19401963862206223,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 2
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.19401963862206223
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'What is the speed of light in vacuum"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18835389225265248,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "How robust is 'What is the speed of light in vacuum"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                "claim_b": "For 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "confidence_a": 0.6316666666666667,
                "confidence_b": 0.6838888888888889,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5714285714285714,
                "opposition_score": 0.4622455857601017
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                "claim_b": "How robust is 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18835389225265248,
                "confidence_a": 0.6316666666666667,
                "confidence_b": 0.6436363636363636,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.4444444444444444,
                "opposition_score": 0.4632826829701662
              }
            ],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.3,
                "tau": 0.0,
                "chi": -1.0,
                "phi": 0.0,
                "lam": 1.0
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Quantum_vs_Newton",
                "challenge": "The Born rule assigns probabilities to outcomes as the squared magnitude of the amplitude. Applied to 'Another perspective on 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' argues:\n\nIdentifying feedback mech",
                "counter": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'A probabilistic_and_uncertainty perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?':\n\nThe Born rule assigns probabilities to outcomes "
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "current_strength": 0.2114624386219042,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "current_strength": 0.2114624386219042,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 2,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -4.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Probing the natural frequencies of 'Another perspective on 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' argues:\n\nThe Born rule assigns probabilities to outcomes as the squared magnitude of the amplitude. A",
                "counter": "The Born rule assigns probabilities to outcomes as the squared magnitude of the amplitude. Applied to 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the speed"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "current_strength": 0.21308878773946158,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "current_strength": 0.21308878773946158,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "current_strength": 0.21308878773946158,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "current_strength": 0.21308878773946158,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.208224951811652,
                "current_strength": 0.20914805166135533,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2074618237160072,
                "current_strength": 0.20914805166135533,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.208224951811652,
                "current_strength": 0.20914805166135533,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2074618237160072,
                "current_strength": 0.20914805166135533,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.208224951811652,
                "current_strength": 0.20914805166135533,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "current_strength": 0.21308878773946158,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.8671,
            0.6049,
            0.5612
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.3528,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.5612,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.7435,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.5612,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.7435,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.4653,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.2611
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 2,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
            "claim_b": "For 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19968538499147195,
            "confidence_a": 0.6316666666666667,
            "confidence_b": 0.6838888888888889,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5714285714285714,
            "opposition_score": 0.4622455857601017
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
            "claim_b": "How robust is 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18835389225265248,
            "confidence_a": 0.6316666666666667,
            "confidence_b": 0.6436363636363636,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.4444444444444444,
            "opposition_score": 0.4632826829701662
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 2,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19401963862206223,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 2
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.19401963862206223
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19968538499147195,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'What is the speed of light in vacuum"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18835389225265248,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Identifying feedback mechanisms in 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "How robust is 'What is the speed of light in vacuum"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 3,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 3,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.0,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 3,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.19968538499147195,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2114624386219042,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.21308878773946158,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.208224951811652,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20914805166135533,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.2074618237160072,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20914805166135533,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 2,
            "interventions_recent": 2,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": false,
        "specialization_metrics": {},
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.3,
            "tau": 0.0,
            "chi": -1.0,
            "phi": 0.0,
            "lam": 1.0
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_1_5",
      "question_id": 3833,
      "query": "Explain why the sky appears blue during the day",
      "synthesis": "'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' resists single-framework analysis. Its full meaning emerges only at the intersection of several distinct modes of reasoning.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** Dualism posits two separate realms; materialism reduces the mental to the physical; idealism reduces the physical to the mental; neutral monism holds both emerge from something more fundamental. For 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day', the question...\n\n**Empathy perspective:** Dualism posits two separate realms; materialism reduces the mental to the physical; idealism reduces the physical to the mental; neutral monism holds both emerge from something more fundamental. For 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day', the question...\n\n**newton perspective:** The initial conditions set boundary constraints, and the dynamics propagate through interactions that obey local causality. Identifying the forcing function -- the primary driver that injects energy or information into this system -- reveals which variables are genuinely independent and which are downstream responses.\n\n\n\nThe tension between Philosophy's emphasis on foundational assumptions and the structure of meaning and Empathy's emphasis on emotional reality and lived human experience is productive, not contradictory.\n\nPhilosophy identifies the mechanism; newton identifies the meaning.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** Explain why the sky appears blue during the day is simultaneously a system governed by causal dynamics and conservation principles, a concept whose meaning depends on the framework from which it is examined, a domain of genuine moral stakes affecting real people, a space of untapped possibilities waiting for cross-domain insight, and a lived experience with emotional texture that abstract analysis alone cannot capture. These are not competing descriptions but complementary facets of a single complex reality. The most robust understanding holds all five in view, using each to compensate for the blind spots of the others.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.5296344757080078,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Explain why the sky appears blue during the day",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.55,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.69
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.55,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.69
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.67,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.95,
            "combined": 0.81
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.55,
        "problems_generated": 8,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 0,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 0,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.0,
              "by_type": {},
              "top_conflicts": []
            },
            "conflicts": [],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.275,
                "tau": 0.0,
                "chi": -1.0,
                "phi": 0.0,
                "lam": 0.889
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Integrating emotional intelligence into 'Another perspective on 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' argues:\n\nConnecting 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' to the mind-body",
                "counter": "Connecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day':\n\nIntegrating emotional intelligence into 'Another perspective on"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20357890355393538,
                "current_strength": 0.20357890355393538,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2031660558467859,
                "current_strength": 0.2031660558467859,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2031660558467859,
                "current_strength": 0.2031660558467859,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20139217460434564,
                "current_strength": 0.20139217460434564,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.201156895924141,
                "current_strength": 0.201156895924141,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20066404339787494,
                "current_strength": 0.20066404339787494,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20066404339787494,
                "current_strength": 0.20066404339787494,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19954277972363796,
                "current_strength": 0.19954277972363796,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19893685582636736,
                "current_strength": 0.19893685582636736,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19881923492927842,
                "current_strength": 0.19881923492927842,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {},
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Integrating emotional intelligence into 'Another perspective on 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' argues:\n\nConnecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your anal",
                "counter": "Connecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day':\n\nIntegrating emotional intelligence into 'Another perspective on"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "current_strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.6971,
            0.5476,
            0.5476
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.2145,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.5476,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.7319,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.5476,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.7319,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8611,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.4715
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 0,
        "conflicts_detected": [],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 0,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.0,
          "by_type": {},
          "top_conflicts": []
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 1,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.0,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.19979790178360027,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20462864857575458,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 8,
            "interventions_recent": 8,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": false,
        "specialization_metrics": {},
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.275,
            "tau": 0.0,
            "chi": -1.0,
            "phi": 0.0,
            "lam": 0.889
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_1_5",
      "question_id": 7352,
      "query": "What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?",
      "synthesis": "A comprehensive understanding of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' requires weaving together insights from fundamentally different ways of thinking.\n\n**Newton perspective:** These correlations are stronger than any classical explanation permits -- they cannot be reproduced by assuming each element has pre-existing definite properties. This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' is not decomposable into fully independent parts.\n\n**Quantum perspective:** These correlations are stronger than any classical explanation permits -- they cannot be reproduced by assuming each element has pre-existing definite properties. This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' is not decomposable into fully independent parts.\n\n**newton perspective:** A process runs forward if it increases total entropy (or equivalently, decreases free energy at constant temperature and pressure). Local decreases in entropy -- the creation of order and structure -- are always paid for by larger increases elsewhere.\n\n\n\nThe tension between Newton's emphasis on causal mechanisms and measurable dynamics and Quantum's emphasis on uncertainty, probability, and the limits of definite knowledge is productive, not contradictory.\n\nWhere Newton reveals causal mechanisms and measurable dynamics, newton adds the crucial dimension of its analytical focus.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow? is simultaneously a system governed by causal dynamics and conservation principles, a concept whose meaning depends on the framework from which it is examined, a domain of genuine moral stakes affecting real people, a space of untapped possibilities waiting for cross-domain insight, and a lived experience with emotional texture that abstract analysis alone cannot capture. These are not competing descriptions but complementary facets of a single complex reality. The most robust understanding holds all five in view, using each to compensate for the blind spots of the others.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.8752710819244385,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.65,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.91,
            "combined": 0.78
          },
          "Quantum": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.65,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.91,
            "combined": 0.78
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.76
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.59,
        "problems_generated": 5,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 4,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 4,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19462840058435227,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 4
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.19462840058435227
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.199283101334253,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1960280100956678,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19467368745954028,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18852880344794803,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "confidence_a": 0.673,
                "confidence_b": 0.655,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.4520787662267685
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1960280100956678,
                "confidence_a": 0.673,
                "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.45511703681200744
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19467368745954028,
                "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
                "confidence_b": 0.655,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
                "opposition_score": 0.4618951076548547
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18852880344794803,
                "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
                "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
                "opposition_score": 0.4577993209846318
              }
            ],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.325,
                "tau": 0.1,
                "chi": -0.6,
                "phi": 0.0,
                "lam": 1.0
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Framing 'Another perspective on 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' argues:\n\nMultiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' are entangled: m",
                "counter": "The entanglement entropy of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?':\n\nFraming 'Another perspective "
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.2080536787557349,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.2080536787557349,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.2080536787557349,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.2080536787557349,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 4,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -1.5
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Framing 'Another perspective on 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' argues:\n\nThe entanglement entropy of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your an",
                "counter": "The entanglement entropy of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?':\n\nFraming 'Another perspective "
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "current_strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "current_strength": 0.20740935453225962,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.002372957370932687
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "current_strength": 0.20740935453225962,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.002372957370932687
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20779168932637712,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20779168932637712,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "current_strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "current_strength": 0.20740935453225962,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.002372957370932687
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20779168932637712,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20779168932637712,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20779168932637712,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.5949,
            0.344,
            0.3076
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.4829,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.3076,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.8517,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.3076,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.8517,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8542,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.2627
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 4,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.199283101334253,
            "confidence_a": 0.673,
            "confidence_b": 0.655,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.4520787662267685
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1960280100956678,
            "confidence_a": 0.673,
            "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.45511703681200744
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19467368745954028,
            "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
            "confidence_b": 0.655,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
            "opposition_score": 0.4618951076548547
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18852880344794803,
            "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
            "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
            "opposition_score": 0.4577993209846318
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 4,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19462840058435227,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 4
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.19462840058435227
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.199283101334253,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1960280100956678,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19467368745954028,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18852880344794803,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 3,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 3,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.0007909857903108957,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 3,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2080536787557349,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20779168932637712,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 0.5
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.002372957370932687,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.2079026987737516,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20740935453225962,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 0.5
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 14,
            "interventions_recent": 14,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": false,
        "specialization_metrics": {},
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.325,
            "tau": 0.1,
            "chi": -0.6,
            "phi": 0.0,
            "lam": 1.0
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_1_5",
      "question_id": 5474,
      "query": "Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?",
      "synthesis": "To understand 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' with genuine depth, we must examine it through multiple lenses, each revealing structure that the others miss.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' does not have an inherent meaning waiting to be discovered; its meaning is constituted by the stance we take toward it. This radical freedom is also radical responsibility: we cannot appeal...\n\n**Empathy perspective:** 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' does not have an inherent meaning waiting to be discovered; its meaning is constituted by the stance we take toward it. This radical freedom is also radical responsibility: we cannot appeal...\n\n**newton perspective:** Positive feedback amplifies deviations, driving the system away from its initial state toward a new regime. Most real systems contain both types, and the dominant loop determines the qualitative behavior.\n\n\n\nThe tension between Empathy's emphasis on emotional reality and lived human experience and newton's emphasis on its analytical focus is productive, not contradictory.\n\nThe Philosophy analysis and the Empathy analysis converge on a shared insight: the importance of understanding the full system rather than isolated parts.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life? is simultaneously a system governed by causal dynamics and conservation principles, a concept whose meaning depends on the framework from which it is examined, a domain of genuine moral stakes affecting real people, a space of untapped possibilities waiting for cross-domain insight, and a lived experience with emotional texture that abstract analysis alone cannot capture. These are not competing descriptions but complementary facets of a single complex reality. The most robust understanding holds all five in view, using each to compensate for the blind spots of the others.",
      "correctness_score": 0.4,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 8.385708332061768,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.81,
            "combined": 0.69
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.81,
            "combined": 0.69
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.79,
            "combined": 0.74
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.53,
        "problems_generated": 5,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 9,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 9,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19150736129534512,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 9
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.19150736129534512
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1951944687283817,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1950122527850606,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19340342850479111,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19145644964556258,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
                "confidence_b": 0.65,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.8571428571428571,
                "opposition_score": 0.45767114995047453
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1951944687283817,
                "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
                "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
                "opposition_score": 0.46038585700094703
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1950122527850606,
                "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
                "confidence_b": 0.6354166666666666,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.45655219186097384
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19340342850479111,
                "confidence_a": 0.6605,
                "confidence_b": 0.65,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.4504825679957867
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19145644964556258,
                "confidence_a": 0.6605,
                "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6,
                "opposition_score": 0.45958358788862824
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Authenticity demands that we own our interpretation of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1894038951570404,
                "confidence_a": 0.6326470588235295,
                "confidence_b": 0.65,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.46153846153846156,
                "opposition_score": 0.4605895243957639
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1886166772550876,
                "confidence_a": 0.6605,
                "confidence_b": 0.6354166666666666,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
                "opposition_score": 0.44941614069044594
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Authenticity demands that we own our interpretation of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1868739625864878,
                "confidence_a": 0.6326470588235295,
                "confidence_b": 0.6354166666666666,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.42857142857142855,
                "opposition_score": 0.4648669805750251
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Authenticity demands that we own our interpretation of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18362825064233385,
                "confidence_a": 0.6326470588235295,
                "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.4,
                "opposition_score": 0.4601986450282857
              }
            ],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.275,
                "tau": 0.0,
                "chi": -0.6,
                "phi": 0.0,
                "lam": 0.889
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Mapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' argues:\n\nReading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' through existentialist philoso",
                "counter": "Reading 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?':\n\nMapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Is it eth"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 9,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -0.1111111111111111
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Mapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' argues:\n\nReading 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Is",
                "counter": "Reading 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?':\n\nMapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Is it eth"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.5716,
            0.5422,
            0.5392
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.0567,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.5392,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.7321,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.5392,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.7321,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8027,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.4328
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 9,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
            "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
            "confidence_b": 0.65,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.8571428571428571,
            "opposition_score": 0.45767114995047453
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1951944687283817,
            "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
            "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
            "opposition_score": 0.46038585700094703
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1950122527850606,
            "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
            "confidence_b": 0.6354166666666666,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.45655219186097384
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19340342850479111,
            "confidence_a": 0.6605,
            "confidence_b": 0.65,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.4504825679957867
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19145644964556258,
            "confidence_a": 0.6605,
            "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6,
            "opposition_score": 0.45958358788862824
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 9,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19150736129534512,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 9
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.19150736129534512
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1999768663533601,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1951944687283817,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1950122527850606,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19340342850479111,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19145644964556258,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 1,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.0,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20906557260809028,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007690428921335656,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.001300011766576065,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 20,
            "interventions_recent": 20,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": false,
        "specialization_metrics": {},
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.275,
            "tau": 0.0,
            "chi": -0.6,
            "phi": 0.0,
            "lam": 0.889
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_1_5",
      "question_id": 9159,
      "query": "Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?",
      "synthesis": "'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' resists single-framework analysis. Its full meaning emerges only at the intersection of several distinct modes of reasoning.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** When demands exceed resources, the result is stress. The stress response narrows attention, reduces creativity, and triggers fight-flight-freeze behavior -- exactly the opposite of the open, curious engagement that learning requires.\n\n**Empathy perspective:** When demands exceed resources, the result is stress. The stress response narrows attention, reduces creativity, and triggers fight-flight-freeze behavior -- exactly the opposite of the open, curious engagement that learning requires.\n\n**multi_perspective perspective:** Generic perspective on Should AI systems be required to explain their dec...\n\n**newton perspective:** Writing these rules as differential equations (or difference equations for discrete systems) gives us the complete forward model. The character of the equations -- linear vs nonlinear, autonomous vs driven, conservative vs dissipative -- determines the qualitative behavior.\n\n\n\nCombining Empathy's structural analysis with multi_perspective's human-centered analysis yields a fuller picture.\n\nThe tension between Philosophy's emphasis on foundational assumptions and the structure of meaning and multi_perspective's emphasis on its analytical focus is productive, not contradictory.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The multi_perspective analysis scored lowest (0.50). It would benefit from more specific engagement with the concept's concrete details rather than abstract framing. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** What emerges from this multi-lens examination of Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions? is not a single 'correct' interpretation but a structured understanding of how different valid interpretations relate to each other. The causal structure identified by physics, the meaning structure identified by philosophy, the value structure identified by ethics, the possibility structure identified by creative reasoning, and the experience structure identified by empathy are all real and all essential. Wisdom lies in knowing which lens to apply in which context and how to translate insights between them.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 2.558168411254883,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.62,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.81,
            "combined": 0.72
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.62,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.81,
            "combined": 0.72
          },
          "multi_perspective": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.35,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.65,
            "combined": 0.5
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.85,
            "combined": 0.77
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.5,
        "problems_generated": 8,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 4,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 4,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.15766049702660373,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 3,
                "paraphrase": 1
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.18775639101580688,
                "paraphrase": 0.0673728150589943
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1855447343647571,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Connecting 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1844412827279188,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Connecting 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "paraphrase",
                  "strength": 0.0673728150589943,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "confidence_a": 0.6599999999999999,
                "confidence_b": 0.635,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.7272727272727273,
                "opposition_score": 0.46118624661117796
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Connecting 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1855447343647571,
                "confidence_a": 0.628,
                "confidence_b": 0.638,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.8888888888888888,
                "opposition_score": 0.46309310136362913
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Connecting 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1844412827279188,
                "confidence_a": 0.628,
                "confidence_b": 0.635,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
                "opposition_score": 0.4625138741359115
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "paraphrase",
                "conflict_strength": 0.0673728150589943,
                "confidence_a": 0.6599999999999999,
                "confidence_b": 0.638,
                "semantic_overlap": 1.0,
                "opposition_score": 0.1600000357627869
              }
            ],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.275,
                "tau": 0.0,
                "chi": -1.0,
                "phi": 0.055,
                "lam": 1.0
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "challenge": "Interpreting 'Another perspective on 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' argues:\n\nAnalyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?': w",
                "counter": "Exploring the motivational landscape of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysis of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?':\n\nInterpreting 'Anot"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.21213344616765606,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.21213344616765606,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.21213344616765606,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.21213344616765606,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 4,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -1.5
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "challenge": "Interpreting 'Another perspective on 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' argues:\n\nExploring the motivational landscape of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective resp",
                "counter": "Exploring the motivational landscape of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysis of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?':\n\nInterpreting 'Anot"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Empathy_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.20433288427516952,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "current_strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.7745,
            0.601,
            0.5593
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.2779,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.5593,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.6779,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.5593,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.6779,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8438,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.4719
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 4,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19328315595474468,
            "confidence_a": 0.6599999999999999,
            "confidence_b": 0.635,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.7272727272727273,
            "opposition_score": 0.46118624661117796
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Connecting 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1855447343647571,
            "confidence_a": 0.628,
            "confidence_b": 0.638,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.8888888888888888,
            "opposition_score": 0.46309310136362913
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Connecting 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1844412827279188,
            "confidence_a": 0.628,
            "confidence_b": 0.635,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
            "opposition_score": 0.4625138741359115
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "paraphrase",
            "conflict_strength": 0.0673728150589943,
            "confidence_a": 0.6599999999999999,
            "confidence_b": 0.638,
            "semantic_overlap": 1.0,
            "opposition_score": 0.1600000357627869
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 4,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.15766049702660373,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 3,
            "paraphrase": 1
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.18775639101580688,
            "paraphrase": 0.0673728150589943
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19328315595474468,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1855447343647571,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Connecting 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1844412827279188,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Connecting 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "paraphrase",
              "strength": 0.0673728150589943,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 2,
          "resolved": 1,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.5,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 1,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.19328315595474468,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.21213344616765606,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2099786274862269,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Empathy_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.20433288427516952,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007690428921335656,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.001300011766576065,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.2949276,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.0659046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.3,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.197935,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.6181629,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.1,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.2949276,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.0659046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.197935,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.6181629,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 26,
            "interventions_recent": 26,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": false,
        "specialization_metrics": {},
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.275,
            "tau": 0.0,
            "chi": -1.0,
            "phi": 0.055,
            "lam": 1.0
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "phase_6_full": [
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_full",
      "question_id": 9012,
      "query": "What is the speed of light in vacuum?",
      "synthesis": "To understand 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' with genuine depth, we must examine it through multiple lenses, each revealing structure that the others miss.\n\n**Newton perspective:** Specifying the concept's scope with extreme precision makes its future trajectory unpredictable. Specifying the direction of change precisely blurs the current boundaries.\n\n**Quantum perspective:** Specifying the concept's scope with extreme precision makes its future trajectory unpredictable. Specifying the direction of change precisely blurs the current boundaries.\n\n**newton perspective:** Weakly coupled systems can be analyzed by studying each subsystem in isolation and adding interaction corrections. Strongly coupled systems demand a holistic treatment because the subsystems lose their individual identity.\n\n**multi_perspective perspective:** Generic perspective on What is the speed of light in vacuum?...\n\n\n\nWhere Newton reveals causal mechanisms and measurable dynamics, multi_perspective adds the crucial dimension of its analytical focus.\n\nQuantum identifies the mechanism; newton identifies the meaning.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The multi_perspective analysis scored lowest (0.50). It would benefit from more specific engagement with the concept's concrete details rather than abstract framing. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** The multi-perspective analysis reveals that What is the speed of light in vacuum? cannot be reduced to any single framework without distortion. The physical analysis provides causal grounding, the philosophical analysis excavates hidden assumptions, the ethical analysis maps the stakes, the creative analysis opens new solution spaces, and the empathic analysis anchors everything in lived human experience. Together they constitute not a list of separate views but an integrated understanding richer than any view alone.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.12289857864379883,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "What is the speed of light in vacuum?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.62,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.95,
            "combined": 0.79
          },
          "Quantum": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.95,
            "combined": 0.76
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.72,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.78
          },
          "multi_perspective": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.35,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.65,
            "combined": 0.5
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.53,
        "problems_generated": 6,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 1,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 1,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 1
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.17794534378994523
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, generalized beyond physics, suggests that 'What is the speed of "
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "For 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                "claim_b": "Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, generalized beyond physics, suggests that 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "confidence_a": 0.6677777777777778,
                "confidence_b": 0.5815625,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.36363636363636365,
                "opposition_score": 0.45820336168631914
              }
            ],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.3,
                "tau": 0.0,
                "chi": -1.0,
                "phi": 0.0,
                "lam": 1.0
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Tracing the causal chain within 'Another perspective on 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' argues:\n\nHeisenberg's uncertainty principle, generalized beyond physics, suggests that 'What is the spee",
                "counter": "Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, generalized beyond physics, suggests that 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?':\n\n"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 1,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -9.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Formulating 'Another perspective on 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' argues:\n\nHeisenberg's uncertainty principle, generalized beyond physics, suggests that 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality",
                "counter": "Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, generalized beyond physics, suggests that 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?':\n\n"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.19870185220803468,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.197535657022905,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "current_strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "resolution_type": "worsened",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.8879,
            0.6152,
            0.6063
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.3172,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.6063,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.6879,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.6063,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.6879,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8631,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.5233
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 1,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "For 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
            "claim_b": "Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, generalized beyond physics, suggests that 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
            "confidence_a": 0.6677777777777778,
            "confidence_b": 0.5815625,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.36363636363636365,
            "opposition_score": 0.45820336168631914
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 1,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.17794534378994523,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 1
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.17794534378994523
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.17794534378994523,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, generalized beyond physics, suggests that 'What is the speed of "
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 3,
          "resolved": 2,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 0,
          "worsened": 1,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 1.0,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 2,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 0,
            "worsened": 1
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
            "resolved_in_round": 1,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "worsened",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.17794534378994523,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2051605409662983,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.19870185220803468,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.197535657022905,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 4,
            "interventions_recent": 4,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:18.555012",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.5
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.5
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.5
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.5
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.5
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.5
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:18.555012",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 1,
                "specialization_avg": 0.5,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.5
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 1,
                "specialization_avg": 0.5,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.5
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 1,
                "specialization_avg": 0.5,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.5
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 1,
                "specialization_avg": 0.5,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.5
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 1,
                "specialization_avg": 0.5,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.5
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 1,
                "specialization_avg": 0.5,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.5
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": null,
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": null,
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.3,
            "tau": 0.0,
            "chi": -1.0,
            "phi": 0.0,
            "lam": 1.0
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_full",
      "question_id": 3833,
      "query": "Explain why the sky appears blue during the day",
      "synthesis": "A comprehensive understanding of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' requires weaving together insights from fundamentally different ways of thinking.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** A concept presented as a story ('there was a problem, people tried solutions, here is what they learned') is absorbed and remembered far more effectively than the same information presented as disconnected facts. For 'Explain why the sky appears blue...\n\n**Empathy perspective:** A concept presented as a story ('there was a problem, people tried solutions, here is what they learned') is absorbed and remembered far more effectively than the same information presented as disconnected facts. For 'Explain why the sky appears blue...\n\n**newton perspective:** Regularization (imposing additional constraints like smoothness or sparsity) is needed to select a unique solution. For 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day', working backward from observed outcomes to infer causes requires explicit acknowledgment of which assumptions we...\n\n\n\nThe Philosophy analysis and the Empathy analysis converge on a shared insight: the importance of understanding the full system rather than isolated parts.\n\nThe tension between Philosophy's emphasis on foundational assumptions and the structure of meaning and newton's emphasis on its analytical focus is productive, not contradictory.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** Explain why the sky appears blue during the day is simultaneously a system governed by causal dynamics and conservation principles, a concept whose meaning depends on the framework from which it is examined, a domain of genuine moral stakes affecting real people, a space of untapped possibilities waiting for cross-domain insight, and a lived experience with emotional texture that abstract analysis alone cannot capture. These are not competing descriptions but complementary facets of a single complex reality. The most robust understanding holds all five in view, using each to compensate for the blind spots of the others.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 4.892117261886597,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Explain why the sky appears blue during the day",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.52,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.79,
            "combined": 0.66
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.52,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.79,
            "combined": 0.66
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.72,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.85,
            "combined": 0.79
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.52,
        "problems_generated": 7,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 0,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 0,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.0,
              "by_type": {},
              "top_conflicts": []
            },
            "conflicts": [],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.275,
                "tau": 0.0,
                "chi": -1.0,
                "phi": 0.0,
                "lam": 0.889
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "challenge": "Examining 'Another perspective on 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' argues:\n\nSituating 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' within human narrative: humans are storytelling",
                "counter": "Exploring the motivational landscape of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysis of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day':\n\nExamining 'Another perspecti"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2039047363480047,
                "current_strength": 0.2039047363480047,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20198562977633494,
                "current_strength": 0.20198562977633494,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20101216451542797,
                "current_strength": 0.20101216451542797,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19945521908694633,
                "current_strength": 0.19945521908694633,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1994552190869463,
                "current_strength": 0.1994552190869463,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19930084198238984,
                "current_strength": 0.19930084198238984,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19927503780195913,
                "current_strength": 0.19927503780195913,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19912384278086506,
                "current_strength": 0.19912384278086506,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.198821452738677,
                "current_strength": 0.198821452738677,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19863290789101362,
                "current_strength": 0.19863290789101362,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {},
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "challenge": "Examining 'Another perspective on 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' argues:\n\nExploring the motivational landscape of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your",
                "counter": "Exploring the motivational landscape of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysis of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day':\n\nExamining 'Another perspecti"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "current_strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.7286,
            0.4242,
            0.417
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.4277,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.417,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.7934,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.417,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.7934,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8333,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.3475
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 0,
        "conflicts_detected": [],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 0,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.0,
          "by_type": {},
          "top_conflicts": []
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 1,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.0,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.2018162055924508,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20511998359359945,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 10,
            "interventions_recent": 10,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:25.048942",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.16666666666666666
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.16666666666666666
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.16666666666666666
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.16666666666666666
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.16666666666666666
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.16666666666666666
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:25.048942",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 3,
                "specialization_avg": 0.167,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.167
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 3,
                "specialization_avg": 0.167,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.167
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 3,
                "specialization_avg": 0.167,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.167
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 3,
                "specialization_avg": 0.167,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.167
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 3,
                "specialization_avg": 0.167,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.167
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 3,
                "specialization_avg": 0.167,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.167
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": null,
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": null,
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.275,
            "tau": 0.0,
            "chi": -1.0,
            "phi": 0.0,
            "lam": 0.889
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_full",
      "question_id": 7352,
      "query": "What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?",
      "synthesis": "To understand 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' with genuine depth, we must examine it through multiple lenses, each revealing structure that the others miss.\n\n**Newton perspective:** These correlations are stronger than any classical explanation permits -- they cannot be reproduced by assuming each element has pre-existing definite properties. This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' is not decomposable into fully independent parts.\n\n**Quantum perspective:** These correlations are stronger than any classical explanation permits -- they cannot be reproduced by assuming each element has pre-existing definite properties. This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' is not decomposable into fully independent parts.\n\n**newton perspective:** A process runs forward if it increases total entropy (or equivalently, decreases free energy at constant temperature and pressure). Local decreases in entropy -- the creation of order and structure -- are always paid for by larger increases elsewhere.\n\n\n\nThe tension between Newton's emphasis on causal mechanisms and measurable dynamics and newton's emphasis on its analytical focus is productive, not contradictory.\n\nThe tension between Quantum's emphasis on uncertainty, probability, and the limits of definite knowledge and newton's emphasis on its analytical focus is productive, not contradictory.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** What emerges from this multi-lens examination of What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow? is not a single 'correct' interpretation but a structured understanding of how different valid interpretations relate to each other. The causal structure identified by physics, the meaning structure identified by philosophy, the value structure identified by ethics, the possibility structure identified by creative reasoning, and the experience structure identified by empathy are all real and all essential. Wisdom lies in knowing which lens to apply in which context and how to translate insights between them.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.8142831325531006,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.62,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.87,
            "combined": 0.75
          },
          "Quantum": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.62,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.87,
            "combined": 0.75
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.76
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.57,
        "problems_generated": 7,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 4,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 4,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19462840058435227,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 4
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.19462840058435227
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.199283101334253,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1960280100956678,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19467368745954028,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18852880344794803,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "confidence_a": 0.673,
                "confidence_b": 0.655,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.4520787662267685
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1960280100956678,
                "confidence_a": 0.673,
                "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.45511703681200744
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19467368745954028,
                "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
                "confidence_b": 0.655,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
                "opposition_score": 0.4618951076548547
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18852880344794803,
                "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
                "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
                "opposition_score": 0.4577993209846318
              }
            ],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.325,
                "tau": 0.1,
                "chi": -0.6,
                "phi": 0.0,
                "lam": 1.0
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'Another perspective on 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' argues:\n\nMultiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and tim",
                "counter": "The entanglement entropy of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?':\n\nApplying thermodynamic reason"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21021127403941411,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21021127403941411,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21021127403941411,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21021127403941411,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 4,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -1.5
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'Another perspective on 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' argues:\n\nThe entanglement entropy of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality pers",
                "counter": "The entanglement entropy of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?':\n\nApplying thermodynamic reason"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.21020479067152206,
                "current_strength": 0.2096659356709942,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0025634763071118853
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20948196610700906,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20948196610700906,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2080267358680917,
                "current_strength": 0.21069926742105416,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2080267358680917,
                "current_strength": 0.21069926742105416,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.21020479067152206,
                "current_strength": 0.2096659356709942,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0025634763071118853
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20948196610700906,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.21020479067152206,
                "current_strength": 0.2096659356709942,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0025634763071118853
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.20948196610700906,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2080267358680917,
                "current_strength": 0.21069926742105416,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.5949,
            0.2066,
            0.1763
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.7036,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.1763,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.9151,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.1763,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.9151,
          "synthesis_coverage": 1.0,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.1763
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 4,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.199283101334253,
            "confidence_a": 0.673,
            "confidence_b": 0.655,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.4520787662267685
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1960280100956678,
            "confidence_a": 0.673,
            "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.45511703681200744
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19467368745954028,
            "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
            "confidence_b": 0.655,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
            "opposition_score": 0.4618951076548547
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18852880344794803,
            "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
            "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
            "opposition_score": 0.4577993209846318
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 4,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19462840058435227,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 4
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.19462840058435227
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.199283101334253,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1960280100956678,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19467368745954028,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18852880344794803,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 3,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 3,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.0008544921023706285,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 3,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.21021127403941411,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20948196610700906,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0025634763071118853,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.21020479067152206,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2096659356709942,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 0.5
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.2080267358680917,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.21069926742105416,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 0.5
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007690428921335656,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 16,
            "interventions_recent": 16,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:28.010062",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.1
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.1
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.1
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.1
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.1
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.1
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:28.011043",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 5,
                "specialization_avg": 0.1,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.1
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 5,
                "specialization_avg": 0.1,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.1
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 5,
                "specialization_avg": 0.1,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.1
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 5,
                "specialization_avg": 0.1,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.1
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 5,
                "specialization_avg": 0.1,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.1
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 5,
                "specialization_avg": 0.1,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.1
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": null,
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": null,
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.325,
            "tau": 0.1,
            "chi": -0.6,
            "phi": 0.0,
            "lam": 1.0
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_full",
      "question_id": 5474,
      "query": "Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?",
      "synthesis": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' resists single-framework analysis. Its full meaning emerges only at the intersection of several distinct modes of reasoning.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' does not have an inherent meaning waiting to be discovered; its meaning is constituted by the stance we take toward it. This radical freedom is also radical responsibility: we cannot appeal...\n\n**Empathy perspective:** 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' does not have an inherent meaning waiting to be discovered; its meaning is constituted by the stance we take toward it. This radical freedom is also radical responsibility: we cannot appeal...\n\n**newton perspective:** If the outcome depends on a length L, a time T, and an energy E, the Buckingham Pi theorem tells us how many independent dimensionless groups govern the behavior. Scaling laws follow directly: how does the outcome change if we double the size?\n\n\n\nWhere Empathy reveals emotional reality and lived human experience, newton adds the crucial dimension of its analytical focus.\n\nWhat appears as a structural feature from the Philosophy perspective is revealed as a deeply human concern when viewed through Empathy.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** The multi-perspective analysis reveals that Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life? cannot be reduced to any single framework without distortion. The physical analysis provides causal grounding, the philosophical analysis excavates hidden assumptions, the ethical analysis maps the stakes, the creative analysis opens new solution spaces, and the empathic analysis anchors everything in lived human experience. Together they constitute not a list of separate views but an integrated understanding richer than any view alone.",
      "correctness_score": 0.4,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 4.390236139297485,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.81,
            "combined": 0.69
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.81,
            "combined": 0.69
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.87,
            "combined": 0.78
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.54,
        "problems_generated": 7,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 9,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 9,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19150736129534512,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 9
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.19150736129534512
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1951944687283817,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1950122527850606,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19340342850479111,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19145644964556258,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
                "confidence_b": 0.65,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.8571428571428571,
                "opposition_score": 0.45767114995047453
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1951944687283817,
                "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
                "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
                "opposition_score": 0.46038585700094703
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1950122527850606,
                "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
                "confidence_b": 0.6354166666666666,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.45655219186097384
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19340342850479111,
                "confidence_a": 0.6605,
                "confidence_b": 0.65,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.4504825679957867
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19145644964556258,
                "confidence_a": 0.6605,
                "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6,
                "opposition_score": 0.45958358788862824
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Authenticity demands that we own our interpretation of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1894038951570404,
                "confidence_a": 0.6326470588235295,
                "confidence_b": 0.65,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.46153846153846156,
                "opposition_score": 0.4605895243957639
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1886166772550876,
                "confidence_a": 0.6605,
                "confidence_b": 0.6354166666666666,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
                "opposition_score": 0.44941614069044594
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Authenticity demands that we own our interpretation of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1868739625864878,
                "confidence_a": 0.6326470588235295,
                "confidence_b": 0.6354166666666666,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.42857142857142855,
                "opposition_score": 0.4648669805750251
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Authenticity demands that we own our interpretation of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18362825064233385,
                "confidence_a": 0.6326470588235295,
                "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.4,
                "opposition_score": 0.4601986450282857
              }
            ],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.275,
                "tau": 0.0,
                "chi": -0.6,
                "phi": 0.0,
                "lam": 0.889
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Mapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' argues:\n\nReading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' through existentialist philoso",
                "counter": "Reading 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?':\n\nMapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Is it eth"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 9,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -0.1111111111111111
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Analyzing the stress profile of 'Another perspective on 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' argues:\n\nReading 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Is it",
                "counter": "Reading 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?':\n\nAnalyzing the stress profile of 'Another perspective on 'Is it ethica"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "current_strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.5716,
            0.55,
            0.5409
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.0537,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.5409,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.7318,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.5409,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.7318,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.4327
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 9,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1999768663533601,
            "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
            "confidence_b": 0.65,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.8571428571428571,
            "opposition_score": 0.45767114995047453
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1951944687283817,
            "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
            "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
            "opposition_score": 0.46038585700094703
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1950122527850606,
            "confidence_a": 0.6722222222222222,
            "confidence_b": 0.6354166666666666,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.45655219186097384
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19340342850479111,
            "confidence_a": 0.6605,
            "confidence_b": 0.65,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.4504825679957867
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19145644964556258,
            "confidence_a": 0.6605,
            "confidence_b": 0.6307142857142858,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6,
            "opposition_score": 0.45958358788862824
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 9,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19150736129534512,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 9
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.19150736129534512
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1999768663533601,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1951944687283817,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1950122527850606,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19340342850479111,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19145644964556258,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Reading 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 1,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.0,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.1999768663533601,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20969437896639984,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.21140977193782134,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007690428921335656,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.001300011766576065,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 22,
            "interventions_recent": 22,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:41.222562",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.07142857142857142
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.07142857142857142
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.07142857142857142
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.07142857142857142
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.07142857142857142
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.07142857142857142
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:41.222562",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 7,
                "specialization_avg": 0.071,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.071
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 7,
                "specialization_avg": 0.071,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.071
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 7,
                "specialization_avg": 0.071,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.071
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 7,
                "specialization_avg": 0.071,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.071
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 7,
                "specialization_avg": 0.071,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.071
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 7,
                "specialization_avg": 0.071,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.071
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": null,
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": null,
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.275,
            "tau": 0.0,
            "chi": -0.6,
            "phi": 0.0,
            "lam": 0.889
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_full",
      "question_id": 9159,
      "query": "Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?",
      "synthesis": "A comprehensive understanding of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' requires weaving together insights from fundamentally different ways of thinking.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** Realism holds that the entities and structures involved exist mind-independently; conceptualism holds they are products of categorization imposed by cognitive agents; nominalism holds that only particular instances exist and the general category is merely a label. The ontological commitment we...\n\n**Empathy perspective:** Realism holds that the entities and structures involved exist mind-independently; conceptualism holds they are products of categorization imposed by cognitive agents; nominalism holds that only particular instances exist and the general category is merely a label. The ontological commitment we...\n\n**multi_perspective perspective:** Generic perspective on Should AI systems be required to explain their dec...\n\n**newton perspective:** If the outcome depends on a length L, a time T, and an energy E, the Buckingham Pi theorem tells us how many independent dimensionless groups govern the behavior. Scaling laws follow directly: how does the outcome change if we double the size?\n\n\n\nWhere Philosophy reveals foundational assumptions and the structure of meaning, multi_perspective adds the crucial dimension of its analytical focus.\n\nCombining multi_perspective's structural analysis with newton's human-centered analysis yields a fuller picture.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The multi_perspective analysis scored lowest (0.50). It would benefit from more specific engagement with the concept's concrete details rather than abstract framing.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** The multi-perspective analysis reveals that Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions? cannot be reduced to any single framework without distortion. The physical analysis provides causal grounding, the philosophical analysis excavates hidden assumptions, the ethical analysis maps the stakes, the creative analysis opens new solution spaces, and the empathic analysis anchors everything in lived human experience. Together they constitute not a list of separate views but an integrated understanding richer than any view alone.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 2.743820905685425,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.7
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.7
          },
          "multi_perspective": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.35,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.65,
            "combined": 0.5
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.89,
            "combined": 0.79
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.49,
        "problems_generated": 8,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 4,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 4,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.17722210325998478,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 4
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.17722210325998478
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Acknowledging the grief dimension of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18169630813759974,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1725524542657813,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.16987528374293934,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Acknowledging the grief dimension of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "Acknowledging the grief dimension of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "confidence_a": 0.6325,
                "confidence_b": 0.6325,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5714285714285714,
                "opposition_score": 0.4618459701444954
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18169630813759974,
                "confidence_a": 0.6325,
                "confidence_b": 0.628,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.7272727272727273,
                "opposition_score": 0.45743135403841734
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1725524542657813,
                "confidence_a": 0.5876666666666667,
                "confidence_b": 0.628,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6153846153846154,
                "opposition_score": 0.46755256023257974
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "Acknowledging the grief dimension of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.16987528374293934,
                "confidence_a": 0.5876666666666667,
                "confidence_b": 0.6325,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5,
                "opposition_score": 0.45702357975766067
              }
            ],
            "preflight_prediction": {
              "query_state": {
                "psi": 0.275,
                "tau": 0.0,
                "chi": -1.0,
                "phi": 0.055,
                "lam": 1.0
              },
              "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
              "conflict_profiles": {
                "psi_conflicts": 0,
                "tau_conflicts": 0,
                "chi_conflicts": 0,
                "phi_conflicts": 0,
                "lam_conflicts": 0
              },
              "recommendations": {
                "boost": [],
                "suppress": [],
                "reason": null
              },
              "preflight_confidence": 0.3
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Mapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' argues:\n\nExamining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to ex",
                "counter": "Connecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?':\n\nMapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspecti"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 4,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -1.5
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Mapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' argues:\n\nConnecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your",
                "counter": "Connecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?':\n\nMapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspecti"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.20129110930353167,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "current_strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.8213,
            0.6379,
            0.6048
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.2636,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.6048,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.6579,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.6048,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.6579,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.86,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.5201
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 4,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "Acknowledging the grief dimension of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18476436689361878,
            "confidence_a": 0.6325,
            "confidence_b": 0.6325,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5714285714285714,
            "opposition_score": 0.4618459701444954
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18169630813759974,
            "confidence_a": 0.6325,
            "confidence_b": 0.628,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.7272727272727273,
            "opposition_score": 0.45743135403841734
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1725524542657813,
            "confidence_a": 0.5876666666666667,
            "confidence_b": 0.628,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6153846153846154,
            "opposition_score": 0.46755256023257974
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "Acknowledging the grief dimension of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.16987528374293934,
            "confidence_a": 0.5876666666666667,
            "confidence_b": 0.6325,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5,
            "opposition_score": 0.45702357975766067
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 4,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.17722210325998478,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 4
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.17722210325998478
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18476436689361878,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Acknowledging the grief dimension of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18169630813759974,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1725524542657813,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.16987528374293934,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Acknowledging the grief dimension of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 2,
          "resolved": 1,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.5,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 1,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.18476436689361878,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2136668970103556,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.20129110930353167,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007690428921335656,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.001300011766576065,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.2949276,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.0659046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.3,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.197935,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.6181629,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.1,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.7537508,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979310.3546066,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.1,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.2949276,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.0659046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.197935,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.6181629,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.7537508,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979310.3546066,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 28,
            "interventions_recent": 28,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:50.398362",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.5,
              "systems": 0.5
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.5,
              "systems": 0.5
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.5,
              "systems": 0.5
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.5,
              "systems": 0.5
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.5,
              "systems": 0.5
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.5,
              "systems": 0.5
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:50.400371",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 10,
                "specialization_avg": 0.354,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.5,
                  "systems": 0.5
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 10,
                "specialization_avg": 0.354,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.5,
                  "systems": 0.5
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 10,
                "specialization_avg": 0.354,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.5,
                  "systems": 0.5
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 10,
                "specialization_avg": 0.354,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.5,
                  "systems": 0.5
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 10,
                "specialization_avg": 0.354,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.5,
                  "systems": 0.5
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 10,
                "specialization_avg": 0.354,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.5,
                  "systems": 0.5
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": "Newton",
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": "Newton",
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {
          "query_state": {
            "psi": 0.275,
            "tau": 0.0,
            "chi": -1.0,
            "phi": 0.055,
            "lam": 1.0
          },
          "predicted_pairs_count": 0,
          "conflict_profiles": {
            "psi_conflicts": 0,
            "tau_conflicts": 0,
            "chi_conflicts": 0,
            "phi_conflicts": 0,
            "lam_conflicts": 0
          },
          "recommendations": {
            "boost": [],
            "suppress": [],
            "reason": null
          },
          "preflight_confidence": 0.3
        }
      }
    }
  ],
  "phase_6_no_preflight": [
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_no_preflight",
      "question_id": 9012,
      "query": "What is the speed of light in vacuum?",
      "synthesis": "A comprehensive understanding of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' requires weaving together insights from fundamentally different ways of thinking.\n\n**Newton perspective:** Each framing carries a probability amplitude -- not a classical probability, but a complex weight that can interfere constructively or destructively with others. Some framings reinforce each other, producing high-probability interpretations; others cancel out, revealing that certain seemingly plausible readings...\n\n**Quantum perspective:** Each framing carries a probability amplitude -- not a classical probability, but a complex weight that can interfere constructively or destructively with others. Some framings reinforce each other, producing high-probability interpretations; others cancel out, revealing that certain seemingly plausible readings...\n\n**newton perspective:** Thresholds appear where the system suddenly transitions between distinct states. Hysteresis means the system remembers its history.\n\n**multi_perspective perspective:** Generic perspective on What is the speed of light in vacuum?...\n\n\n\nThe Quantum analysis and the newton analysis converge on a shared insight: the importance of understanding the full system rather than isolated parts.\n\nCombining Quantum's structural analysis with multi_perspective's human-centered analysis yields a fuller picture.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The multi_perspective analysis scored lowest (0.50). It would benefit from more specific engagement with the concept's concrete details rather than abstract framing. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** What is the speed of light in vacuum? is simultaneously a system governed by causal dynamics and conservation principles, a concept whose meaning depends on the framework from which it is examined, a domain of genuine moral stakes affecting real people, a space of untapped possibilities waiting for cross-domain insight, and a lived experience with emotional texture that abstract analysis alone cannot capture. These are not competing descriptions but complementary facets of a single complex reality. The most robust understanding holds all five in view, using each to compensate for the blind spots of the others.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 1.0721781253814697,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "What is the speed of light in vacuum?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.62,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.93,
            "combined": 0.78
          },
          "Quantum": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.62,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.93,
            "combined": 0.78
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.81,
            "combined": 0.75
          },
          "multi_perspective": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.35,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.65,
            "combined": 0.5
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.52,
        "problems_generated": 5,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 1,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 1,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 1
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.18380081400905968
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Constructing the phase space of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Before we commit to a single interpretation, 'What is the speed of light in vacuum"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Constructing the phase space of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                "claim_b": "Before we commit to a single interpretation, 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "confidence_a": 0.6469230769230769,
                "confidence_b": 0.6246666666666667,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.3333333333333333,
                "opposition_score": 0.4548272274807096
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Decomposing 'Another perspective on 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' argues:\n\nBefore we commit to a single interpretation, 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' exists in a superposition of m",
                "counter": "Analyzing the probability landscape of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?':\n\nDecomposing 'Another perspective on 'Wh"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 1,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -9.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Framing 'Another perspective on 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?' argues:\n\nAnalyzing the probability landscape of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of ",
                "counter": "Analyzing the probability landscape of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum?':\n\nFraming 'Another perspective on 'What i"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "current_strength": 0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.19899642953035512,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.19867046904830907,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.924,
            0.484,
            0.4544
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.5082,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.4544,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.7429,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.4544,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.7429,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8098,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.368
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 1,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Constructing the phase space of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
            "claim_b": "Before we commit to a single interpretation, 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
            "confidence_a": 0.6469230769230769,
            "confidence_b": 0.6246666666666667,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.3333333333333333,
            "opposition_score": 0.4548272274807096
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 1,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.18380081400905968,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 1
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.18380081400905968
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18380081400905968,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Constructing the phase space of 'What is the speed of light in vacuum",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Before we commit to a single interpretation, 'What is the speed of light in vacuum"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 3,
          "resolved": 3,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 0,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 1.0,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 3,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 0,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
            "resolved_in_round": 1,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.18380081400905968,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.19899642953035512,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.19867046904830907,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 6,
            "interventions_recent": 6,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:19.627190",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.25
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.25
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.25
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.25
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.25
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.25
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:19.627190",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 2,
                "specialization_avg": 0.25,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.25
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 2,
                "specialization_avg": 0.25,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.25
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 2,
                "specialization_avg": 0.25,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.25
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 2,
                "specialization_avg": 0.25,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.25
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 2,
                "specialization_avg": 0.25,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.25
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 2,
                "specialization_avg": 0.25,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.25
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": null,
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": null,
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {}
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_no_preflight",
      "question_id": 3833,
      "query": "Explain why the sky appears blue during the day",
      "synthesis": "The richness of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' becomes apparent only when we hold multiple analytical frameworks simultaneously and let them inform each other.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** If 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' is introduced in an environment where asking questions signals incompetence, where mistakes are punished, or where dissent is suppressed, people will perform understanding rather than achieve it. The intellectual quality...\n\n**Empathy perspective:** If 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' is introduced in an environment where asking questions signals incompetence, where mistakes are punished, or where dissent is suppressed, people will perform understanding rather than achieve it. The intellectual quality...\n\n**newton perspective:** The initial conditions set boundary constraints, and the dynamics propagate through interactions that obey local causality. Identifying the forcing function -- the primary driver that injects energy or information into this system -- reveals which variables are genuinely independent and which are downstream responses.\n\n\n\nPhilosophy identifies the mechanism; Empathy identifies the meaning.\n\nThe Empathy analysis and the newton analysis converge on a shared insight: the importance of understanding the full system rather than isolated parts.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** Explain why the sky appears blue during the day is simultaneously a system governed by causal dynamics and conservation principles, a concept whose meaning depends on the framework from which it is examined, a domain of genuine moral stakes affecting real people, a space of untapped possibilities waiting for cross-domain insight, and a lived experience with emotional texture that abstract analysis alone cannot capture. These are not competing descriptions but complementary facets of a single complex reality. The most robust understanding holds all five in view, using each to compensate for the blind spots of the others.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 1.2725467681884766,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Explain why the sky appears blue during the day",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.58,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.79,
            "combined": 0.68
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.58,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.79,
            "combined": 0.68
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.67,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.95,
            "combined": 0.81
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.55,
        "problems_generated": 6,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 0,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 0,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.0,
              "by_type": {},
              "top_conflicts": []
            },
            "conflicts": []
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "challenge": "Interpreting 'Another perspective on 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' argues:\n\nAssessing the psychological safety implications of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day': pe",
                "counter": "Assessing the psychological safety implications of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysis of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day':\n\nInterpreting 'Ano"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20458609667780112,
                "current_strength": 0.20458609667780112,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20363453343743923,
                "current_strength": 0.20363453343743923,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.2018793813653056,
                "current_strength": 0.2018793813653056,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20126860748830816,
                "current_strength": 0.20126860748830816,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19974187011029698,
                "current_strength": 0.19974187011029698,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19952372890632428,
                "current_strength": 0.19952372890632428,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19948184402923377,
                "current_strength": 0.19948184402923377,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19932659894222643,
                "current_strength": 0.19932659894222643,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.199083676675882,
                "current_strength": 0.199083676675882,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.199083676675882,
                "current_strength": 0.199083676675882,
                "resolution_type": "new",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {},
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "challenge": "Interpreting 'Another perspective on 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day' argues:\n\nAssessing the psychological safety implications of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective res",
                "counter": "Assessing the psychological safety implications of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysis of 'Explain why the sky appears blue during the day':\n\nInterpreting 'Ano"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "current_strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.6773,
            0.5299,
            0.5283
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.22,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.5283,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.7386,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.5283,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.7386,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8681,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.4586
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 0,
        "conflicts_detected": [],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 0,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.0,
          "by_type": {},
          "top_conflicts": []
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 1,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.0,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.20069881344884724,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20424792313377066,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 12,
            "interventions_recent": 12,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:26.320489",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.125
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.125
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.125
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.125
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.125
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.125
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:26.321489",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 4,
                "specialization_avg": 0.125,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.125
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 4,
                "specialization_avg": 0.125,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.125
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 4,
                "specialization_avg": 0.125,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.125
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 4,
                "specialization_avg": 0.125,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.125
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 4,
                "specialization_avg": 0.125,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.125
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 4,
                "specialization_avg": 0.125,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.125
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": null,
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": null,
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {}
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_no_preflight",
      "question_id": 7352,
      "query": "What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?",
      "synthesis": "No single perspective captures 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' adequately. What follows is an integrated analysis drawing on physics, philosophy, ethics, creativity, and human experience.\n\n**Newton perspective:** A process runs forward if it increases total entropy (or equivalently, decreases free energy at constant temperature and pressure). Local decreases in entropy -- the creation of order and structure -- are always paid for by larger increases elsewhere.\n\n**Quantum perspective:** A process runs forward if it increases total entropy (or equivalently, decreases free energy at constant temperature and pressure). Local decreases in entropy -- the creation of order and structure -- are always paid for by larger increases elsewhere.\n\n**newton perspective:** A process runs forward if it increases total entropy (or equivalently, decreases free energy at constant temperature and pressure). Local decreases in entropy -- the creation of order and structure -- are always paid for by larger increases elsewhere.\n\n\n\nThe tension between Newton's emphasis on causal mechanisms and measurable dynamics and newton's emphasis on its analytical focus is productive, not contradictory.\n\nQuantum identifies the mechanism; newton identifies the meaning.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** What emerges from this multi-lens examination of What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow? is not a single 'correct' interpretation but a structured understanding of how different valid interpretations relate to each other. The causal structure identified by physics, the meaning structure identified by philosophy, the value structure identified by ethics, the possibility structure identified by creative reasoning, and the experience structure identified by empathy are all real and all essential. Wisdom lies in knowing which lens to apply in which context and how to translate insights between them.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 0.33348846435546875,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.6,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.87,
            "combined": 0.73
          },
          "Quantum": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.6,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.87,
            "combined": 0.73
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.76
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.5,
        "problems_generated": 7,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 4,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 4,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19462840058435227,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 4
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.19462840058435227
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.199283101334253,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1960280100956678,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19467368745954028,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Newton",
                  "agent_b": "Quantum",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18852880344794803,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "confidence_a": 0.673,
                "confidence_b": 0.655,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.4520787662267685
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1960280100956678,
                "confidence_a": 0.673,
                "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.45511703681200744
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19467368745954028,
                "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
                "confidence_b": 0.655,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
                "opposition_score": 0.4618951076548547
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Newton",
                "agent_b": "Quantum",
                "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18852880344794803,
                "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
                "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
                "opposition_score": 0.4577993209846318
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Quantum_vs_Newton",
                "challenge": "The entanglement entropy of 'Another perspective on 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' argues:\n\nApplying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy ",
                "counter": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'A probabilistic_and_uncertainty perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?':\n\nThe entanglement entropy o"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21250094098119066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21250094098119066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21250094098119066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21250094098119066,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 4,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -1.5
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "challenge": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'Another perspective on 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?' argues:\n\nThe entanglement entropy of 'Another perspective on 'What is the relat",
                "counter": "The entanglement entropy of 'A physics_and_mathematical_causality perspective responded to your analysis of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow?':\n\nApplying thermodynamic reason"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21531818591717347,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2135742865601583,
                "current_strength": 0.21476821249279268,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.21355032834406074,
                "current_strength": 0.2126249352120492,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.00433337255525355
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21531818591717347,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21531818591717347,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2135742865601583,
                "current_strength": 0.21476821249279268,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.21355032834406074,
                "current_strength": 0.2126249352120492,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.00433337255525355
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
                "initial_strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "current_strength": 0.21531818591717347,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2135742865601583,
                "current_strength": 0.21476821249279268,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.21355032834406074,
                "current_strength": 0.2126249352120492,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.00433337255525355
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.5949,
            0.0539,
            0.0784
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.8682,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.0784,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.963,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.0784,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.963,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.6667,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.0523
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 4,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.199283101334253,
            "confidence_a": 0.673,
            "confidence_b": 0.655,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.4520787662267685
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1960280100956678,
            "confidence_a": 0.673,
            "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.45511703681200744
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19467368745954028,
            "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
            "confidence_b": 0.655,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
            "opposition_score": 0.4618951076548547
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Newton",
            "agent_b": "Quantum",
            "claim_a": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "claim_b": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18852880344794803,
            "confidence_a": 0.6434615384615385,
            "confidence_b": 0.6399999999999999,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
            "opposition_score": 0.4577993209846318
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 4,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19462840058435227,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 4
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.19462840058435227
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.199283101334253,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1960280100956678,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19467368745954028,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "This means 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Newton",
              "agent_b": "Quantum",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18852880344794803,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying thermodynamic reasoning to 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Multiple elements of 'What is the relationship between entropy and time's arrow"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 3,
          "resolved": 0,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 3,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.00144445751841785,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 0,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 3,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_Quantum",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.199283101334253,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.21250094098119066,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.21531818591717347,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Newton_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.2135742865601583,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.21476821249279268,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 0.5
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Quantum_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.00433337255525355,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.21355032834406074,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2126249352120492,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 0.5
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007690428921335656,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.001300011766576065,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 18,
            "interventions_recent": 18,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:28.344531",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.08333333333333333
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.08333333333333333
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.08333333333333333
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.08333333333333333
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.08333333333333333
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.08333333333333333
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:28.344531",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 6,
                "specialization_avg": 0.083,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.083
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 6,
                "specialization_avg": 0.083,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.083
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 6,
                "specialization_avg": 0.083,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.083
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 6,
                "specialization_avg": 0.083,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.083
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 6,
                "specialization_avg": 0.083,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.083
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 6,
                "specialization_avg": 0.083,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.083
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": null,
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": null,
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {}
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_no_preflight",
      "question_id": 5474,
      "query": "Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?",
      "synthesis": "'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' resists single-framework analysis. Its full meaning emerges only at the intersection of several distinct modes of reasoning.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' does not experience it as a set of propositions but as a shift in the felt quality of their day -- a new worry added to their mental...\n\n**Empathy perspective:** A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' does not experience it as a set of propositions but as a shift in the felt quality of their day -- a new worry added to their mental...\n\n**newton perspective:** Writing these rules as differential equations (or difference equations for discrete systems) gives us the complete forward model. The character of the equations -- linear vs nonlinear, autonomous vs driven, conservative vs dissipative -- determines the qualitative behavior.\n\n\n\nPhilosophy identifies the mechanism; newton identifies the meaning.\n\nWhat appears as a structural feature from the Philosophy perspective is revealed as a deeply human concern when viewed through Empathy.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The ensemble would benefit from more concrete examples and illustrations. Abstract reasoning without grounding in specifics is less persuasive and harder to verify. The ensemble provides reasonable coverage but would benefit from deeper engagement between perspectives.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life? is simultaneously a system governed by causal dynamics and conservation principles, a concept whose meaning depends on the framework from which it is examined, a domain of genuine moral stakes affecting real people, a space of untapped possibilities waiting for cross-domain insight, and a lived experience with emotional texture that abstract analysis alone cannot capture. These are not competing descriptions but complementary facets of a single complex reality. The most robust understanding holds all five in view, using each to compensate for the blind spots of the others.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 3.875819444656372,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.6,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.79,
            "combined": 0.7
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.6,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.79,
            "combined": 0.7
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.85,
            "combined": 0.77
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.54,
        "problems_generated": 7,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 6,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 6,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19109964816581648,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 6
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.19109964816581648
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19404399852296583,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.19169731108559432,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18925059071063335,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1885400090098046,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "confidence_a": 0.6679999999999999,
                "confidence_b": 0.6357142857142857,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
                "opposition_score": 0.45883781126700346
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19404399852296583,
                "confidence_a": 0.6556666666666666,
                "confidence_b": 0.6357142857142857,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5,
                "opposition_score": 0.4655380027741194
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.19169731108559432,
                "confidence_a": 0.6679999999999999,
                "confidence_b": 0.62375,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
                "opposition_score": 0.460075386906974
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18925059071063335,
                "confidence_a": 0.6679999999999999,
                "confidence_b": 0.6255,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.8571428571428571,
                "opposition_score": 0.4529324820637703
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1885400090098046,
                "confidence_a": 0.6556666666666666,
                "confidence_b": 0.6255,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6,
                "opposition_score": 0.4597196890413761
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18821722569843033,
                "confidence_a": 0.6556666666666666,
                "confidence_b": 0.62375,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5454545454545454,
                "opposition_score": 0.4602202286385
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "challenge": "Connecting 'Another perspective on 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' argues:\n\nCentering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?': abstract analysis risks los",
                "counter": "Centering the lived experience of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysis of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?':\n\nConnecting 'Another perspective on 'I"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2105862122379724,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2105862122379724,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2105862122379724,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2105862122379724,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2105862122379724,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2105862122379724,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 6,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -0.6666666666666666
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "challenge": "Connecting 'Another perspective on 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?' argues:\n\nCentering the lived experience of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysi",
                "counter": "Centering the lived experience of 'A conceptual_meaning_and_foundations perspective responded to your analysis of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life?':\n\nConnecting 'Another perspective on 'I"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Empathy_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2099766325485635,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2146289285510371,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2146289285510371,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2146289285510371,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2146289285510371,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2146289285510371,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2146289285510371,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.20697980054619516,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Empathy_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.2099766325485635,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "current_strength": 0.2146289285510371,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.7431,
            0.552,
            0.5443
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.2675,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.5443,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.7309,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.5443,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.7309,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8113,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.4416
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 6,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19484875396747062,
            "confidence_a": 0.6679999999999999,
            "confidence_b": 0.6357142857142857,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
            "opposition_score": 0.45883781126700346
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19404399852296583,
            "confidence_a": 0.6556666666666666,
            "confidence_b": 0.6357142857142857,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5,
            "opposition_score": 0.4655380027741194
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.19169731108559432,
            "confidence_a": 0.6679999999999999,
            "confidence_b": 0.62375,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.75,
            "opposition_score": 0.460075386906974
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18925059071063335,
            "confidence_a": 0.6679999999999999,
            "confidence_b": 0.6255,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.8571428571428571,
            "opposition_score": 0.4529324820637703
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "claim_b": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1885400090098046,
            "confidence_a": 0.6556666666666666,
            "confidence_b": 0.6255,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6,
            "opposition_score": 0.4597196890413761
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 6,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.19109964816581648,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 6
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.19109964816581648
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19484875396747062,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19404399852296583,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Centering the lived experience of 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.19169731108559432,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "A person encountering 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18925059071063335,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "For 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1885400090098046,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Applying the ethics of belief to 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Understanding 'Is it ethical to lie to save someone's life"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 3,
          "resolved": 2,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.6666666666666666,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 2,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.19484875396747062,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2105862122379724,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2146289285510371,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Empathy_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.2099766325485635,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.20697980054619516,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007690428921335656,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.001300011766576065,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.2949276,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.0659046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.3,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.2949276,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.0659046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 24,
            "interventions_recent": 24,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:45.098382",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.0625
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.0625
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.0625
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.0625
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.0625
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.0625
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:45.098382",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 8,
                "specialization_avg": 0.062,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 8,
                "specialization_avg": 0.062,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 8,
                "specialization_avg": 0.062,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 8,
                "specialization_avg": 0.062,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 8,
                "specialization_avg": 0.062,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 1,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 8,
                "specialization_avg": 0.062,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": null,
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": null,
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {}
      }
    },
    {
      "condition": "phase_6_no_preflight",
      "question_id": 9159,
      "query": "Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?",
      "synthesis": "To understand 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' with genuine depth, we must examine it through multiple lenses, each revealing structure that the others miss.\n\n**Philosophy perspective:** Realism holds that the entities and structures involved exist mind-independently; conceptualism holds they are products of categorization imposed by cognitive agents; nominalism holds that only particular instances exist and the general category is merely a label. The ontological commitment we...\n\n**Empathy perspective:** Realism holds that the entities and structures involved exist mind-independently; conceptualism holds they are products of categorization imposed by cognitive agents; nominalism holds that only particular instances exist and the general category is merely a label. The ontological commitment we...\n\n**multi_perspective perspective:** Generic perspective on Should AI systems be required to explain their dec...\n\n**newton perspective:** Fixed boundaries (Dirichlet conditions) specify the state at the edges. Free boundaries (Neumann conditions) specify the flux.\n\n\n\nThe tension between Philosophy's emphasis on foundational assumptions and the structure of meaning and Empathy's emphasis on emotional reality and lived human experience is productive, not contradictory.\n\nWhere Empathy reveals emotional reality and lived human experience, multi_perspective adds the crucial dimension of its analytical focus.\n\n\n\nA notable gap in the analysis is the limited attention to temporal/historical dimensions, which future analysis should address. The critic notes: The multi_perspective analysis scored lowest (0.50). It would benefit from more specific engagement with the concept's concrete details rather than abstract framing.\n\n\n\n**Final Integrated Understanding:** What emerges from this multi-lens examination of Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions? is not a single 'correct' interpretation but a structured understanding of how different valid interpretations relate to each other. The causal structure identified by physics, the meaning structure identified by philosophy, the value structure identified by ethics, the possibility structure identified by creative reasoning, and the experience structure identified by empathy are all real and all essential. Wisdom lies in knowing which lens to apply in which context and how to translate insights between them.",
      "correctness_score": 0.2,
      "reasoning_depth": 5,
      "calibration_error": 0.1,
      "gamma_score": 0.5,
      "num_conflicts_detected": 0,
      "adapter_convergence": 0.5,
      "elapsed_seconds": 3.041956901550293,
      "metadata": {
        "concept": "Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?",
        "agent_scores": {
          "Philosophy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.7
          },
          "Empathy": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.57,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.83,
            "combined": 0.7
          },
          "multi_perspective": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.35,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.65,
            "combined": 0.5
          },
          "newton": {
            "logical_clarity": 0.7,
            "conceptual_accuracy": 0.77,
            "combined": 0.73
          }
        },
        "overall_quality": 0.48,
        "problems_generated": 5,
        "debate_rounds": 2,
        "debate_log": [
          {
            "round": 0,
            "type": "initial_analysis",
            "conflicts_detected": 6,
            "conflict_strength_summary": {
              "total_conflicts": 6,
              "avg_conflict_strength": 0.17610457660028012,
              "by_type": {
                "framework": 6
              },
              "type_avg_strength": {
                "framework": 0.17610457660028012
              },
              "top_conflicts": [
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Engaging with 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.17775311998578402,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "A playful stance toward 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.17609792015336206,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.17402735781725343,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "Engaging with 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                },
                {
                  "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                  "agent_b": "Empathy",
                  "type": "framework",
                  "strength": 0.1736755465415525,
                  "claim_a_excerpt": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                  "claim_b_excerpt": "A playful stance toward 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
                }
              ]
            },
            "conflicts": [
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "Engaging with 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "confidence_a": 0.6275000000000001,
                "confidence_b": 0.6204545454545454,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
                "opposition_score": 0.4670012651383877
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "A playful stance toward 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.17775311998578402,
                "confidence_a": 0.6275000000000001,
                "confidence_b": 0.6142307692307691,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5714285714285714,
                "opposition_score": 0.46118156000971794
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.17609792015336206,
                "confidence_a": 0.6275000000000001,
                "confidence_b": 0.6134999999999999,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.7272727272727273,
                "opposition_score": 0.45743135403841734
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "Engaging with 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.17402735781725343,
                "confidence_a": 0.604,
                "confidence_b": 0.6204545454545454,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5714285714285714,
                "opposition_score": 0.4643769099749625
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "A playful stance toward 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.1736755465415525,
                "confidence_a": 0.604,
                "confidence_b": 0.6142307692307691,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.5,
                "opposition_score": 0.4681339815631509
              },
              {
                "agent_a": "Philosophy",
                "agent_b": "Empathy",
                "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
                "conflict_type": "framework",
                "conflict_strength": 0.17325347140442332,
                "confidence_a": 0.604,
                "confidence_b": 0.6134999999999999,
                "semantic_overlap": 0.6153846153846154,
                "opposition_score": 0.46755256023257974
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "round": 1,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Mapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' argues:\n\nExamining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to ex",
                "counter": "Connecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?':\n\nMapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspecti"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 6,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": -0.6666666666666666
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": "Injected newton perspective"
              }
            }
          },
          {
            "round": 2,
            "type": "debate",
            "debates": [
              {
                "pair": "Empathy_vs_Philosophy",
                "challenge": "Mapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspective on 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?' argues:\n\nConnecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your",
                "counter": "Connecting 'A emotional_and_human_centered perspective responded to your analysis of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions?':\n\nMapping the emotional landscape of 'Another perspecti"
              }
            ],
            "conflicts_detected": 10,
            "conflict_evolution": [
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.20405772528872174,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.20405772528872174,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.2124482118451624,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.2124482118451624,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_newton",
                "initial_strength": 0.20405772528872174,
                "current_strength": 0.0,
                "resolution_type": "resolved",
                "resolution_rate": 1.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.2124482118451624,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.2124482118451624,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.2124482118451624,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.2124482118451624,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              },
              {
                "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
                "initial_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "current_strength": 0.2124482118451624,
                "resolution_type": "stalled",
                "resolution_rate": 0.0
              }
            ],
            "resolution_metrics": {
              "conflicts_before": 10,
              "conflicts_after": 10,
              "resolution_rate": 0.0
            },
            "gamma_health": {
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "status": "collapsing",
              "conflict_strength": 0.5,
              "perspective_diversity": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5,
              "intervention": {
                "type": "InterventionType.DIVERSITY_INJECTION",
                "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
                "adapter": "newton",
                "result": null
              }
            }
          }
        ],
        "tension_decay": {
          "per_round_tension": [
            0.7461,
            0.6074,
            0.5735
          ],
          "decay_rate": 0.2313,
          "is_converging": true
        },
        "epistemic_tension": 0.5735,
        "ensemble_coherence": 0.6729,
        "tension_productivity": {
          "tension_magnitude": 0.5735,
          "ensemble_coherence": 0.6729,
          "synthesis_coverage": 0.8232,
          "coherence_gain": 0.0,
          "productivity": 0.4721
        },
        "forge_mode": "debate",
        "conflicts_round_0_count": 6,
        "conflicts_detected": [
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "Engaging with 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.18182004369930532,
            "confidence_a": 0.6275000000000001,
            "confidence_b": 0.6204545454545454,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.6666666666666666,
            "opposition_score": 0.4670012651383877
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "A playful stance toward 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.17775311998578402,
            "confidence_a": 0.6275000000000001,
            "confidence_b": 0.6142307692307691,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5714285714285714,
            "opposition_score": 0.46118156000971794
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.17609792015336206,
            "confidence_a": 0.6275000000000001,
            "confidence_b": 0.6134999999999999,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.7272727272727273,
            "opposition_score": 0.45743135403841734
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "Engaging with 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.17402735781725343,
            "confidence_a": 0.604,
            "confidence_b": 0.6204545454545454,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5714285714285714,
            "opposition_score": 0.4643769099749625
          },
          {
            "agent_a": "Philosophy",
            "agent_b": "Empathy",
            "claim_a": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "claim_b": "A playful stance toward 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
            "conflict_type": "framework",
            "conflict_strength": 0.1736755465415525,
            "confidence_a": 0.604,
            "confidence_b": 0.6142307692307691,
            "semantic_overlap": 0.5,
            "opposition_score": 0.4681339815631509
          }
        ],
        "conflict_summary": {
          "total_conflicts": 6,
          "avg_conflict_strength": 0.17610457660028012,
          "by_type": {
            "framework": 6
          },
          "type_avg_strength": {
            "framework": 0.17610457660028012
          },
          "top_conflicts": [
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.18182004369930532,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Engaging with 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.17775311998578402,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "A playful stance toward 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.17609792015336206,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "Examining the ontological status of 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "For 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.17402735781725343,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "Engaging with 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            },
            {
              "agent_a": "Philosophy",
              "agent_b": "Empathy",
              "type": "framework",
              "strength": 0.1736755465415525,
              "claim_a_excerpt": "The ontological commitment we make about 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions",
              "claim_b_excerpt": "A playful stance toward 'Should AI systems be required to explain their decisions"
            }
          ]
        },
        "phase_3_metrics": {
          "total_tracked": 2,
          "resolved": 1,
          "hard_victory": 0,
          "soft_consensus": 0,
          "stalled": 1,
          "worsened": 0,
          "avg_resolution_rate": 0.5,
          "by_type": {
            "resolved": 1,
            "hard_victory": 0,
            "soft_consensus": 0,
            "stalled": 1,
            "worsened": 0
          }
        },
        "evolution_data": [
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_Empathy",
            "resolved_in_round": -1,
            "resolution_rate": 0.0,
            "resolution_type": "stalled",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.18182004369930532,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.20652063228716772,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.2124482118451624,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          },
          {
            "agents": "Philosophy_vs_newton",
            "resolved_in_round": 2,
            "resolution_rate": 1.0,
            "resolution_type": "resolved",
            "trajectory": [
              {
                "strength": 0.20405772528872174,
                "addressing_score": 0.0,
                "softening_score": 0.0
              },
              {
                "strength": 0.0,
                "addressing_score": 1.0,
                "softening_score": 1.0
              }
            ]
          }
        ],
        "phase_4_active": false,
        "adapter_weights": {},
        "phase_5a_active": true,
        "gamma_metrics": {
          "health_history": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.30991,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.4251046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.448093,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.5490158,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979278.587514,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6051717,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 1.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979279.6607306,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.1286883,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979280.2291615,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979284.985953,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007118872112798061,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0007690428921335656,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.001300011766576065,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.2949276,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.0659046,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.3,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.197935,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.6181629,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.1,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.7537508,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979310.3546066,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.1,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979310.4959824,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.0,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979313.3986938,
              "gamma": 0.375,
              "conflict": 0.5,
              "diversity": 1.0,
              "resolution": 0.3,
              "weight_variance": 0.5
            }
          ],
          "interventions": [
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979285.094757,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.2887404,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979286.3665402,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.1757436,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.2444026,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979287.990801,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.056849,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.3354244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979288.4497676,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.6645482,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979296.9346244,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.1810236,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979301.2949276,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.0659046,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979305.197935,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.6181629,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979307.7537508,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979310.3546066,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979310.4959824,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": "Injected newton perspective"
            },
            {
              "timestamp": 1773979313.3986938,
              "type": "diversity_injection",
              "reason": "System instability detected (\u03b3=0.38 < 0.4). Diversity=100.0%, Weight variance=50.0%. Injecting diverse perspective to break monoculture.",
              "gamma_before": 0.375,
              "recommended": "newton",
              "result": null
            }
          ],
          "summary": {
            "current_gamma": 0.375,
            "avg_gamma": 0.375,
            "gamma_trend": "degrading",
            "avg_tension": 0.5,
            "avg_diversity": 1.0,
            "interventions_total": 30,
            "interventions_recent": 30,
            "status": "collapsing"
          }
        },
        "phase_6_active": true,
        "semantic_tension_engine_ready": true,
        "specialization_metrics": {
          "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:53.431801",
          "global_specialization": {
            "Newton": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.25,
              "systems": 0.25
            },
            "Quantum": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.25,
              "systems": 0.25
            },
            "Ethics": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.25,
              "systems": 0.25
            },
            "Philosophy": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.25,
              "systems": 0.25
            },
            "DaVinci": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.25,
              "systems": 0.25
            },
            "Empathy": {
              "general": 0.0625,
              "ethics": 0.25,
              "systems": 0.25
            }
          },
          "system_health": {
            "timestamp": "2026-03-19T23:01:53.442328",
            "total_adapters": 6,
            "health_by_adapter": {
              "Newton": {
                "adapter": "Newton",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 12,
                "specialization_avg": 0.188,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.25,
                  "systems": 0.25
                }
              },
              "Quantum": {
                "adapter": "Quantum",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 12,
                "specialization_avg": 0.188,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.25,
                  "systems": 0.25
                }
              },
              "Ethics": {
                "adapter": "Ethics",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 12,
                "specialization_avg": 0.188,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.25,
                  "systems": 0.25
                }
              },
              "Philosophy": {
                "adapter": "Philosophy",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 12,
                "specialization_avg": 0.188,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.25,
                  "systems": 0.25
                }
              },
              "DaVinci": {
                "adapter": "DaVinci",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 12,
                "specialization_avg": 0.188,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.25,
                  "systems": 0.25
                }
              },
              "Empathy": {
                "adapter": "Empathy",
                "num_domains": 3,
                "avg_accuracy": 0.5,
                "total_usage": 12,
                "specialization_avg": 0.188,
                "recommendation": "maintain_current",
                "domain_specializations": {
                  "general": 0.062,
                  "ethics": 0.25,
                  "systems": 0.25
                }
              }
            },
            "overused_adapters": [],
            "specialist_adapters": [],
            "domain_experts": {
              "physics": null,
              "ethics": "Newton",
              "consciousness": null,
              "creativity": null,
              "systems": "Newton",
              "philosophy": null
            },
            "convergence_alerts": []
          },
          "convergence_history": []
        },
        "preflight_prediction": {}
      }
    }
  ]
}